Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Criminal Appeal (D.B.) No.1400 of 2018
-----(Arising out of judgment of conviction dated 24.08.2018
and order of sentence dated 29.08.2018 passed by learned
Additional Sessions Judge-III, West Singhbhum at
Chaibasa in S.T. Case No.30/2014)
-----Goma Gope @ Goma, son of Late Ramayan Gope, resident of
Village Chota Lagiya, P.O. & P.S. Mufassil, Chaibasa, District
Singhbhum (West).
… … … Appellant
Versus
The State of Jharkhand.
… … … Respondent
-----PRESENT :
SRI ANANDA SEN, J.
:
SRI PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, J.
-----For the Appellant
:
Mrs. Alpana Verma, Advocate
(Amicus Curiae)
For the State
:
Mr. Tarun Kumar, A.P.P.
-----JUDGMENT
By Court, :
24th September, 2026
This Criminal Appeal is preferred on behalf of the
appellant being aggrieved by the judgment of conviction dated
24.08.2018 and order of sentence dated 29.08.2018 passed by
learned
Additional
Sessions
Judge-III,
West
Singhbhum
at
Chaibasa in S.T. Case No.30/2014, whereby and wherein the
appellant has been convicted for offence under Sections 302 IPC.
He was sentenced to undergo life imprisonment, with a fine of
Rs.5,000/-.
2.
We have heard Mrs. Alpana Verma, learned Amicus
Curiae representing the appellant and Mr. Tarun Kumar, learned
A.P.P. representing the State, at length, and have gone through
the materials available on record.
3.
Learned counsel representing the appellant submitted
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
that the appellant had falsely been implicated in this case, only on
the basis of conjectures and surmises. She further submitted that
the appellant is facing incarceration since long without any rhymes
or reason, thus he deserves to be released from custody after
setting aside his judgment of conviction and order of sentence.
4.
Learned A.P.P. representing the State, opposes the
aforesaid prayer and submitted that the appellant had rightly been
convicted in this case, as he had committed murder of his son by
a knife and the Police also recovered blood-stained soil and a knife
from the place of occurrence.
5.
The case of the prosecution on the basis of fardbeyan
of the informant - Jema Gope (wife of the appellant - Goma Gope
@ Goma), is that on the fateful day, the informant was at home
and was busy in her domestic work and her husband (appellant
herein), was also in the house and had drunk hariya, when their
son - Pratap Gope (deceased), came to home and told his father
that why is he drinking so much hariya, which led to an argument
between them over the said issue and in the heat of moment, the
appellant with a vegetable cutting knife, stabbed the deceased in
his stomach causing his intestines to spill out and leading to
profuse bleeding, due to which he succumbed to death on spot.
6.
On the basis of the fardbeyan dated 22.11.2013 of the
informant, as per whom, the date of incident was 21.11.2013, an
F.I.R. being Mufassil P.S. Case No.120/2013 dated 22.11.2013 was
registered under Section 302 IPC; and after investigation, chargesheet was filed against the appellant.
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
6.1.
Thereafter, cognizance was taken by the Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Chaibasa, and the case was committed to the Court of
Sessions and ultimately transferred to the Court of Additional
Sessions Judge-III, West Singhbhum, at Chaibasa. The case was
numbered as S.T. Case No.30/2014. The Court framed charge
against the appellant under Section 302 IPC and the trial
proceeded.
7.
To prove the prosecution case, total eight prosecution
witnesses have been examined in this case, whose depositions are
as follows :7.1.
P.W.-1 namely Raghunath Sundi, is the one who had
informed the Police about the incident; however, he is not an eyewitness. He deposed that as per the information given by the
villagers, he rushed to the house of the appellant and saw the
dead body of Pratap Gope (deceased), which bore wound on the
stomach. He had signed on the inquest report and the seizure list,
which were marked as Ext.-1 and Ext.-2 respectively.
In his cross-examination, he admitted that he had not
witnessed the incident except the blood-stained soil and a knife,
which were recovered by the Police.
7.2.
P.W.-2 namely Ramay Gope, is the brother of the
deceased. He had assisted the Police by translating the local
language, spoken by his mother while giving fardbeyan. He signed
on the inquest report, seizure list and the fardbeyan, which were
marked as Exts.-1/1, 2/1 and 3 respectively.
In his cross-examination, he admitted that he had not
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
witnessed the incident. He also deposed that the appellant used to
drink haria and used to remain under its influence.
7.3.
P.W.-3 namely Jema Gope (informant), who is wife of
the appellant and mother of the deceased, had deposed that at
the time of incident she had gone to river and when she returned
home, her husband was in an intoxicated condition and her son
was telling him to stay quiet, upon which the appellant stabbed
the deceased with a knife. She stated that she had not seen as to
where is the wound and her son (deceased) told her that the
accused stabbed him.
In her cross examination, she deposed that she did not
see the appellant killing the deceased with the knife.
7.4.
P.W.-4 namely Dr. Brajkishore Pandey, is the Medical
Officer, who had conducted the post-mortem on the body of the
deceased; and gave several findings, which are as follows:"The Antemortem findings are as follows:- Rigor
mortis was present in all the limbs.
2. External and Internal examination:External - Fist closed, clothings over chest and
Abdomen teared. Lower ribs on left chest was
punctured with outpouching of soft tissues and
intestine. Blood (free flowing fresh blood in abdominal
cavity) punctured wound where clean cut with margins
measuring 5.5x2 c.m. dimention.
Internal - Intestine punctured at two sites with clotted
blood at that sites. spleen, liver N.A.D. Lungs N.A.D.
Stomach empty. Heart empty.
Cause of death :- Hemorrhage due to above
injuries caused by penetrating knife.
Time since Death :- Less than 24 hours.
The above injuries are sufficient to cause death in
ordinary course of life"
The post-mortem report was prepared and signed by
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
him and the same was marked as Ext.-3.
In his cross-examination, he also deposed that other
sharp cutting instruments may cause the injury rather than the
knife mentioned in this case.
7.5.
P.W.-5 namely Manki Sundi and P.W.-6 namely Ladura
Gope, are the hearsay witnesses, who in their cross-examination
had clearly admitted that they had heard about the murder from
people.
7.6.
P.W.-7 namely Bir Singh Sundi, is also a hearsay
witness, as he had deposed that he had heard about the murder
from the people.
7.7.
P.W.-8 namely Mohan Baitha, is the Investigating
Officer, who was posted in Mufassil Police Station, Chaibasa. He
deposed that he received information about the murder and after
lodging sanha, went to the place of occurrence, and conducted
investigation. He took the custody of dead body and also prepared
seizure list. He also submitted the inquest report. He had taken
the re-statement of the informant and statements of other
witnesses.
8.
Several documentary evidences and material evidences
were also produced, which are as follows:-
Ext.-1
Ext.-2
Ext.-3
Ext.-3/1
Ext.-1/1
Ext.-2/1
Documentary Evidences :Signature of Raghunath Sundi with Carbon
copy of Inquest Report.
Signature of Raghunath Sundi in seizure list
Signature of Ramay Gope in Fardbeyan
Signature of Raghunath Sundi in Fardbeyan
Signature of Ramay Gope in carbon copy of
Inquest Report
Signature of Ramay Gope in Seizure List
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
Ext.-3
Ext.-3/2
Ext.-4
Ext.-1/2
Ext.-2/2
Post mortem report of deceased Pratap Gope
Registration in Fardbeyan
F.I.R.
Inquest Report
Seizure List
Ext-A
Ext-B
Material Exhibits :Blood-stained soil
Vegetable cutting knife
9.
The appellant had been examined under Section 313
Cr.P.C., and he had not pleaded guilty and deposed that his son
was going to kill him, but as he bent down, his knife accidentally
plunged into his own stomach.
10.
The Trial Court after hearing both the parties, on the
basis of prosecution evidences as well as exhibited documents /
materials available on record, found the appellant guilty and
accordingly convicted him under Section 302 IPC, and sentenced
him for life imprisonment.
11.
The appellant in this Criminal Appeal is assailing the
aforesaid judgment of conviction and order of sentence, under
Section 302 IPC. The deceased is none, but a twenty years' son of
the appellant. The appellant allegedly stabbed the deceased under
the influence of hariya, as he questioned him for consumption of
hariya.
12.
From the entire evidences of the prosecution witnesses,
we find that none of the prosecution witnesses, except the
informant, was present at the place of occurrence.
13.
To prove the charge under Section 302 IPC, the
prosecution has to prove that the death is homicidal amounting to
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
murder or not. Section 300 IPC defines ‘murder’, which reads as
follows:“300. Murder.- Except in the cases hereinafter
excepted, culpable homicide is murder, if the act
by which the death is caused is done with the
intention of causing death, or
Secondly.-If it is done with the intention of
causing such bodily injury as the offender knows to
be likely to cause the death of the person to whom
the harm is caused, or
Thirdly.-If it is done with the intention of causing
bodily injury to any person and the bodily injury
intended to be inflicted is sufficient in the ordinary
course of nature to cause death, or
Fourthly.-If the person committing the act knows
that it is so imminently dangerous that it must, in
all probability, cause death or such bodily injury as
is likely to cause death, and commits such act
without any excuse for incurring the risk of causing
death or such injury as aforesaid.
Exception 1-3 ………………
Exception 4.- Culpable homicide is not murder if it
is committed without premeditation in a sudden
fight in the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel
and without the offender’s having taken undue
advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner.
Explanation.-It is immaterial in such cases which
party offers the provocation or commits the first
assault.
Exception-5 ………….”
14.
From the aforesaid Exception-4 of Section 300 IPC, it is
clear that there must be an element of premeditation to commit
the act. Further, if the act is done on a sudden provocation or fight
between the accused and the victim, the culpable homicide is not
murder. Further, the most important postulate of this exception is
that the assault must happened in the heat of passion and in a
spur of moment, to exclude the act from the definition of murder.
15.
From perusal of the medical evidence of the Doctor
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
(P.W.-4) and other evidences, it is evident that there was only one
blow of knife, given to the deceased. The assault is not
premeditated and it happened on the spur of the moment.
15.1.
In the backdrop of the aforesaid, it will not be hasten to
add that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove any
premeditation on part of the appellant of taking life of the
deceased, as the feud occurred in a spur of moment; and as the
appellant was intoxicated, under the influence of hariya, and when
the deceased suddenly came to the house and chided him about
consumption of hariya, he in a heat of passion, stabbed the knife
on the stomach of the deceased, just forgetting that his own son
is standing before him and how dangerous the knife blow could
be.
16.
Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances of
the case, so also the medical report and the proximity of the death
with the assault, we are of the opinion that though the case is of
culpable homicide, but the same cannot be said to be a murder,
thus the case of the appellant falls under Exception-4 of Section
300 IPC. Thus, we hereby convert the conviction from Section 302
IPC to Section 304 Part-II IPC.
16.1.
Since the appellant has already remained in custody
during trial and he is still in custody, and since the appellant was
of 80 years at the time of examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C.,
as also at the time of filing of this Criminal Appeal, and now, he is
aged about 88 years, thus, considering the old age of this
appellant and the fact that he was in custody during trial and
2026:JHHC:28803-DB
faced incarceration of this criminal proceeding for about thirteen
years, we convert the sentence to the period which the appellant
has already undergone.
16.2.
Thus, the impugned judgment of conviction dated
24.08.2018 and order of sentence dated 29.08.2018 passed by
learned
Additional
Sessions
Judge-III,
West
Singhbhum
at
Chaibasa in S.T. Case No.30/2014, are modified accordingly.
17.
Accordingly,
the
Criminal
Appeal
stands
partly
if
stands
allowed.
17.1.
Pending
interlocutory
application,
any,
disposed of.
18.
The appellant is directed to be released forthwith from
custody, if nor required in any other case.
19.
Trial Court Record be transmitted back to the Court
concerned.
20.
Considering the sincere efforts put in by Amicus Curiae
representing the appellant, we direct the High Court Legal
Services Committee (HCLSC), to pay remuneration of Rs.7,500/to
Mrs. Alpana Verma, Advocate (Amicus Curiae).
(ANANDA SEN, J.)
(PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, J.)
HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND, RANCHI
Dated:- 24th September, 2026
Prashant
NAFR
Uploaded on 29.09.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review