Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
BEFORE:
The Hon’ble Justice Hiranmay Bhattacharyya
CO 4537 of 2023
Saikat Mitra
Versus
Amrita Dutta
With
CO 1168 of 2024
Amrita Dutta
Versus
Saikat Mitra
Mr. Debdutta Raha
Mr. Avishek Bhandari
Mr. Rupam Gupta
Mr. Dipayan Dan
Mr. Avishek Bhandari
Mr. Dipayan Dan
…for the petitioner in CO 4537/2023
for opposite party in CO 1168/2024
Mr. Partha Pratim Roy
Mr. Shibaji Kr. Das
Mr. Ahshan Ahmed
Ms. Deblina De
…for the petitioner in CO 1168/2024
for opposite party in CO 4537/2023
Heard on:
20.05.2026
Judgement delivered
In open Court on:
20rd May, 2026.
The Court:1.
The order dated September 19, 2023 passed by the learned Additional District Judge,
Fast Track Court No. V at Barasat in Misc. Case No. 73 of 2021 arising out of
Matrimonial Suit No. 1727 of 2020, is under challenge at the instance of the husband
and wife. The civil revisioanl application filed by the husband is registered as CO
4537 of 2023 and that filed by the wife is registered as CO 1168 of 2024.
2. By the order impugned, the learned Additional District Judge allowed the
Misc. Case No. 73 of 2021 thereby directing the husband to pay alimony to the wife at
the rate of Rs.10,000/- per month for herself and Rs.8,000/- per month for the minor
daughter with effect from the date of filing of the application together with one time
litigation cost of Rs.15,000/-.
3. The learned Advocate appearing for the husband submits that the wife is
having sufficient income of her own to maintain herself as well as the minor daughter.
He submits that the learned Trial Judge ought not to have granted any amount on
account of alimony for the wife.
4. Mr. Roy, learned Advocate appearing for the wife submits that the income
of the husband is much more than that of the income of the wife. He thus, submits that
the wife is entitled to some more amounts to compensate such difference in the income
between the husband and the wife in view of the well-settled proposition of law that
the wife shall have to be maintained in the same status as that of the husband. He
further submits that the learned Trial Judge, without considering the actual income of
the husband has, fixed the amount of alimony for the wife and the minor daughter at a
much lower rate than what the wife is entitled to. Mr. Roy further submits that in the
meantime the income of the husband has also increased considerably and, therefore,
the amount of alimony should be increased taking note of the subsequent increase for
the salary of the husband.
5. In reply, the learned Advocate for the husband submits that the income of
the wife has also increased in the meantime. He submits that since the wife is earning a
substantial amount on account of salary, the wife is not entitled to any alimony for
herself.
6. Heard the learned Advocates for the respective parties and perused the
materials placed.
7. The application under Section 36 of the Special Marriage Act was filed and
registered as a miscellaneous case. It is not in dispute that the affidavits of assets and
liabilities were filed by the respective parties to support their respective contentions in
the Misc. Case.
8. The impugned order was passed sometime in the month of September, 2023
taking note of the income of the respective parties and expenses of the respective
parties as well as the minor daughter as per the available materials that were available
on record. It is not in dispute that in the meantime the income of the parties as well as
the expenses for the minor daughter have increased.
9. A party seeking enhancement of alimony is also free to approach the Court
for such purpose. Though it is well-settled that while deciding an application under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the Court should restrict itself to the materials
that were available on record before the learned Trial Judge at the time when the order
under challenge was passed, however, considering the fact that the matter relates to
alimony and the suit is at the stage of evidence and the evidence of the husband has
already been concluded and a date for evidence of the wife in the matrimonial suit has
already been fixed, this Court is of the considered view that relegating the wife to file
an application for enhancement before the leaned Trial Judge would further delay the
hearing of the matrimonial suit.
10. In course of hearing of these civil revisional applications, the husband has
produced the copy of the pay slip for the month of December 2025 and the wife has
also produced a certificate issued by her employer certifying her salary for the month
of December, 2025 which were taken on record. Copies of the same have been
exchanged between the parties.
11. Mr. Roy, learned Advocate appearing for the wife has also produced the
details of current monthly expenses for the minor daughter, who is presently studying
in Class V at BGS International Public School. The receipt showing payment of tuition
fee and transport fee and other fees to the school for the child has been produced by
Mr. Roy.
12. Wife has claimed that the monthly expenses of the daughter including the
school fees, food, clothing, tuition, extra-curricular activities, fees of medicine etc. is
Rs.41,781/- as on May 15, 2026.
13. From the salary certificate issued by the employer of the wife, it appears
that the Gross Pay of the wife is Rs.1,55,656/- for the month of December 2025 and
after compulsory deduction, the net pay comes to Rs.1,26,914/-. On the other hand,
from the Pay Slip filed by the husband for the month of December, 2025, it appears
that the gross salary of the husband is Rs.2,53,537/- and after deductions and recovery
of an amount of Rs.1,15,543/-, the net pay of the husband comes to Rs.1,37,994/-.
14. After going through the pay slip filed by the husband, this Court finds that
some of the deductions as indicated in the pay slip are voluntary in nature. For the
purpose of fixation of the alimony pendente lite to be paid by the husband to the wife
for herself and the minor daughter, only statutory deductions are to be taken into
consideration.
15. Be that as it may, the husband and the wife are both earning substantial
amount on account of salary income. After considering the salary of the husband and
the wife, this Court is of the considered view, that the husband and the wife have to
share the expenses for the minor daughter in proportion to their respective income.
16. Though Mr. Roy learned Advocate for the wife, in course of his argument
contended that the husband has suppressed his income in the affidavit of assets and
liabilities, this Court is not inclined to accept such submission for the reasons as stated
hereinafter.
17. From the salary slip for the month of March, 2021 produced by the husband
before the learned Trial Judge, it appears that the gross salary of the husband for the
month of March, 2021 was Rs.1,12,567/- and after deduction, the net income comes to
Rs.1,01,933/-.
18. After going through the impugned order, this Court finds that the learned
Trial Judge took note that the monthly income of the husband was approximately
Rs.1,02,000/- but observed that the husband has not mentioned his gross income. Such
finding of the learned Trial Judge is a perverse finding as it appears from the pay slip
produced by the husband that the gross income as well as the net pay of the husband
has been clearly reflected therein.
19. The wife, at the relevant point of time, claimed Rs.25,000/- per month for
her minor daughter and the learned Trial Judge after considering the materials on
record directed the husband to pay a sum of Rs.10,000/- per month for the
maintenance and the educational expenses of the minor daughter.
20. Considering the materials that were placed before the learned Trial Judge,
this Court is of the considered view that the learned Trial Judge was right in fixing the
amount of alimony pendente lite for the wife at the rate of Rs.10,000/- per month and
for the minor daughter at the rate of Rs.8,000/- per month.
21. However, since a substantial time has expired from filing of the application
and this Court has already observed that relegating the wife before learned Trial Judge
to apply for enhancement would further delay the hearing of the matrimonial suit, this
Court is inclined to consider prayer of the wife to enhance the amount of alimony for
the minor daughter only.
22. The minor daughter is presently studying in Class V. From the documents
produced by the wife in connection with the expenses for the daughter, this Court is of
the considered view that the husband should be directed to pay an additional amount
for the minor daughter over and above the amount which the learned Trial Judge has
directed the husband to pay.
23. The husband shall pay an additional amount over and above the amount
directed to be paid by the impugned order at the rate of Rs.8000/- per month for the
minor daughter with effect from the month of April 2026 till the disposal of the
Matrimonial Suit. It is, however, made clear that the husband shall go on paying the
amount of alimony for the wife and daughter in the matter as directed by the impugned
order.
24. Considering the fact that date has been fixed for the evidence of the wife
sometimes in the month of July 2026, this Court requests the learned Additional
District Judge, Fast Track Court no.V at Barasat to make an endeavour to dispose of
the Matrimonial Suit No. 1727 of 2020 as expeditiously as possible but positively by
the end of the month of September, 2026 without granting any unnecessary
adjournment to either of the parities, subject to the husbandbeing not a defendant in
payment of alimony.
25. On a query of the Court, Mr. Roy, learned Advocate appearing for the wife,
submits that the husband is regularly paying alimony at the rate as directed by the
impugned order.
26. The arrear amount on account of the additional amount as directed to be
paid by this Court for the maintenance of the daughter for the month of April, 2026
and May, 2026 shall be paid by 15th July, 2026.
27. The husband shall pay the additional amount on and from the month of
June, 2026 along with the amount as directed by the impugned order within the time
limit and in the manner as stipulated in the impugned order.
28. With the above observations and directions, the revisional applications are,
accordingly, disposed of.
29. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance of all requisite formalities.
(Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.)
sg
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review