Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 23rd OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 2636 of 2023
BETWEEN:SAGARMAL S/O BASANTILAL, AGE: 48 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
CONTRACTOR AND BUSINESS, ADDRESS: SURAJ COLONY, NAYA GAON,
1.
TEHSIL JAVAD DISTRICT NEEMUCH (MADHYA PRADESH)
SURESH S/O HARIPRASAD SODANI MAHESHWARI, AGE: 45 YEARS,
2. OCCUPATION: BUSINESS, ADDRESS: SURAJ COLONY, NAYA GAON, TEHSIL
JAVAD, DISTRICT NEEMUCH (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(BY SHRI SUNIL KUMAR YADAV - ADVOCATE.)
AND
KAMLESH S/O BANSHILAL, AGE: 30 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE,
ADDRESS: SURAJ COLONY, NAYA GAON, TEHSIL JAVAD, DISTRICT
NEEMUCH (MADHYA PRADESH)
THROUGH POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER DINESH S/O BANSHILALJI, AGE:
33 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE, ADDRESS: SURAJ COLONY, NAYA GAON,
TEHSIL JAVAD, DISTRICT NEEMUCH (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(NONE PRESENT.)
Heard and reserved on:
09.01.2024.
Judgment pronounced on: 23.01.2024.
This appeal coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
Signed by: RAMESH
CHANDRA PITHAWE
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:44:47 PM
JUDGMENT
The appellants – defendants have filed this second appeal under Section
100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (herein after referred to as the Code)
against judgment and decree dated 26.09.2023 in Regular Civil Appeal No.02-A
of 2016 passed by learned District Judge, Jawad, District Neemuch (M.P.)
whereby while reversing judgment and decree dated 01.07.2015 passed in
Regular Civil Suit No.91-A of 2014 by the learned Second Civil Judge, Class-II,
Jawad, District Neemuch (M.P.), the suit has been decreed in favour of the
respondent - plaintiff, directing the appellants - defendants to vacate and
handover the possession of the suit property to respondent - plaintiff within one
month.
2.
The plaintiff filed Civil Suit No.91-A of 2014 for possession, permanent
and mandatory injunction against defendants in respect of house (a two storied
building) constructed on Survey No.1870 and 1871 situated at Suraj Colony,
Nayagaon, Tehsil Jawad, District Neemuch (M.P.).
3.
According to the plaintiff, father of defendant No.1 Basantilal died thirty
five years ago. The grandfather of plaintiff Surajmal and uncle had cordial
relationship with Basantilal. Basantilal was in a heavy debt, during his life
time, therefore, he sold immovable properties (left by Hajarilal). After the
death of Basantilal, financial condition of defendant No.1 was also very poor.
He was not having any proper house for residence, therefore, the grandmother
Signed by: RAMESH
CHANDRA PITHAWE
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:44:47 PM
of plaintiff Shanibai gave the suit house to defendant No.1 till the arrangement
of house by him. Defendant No.1 agreed to return vacant possession of the suit
house, after making arrangement of his own house. The description of the
house is given in paragraph No.1 of judgment of the trial Court, which is
reproduced, as under: “oknxLr nks eaftyk edku tks fd lqjt dkWyksuh Uk;kxkao] rg tkon es a fLFkr Hkwfe losZ
Øekad 1870 o 1871 es a fLFkr gS ftldh pqqrqlhZek mRrj es a izfroknh Øekad 01 ds
LokfeRo ,oa vkf/kiR; dk edku ftls vfuy dqekj firk izHkqn;ky fuoklh bUnkSj ls jftLVMZ
foØ; i= fnukad 06&02&1997 vuqlkj vftZr djuk crk;k gS] nf{k.k esa oknh ds
LokfeRo ,oa vkf/kiR; dk edku] iwoZ esa feJkth ,oa egsUnzflag vkfn dk edku ,oa if’pe esa
vke jkLrk fLFkr gS vkSj mDr edku ds rhu njokts if’peh eq[kh gksdj mDr edku nks
eaftyk cuk gqvk gS ftlesa lrgh eafty ij 9 dejs] xfy;kjk] uky] ysVfju] ckFk:e vkfn
cus gq;s gS o izFke eafty ij fLFkr nks dejs] ,d gky] ,d jlkbZ o ,d ysVfju ckFk:e cus
gq;s gSA”
4.
According to the plaintiff, after the death of his grandmother, with the
permission of plaintiff and his father, defendant No.1 continued to reside in the
said house on an oral permission, without paying any rent. The plaintiff got the
said house by way of partition in the family and the defendant had knowledge
about the said partition.
According to the plaintiff, defendant No.1 has
constructed a house in the same locality in 705 sq. ft. area by purchasing land
vide registered sale-deed dated 06.02.1997, therefore, plaintiff requested him to
vacate the house in question, but the defendant has avoided on lame excuses.
Therefore, civil suit was filed for eviction.
The plaintiff sent a notice to
defendant on 15.06.2011. Now the defendant is trying to deny the title of the
plaintiff.
Signed by: RAMESH
CHANDRA PITHAWE
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:44:47 PM
5.
Defendants No.1 and 2 filed written statement denying the title of
Shanibai as well as plaintiff. The defendants have further pleaded that the land
on which this house (in dispute) is constructed was owned by Surajmal, who
gave it to his grandson i.e. defendant No.1, because of love and affection. On
the day of Basant Panchami in the year 1990, he declared that defendant No.1
Sagarmal would be the owner of this land. Therefore, on the basis of this oral
Will, he has become the owner of the house in question. They have also
pleaded that if the plaintiff has established his title on suit house, then they have
acquired the title by way of adverse possession. Hence, the suit is liable to be
dismissed.
6.
Defendants have also denied that they are residing in the said house by
taking permission from Shanibai since twenty one years ago.
7.
Learned Civil Court framed eight issues for adjudication and dismissed
the same vide judgment and decree dated 01.07.2015, as plaintiff has failed to
prove title of the suit house by way of partition. The plaintiff has also failed to
prove that his grandmother Shanibai gave the house to defendant No.1 by way
of oral permission.
8.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree, the plaintiff
preferred First Appeal No.02-A of 2016 before the learned District Judge,
Jawad, District Neemuch (M.P.) which came to be allowed vide judgment and
Signed by: RAMESH
CHANDRA PITHAWE
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:44:47 PM
decree dated 26.09.2023 passed in favour of the plaintiff. Hence, this second
appeal before this Court.
9.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellants – defendants submits that
the learned trial Court rightly dismissed the suit, as plaintiff failed to prove his
exclusive title of suit house which he got by way of partition; and the learned
First Appellate Court has wrongly reversed the said findings. Shanibai had six
sons and two daughters. Banshilal was her second son and the plaintiff is the
son of Banshilal, therefore, whether the plaintiff became the exclusive owner of
the suit house, has not been established by him. Therefore, the decree of
eviction has wrongly been granted in his favour.
Learned
counsel
has
suggested following substantial questions of law: “fof/k ds lkjHkwr iz’u %&
1- D;k ekuuh; vihyh; U;k;ky; }kjk ikfjr fu.kZ; ,oa fMØh fof/k fo/kku ds foijhr
gksus ls ijolZ gS\
2- D;k ekuuh; vihyh; U;k;ky; }kjk iFke vihydrkZ ¼oknh½ dks nkfo;k laifRr
dk ,dek= LoRo/kkjh ekuus esa ;k fu/kkZfjr djus esa oS/kkfud =qfV dh gS\
3- D;k izFke vihyh; U;k;ky; }kjk /kkjk
lk{; vf/kfu;e dk mfpr vFkZ fu/kkZfjr uk
djrs gq, nkfo;k laifRr ij izfroknh dk vkf/kiR; fdl vk/kkj ij gS] bl iz’u dks
fl) djus dk Hkkj izfroknh ij gksus laca/kh vfHker ikfjr djus esa oS/kkfud =qfV dh gS\
4- D;k izFke vihyh; U;k;ky; vihydrkZ ¼izfroknh½ dks vuqKfIr/kkjh fu/kkZfjr djus esa
oS/kkfud =qfV dh gS\
5- D;k oknh }kjk izLrqr okn izFke vihyh; U;k;y; }kjk le;kof/k esa ekurs gq,] okn
fMØh djus esa oS/kkfud =qfV dh gS\”
Heard.
10.
However, it is not in dispute that defendant No.1 had purchased a house
constructed over 705 sq. ft. of land by way of registered sale-deed dated
06.02.1997, and therefore, he having his own house for the purpose of
Signed by: RAMESH
CHANDRA PITHAWE
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:44:47 PM
residence. Apart from this, defendant No.1 claimed title on the land by way of
oral gift executed on 31.01.1990 on the day of Basanti Panchami. No counter
claim was filed by defendants to get a declaration about the ownership of suit
house. The Family Tree of the plaintiff is not in dispute. The ownership of
grandfather of the plaintiff has not been disputed by the defendants. It is correct
that the trial Court did not find title in favour of the plaintiff, however, in first
appeal, the plaintiff filed Khasra Entries of the years 2010-11 to 2020-21 in
which land bearing Survey No.1870 and 1871 and house are recorded in the
name of plaintiff.
Being government documents, the authenticity of the
documents has not been disputed by the defendants, therefore, the documents
filed under Order 41 Rule 27 of the Code has established the title of the
plaintiff. Defendants took a plea of ownership by virtue of oral gift, therefore,
the plea of adverse possession would not be available to them. The plaintiff is
having a better title documents of the suit property, as his name is recorded in
Survey No.1870 and 1871 situated at Suraj Colony, Nayagaon, Tehsil Jawad,
District Neemuch (M.P.).
11.
Partition document dated 29.06.1990 was filed as Ex.D/8 executed during
the life time of Surajmal and Shanibai. By way of the partition, land bearing
Survey No.1870 and 1871 and the house came into share of Smt. Shanibai.
Surajmal was not the owner of the suit property, therefore, he had no right and
Signed by: RAMESH
CHANDRA PITHAWE
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:44:47 PM
title to transfer the suit house to the defendant / Sagarmal. Defendant Sagarmal
only purchased land measuring 705 sq. ft. from Anil Kumar S/o Prabhudayal
Singh vide registered sale-deed dated 06.02.1997 Ex.P/13. Out of which, south
part of the land area 14 x 45 sq. ft. sold to defendant No.2 Suresh in Rs.11,500/(rupees eleven thousand five hundred).
Thereafter, Suresh S/o Hariprasad
Sodani Maheshwari constructed the house. Therefore, the plaintiff has rightly
been held owner of land bearing Survey No.1870 and 1871 and two storied
building constructed on the said land. The defendant is only the owner of the
house which is situated in the north side of the suit house purchased by
registered sale-deed dated 06.02.1997.
The plaintiff is entitled to get the
possession from defendant for which two months time is granted.
12.
I do not find any substantial questions of law involve in this appeal, as all
the findings are based on proper appreciation of evidence. The judgment and
decree is based on findings of facts.
13.
With the aforesaid observation, the present second appeal stands disposed
off. Pending I.A. if any, also stands disposed off.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
rcp
Signed by: RAMESH
CHANDRA PITHAWE
Signing time: 1/23/2024
6:44:47 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review