Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.179 of 2025
Sagnik Roy, Age-34 years
S/O Lt. Ratan Roy,
R/o-Ramnagar Road No.3,
Opposite Ramkrishna Club, Ramkrishna Lane,
P.O-Ramnagar, P.S-West Agartala,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799002.
------ Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary, Rural Development
Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
2. The Secretary,
Rural Development Department, Govt. of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
3. The Chief Executive Officer,
Tripura Rural Livelihood Mission,
Rural Development Department, Govt. of Tripura, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN-799006
4. Smt. Debasree Patwary
W/O Santanu Chanda, R/O Joynagar Road No.6, Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799001
Presently posted as State Mission Manager (Financial Inclusion),
State Mission Management Unit, Tripura Rural Livelihood
Mission, Rural Development Department, Govt. of Tripura.
------ Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. Sankar Kr. Deb, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Saugat Datta, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
16.03.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
19.03.2026
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman
assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. Kawsik Nath appearing on behalf
of the petitioner. Also heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Sankar
Kr. Deb assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. Saugat Datta appearing
on behalf of the respondent No.4 and Learned Addl. G.A., Mr.
Mangal Debbarma appearing on behalf of the State-respondents.
2.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner, Mr. Roy Barman drawn the attention of this Court that the
respondent-authority issued an advertisement bearing No.01/2023
dated 18.12.2023 for filling up of various posts including State Mission
Manager(Financial Inclusion) under Tripura Rural Livelihood Mission
and the petitioner applied for the said post under Tripura Rural
Livelihood Mission and for personal interview, the petitioner and the
respondent No.4 and another were shortlisted but inspite of having
requisite
qualifications
and
experience
of
the
petitioner,
the
respondent No.4 who had no requisite experience was selected by the
respondent-authority for the said post arbitrarily. Learned Senior
Counsel further drawn the attention of the Court referring para No.3
of the writ petition wherein the required qualification and experience
for the said post has been mentioned, which is enumerated herein
below:
Name
of
the post
Status
of
Engagement
No
of
post
State
Mission
Manager
(Financial
Contractual
Upper
Age
Limit
(Yrs)
Required
Educational
Qualification
Experience
MBA from a
recognized
University/I
nstitution
Minimum 5 years of
work experience in
Public or Private
Sector
Bank
Inclusion)
3.
including at least
two
years
work
experience in rural
areas.
Or
Having worked in a
registered
NBFC/MFI
for
minimum 5 years
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that although the
present petitioner had the required educational qualification and
requisite experience for the said post but the respondent-authority
without any basis failed to consider the candidature of the petitioner
rather most illegally appointed the respondent No.4 for the said post
of the State Mission Manager (Financial Inclusion) who did not have
the requisite experience for which the petitioner has compelled to file
this writ petition. Referring the documents annexed with the writ
petition, the counter affidavit filed by the State-respondents and also
the rejoinder filed by the petitioner, Learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that the appointment of respondent No.4 needs to be
cancelled and the present petitioner be appointed for the said post by
cancelling the order of engagement of said respondent No.4.
4.
The State-respondents have contested the writ petition by
filing counter affidavit denying the assertions of the petitioner in the
writ petition. In para No.4 of their counter affidavit, the Staterespondents have specifically submitted that the selection was made
observing 4 steps i.e. Common Aptitude Test (which is a written test),
Group Discussion (GD), Personal Interview (PI) and Rural Attachment
Test (RAT) and in all the tests, the respondent No.4 secured more
marks than that of the petitioner and also the respondent No.4 had
requisite experience for the said post. Thus, the State-respondents
appointed her legally for the said post and prayed for dismissal of this
writ petition.
4.
The private respondent No.4 also denied the assertions of the
petitioner and submitted that she had all the requisite qualifications
and experience and she secured more marks than that of the
petitioner in all the stages and as such, her recruitment for the said
post was lawful and justified and prayed before the Court for dismissal
of this writ petition.
5.
I have heard the parties at length and perused the writ
petition, counter affidavit and the documents annexed by the parties
in the petition. Regarding educational qualification, there is no dispute
on record in respect of the petitioner as well as the respondent No.4.
The petitioner in this case only confined his argument in respect of
experience of the respondent No.4 because as per advertisement two
criteria were mentioned: “either minimum 5 years of work experience
in public or private sector banks including at least two years working
experience in rural areas or having worked in registered NBFC/MFI for
minimum five years”. At the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel
for the petitioner further drawn the attention of the Court that in para
No.4 of the writ petition, the experience of the petitioner was
mentioned and submitted that the respondent No.4 had only 5 years
and 10 months experience and she had no working experience in
registered NBFC/MFI for minimum 5 years and as such, her
appointment was totally illegal. The said fact has been denied by the
respondent No.4 along with other respondents. Learned Senior
Counsel for the respondent No.4, Mr. Sankar Kr. Deb at the time of
hearing drawn the attention of the Court that first of all the present
petitioner had no locus standi to file this writ petition before this Court
because without having any locus standi the petitioner had no right to
seek relief for Mandamus without applying for writ of Certiorari.
6.
In this regard, reliance was placed by Learned Senior Counsel
for the respondent No.4 in Halsbury’s Laws of England wherein the
conditions precedent to issue of Mandamus is mentioned as follows:
(iii) Conditions Precedent to Issue of Mandamus
120. Legal right or substantial interest. The applicant
for an order of mandamus must show that there
resides in him a legal right to the performance of a
legal duty by the party against whom the mandamus
is sought, or alternatively that he has a substantial
personal interest in its performance. In order that a
mandamus may issue to compel something to be
done under a statute, it must be shown that the
statute imposes a legal duty; the duty may be to
exercise a genuine discretion, or to exercise a
discretionary power according to law. It has been
said that the court will not enforce an equitable, as
distinct from a legal, right by this remedy; but it
would seem that an applicant may have a right
enforceable by mandamus to secure compliance with
a public duty to give effect to his equitable
interests.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel has drawn the
attention of the Court that here in the case at hand the petitioner
failed to satisfy the Court that he had valid legal right to pray for
Mandamus
because
according
to
Learned
Senior
Counsel,
the
petitioner in all the stages of recruitment secure lesser marks than
that of the respondent No.4 and referring Annexure-R/2, Learned
Senior Counsel drawn the attention of the Court that the petitioner
only secured 73.33% marks whereas the respondent No.4 secured
77.41% which shows that the marks of the respondent No.4 was
much more than that of the petitioner. So, the respondent-authority
rightly appointed her for the said post.
Further, reliance was placed upon another judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in AIR 1962 SC 1044
[titled as Calcutta Gas Company(Proprietary) Ltd. v. State of
West Bengal and others] wherein in para No.5, Hon’ble the Apex
Court observed as under:
“5. The first question that falls to be considered is
whether the appellant has locus standi to file the
petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution. The
argument of learned counsel for the respondents is
that the appellant was only managing the industry
and it had no proprietary right therein and,
therefore, it could not maintain the application.
Article 226 confers a very wide power on the High
Court to issue directions and writs of the nature
mentioned therein for the enforcement of any of the
rights conferred by Part III or for any other purpose.
It is, therefore, clear that persons other than those
claiming fundamental rights can also approach the
Court seeking a relief thereunder. The Article in
terms does not describe the classes of persons
entitled to apply thereunder; but it is implicit in the
exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction that the
relief asked for must be one to enforce a legal right.
In State of Orissa v. Madan Gopal 1952 SCR 28: (AIR
1952 SC 12) this Court has ruled that the existence
of the right is the foundation of the exercise of
jurisdiction of the Court under Art. 226 of the
Constitution. In Charanjit Lal Chowdhuri v. Union of
India, 1950 SCR 869: (AIR 1951 SC 41), it has been
held by this Court that the legal right that can be
enforced under Art. 32 must ordinarily be the right of
the petitioner himself who complains of infraction of
such right and approaches the Court for relief. We do
not see any reason why a different principle should
apply in the case of a petitioner under Art. 226 of the
Constitution. The right that can be enforced under
Art. 226 also shall ordinarily be the personal or
individual right of the petitioner himself, though in
the case of some of the writs like habeas corpus or
quo warranto this rule may have to be relaxed or
modified. The question, therefore, is whether in the
present case the petitioner has a legal right and
whether it has been infringed by the contesting
respondents. The petitioner entered into an
agreement dated July 24, 1918, with respondent
No.5 in regard to the management of the Oriental
Gas Company. Under the agreement, the appellant
was appointed as Manager and the general
management of the affairs of the Company was
entrusted to it for a period of 20 years. The appellant
would receive thereunder by way of remuneration
for its services, (a) an office allowance of Rs.
3,000/- per mensem, (b) a commission of 10 per
cent on the net yearly profit of the Company, subject
to a minimum of Rs. 60,000 per year in the case of
absence of or inadequacy of profits, and (c) a
commission of Re.1 per ton of all coal purchased and
negotiated by the Manager. In its capacity as
manager, the appellant-Company was put in charge
of the entire business and its assets in India and it
was given all the incidental powers necessary for the
said management. Under the agreement, therefore,
the appellant had the right to manage the Oriental
Gas Company for a period of 20 years and to receive
the aforesaid amounts towards its remuneration for
its services. Section 4 of the impugned Act reads:
“With effect from the appointed day and for a
period of five years thereafter(a) the undertaking of the Company shall
stand transferred to the State Government
for the purpose of management and
control;
(b) the Company and its agents, including
managing agents, if any, and servants shall
cease to exercise management or control in
relation
to
the
undertaking
of
the
Company;
(c) all contracts, excluding any contract or
contracts in respect of agency or managing
agency, subsisting immediately before the
appointed
day
and
affecting
the
undertaking of the Company shall cease to
have effect or to be enforceable against the
Company, its agents or any person who
was a surety thereto or had guaranteed the
performance thereof and shall be of as full
force and effect against or in favour of the
State of West Bengal and shall be
enforceable as fully and effectively as if
instead of the Company the State of West
Bengal had been named therein or had
been a party thereto:”
Under the said section, with effect from the
appointed day and for a period of five years
thereafter, the management of the Company shall
stand transferred to the State Government, and the
Company, its agents and servants shall cease to
exercise management or control of the same. Under
Cl.(c) of the section, the contracts of agency or
managing agency are not touched, but all the other
contracts cease to have effect against the Company
and are enforceable by or against the Company are
are enforceable by or against the State. It is not
necessary in this case to decide whether under the
said agreement the appellant was constituted as
agent or managing agent or a servant of the Oriental
Gas Company. Whatever may be its character, by
reason of S. 4 of the impugned Act, it was deprived
of certain legal rights it possessed under the
agreement. Under the agreement, the appellant had
the right to manage the Oriental Gas Company for a
period of 20 years and to receive remuneration for
the same. But under S. 4 of the impugned Act, it was
deprived of that right for a period of five years. There
was certainly a legal right accruing to the appellant
under the agreement and that was abridged, if not
destroyed, by the impugned Act. It is, therefore,
impossible to say that the legal right of the appellant
was not infringed by the provisions of the impugned
Act. In the circumstances, as the appellant’s
personal right to manage the Company and to
receive remuneration therefor had been infringed by
the provisions of the statute, it had locus standi to
file the petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that
the petitioner had no locus standi to seek redress for Mandamus in
this case, as such, the same is liable to be rejected with costs.
Lastly, Learned Senior Counsel relied upon another judgment
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in AIR 1977 SC 276
[titled as Mani Subrat Jain etc. etc., v. State of Haryana and
others] wherein para No.9 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as
under:
“9. The High Court rightly dismissed the petitions. It
is elementary though it is to be restated that no one
can ask for a mandamus without a legal right. There
must be a judicially enforceable right as a legally
protected right before one suffering a legal grievance
can ask for a mandamus. A person can be said to be
aggrieved only when a person is denied a legal right
by some one who has a legal duty to do something or
to abstain from doing something (See Halsbury’s
Laws of England 4th Ed. Vol. I, paragraph 122); State
of Haryana v. Subash Chander, (1974) 1 SCR
165=(AIR 1973 SC 2216); Jasbhai Motibhai Desai v.
Roshan Kumar Haji Bashir Ahmed,(1976) 3 SCR 58
=(AIR 1976 SC 578) and Ferris Extraordinary Legal
Remedies paragraph 198.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel has drawn the
attention of the Court that since the present petitioner has failed to
make out a case for issuing writ of Mandamus, as such, the present
petition is liable to be dismissed.
7.
Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Deb again drawn the attention of
the Court relying upon Annexure-A and Annexure-B of the reply to
rejoinder affidavit filed by the respondent No.4 wherein it is crystal
clear that the respondent No.4 had requisite experience of having
worked in registered NBFC/MFI for minimum 5 years. So, the
respondent-authority rightly appointed the respondent No.4 for the
post of State Mission Manager (Financial Inclusion) and since form the
aforesaid documents, it is clear that the respondent No.4 had the
requisite experience, so, the plea taken by the petitioner in rejoinder
affidavit in para No.6 cannot have any legal stand.
8.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P. Roy
Barman referring the counter affidavit filed by the respondent No.4
submitted that the statement of respondent No.4 in para No.7 of the
counter affidavit and her subsequent affidavit against the rejoinder
appears to be contrary to each other. So, according to Learned Senior
Counsel, the respondent No.4 had no valid requisite experience to be
appointed for the said post. In para No.7 of the counter affidavit, the
respondent No.4 made the following assertions:
“7. The statements made in paragraph 12 of the
petition are strongly and vehemently denied and
disputed. The contention of the petitioner that the
respondent No.4 has not ever worked in rural areas
in accordance with the criteria mentioned in the
Advertisement No.01 of 2023 are strongly disputed.
The
respondent
No.4
was
appointed
under
No.UJJ/KOL/35951/ER-OFR/03/1361
dated
18.06.2016. The said Ujjivan is a registered NBFC
and such appointment of the respondent No.1
continued till 1st March, 2022 which was registered
as Ujjivan, a Micro Financial Institution subsequently
declared as a Small Financial Banking Institution. As
such the respondent No.4 satisfies the experience
required under the Notification dated 08.12.2023
(Annexure 1 to the writ petition). It may however be
stated that the petitioner himself worked to the said
post prior to joining of the respondent No.4 under
Ujjivan Financial Service Limited and he himself has
claimed the experience of his working in the said
Ujjavan Financial Service Limited as a valid
experience earned by him. It is however stated that
though the petitioner has stated he acquired the
require experience but the statements made in the
said petition do not satisfy as such in as much as the
first part of the experience required Minimum 5
years of work experience in Public or Private Sector
Bank including atleast two years work experience in
rural areas. The experience schedule as stated by the
petitioner in Paragraph 4 of the petition, never and
nowhere demonostrates about the satisfaction of the
requisite qualification in as much as he claims to
have 5 years of work experience in banking sector
which must invariably also include atleast 2 years
work experience in rural areas. Nowhere the
petitioner has stated and claimed that he satisfied
the same experience as is required under the said
advertisement while on the other hand the
respondent No.4
satisfies the alternative to
experience as required under the said advertisement
(Annexure 1 to the writ petition).”
And also in para No.6 and 8 of the reply to the rejoinder
affidavit filed by the respondent No.4, the said respondent also made
the following assertions:
“6. With regard to the statements made in the
Rejoinder Affidavit, I say that I have worked for
more than 5 years in Ujjivan Financial Services
Banks. Initially I joined the Ujjivan Financial
Services Limited on 21.06.2016 and it was fully an
NBFC/MFI to serve the underserved areas which
includes rural areas too. Thereafter, the Ujjivan
Financial Services Limited graduated to Small
Finance Bank. It is to be mentioned here that all
such SFBs when they become bank from NBFC. MFIs
to SFBs when they become bank from NBFC. MFIs to
SFBs they maintain the existing businesses and
existing clients, area of operations etc. and
alongwith that these SFBs they were allowed to add
new businesses. So, there was no surrender of
existing businesses and clients and just the new
businesses added due to the change of status from
NBFC/MFI to Small Finance Bank.
As per the RBI, press release-2014-2015/1090 dated
27.11.2024 it was clearly mentioned here that “The
Small Finance Bank shall primarily undertake basic
banking activities of acceptance of deposits and
lending to unserved and underserved sections
including small business units, small and marginal
farmers, micro and small industries and other
undergoing sector entities.” Also mentioned “there
will not be any restriction in the area of operations of
small finance banks”. May be seen at Annexure 1.
Due to the technological advancements, service area
concept was withdrawn by the RBI during 2014, the
details have given at Annexure B.
Therefore, it is clearly evident that Ujjivan Financial
Services or the Ujjivan Small Finance Bank has
served in underserved including rural areas and
simultaneously. The same experience is also counted
by the Tripura Rural Livelihood Mission.
So, it is clearly evident that I have required
experience
of
NBFC/MFI/Banks
including
the
experience of rural segment which allowed the
screening committee of TRLM to shortlist me to
appear the recruitment process. I secured the top of
the merit list through my performance during the
recruitment process.
I have worked in Small Finance Bank for more than 5
years. And the mandate of Ujjivan Small Finance
Bank is to serve in rural underserved areas, farmers,
small and micro businesses, and more over as per
RBI the businesses of Ujjivan Small Finance Bank is
not limited to any urban area and the branches are
also serving the rural areas. Moreover, the additional
experience of mine in core MFI/NBFC makes me
more strong candidate for TRLM.
As per the RBI branches having no service area
limitation may kindly be seen at Annexure 2.
Moreover, as per RBI SFBs are not limited to any
urban/rural areas, therefore, working in any branch
at Agartala does not define that I do not have
experience for dealing in rural area. Now a days
banking is not limited to brick and mortar branches,
an urban branch is also serving in rural areas
through various channels, and for SFBs it is the fact.
The petitioner’s claim is absolutely full with preconceived notion about him. Here, it is also
mentioned that, the petitioner worked in the private
bank branch of HDFC, he claimed that he worked for
Rural segment and sitting in urban branches. Even
while earlier working in TRLM, the petitioner was
posted at the State level office of TRLM not in the
rural areas.”
9.
So, after hearing both the sides and also after going through
the relevant documents filed by the parties as well as the writ petition
and the counter affidavit submitted by the respondents, it appears
that in the process of selection, the present petitioner could not
secure more marks than that of the respondent No.4 although he was
shortlisted and called for personal interview and as such, the
respondent-authority rightly appointed the respondent No.4 for the
post of State Mission Manager (Financial Inclusion). Furthermore, the
respondent No.4 also had the requisite experience to serve in
NBFC/MFI for minimum 5 years which has been duly considered by
the respondent No.3. Moreso, since the petitioner could not satisfy the
Court that he had the legal right to file this writ petition challenging
the appointment of respondent No.4, as such, this writ petition filed
by the petitioner praying for issuing writ of Mandamus also does not
appears to be valid in the eye of law. The petitioner has failed to
make out any case for issuing Mandamus against the respondents for
quashing the memo dated 10.12.2024 issued by the Chief Executive
Officer, Tripura Rural Livelihood Mission.
10.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner is found
to be bereft of merit. Accordingly, the same stands dismissed. No
order is passed as to costs.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2026.03.20 04:12:54
-07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review