The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. In view of above discussion, this Court finds that there is no evidence to convict the appellants under Section 308/34 of the IPC. Accordingly, judgment of conviction dated 30.11.2021and order of sentence, dated 09.12.2021 passed in Sessions Trial No. 185 of 2018 arising out of Margomunda P.S. Case No. 53 of 2017, by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-VI, Deoghar are quashed and set aside.
15. Accordingly, the criminal appeal is allowed. The appellants are on bail, hence they are discharged from the liability of their bail bond.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:19150
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cr. Appeal (S.J.) No. 544 of 2021
----[Against the judgment of conviction dated 30.11.2021and order of sentence,
dated 09.12.2021 passed in Sessions Trial No. 185 of 2018 arising out of
Margomunda P.S. Case No. 53 of 2017, by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge-VI, Deoghar]
1.Safual Ansari @ Safaul Ansari, aged about 23 years, son of Safique Mian.
2.Tajmul Ansari, aged about 20 years, son of Safique Mian.
Both are residents of Murli Pahari, P.O. Karanjo, P.S. Margomunda,
District- Deoghar, Jharkhand
--- --- Appellants
Versus
The State of Jharkhand
--- --- Respondent
…....
For the Appellants
: Mr. Arvind Kumar Choudhary, Advocate
Mr. Pratik, Advocate
Mr. Ritu Raj, Advocate
Mr. Pratik Singh, Advocate
: Mr. Vineet Kr. Vashishtha, Spl.P.P.
For the State
PRESENT
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR
JUDGMENT
By Court
1.
Heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned Spl.P.P.
representing the State.
2.
The present appeal has been preferred against the judgment of
conviction dated 30.11.2021and order of sentence, dated 09.12.2021
passed in Sessions Trial No. 185 of 2018 arising out of Margomunda
P.S. Case No. 53 of 2017, by the learned Additional Sessions JudgeVI, Deoghar, whereby the appellants have been convicted for the
offence punishable under Sections 308/34 of the IPC and have been
sentenced to undergo R.I. for 4 years with a fine of Rs. 25,000/- each
and in case of default of payment of fine, they are further directed to
undergo R.I. for 1 year.
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 544 of 2021
2026:JHHC:19150
3.
The criminal law has been put into motion on lodging of written
application by the informant Fatima Bibi before the Officer-in-charge
of Margomunda Police Station on 05.06.2017 on the basis of which
Margomunda P.S. Case No. 53 of 2017 was registered against seven
accused persons.
In the said fardbeyan, the informant has stated that on
04.06.2017 at about 8.35 P.M., it was the month of Ramzan when the
accused assaulted and beat the informant’s son with deadly weapons
such as tangi, lathi etc. on his head and other body parts causing
grievous injuries.
4.
On the basis of the above fardbeyan, the case was registered
being Margomunda P.S. Case No. 53 of 2017 dated 05.06.2017 under
Sections 341,323,324,326 and 307/34 IPC against the accused.
5.
After investigation of the case, police has submitted charge
sheet under Sections 341,323,325,307,34 of the IPC against seven
accused persons including the present two appellants. Cognizance in
the matter was accordingly taken vide order dated 02.05.2018.
6.
Thereafter, charge was framed on 14.09.2018 against the
accused under Section 307/34 of the IPC, which was later on amended
on 18.02.2021 wherein only the name of the injured was changed and
that was not objected by the defence. The charge was read over to the
accused to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
7.
To
substantiate
the
prosecution
story
altogether
eight
prosecution witnesses have been examined. Their brief statements are
as follows:
I.
P.W.1(Saddam Ansari) – He is the brother of the injured
and deposed that on the date of the incident, prior to the
occurrence, the accused Tazmul tried to steal mango from
the fruit cart and when confronted by the injured, it led to an
altercation and intimidation at the hands of the accused. On
the same day, after the evening Namaz, when the injured
came out of the mosque, the accused Tazmul Ansari was
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 544 of 2021
2026:JHHC:19150
having tangi, Safaul had iron rod, Safique, Karu, Hamid,
Roshan and Bahruddin Mian had lathi and all unleashed
violent attack on his brother Firdaus. Tazmul gave a tangi
blow on the right side of the head and Safaul and others beat
his brothers with lathi. His brother was badly drenched in
blood and bearing the commotion and cry of help, his
mother and others gathered and the accused managed to flee
away. All the accused attacked with his brother with the
intention of causing his death. Thereafter, they informed the
police and, on advice, they took the injured to Madhupur
Hospital and for better treatment to Deoghar Hospital where
he was admitted for two days and from there he was taken to
Dhanbad for better treatment but his admission was denied.
Thereafter they took his brother to Medanta Institute of
Neuro Science, Ranchi where for 17-18 days he was treated.
His brother is still undergoing treatment even after one and a
half year of the incident. The accused was identified by the
witness.
II.
P.W.2(Sajjad Ansari) – He is also brother of the injured and
he has reiterated as stated by P.W.1
III.
P.W.3(Irshad Ansari) – He is the uncle of injured and he
has also reiterated the statement made by P.W.1 and P.W.2
IV.
P.W.4(Shamsher Ansari) – He is an independent witness
and has also reiterated the incident narrated by P.W.1, 2 and
3. In cross examination he has deposed that he was not
present at the place of occurrence
V.
P.W.5(Fatima Bibi)- She is the informant of the case and
mother of the injured. She is the eye witness of the case. She
deposed she was sitting outside of her house. When her son
came out of the mosque, Tazmul Ansari gave a tangi blow
on the head of her son and Safaul Ansari assaulted him with
iron rod on his head. Safique Mian, Karu Mian, Hamid
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 544 of 2021
2026:JHHC:19150
Mian, Roshan Mian and Bahruddin Mian beat him with
lathi. Thereafter, they fled away. Further, she took her son to
Madhupur hospital and from there to Deoghar hospital and
thereafter, to Apollo Ranchi and even after a span of two
years, her son has not recovered and is on the cot. On the
next day on 05.06.2017 she gave a complaint to the police
which bears her thumb impression and recognized the
accused in the dock. In cross examination she has admitted
in paragraph 9 that on hulla she had approached the place of
incident.
VI.
P.W.6(Firdaus Ansari)- He is the victim- injured of the
violent attack. He has deposed that when he came out of the
mosque, all the accused surrounded him and Tazmul Ansari
gave a axe blow on his head due to which he started
bleeding (the witness showed his injury in the court). The
other accused Safaul Ansari with the intention of causing his
death hit him with the iron rod. Other accused Bahruddin,
Hamid, Karu and Roshan hit him with the wooden staff due
to which he suffered other injuries. For treatment he was
referred to Referral Hospital, Madhupur thereafter to
Deoghar and thereafter to Dhanbad and thereafter to Ranchi
for better treatment. The witness deposed that after the
evening Namaz around 04:00 PM, the accused Tazmul stole
the mango and when he confronted him, he was threatened
with dire consequences. The witness recognized the accused
in the dock. In cross examination he has admitted about the
previous enmity with them.
VII.
P.W.7(Ravindra Singh)- He is the I.O of the case and was
assigned investigation of this case. He recognized the
complaint given by the informant and forwarding on it by
then I/c which is exhibited as Ext. 1. FIR was exhibited as
Ext. 2. He has deposed in his chief examination that he took
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 544 of 2021
2026:JHHC:19150
the statement of the informant and inspected the place of
occurrence during the investigation. Thereafter, he took
statement of other witnesses and procured injury report of
Firdaus Ansari and also took statement of Firdaus Ansari and
after investigation he submitted charge sheet against the
accused persons.
VIII.
P.W.8 (Dr. Manoj Kr. Hembrom)- He is the Medical
Witness of the case. He deposed that he was posted as
Medical Officer at Sub-divisional Hospital, Madhupur. On
that day, he examined Firdaus Ansari and found lacerated
wound at right side of scalp measuring 4" x 1½" x 4" deep in
nature. The injuries are of within six hours. The injuries are
caused by hard object. The colour of injuries are blood in
nature. The injury report was prepared by him is his pen and
signature the same has been Exhibited as Ext. 3. The nature
of the injury was opined to be grievous in nature. The
supplementary report was also prepared by him and the
same was Exhibited as Ext. 3/1. The injury report of Firdaus
Ansari was prepared by Dr. RP Singh and the witness also
identified it and the same was Exhibited as Ext. 3/2. The CT
Scan report of Firdaus Ansari was also identified by him and
the same was Exhibited as Ext. 3/3.
8.
The prosecution has also adduced documentary evidence as
under:
I.
Exhibit -1 – Endorsement on written application.
II. Exhibit-2- Formal F.I.R.
III. Exhibit-3 –Injury report
IV. Ext.3/1-Supplementary injury report
V.
Ext.3/2- Signature of Dr. R.P. Singh on injury report of Firdaus
Ansari.
VI. Ext.3/3-Signature of Dr. R.P. Singh on CT Scan report
9.
After conducting full-fledged trial, the learned Trial Court has
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 544 of 2021
2026:JHHC:19150
acquitted 5 accused out of the 7 charge-sheeted accused and convicted
and sentenced the two appellants as aforesaid.
10.
On the basis of evidences brought on record, learned counsel
for the appellants has made the following submissions:
a. The cross examination of the witnesses clearly
suggests that except the victim, nobody is eye witness
to the occurrence.
b. Even as per the victim, the manner of commission of
crime and the place of occurrence does not get
corroboration by the medical evidence or by the
Investigating Officer.
c. For the same set of evidences, five accused persons
have been acquitted while these two appellants have
been convicted without assigning any reason.
d. Even the time and nature of injury as disclosed by the
doctor P.W.8 through medical evidence totally
mismatched with the prosecution story as disclosed by
P.W.1 to P.W.6.
e. It has also been admitted by the prosecution evidence
that parties are on litigating terms and the simple
injury caused to the victim may be accidental, but the
same has been misused to rope in the appellants and
other accused persons. On the above basis, it has
been submitted that the entire prosecution story is
doubtful and major portion of the evidence has been
disbelieved by the Court below also and in such
doubtful scenario, the judgment of conviction is bad
in law.
11.
Learned counsel for the State has supported the judgment of
conviction passed by the learned Trial Court. It has been submitted
that the testimonies of prosecution witnesses clearly suggest that due
to theft of mango committed by the accused persons, this incident has
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 544 of 2021
2026:JHHC:19150
taken place in front of masjid and all the prosecution witnesses have
supported the allegation.
12.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of
the record, it appears that :
I.
P.W.1, P.W.2, P.W.3 who have claimed that they were
with the victim at the time of namaz but they could not
disclose the name of the imam. Further on scrutiny of
evidence, it is clear they are not the eye witness of the
incident. Even the injury disclosed by them does not
match with the medical evidence.
II.
The sequence of events i.e. time of F.I.R and time of the
incidence narrated by P.W.5, who is the mother of the
victim, does not match testimony of other witness. Even
as per her statement she does not appear to be an eye
witness to the incident.
III.
Even the victim has clearly disclosed that he has been hit
upon head several times by the two appellants by tangi
and iron rod. So far as other accused are concerned, that
has been disbelieved by the Court below itself.
IV.
The present appellants who have been convicted on the
statement of the victim that they have assaulted himwith
iron rod and tangi several times, does not match with the
medical evidence I.e., P.W.8
V.
Even the time of injury does not match.
VI.
It has been admitted by the victim that there was previous
enmity.
VII.
Except the physical examination by the first doctor,
nothing has been brought on record to further elaborate
the injury.
13.
Thus, this Court finds that there is no enough material to
convict the appellants under Section 308 IPC by taking aid of Section
34 IPC. The incident itself is doubtful as neither the time nor place of
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 544 of 2021
2026:JHHC:19150
occurrence gets proved rather the time of injury has been opined by
the doctor to be of 6 hours. There are several discrepancies as per
reporting time of the police and intervention by the police.
14.
In view of above discussion, this Court finds that there is no
evidence to convict the appellants under Section 308/34 of the IPC.
Accordingly, judgment of conviction dated 30.11.2021and order of
sentence, dated 09.12.2021 passed in Sessions Trial No. 185 of 2018
arising out of Margomunda P.S. Case No. 53 of 2017, by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge-VI, Deoghar are quashed and set aside.
15.
Accordingly, the criminal appeal is allowed. The appellants are
on bail, hence they are discharged from the liability of their bail bond.
16.
Let the trial court record be sent back to the court below
forthwith.
(Rajesh Kumar, J.)
A. Mohanty
Jharkhand High Court
Dated 30.06.2026
Uploaded
___/____/2026
Cr. Appeal (SJ) No 544 of 2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review