The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. When an application is filed under Section 47 specifically relating to delivery of property to an auction purchaser, the court ought to have applied its mind into the merits of the case and then decide whether the petitioner is entitled to a decision on merits. The Execution court has dismissed the application in limine on the ground that since irregularities are projected regarding the sale, an application under Order 21 Rule 90 CPC will alone lie.
8. When Explanation II-(b) to Section 47 gives power to the execution court to decide the questions relating to the delivery of possession of the property to the purchaser or his legal representative in execution, discharge or satisfaction of the decree, the Execution Court ought to have gone into the contentions raised by the auction purchaser and also the nature of the property which was sold in execution. In such circumstances, 2025:KER:25095 I am of the view that Ext.P7 requires reconsideration. In the result, this O.P.(C.) is allowed, Ext.P7 order dated
13. 6.2023 in E.A.No.74 of 2023 in E.P. No.50 of 2011 passed by the Sub Judge, Thiruvalla, is set aside. The Execution court is directed to reconsider Ext.P6, after giving an opportunity of hearing to the decree-holder as well as the judgment debtor. It is made clear that this court has not gone into the merits of the contentions raised by the auction purchaser. SD/BASANT BALAJI dl / 2025:KER:25095 Exhibit P1 TRUE COPY OF EA 134 OF 2014 IN EP NO. 50 OF 2011 IN OS NO. 175 OF 2007 ON THE FILES OF SUB COURT, Exhibit P2 TRUE COPY OF THE SALE NOTICE ISSUED UNDER ORDER 21 RULE 66, CPC BY THE SUB COURT, THIRUVALLA IN EP 50 OF 2011 Exhibit P3 TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 03.09.2015 SUBMITTED BY THE AMIN BEFORE THE SUB COURT, Exhibit P4 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 15.12.2015 IN EP NO. 50 OF 2011 IN OS NO. 175 OF 2007 OF SUB COURT, Exhibit P5 TRUE COPY OF THE EA. NO. 187 OF 2015 IN EP NO. 50 OF 2011 BEFORE SUB COURT, THIRUVALLA Exhibit P6 TRUE COPY OF EA NO. 74 OF 2023 IN EP NO. 50 OF 2011 IN OS NO. 175 OF 2007 OF SUB COURT, Exhibit P6(a) TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 06.07.2023 BEARING NO. R3/13511/2023 ISSUED BY THE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER, THIRUVALLA MUNICIPALITY Exhibit P6(b) TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 10.07.2023 BEARING NO. E4/13357/2023 ISSUED BY THE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER, THIRUVALLA MUNICIPALITY Exhibit P7 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED ON. 13.06.2023 IN EA NO. 74 OF 2023 I…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1482 OF 2023
EP NO.50 OF 2011 OF ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/SUB COURT/COMMERCIAL
COURT, THIRUVALLA
PETITIONER/S:
SAJI M MATHEW
AGED 61 YEARS
S/O SIMON, MANNATTU VEEDU, KIZHAKKEN MUTHOOR, KUTTAPPUZHA
P.O., KUTTAPPUZHA VILLAGE, PIN- 689103, PIN - 689103
BY ADVS.
JACOB P.ALEX
JOSEPH P.ALEX
AMAL AMIR ALI
MANU SANKAR P.
RESPONDENT/S:
V.N VARGHESE
S/O NINAN PHILIPOSE, VADAKKEPARAMPL HOUSE, NEAR SCS
JUNCTION, THIRUVALLA, PIN- 689101, PIN - 689101
AMMUKKUTTY VARGHESE
AGED 82 YEARS
W/O V.N VARGHESE VADAKKEPARAMPL HOUSE, NEAR SCS JUNCTION,
THIRUVALLA, PIN- 689101, PIN - 689101
M/S CVP PROPERTIES PVT LTD
REGISTERED OFFICE, CROSS JUNCTION, THIRUVALLA, PIN- 689101
REPRESENTED BY MANAGING DIRECTOR, C.P. JOHN, CHANDRAVRUTHIL
VEEDU, CHANDRAVRUTHIL VEEDU, THUKALASSERY, THIRUVALLA P.O.,,
PIN - 689101
C.P JOHN
AGED 59 YEARS
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
MANAGING DIRECTOR, M/S.CVP PROPERTIES S/O LATE C.V
PHILIPOSE, CHANDRAVRUTHIL VEEDU, THUKALASSERY, THIRUVALLA
P.O., PIN- 689101, PIN - 689101
THE PRESIDENT
THIRUVALLA PARLIAMENT SQUARE RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION CVP
PARLIAMENT SQUARE BUILDING CROSS JUNCTION, THIRUVALLA PIN 689101, PIN - 689101
BY ADVS.
Sarin
PARVATHI KRISHNA(K/000807/2022)
P.SANTHOSHKUMAR (KARUMKULAM)(K/784/1992)
SAUMYA.P.S(K/003383/2022)
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 24.03.2025, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 24th day of March 2025)
The petitioner is the auction purchaser in E.P.No.50 of 2011
in O.S.No.175 of 2007 on the files of the Sub Court, Thiruvalla.
Respondent Nos.1 and 2 are decree holders, and respondent Nos.
3 and 4 are judgment debtors. The fifth respondent is the claim
petitioner.
2. O.S.No.175 of 2007 is filed against respondents Nos.3
and 4, for the return of money. The suit was decreed on 27.2.2009,
allowing respondents 1 and 2 to realise an amount of
Rs.9,04,000/- together with interest.
On the strength of the
decree, E.P.No.50 of 2011 was filed seeking realisation of the
decree amount by sale of an apartment in the residential complex
constructed by respondents Nos.3 and 4. The court sale did not
take place as there were no bidders. Later, respondent Nos.1 and
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
2 filed E.A. No.134 of
2014, seeking a sale of the
building/godown purportedly bearing No.XXIV-540(2) of
Thiruvalla Municipality, being the cellar floor of a building
known as CVP Parliament Square. The auction was conducted
on 3.9.2015. The petitioner participated in the said auction and
successfully bid the auctioned property for an amount of
Rs.15,00,100/-. One-fourth of the auction amount was deposited
on 03.09.2015, and the balance sale consideration and stamp duty
was paid, and the sale was confirmed on 15.12.2015.
3. While so, the 5th respondent filed E.A.No.187 of 2015, to
set aside the sale under Order XXI Rule 90 and 91 CPC on the
ground that the property sold in auction is the parking area of the
building and the members of the 5th respondent are having a right
over the property sold. The petitioner, therefore, made enquiries
with the local authority, and it was realised that the property now
sold and bought by him was not assigned any number by the
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
Thiruvalla municipality, and the entire proceedings leading to the
auction held on 03.09.2015 is vitiated by gross mistakes,
illegalities and irregularities. Therefore, E.A.No.74 of 2023 was
filed under section 47, read with Sections 144 and 151 CPC, to
set aside the confirmation of court sale and to return the purchase
price and stamp duty.
4. The execution court, by Ext.P7, dismissed the application,
holding that if there was any irregularity or fraud in the sale, an
application under Order 21 Rule 90 is the remedy, and a petition
under Section 47 will not lie, and that too after the period of
limitation under Article 127 of the Limitation Act.
5. Counsel for the petitioner, Sri.Jacob P Alex submitted that
under Section 47 CPC, all questions arising between the parties
to the suit in which the decree was passed, or their representatives,
and relating to the execution, discharge or satisfaction of the
decree, shall be determined by the court executing the decree and
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
not by a separate suit. Explanation II-(a) to the said Section states
that a purchaser of the property at a sale in execution of a decree
shall be deemed to be a party to the suit in which the decree is
passed. Explanation II-(b) to Section 47 CPC prescribes that all
questions relating to the delivery of possession of such property
to such purchaser or his representative shall be deemed to be
questions relating to the execution, discharge or satisfaction of the
decree within the meaning of this section. He relied on the
judgment of the apex court in Desh Bandhu Gupta v. N.L.
Anand & Rajinder Singh [(1994) 1 SCC 131, wherein it is held
as follows:
“17. Under Section 47 all questions relating to
execution, discharge or satisfaction of the decree should be
determined by the Executing Court alone. The pre-sale
illegalities committed in the execution are amenable to the
remedy under Section 47. Post-sale illegalities or
irregularities causing substantial injury to the judgmentdebtor are covered under Order 21 Rule 90. Sub-rule (1)
thereof covers the field of material irregularities or fraud in
publicity or conducting the sale. Sub-rule (2) enjoins proof
thereof, and the court should find that by reason thereof, the
applicant sustained substantial injury. The total absence of
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
drawing up of the proclamation of sale and settlement of its
term by judicial application of mind renders the sale a nullity
being void. It is covered by Section 47. The non-application
of mind whether the sale of a part of the property would
satisfy the decree debt is a material irregularity causing
substantial injury to the appellant attracting Order 21 Rule 90.
In either case, the sale is liable to be set aside. It is true that
there is a distinction between mere irregularity and material
irregularities, and the sale is not liable to be set aside on proof
of mere irregularity. It must be material irregularity, and the
court must be satisfied that, on account thereof, substantial
injury was sustained by the appellant. xxx xxx xxx.”
Reliance was placed on the judgment of the apex court in
Harnandrai Badridas v. Debidutt Bhagwati Prasad and
others [(1973) 2 SCC 467], wherein the apex court had held thus:
6. Section 47, in our view, should be construed liberally.
As far back as in 1892, the Privy Council spoke strongly in
favour of putting a liberal construction on Section 244 of the
Code of Civil Procedure of 1882 which corresponded to present
Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908. The Privy
Council reiterated this in Ganapathy v. Krishnamachariar. If a
liberal construction be put upon Section 47 it is difficult to
understand why a decree-holder who has been a party to the
decree will shed his character as such party merely upon
purchasing the property at the execution sale. After all, a decreeholder purchases the property in execution of his decree with
the permission of the court. There is no reason why he should
not retain his character of a party to the suit until the delivery of
possession to him of the property purchased by him. Having
regard to this consideration, if any question is raised by the
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
judgment-debtor at the time of delivery of possession
concerning the nature of the rights purchased and if the
judgment-debtor offers any resistance to delivery of possession,
the question must be one which in our view relates to the
execution, discharge and satisfaction of the decree and arises
between the parties to the suit.”
6. Coming to the facts of this case, it can be seen that the
petitioner participated in the auction based on the proclamation
issued as per Ext.P2. A perusal of Ext.P2 shows that a godown is
sought to be sold, having an extent of 2,550 sq.ft. in the cellar
portion of CVP Parliament Square.
The petitioner obtained
Ext.Nos.P6(a) and P6(b) from the Public Relation Officer of
Thiruvalla Municipality, which states that no number is assigned
to the property shown in the proclamation schedule. By the time,
the sale was conducted and confirmed, the petitioner had remitted
the entire sale consideration.
In such circumstances, the
petitioner has filed Ext.P6 under Section 47 CPC to set aside the
order confirming the sale and for the return of purchase money
and stamp duty as he is not going to get possession of the property
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
sold in the auction, which is non-existent as per Ext.Nos.P6(a)
and P6(b).
7. When an application is filed under Section 47 specifically
relating to delivery of property to an auction purchaser, the court
ought to have applied its mind into the merits of the case and then
decide whether the petitioner is entitled to a decision on merits.
The Execution court has dismissed the application in limine on
the ground that since irregularities are projected regarding the
sale, an application under Order 21 Rule 90 CPC will alone lie.
8. When Explanation II-(b) to Section 47 gives power to the
execution court to decide the questions relating to the delivery of
possession of the property to the purchaser or his legal
representative in execution, discharge or satisfaction of the
decree, the Execution Court ought to have gone into the
contentions raised by the auction purchaser and also the nature of
the property which was sold in execution. In such circumstances,
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
I am of the view that Ext.P7 requires reconsideration.
In the result, this O.P.(C.) is allowed, Ext.P7 order dated
13.6.2023 in E.A.No.74 of 2023 in E.P. No.50 of 2011 passed by
the Sub Judge, Thiruvalla, is set aside. The Execution court is
directed to reconsider Ext.P6, after giving an opportunity of
hearing to the decree-holder as well as the judgment debtor.
It is made clear that this court has not gone into the merits of
the contentions raised by the auction purchaser.
SD/BASANT BALAJI
JUDGE
dl
/
OPC 1482/2023
2025:KER:25095
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1482/2023
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF EA 134 OF 2014 IN EP NO. 50 OF 2011
IN OS NO. 175 OF 2007 ON THE FILES OF SUB COURT,
THIRUVALLA
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE SALE NOTICE ISSUED UNDER ORDER
21 RULE 66, CPC BY THE SUB COURT, THIRUVALLA IN
EP 50 OF 2011
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 03.09.2015
SUBMITTED BY THE AMIN BEFORE THE SUB COURT,
THIRUVALLA
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 15.12.2015 IN EP NO.
50 OF 2011 IN OS NO. 175 OF 2007 OF SUB COURT,
THIRUVALLA
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE EA. NO. 187 OF 2015 IN EP NO. 50
OF 2011 BEFORE SUB COURT, THIRUVALLA
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF EA NO. 74 OF 2023 IN EP NO. 50 OF
2011 IN OS NO. 175 OF 2007 OF SUB COURT,
THIRUVALLA
Exhibit P6(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 06.07.2023 BEARING
NO. R3/13511/2023 ISSUED BY THE PUBLIC
INFORMATION OFFICER, THIRUVALLA MUNICIPALITY
Exhibit P6(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 10.07.2023 BEARING
NO. E4/13357/2023 ISSUED BY THE PUBLIC
INFORMATION OFFICER, THIRUVALLA MUNICIPALITY
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED ON. 13.06.2023 IN EA
NO. 74 OF 2023 IN EP NO. 50 OF 2011
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 13.06.2023 IN EA NO.
187 OF 2015 IN EP NO. 50 OF 2011 IN OS NO. 175 OF
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS SHEET OF SUB COURT
THIRUVALLA IN EP NO. 50 OF 2011 BETWEEN 29-072011 AND 12-01-2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review