Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.607 of 2024
1.
Sajal Kanti Biswas, son of Rabindra Kumar Biswas, resident of
Badharghat Sreepally, Agartala, PO-Madhuban, PS-Amtali, District-West
Tripura, Pin-799003, Age-39 years.
2.
Dipanjan Laskar, son of Late Debasish Laskar, resident of Town
Bardowali, Agartala, PO-Bardowali, PS-A.D. Nagar, District-West Tripura, Pin799001, Age-28 years.
3.
Subhajit Debnath, son of Sanjit Debnath, resident of North Kacharghat,
Kailashahar, PO & PS-Kailashahar, District-Unakoti Tripura, Pin-799277, Age31 years.
4.
Subrata Debnath, son of Sushil Chandra Debnath, resident of village, PO
& PS-Panisagar, District-North Tripura, Pin-799260, Age-30 years.
5.
Kaushik Das, son of Sibu Chandra Das, resident of Joynagar, POAgartala, PS-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799001, Age-26 years.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.
Tripura Public Service Commission(TPSC), represented by its
Secretary, Akhaura Road, PO-Agartala, PS-West Agartala, District-West
Tripura, Pin-799001.
2.
The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission (TPSC), Akhaura
Road, PO-Agartala, PS-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799001.
3.
The Chairman, Tripura Public Service Commission (TPSC), Akhaura
Road, PO-Agartala, PS-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799001.
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. K. Chakraborty, Advocate
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
25.11.2024
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
By way of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioners have
prayed for directing the respondents-Tripura Public Service Commission(for
short, TPSC) to allow them to inspect their respective answer-scripts of the Main
Examination [i.e., Paper-I (English) & Paper-II (General Studies & Arithmetic)]
conducted in connection with the Advertisement No.06/2021 dated 07.12.2021
and subsequent Addendum dated 02.05.2022 (Annexures-1 and 2 respectively to
the writ petition).
At the request of learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioners and on being consented by learned counsel appearing for the
respondents-TPSC, the matter has been taken up for hearing at the admission
stage itself.
2.
Facts:
The short fact of the case is that in pursuance of an advertisement
dated 07.12.2021 and subsequent Addendum dated 02.05.2022, the petitioners
had applied for various posts and participated in the selection process. After
publication of result, the petitioners did not find their names in the list of
successful
candidates.
Having
found
themselves
unsuccessful
in
the
examination, the petitioners submitted an application to TPSC to allow them to
inspect their respective answer-scripts on the subjects mentioned above. The
TPSC having received their applications followed by subsequent legal notice
informed the petitioners about its inability to produce and show the answerscripts to the petitioners for inspection on the basis of the notification dated
20.06.2024(Annexure-6 to the writ petition). Ultimately, prayer for inspection of
answer-scripts had been rejected by the respondents-TPSC. Feeling aggrieved,
the petitioners have approached this Court.
3.
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
K. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners. Also heard Mr.
Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-TPSC.
4.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioners:
4.1.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioners has submitted that the petitioners have the right to inspect their
answer-scripts and rejection of the same is arbitrary and discriminatory.
Furthermore, according to learned senior counsel, rejection to inspect the
answer-scripts has raised serious doubt as regards the transparency in the process
of conducting examination. So, to bring transparency, the petitioners should be
allowed to inspect their answer-scripts.
4.2.
To fortify his submission, Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
has placed reliance upon the judgments rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Mradul Mishra vs. Chairman, U.P. Public Service Commission Allahabad
and Ors. decided on 16.07.2018 in Civil Appeal No.6723 of 2018[Arising out
of SLP(C) No.33006 of 2017](Para 14) and Central Board of Secondary
Education and Anr. vs. Aditya Bandopadhyay and Ors. reported in (2011) 8
SCC 497(Para 51, 59 and 66)
5.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents-TPSC:
5.1.
The above submissions of learned senior counsel for the petitioners
have vehemently been objected by Mr. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents-TPSC. The main ground for objection is that the instant writ petition
has been filed after six months of conducting the examination and in the
meantime, appointment orders in favour of the selected candidates have already
been issued and the recommended candidates have also been appointed in the
posts for which the advertisement was published.
5.2.
Secondly, the learned counsel has placed reliance on the decision of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Union Public Service Commission
and Ors. vs. Angesh Kumar and Ors. in Civil Appeal nos.6159-6162 of 2013
decided on 20th February, 2018, reported in (2018) 4 SCC 530. Mr. Datta,
learned counsel for the respondents-TPSC has submitted that considering the
need for transparency and accountability of the Commission, the answer-scripts
should not be allowed to be inspected by the candidates who have appeared in
the examination. It is further submitted that if this kind of prayer is allowed,
then, the integrity of the Public Service Commission will be at stake and the
entire system of conducting examination will be jeopardized. Mr. Datta, learned
counsel for the respondents has candidly submitted that the entire process was
completed maintaining optimum transparency and there is no scope of doubting
the integrity about the evaluation of the answer-scripts. It is further contended
that unless and until public interest is involved, the Court should not permit the
candidates to inspect the answer-scripts.
5.3.
Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the respondents-TPSC has placed
reliance on para 12 of the case of Prashant Ramesh Chakkarwar vs. Union
Public Service Commission and others, reported in (2013) 12 SCC 489 and
paras 6, 7 and 9 of the case of Angesh Kumar(supra). Reliance has also been
placed on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Pranav Verma and Ors.
vs. Registrar General of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at
Chandigarh and Anr., reported in (2020) 15 SCC 377 [Three-Judge Bench
(SCC p 395 para 28)]
6.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing for
the parties and perused the documents enclosed to the writ petition. I have also
gone through the counter affidavit and the judgments cited at the bar by learned
counsel appearing for the parties.
7.
Discussion and conclusion:
7.1.
Before I delve into the merits of the writ petition, I may take note of
the principles laid down in the case of Angesh Kumar(supra), as extracted in the
case of Mradul Mishra(supra). The Hon’ble Supreme Court has also referred
the case of Aditya Bandopadhyay(supra) while disposing the case of Mradul
Mishra(supra).The relevant portion is reproduced hereunder, for convenience:
“12. Reference has been made to Paragraphs 5 and 10 of the judgment which
read as follows:
(5) It is submitted that though Sections 3 and 6 of the Act confer right to
information (apart from statutory obligation to provide specified
information Under Section 4), Sections 8, 9 and 11 provide for exemption
from giving of information as stipulated therein. The exclusion by Sections
8, 9 and 11 is not exhaustive and parameters under third recital of the
preamble of the Act can also be taken into account. Where information is
likely to conflict with other public interest, including efficient operation of
the Government, optimum use of fiscal resources and preservation of
confidentiality of some sensitive information, exclusion of right or
information can be applied in a given fact situation.
(10) Weighing the need for transparency and accountability on the one hand
and requirement of optimum use of fiscal resources and confidentiality of
sensitive information on the other, we are of the view that information
sought with regard to marks in Civil Services Exam cannot be directed to be
furnished mechanically. Situation of exams of other academic bodies may
stand on different footing. Furnishing raw marks will cause problems as
pleaded by the UPSC as quoted above which will not be in public interest.
However, if a case is made out where the Court finds that public interest
requires furnishing of information, the Court is certainly entitled to so
require in a given fact situation. If rules or practice so require, certainly
such rule or practice can be enforced. In the present case, direction has
been issued without considering these parameters.
13. It may be noted that Paragraph 5 contains the submission while the finding is
in Paragraph 10 of the decision.
14. In our opinion, permitting a candidate to inspect the answer sheet does not
involve any public interest nor does it affect the efficient operation of the
Government. There are issues of confidentiality and disclosure of sensitive
information that may arise, but those have already been taken care of in the case
of Aditya Bandopadhyay where it has categorically been held that the identity of
the examiner cannot be disclosed for reasons of confidentiality.
15. That being the position, we have no doubt that the Appellant is entitled to
inspect the answer sheets. Accordingly, we direct the Respondent U.P. Public
Service Commission to fix the date, time and place where the Appellant can come
and inspect the answer sheet within four weeks.
The appeal stands disposed of.”
7.2.
On plain reading of the case supra and the principles enunciated
therein, it can reasonably be held that if the prayer of a candidate is limited to the
extent of inspection of answer sheets and not in conflict with larger public
interest without affecting the efficiency of government functionalities and
further, confidentiality of sensitive information is preserved, in that situation,
right to inspect the answer sheets should not be denied.
7.3.
In the case of Prashant Ramesh Chakkarwar(supra), the
petitioners had challenged the method of moderation adopted by the
Commission where the Hon’ble Supreme Court while rejecting the challenge
had upheld the method of moderation adopted by the Commission observing
thus:
“14………………The above procedure of „moderation‟ would bring in considerable
uniformity and consistency. It should be noted that absolute uniformity or
consistency in valuation is impossible to achieve where there are several examiners
and the effort is only to achieve maximum uniformity.
***
26. The Union Public Service Commission („UPSC‟, for short) conducts the largest
number of examinations providing choice of subjects. When assessing inter se
merit, it takes recourse to scaling only in Civil Service Preliminary Examination
where candidates have the choice to opt for any one paper out of 23 optional
papers and where the question papers are of objective type and the answer scripts
areevaluated by computerised scanners. In regard to compulsory papers which are
of descriptive (conventional) type, valuation is done manually and scaling is not
resorted to. Like UPSC, most examining authorities appear to take the view that
moderation is the appropriate method to bring about uniformity in valuation where
several examiners manually evaluate answer scripts of descriptive/conventional
type question papers in regard to same subject; and that scaling should be resorted
to only where a common merit list has to be prepared in regard to candidates who
have taken examination in different subjects, in pursuance of an option given to
them.”
From the above extracted portion of the judgment in Sanjay Singh case [Sanjay
Singh v. U.P. Public Service Commission, (2007) 3 SCC 720 : (2007) 1 SCC (L&S)
870] , it is clear that the three-Judge Bench [Sanjay Singh v. U.P. Public Service
Commission, (2007) 3 SCC 720 : (2007) 1 SCC (L&S) 870] had approved the
method of moderation adopted by the Commission.”
In the instant case, the petitioners have not challenged the method
of moderation. So this judgment is of no relevance to the merits of the instant
case. The judgment rendered in the case of Pranav Verma(supra) as cited by the
learned counsel appearing for the respondents-TPSC is also not relevant in
deciding the disputes raised in this writ petition.
7.4.
In the case of Angesh Kumar(supra), as referred to by Mr. Datta,
learned counsel for the respondents-TPSC, it has been observed that: “ Weighing
the need for transparency and accountability on the one hand and requirement
of optimum use of fiscal resources and confidentiality of sensitive information on
the other, we are of the view that information sought with regard to marks in
Civil Services Exam cannot be directed to be furnished mechanically. Situation
of exams of other academic bodies may stand on different footing. Furnishing
raw marks will cause problems as pleaded by the UPSC as quoted above which
will not be in public interest. However, if a case is made out where the Court
finds that public interest requires furnishing of information, the Court is
certainly entitled to so require in a given fact situation. If rules or practice so
require, certainly such rule or practice can be enforced. In the present case,
direction has been issued without considering these parameters”.
7.5.
Now, considering the facts of the instant writ petition, it is pertinent
to mention that when the matter came up before this Court on 23.09.2024,
following order at the stage of motion was passed:
“Heard Mr. K. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners.
Also heard Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondentsTPSC.
Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the respondents-TPSC has sought for an
adjournment to file reply. In the meantime, considering the grievances of the
petitioners, this Court requests Mr. Datta, learned counsel for respondentsTPSC to produce the answer scripts relating to the petitioners as well as last
five selectees, whose names appeared in the selection list.
List the matter tomorrow (24.09.2024).”
Thereafter, the matter came up on 24.09.2024 when this Court had
passed the following order:
“Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K.
Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners. Also heard Mr.
Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-TPSC.
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioners have prayed for
following reliefs:“(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, directing them, to transmit the records, lying with them, for rendering
substantive
and
quashing/setting
conscionable
justice
aside the impugned
to
the
Petitioners,
and
for
Notification dated 20.06.2024
(Annexure-6 supra);
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show
cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them, to allow the Petitioners to inspect their
respective answer scripts of the Main Examination [i.e., Paper-I (English) &
Paper- II (General Studies & Arithmetic)], conducted in connection with the
Advertisement No. 06/2021 dated 07.12.2021 & the Addendum dated
02.05.2022 (Annexures-1 & 2 respectively supra), by serving copies thereof;
(iii); Call for the records, appertaining to this Writ petition;
(iv) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule absolute in terms of
(i) & (ii) above;
(V) Costs of and incidental to this proceeding
(vi) Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon'ble High Court may deem fit and
proper;”
Let a notice be issued calling upon the respondents to show cause as to
why a rule should not be issued as prayed for; and/or as to why such further
order/s should not be passed as to this court may seem fit and proper.
Notice is made returnable within 6(six) weeks.
Since all the respondents have already entered their appearance, no formal
notice is called for.
In pursuance of the order dated 23.09.2024, Mr. Datta, learned counsel
for the respondents-TPSC has produced the answer scripts relating to the
petitioners before this Court.
I have perused the answer scripts and I do not find any discrepancy in
the marks awarded in favour of the petitioners.
List the matter on 05.11.2024. In the meantime, the respondents may
file their counter affidavits, if they so desire.”
7.6.
From the order dated 24.09.2024, it comes to fore that the
respondents-TPSC had produced the answer-scripts in terms of the order dated
23.09.2024. This Court on meticulous perusal of the answer-scripts had
categorically observed that there was no discrepancy in accounting the marks
awarded in favour of the petitioners. This Court had inspected the answer-scripts
in front of the learned counsel appearing for the parties. The petitioners have not
challenged the observation made by this Court as well as the inspection
conducted by this Court about the awarding of marks. The Court cannot evaluate
or re-assess the marks awarded by the examiners. It is now well-settled that the
Courts should not step into the shoes of the evaluators or examiners and reassess the answer scripts. It is absolutely within the prerogative of the examiners.
The examiners, at the time of evaluation or assessment of the answer maintain
and follow optimum standard and uniformity in awarding marks against each
answer. As such, any candidate appearing in the examination cannot question or
raise any doubt about the process of evaluation or assessment in awarding the
marks against an answer given by the examiner.
In view of this, the Court’s interference in this matter is not called
for at all. That will definitely doubt the integrity and the competency of the
Public Service Commission, which will paralyze the system.
7.7.
In the light of the above observations, I am obviously reluctant to
accept the submission of learned senior counsel for the petitioners for a direction
upon the respondents-TPSC to place the answer-scripts to the candidates to
inspect the same, particularly, when this Court itself has inspected the answerscripts.
7.8.
Now, entering into the second fold of submission advanced by
learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners that they have challenged the
notification dated 20.06.2024(Annexure-6 to the writ petition), I find no
reasonable ground to interfere with the said notification. For convenience, the
notification dated 20.06.2024 issued by the TPSC may be reproduced hereunder,
in extenso:
“TRIPURA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
AGARTALA
No. F. 9 (29-146)/Exam/TPSC/2022
Dated, the 20 June, 2024
NOTIFICATION
It is for information of all concerned that in pursuance of Honb'le Supreme
Court of India order arising upon Civil Appeal No.(s).6159-6162 of 2013 with
C.A.No.5924/2013 and order of Tripura Information Commission vide Appeal
No.TIC-08 of 2020-21/5888-89 dated 20.04.2021 the Commission's decision is
inforce that inspection of Answer Scripts (Conventional Type)/ OMR base
examination are not allowed by individual candidate or any third party. The same
decision of the Commission not to allow inspection of Answer Scripts
(Conventional Type)/ OMR base examination by individual candidate or any third
party will continue. The Commission will not entertain such request either through
plain paper application or RTI application.
-Sd
(S Mog, IAS)
Secretary, TPSC”
7.9.
In my opinion, this notification cannot be said to be unreasonable
and arbitrary. In the line of principles laid down in the cited cases supra,
consistent view is that there must be some restrictions in allowing an individual
candidate or any third party to inspect the answer-scripts. In the opinion of this
Court, the notification dated 20.06.2024 issued by the TPSC is constitutionally
valid since the intention behind the issuance of this notification is to prevent
lodging of frivolous complaints vis-à-vis claims thereof that will lead to an
unhealthy atmosphere in the smooth functioning and administration of Public
Service Commissions. Furthermore, it goes without saying that Public Service
Commissions are perpetually engaged in organizing numerous examinations
throughout the year. Having viewed so, I am of the opinion that the notification
dated 20.06.2024 cannot be said to put an unreasonable restriction, and does not
offend Article 14 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, the submission of
learned senior counsel to quash the said notification is not accepted.
8.
In the instant case, when this Court itself inspected the answer
scripts of the petitioners, in that case, further direction upon the respondentsTPSC to place the answer-scripts before the petitioners will not be proper and
justified.
9.
In the light of the above discussions and for the reasons recorded
here-in-above, I find no merit in the instant writ petition and accordingly, the
same stands dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
SANJAY Digitally
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2024.12.05
GHOSH 15:44:24 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review