The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. 04.2034 and 26.04.2024 rendered by the Akashwani Imphal and Ld. Central Administrative Tribunal respectively, the following factual situation emerges; (i) That, the 042/0178/2023 petitioner’s was allowed original by application the Ld. No. Central Administrative Tribunal, vide order dated 21.07.2023 thereby directing the competent authority to take a final decision on the former’s application for compassionate appointment after granting an opportunity of personal hearing and ensuring communication of the decision to him by way of reasoned and speaking order. (ii) That, the competent authority, vide impugned order dated 23.04.2024, disposed of the petitioner’s application after affording him an adequate opportunity of being heard in person and arriving at the conclusion that he had obtained inadequate points in terms of the subject SOP grading to be granted compassionate appointment. Page 5|6 [6] In view of the above speaking order dated 23.04.2024, the Ld. Central Administrative Tribunal, vide the impugned order dated
26. 04.2024, dropped the contempt proceedings and discharged the notice issued to the competent authority. [7] Vide the said impugned order dated 26.04.2024, however, the petitioner was granted liberty to challenge the said speaking order dated
23. 04.2024, if so advised, in accordance with law. [8] It is trite to state that the relief of compassionate appointment cannot be adjudicated by the High Court in the first instance for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. The order, being assailed in the present proceeding, is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati. Even otherwise, substantive relief cannot be considered/granted in a proceeding for contempt. [9] Consequently, the present writ petition is devoid of merit and is, accordingly, dismissed, while deserving liberty to the petitioner to assail the speaking order dated 23.04.2024, if so advised, in accordance with law, before the forum having subject jurisdiction over the substantive relief. Bipin Page 6|6
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
KHOIROM Digitally
KHOIROM
SINGH
BIPINCHAN BIPINCHANDRA
Date: 2024.08.30
DRA SINGH 14:20:43 +05'30'
Item No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(C) No. 492 of 2024
Salam Pinky Singh
… Petitioner
- Versus Union of India & 4 Ors.
… Respondents
BE FO R E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SIDDHARTH MRIDUL
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU
ORDER
(Oral)
28.08.2024
(Siddharth Mridul, CJ)
[1]
Heard Mr. H. Nabachandra, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner and Mr. Kh. Samarjit, learned DSGI assisted by Mr.
Armananda, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents.
[2]
The present petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, has been instituted on behalf of Sri Salam Pinky Singh, assailing an
order dated 26.04.2024 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
Guwahati, dropping the contempt petition filed by him and discharging the
notice issued to the Union of India in relation to an earlier order dated
21.07.2023 passed by the Ld. Central Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No.
042/0178/2023 filed by the petitioner herein, wherein the Director General,
All India Radio and Doordarshan/competent authority was directed to take
a final decision with regard to the former’s compassionate appointment
Page 1|6
after granting an opportunity of personal hearing and communicating the
decision taken to him by way of reasoned and speaking order.
[3]
It is observed that in terms of the direction issued by the Ld.
Central Administrative Tribunal, vide order dated 21.07.2023 in the O.A.
No. 042/0178/2023 filed by Sri Salam Pinky Singh, the petitioner herein,
the head of office, the Akashvani Imphal passed a speaking order being No.
A-4406/16/2023-ADMIN-AIR IMPHAL/E-942, dated 23.04.2024. In order to
appreciate the contention canvassed before this Court, it would be relevant
and proper to extract the said speaking order in-extenso; which reads as
follows:
“PRASAR BHARATI
(India's Public Service Broadcaster)
Akashvani Imphal
***
No. A-4406/16/2023-ADMIN-AIR IMPHALIE-942
Dated the 23rd April, 2024
SPEAKING ORDER
1. Whereas, the Hon'ble CAT, Guwahati disposed of OA No. 178/2023
filed by Shri Salam Pinky Singh, son of Late Shri Salam Priyokumar
Singh, Ex-Announcer. Akashvani Imphal vs Uol & Others vide order
dated 21.07.2023 with a direction that the respondents shall take a final
decision with regard to the compassionate appointment of the applicant
after granting him an opportunity of personal hearing and communicate
his decision by way of a reasoned and speaking order.
2. Whereas, personal hearing has been conducted on 04.09.2023 and
as per the extant rules and the instructions of DoPT, only 5% of Direct
Recruitment vacancies of Group 'C' posts are reserved to be filled up
through appointment on compassionate grounds.
3. Whereas, keeping in view the policy of compassionate appointment
envisaged by Department of Personnel & Training, Government of India,
a Standing Operating Procedure (SOP) with grading points has been
devised by Prasar Bharati Secretariat and Screening Committee is
constituted to evaluate all cases. The Screening Committee assesses and
takes into account monthly family pension, movable- immovable
property inherited by the applicant, the length of service rendered, postretirement benefits, monthly income, number of minor children,
dependents & unmarried daughters and allots points accordingly.
Page 2|6
Thereafter, candidates scoring the highest points and as such most
deserving amongst the applicants are recommended for appointment
subject to availability of vacancies for compassionate appointment in a
particular recruitment year.
4. Whereas, the Committee met on 11.10.2021, 13.10.2023 and
09.04.2024 and scrutinized all the 115 applications of North-East Zone
and allotted grading in terms of Standard Operating Procedure. The
Committee has gone through the details of all applications in detail
taking into consideration pension and other benefits received and also
the responsibility of looking after the dependents and the urgent needs
for relief etc. The SOP grading has been worked out on the basis of
details given in original applications submitted by the applicant.
5. Whereas, there are 07 posts (for Group 'C') earmarked for
compassionate appointment, from 2014 to 2020 (as per stipulation of
5% of total vacancies in a year in view of the DoPT guidelines) in NorthEast Zone. Accordingly, the committee considered all the cases including
the case of the applicant i.e. Sh. Salam Pinky Singh, son of Late Shri
Salam Priyokumar Singh, Ex-Announcer, Akashvani Imphal.
6. Whereas, on the basis of SOP grading, Sh. Salam Pinky Singh scored
only 32 points as against 103, 95, 89, 87, 87, 81 and 79 points
respectively scored by recommended 7 applicants for compassionate
appointment. Accordingly, rest of 109 cases including that of Sh. Salam
Pinky Singh could not be recommended.
7. However, the candidates who could not secure highest points may
re-apply if they wish to be considered once again for compassionate
appointment in subsequent years.
8. In the view of above facts and circumstances, the
application/representation for compassionate appointment has been
disposed of by the competent authority which is accordingly hereby
communicated to Sh. Salam Pinky Singh.
This issues with the approval of CEO, Prasar Bharti.
Sd/N. Nandakumar Singh
(Head of Office)
DE, Akashvani Imphal
Shri Salam Pinky Singh
Son of Late Sh. Salam Priyokumar Singh
Lamdeng Khunou, P. O. Lamsang, P. S. Lamsang-795113
Imphal West, Manipur.”
Page 3|6
[4]
It is, in view of the contents of the above extracted speaking
order dated 23.04.2024, that the Ld. Central Administrative Tribunal
disposed of, vide impugned order dated 26.0.2024, the contempt petition
instituted on behalf of the petitioner in the following terms.
“Order of the Tribunal
Today, Sri V.K. Bhatra, learned Sr. CGSC appearing on behalf of
the alleged contemnors has placed one Speaking Order dated
23.04.2023 and has submitted that they have complied with the
Order dated 21.07.2023 passed by this Tribunal in O.A. No.
042/00178/2023.
2.
Let the copy of the said Speaking Order be kept on record.
3.
It is noted that this Tribunal vide Order dated 21.072023 in
O.A. No. 042/00178/2023 had directed the alleged Contemnor
No./Respondent No. 3 in the O.A. to take final decision with regard
to the compassionate appointment of the applicant after granting
him an opportunity of personal hearing.
4.
We have perused the Speaking Order dated 23.04.2024 and
found that personal hearing was granted to the applicant on
04.09.2023 and on the basis of the SOP grading, applicant scored
only 32 points and therefore, his case was not recommended for
compassionate appointment along with others. Para No. 5 & 6 of
the said Speaking Order reads as follows:
“5.
Whereas, there are 07 posts (for Group ‘C’)
earmarked for compassionate appointment from 2014 to
2020 (as per stipulation of 5% of total vacancies in a year
in view of the DoPT guidelines) in North-East Zone.
Accordingly, the committee considered all the cases
including the case of the applicant i.e. Sh. Salam Pinky
Singh, son of Late Shri Salam Priyokumar Singh, ExAnnouncer, Akashvani Imphal.
6.
Whereas, on the basis of the SOP grading, Sh. Salam
Pinky Singh scored only 32 points as against 103, 95, 89,
87, 87, 81 and 79 points respectively scored by
recommended
applicants
for
compassionate
appointment. Accordingly, rest of 109 cases including that
of Sh. Salam Pinky Singh could not be recommended.”
5.
Therefore, in our considered opinion, the Order dated
21.07.2023 passed by this Tribunal in O.A. No.042/00178/2023
has been substantially complied with.
6.
Accordingly, C.P. is dropped. Notices are discharged.
Page 4|6
7.
However, applicant is at liberty to challenge the aforesaid
Speaking Order dated 23.04.2024, if so advice.
Sd/Smt. Urmita Datta Sen
Hon’ble Member (J)
Sd/Dr. Sumeet Jerath
Hon’ble Member (A)”
[5]
On conjoint reading of the aforesaid impugned orders dated
23.04.2034 and 26.04.2024 rendered by the Akashwani Imphal and Ld.
Central Administrative Tribunal respectively, the following factual situation
emerges;
(i)
That,
the
042/0178/2023
petitioner’s
was
allowed
original
by
application
the
Ld.
No.
Central
Administrative Tribunal, vide order dated 21.07.2023 thereby
directing the competent authority to take a final decision on
the former’s application for compassionate appointment after
granting an opportunity of personal hearing and ensuring
communication of the decision to him by way of reasoned
and speaking order.
(ii)
That, the competent authority, vide impugned order
dated 23.04.2024, disposed of the petitioner’s application
after affording him an adequate opportunity of being heard
in person and arriving at the conclusion that he had obtained
inadequate points in terms of the subject SOP grading to be
granted compassionate appointment.
Page 5|6
[6]
In view of the above speaking order dated 23.04.2024, the
Ld. Central Administrative Tribunal, vide the impugned order dated
26.04.2024, dropped the contempt proceedings and discharged the notice
issued to the competent authority.
[7]
Vide the said impugned order dated 26.04.2024, however, the
petitioner was granted liberty to challenge the said speaking order dated
23.04.2024, if so advised, in accordance with law.
[8]
It is trite to state that the relief of compassionate appointment
cannot be adjudicated by the High Court in the first instance for lack of
subject matter jurisdiction. The order, being assailed in the present
proceeding, is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati. Even otherwise, substantive relief
cannot be considered/granted in a proceeding for contempt.
[9]
Consequently, the present writ petition is devoid of merit and
is, accordingly, dismissed, while deserving liberty to the petitioner to assail
the speaking order dated 23.04.2024, if so advised, in accordance with law,
before the forum having subject jurisdiction over the substantive relief.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Bipin
Page 6|6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review