The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. The FIR was registered in the year 2017 and the charge sheet was filed in the year 2018. The applicants are shown in the charge sheet as absconding and a reference is made to Section 299 of the Cr.P.C. However, beyond this recital, the prosecution has not presently produced any warrant, execution report, proclamation or other contemporaneous material demonstrating the efforts made to secure the presence of the applicants for the purpose of investigation as required under Sections 82 and 83 of the Code. Their late arrest is undoubtedly a circumstance demanding appropriate safeguards. But, in absence of further material, it would not justify indefinite retention after completion of the investigation.
10. The applicants have undergone custody for more than 7 -8947-BA-1199-2026 months. The offences carry a maximum punishment of 7 years. The case is founded predominantly upon documentary evidence and the prosecution proposes to rely upon several official and documentary witnesses. There are no allegations pertaining to criminal antecedents. The contractor has been released on statutory bail, while the other co-accused are also released on statutory bail. Having regard to the completion of the investigation, filing of the charge sheet, documentary nature of the evidence, period of custody, punishment prescribed, and the possibility of securing the applicants' presence by imposing stringent conditions, this Court is satisfied that the applicants can be released on bail. Hence, the following order : (i) The Bail Application is allowed. (ii) The applicants shall be released on bail in Crime No.345 of 2026, registered with Beed Rural Police Station, District Beed, for the offences punishable under Sections 406 and 420 read with Section 34 of the IPC, on each furnishing a personal bond of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only) with one solvent surety in the like amount, subject to the following conditions : a) The applicants shall attend the trial Court on every date fixed, unless their attendance is specifically exempted. -9947-BA-1199-2026 b) The applicants shall not, directly or i…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:43488
-1947-BA-1199-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 1199 OF 2026
1.
Sakharam Umaji Kamble
2.
Shriram Balasaheb Pande
… Applicants
Versus
The State of Maharashtra
… Respondent
.....
Advocate for Applicant : Mr. Nilesh Kashyap (Through V.C.) a/w
Ms. Pooja Anant Dongre and Mr. Baliram Ingle
APP for Respondent - State : Mr.V. K. Kotecha
.....
CORAM : HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR, J.
DATED : 22nd SEPTEMBER 2026
PER COURT :
1.
Heard the learned Advocate for the applicants and the
learned APP for the respondent-State. With the able assistance of
the learned Advocates, I have also perused the entire charge sheet
and the investigation report.
2.
The present application is filed seeking regular bail by
the applicants who are arrested in connection with Crime No.345
of 2026, registered with Beed Rural Police Station, District Beed,
for the offences punishable under Sections 406 and 420 read with
Section 34 of the IPC. Applicant No.1 was arrested on 22 nd
January, 2026, whereas Applicant No.2 was arrested on 23 rd
-2947-BA-1199-2026
January, 2026 and both have since been in custody. Accused No.3,
who was the contractor to whom the alleged misappropriated
amount had been disbursed, has already been released on bail.
3.
The prosecution case, briefly stated, arises out of
financial assistance provided by the State Government under the
Special Component Scheme to Nagad Narayan Industrial Cooperative
Society,
Nagzari,
for
establishing
a
PVC
pipe
manufacturing project. Applicant No.1 was the President and
Applicant No.2 was the Secretary of the Society. The Government
share capital of Rs.1 crore and a long-term government loan of
Rs.1 crore were sanctioned. Out of which Rs.1,92,50,000/- was
released to the Society. The construction of the project was
entrusted to co-accused Sachin Samadhan Gavhad for a contract
value of Rs.1.42 crores. Under the agreement, 15% of the contract
value was payable at the commencement of work, 80% after
completion, and the balance 5% was to be retained as security. The
work was required to be completed within a stipulated period. The
test audit conducted in 2017 recorded that an aggregate amount of
Rs.1,76,12,500/- had been shown as paid towards construction
between 15th March, 2012 and 15th November, 2012. When the
auditor inspected the site, walls of about 12 to 14 feet had been
constructed, but the structure was allegedly built without
-3947-BA-1199-2026
plastering and roofing and the project had not commenced its
intended activity. It is alleged that the applicants, in their capacity
as President and Secretary, released an amount far in excess of the
contractual stages, failed to obtain the utilisation certificate, and
neither secured completion of the project nor recovered the
amount from the contractor. On that basis, it is alleged that the
applicants in connivance with the contractor and the other coaccused persons, committed criminal breach of trust and cheated
the State Government.
4.
Learned Advocate appearing for the applicants submits
that the accusation of the entire amount was misappropriated is
contradicted by the subsequent valuation made by the PWD
Department. The report dated 16th June, 2026 values the existing
structure at Rs.1,72,60,056/-. It is submitted that substantially the
entire amount was utilised in constructing the project and that the
remaining construction material is also lying at the site. It is
further submitted that the dispute, at its highest, concerns noncompletion of the construction within the contractual period and
irregularity in releasing the installments. There is no material
showing that either applicant received any part of the amount
personally or used it for acquiring any personal asset. Learned
counsel further submits that the FIR was registered in December
-4947-BA-1199-2026
2017, the charge sheet has been filed in June 2018, and the
applicants have been in custody since January 2026. The
investigation is complete and the prosecution case rests principally
upon the audit report, bank statements, agreements, and other
documentary material already in the custody of the investigating
agency. It is submitted that the applicants were never declared
proclaimed offenders by following the procedure prescribed under
Sections 82 and 83 of the Cr.P.C. The contractor and the other coaccused have already been released on bail. Both the applicants
have no criminal antecedents and are ready to abide by any
stringent conditions securing their presence during the trial.
5.
Learned APP opposes the application. He submits that
the subsequent valuation cannot establish utilisation of the amount
in 2012. Because it has been prepared by applying the prevailing
rates described in 2019. The original contract was for Rs.1.42
crores, whereas Rs.1.76 crores were released despite the
construction remaining incomplete. The first substantial payment
itself was contrary to the contractual stipulation, which permitted
only 15% as advance. The applicants controlled the financial affairs
and bank transactions of the Society. It is also submitted that they
remained unavailable for several years and were arrested only in
January 2026. Their past conduct, therefore, gives rise to a
-5947-BA-1199-2026
reasonable apprehension that their presence during the trial may
not be secured if they are released.
6.
I have considered the rival submissions and examined
the charge sheet and the documents placed on record. The
accusations concern public money and cannot be treated lightly. At
the same time, the seriousness of an economic offence is one of the
relevant considerations and not a substitute for examining the
particular role, nature of evidence, custody undergone, possibility
of the trial concluding within a reasonable time, and the risk
associated with the release.
7.
The
material
relied
upon
by
the
prosecution
undoubtedly indicates that substantial amounts were released
without adhering to the stages described in the construction
agreement. The project was not completed within the stipulated
period,
and
no
utilisation
certificate
was
obtained.
These
circumstances constitute prima facie material requiring the
applicants to face trial. However, the question at this stage is not
whether the payments were made in accordance with the contract
or administratively were not regular, but whether further pre-trial
detention of the applicants is necessary.
-6947-BA-1199-2026
8.
The prosecution alleges that in the FIR and the audit
report that Rs.1,76,00,000/- was misappropriated. The subsequent
PWD assessment values the existing structure at Rs.1,72,60,000/-.
The contention that the document pertains to Gut No.111-A, at this
stage, need not be gone into for the simple reason that the letter
produced by the applicant dated 21st September, 2026 issued by
the Gram Panchayat Office, Tandalwadi, clearly states that the
building constructed by the Society falls in Gut No.111-A and the
photographs are also annexed. The same letter is taken on record
and marked as Exhibit-''X'' for the purpose of identification. The
evaluation stated in the said document, which is annexed to the
present application at page 307 establishes complete utilisation of
the original amount, though this document in itself cannot be
accepted as conclusive proof, and the same has to be tested at the
time of trial. The valuation also cannot retrospectively regularise
payments made contrary to the agreement. Nevertheless, the
report is an official document demonstrating the existence of a
substantial structure at the projected site. It is, therefore, a
relevant subsequent circumstance while considering whether the
applicants should continue to remain in custody. Despite a specific
query, no material was pointed out at this stage showing that any
identified portion of the amount was credited to the personal
account of the present applicants or utilised by them for acquiring
-7947-BA-1199-2026
any
personal
assets.
The
bank
transactions,
resolutions,
agreement, audit report and other financial reports are already
part of the charge sheet. The precise destination of each payment,
the authority under which it was made, the actual value of the
construction at the relevant time and whether the applicants acted
with dishonest intention necessary to constitute the alleged offence
are matters requiring evidence. Any conclusive finding on these
aspects would prejudge the trial.
9.
The FIR was registered in the year 2017 and the charge
sheet was filed in the year 2018. The applicants are shown in the
charge sheet as absconding and a reference is made to Section 299
of the Cr.P.C. However, beyond this recital, the prosecution has not
presently produced any warrant, execution report, proclamation
or other contemporaneous material demonstrating the efforts
made to secure the presence of the applicants for the purpose of
investigation as required under Sections 82 and 83 of the Code.
Their late arrest is undoubtedly a circumstance demanding
appropriate safeguards. But, in absence of further material, it
would not justify indefinite retention after completion of the
investigation.
10.
The applicants have undergone custody for more than 7
-8947-BA-1199-2026
months. The offences carry a maximum punishment of 7 years.
The case is founded predominantly upon documentary evidence
and the prosecution proposes to rely upon several official and
documentary witnesses. There are no allegations pertaining to
criminal antecedents. The contractor has been released on
statutory bail, while the other co-accused are also released on
statutory
bail.
Having
regard
to
the
completion
of
the
investigation, filing of the charge sheet, documentary nature of the
evidence, period of custody, punishment prescribed, and the
possibility of securing the applicants' presence by imposing
stringent conditions, this Court is satisfied that the applicants can
be released on bail. Hence, the following order :
ORDER
(i)
The Bail Application is allowed.
(ii)
The applicants shall be released on bail in Crime No.345 of
2026, registered with Beed Rural Police Station, District
Beed, for the offences punishable under Sections 406 and 420
read with Section 34 of the IPC, on each furnishing a personal
bond of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only) with one
solvent surety in the like amount, subject to the following
conditions :
a)
The applicants shall attend the trial Court on every
date fixed, unless their attendance is specifically
exempted.
-9947-BA-1199-2026
b)
The applicants shall not, directly or indirectly, contact,
threaten, induce or influence the informant or any
prosecution witness and shall not tamper with the
prosecution evidence.
c)
The applicants shall furnish their current residential
addresses and mobile numbers to the Investigating
Officer and the trial Court within seven days of release,
intimate
any
change
forthwith,
and
attend
the
Investigating Officer upon prior written notice if further
investigation is required.
d)
The applicants shall not leave India without prior
permission of the trial Court and, if they possess
passports, shall deposit the same with the trial Court
within seven days of their release.
e)
The applicants shall not involve themselves in any
offence of a similar nature while on bail.
f)
Breach of any of the above conditions shall entitle the
prosecution to apply for cancellation of bail.
g)
All observations in this order are prima facie and
confined to the decision of this bail application. At the
time of trial, any observations will also not preclude the
authorities from proceeding under appropriate law for
recovering the amount which has been disposed of.
(iii) The Bail Application is disposed of in the above terms.
Tandale
(HITEN S. VENEGAVKAR)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review