Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/55
GAHC040002942023
2026:GAU-AP:220
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.A./9/2023
Sagar Sobar
Resident of Balukpong near Khola Camp, Assam Boundary, PO/PS Balukpong, West
Kameng District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF AP and Anr.
Through the Public Prosecutor, Arunachal Pradesh.
2:Nyakam Rangmo
Age: 0
Occupation :
S/o Lt. Mera Rangmo
Village Kholacamp Bhalukpong
PO/PS Bhalukpong
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
Tana Tara
: Nikita Danggen, Oken Duggong,P Siga,Y Dagiam,K Chotton,Honi
Advocate for the Respondent : P P of AP, Gimi Tarak Amicus Curiae for R-2
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NELSON SAILO
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
Date on which judgment was reserved :
10.12.2025
Date of pronouncement of judgment
09.03.2026
:
Page No.# 2/55
Whether the pronouncement is of the :
Yes
operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
:
NA
pronounced?
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(CAV)
(Anjan Moni Kalita, J.)
Heard Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel appearing for the appellant. Also
heard Mr. T. Ete, learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State and Mr. G.
Tarak, learned Amicus Curiae for the respondent No. 2.
2.
The instant appeal is filed under Section 374(2) of the Cr.P.C assailing the
Judgment and Order of conviction under Section 302 of the IPC, dated
30.04.2021, passed by the learned District and Sessions’ Judge, Bomdila, West
Kameng District, Arunachal Pradesh in Sessions Case No. 05/2019, convicting
the Appellant to undergo life imprisonment, out of which the convicted
Appellant shall spend 10 (ten) years under Rigorous Imprisonment and pay a
fine of Rs. 5,000/-, in default of payment of fine, the Appellant shall undergo
three (3) months' imprisonment.
3.
The prosecution story, in brief, is that on 19.02.2017 at 09:00 hours, a
written complaint was received from one Shri Nyokam Rangmo, S/o Late Mera
Rangmo of Khola Camp, Bhalukpong, to the effect that on the previous night,
i.e. 18.02.2017 between 7:15 p.m. and 8:00 p.m., one Rakesh Beyong was
murdered at Khola Camp and he strongly suspected Shri Ajit Rangmo, Shri
Binglu Takio, Arun Chetry, Sagar Adivasi, and Bikash Boro to be the persons
behind the murder. Upon receipt of the above information, a case was
Page No.# 3/55
registered vide Bhalukpong P.S. Case No. 04/17 under Sections 302/34 of the
IPC and was endorsed to Inspector Sri E. Ette for investigation. Thereafter, the
same was re-endorsed to SI Duto Bagra for further investigation, vide Order No.
BDL/CR-43/2017 dated 18th September, 2017.
4.
During the course of investigation, the place of occurrence was visited, a
rough sketch map was drawn and photographs were taken by the Investigating
Officer. Soil, a twig with blood stains, and blood samples were collected from
the spot and from the dead body of the deceased. One grey shirt and white
ganjee and a red-violet shirt were also seized from the possession of the
deceased and suspect Sagar Sobar (Adivasi), respectively. The collected blood
stains, blood samples and seized clothes were sent to the FSL for chemical
analysis. An inquest over the dead body was conducted and it was forwarded to
the Community Health Centre, Bhalukpong, for post-mortem examination.
Thereafter, the post-mortem was conducted and the dead body was handed
over to the relatives for the last rites. The post-mortem report was received
wherein Dr. Tage Neha opined that the cause of death was hemorrhagic shock
due to excessive bleeding following multiple stab injuries on the chest, back,
neck, and face.
5.
The suspects, namely Sri Ajit Rangmo, Sri Takio Binglu, Sri Mintu Boruah,
Sri Bikash Mahalia, Sri Anand Topno, Sri Arun Rai, and Sri Sunil Jebisow were
arrested on 19.02.2017 and produced before the Executive Magistrate,
Bhalukpong on 20.02.2017 and were remanded to police custody for seven days
except Sri Sunil Jebisow and Anand Topno, who were released on the same day
by the Executive Magistrate as they were juveniles. Sri Ajit Rangmo was
released on 21.03.2017 on bail by the learned Court of ADSJ, Bomdila. The
Page No.# 4/55
other arrestees, namely Sri Takio Binglu, Sri Arun Rai, Sri Mintu Boruah and Sri
Bikash Mahalia were released on bail on 23.03.2017 by the learned Court of
ADSJ, Bomdila. On 23.02.2017, the prime suspect, Sri Sagar Sobar was
arrested.
6.
After completion of the investigation, the Investigating Officer filed Charge-
Sheet No. 08/2017 dated 19.12.2017 against the Appellant, i.e., Sagar Sobar.
However, the police did not charge-sheet Sri Mintu Boruah, Sri Bikash Mahalia,
Sri Ajit Rangmo, Sri Takio Binglu, Sri Anand Topno, Sri Arun Rai, and Sri Sunil
Jebisow. The police named thirteen (13) PWs in the charge-sheet to be
examined.
7.
Upon the appearance of the Appellant before the Trial Court, charges under
Sections 302/201 of the IPC were read over to the accused appellant, to which
he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
8.
The prosecution adduced evidence of seventeen (17) PWs and the
Appellant adduced one DW. The examination of the Appellant under Section 313
of the Cr.P.C was conducted on 20.01.2021. During the examination, the
Appellant denied the commission of the offence but admitted certain facts of the
case, for example, visiting the shop of PW-8, Narayan Sharma and departing
from the shop of Ajit Rangmo (PW-5) in the opposite direction of the road. The
Appellant admitted that a quarrel had taken place between him and the
deceased during the day before the incident at Atobong. After examination of
the PWs and DW and hearing the parties, the learned Trial Court passed the
impugned Judgment and Order dated 30.04.2021, convicting the Appellant to
life imprisonment, out of which he shall spend 10 years under Rigorous
Imprisonment and pay a fine of Rs. 5,000/-, and in default of payment, he shall
Page No.# 5/55
undergo three (3) months’ imprisonment.
9.
Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel for the Appellant, submits that the
evidence on record does not warrant the conviction and sentence of the
Appellant under Section 302 of the IPC and as such, the conviction and
sentence are liable to be set aside. She submits that the instant case rests
entirely on circumstantial evidence, and the chain of circumstances should be so
complete that there is no room for doubt that it is the Appellant and only the
Appellant who committed the offence. However, in the instant case, none of the
circumstances sought to be proved against the Appellant has been proved. She
submits that the learned Trial Court failed to establish that as not a single PW
made any adverse statement against the Appellant regarding assaulting the
deceased. She submits that the timeline as demonstrated by the prosecution
through PW-2, PW-3, PW-5, and PW-13 is contradictory, which makes the
prosecution story unreliable and untruthful. She submits that only the fact that
the deceased was most likely killed by a sharp weapon has been proved through
PW-7 (the doctor who conducted the post-mortem), but the more significant
part, i.e., the weapon of offence, was never recovered even though it was
allegedly thrown in a public place, namely, the Sunday market area where the
market was held the very next day. Therefore, the non-recovery of the weapon
is crucial to the prosecution story and raises serious doubt. She further submits
that the place of occurrence as mentioned by PW-15 is shown in a
reconstructed map of the scene of crime. However, none of the witnesses were
shown the said map, though in their depositions they merely stated that the
place of occurrence was near the house of PW-1. Surprisingly, the house of PW1 is not shown in the map and only the location of PW-8 is shown. Therefore,
the place of occurrence has not been properly proved.
Page No.# 6/55
10. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel further submits that no apparent motive has
been proved in the instant case. The prosecution sought to prove motive by
stating that the Appellant and the deceased had a quarrel at Atobong, where
the deceased humiliated him. However, all relevant PWs stated that the dispute
was compromised and the departure was peaceful. It is settled law that motive
alone, even if proved, cannot be the basis for conviction. She submits that the
time of the incident is relevant, as evidence shows that the appellant left
Bhalukpong at around 6:00 p.m., yet the prosecution argues that he was still
there in between 6:00 p.m. and 7:30 p.m., which was the alleged time of the
incident. The timeline given by PW-2, PW-3, PW-5, and PW-13 is contradictory.
PW-8 stated that the accused came to his shop at around 7:00–7:30 p.m., but
he failed to identify the accused in cross-examination. No Test Identification
Parade (TIP for short) was conducted. Many people visited the shop in the
evening and merely because the Appellant admitted visiting the shop at around
6:00 p.m., it cannot be concluded that he was there at 7:00–7:30 p.m.
11. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel submits that during the statement of PW-4,
the prosecution sought to prove that upon hearing a sound, someone was seen
running away near the place of occurrence 20–25 minutes before the news of
the incident. She submits that this fact was not proved, as the statement of PW3 does not support this version and, therefore, contradicts the statement of PW4. Hence, the same cannot be said to have been proved. She further submits
that the alleged extra-judicial confession made by the Appellant before PW-12
(brother-in-law of the deceased) and PW-17 (his wife) cannot be taken into
consideration in the instant case. She submits that from the depositions of PW12 and PW-17, it is clear that the alleged confession was made before the
police, which PW-12 claims to have heard. In the case of PW-17, he is a seizure
Page No.# 7/55
witness who stated that he heard the same while the Appellant was giving his
statement to the police. However, none of these witnesses made any statement
under Section 161 Cr.P.C regarding this fact. She submits that this allegation
was denied by the Appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C. She further submits that
it is a settled law that an extra-judicial confession is a weak piece of evidence
and ought not to be relied upon unless it is voluntary and true, depending upon
the facts and surrounding circumstances. In this connection, she relied on the
case of Ramanand alias Nandlal Bharti Vs. State of UP , reported in (2023) 3
SCC 510.
12. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel, submits that though the prosecution has
made up a story against the Appellant that after the alleged commission of the
incident he went absconding, the same is not proved. The prosecution relied on
the statements of PW-10 (the previous I.O.) and PW-5 to contend that the
Appellant absconded after the incident. The prosecution tried to prove that the
Appellant came back from Mumbai after PW-5 trapped him at the behest of PW10. She submits that from the record it can be seen that PW-5 nowhere states
that the Appellant came back because he was guilty, rather, PW-5 states that he
came back to clear his name when he was told that he was a suspect. It is also
a fact that PW-5 deposed that the Appellant went to meet his supervisor after
leaving his shop. Therefore, she submits that the Appellant, in fact, did not
abscond, rather, he came back to clear his name when he got to know that he
had also been made a suspect. Therefore, she submits that the prosecution has
failed to establish the fact of his absconding in the present case.
13. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel, submits that the prosecution has tried to
rely on the circumstances allegedly appearing against the Appellant from his
Page No.# 8/55
statement made under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C regarding the blood seen on his
right hand by PW-8. This circumstance, even if true, cannot be relied upon, as
such, a circumstance alone, without completion of the other links, is not
sufficient to convict the appellant. It is settled law that the prosecution must
stand or fall on its own legs and cannot derive any strength from the weakness
of the defence. It is only when all other links are complete and do not suffer
from any infirmity that such a circumstance can be taken as an additional link.
In this connection, she relied on the case of Ramanand (Supra).
14. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel, submits that there are many lacunae in the
prosecution case which show a high improbability of the Appellant having
committed the offence. She submits that no materials allegedly seized by the
police were ever sent for FSL examination. She further submits that no TIP was
held to enable PW-8, who was previously not acquainted with the Appellant, to
identify him. She submits that it has not been shown in evidence from where
the alleged weapon of offence was obtained by the Appellant. She submits that
it has come in evidence that the knife was thrown in the Sunday market area,
where the Sunday market was held the very next day. However, there is no
explanation as to how no one noticed the knife during the Sunday market
despite several people visiting the market. She submits that it is highly
improbable that the Appellant would have visited the shop of PW-8 during the
evening hours with blood on his hands, face and neck. It is very unreasonable
and unbelievable because, as per the statement of PW-10, he allegedly washed
his T-shirt and threw away his long pant and thereafter, stole a long pant from
the house of one Ranjan Narzari after leaving the shop of PW-8. Learned
counsel submits that if the statement of PW-10 is true, then at the time of his
visit to the shop of PW-8, his clothes, including his pant, must have been
Page No.# 9/55
covered in blood so as to necessitate him washing the T-shirt and throwing
away the long pant in the Kameng River. It is, therefore, highly improbable that
PW-8 would not have noticed such blood on his clothes.
15. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel further submits that PW-17, on whom the
prosecution relies to prove the extra-judicial confession, was not put any specific
question on the said point, and as such, the same cannot be relied upon. In this
connection, Ms. Danggen, learned counsel, relies on the case of Asraf Ali Vs.
State of Assam, reported in (2008) 16 SCC 328, wherein it was held that
where no specific question has been put by the trial court on any inculpatory
material in the prosecution evidence, it would vitiate the trial.
16. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel, further submits that PW-13, the cousin
brother of PW-5, Ajit Rangmo, stated that it was PW-5 who actually killed the
deceased. This statement of PW-13 also casts doubt on the prosecution case.
She submits that most of the prosecution witnesses, including PW-12, PW-13,
PW-2, PW-3, PW-4, PW-5, and PW-9, opined that the Appellant was a good
person and that they did not think he might have killed the deceased. On the
contrary, they deposed that the deceased had criminal records and was an
aggressive person. She submits that the PW-13 stated in her statement that it
was likely that the deceased had enemies and that the Appellant, being of
smaller stature compared to the deceased, probably could not have killed him.
Therefore, she submits that the prosecution story does not prove the case
beyond reasonable doubt and the circumstantial evidence also does not point to
anything against the Appellant in the present case. Hence, she submits that the
prosecution has failed to prove it’s case and therefore, the Judgment and Order
dated 30.04.2021, passed by the learned District and Sessions Judge, Bomdila,
Page No.# 10/55
is liable to be set aside and quashed. She further submits that it is a settled
position of law that an adverse inference can be drawn against the accused only
if the incriminating material stands fully established, whether based on
circumstantial evidence or otherwise, and the accused is unable to furnish any
explanation for the same. In this regard, she relied on the case of Raj Kumar
Singh Vs. State of Rajasthan, reported in (2013) 5 SCC 722.
17. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel further submits that it is a settled principle
of law that if two views are possible in a case, one pointing to the guilt of the
accused and the other to his innocence, the view favourable to the accused
should be adopted. She submits that in the instant case, the prosecution has
miserably failed to satisfy the golden test laid down in Sharad Birdhichand
Sharda vs. State of Maharashtra, reported in (1984) 4 SCC 116, wherein it
was held that the chain of circumstances/evidence must be so complete as not
to leave any reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence
of the accused and must show that, in all human probability, the act must have
been done by the accused alone.
18. Under the facts and circumstances as aforesaid, she submits that the
Appellant has been wrongly convicted by the learned Trial Court and that the
prosecution has failed to meet the standard of proof required in a case resting
on circumstantial evidence. Hence, she prayed that the instant criminal appeal
may be allowed by setting aside the Judgment and Order dated 30.04.2021
passed by the learned District and Sessions Judge, Bomdila, West Kameng
District.
19. On the other hand, Mr. T. Ete, learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the
State, submits that through a coherent, consistent and fully corroborated chain
Page No.# 11/55
of circumstances, the prosecution has established the guilt of the Appellant,
namely, Sri Sagar Sobar, under Section 302 IPC beyond all reasonable doubt in
the present case. He submits that the motive of the Appellant is clear, arising
from an immediate quarrel, humiliation, and threats. He further submits that the
conduct of the Appellant before and after the incident is important and the
prosecution has proved such conduct against the Appellant. Therefore, the
circumstances in the present case form a complete and unbroken chain pointing
exclusively to the guilt of the Appellant and leaving no room for any hypothesis
consistent with innocence.
20. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State submits that the
testimonies of PW-2, PW-3, PW-6 and PW-15 establish that the Appellant and
the deceased consumed alcohol together and remained in the same group
throughout the day, which fact was not denied by the Appellant in his statement
under Section 313 Cr.P.C. He submits that a strong, immediate and proximate
motive is firmly established due to the quarrel, humiliation and threats arising
from the fight with the deceased. He further submits that the statements of
PWs-2, 3, 10, and 15 clearly establish beyond doubt that the Appellant felt
humiliated and therefore, there was a strong probability of retaliation by him,
which in fact occurred when he killed the deceased in the present case. He
submits that the statements of the aforesaid PWs, taken together, make it clear
that the repeated acts of assault, humiliation and threats by the deceased
created a situation ripe for retaliatory violence. Therefore, the motive not only
stands proved through consistent prosecution evidence but also stands admitted
by the Appellant himself, making it an important and decisive link in the chain of
circumstances pointing toward guilt. In this connection, the learned Additional
Public Prosecutor has relied on the case of Rohtash Kumar vs. State of
Page No.# 12/55
Haryana, reported in (2013) 14 SCC 434, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court held
that if the evidence on record adequately suggests the existence of a necessary
motive to commit a crime, it may be inferred that the accused, in fact,
committed the same.
21. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State submits that the
Last-Seen Evidence in the instant case forms a decisive link. He submits that the
evidence of PW Nos. 2, 3, 5 and 7 makes it clear that the deceased visited PW
5’s shop at around 5:00–5:30 p.m. and the Appellant arrived shortly thereafter,
leaving a narrow interval of barely 30 minutes between them. He further
submits that both were seen proceeding in the same direction, along the route
leading toward the very area where the body was eventually discovered. He
submits that this testimony is of great significance not only because PW-5 is an
independent witness but also because the Appellant himself, during his
examination under Section 313 CrPC, admitted these movements, thereby
corroborating PW-5's statement in material particulars. Therefore, it is
discernible from the evidence of the aforesaid PW-5 that the Appellant was
moving around the place of occurrence where the deceased was later found
dead. Such circumstances constitute a material fact linking the Appellant to the
incident.
22. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further submits that, though the
exact moment of the assault cannot be pinpointed to the minute, the
statements of PW-1, PW-5 and PW-8 permit a natural and reasonable inference
that the incident occurred between 5:30 p.m. and 7:15 p.m. This timeframe is
entirely consistent with the medical opinion of PW-7 and with the Appellant's
own admitted movements. He submits that the absence of an exact timestamp
Page No.# 13/55
does not dilute the prosecution case, as every other circumstance converges
irresistibly to point to the guilt of the Appellant and fully excludes the
involvement of any other person. He, therefore, submits that the last-seen
evidence in the present case is natural, consistent and unshaken, forming a
significant, though not solitary, link in the complete chain of circumstances
proving the guilt of the Appellant.
23. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor submits that the pleaded case of
the Appellant is not established and the guilt, as stated by PW-8 and PW-10,
consistently points toward the clear involvement of the Appellant in the
commission of the offence. He submits that PW-8, in his deposition under
Section 313 of the Cr.P.C, has categorically deposed against the Appellant, which
strengthens the prosecution case. He further submits that the non-holding of a
TIP is not fatal, as it is settled law that a TIP is not substantive evidence; it is
merely an investigative tool meant to provide corroboration during the early
stages of inquiry. He submits that the necessity of a TIP stands completely
neutralized, as the most vital element, the identity of the person with bloodstained hands, has been admitted by the Appellant himself. Once the accused
acknowledges that he was the person who came to PW-8's shop immediately
after the incident, the absence of a TIP has no adverse bearing on the
prosecution. On the contrary, the accused's own admission of acts provides the
strongest corroboration, rendering any TIP redundant and wholly unnecessary.
In this connection, he relied on the case of Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu
Sharma vs. State (NCT of Delhi) , reported in (2010) 6 SCC 1, wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that conduct which destroys the presumption of
innocence can be considered as material evidence against the accused. He
further relied on the case of Mulakh Raj & Ors. vs. Satish Kumar & Ors. ,
Page No.# 14/55
reported in (1992) 3 SCC 43, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court held that the
absence of ordinary conduct on the part of an accused and the human
probabilities of the case are also relevant considerations.
24. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State submits that the fact
that the Appellant absconded to Assam is a relevant circumstance indicating a
guilty mind. He submits that PW-10, in his statement, has categorically stated
that immediately after the incident, the Appellant fled and absconded to Assam,
which is a classic circumstance demonstrating a consciousness of guilt and has
long been recognized by courts as a highly incriminating factor. He further
submits that the Appellant did not return voluntarily, rather, he was traced and
brought back only after PW-5 assisted the police in laying a trap to secure his
apprehension, which underscores that the Appellant was actively evading arrest.
Therefore, this behaviour of the Appellant is wholly inconsistent with innocence
and, when viewed cumulatively with his flight and evasive conduct, forms a
powerful incriminating circumstance that further strengthens the prosecution
case. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor submits that the Appellant claims
that he was at Charduar, but without providing any travel or location details, as
well as no supporting witnesses, the alibi taken by the Appellant, instead of
assisting him, becomes an additional incriminating circumstance indicating his
guilt. He further submits that the extra-judicial confession made by the
Appellant to PW Nos. 12 and 13 constitutes indestructible evidence, clearly
demonstrating his guilt in the offence. In this connection, he refers to the case
of State of Rajasthan vs. Raja Ram, reported in (2003) 8 SCC 180, wherein
the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that an extra-judicial confession can be the sole
basis of conviction if it is credible and trustworthy. As a matter of prudence, the
Court may look for corroboration, but such corroboration is not an invariable
Page No.# 15/55
rule of law in all cases.
25. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor submits that the circumstantial
chain in the present case is complete, uninterrupted, and incapable of any
interpretation other than the guilt of the Appellant. He submits that the
deceased was last seen alive shortly before the Appellant arrived at the shop of
PW-5, and there was merely a short interval between the incident and the
departure of the deceased and the Appellant from the shop of PW-5. The
medical evidence, supplied by PW-7, conclusively proves that the deceased died
due to multiple stab injuries, which aligns perfectly with the prosecution's
timeline and the movements of the Appellant during that period. After the
incident, the Appellant was found missing; therefore, the aforesaid facts fully
constitute substantial evidence, forming a coherent, consistent, and compelling
chain of incriminating circumstances, all pointing unerringly toward the guilt of
the Appellant and wholly inconsistent with any hypothesis of innocence. He,
therefore, submits that the Judgment and Order passed by the learned District
and Sessions Judge, Bomdila, should not be interfered with by this Court. In this
connection, he relied upon the case of State of Madhya Pradesh vs. Balveer
Singh, reported in 2025 SCC Online SC 390, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme
Court reiterated that certain tests must be satisfied when a case rests on
circumstantial evidence, and the present case fully satisfies those tests.
26. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor submits that the defence version is
false and fabricated, as the Appellant has taken a false alibi which has no
substantive value. He further submits that the non-recovery of the weapon of
offence is not fatal, therefore, it cannot be a ground for denying the commission
of the offence by the Appellant. He further submits that the non-recovery of the
Page No.# 16/55
weapon is not only explainable but expected, and it does not cast the slightest
doubt on the prosecution case, particularly when the remaining evidence is
cogent, consistent, overwhelming, and independently establishes the guilt of the
Appellant. In this regard, he relied upon the case of Laxmi & Ors. vs. State of
U.P., reported in (2002) 7 SCC 198, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court held that
“non-recovery of the weapon used in the offence is not fatal to the prosecution
in all cases. Each case must be decided on its own facts and circumstances, and
where there is overwhelming evidence supporting conviction, the absence of the
weapon does not weaken the prosecution case. He submits that in view of the
ingredients of Section 302 of the IPC being present in the instant case, the
learned District and Sessions Judge, Bomdila, has rightly convicted the Appellant
under the said Section.
27. In view of the aforesaid, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the
State submits that the guilt of the Appellant, Sri Sagar Sobar, in the instant case
is apparent, and he is guilty of the offence under Section 302 of the IPC beyond
reasonable doubt. Therefore, this appeal is without any merit and is liable to be
dismissed.
28. Mr. G. Tarak, learned Amicus Curiae for Respondent No. 2, has adopted the
submissions advanced by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State.
29. We have perused the materials available on record and carefully examined
the Trial Court Record brought before this Court. We have also considered the
detailed submissions advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the
respective parties.
30. We now propose to examine the depositions of PWs and DW before the
Page No.# 17/55
Trial Court.
31. PW-1, Mrs Rina Rai deposed that the deceased was her neighbour. She
heard a sound like vomiting of a dog, so, she came out from the house and
noticed a person was lying on the road, She came close to the person and
identified him as the deceased Rakesh. She called Binglu by name, who was
present in a house nearby the PO. He came along with other boys and found
blood on the body of the deceased. The boys took the victim to the hospital.
The deceased was not in the state of speaking. She informed the relatives of
the deceased. The deceased was alive till he was taken to the hospital. It was
evening time but she cannot exactly say the time. After the death of the
deceased, the police arrived in the hospital and recorded their statements. She
has stated the same thing whatever she has deposed. Police arrested all the
boys who had taken the deceased to the hospital and also her husband. Her
husband was also with the boys who were present near to the PO and busy in
merry making. She recognised the person standing on the dock and said he is
Sagar Sabor. She knows him since longtime back. The accused was suspected to
have commit the offence as he had a quarrel with the deceased on the day of
incident after consumption of alcohol. Later on, he was arrested by the Police.
In her cross examination, she deposed that she was not interested to call her
husband as she had a quarrel with him in the evening. The PO was at a distance
of around 22 to 25 feet away from the place where the boys were merry
making. The body of the deceased lay hardly at a distance of 12 feet from her
house. The sound cannot be heard from the deceased’s house which is a
distance of around 40-50 feet. The mother of deceased was not present so she
informed the other relatives. She heard from Mr. Binglu that the accused had a
quarrel with deceased during the day time on the day of the incident. She did
Page No.# 18/55
not hear the reasons of quarrel. She has not carefully noticed the portion of the
body where bloods were oozing out she did not see the injury. She did not see
the Incident of causing hurt of the victim.
32. PW-2, Mr. Mintu Borua deposed that he knows the accused standing on
the dock and that he is his childhood friend. He was also arrested as a suspect
by police as he was also present at Atobong, Khola Camp under Bhalukpong
Circle with the accused, deceased and other elders namely, Takio Binglu and
Sunil Jebisow. Around 1 or 2 PM Mr Takio Binglu and the deceased asked him to
accompany them in the shed with alcohol in their hands. He agreed and three of
them reached at Atobong and started drinking the local wine. While three of
them were drinking alcohol, one Shri Sunil Jebisow came and joined them. The
deceased asked him to buy alcohol and accordingly, he along with Sunil Jebisow
went to buy alcohol from the market. He happened to meet the accused in the
shop of Ajit Rangmo and asked him to join them. On noticing the accused, the
deceased lost his temper and started abusing the accused. The deceased stated
that the accused is a non-tribal and that he would bury him before leaving
Atobong. Anyway, the accused also joined them in drinking alcohol even after
the threatening from the deceased. The alcohol was completed and the
deceased asked the accused to take Rs. 120.00 to buy alcohol. The deceased
first held the collar of the accused and slapped him three or four times without
any reasons. In retaliation the accused gave one punch to the deceased. He
asked the accused to leave the place but Shri Binglu asked him to stay and
slapped the accused twice. He separated them and cried. The deceased assured
him that he would not be beaten. Accused was chased by the deceased at P.O.,
however, the matter was compromised and the accused left the place in the
evening time when the dark was started. The deceased and Binglu also left the
Page No.# 19/55
place after gap of 5 to 10 minutes. He along with Sunil Jebisow left the place
after 20 minutes time gap when the deceased and Binglu left. He along with
Sunil came to the shop of accused as to know the injuries sustained by him but
he was not found at the shop. While he was having cigarette at the shop of the
accused, the PW-1 told them that the deceased was found at the PO in injured
state and also stated that she was going to inform the incident to the relatives
of deceased. The time gap of the incident of leaving Atobong by the accused to
the information of PW-1 about the injury of the deceased was hardly half an
hour time. He went to his home and did not visit the deceased. On next day
morning at 6 a.m, he was arrested by the police. The accused was arrested
after 5 days of the incident as he was absconding and he heard from the Police
the deceased was killed by the accused. In his cross examination, he deposed
that the accused is a normal person as he knows but often lost his temper in
joking by the friends. The accused sustained injury on that day and there was a
swelling on the face. The deceased was not liked by the people of Colony. He
was very aggressive after consumption of alcohol and always used to show his
Dao. When the accused left the place it was lightly dark. He heard that the
deceased was having a case under NDPS Act.
33. PW-3, Mr. Takio Binglu deposed that he knows the accused standing on
the dock, he is Sagar Sabor. He was also arrested under suspect by police as he
had taken the deceased by picking up the deceased near from the house of PW1. He was also present at Atobong with the accused, deceased and other elders
namely, PW-2, & Sunil Jebisow. The alcohol was finished at Atobong and the
accused was asked to go to buy alcohol by the deceased to which the accused
refused and the deceased beaten the accused. The accused also retaliated to
the deceased. However, the matter was compromised. The accused along with
Page No.# 20/55
Sunil Jebisow left the place Atobong and after few minutes later, he along with
the deceased left the place Atobong. He went to his home and the deceased left
for his house. Again within an hour some of them gathered at a construction
site nearby the resident of PW-1. It was dark and he does not recall the time.
The deceased and accused were not present in the gathering in the construction
site. When the incident was informed by PW-1 they rushed at the PO. He
dispersed with the deceased nearby his house in a juncture where the footpath
road is leading to the house of the deceased in the village. The normal time to
reach the juncture of his house from Atobong is of 5 to 6 minutes. The PO,
where the dead body of the deceased was found is 300 to 400 meters away
from juncture of his home. The deceased was lying on the road in injured state
and blood was oozing out from the body. He was not able to speak. They
evacuated him to hospital. He lost his slippers at PO while picking up the
deceased. After few minute later, they were informed that the deceased had
expired at Hope health clinic, Bhalukpong. The police came later on and
recorded their statements. They were detained in the custody in the same
evening. Later on, he heard that the deceased was killed by the accused. In his
cross examination, he deposed that he knows accused from longtime back. The
distance between his house and the diversion road is around 50 feet. The road
leading to the house of the deceased is not an isolated place but a village. The
distance between construction site where they were merry making is a 20 feet
away from the dead body of the deceased. The PW-1 informed them from the
PO. They did not hear any sound of the incident though it was near as they
were playing guitars. It is true that his slippers were seized by the police. The
deceased was good to him but not good for other people after having alcohol.
He heard that the deceased was having a case under NDPS Act. He does not
Page No.# 21/55
think the accused had committed offence. Court question:- how long you
stayed at home after dispersed from the deceased at diversion point? Answer:He stayed around one hour in his home. Shri Arun Rai came to his home with a
proposal to go at construction site to play guitar and sing.
34.
PW-4, Mr. Bikash Mohalia deposed that in the evening time at
construction site nearby the house of PW-1 they were playing guitars and
singing. Shri Firoz, Ali, Kumar, Toi, Arun and Takio Binglu were present. While
they were entertaining themselves, they suddenly heard the sound of a person
running. They looked towards the sound but could not see anyone. They again
started merry making and after 20 or 25 minutes the PW-1 informed them
about the incident. Accordingly, they came at PO and found the deceased lying
on his belly on the road. When they turned his body they found blood on his
body. The deceased was taken to medical by them. All other boys went back to
their home to change their clothes and then came back to the hospital. PW-4
did not go back to his home. The doctor informed him about the death of the
deceased and told him not to tell the matter to other persons till the arrival of
police. Police came and detained them for safety measures. PW-4 stated that he
knows the person standing on the dock and his name is Sagar. He also knew the
deceased. In his cross examination, he deposed that he heard the deceased
was having a case under NDPS Act. The accused is a normal person. He did not
see the injury of the deceased as he was nervous on seeing the blood.
35. PW-5, Mr. Ajit Rangmo deposed that he knows the person standing on
the dock since 2001. The accused was with him in his shop. He knew the
incident from PW- 1. He was also detained in custody. The incident of
quarrelling between the accused and the deceased was told to him while in the
Page No.# 22/55
custody by his friend. The accused was absconding and as such he was
suspected. On the day of incident, the accused came back to the shop at
around 5 to 5:30 P.M and left the shop to meet his supervisor who came from
Mumbai. Since then he did not return in the evening. Later on, he was arrested
and detained by police. In his cross examination, he deposed that he does not
know the reasons of quarrelling between the accused and deceased. The
accused is a normal person. He does not believe that the accused had
committed the offence. The deceased used to quarrel with others and has
criminal records. PW-5, Mr. Ajit Rangmo had been re-examined and deposed
that the rough sketch map drawn by the police showing his shop, PO and house
of the deceased etc. are correct. It is correct that the deceased and the accused
came to his shop in the evening time on the date of incident. The deceased
came first before the accused to his shop to have Cigarette. Later on, the
accused came to his shop after the deceased left his shop. There was a gap of
half an hour between the time the deceased left his shop and the arrival of the
accused at his shop. The deceased took the footpath road-2 as shown in rough
sketch map. The accused left the road -1 as shown in rough sketch map. The
accused stayed in his shop for around half an hour and had supper food with
him. He does not remember the wearing appearance of the accused. The
accused had surrendered himself before the Bhalukpong Police. The accused is
his friend and most of the time, he stayed with him. At around 8 pm, he heard
about the incident of the deceased. He did not go to PO to pick up the dead
body of the deceased to take him to hospital. He made a call to the accused
while in the custody as per the instruction of the police as the accused called
him in his mobile. They had a discussion on the case. He told him that the
deceased was lying in an unconscious state and he was arrested as a suspect.
Page No.# 23/55
He told him that he is one amongst the suspected persons. He asked him to
come at PS to clear the matter. Accordingly, he came. The arrival time of
deceased and accused in his shop in that evening was between 5 to 6 pm. In
his cross examination, he deposed that his shop used to be closed by 7:30 or 8
pm. The accused went upward towards the bridge and thereafter, he does not
know which road he took. At around 7:30 pm, he heard about the incident of
the deceased. He does not remember who were the persons came to his shop
in that evening. The other friends were present nearby the PO but they did not
hear about the incident. The accused came from Mumbai. It may be true that
the accused should have been run away if he had committed the offence.
36. PW-6, Mr. Sunil Jebisow deposed that he knows the accused by name.
He was arrested as a suspect by the police in the case. He was also present at
Pung under Bhalukpong Circle with accused, deceased and other friends
namely, Mintu, Takio Bilglo and one more person whom he forgot the name,
were consuming wine. They left the said place before sunset. He left the place
along with Mintu and forgot the rest persons as he was drunk. On next day
morning, he was arrested by the police. What had happened in the evening on
that day was not known to him. The police have recorded his statements. There
was a quarrel amongst the friends at Pung area after consumption of alcohol
but he forgot who were the persons quarrelling and who were pacifying. He was
released on the day of arrest. Accused and the deceased were his friends. He
does not know why he was arrested in this case and also who killed the
deceased Rakesh.
37. PW-7, Dr. Tage Neha deposed that he had conducted PME of deceased
Takesh Beyong and submitted the report. The case was of Bhalukpong PS.
Page No.# 24/55
During PME, externally, he found multiple stab injuries on the chest, neck and
back of the body of the deceased. He mentioned the time of injury in the report
which was 12 to 24 hours at the time of PME. The injury was caused by sharp
weapon like knife or Dao. The cause of death was hemorrhagic shock due to
excessive bleeding. He got the requisition letter from the police to conduct post
Mortem of the deceased. P/Ext. 1(B) is the signature of DMO which he had
identified. P/Ext. 2 (A) & (B) are his signatures. His findings are mentioned in
the PM report. In his cross examination, he deposed that he has 17 years
practice in his present profession. He does not remember the exact number of
the autopsy conducted by him in his service. The deceased was brought before
him at 9 am. He had discussed with the IO of the case before conducting PME.
There were internal laceration injuries in the left side of the lungs. The injuries
found with the deceased cannot be sustained from falling from above to ground
as there were multiple injuries in the body which reveal that it was sustained
from other person. In case of falling from above to the ground, the injuries
would be a one side injury.
38.
PW-8, Shri Narayan Sharma deposed that he has a shop at Lower
Bhalukpong which he personally ran. He forgot the date but it was one evening
at around 7 to 7:30 P.M while he was closing the shop, the accused appeared in
the shop and had purchased one marie gold biscuit and one cigarette. He gave
his statements to the police on the next day. The police asked him about the
boys visiting his shop. He told the police that many boys used to visit his shop.
Again, the police asked him whether he has seen any boys to have been
committed any affray. Then, he remembered that one boy whom he did not
know came to his shop with blood in his right hand while receiving the cigarette
which he noticed. His shop is located at between Shiv Mandir and Namgrah.
Page No.# 25/55
P/Ext. 3 is his shop in rough sketch map. In his cross examination, he deposed
that he did not exactly remember the face of the boy who purchased cigarette,
marie gold in that evening. He was also not sure that the accused who was
standing on the dock was the boy who purchased cigarette; marie gold biscuit
on that evening. In his re-cross examination, he deposed that the accused was
not produced before him for identification.
39. PW-9, Shri Pransanta Baruah deposed that he heard that the accused
had committed the murder. The police arrested Bikash, Mintu, Binglu and Arun.
One day when he was going to give food to his son, Mintu Baruah in the jail, he
noticed the accused standing on middle of the road nearby Dhola Camp RCC
Bridge, Bhalukpong. The accused told him that he was going to police station
and on the way at check gate, the police apprehended the accused. He also
went to the jail to give food to his son. His son was arrested in connection with
the death of deceased Rakesh Beyong as he was in the party with the
deceased. In his cross examination, he deposed that he knew the accused since
his childhood. He was goon in their view.
40.
PW-10, Shri Ige Ete deposed the he came to this Court as witness in
connection to the case in capacity of the IO. He was posted at Bhalukpong at
that point of time as SI. On 19.02.2017, a complaint was received from Shri
Nyokam Rangmo alleging that in the evening of 18.02.2017, around 8 pm, there
was murder and the complainant strongly suspected his friends Ajit Rangmo, Mr.
Binglu Takio, Mr. Arun Chetry, Sagar Adivasi and Vikash Boro. Accordingly, case
was registered and endorsed him for investigation. He visited the PO, drawn
rough sketch map and seized blood samples from the PO. Dead body of the
deceased was sent to PME. He seized sporting T-shirt from the deceased body.
Page No.# 26/55
During investigation, he came across a pan shopkeeper, Bhalukpong who told
him that in the evening, the accused came to his shop asking for cigarette or
something else during which he saw blood on face and cloths of the accused.
Accordingly, his suspicion on the accused became more strong and leading to
arrest of the accused. The accused fled away to Assam. The accused was
trapped by his friend Ajit Rangmo over mobile saying that the victim was alive
and under medical treatment and accused was to provide necessary medical
treatment and as a result of the incident Ajit Rangmo was in custody. As such,
the accused came back to Bhalukpong from Assam on being trapped. The
accused was apprehended at check gate and he accordingly arrested him.
During interrogation, he admitted to committing the offence. PW-10 identified
the accused standing on the dock. According to the accused, during
interrogation he was proceeding towards his mother's house in Assam side and
accidently happened to meet the deceased at PO who was coming to join with
the party of his friends. The deceased attacked the accused first and during the
scuffle a knife came to the hands of the accused and he stabbed the deceased.
The accused had a motive as the deceased humiliated him as and when they
gathered. The accused had also committed theft from the hostel of surrendered
Boro Militants as his long pant was smeared with blood. He washed the sporting
and threw away the long pant in Kameng river in Assam side. He seized his
sporting for FSL test. The weapon of offence could not be recovered. The other
arrested accused persons were found innocent and discharged after the
investigation was completed. He charge sheeted the case U/S 302, IPC. He did
not find any injury on the accused at the time of arrest. P/Ext. 5 is seizure list of
one slipper that actually belongs to the friends of the accused and deceased
who took the deceased to hospital. P/Ext. 6 is seizure memo of red design
Page No.# 27/55
sporting Ganji and white half ganji. P/Ext. 6(A) is his signature and P/Ext. (B) is
signature of Tam Rajput which he can identify. P/Ext. 7(A) is his signature. He
can identify signatures of two witnesses as P/Ext. (B) & (C). P/Ext. 8 is
statement of alleged accused and P/Ext. 8(A) is his Signature on it. P/Ext. 2(C)
is his signature on handing taking over of the dead body by the police. P/Ext.
9(A) is his signature. M/Ext. 1 is the photograph of escape route of the accused
and same was taken on leading by the accused. M/Ext. 1(A) is his signature.
M/Ext. 2 is pan gumty shop and M/Ext. 2(A) is his signature. M/Ext. 3 & 4 is the
PO of committing theft of a pant by the accused. M/Ext. 3(A) & 4(A) are his
signatures. M/Ex. 5 & 6 are picnic spot, M/Ext. 5(A) & 6(A) are his signatures.
M/Ext. 7 to 9 is photograph of PO and M/Ext. 7(a) are his signatures. He took
the photograph from his mobile. M/Ext. 10 to 20 are the photograph of
deceased and M/Ext. 10(A) is his signature. P/Ext. 11 is forwarding of FIR copy
and P/Ext. 11(A) is his signature. In his cross examination, he deposed that he
did not know the accused and deceased were good friends. He had no idea
about the sending of FSL test to the seized sporting by the later IO. No eye
witnesses of the incident. He had not found any other criminal case of the
accused during investigation. In so far as he can remember, the deceased was
involved in a NDPS case. It may be true that P/Ext. 5 slipper belongs to Ajit
Rangmo who was one of the persons who evacuated the deceased. The
accused told him that the weapon of offence was thrown into the Sunday
Market area and next day was the Sunday market. He had not enclosed the
authenticity certificate of all the M/Ext. He had not mentioned the date & time
in all M/Exts. He had not received any FIR for stolen of pant. Civilians were also
present at the time of seizing the materials. It was not a fact that he had
forcefully recorded his admission statement. He had not found any other
Page No.# 28/55
enemies of the deceased during investigation except the accused who had no
good terms with the deceased as the deceased always humiliated the accused
when they happened to meet each other. It was not a fact that the accused
returned to Bhalukpong as he did not commit the offence. The accused was in
good terms with Ajit Rangmo. The accused did not meet Ajit Rangmo after the
incident.
41.
PW-11, Shri Passang Dorjee deposed that he came to the Court as
witness in connection with the case in capacity of a seizure witness. He
accompanied the IO of the case during investigation and witnessed the seizure
of T-shirt of the accused from his possession at PS after he was arrested. He
knew the accused Mr. Sagar Sabor after he was arrested. He did not see
anything in the T-shirt. It was seized in connection with the murder case. P/Ext.
12(A) is his signature. In his cross examination, he deposed that it was not a
fact that he has put his signature involuntarily.
42. PW-12, Mr. Nyakam Rangmo deposed that he is connected to the case
as a witness of murder of his brother in- law Rakesh Beyong. The incident
occurred 2 to 3 years back. He could identify the person standing on the dock,
who admitted before him of having killed the deceased. He strongly suspected
that some others were also involved into the offence. Ajit Rangmo, Vikash Boro,
Takia Binglu, Arun Chetry were together with the deceased and as such he
doubted them too. The deceased was with the aforesaid persons including the
accused the whole day. On the day of the incident, the deceased got payment
from O- Metal Company (Kimi). He got the information of the incident from
Nachung Takio. He came to the private hospital located at lower Bhalukpong. He
saw the body of the deceased and found cut injury in the left portion of chest
Page No.# 29/55
and neck. The deceased was sent for PME. He lodged the FIR at Bhalukpong
PS. On searching the body of the deceased, an amount of Rs 3000/- was found.
He had no idea about the deceased having any enemy. The accused was
arrested after 5 days of the incident. P/Ext. 13(A) is his signature. In his cross
examination, he deposed that he heard that the deceased and all the suspected
persons including the accused together nearby the PO during that night. It
might be also happened that some of other suspected accused have committed
the offence with the accused but the accused was not telling them the truth.
The deceased was arrested for other offences too. The deceased was getting Rs
8000/- to 9000/- per month as security guard. The deceased sustained stab
injuries on neck and chest. He heard that other suspects were set at liberty as
the accused had claimed to have committed the offence alone.
43.
PW-13, Mrs. Ragami Rangmo deposed that she is connected to the
case as witness of murder of her brother Rakesh Beyong. She saw the accused
along with other friends with the deceased on the day of the incident. At 5 pm
her brother came to her house at Khola Camp, Bhalukpong alone and had
supper. His house is also nearby her house. He left after about 30 minutes from
her house. While she was cleaning the potatoes in the evening Smti Rina
Rangmo shouted and told them that her brother got cut injuries and was lying
dead on the road. The incident was reported by Rina Rangmo after about half
an hour from the time the deceased left her house. She immediately, rushed to
the PO and found that the deceased was taken to hospital by his friends. When
she was at hospital, Mr. Ajit Rangmo told her that the deceased visited his shop
while coming back from her house and asked for cigarette and matches by
paying a sum of Rs 2 only. On the day of incident, the deceased got payment Rs
2000/- was handed over to her by police which was recovered from the
Page No.# 30/55
deceased. All named person were arrested except the accused Sagar Sabor as
he was absconding. Accused was staying with Mr. Ajit Rangmo. After few days,
someone had seen the accused coming from the house of Ajit Rangmo and
going towards the PS. When she reached to the accused and asked him why he
had killed her brother, the accused told her that he would speak the truth before
the police and that he was innocent. In the meantime, police arrived and took
him away. She heard that the accused had admitted his guilt before police. Her
husband and mother went to the PS and heard his statement. She did not know
the reason behind the killing. Police had recorded her statement. She noticed
two stab injuries on the ribs side of chest. One stab injury on the side of the
neck and also on the chin. After one month of the incident, one cousin brother
of Ajit Rangmo, Mr. Dayuk Gyadi aged about 5 years stated in presence of many
other persons in our colony that the deceased was actually killed by Ajit
Rangmo. She also heard that the weapon of offence was recovered from the
house of Ajit Rangmo and slipper of Ajit Rangmo was also found at PO. She
never believed that the accused could kill her brother as he was physically weak
comparing to her brother. She believed that the accused cannot do it alone. In
cross examination, she deposed that Rina Rangmo informed her at 5.30 PM.
She came to know about the incident upon hearing of a sound and came out to
see it. She found that the deceased was lying on the road. The PO is a silent
place. Ajit Rangmo and accused was not present at the PO. It was true that
deceased was having criminal case. He might have enemies. It might also be
possible that the accused was confessing the guilt on behalf of others.
44. PW-14, Mr. Anand Topno, deposed that he knew the case and that it
relates to the murder of Rakesh. He deposed that he had not seen the incident,
but he heard, after two months, that the accused Sagar Sobar had committed
Page No.# 31/55
the offence. He was arrested by police in connection with the case. He stated
that he did not know the accused on the dock. The incident took place in the
evening, at around 6 PM on 18.02.2017, and when he was at Khola Camp in the
house of his sister-in-law, he stated that he heard shouting by people.
Thereafter, he came out from the house and noticed that the deceased was
lying on the ground with blood. He stated that the place of occurrence was near
the house of his sister-in-law, and he, Bikash and other friends took the
deceased to Hope Clinic. He stated that after he came back to his house, he
changed his clothes because there were blood stains on them. Subsequently,
police called him to reach Hope Clinic, and he was arrested. In his cross-
examination, he stated he did not know the deceased before the incident. He
stated that he knew him by face. He stated that at the time of his arrival at the
place of occurrence, the deceased was making sounds like the sound of a dog
and he could not speak. He stated that the place of occurrence was not very
visible, as there was no light. He stated that he had not seen any person escape
from the place of occurrence. He, along with some other persons, was arrested
on suspicion of being relatives of the deceased.
45. PW-15, Duto Bagra deposed that he was connected to the Court as he
is 2nd IO of the case. The case was endorsed him on 18.09.2017 and he had
examined 1 or 2 witnesses. He had also prepared and reconstructed rough
sketch map. He filed the CS U/s- 302/201 IPC on the basis of investigation
already done by previous IO. The motive of the crime was for revenge. The
accused and deceased were friends and, on that day, the accused Sagar Sabor,
Sunil Jebisow, Mintu Barua, Takio Binglu & deceased had gone to picnic at
Atobong located in Khola Camp Bhalukpong. They consumed alcohol and ganja
in the picnic. The local beers which they had brought were finished but they
Page No.# 32/55
wanted more. Mr. Mintu Borua was asked to fetch more beer by the deceased.
But Mintu Borua handed over the money to accused Sagar Sabor to fetch local
but the accused refused. On refusal by the accused, deceased Rakesh Beyong
got annoyed and slapped the accused. After having fun at Atobong, they left for
their own house in the evening. In between 6 to 7 pm, the accused came to the
shop of Ajit Rangmo and at the same time, the deceased also came to that shop
and after purchasing a cigarette the deceased left for his home. As soon as the
deceased left for his house, accused also left telling Ajit Rangmo that he was
going to visit his mother. Both of them left in different directions, there are two
roads leading to the house of deceased. One of the roads is towards left and
other is right of the shop of Ajit Rangmo. Deceased took the road of left
direction and accused took road of right direction. Instead of visiting his mother,
accused turned towards the road which lead to the house of deceased. On the
way he found deceased and assaulted him with a knife due to which deceased
sustained multiple stab injuries and succumbed to his injuries. The accused
disclosed that after committing crime, he took the road to Sunday market
located in Assam side and came on the highway where he went to a shop run
by one Mr. Narayan Sharma. At that time, there were blood stains in his hand,
face, body & cloths. He asked biscuit & cigarette from the shopkeeper. When
the shopkeeper queried him about the blood on cloths and face, the accused
told that he had a fight with a boy. After that the alleged accused proceeded
towards (Thursday) on foot and had stolen a jeans pant from the house of
Rahul Narzary. After that, he went to the bank of river Kameng and washed
himself. The weapon of offence could not be recovered as it was thrown at
Sunday market place and immediately next day the Sunday market was
conducted there. P/Ext. 14 is CS P/Ext. 14(A) & (B) are his signatures. P/Ext. 15
Page No.# 33/55
is Seizure list. P/Ext. 15(A) is his signature. P/Ext. 16 is particular of accused.
P/Ext. 16(A) to (H) are his signatures. P/Ext. 17 is particular of witnesses.
P/Ext.17(A) are his signatures. P/Ext. 3 is reconstruction of rough sketch map of
scene of crime. P. Ext. 3(A) is his signature. P/Ext. 18 is statement of Ajit
Rangmo. P.Ext. 18(A) is his signature. P/Ext. 19 is statement of Prasant Borua.
P.Ext. 19(A) is his signature. P/Ext. 20 is statement of Narayan Sharma. P/Ext.
(A) is his signature.
46. PW-16, Mr. Ashok Sono deposed that he knows the case. It is a murder
case of Rakesh Beyong. He had not seen the incident but he heard that the
accused Sagar Sabor had committed the offence. He witnessed the seizure
memo P/Ext. No. 5 and P/Ext. No. 5(b) is his signature. In his cross
examination, he deposed that he put his signature on P/Ext. No. 5 at the PO.
Many people were there but his brother and he had put his signature.
47. PW-17, Mr. Babing Beyong deposed that police called him at PO but he
had not put his signature on the seizure memo P/Ext. No. 5. The signature in
P.EX. No. 5 appears to correspond to his name but it did not belong to him. He
was present at the time of recording the statement of the accused by the police
during which the accused admitted to commit the offence. In his cross
examination he deposed that he did not give statement to the police.
48.
DW- 1, Mr. Sagar Sabor deposed that admittedly, he was present in
party in day time but he was not present at PO at the time of the incident as he
was in another place. At the time of incident, he was at Charduar. The party was
ended around 5 p.m. and he came back to his partnership shop with Ajit
Rangmo. From his shop, he went to his house around 5:40 pm and then to bus
stand at around 6 p.m. He was called from Charduar by Ajit Rangmo over
Page No.# 34/55
telephone informing that the deceased was beaten by unknown person and
asked him to come back if he has not committed the offence to the deceased.
He also told him that the deceased was in medical and alive & unable to speak.
Accordingly, he came back to Bhalukpong and told them that he had not
committed the offence. In his cross examination he deposed that it was not a
fact that he would never come back if he heard news of death of deceased. He
received the call after four days of incident. It was not fact that he made a call
to Ajit Rangmo in order to gather information about the deceased. It was not a
fact that his hand was found with spot of blood at the time of purchasing
cigarette from shop. It was fact that deceased used to humiliate him at various
occasions. He was aggressive in nature. Не informed his mother and sister
about his going to Charduar. He did not know about the exact incident. He was
not able to produce other defence witnesses. Court examination: His home is
walking distance of 15 minutes from his partnership shop with Ajit Rangmo. The
distance between shops of Ajit Rangmo & Nayaran Sharma is a walking distance
of around 25 minute
49. From the above depositions as well as the materials brought before this
Court, the following facts are discernible and emerge:
i) that the Appellant and the deceased were present at a place called
Atobong, located at Khola Camp, along with some other persons,
consuming alcohol. All those who were present at that place left
sometime in the evening before 5 P.M. There was a quarrel between
the deceased and the Appellant due to some humiliating words used
by the deceased against the Appellant. Consequently, a fight
occurred between the deceased and the Appellant, however, the
Page No.# 35/55
same was later compromised, though the Appellant sustained some
injuries during the tussle.
ii) An FIR was lodged by one Nyokam Rangmo before the Officer-inCharge of Bhalukpong Police Station on 19.02.2017, alleging that
one of his family members, namely, Sri Rakesh Beyong (the
deceased), was murdered by someone at Khola Camp at around
7:15 PM to 8:00 PM. It was alleged that the family of the deceased
suspected Shri Ajit Rangmo, Shri Binglu Takhio, Arun Chetry, Sagar
Adivasi (the accused appellant) and Bikash Boro of committing the
murder. It was also alleged that they strongly suspected Mrs. Reena
Rangmo to be involved in the murder case because of her activities
on the previous night. However, during the investigation, Shri Ajit
Rangmo, Shri Binglu Takhio, Arun Chetry, and Bikash Boro were
discharged by the police, having found no materials against them.
Having found sufficient materials against the Appellant, he was
charged with the murder of the deceased, namely Shri Rakesh
Beyong.
iii) From the depositions before the Trial Court, it is seen that PW-1,
i.e., Mrs. Rina Rai, was the first person who saw the deceased lying
on the road beside her house. She called PW-3, namely Shri Takio
Binglu, who was busy merry-making with his friends at a
construction site located at a distance of about 20 to 25 feet from
the place of occurrence. PW-1 also informed the relatives of the
deceased. It is seen that the house of the deceased was about 50
feet away from the place of occurrence.
Page No.# 36/55
iv) As per the evidence of PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4, namely, Mintu
Borua, Takio Binglu and Bikash Mohalia respectively, neither the
accused nor the victim was present with them at the halfconstructed site where they were merry-making at that point of
time. It is also seen that the place where they were merry-making
was about 25 feet away from the place of occurrence.
v) It also emerges from the depositions of PW-2, PW-3, PW-4 and
PW-6 that the Appellant and the deceased had a quarrel at Atobong
during the day prior to the incident in the evening. It is seen that
PW-3, namely Takio Binglu, accompanied the deceased from
Atobong to a point from where they both proceeded to their
respective houses.
vi) It is seen from the deposition of PW-2, namely Mintu Barua, that
he along with PW-6, namely Sunil Jebisow, left the place at Atobong
about 20 minutes after the deceased and PW-3, namely Takio
Binglu, had left. PW-2 stated that he along with PW-6, went to the
shop of the accused appellant to enquire about his injuries but the
accused appellant was not found at the shop. It is stated that while
he was having a cigarette at the shop of the Appellant, PW-1
informed them about the incident.
vii) It is also seen from the deposition of PW-4, namely Bikash
Mohalia, that Shri Firoz, Ali, Kumar, Toi, Arun and Takio Binglu were
present at the construction site when they heard the sound of a
person running but no one was seen. However, he stated that after
about 20 to 25 minutes, PW-1 informed them about the incident.
Page No.# 37/55
viii) PW-5, Shri Ajit Rangmo, deposed that the Accused came to his
shop in the evening between about 5:00 PM and 6:00 PM but left
the shop to meet his supervisor who had come from Mumbai. He
further stated that the deceased also came to his shop in the
evening on the same day to have a cigarette. He stated that the
deceased had come before the accused appellant arrived at his
shop. According to him, there was a gap of about half an hour
between the arrival of the deceased and the accused at the shop.
He further stated that the deceased took footpath road-2, while the
accused left through road-1. He also stated that, as per the
instructions of the police, he informed the Appellant that the
deceased was lying unconscious and that the Appellant was one of
the suspected persons. He stated that he asked the Appellant to
come back and clear his name in the matter. Accordingly, the
Appellant returned and was apprehended by the police.
ix) One of the key witnesses in the instant case, i.e., PW-8, namely
Narayan Sharma, deposed that he runs a shop at Lower
Bhalukpong. He stated that although he forgot the exact date, it was
in the evening at around 7:00–7:30 PM when he was closing his
shop that the Appellant appeared at the shop and purchased one
marigold biscuit and one cigarette. He further stated that he gave
his statement to the police on the following day when the police
came to ask him about the persons who had visited his shop. He
recalled the boy, whom he did not know, but noticed blood on his
right hand while handing over the cigarette. When he asked about
the blood, he replied about a fight. PW-8 later recognized the same
Page No.# 38/55
boy in the dock as the person who had purchased the marigold
biscuit and cigarette from his shop that evening.
x) It is also seen that during the examination of the Appellant under
Section 313 Cr.P.C, the Appellant admitted that he had visited the
shop to buy a marigold biscuit and a cigarette. However, he declined
to comment on the noticing of blood on his right hand by PW-8. It is
pertinent to mention that, as per his statement under Section 313
Cr.P.C, the Appellant arrived at the shop of PW-8 at around 6:00 PM,
rather than at 7:00–7:30 PM as deposed by PW-8. Therefore, there
is no denial of the fact that the Appellant had, in fact, visited the
shop of PW-8, though there is a difference regarding the time of his
visit.
xi) PW-12, namely Nyakam Rangmu, deposed that the Appellant
admitted before him that he had killed the deceased. However, in his
statement he also stated that he suspected that the Appellant might
have committed the offence along with some other suspected
persons and that the Appellant was not disclosing the correct facts.
In addition to what PW-12 had stated, PW-14, namely Shri Babing
Beyong, stated that he was present at the time of recording of the
statement of the Appellant by the police, during which the Appellant
admitted to having committed the offence. It is also seen that
during his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C, the Appellant did not
make any comments in his defence against the statement of PW-14.
However, he denied the statement of PW-12.
xii) It is seen from the evidence of PW-1 that the place of
Page No.# 39/55
occurrence lies around 50 feet away from the house of the
deceased. It is also seen from the evidence of PW-5 that the
deceased left his shop about half an hour before the arrival of the
Appellant and that the Appellant, after staying there for about half
an hour with PW-5, left the place. It is also seen from the evidence
of PW-13 that the deceased came to her house at about 5:00 PM,
had supper and thereafter, left the place. It is further seen from the
evidence of PW-3 that he left the deceased at a junction near the
house of the deceased. Therefore, there is a possibility that the
deceased might have visited the shop of PW-5 between 5:00 PM and
6:00 PM and thereafter, took road-2 and had supper at the house of
PW-13. It is also seen from the evidence of PW-13 that he might
have thereafter come out to join the merry-making at the halfconstructed site, which was around 25 feet away from the place of
occurrence and around 50 feet from the house of PW-13.
xiii) PW-10, namely Shri Ige Ete, the first Investigating Officer (I.O.)
of the case, deposed that during the investigation, he came across a
pan shopkeeper in Bhalukpong who stated that in the evening a boy
had visited his shop asking for a cigarette and some other items,
during which the shopkeeper noticed blood on his face and clothes.
He stated that the Appellant fled to Assam, however, the Appellant
was traced through his friend, Shri Ajit Rangmo, who called him over
the phone. Accordingly, the Appellant returned to Bhalukpong and
was subsequently arrested. PW-10 further stated that the Appellant
admitted to having committed the offence. The Appellant stated that
while proceeding towards his mother’s house, he accidentally
Page No.# 40/55
encountered the deceased at the place of occurrence, the deceased
being on his way to join a merry-making party with his friends. The
Appellant admitted that the deceased attacked him first and during
the scuffle, he stabbed the deceased with a knife. PW-10 further
stated that the Appellant admitted to having stolen clothes from the
hostel of surrendered Boro militants in order to dispose of his bloodsmeared long pant. The Appellant also admitted to having washed
the sporting and thrown the long pant into the Kameng River on the
Assam side. PW-10 further stated that the weapon of offence could
not be recovered as it was disposed of in the area where the weekly
Sunday market is held.
xiv) PW-15, Shri Duto Bagra, the second Investigating Officer of the
case, deposed similarly as stated by PW-10 and corroborated the
prosecution’s case.
50. It is seen in the case in hand that no one has been able to pinpoint the
exact time when the murder actually occurred. However, the FIR suggests that
the incident must have taken place between 7:15 PM and 8:00 PM, as PW-1
discovered the body of the deceased around that time. From all the evidence, as
discussed above, the timing of the offence is approximately during this period.
PW-8 specifically stated that he met the Appellant in his shop at around 7:007:30 PM, which he particularly remembers because it was the usual time when
he closes his shop. The fact of the Appellant visiting PW-8’s shop was not
denied by him during his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C, therefore, it
cannot be ruled out in certain terms that the Appellant was not present in and
around the place of occurrence when the offence actually took place.
Page No.# 41/55
51. The evidence of PW-8, coupled with the admission of the Appellant that he
visited the shop of PW-8, constitutes very strong evidence against him,
establishing that Appellant was in the vicinity of place of occurrence at the
relevant time. The Appellant contended that he left Bhalukpong at around 6:00
PM for Assam, however, this claim is doubtful, as PW-8 specifically stated that
the Appellant was present at his shop around 7:00–7:30 PM. PW-8 stated that
he remembered the timing as usually he closes his shop during that time and
the Appellant visited him during that time. The evidence of PW-5 and PW-13
further indicate that the Appellant left PW-5’s shop after the deceased had left,
probably with a gap of about half an hour. It is also seen that after leaving the
shop, the deceased went to PW-13’s house, had his food, and thereafter left the
place. Therefore, if the deceased left after half an hour and the Appellant left
the shop around the same time, there is a strong probability that the Appellant
and the deceased encountered each other at that point.
52. It is also seen from the statement of PW-5 that the Appellant left the shop
at around 5:40 PM, stating that he was going to meet his supervisor who had
arrived from Mumbai. It is further seen from the evidence that the shop of PW-8
is located at a place that takes about 25 minutes to reach from the shop of PW5. Therefore, in sequence, if the Appellant left the shop of PW-5 at about 5:40
PM, visited his own house and then proceeded to the shop of PW-8, the
probability is that he would have reached the shop of PW-8 by around 6:00 PM,
as claimed by the Appellant. It is also seen that the Appellant claimed that he
left Bhalukpong and went to Assam and thereafter, to Mumbai, returning only
when PW-5 called him. However, there is no material brought before the Trial
Court to support this claim, as he could not produce any evidence corroborating
his later movements. Consequently, the alibi taken by the Appellant becomes
Page No.# 42/55
difficult to be trusted without any corroboration or evidence to that effect. He
failed to provide any details to show that he had actually left the place of
occurrence at around 6:00 PM, after the alleged commission of the murder and
returned only after five days upon learning of the incident and that he was
suspected of committing the offence. Since the Appellant has taken an alibi then
same needs to be supported by his explanation, corroboration and evidence.
53. From the above summary of evidence, it is seen that the party at Atobong
ended sometime around 5:00 PM, although none of the witnesses could
precisely recollect or state the exact time when the party concluded. It was,
however, stated that the party ended when it was about to get dark in the
evening. The evidence further shows that the Appellant and the deceased left
the party at Atobong in a gap of approximately 10-15 minutes. It is seen that
the Appellant came to the shop of PW-5 after the deceased had already left the
shop and according to the evidence, there was a gap of about half an hour
between the arrivals of the deceased and the Appellant. Therefore, it is
apparent that the Appellant must have spent some time somewhere after
leaving Atobong and before reaching the shop of PW-5, whereas the deceased
may have reached the shop directly.
54. In his first examination, PW-5 stated that the Appellant visited his shop
between 5:00 and 5:30 PM, whereas in his second examination, he stated that
the Appellant visited the shop between 5:00 and 6:00 PM. Therefore, it may be
taken that both the Appellant and the deceased visited the shop of PW-5 in
between 5:00 and 6:00 PM. If the timing is considered as 5:00–5:30 PM, then
the Appellant must have visited the shop of PW-5 around 5:30 PM because the
Appellant visited his shop after the leaving of the shop by the deceased and as
Page No.# 43/55
there was a gap of 30 mnts. time. So If after the party at Atobong about 5 PM,
the deceased visited his place after 5 PM about 5:10 PM, he must have left the
place at 5:10-15 PM and thereafter, the Appellant arrived at the shop at around
5:40 PM and thereafter, stayed for another half an hour, having food. In that
case, he must have left the shop about 6:10-15 PM and in that case, it would
not have been possible for him to reach the shop of PW-8 before 6:00 PM, as he
had claimed. On the other hand, if the timing is taken as 5:30–6:00 PM for the
visit of both the Appellant and the deceased to PW-5’s shop, it would be even
more difficult for the Appellant to reach the shop of PW-8 before 6:00 PM.
Considering that the shop of PW-8 takes about 25 minutes to reach from PW-5’s
shop, in either case, it would still not have been possible for the Appellant to
reach PW-8’s shop before 6:00 PM. Therefore, the circumstances of the case
clearly indicate that the presence of the Appellant near the place of occurrence
at the time of the incidence and the same cannot be disregarded.
55. It is also seen from the evidence of PW-13 that the deceased visited her
house at about 5:00 PM and spent approximately 30 minutes there. She further
stated that she was informed about the commission of the murder by Mrs.
Reena Rangmo about half an hour after the deceased had left her house.
Therefore, the incident appears to have occurred between 5:30-6:30 PM. This
fact indicates that if the deceased visited the shop of PW-5 at 5:00 PM, the
incident must have taken place approximately around 6:30 PM. If, however, the
deceased visited the shop of PW-5 at around 5:30 PM and thereafter, visited his
sister’s house then the incident would have occurred around 7:30 PM. In either
scenario, the probable presence of the Appellant at or near the place of
occurrence cannot be ruled out taking into account the statement of PW5 as
discussed above.
Page No.# 44/55
56. It is also seen from the deposition of PW-3 and PW-4 that they heard the
sound of a person running when they were merry-making and they received
information about the incident from PW-1 within 20 minutes of hearing such
sound. This also places the occurrence of the incident sometime around 6:30
PM. It is further seen from the medical report that the approximate time of the
incident was 12 to 24 hours prior to the examination. The post-mortem
examination was conducted on 19.02.2017 at 9:00 hours; therefore, the postmortem report also indicates that the timing of the incident was within the time
suggested in the prosecution story. PW-8 was specific in his statement that the
Appellant came to his shop at about 7.00 to 7.30 p.m. This circumstance also
strongly points towards the presence of the Appellant near the place of
occurrence at that point of time. This negates the version of the Appellant that
he left Bhalukpung at 6 PM. Taking into account the entire facts as they have
emerged in the instant case, the circumstances clearly provide valuable material
to show the presence of the Appellant near the place of occurrence at the time
of commission of the offence, that is sometime between 6.00 PM. and 7.00 PM.
57. It is also seen from the evidence that the motive of the Appellant in the
commission of the murder can be inferred from the incident that happened in
the earlier part of the day, wherein the deceased had assaulted the Appellant. It
is further seen that the Appellant went missing after the alleged commission of
the offence and returned only when he was assured by his friend, PW-5, about
the status of the deceased as being under medical treatment.
58. It is also seen that although the Appellant had taken an alibi by stating
that he was not present at the time of the occurrence and that he had, in fact,
not absconded but had gone for some work without knowing anything about the
Page No.# 45/55
alleged commission of the offence, in his defence, he could not produce any
material to support the aforesaid alibi. Rather, he admitted that he had visited
the shop of PW-8 in the evening. Therefore, the circumstances, as discussed
above, clearly show the proximate presence of the Appellant at the place of
occurrence at the relevant point of time and the prosecution’s story could not be
shaken by the defence in the instant case.
59. Ms. Danggen, learned counsel for the Appellant and Mr. T. Ete, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor for the State, have cited several case laws, which
have been duly considered by this Court. Relevant ones are discussed below.
60. As far as the question of motive is concerned, the learned Additional Public
Prosecutor for the State has relied on the case of Rohtash Kumar v. State of
Haryana, reported in (2013) 14 SCC 434, wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court held
that if the evidence on record adequately suggests the existence of a necessary
motive to commit a crime, it may be inferred that the accused, in fact,
committed the same. In this connection, paragraph 28, being relevant, is
extracted herein below:
“28.
The evidence regarding the existence of a motive which operates
in the mind of the accused is very often very limited, and may not be
within the reach of others. The motive driving the accused to commit an
offence may be known only to him and to no other. In a case of
circumstantial evidence, motive may be a very relevant factor. However, it
is the perpetrator of the crime alone who is aware of the circumstances
that prompted him to adopt a certain course of action, leading to the
commission of the crime. Therefore, if the evidence on record suggests
adequately, the existence of the necessary motive required to commit a
crime, it may be conceived that the accused has in fact, committed the
same. (Vide: Subedar Tewari v. State of U.P. & Ors., AIR 1989 SC
733; Suresh Chandra Bahri v. State of Bihar, AIR 1994 SC 2420; and Dr.
Page No.# 46/55
Sunil Clifford Daniel v. State of Punjab, (2012) 11 SCC 205).”
61. In the instant case, it is evident that there was a quarrel between the
Appellant and the deceased. The quarrel arose because the deceased humiliated
the Appellant. The quarrel resulted in a physical assault in which the Appellant
was injured. Therefore, there is a strong possibility that the Appellant, being
hurt both physically and emotionally, became agitated and sought to take
revenge on the deceased. Thus, a strong inference of motive can be drawn from
that aspect.
62. Though the Appellant claimed that he had left Bhalukpong before 6 P.M.
and went to Assam and thereafter to Mumbai, both the Appellant and PW-5
stated that he returned from Mumbai on 23.02.2017 after about four days of
the incident. If it is assumed that the Appellant had left Bhalukpong on
18.02.2017 in the evening for Assam and thereafter, went to Mumbai and
returned to Bhalukpong on 23.02.2017, then he must have completed the entire
journey within a period of four days, i.e., going to Mumbai and coming back
from Mumbai to Bhalukpong. In the considered opinion of this Court, it may not
be possible for a person to travel to Mumbai by road from Bhalukpong and
return within four days and there is no material to suggest that the Appellant
had travelled by air. Therefore, the claim of going to Mumbai and returning to
Bhalukpong appears to be not realistic to be believed. Additionally, the Appellant
did not produce any evidence of such travel. In the opinion of this Court, this
apparently a false claim by the Appellant in the instant case which undermines
the presumption of innocence, which is a material consideration against him. In
this connection, the case of Siddharth Vashisht alias Manu Sharma v. State
(NCT of Delhi), reported in (2010) 6 SCC 1, as relied on by the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor, can be referred to. Paragraphs 232 and 233, being
Page No.# 47/55
relevant, are extracted herein below:
“232. A criminal trial is not an enquiry into the conduct of an accused for
any purpose other than to determine whether he is guilty of the offence
charged. In this connection, that piece of conduct can be held to be
incriminatory which has no reasonable explanation except on the
hypothesis that he is guilty. Conduct which destroys the presumption of
innocence can alone be considered as material. In this regard, it is useful
to refer Anant Chaintaman Lagu vs. State of Bombay AIR 1960 SC 500:"68. Circumstantial evidence in this context means a combination
of facts creating a network through which there is no escape for
the accused, because the facts taken as a whole do not admit of
any inference but of his guilt.
……76. this conduct [of the accused] was so knit together as to
make a network of circumstances pointing only to his guilt......His
methods was his own undoing; because even the long arm of
coincidence could not explain the multitude of circumstances
against him, and they destroyed the presumption of innocence with
which law clothed him."
233. Thus, it has been proved beyond reasonable doubt that accused
Manu Sharma absconded after the incident which is a very relevant
conduct under Section 8 of Evidence Act. Disclosure statements of the
accused persons and their admissibility under Section 27 of the Evidence
Act.”
63. As discussed above, the circumstantial evidence in the instant case is
sufficient to point the finger of guilt towards the Appellant. Sufficient materials
have been placed before this Court suggesting that the Appellant was, in fact,
present near the place of occurrence at the time the incident took place. The
evidence of PW-5, PW-8, and PW-13 completes the chain of circumstances.
Additionally, the key evidence of PW-8, to the effect that he saw the Appellant in
his shop with bloodstained hands, was not denied by the Appellant. In fact, he
Page No.# 48/55
admitted to having visited the shop of PW-8. This version of PW-8 was neither
discredited nor rendered doubtful by any defence evidence. Therefore, the chain
of circumstances in the instant case is complete, establishing the clear guilt of
the Appellant.
64. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in a catena of cases, has laid down the
principles regarding circumstantial evidence on which a person can be
convicted. In the case of State of Madhya Pradesh v. Balveer Singh, reported
in 2025 SCC Online Supreme Court 390, the Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated
that certain tests must be satisfied when a case rests on circumstantial
evidence. Paragraphs 61, 62 and 63 of the aforesaid case, being relevant to the
instant case, is extracted herein below:
“61.
Although there can be no straight jacket formula for appreciation
of circumstantial evidence, yet to convict an accused on the basis of
circumstantial evidence, the Court must follow certain tests which are
broadly as follows: (i)
Circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to
be drawn must be cogently and firmly established;
(ii)
Those circumstances must be of a definite tendency
unerringly pointing towards guilt of the accused and must be
conclusive in nature;
(iii)
The circumstances, if taken cumulatively, should form a chain
so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion that
within all human probability the crime was committed by the
accused and none else; and
(iv)
The circumstantial evidence in order to sustain conviction
must be complete and incapable of explanation of any other
hypothesis than that of the guilt of the accused but should be
inconsistent with his innocence. In other words, the
Page No.# 49/55
circumstances should exclude every possible hypothesis except
the one to be proved.
62. In an Essay on the ‘Principles of Circumstantial Evidence’ by William
Wills by T. and J.W. Johnson and Co. 1872, it has been explained that
circumstantial evidence implies the existence of a certainty in the relation
between the facts and the inferences stemming therefrom. The relevant
extract reads as under: “In matters of direct testimony, if credence be given to the
relators, the act of hearing and the act of belief, though really
not so, seem to be contemporaneous. But the case is very
different when we have to determine upon circumstantial
evidence, the judgment in respect of which is essentially
inferential. There is no apparent necessary connection
between the facts and the inference; the facts may be true,
and the inference erroneous, and it is only by comparison with
the results of observation in similar or analogous
circumstances, that we acquire confidence in the accuracy of
our conclusions.
The term PRESUMPTIVE is frequently used as synonymous
with CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE; but it is not so used with
strict accuracy, The word" presumption," ex vi termini, imports
an inference from facts; and the adjunct "presumptive," as
applied to evidentiary facts, implies the certainty of some
relation between the facts and the inference. Circumstances
generally, but not necessarily, lead to particular inferences; for
the facts may be indisputable, and yet their relation to the
principal fact may be only apparent, and not real; and even
when the connection is real, the deduction may be erroneous.
Circumstantial and presumptive evidence differ, therefore, as
genus and species.
The force and effect of circumstantial evidence depend upon
its incompatibility with, and incapability of, explanation or
solution upon any other supposition than that of the truth of
the fact which it is adduced to prove; the mode of argument
Page No.# 50/55
resembling the method of demonstration by the reductio ad
absurdum.”
63. It is settled principle of law that an accused can be punished if he is
found guilty even in cases of circumstantial evidence provided, the
prosecution is able to prove beyond reasonable doubt the complete chain
of events and circumstances which definitely points towards the
involvement or guilt of the accused. The accused will not be entitled to
acquittal merely because there is no eye witness in the case. It is also
equally true that an accused can be convicted on the basis of
circumstantial evidence subject to satisfaction of the expected principles
in that regard.”
65. This Court has also considered the statements recorded under Section 313
of the Cr.P.C, which were relied upon by the Trial Court as well as by this Court
in completing the chain of circumstances. It is seen from the statements under
Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. that, although the Appellant denied his involvement in
the commission of the crime, he did not deny the specific question put to him
regarding his visit to the shop of PW-8, to which he replied as follows:
“It is true that I went to the shop of PW8 to purchase marigold
biscuit and cigarette but the time was around 6 pm not 7 to 7.30
pm. I have no comments on the statement of PW-8 about noticing
blood in my right hand at the time of delivery of cigarette in the
early incident of evening.”
66. From the above, it is seen that the Appellant had admitted that he visited
the shop of PW-8, although he stated the timing to be different. It is also seen
that, on being asked about the blood on his hands, he did not offer any
comment nor did he explain anything about the same. It is true that an accused
has the right to remain silent, however, taking into account the entire
Page No.# 51/55
statements made under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C., it is observed that he had
been consistently denying involvement and had sufficiently explained his
activities in response to other questions put to him. Yet, in the instant question,
he preferred not to provide any explanation. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the
case of Sanatan Naskar and Another v. State of West Bengal , reported in AIR
2010 SC 3570, held that the Court may rely upon those portions of the
statements made under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. which support the prosecution
case, provided such portions are considered in conjunction with the evidence on
record and not in isolation. In this connection, paragraph 10 of the above case,
being relevant, is extracted herein below:
“10. The answers by an accused under Section 313 of the Cr.PC are of
relevance for finding out the truth and examining the veracity of the case
of the prosecution. The scope of Section 313 of the Cr.PC is wide and is
not a mere formality. Let us examine the essential features of this section
and the principles of law as enunciated by judgments, which are the
guiding factors for proper application and consequences which shall flow
from the provisions of Section 313 of the Cr.PC. As already noticed, the
object of recording the statement of the accused under Section 313 of
the Cr.PC is to put all incriminating evidence to the accused so as to
provide him an opportunity to explain such incriminating circumstances
appearing against him in the evidence of the prosecution. At the same
time, also permit him to put forward his own version or reasons, if he so
chooses, in relation to his involvement or otherwise in the crime. The
Court has been empowered to examine the accused but only after the
prosecution evidence has been concluded. It is a mandatory obligation
upon the Court and, besides ensuring the compliance thereof, the Court
has to keep in mind that the accused gets a fair chance to explain his
conduct. The option lies with the accused to maintain silence coupled
with simplicitor denial or, in the alternative, to explain his version and
reasons, for his alleged involvement in the commission of crime. This is
the statement which the accused makes without fear or right of the other
party to cross-examine him. However, if the statements made are false,
Page No.# 52/55
the Court is entitled to draw adverse inferences and pass consequential
orders, as may be called for, in accordance with law. The primary purpose
is to establish a direct dialogue between the Court and the accused and
to put every important incriminating piece of evidence to the accused and
grant him an opportunity to answer and explain. Once such a statement
is recorded, the next question that has to be considered by the Court is to
what extent and consequences such statement can be used during the
enquiry and the trial. Over the period of time, the Courts have explained
this concept and now it has attained, more or less, certainty in the field of
criminal jurisprudence. The statement of the accused can be used to test
the veracity of the exculpatory of the admission, if any, made by the
accused. It can be taken into consideration in any enquiry or trial but still
it is not strictly evidence in the case. The provisions of Section 313 (4) of
Cr.PC explicitly provides that the answers given by the accused may be
taken into consideration in such enquiry or trial and put in evidence for or
against the accused in any other enquiry into or trial for, any other
offence for which such answers may tend to show he has committed. In
other words, the use is permissible as per the provisions of the Code but
has its own limitations. The Courts may rely on a portion of the statement
of the accused and find him guilty in consideration of the other evidence
against him led by the prosecution, however, such statements made
under this Section should not be considered in isolation but in conjunction
with evidence adduced by the prosecution. Another important caution
that Courts have declared in the pronouncements is that conviction of the
accused cannot be based merely on the statement made under Section
313 of the Cr.PC as it cannot be regarded as a substantive piece of
evidence. In the case of Vijendrajit v. State of Bombay, [AIR 1953 SC
247], the Court held as under:
"(3). .................As the appellant admitted that he was in charge of
the godown, further evidence was not led on the point. The
Magistrate was in this situation fully justified in referring to the
statement of the accused under S.342 as supporting the
prosecution case concerning the possession of the godown. The
contention that the Magistrate made use of the inculpatory part of
the accused's statement and excluded the exculpatory part does
not seem to be correct. The statement under S.342 did not consist
Page No.# 53/55
of two portions, part inculpatory and part exculpatory. It concerned
itself with two facts. The accused admitted that he was in charge
of the godown, he denied that the rectified spirit was found in that
godown. He alleged that the rectified spirit was found outside it.
This part of his statement was proved untrue by the prosecution
evidence and had no intimate connection with the statement
concerning the possession of the godown."
67. The Court has also considered the aspect of non-recovery of the weapon of
offence in the instant case. As per the prosecution story, the same was thrown
at the place where the weekly Sunday market is held, the day after the incident
in the instant case. The police stated that they could not recover the weapon of
offence. This Court is of the opinion that, in all cases, the recovery of the
weapon of offence is not always necessary and its absence may not be fatal
depending on the facts and circumstances of the case. However, the significance
of non-recovery always depends on the facts and circumstances of the case as
well as other circumstances and evidence brought on record by the prosecution.
In this connection, the case of Lakshmi and Others v. State of UP, reported in
(2002) 7 SCC 198, can be referred to. Paragraph 16, being relevant, is
extracted herein below:
“16.
Undoubtedly, the identification of the body, cause of death and
recovery of weapon with which injury may have been inflicted on the
deceased are some of the important factors to be established by the
prosecution in an ordinary given case to bring home the charge of
offence under Section 302 IPC. This, however, is not an inflexible rule. It
cannot be held as a general and broad proposition of law that where
these aspects are not established, it would be fatal to the case of the
prosecution and in all cases and eventualities, it ought to result in the
acquittal of those who may be charged with the offence of murder. It
would depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. A charge of
murder may stand established against an accused even in the absence of
identification of the body and cause of the death.”
Page No.# 54/55
68. Before concluding, this Court is of the opinion that the case laws referred
to by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellant should also be
discussed. The case of Ramanand @ Nandlal Bharti v. State of Uttar Pradesh ,
reported in (2023) 16 SCC 510, relates to extrajudicial confession. The learned
counsel argued that the extra-judicial confession in the instant case has no
relevance before this Court and cannot be taken into account. However, in the
case of Ramanand (supra), the facts were entirely different, as the Hon’ble
Supreme Court rejected the extra-judicial confession on the ground that the
accused in that case was not in a position to make an extra-judicial confession,
being not a free person at that point of time. Therefore, it was found highly
improbable that the accused could have made the extra-judicial confession. In
the case in hand, the Appellant was in a position to make an extra-judicial
confession, as there is nothing on record to suggest otherwise. It is also a fact
that, in the instant case, the Appellant was convicted not solely on the basis of
the extra-judicial confession, but also on the basis of other relevant
circumstantial evidence available against him.
69. The learned counsel for the Appellant further relied on the case of
Ramanand (supra) to contend that the statement of the Appellant under Section
313 of the Cr.P.C. cannot be relied upon in the absence of other circumstantial
evidence proving the guilt of the Appellant. In this connection, she submitted
that the prosecution had sought to rely on the circumstances allegedly arising
against the Appellant from his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. regarding
the blood seen on his right hand by PW-8. However, in the case in hand, it is
seen from the discussion above that the Appellant was not convicted solely on
the basis of the statement of Appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C., regarding the
deposition of PW-8. In the instant case, there are circumstances independent of
Page No.# 55/55
the aforesaid statement which strongly indicates the involvement of the
Appellant in the commission of the offence. The non-denial by the Appellant in
his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. serves only as an additional link in the
prosecution’s chain of evidence, further strengthening the prosecution’s case.
The circumstantial evidence available in the case is sufficient to uphold the
prosecution’s story, which could not be shaken or disturbed by the defence.
70. From the aforesaid discussions, the materials available on record, the
evidence of the witnesses, the Trial Court records, and the case laws relied upon
by the learned counsel appearing for the respective parties, we find that there is
no infirmity in the Judgment and Order passed by the learned District and
Sessions Judge, West Kameng District, Bomdila, dated 30.04.2021. Accordingly,
the instant criminal appeal is dismissed.
71. Send back the Trial Court Record.
72. For the valuable assistance rendered by Mr. G. Tarak, learned Amicus
Curiae appearing for Respondent No. 2, the Arunachal Pradesh State Legal
Services Authority shall pay him a fee as may be stipulated in this regard.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review