The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. In view of the aforesaid, the instant writ petition being WPA 23998 of 2009 stands dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Sudip Deb
WPA 23998 of 2009
Sagar Chandra Ghosh
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
For the petitioner
: Mr. Samiran Mandal
Mr. Nitish Samanta
Ms. Shreyashee Mitra
Ms. Aguiva Mandal
For the Union of India
: Mr. Indrajeet Dasgupta
For the respondent Nos.2 to 5
: Mr. Dinabandhu Dan
Mr. Dipankar Ghosh
Heard on
: 16.09.2026
Judgment on
: 16.09.2026
Sudip Deb, J. (Dictated in Court) :1.
On the last day when the matter was called on since nobody
appeared on behalf of the respondents, this Court directed the
petitioner to serve notice on all the respondents intimating the
respondents the next date of hearing. Today, the petitioner has filed
an affidavit of service which shows that the respondent Nos.1, 6
and 8 have been duly served. The affidavit of service is taken on
record.
2.
Despite service, nobody appears on behalf of the respondent Nos.6
to 8. The other respondents are duly represented.
3.
The principal grievance of the writ petitioner in the instant writ
petition is that even after making a representation for appointing
the petitioner’s son under the land loser category, his name has not
been considered by the respondent Nos.1 to 6. By filing this writ
petition, the petitioner made two prayers which are quoted
hereinbelow:
Firstly, the petitioner seeks appointment of his son under the
land loser category.
Secondly, the representation made by the petitioner dated
29th December, 2008 seeking appointment of his son be
considered by the respondents.
4.
It appears from the records that when the writ petition was moved,
direction was given for filing affidavits by a coordinate Bench of this
Court.
5.
Pursuant thereto, respondent Nos.2 to 5 have filed their affidavit-inopposition. The petitioner has also filed his reply to the said
affidavit-in-opposition. It further appears that pursuant to an order
passed by the coordinate Bench of this Court a report in the form of
an affidavit has been filed on behalf of the respondent Nos.7 and 8.
This Court also takes not of the fact that no exception to the said
report has been filed and the same would be evident from the note
of the department dated 20th November, 2025.
6.
I have heard the learned advocates appearing for the petitioner and
the respondent Nos.2 to 5.
7.
Learned advocate appearing for the petitioner while placing his case
has drawn the attention of this Court to page 18 which is a
representation of the petitioner made through his advocate dated
29th December, 2008 addressed to the respondent Nos.5, 6 and 8.
By the said representation the petitioner requested the said
respondents to consider the appointment of petitioner’s son.
8.
Learned advocate for the petitioner has further drawn the attention
of this Court to a hearing notice dated 9th July, 2003 by which the
intimation was sent to the petitioner for attending the hearing to be
held on 15th July, 2009 for considering such appointment. Learned
advocate for the petitioner relying on all these two documents
submits that the representation of the petitioner has not been
considered by the respondents as yet. He further submits that
though the petitioner has got compensation as land loser but in
terms of the requirement policy which is annexed to page 18 of the
affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent Nos.2 to 5, the
petitioner’s son has fulfilled the eligibility criteria and is entitled to
be appointed in Group – D under the land loser category.
9.
Learned advocate representing the respondent Nos.2 to 5 contends
that the petitioner has already got adequate compensation in 1987
and after remaining silent for about 22 years the petitioner has filed
the instant writ petition praying for appointment of his son on the
ground of land loser. This apart, he also submits that the
petitioner’s son did not fulfil the requirements for being appointed
in Group-D category. He also submits that the representation had
never been received by the MTPS (Mejia Thermal Power Station
DVC). He submits that from the averment made in the writ petition
itself it would be evident that the petitioner’s son never fulfilled the
eligibility criteria for appointment in Group-D category as the
petitioner himself has said in the writ petition that the petitioner’s
son had passed the Madhyamik Examination in 2008. He further
contends that when the application was made by the petitioner for
appointment of his son in 2003, his son did not fulfil the eligibility
criteria.
10.
The Learned advocate for the respondent No. 1 did not make any
submission.
11.
I have gone through the pleadings as well as the documents
annexed to the petition as also the report filed in the form of an
affidavit on behalf of the respondent Nos.7 and 8.
12.
It appears from the report filed by the respondent Nos.7 and 8 that
the said respondents have categorically stated when the writ
petitioner was called on for hearing on 15th July, 2003 by Special
Land Acquisition Officer, Bankura for verifying the original
documents, the petitioner did not comply with the same. It further
appears from the said report that the eligibility criteria for getting
appointment in Group-D (lowest category of unskilled job) for which
the petitioner has applied under land loser category discloses that
(i) Minimum Class-VIIII pass; (ii) His/her age should be between 18
to 45 years (age is relaxation for SC/ST/OBC as per GOI norms);
(iii) In case of nomination by the awardee, the nominee has to be
either wife/husband/son/unmarried daughter who fulfils other
criteria; (iv) Land loss percentage should be minimum 76 percent of
the total land and minimum land holding should be 0.33 acres; (v)
Land should have been acquired for MTPS construction on or before
20th March, 1986.
13.
It also appears from the said report that the respondent Nos.7 and
8 have categorically taken a stand that they are not the appropriate
authority who will issue the appointment letter to any person. The
report further discloses that the Damodar Valley Corporation, MTPS
(Mejia Thermal Power Station) is the appropriate authority who will
consider the prayer of the petitioner for appointment in accordance
with their declared policy.
14.
The learned advocate for the respondent Nos.2 to 5 has also drawn
the attention of this Court to the communications dated 8th April,
2025 and 11th April, 2025 which are part of the said report to
substantiate that though the representation dated 29th December,
2008 had been addressed to the respondent Nos.5, 6 and 8 but the
MTPS (Mejia Thermal Power Station DVC) did not receive the same.
15.
It also appears that though
the representation dated 29th
December, 2008 alleged to have been sent to the respondent Nos.5,
6 and 8 but there is no evidence in the writ petition that the MTPS
(Mejia Thermal Power Station DVC) have actually received the
same.
16.
There is no doubt that apart from receiving the compensation, the
petitioner’s son if fulfils the criteria then is entitled to be appointed
for the post as per the requirement policy for unskilled manual
posts at MTPS but such appointment has to be given strictly
adhering to the rules and regulations.
17.
It is curious to note that in the instance case though the
representation was made on 29th December, 2008 for considering
the petitioner’s son’s appointment but at the same time averment
has been made in the writ petition that the petitioner’s son had
passed Madhyamik Examination in 2008. It is equally important to
note that when the notice for considering the petitioner’s son for the
post was issued on 9th July, 2003 by the respondent No.8, the
petitioner’s son admittedly did not fulfil the eligibility criteria as he
had not passed class VIII examination then. There is no iota of
evidence disclosed in the writ petition which shows that the
petitioner’s son has fulfilled the eligibility criteria for making
himself eligible for the post for which he has applied.
18.
This is also a fact it does not appear anywhere from the records
that the MTPS (Mejia Thermal Power Station DVC) had received the
representation dated 29th December, 2008.
19.
The law is well settled in this regard. The Division Bench of this
Court in the matter of Damodar Valley Corporation & Ors. Vs.
Sephali Majhi & Ors. has categorically stated referring to a
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
Punjab State Electricity Board and Ors. Vs. Malkiat Singh,
reported in JT 2004 (8) SC 526 that every employment as an
additional benefit in the case of land losers whose lands are
acquired, to be made strictly in terms of the Scheme framed
therefor.
20.
From the documents annexed to the writ petition as well as from
the compliance report filed on behalf of the respondent Nos.7 and 8
it does not appear to the Court that the petitioner’s son has fulfilled
the eligibility criteria. This apart, there is also enough doubt as to
whether the representation sent by the petitioner has actually been
received by MTPS (Mejia Thermal Power Station DVC) or not.
Another aspect of the matter which needs to be considered here
that the petitioner has waited for 22 years in filing the present writ
application seeking appointment of his son after receiving the
compensation in 1987 and there is no explanation offered by the
petitioner in the instant writ petition for not approaching the Court
in the interregnum.
21.
In view of the aforesaid, the instant writ petition being WPA 23998
of 2009 stands dismissed.
22.
It is made clear that this Court has only decided the issue of
appointment of the petitioner’s son raised in the writ petition and
nothing beyond that.
23.
There will be no order as to costs.
24.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given
to the parties upon compliance of all formalities.
(Sudip Deb, J.)
ss
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review