Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. Rev. P. No.26 of 2025
Saha Alam
Son of late Abdul Mujid, R/O-, VillKalshimura, P.S. Kalamchara, DistrictSepahijala, Tripura
…….Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
Beauty Akter
W/O- Mijanur Rahaman, R/O, VillKalshimura, P.S. Kalamchara, DistrictSepahijala, Tripura
2.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the learned Public
Prosecutor, High Court of Tripura
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner (s)
:
Mr. H.K. Bhowmik, Adv.
For the Respondent (s)
:
M. R. Saha, Addl. P.P
Date of hearing and delivery :
of Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
13.11.2025
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. H.K. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner and Mr. R. Saha, Addl. P.P. appearing for the State.
None appears for the respondent No.1.
[2]
Initially, the petitioner in case No.CR 03(C) of 2022 was
charged with committing an offence punishable under Section 323
of the IPC for allegedly attacking the respondent No.1, her elder
daughter Ruma Akter (11 years) and younger daughter Tasnia
Akter (6 years) by inflicting fists, blows and kicks etc. Upon
completion of the trial, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Sepahijala District on 28.03.2023 convicted the petitioner under
Section 323 of the IPC but without imposing a sentence allowed
him to be released on probation under the following terms:
“20. In the result, it is hereby held that prosecution has
become successful in proving the guilt of the accused Saha
Alam u/Sec. 323 of IPC beyond all shadows of reasonable
doubt and as a result, I find accused Saha Alam guilty for
committing the offence punishable u/Sec. 323 of IPC.
Consequently, accused Saha Alam is convicted u/Sec. 323
of IPC.
21. Having regard to the circumstance of this case including
the nature of the offence, age and character of convict, the
convict Saha Alam is hereby released on probation for
keeping peace and good behaviour for a period of one year.
The convict is directed to execute a bond for keeping peace
and good behaviour for an amount of Rs. 10,000/- with one
surety of like amount and the convict shall remain under
the supervision of the Probation Officer, Sonamura,
Sepahijala District for a period of one year from the date of
execution of the bond. If the convict fails to observe the
condition of the bond, then he shall be called upon to
receive the sentence to be inflicted. It is hereby further
directed that the convict shall pay an amount of Rs. 1,000/(One thousand) only to the complainant Beauty Akter as
compensation in view of Section 5 of the Probation of
Offenders’ Act, 1958 on the date of execution of the bond
for keeping peace and good behaviour.”
[3]
As per the said order, according to Mr. Bhowmik,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, the petitioner
executed a bond of Rs.10,000/- for keeping peace and good
behaviour during the said probation period of one year and also
deposited
Rs.1,000/-
to
be
paid
to
the
complainant
as
compensation. In terms of the order dated 01.06.2023, the
petitioner was supposed to remain on probation under the
supervision of the Probation Officer for one year from the said
date. On that day the bond submitted by the appellant was
actually accepted by Court in presence of Probation Officer. On
that day, the probation officer was also directed to submit the
status report regarding the conduct of the petitioner, once in every
3[three] months during the probation period and fixed the next
date on 02.09.2023.
[4]
On 02.09.2023, none was present and the regular
Presiding Officer was also on leave and therefore, the date was
shifted to 14.09.2023 for submission of the report by the
Probation Officer. On 14.09.2023, the Probation Officer again did
not appear and the Court asked him to submit a report on
17.10.2023. On that day, the report was submitted by the
Probation Officer. The Probation Officer reported to the Court that
as per the order of the court, the petitioner was supposed to
appear once in every quarter but he did not appear and not even
an intimation was submitted by the petitioner to him.
[5]
Learned trial \Court taking note of the said report
observed on 17.10.2023 that the convict had violated the terms
and conditions of the bond executed by him under Section 4 of the
Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 (for short, ‘the Act’), and
therefore, notice was directed to be issued to his surety and the
appellant (the convict) was ordered to be summoned for his
appearance on the next date. On the next date i.e. on 29.11.2023,
the petitioner accordingly appeared before the trial Court.
[6]
The learned trial Court thereafter, resorting to the
provisions of Section 9(3) of the Act, observed that the petitioner
had failed to observe the conditions of the bond submitted by him
under Section 4 of the Act and also failed to file any bail
application under Section 9(2) of the Act. Therefore, he was
remanded to the judicial custody till his prayer for exonerating him
from the liability of violation of conditions of the bond was heard.
Next date was accordingly fixed on 05.12.2023.
[7]
On 05.12.2023, the learned trial Court observed that
the grounds stated by the petitioner namely, that he could not
properly understand the terms and conditions of the bond
executed by him and that on two occasions, he had gone to meet
the Probation Officer, Sepahijala but he was out of the office, were
not convincing. Accordingly, his petition for exoneration was
rejected. On the same day, learned trial Court imposed sentence
upon him to suffer simple imprisonment for 6[six] months for
committing the offence punishable under Section 323 of the IPC
with a further direction that the period of detention already
undergone by him shall be set off from the substantive sentence.
[8]
Thereafter, the petitioner preferred an appeal (Criminal
Appeal No.08 of 2023) before the learned Sessions Judge,
Sepahijala District and after hearing matter, learned Sessions
Judge dismissed the said appeal on 10.04.2025.
[9]
On perusal of the said order of the learned Sessions
Judge, it is found that the said appeal was actually filed under
Section 374 of the Cr.P.C. by the present petitioner against the
order of learned trial Court, whereby he was ordered to undergo
simple imprisonment for 6[six] months for commission of an
offence punishable under Section 323 of the IPC, but while
dismissing the appeal the learned Sessions Judge observed that it
was an admitted fact that surety had failed to produce the convict
before the Probation Officer and his bail bond amount of
Rs.10,000/- had been forfeited. Therefore, as the surety had failed
to produce the convict before the Probation Officer, learned trial
Court was right in forfeiting the bail amount and correctly directed
the surety to pay the forfeited bail amount and therefore, there
was no illegality in the said order passed by the learned trial court.
Consequently, the ‘revision petition’, being devoid of any merit,
was being rejected.
[10]
In view of the above observations and reasoning given
by the learned Sessions Judge, it appears that it was totally a
case of non-application of mind of the learned Sessions Judge.
When he was under obligation to hear the appeal filed by the
convict-petitioner
regarding
the
sentence
of
months
imprisonment imposed on him, the learned Sessions Judge did not
decide the appeal on the grounds taken by the appellant, rather
treated the said appeal as a revision petition, as if it was filed by
the surety of the said convict.
[11]
Challenging
the
said
order,
the
present
criminal
revision petition is filed by the convict petitioner.
[12]
Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel submits that apart from
such illegality committed by the learned Sessions Judge, there
was also no specific direction issued by the learned trial Court
requiring the appellant to appear before the Probation Officer once
in every 3 months. Therefore, according to him, the order of the
learned trial Court imposing punishment on the appellant itself
was illegal. Learned counsel further submits that as per provisions
of Section 9(3) of the Act, it was obligatory for the learned trial
Court to impose, at best, a penalty of Rs.50/-, since it was the
first time default committed by the petitioner. He also submits
that the petitioner was in custody from 29.11.2023 to 15.12.2023
i.e. for 16 days and has already paid compensation of Rs.1,000/to the victim. Therefore, the period undergone by him in
incarceration may be treated as the sufferance of full sentence
imposed upon him and he may be set at liberty. According to
learned counsel, the petitioner is a hexagenarian, aged about 65
years and is suffering from various ailments.
[13]
Mr. Saha, learned Addl. P.P appearing for the State,
raises an objection and also submits that the provisions of
Clause(a) of sub Section 3 of Section 9 of the Act empower the
Court to sentence a person for the original offence when the Court
is satisfied that the offender has failed to observe any of the
conditions of the bond or bonds entered into by him and
therefore, the learned trial Court was justified in passing the
impugned order. Mr. Saha, learned Addl. P.P also expresses the
view that the appeal filed by the petitioner was not properly heard
and disposed of by the learned Sessions Judge in its true sense.
Therefore, the matter may be remanded back to the learned
Sessions Judge for deciding the appeal afresh. Learned Addl. P.P,
however, admits that in terms of sub-Section 4 of Section 4 of the
Act, no specific order was passed by the learned trial court
directing the petitioner to appear before the Probation Officer
once in every 3[three] months during the probation period.
[14]
Mr. Saha, learned Addl. P.P relies on the paragraph
Nos.51,52 & 53 of a decision of Calcutta High Court in the case of
Chittaranjan Khatua vs. State, 1989 Legal Eagle (CAL HC)
566 which are reproduced hereunder:
51. In dealing with a probationer for the offence for which
the probation order was made the Court must deal with him
in the light of all circumstances and conditions which
existed at that time, not merely those that existed when he
was first convicted. A probation order releases the offender
from custody but required him to be under the supervision
of a probation officer for a period of two years. On proof of
the probationer's failure to comply with the terms of the
order, the Court may sentence him for the original offence.
In this case, the learned Assistant Sessions Judge did not
hold, as contended by the learned Advocate for the
petitioner, that because the petitioner was charged with an
offence punishable u/s 304, Part II of the Indian Penal
Code, his probation order was revoked and sentence was
imposed for original offence. The learned Judge has taken
into account all the facts and circumstances existing at that
time. He was of the view that the condition of good
behavior was violated. It is no doubt true that the
probationer's failure to comply will the probation order has
to be proved on evidence. In the case before us, it was not
disputed that the petitioner was absconding when the First
Information Report was lodged on 30th March, 1987,
implicating him. This fact is also apparent from the order
refusing to grant bail to the petitioner when he surrendered
on 4th September, 1987. At the instance of the petitioner,
the records in the other proceeding in which charge was
framed against the petitioner were brought before the
learned Additional Sessions Judge while dealing with the
petitioner for violation of the conditions of the bond. We
have referred to what the petitioner said in his petition
opposing the prayer of the Public Prosecution for revocation
of the probation order and dealing him with the original
offence. He did not deny categorically the b(sic)h. He did
not give and call evidence to rebut what was already on
record. In the instant case the Court has reason to believe
that the offender has failed to observe any of the conditions
of the bond. Such belief was formed on the basis of the
materials placed before the Court by one Srijib Das, the
brother of the victim in the case where the petitioner was
convicted and thereupon released on probation and the
application made by the public prosecutor.
52. On the facts and circumstances of the case, we are of
the view that the undisputed facts unmistakably point out
that the petitioner failed to comply with the requirement of
the Bond as regards good behaviour during the period of
probation.
54. Mr. Bose then contended that the breach of condition
of good behaviour ought to have been proved in the
proceeding after giving the probationer opportunity of
hearing. Since it was not done, the matter should be
restored to the file of the learned Additional Sessions Judge
for fresh consideration. In our view, this contention has no
substance. Where the probationer does not deny the
breach, the question of calling evidence does not arise. If
he denies the breach, he must give and call evidence. The
petitioner relied on the records which proved his failure to
comply with the requirement of the law. In such a case,
fresh hearing would serve no purpose. It will be a
meaningless pursuit for ensuring procedural formality as
justice has not been denied to the probationer.
It appears that the said judgment was delivered in a
different context. It was not a case in which there was no specific
order of appearance of the convict once in three months, as in like
the present case.
[15]
This Court has taken consideration of the submissions
of both the parties and also the materials placed on record. As
already discussed above, no such direction from the side of the
learned trial Court was there asking the petitioner to appear
before the Probation Officer once in every 3[three] months,
although it was incumbent upon the learned trial Court, as per sub
Section 4 of Section 4 of the Act, to specify in the supervision
order as to the conditions which the convict was required to
observe and comply with. It is a failure on the part of the learned
trial Court itself in giving such specific direction for compliance by
the petitioner and therefore, the Court cannot expect performance
or compliance of the same by the petitioner. The trial Court also
did not even assign any reason as to why it has imposed sentence
resorting to the provisions of Clause (a) of sub Section (3) of
Section 9 of the Act without imposing any penalty in terms of sub
Clause (b) of sub Section 3 of Section 9 of the Act when no
material was there in the record that it was not the first default
committed by the petitioner. Considering all these aspects, the
order dated 05.12.2023 passed by the learned trial Court appears
to be illegal and is hereby set aside. The petitioner is already on
bail, no further order of release is required.
Accordingly, the criminal revision petition is allowed and
consequently, the order dated 10.04.2025 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Sepahijala District, Sonamura in Criminal Appeal
No.08 of 2023 is also set aside.
More than 2[two] years have elapsed from the date
when the petitioner was kept under probation and meanwhile he
has also suffered imprisonment for a certain period. He is a
hexagenarian. As informed, he is now on bail. Considering all
these aspects, the probation period is not being revived further.
The petitioner is, therefore, set at liberty.
The revision petition is disposed of accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.11.19 16:32:12 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review