Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:29588-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
-------Cr. Appeal (DB) No. 1389 of 2018
-----(Against the Judgment of conviction and order of sentence both dated
20.11.2018 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge-XII, Hazaribagh,
in Sessions Trial No. 335 of 2017.)
-----1. Kailash Ram age 40 years, S/o Chaudhari Ravidas.
2. Lalita Devi aged 26 years, W/o Kailash Ram.
Both Resident of Shyampatti, P.O. & P.S. Charhi, District-Hazaribag.
… … Appellants
Versus
The State of Jharkhand
… Respondent
---------PRESENT
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PRASAD
…..
For the Appellants
: Mr. Abdul Wahab, Advocate
For the Resp.-State
: Mrs. Vandana Bharti, APP
…..
st
C.A.V./Reserved on 21 August, 2026
Pronounced on: 30/09/2026
Per Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.:
1. The instant appeal, under Section 374 (2) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, has been preferred against the Judgment of conviction and order
of sentence both dated 20.11.2018 passed by learned Additional Sessions
Judge-XII, Hazaribagh, in Sessions Trial No. 335 of 2017 corresponding to
G.R. No.2102 of 2017 arising out of Charhi P.S. Case No.58 of 2017,
whereby and whereunder, the appellants have been convicted under
Section 302/34 of IPC and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for
life along with fine of Rs.30,000/- (Rupees Thirty Thousand) each and in
default of payment of fine they shall further undergo a period of one year
Simple Imprisonment.
Factual Matrix
2. The prosecution story in brief is required to be referred herein, which is as
under:
2.1 The prosecution case is based on the written report of the informant
Mahaveer Ram (PW-9) alleging therein that on 21.07.2017 at about
15:00 hrs., informant received a telephonic information that his
daughter is ill. On this information he went to the house (matrimonial
house) of his daughter at Charhi and he saw his daughter was lying
dead.
2.2 Informant further stated that the marriage of his daughter Sita
Devi(deceased) was performed in the year 1998 with Kailash Ram
(appellant herein), but his daughter was issueless and his son-in-law
had solemnized second marriage with Lalita Devi (appellant herein)
and both his wives quarrel with each other. Informant claimed that his
son-in-law and his new wife had murdered informant’s daughter,
pressing her neck.
2.3 On the basis of written application of the informant, Charhi P.S. Case
No. 58/2017 was registered u/s 302/34 of the IPC against accused
persons/appellants.
2.4 After investigation charge-sheet No. 107/17 dated 31.10.2017 and
charge-sheet No.18/18 dated 28.02.2018, were submitted against the
accused Kailash Ram and Lalita Devi, respectively under Section
302/34 of IPC and cognizance of the offence was taken and the case
was committed to the court of sessions.
Page | 2
3. Charge was framed against the accused persons/appellants Kailash Ram
and Lalita Devi u/s 302/34 of the IPC and the same was read over and
explained to both of the accused persons in Hindi to which they pleaded
not guilty and claimed to be tried.
4. Thereafter, after the framing of charges, trial proceeded and on conclusion
of the trial, the appellants were convicted and sentenced as aforesaid,
hence, this appeal.
5. The aforesaid judgment of conviction and sentence is under challenge
herein.
Submission of the learned counsel for the Appellants:
6. Learned counsel for the appellants has taken the following grounds for
interfering with the finding recorded by the learned trial court in the
impugned judgment:
(i)
It is submitted that the learned trial court has committed error in law
as well as on facts in its finding while passing the judgment
impugned.
(ii)
It is also submitted that there is no evidence for commission of
offence except confession before the police, as such, the judgment of
conviction is fit to be set aside.
(iii)
It has also been submitted that there is no eye witness to the
occurrence and the prosecution witnesses P.W.-4 to P.W.-7 have
turned hostile and rest of the prosecution witnesses are hearsay
witnesses.
Page | 3
(iv)
It has been contended that the investigating officer has stated in his
evidence that no incriminating material like danda, rope, weapon,
etc. were found from the place of occurrence as well as no materials
like hair or blood on the nail etc. was found from the palm of the
deceased.
7. The learned counsel for the appellants, based upon the aforesaid grounds,
has submitted that the learned trial court has not taken into consideration
the aforesaid facts, as such, the impugned judgment requires interference,
hence not sustainable in the eyes of law.
Submission of learned counsel for the Respondent-State:
8. While defending the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the State
has submitted that the prosecution has fully succeeded in establishing the
charge levelled against the accused persons beyond shadow of reasonable
doubt and from all corners, the ingredients of the charge levelled against
the accused persons stand completely proved.
9. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further submitted that murder of
the deceased is proved from the medical evidence of the Doctor as Doctor
in postmortem report had opined that death of the deceased was result of
Asphyxia due to throttling.
10. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondentState, based upon the aforesaid premise, has submitted that the impugned
judgment does not suffer from any error, hence the instant appeal is fit to
be dismissed.
Page | 4
Analysis
11. We have heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the documents
available on record as also the finding recorded by the learned trial court in
the impugned judgment.
12. We have also gone through the testimonies of the witnesses as available in
the LCR as also the exhibits appended therewith.
13. This Court before considering the argument advanced on behalf of the
parties is now proceeding to consider the testimonies of witnesses,
produced on behalf of both sides, which have been recorded by learned
trial Court.
14. The learned trial court had altogether examined eleven prosecution
witnesses out of whom PW-9 Mahaveer Ram, is the informant of the case
and father of the deceased; PW-1 Kapil Ram, is the uncle of the deceased;
PW-2 Anand Ram, is the cousin brother of the deceased; PW-3 Dileshwar
Ram, is the another uncle of the deceased; PW-4 Gopal Ravidas, PW-5
Shanti Devi, PW-6 Lalo Devi and PW-7 Binita Devi, all these four
witnesses were declared hostile on the request of prosecution; PW-8 is Dr.
Mahendra Prasad Chaudhary, PW-10 Naresh Ram, is uncle of the deceased
and PW-11 Vijay Kerketta, is the Investigating Officer.
15. Defence had examined three witnesses in support of their case which are
D.W.-1 Prakash Singh, D.W.-2 Mutun Ravidas and D.W.-3 is Tilki Devi.
16. PW-1 Kapil Ram, is the uncle of the deceased, who had stated in
examination-in-chief that on 21.07.2017, he was at his house. At 3:00 P.M,
information was received that his niece Sita Devi has been murdered by
Page | 5
throttling and hearing this information, he went at the matrimonial house at
Charhi, of his niece Sita Devi. He saw his niece was lying dead on cot in a
room and throttling mark was there on the neck. When he reached there,
husband of his niece Kailash Ram and his second wife Lalita Devi were
absconding. His niece Sita Devi was issueless, so, his husband Kailash
Ram had solemnized another marriage and used to beat his niece and lastly
has murdered her.
17. During cross-examination, this witness has deposed that the deceased was
his niece and he used to meet her after her marriage. Deceased had never
complaint before the occurrence.
18. PW-2 Anand Ram, is the cousin brother of the deceased, who had stated
in his examination-in-chief that on 21.07.2017 at 3:00 PM, his uncle
Mahaveer Ram, received an information from Shayam Patti, Charhi, which
is the matrimonial house of his daughter that his daughter was ill. On this
information, he also accompanied with other persons and went to the
matrimonial house of Sita Devi and there they saw that the dead body of
Sita Devi was lying and there was mark of throttling on her neck. Sita Devi
was issueless, so her husband Kailash Ram used to quarrel with her and
solemnized second marriage with Lalita Devi. He further stated that his
sister was murdered by throttling by her husband and his second wife
Lalita Devi. When they had reached at the matrimonial house of Sita Devi,
her husband and his second wife were absconding.
19. PW-3 is Dileshwar Ram, is another uncle of the deceased, who had stated
in examination-in-chief that on 21.07.2017, at about 3:00 PM, his cousin
brother Mahabir Ram received information on his mobile that his daughter
Page | 6
was ill and to come and see her. Then they went to the matrimonial house
of Sita Devi where they saw Sita Devi in dead condition and there was
throttling mark on her neck. Later on, they came to know that Kailash Ram
and his second wife had murdered her.
20. During cross-examination, he stated that he had visited matrimonial house
of Sita Devi several time with brother of Sita Devi and his father. The dead
body of Sita Devi was inside the house lying on a chauki.
21. PW-8 is Dr. Mahendra Prasad Chaudhary, who had conducted
postmortem examination. He had stated in his evidence that on 22.07.2017
he was posted as a Medical Office at Sadar Hospital, Hazaribag, and on the
same day he had conducted postmortem examination on the dead body of
Sita Devi. Doctor had given following findingsOn external examination: 1. Hair black and long
2. Both eyes open, blood stain discharge from right nostril of the nose, mouth
partly open and teeth visible and froth present on mouth.
3. Rigor mortis present in both upper and lower limbs
Injuries: 1. Bruise 1/4’’ X 1/4’’ black in colour on right part of neck behind right ear.
2. Black colouration of skin on front of neck.
3. All are Antimortem in nature and caused by hard and blunt substance.
On external examination: 1. Extra vasation of blood present in the subcutaneous tissue on front of neck
and adjacent muscles of neck.
2. Heamatoma present on external part of hyoid bone and hyoid bone not
fractured.
3. Internal wall of hyoid bone congested.
4. Laryinx and trachea are congested.
Page | 7
5. Both lungs intact and congested.
6. Right chamber of heart contains dark blood and left chamber of heart empty.
7. Stomach contains undigested food particles rice and vegetables ounce five
and mucosal wall normal.
8. Liver, Spleen and Kidneys are intact and congested.
9.Urinary bladder empty
10. Uterus non gravid and normal and Vagina normal.
22. Doctor opinioned that time elapsed since death was within 36 hrs and cause
of death was Asphyxia due to throttling. Postmortem report was marked as
Ext-1.
23. In his cross-examination, Doctor deposed that no internal injuries were
found. In case of hanging ligature, mark will be present on the neck but no
such ligature mark was found in this case on the neck of deceased. By
pressing nose, neck and mouth such death may by caused.
24. PW-9 Mahaveer Ram, is the informant of the case and father of the
deceased. He had stated in examination-in-chief that occurrence took place
on 21.07.2017 at Shyampatti within Charhi police station and he received a
telephonic message at about 3:00 PM that his daughter was ill. On this
information he along with Anand, Kapil, Naresh and 2-4 women went to
his daughter’s house. His daughter was married with Kailash Ram. When
they reached there, they saw the dead body of his daughter lying on a
chauki. His son-in-law Kailash Ram and his second wife Lalita Devi were
absconding from the house. There was black mark on the neck of his
daughter. On inquiry he came to know that Kailash Ram and his second
wife had killed his daughter by throttling.
Page | 8
25. Informant further stated that quarrel used to occur between his daughter
and accused person. His son-in-law used to torture his daughter and
through her demand dowry. Informant has proved his signature on the
written application and in the inquest report which were marked as Ext-2
and Ext.-3 respectively.
26. In his cross-examination, informant stated that his daughter Sita Devi was
married with Kailash Ram 18-19 years ago. He used to visit to the
matrimonial house of his daughter and he stayed there for 2-3 days. He had
seen the dead body of his daughter Sita Devi at Shyampatti.
27. PW-10 Naresh Ram, is another uncle of the deceased. He had stated in
examination-in-chief that incident took place on 21.07.2017 at about 10:00
AM situated at Shayampatti within Charhi. Kailash Ram and Lalita Devi
murdered his niece Sita Devi by throttling. Persons of matrimonial house
of Sita Devi informed by phone at about 3:00 P.M that Sita Devi is ill. On
information he along with Mahabir Ram, Kapil Ram, Dineshwar Ram,
Lakhan Ram and Anand Ram reached at the place of occurrence and saw
his niece Sita Devi was killed and laying on a chauki. There was pressure
mark on her neck and froth was coming from her mouth. Persons nearby
told that Kailash Ram and his second wife Lalita Devi killed Sita Devi by
throttling. Police reached at the place of occurrence and prepared inquest
report which bears his signature, marked as Ext-3/1. When they reached at
the matrimonial house of Sita Devi, Kailash Ram and his second wife
Lalita Devi was not present at the house, they absconded.
28. PW-11 Vijay Kerketta, is the Investigating Officer of the case. He had
stated in his examination-in-chief that on 22.07.2017, he was posted as
Page | 9
officer-in-charge at Charhi police station. On receiving the written
application, he registered the case and he himself took the charge of
investigation of the case. He went to the place of occurrence and prepared
inquest report and sent the dead body for postmortem to Sadar Hospital,
Hazaribag. Thereafter he inspected the Place of occurrence. The place of
occurrence of this case is the house of accused Kailash Ram situated at
Shayampatti which is one kilometer south from Charhi police station where
dead body of deceased was found. Thereafter, he recorded the re-statement
of informant who supported the written application. He recorded the
statement of witness Anand Ram, Kapil Ram, Dineshwar Ram, Gopal
Ravidas, Shanti Devi, Kalo Devi, all supported the FIR and stated the
deceased Sita Devi was murdered by Kailash Ram and Lalita Devi.
29. Investigating officer further stated that during the inspection of place of
occurrence both the accused persons were found absconding. Later on,
dated 08.08.2016, Kailash Ram was arrested and confessed his guilt.
Thereafter, he received the postmortem report wherein the cause of death
by throttling was mentioned. He submitted charge-sheet No. 107/17 dated
31.10.2017 u/s 302/34 of the IPC against accused Kailash Ram and
investigation kept going on against accused Lalita Devi. Formal FIR,
endorsement on written application and Charge-sheet No. 107/17 were
written and signed by him, which were marked as Ext.-4, Ext.- 2/1 and
Ext- 5 respectively.
30. Investigating officer further stated that on 23.02.2018, Lalita Devi was
arrested and she also confessed her guilt. He submitted charge-sheet No.
18/18 dated 28.02.2018 against accused Lalita Devi u/s 302/34 of the IPC,
Page | 10
which was written and signed by him and marked as Ext.-6. Carbon copy
of Inquest report was written by A.S.I Anil Kumar Singh which he knows
and marked as Ext- 3/2. Confessional statement of accused Kailash Ram
and Lalita Devi were recorded and written by him, which were marked as
Ext.- 7 and Ext-8 respectively.
31. In his cross-examination, Investigating Officer stated that first time he
reached at the place of occurrence on 22.07.2017 at about 6:30 A.M. No
map was prepared of the place of occurrence. Statements of Gopal Ravidas,
Shanti Devi, Kalo Devi, were recorded who comes within the boundary of
the place of occurrence. Maike people of Sita Devi first went to police
station, then they went to the place of occurrence with him. There is no eye
witness of this occurrence. No sanha was registered with respect to dispute
between the deceased Sita Devi and accused persons. No objectionable
materials like danda, rope, weapon etc. were recovered from the place of
occurrence. Froth was coming out from the mouth of deceased and no
external injury was found on the body of deceased.
32. The learned trial court had recorded the testimony of three defence
witnesses which are being referred herein as under.
33. D.W.-1 is Prakash Singh, who had stated in examination-in-chief that he
knows Kailash Ram. He does not know anything about the family of
Kailash Ram. In his cross-examination, he deposed that he had not received
any notice for adducing his evidence.
34. D.W.-2 Mutun Ravidas, had stated in examination-in-chief that he knows
Kailash Ram and he knows about the family of Kailash Ram. He had not
heard any dispute between Kailash Ram and his family. He had not seen
Page | 11
quarrel between Kailash Ram and his wife. His house is 200 meter away
from the house of Kailash Ram. He used to meet daily with Kailash Ram
and his wife. In his cross-examination he deposed that he had not received
any notice or summon for adducing his evidence. On instruction of Kailash
Ram and Lalita Devi, he came to adduce his evidence. In the life time of
Sita Devi, Kailash Ram had solemnized second marriage with Lalita Devi.
35. D.W.-3 Tilki Devi, had stated in examination-in-chief that she knows
Kailash Ram and his family. Kailash Ram is not her relative, she resides in
the same mohalla. She denied that Sita Devi wife of Kailash Ram was
murdered. She never saw quarrel between Kailash Ram and his wife. In her
cross-examination, she deposed that she had not received any notice for
adducing her evidence. She came to the court for adducing her evidence on
instruction of Kailash Ram and Lalita Devi. Sita Devi was first wife of
Kailash Ram and in her life time Kailash Ram solemnized second marriage
with Lalita Devi. She admitted that accused Kailash Ram, is the son of her
sister-in-law (gotni).
36. The learned Trial Court on the basis of the testimony of witnesses, who had
seen mark of injury over the neck of the deceased and medical evidence of
the Doctor PW-8, who had opined death was caused as a result of asphyxia
due to throttling, found the substance in the prosecution version and passed
the impugned judgment of conviction, convicting the appellants under
Section 302/34 of IPC and sentenced as aforesaid.
37. This Court, on the basis of aforesaid factual aspect vis-à-vis argument
advanced on behalf of parties, is now proceeding to examine the legality
Page | 12
and propriety of impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence
by formulating following questions to be answered by this Court:
i.
Whether the prosecution has proved the homicidal death of
the deceased?
ii.
Whether on the basis of the testimony of the witnesses can it
be said to be a case based on circumstantial evidence or if it
based upon the circumstantial evidence the chain is being
completed or not?
iii.
Whether the trial Court, while convicting the appellants, has
committed any illegality or not?
Re: Issue no.(i) :
38. The issue no.(i) is whether the prosecution has proved the homicidal death
of the deceased?
39. To answer this issue, this Court has firstly gone through the oral testimony
of PW-1, PW-3 and PW-10, who are the uncles of the deceased and PW9(informant), who is the father of the deceased, and all these witnesses
have stated in their evidences that they had seen the mark of injury on the
neck of the deceased.
40. Further, Doctor PW-8, who had conducted post mortem examination had
found antemortem injuries-(i) bruise 1/4’’ X 1/4’’ black in colour on right
part of neck behind right ear and (ii) Black colouration of skin on front of
neck.
41. Again, on the internal examination, Doctor PW-8 had inter alia found-
Page | 13
i.
Extra vasation of blood present in the subcutaneous tissue on front of
neck and adjacent muscles of neck.
ii.
Heamatoma present on external part of hyoid bone and hyoid bone not
fractured.
iii.
Right chamber of heart contains dark blood and left chamber of heart
empty.
42. Doctor opined that cause of death was asphyxia due to throttling. In his
cross-examination, doctor stated that in case of hanging ligature, mark will
be present on the neck but no such ligature mark was found in this case on
the neck of deceased and by pressing nose, neck and mouth such death may
by caused.
43. Upon careful appraisal of the evidence adduced, particularly the testimony
of P.Ws. 1, 3, 9 (informant), and 10, together with the medical evidence
tendered by P.W.8 (the Doctor), It is evident that the prosecution has
successfully established that the death of the deceased was occasioned by
asphyxia resulting from throttling.
44. Accordingly, upon the cumulative assessment of the ocular and medical
evidence, this Court arrives at the considered conclusion that the death of
the deceased was homicidal in nature. The cause of death being asphyxia
due to throttling, as duly corroborated by the medical testimony,
unmistakably excludes any possibility of accidental or natural demise.
45. Accordingly, issue No.(i) has been answered herein.
Re: issue no.(ii) :
46. This issue is whether on the basis of the testimony of the witnesses can it
be said to be a case based on circumstantial evidence or if it based upon the
circumstantial evidence the chain is being completed or not?
Page | 14
47. The learned Trial Court, in the impugned judgment, noted that when the
prosecution witnesses reached the house of the accused, both accused
persons had already fled from the place of occurrence. The Trial Court
regarded such conduct as highly suspicious and, by invoking the principle
embodied in Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, inferred that the
accused persons were responsible for the homicidal death of the deceased
and, apprehending arrest, absconded from the scene.
48. Before adverting to the merits of such inference, this Court considers it
apposite to recall the settled proposition of law enunciated by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in relation to Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act. The
said provision assumes particular significance in circumstances where the
homicidal death of a woman has occurred within the confines of her
matrimonial home and, immediately thereafter, the accused/appellants are
found absconding from the said premises.
49. It cannot be disputed that if the death has occurred within the four corners
of the matrimonial house of the deceased, then the principle of reverse onus
will be there. Further, it needs to refer herein that when any fact is
especially within the knowledge of a person, the burden of proving that fact
is upon him. The provisions of Section 106 of the Evidence Act itself are
unambiguous and categoric in laying down that when any fact is especially
within the knowledge of a person, the onus of proving that fact is upon
him. If he does so he must be held to have discharged his burden. If he fails
to offer an explanation on the basis of facts within his special knowledge,
he fails to discharge the burden cast upon him by Section 106 of the
Evidence Act.
Page | 15
50. In case of Shambu Nath Mehra v. State of Ajmer, AIR 1956 SC 404:
(1956)1SCC 337, Hon’ble Apex Court laid down that it is general rule that
in a criminal case the burden of proof is on the prosecution and Section 106
is certainly not intended to relieve it of that duty. On the contrary, it is
designed to meet certain exceptional cases in which it would be impossible,
or at any rate disproportionately difficult, for the prosecution to establish
facts which are “especially” within the knowledge of the accused and
which he could prove without difficulty or inconvenience. The word
“especially” stresses that it means facts that are pre-eminently or
exceptionally within his knowledge. Relevant paragraph of this case is
quoted herein below“11. This lays down the general rule that in a criminal case the
burden of proof is on the prosecution and Section 106 is certainly not
intended to relieve it of that duty. On the contrary, it is designed to
meet certain exceptional cases in which it would be impossible, or at
any rate disproportionately difficult, for the prosecution to establish
facts which are “especially” within the knowledge of the accused
and which he could prove without difficulty or inconvenience. The
word “especially” stresses that. It means facts that are preeminently or exceptionally within his knowledge. If the section were
to be interpreted otherwise, it would lead to the very startling
conclusion that in a murder case the burden lies on the accused to
prove that he did not commit the murder because who could know
better than he whether he did or did not. It is evident that that cannot
be the intention and the Privy Council has twice refused to construe
this section, as reproduced in certain other Acts outside India, to
mean that the burden lies on an accused person to show that he did
not commit the crime for which he is tried. These cases
are Attygalle v. R. [Attygalle v. R., 1936 SCC OnLine PC 20 : AIR
1936 PC 169] and Seneviratne v. R. [Seneviratne v. R., 1936 SCC
OnLine PC 57 : (1936) 44 LW 661]”
Page | 16
51. Again, in case of State of W.B. v. Mir Mohammad Omar, (2000) 8 SCC
382, Hon’ble Apex Court laid down that section 106 of the Evidence Act,
is not intended to relieve the prosecution of its burden to prove the guilt of
the accused beyond reasonable doubt. But the section would apply to cases
where the prosecution has succeeded in proving facts from which a
reasonable inference can be drawn regarding the existence of certain other
facts, unless the accused by virtue of his special knowledge regarding such
facts, failed to offer any explanation which might drive the court to draw a
different inference. Paragraph-36,37 and 38 of this judgment is quoted
herein below“36. In this context we may profitably utilise the legal principle
embodied in Section 106 of the Evidence Act which reads as follows:
“When any fact is especially within the knowledge of any person, the
burden of proving that fact is upon him.”
37. The section is not intended to relieve the prosecution of its
burden to prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt.
But the section would apply to cases where the prosecution has
succeeded in proving facts from which a reasonable inference can
be drawn regarding the existence of certain other facts, unless the
accused by virtue of his special knowledge regarding such facts,
failed to offer any explanation which might drive the court to draw a
different inference.
38. Vivian Bose, J., had observed that Section 106 of the Evidence
Act is designed to meet certain exceptional cases in which it would
be impossible for the prosecution to establish certain facts which are
particularly within the knowledge of the accused. In Shambhu Nath
Mehra v. State of Ajmer [AIR 1956 SC 404 : 1956 SCR 199 : 1956
Cri LJ 794] the learned Judge has stated the legal principle thus:
“This lays down the general rule that in a criminal case the
burden of proof is on the prosecution and Section 106 is
certainly not intended to relieve it of that duty. On the contrary,
it is designed to meet certain exceptional cases in which it
would be impossible, or at any rate disproportionately difficult
Page | 17
for the prosecution to establish facts which are ‘especially’
within the knowledge of the accused and which he could prove
without difficulty or inconvenience.”
52. Further in case of Sucha Singh v. State of Punjab ,(2001) 4 SCC 375,
Hon’ble Apex Court reiterated that It is trite law that Section 106 of the
Indian Evidence Act does not absolve the prosecution of its primary burden
to establish the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. The
provision is intended to operate in a limited sphere, namely, in cases where
the prosecution has succeeded in proving certain foundational facts from
which a reasonable inference may legitimately be drawn regarding the
existence of other attendant facts. In such circumstances, if the accused, by
virtue of special knowledge of those attendant facts, fails to tender any
plausible explanation, the Court may be driven to draw an adverse
inference. Pargraph-19 of this judgment is quoted herein below“19. We pointed out that Section 106 of the Evidence Act is not
intended to relieve the prosecution of its burden to prove the guilt of
the accused beyond reasonable doubt, but the section would apply to
cases where the prosecution has succeeded in proving facts for which
a reasonable inference can be drawn regarding the existence of
certain other facts, unless the accused by virtue of special knowledge
regarding such facts failed to offer any explanation which might drive
the court to draw a different inference.”
53. In the case of Tulshiram Sahadu Suryawanshi v. State of Maharashtra,
(2012) 10 SCC 373, Hon’ble Apex Court held that it is settled law that
presumption of fact is a rule in law of evidence that a fact otherwise
doubtful may be inferred from certain other proved facts. When inferring
the existence of a fact from other set of proved facts, the court exercises a
process of reasoning and reaches a logical conclusion as the most probable
position. The above position is strengthened in view of Section 114 of the
Page | 18
Evidence Act, 1872. It empowers the court to presume the existence of any
fact which it thinks likely to have happened. In that process, the courts
shall have regard to the common course of natural events, human conduct,
etc. in addition to the facts of the case. In these circumstances, the
principles embodied in Section 106 of the Evidence Act can also be
utilised. The paragraph-23 of this judgment is quoted herein below“23 It is settled law that presumption of fact is a rule in law of
evidence that a fact otherwise doubtful may be inferred from certain
other proved facts. When inferring the existence of a fact from other
set of proved facts, the court exercises a process of reasoning and
reaches a logical conclusion as the most probable position. The above
position is strengthened in view of Section 114 of the Evidence Act,
1872. It empowers the court to presume the existence of any fact
which it thinks likely to have happened. In that process, the courts
shall have regard to the common course of natural events, human
conduct, etc. in addition to the facts of the case. In these
circumstances, the principles embodied in Section 106 of the Evidence
Act can also be utilised. We make it clear that this section is not
intended to relieve the prosecution of its burden to prove the guilt of
the accused beyond reasonable doubt, but it would apply to cases
where the prosecution has succeeded in proving facts from which a
reasonable inference can be drawn regarding the existence of certain
other facts, unless the accused by virtue of his special knowledge
regarding such facts, failed to offer any explanation which might drive
the court to draw a different inference….”
54. Thus, it is evident that in cases of this nature, unless the accused is able to
properly explain the material circumstances appearing against him, he may
be held guilty of the offence with which he is charged. At the same time, it
is equally well-settled that the applicability of this doctrine must be tested
on the facts of each individual case, and every matter must therefore be
examined on its own merits before invocation of the principle.
Page | 19
55. Re-adverting to the present case, in the forthcoming discussion, this Court
will examine whether the prosecution had laid evidences to prove the two
vital facts –
i.
Firstly, whether the body of the deceased was found in her
matrimonial home i.e. in the house of her husband Kailash
Ram (appellant herein), and
ii.
Secondly, whether the accused persons absconded from their
house immediately after the homicidal death of the deceased.
56. In order to examine the fact whether the body of the deceased was found in
her matrimonial home i.e. in the house of her husband Kailash Ram
(appellant herein), this Court finds that PW-1 and PW-10, who are the
uncles of the deceased, had specifically deposed that they had seen the
body of the deceased lying on the cot inside the room. PW-11 Investigating
Officer had also deposed that the body of the deceased was found in the
house Kailash Ram (appellant herein).
57. Again, from the inquest report Ext.-3, this Court finds that body was found
in the house.
58. Hence, from the testimony of P.W.-1, P.W.-10, the Investigating Officer
P.W.-11, and the inquest report (Ext.-3), it stands proved that the dead
body of the Sita Devi (deceased) was recovered from her matrimonial
home, i.e., from the house of her husband Kailash Ram (the appellant
herein).
59. In order to ascertain whether the accused persons/appellants absconded
from their matrimonial home immediately after the homicidal death of the
deceased, this Court has scrutinised the depositions of P.Ws. 1, 2, 9
Page | 20
(informant), and 10. Each of these witnesses has consistently deposed that
upon their arrival at the matrimonial house of the deceased, both
accused/appellants were conspicuously absent. This circumstance stands
corroborated by the testimony of the Investigating Officer, P.W. 11, who
categorically stated that at the time of his inspection of the place of
occurrence, neither of the appellants was present in the house. The
uniformity of these testimonies lends credence to the prosecution’s
assertion that the accused persons absconded from the scene immediately
after the incident, thereby constituting a circumstance of considerable
evidentiary value.
60. In view of the consistent depositions of P.Ws. 1, 2, 9 (informant), and 10,
duly corroborated by the testimony of the Investigating Officer, P.W. 11,
this Court finds that the prosecution has proved the circumstance that,
immediately after the homicidal death of the deceased when the
prosecution witnesses reached at the house of appellant namely Kailash
Ram (husband of the deceased), both the appellants were not present in
their matrimonial home and had absconded therefrom.
61. From the foregoing discussion, three material facts stand conclusively
established: firstly, that the death of the deceased was homicidal in nature,
caused by asphyxia due to throttling; secondly, that the dead body of Sita
Devi (deceased) was discovered within her matrimonial home, namely the
house of her husband, Kailash Ram (appellant herein); and thirdly, that
immediately after the homicidal death, the accused/appellants were not
found present in their house and had absconded.
Page | 21
62. Thus, in the present case, once it stands proved that the death of Sita Devi
(deceased) was homicidal in nature, that her dead body was recovered from
her matrimonial home, i.e., the house of her husband/appellant Kailash
Ram, and that immediately after the homicidal death the accused persons
were not found in their house and had absconded, the burden of proof, by
virtue of Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, squarely shifts upon the
accused/appellants to explain the circumstances under which the homicidal
death of the deceased occurred within the four corners of her matrimonial
home.
63. Before proceeding, it is pertinent to note herein that informant (PW-9),
who is the father of the deceased, had specifically stated in his written
report that his daughter Sita Devi (deceased), was married to Kailash Ram
(appellant herein), in the year 1998 and his daughter had no issue and
hence, his son-in law Kailash Ram (appellant herein) had married again,
some days ago, prior to the death of his daughter Sita Devi(deceased).
64. Further, Informant (PW-9), PW-1 and PW-2, have deposed that Sita
Devi(deceased) had no issue, due to this reason her husband Kailash Ram
(appellant), used to quarrel with her and torture her and had married again,
some days ago prior to the occurrence, with Lalita Devi (appellant no.2).
65. In the present case, the evidence of P.W. 9 (informant), P.W. 1, and P.W. 2
establishes that appellant Kailash Ram was in the habit of quarrelling with
and subjecting his first wife, Sita Devi (deceased), to torture. It further
stands proved that shortly prior to the occurrence, appellant Kailash Ram
contracted a second marriage with appellant no. 2, Lalita Devi. In the
backdrop of these facts and circumstances, the obligation under Section
Page | 22
106 of the Indian Evidence Act lies heavily upon appellant Kailash Ram to
disclose any fact within his special knowledge as to how his first wife, Sita
Devi, came to suffer homicidal death inside his house.
66. In the instant case, it is manifest from the record that appellant Kailash
Ram, being the husband of the deceased Sita Devi, has failed to furnish any
explanation during the course of trial as to the circumstances under which
his wife suffered homicidal death inside his matrimonial home. Equally, no
explanation has been offered as to why, immediately after the death, he
absconded from the house. The failure of the appellant to discharge the
burden cast upon him under Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act,
despite the facts being within his exclusive knowledge, constitutes a grave
infirmity in his defence and warrants the drawing of an adverse inference
against him.
67. In the present case, a presumption of fact arises against appellant Kailash
Ram, the husband of the deceased Sita Devi, under Section 114 of the
Indian Evidence Act. The proved circumstances are fourfold: (i) that Sita
Devi(deceased) suffered homicidal death by strangulation within her
matrimonial home, i.e., the house of appellant Kailash Ram; (ii) that no
plausible explanation has been offered by him as to the manner in which
such homicidal death occurred; (iii) that immediately thereafter he
absconded from the house; and (iv) that there exists a prior history of
cruelty inflicted by him upon the deceased, as corroborated by the
prosecution witnesses.
68. When these circumstances are read conjointly, the evidentiary burden
under Section 106 of the Evidence Act squarely fell upon appellant Kailash
Page | 23
Ram to explain facts within his exclusive knowledge. His failure to
discharge this burden, coupled with his incriminating conduct of
abscondence, justifies the drawing of an adverse inference under Section
114(g).
69. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has consistently held as discussed in
preceding paragraphs that in cases of matrimonial or custodial deaths,
where the deceased is found dead within the four corners of the
matrimonial home, the husband or inmates of the house are under a special
duty to explain the circumstances of death.
70. In Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra (2006) 10 SCC 681,
the Hon’ble Court while taking reference of
Ganeshlal v. State of
Maharashtra (1992) 3 SCC 106 wherein the appellant was prosecuted for
the murder of his wife which took place inside his house has observed that
when the death had occurred in his custody, the appellant is under an
obligation to give a plausible explanation for the cause of her death in his
statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. The mere denial of the prosecution
case coupled with absence of any explanation were held to be inconsistent
with the innocence of the accused, but consistent with the hypothesis that
the appellant is a prime accused in the commission of murder of his wife.
71. Similarly, in State of Rajasthan v. Kashi Ram (2006) 12 SCC 254, it was
held that abscondence and silence of the accused in such circumstances are
strong incriminating factors.
72. Applying these settled principles, this Court is constrained to hold that the
homicidal death of Sita Devi was caused by appellant Kailash Ram. The
presumption under Section 114(g), read with the burden under Section 106,
Page | 24
operates decisively against him, and his failure to explain the death of his
wife within his own house leaves no escape from the conclusion of guilt.
73. Now, in the present case, since there is no eye witness to the homicidal
death of the deceased, therefore, this Court is now adverting to
analyze
and appreciate the circumstances that whether on the basis of the
circumstantial evidence the culpability of the accused particularly the
appellant Kailash Ram, can be proved or not, therefore this Court think it
apposite to refer to certain authorities pertaining to delineation of cases that
hinge on circumstantial evidence.
74. There is no quarrel with the settled position of law that in the case of
circumstantial evidence, the chain should be complete then only there will
be conviction of the concerned accused person, as has been laid down by
the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Hanumant son of Govind
Nargundlar vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1952 SC 343 wherein it
has been held that "It is well to remember that in cases where the evidence
is of a circumstantial nature, the circumstances from which the conclusion
of guilt is to be drawn should in the first instance be fully established, and
all the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of
the guilt of the accused. Again, the circumstances should be of a conclusive
nature and tendency and they should be such as to exclude every
hypothesis but the one proposed to be proved. In other words, there must
be a chain of evidence so far complete as not to leave any reasonable
ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and it
must be such as to show that within all human probability the act must
have been done by the accused."
Page | 25
75. The same view has been taken by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Bakhshish
Singh vs. State of Punjab, (1971) 3 SCC 182 wherein the Hon'ble Apex
Court has observed that the principle in a case resting on circumstantial
evidence is well settled that the circumstances put forward must be
satisfactorily proved and those circumstances should be consistent only
with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused. These circumstances should
be of a conclusive nature and tendency and they should be such as to
exclude every hypothesis but the one proposed to be proved. In other
words, there must be a chain of evidence so far complete as not to leave
any reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of
the accused and it must be such as to show that within all human
probability the act must have been done by the accused.
76. The Hon'ble Apex Court while laying down such proposition in the said
case has considered the factual aspect revolving around therein and while
considering the fact has only found the incriminating evidence against the
appellant was his pointing the place where the dead body of the deceased
had been thrown which the Hon'ble Apex Court has not considered to be
circumstantial evidence though undoubtedly it raises a strong suspicion
against the appellant. The Hon'ble Apex Court while coming to such
conclusion has observed that even if he was not a party to the murder, the
appellant could have come to know the place where the dead body of the
deceased had been thrown. Hence anyone who saw those parts could have
inferred that the dead body must have been thrown into the river near about
that place. In that pretext, the law has been laid down at paragraph-9
thereof, which reads as under:
Page | 26
"9. The law relating to circumstantial evidence has been stated by this
Court in numerous decisions. It is needless to refer to them as the law
on the point is well-settled. In a case resting on circumstantial
evidence, the circumstances put forward must be satisfactorily proved
and those circumstances should be consistent only with the hypothesis
of the guilt of the accused. Again, those circumstances should be of a
conclusive nature and tendency and they should be such as to exclude
every hypothesis but the one proposed to be proved. In other words,
there must be a chain of evidence so far complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of
the accused and it must be such as to show that within all human
probability the act must have been done by the accused."
77. It is, thus, evident from the close analysis of the aforesaid judgments, the
following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can
be said to be fully established:
(i) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be
drawn should be fully established.
(ii) the facts so established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not
be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is
guilty,
(iii) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency,
(iv) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to
be proved, and
(v) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of
the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must
have been done by the accused.
Page | 27
78. The Hon'ble Apex Court has reiterated the said principle again in the case
of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda vs. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC
116 holding all the above five principles to be the golden principles which
constitute the panch-sheel of the proof of a case based on circumstantial
evidence. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the said case as under paragraph-155,
156, 157, 158 and 159 has been pleased to hold that if these conditions are
fulfilled only then a Court can use a false explanation or a false defence as
an additional link to lend an assurance to the court and not otherwise.
Paragraphs-155, 156, 157, 158 and 159 of the said judgment read as under:
"155. It may be interesting to note that as regards the mode of proof in
a criminal case depending on circumstantial evidence, in the absence
of a corpus delicti, the statement of law as to proof of the same
was laid down by Gresson, J. (and concurred by 3 more Judges) in
King v. Horry [1952 NZLR 111] thus: "Before he can be convicted,
the fact of death should be proved by such circumstances as render
the commission of the crime morally certain and leave no ground for
reasonable doubt: the circumstantial evidence should be so cogent
and 2025:JHHC:13669-DB compelling as to convince a jury that
upon no rational hypothesis other than murder can the facts be
accounted for."
156. Lord Goddard slightly modified the expression "morally certain"
by "such circumstances as render the commission of the crime
certain".
157. This indicates the cardinal principle of criminal jurisprudence
that a case can be said to be proved only when there is certain and
explicit evidence and no person can be convicted on pure moral
conviction. Horry case [1952 NZLR 111] was approved by this Court
in Anant Chintaman Lagu v. State of Bombay [AIR 1960 SC 500]
Lagu case [AIR 1960 SC 500] as also the principles enunciated by
this Court in Hanumant case [(1952) 2 SCC 71] have been uniformly
and consistently followed in all later decisions of this Court without
any single exception. To quote a few cases -- Tufail case [(1969) 3
Page | 28
SCC 198] , Ramgopal case [(1972) 4 SCC 625] , Chandrakant
Nyalchand Seth v. State of Bombay [ Criminal Appeal No 120 of
1957,], Dharambir Singh v. State of Punjab [ Criminal Appeal No 98
of 1958,]. There are a number of other cases where although
Hanumant case [(1952) 2 SCC] has not been expressly noticed but the
same principles have been expounded and reiterated, as in Naseem
Ahmed v. Delhi Administration [(1974) 3 SCC 668, 670] , Mohan Lal
Pangasa v. State of U.P. [(1974) 4 SCC 607,] , Shankarlal Gyarasilal
Dixit v. State of Maharashtra [(1981) 2 SCC 35, 39] and M.G.
Agarwal v. State of Maharashtra [AIR 1963 SC 200 : (1963) 2 SCR
405,] -- a five-Judge Bench decision.
158. It may be necessary here to notice a very forceful argument
submitted by the Additional Solicitor General relying on a decision of
this Court in Deonandan Mishra v. State of Bihar [AIR 1955 SC 801]
to supplement his argument that if the defence case is false it would
constitute an additional link so as to fortify the prosecution case. With
due respect to the learned Additional Solicitor-General we are unable
to agree with the interpretation given by him of the aforesaid case, the
relevant portion of which may be extracted thus: "But in a case like
this where the various links as stated above have been satisfactorily
made out and the circumstances point to the appellant as the probable
assailant, with reasonable definiteness and in proximity to the
deceased as regards time and situation. such absence of explanation
or false explanation would itself be an additional link which completes
the chain."
159. It will be seen that this Court while taking into account the
absence of explanation or a false explanation did hold that it will
amount to be an additional link to complete the chain but these
observations must be read in the light of what this Court said earlier
viz. before a false explanation can be used as additional link, the
following essential conditions must be satisfied: (1) various links in
the chain of evidence led by the prosecution have been satisfactorily
proved, (2) the said circumstance points to the guilt of the accused
with reasonable definiteness, and (3) the circumstance is in proximity
to the time and situation."
79. The foremost requirement in the case of circumstantial evidence is that the
chain is to be completed. In Padala Veera Reddy v. State of A.P. [1989
Page | 29
Supp (2) SCC 706 the Hon'ble Apex Court held that when a case rests
upon circumstantial evidence, the following tests must be satisfied:
"10. ... (1) the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is
sought to be drawn, must be cogently and firmly established; (2) those
circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing
towards guilt of the accused; (3) the circumstances, taken
cumulatively, should form a chain so complete that there is no escape
from the conclusion that within all human probability the crime was
committed by the accused and none else; and (4) the circumstantial
evidence in order to sustain conviction must be complete and
incapable of explanation of any other hypothesis than that of the guilt
of the accused and such evidence should not only be consistent with
the guilt of the accused but should be inconsistent with his innocence."
80. In Ram Singh v. Sonia (2007) 3 SCC 1, while referring to the settled proof
pertaining to circumstantial evidence, the Hon’ble Apex Court reiterated
the principles about the caution to be kept in mind by court. It has been
stated therein as follows:
"39. ... in a case depending largely upon circumstantial evidence,
there is always a danger that conjecture or suspicion may take the
place of legal proof. The court must satisfy itself that various
circumstances in the chain of events have been established clearly and
such completed chain of events must be such as to rule out a
reasonable likelihood of the innocence of the accused. It has also been
indicated that when the important link goes, the chain of
circumstances gets snapped and the other circumstances cannot in
any manner, establish the guilt of the accused beyond all reasonable
doubts."
81. Thus, it is evident that for proving the charge on the basis of circumstantial
evidence, it would be necessary that evidence so available must induce a
reasonable man to come to a definite conclusion of proving of guilt;
meaning thereby there must be a chain of evidence so far it is complete as
not to leave any reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the
Page | 30
innocence of the accused and it must be such as to show that within all
human probability the act must have been done by the accused.
82. Reverting to the present case, since the present case is based on the
circumstantial evidence, hence, at this juncture, this court is proceeding
examine, whether motive is present, in the homicidal death of the deceased.
83. In this regard this Court has gone through the written report dated
22.07.2017, wherein the informant PW-9 (father of the deceased) had
stated that his daughter Sita Devi (deceased), was married to Kailash Ram
(appellant herein), in the year 1998 and his daughter had no issue and his
son-in law Kailash Ram (appellant herein) had married again, some days
ago, prior to the death of his daughter Sita Devi(deceased).
84. In his evidence also, Informant (PW-9), had deposed that quarrel often took
place between his daughter (deceased) and the accused persons and his
daughter(deceased) was being tortured by her husband Kailash Ram
(appellant herein). PW-1, who is the uncle of the deceased had deposed in
his evidence that his niece Sita Devi(deceased) was issueless, so his
husband Kailash Ram (appellant herein) had solemnized another marriage
and used to beat his niece and lastly murdered her. PW-2, who is the cousin
brother of the deceased had also stated in his evidence that his sister Sita
Devi(deceased) had no issue and for this reason her husband Kailash Ram
(appellant herein), used to quarrel with her.
85. On the basis of the written report and the testimony of P.W. 9 (informant),
P.W. 1, and P.W. 2, this Court finds that the deceased, Sita Devi, had no
issue from her marriage with appellant Kailash Ram. The evidence further
establishes that, owing to this circumstance, appellant Kailash Ram was in
Page | 31
the habit of quarrelling with and subjecting her to cruelty. It also stands
proved that shortly prior to the occurrence, he contracted a second marriage
with appellant no. 2, Lalita Devi.
86. These facts, taken together, furnish a clear motive for the commission of
the crime. The absence of issue, coupled with habitual cruelty and the
contracting of a second marriage, created a hostile matrimonial
environment and provided appellant Kailash Ram with a compelling reason
to eliminate his first wife. The existence of motive, though not
indispensable in every case of circumstantial evidence, assumes
considerable significance here, as it fortifies the prosecution’s chain of
circumstances.
87. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has consistently held that proof of motive,
while not a sine qua non for conviction, strengthens the prosecution case
where the evidence is otherwise circumstantial. In Babu v. State of Kerala
(2010) 9 SCC 189, it was observed that motive assumes importance in
cases resting on circumstantial evidence, as it provides the background
against which the incriminating circumstances must be evaluated.
Applying this principle, the motive established in the present case operates
as an additional link in the chain of circumstances pointing towards the
culpability of appellant Kailash Ram.
88. This Court, after adverting to the testimony of the prosecution witnesses
and upon reference to the settled principles of law on circumstantial
evidence as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the preceding
paragraphs, finds that the prosecution has succeeded in proving the
following material facts:
Page | 32
i.
Homicidal death of the deceased by asphyxia due to throttling,
substantiated from the evidence of PW-1, PW-3, PW-10, PW9(informant) and medical evidence of the Doctor (PW-8).
ii.
From the testimony of PW-1, PW-10, Investigating Officer
(PW-11) and the inquest report Ext.-3, it is proved that dead
body of the deceased was found at her matrimonial home i.e.
in the house of her husband Kailash Ram (appellant herein).
iii.
After the homicidal death of the deceased, appellants were not
present in their house and they had absconded.
iv.
There is presumption of facts under Section 114(g) of the
Indian Evidence Act and this Court, in the preceding
paragraph,
has
come
to
the
conclusion
that
Sita
Devi(deceased), was strangulated before her death by the
appellant Kailash Ram, who is the husband of the Sita Devi
(deceased), as a result she died in her matrimonial home and
after homicidal death of the deceased, the accused/appellants
absconded from their house and the accused person failed to
disprove this presumption of facts.
89. Hence, due to the establishment of aforesaid facts in the present case, chain
of circumstances is complete, from which the conclusion of guilt may be
drawn against the accused person.
90. Accordingly, issue no.(ii) has been answered.
Re: issue no.(iii)
91. This issue is whether the trial Court, while convicting the accused
persons/appellants, has committed any illegality or not?
Page | 33
92. In this regard this Court finds that both the appellants Kailash Ram and
Lalita Devi, were convicted under Section 302/34 of IPC.
93. Regarding this issue, this Court is proceeding to examine the individual
guilt or innocence of the appellants Kailash Ram and Lalita Devi.
Re: Conviction of appellant no.2 Lalita Devi:
94. Appellant Lalita Devi, was convicted by the learned Trial Court under
Section 302 with the aid of 34 of IPC.
95. The only incriminating circumstance alleged against appellant no. 2, Lalita
Devi, is that when the prosecution witnesses reached the place of
occurrence, namely the house of appellant no. 1, Kailash Ram, she was not
present and had absconded. Save and except this solitary circumstance, no
other incriminating material has surfaced against her. None of the
prosecution witnesses have deposed that Lalita Devi ever participated with
appellant no. 1 in causing cruelty to the deceased. It is further an admitted
fact that she had contracted marriage with appellant no. 1 only a few days
prior to the occurrence, and therefore she cannot be attributed any role in
the longstanding strained relationship between appellant no. 1 and the
deceased.
96. This Court now proceeds to examine the culpability of appellant no. 2,
Lalita Devi, in the light of the principles of joint criminal liability under
Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, under which she was convicted by the
learned Trial Court. The background circumstances are that she is the
newly-wedded second wife of appellant no. 1, Kailash Ram, having
contracted marriage with him only a few days prior to the homicidal death
of Sita Devi (deceased), his first wife. The crucial issue for consideration is
Page | 34
whether appellant no. 2 shared a common intention with appellant no. 1,
i.e., whether there was a prior meeting of minds which activated and
facilitated the homicidal death of Sita Devi.
97. At this juncture, it needs to refer herein the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
in the case of Pandurang v. State of Hyderabad, AIR 1955 SC 216,
wherein Hon’ble Apex Court laid down that a common intention
presupposes prior concert. It requires a pre-arranged plan because before a
man can be vicariously convicted for the criminal act of another, the act
must have been done in furtherance of the common intention of them all.
Paragraph-33 and 34 of this judgment is quoted herein below“33. Now in the case of Section 34 we think it is well established that
a common intention presupposes prior concert. It requires a prearranged plan because before a man can be vicariously convicted for
the criminal act of another, the act must have been done in
furtherance of the common intention of them all : Mahbub Shah v.
King Emperor. Accordingly there must have been a prior meeting of
minds. Several persons can simultaneously attack a man and each can
have the same intention, namely the intention to kill, and each can
individually inflict a separate fatal blow and yet none would have the
common intention required by the section because there was no prior
meeting of minds to form a pre-arranged plan. In a case like that,
each would be individually liable for whatever injury he caused but
none could be vicariously convicted for the act of any of the others;
and if the prosecution cannot prove that his separate blow was a fatal
one he cannot be convicted of the murder however clearly an intention
to kill could be proved in his case : Barendra Kumar Ghosh v. KingEmperor2 and Mahbub Shah v. King-Emperor3. As Their Lordships
say in the latter case, “the partition which divides their bounds is
often very thin : nevertheless, the distinction is real and substantial,
and if overlooked will result in miscarriage of justice”.
34. The plan need not be elaborate, nor is a long interval of time
required. It could arise and be formed suddenly, as for example when
one man calls on bystanders to help him kill a given individual and
Page | 35
they, either by their words or their acts, indicate their assent to him
and join him in the assault. There is then the necessary meeting of the
minds. There is a pre-arranged plan however hastily formed and
rudely conceived. But pre-arrangement there must be and
premeditated concert. It is not enough, as in the latter Privy Council
case, to have the same intention independently of each other, e.g., the
intention to rescue another and, if necessary, to kill those who
oppose.”
98. Again, in case of Devi Lal v. State of Rajasthan, (1971) 3 SCC 471,
Hon’ble Apex Court laid down that the words “in furtherance of the
common intention of all” are a most essential part of Section 34 of the
Penal Code, 1860. It is common intention to commit the crime actually
committed. This common intention is anterior in time to the commission of
the crime. Common intention means a pre-arranged plan. Paragraph-13 of
this judgment is quoted herein below“13. The distinction between Sections 34 and 149 of the Penal Code,
1860 was not clearly noticed by the Sessions Court and the High
Court did not deal with this point at all. Under Section 34, when a
criminal act is done by several persons in furtherance of the common
intention of all, each of such persons is liable for that act in the same
manner as if it were done by him alone. The words “in furtherance of
the common intention of all” are a most essential part of Section 34 of
the Penal Code, 1860. It is common intention to commit the crime
actually committed. This common intention is anterior in time to the
commission of the crime. Common intention means a pre-arranged
plan. On the other hand. Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 speaks
of an offence being committed by any member of an unlawful
assembly in prosecution of the common object of that assembly. The
distinction between “common intention” under Section 34 and
“common object” under Section 149 is of vital importance. The
Sessions Court fell into the error of convicting the appellants under
Section 302, read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860 by holding
that “if a number of persons assault another with a stick mercilessly
their intention can only be to murder that man or at least they should
know that they are likely to cause death of the person concerned”.
Page | 36
This aspect of their being likely to cause death would be relevant
under Section 149 and not under Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860
for the obvious reason that under Section 34 it has to be established
that there was the common intention before the participation by the
accused.”
(emphasis supplied)
99. Hence, Hon’ble Apex Court laid down that a common intention
presupposes prior concert. It requires a pre-arranged plan because before a
man can be vicariously convicted for the criminal act of another, the act
must have been done in furtherance of the common intention of them all.
The words “in furtherance of the common intention of all” are a most
essential part of Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860. It is common
intention to commit the crime actually committed.
100. Reverting to the facts of the present case, in order to examine the guilt of
the appellant no.2 Lalita Devi, this Court finds that out of the eleven
witnesses examined by the prosecution, Mahaveer Ram (PW-9), is the
informant and father of the deceased and Kapil Ram (PW-1), Dileshwar
Ram (PW-3) and Naresh Ram (PW-10) are the three uncles of the
deceased and Anand Ram (PW-2), is the cousin brother of the deceased.
101. This Court finds that out of the aforesaid five witnesses, PW-1 has not
testified anything entangling appellant Lalit Devi, in his oral evidence.
102. Further, both PW-3 and PW-10 has also not stated anything overt act
against the appellant Lalita Devi. PW-3 had simply stated in his evidence,
that after the occurrence, later on he came to know that Kailash Ram and
his second wife (appellant Lalita Devi), both had murdered Sita devi.
Likewise, PW-10, had deposed that from neighbors he, came to know that
Page | 37
Kailash Ram and his second wife (appellant Lalita Devi) had killed the
deceased by throttling.
103. Again, PW-9, who is the father of the deceased had made only specific
allegation against his son-in-law Kailash Ram (appellant no.1) and
deposed that Kailash Ram used to torture his daughter(deceased).
104. Hence, fact emerges that none of the related witnesses PW-1, PW-2, PW3, PW-9(informant) and PW-10, had given any concrete oral evidence
against Lalita Devi(appellant), pointing her guilt, in murder of the Sita
Devi.
105. Further, this Court in the preceding paragraph has strong presumption of
the existence of fact under Section 114(g) of the Indian Evidence Act,
against the the appellant Kailash Ram, who is the husband of the Sita
Devi (deceased), that he had strangulated Sita Devi(deceased).
106. Hence, in the facts and circumstance of the present case, there is no
evidence against the appellant Lalita Devi, that she had pre-arranged plan,
with the appellant Kailash Ram and she acted in furtherance of the
common intention in murder of Sita Devi(deceased).
107. The only circumstance against, appellant Lalita Devi, was that after the
death of the deceased, she was absconded. Hence, under such situation,
she being newly married wife of Kailash Ram (appellant no.1herein),
after the death of the deceased, had chosen to absconded out of fear.
Hence, in the present case only her fleeing away from her matrimonial
home, does not lead to conclusion that she was she acting in furtherance
of the common intention in murder of Sita Devi(deceased).
Page | 38
108. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dharam Pal v. State of Haryana (2002)
4 SCC 163 and Ramaswami Ayyangar v. State of T.N. (1976) 3 SCC 779
has held that common intention must be established either by direct
evidence or by necessary inference drawn from proved circumstances,
and cannot be presumed solely on account of association or relationship.
109. The learned Trial Court, overlooked that a man can be vicariously
convicted for the criminal act of another, if the act has been done in
furtherance of the common intention. But, the learned trial court, in
convicting the appellant Lalita Devi, did not gather the facts from the oral
evidence of prosecution witnesses, as to how she was acting in
furtherance of the common intention.
110. This Court finds that none of the prosecution witnesses have testified any
overt act against the appellant Lalita Devi(appellant). But, without any
cogent evidence against the Lalita Devi(appellant), the learned trial court
had convicted her under Section 302 with aid of 34 of IPC.
111. Hence, this Court, after having discussed the factual aspect and legal
position as discussed hereinabove is of the view that the prosecution has
failed to prove the charge under section 302 IPC, against the appellant
no.2 Lalita Devi beyond all reasonable doubt as such the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence requires interference by this
Court, so far as conviction of appellant Lalita Devi is concerned.
Re: Conviction of appellant no.1 Kailash Ram:
112.
Regarding conviction of the appellant Kailash Ram, this Court finds
that informant (PW-9), who is the father of the Sita Devi(deceased) had
Page | 39
deposed that appellant Kailash Ram used to torture his daughter Sita Devi
(deceased).
113.
In the preceding paragraph, motive is also proved from the evidence
of Informant (PW-9), PW-1 and PW-2, that Sita Devi(deceased) since had
no issue, due to this reason her husband Kailash Ram (appellant), used to
quarrel with her and torture her and some days ago prior to the occurrence,
his son-in-law (i.e. appellant Kailash Ram) had married again with Lalita
Devi (appellant no.2).
114.
Further, prosecution has proved the chain of circumstances, linking
him in the murder of his first wife Sita Devi(deceased), as has been
discussed in the issue no. (ii).
115.
Hence, prosecution has proved the charge against the appellant
Kailash Ram, under Section 302 of IPC, beyond reasonable doubt.
Conclusion:
116. On the basis of the discussion made hereinabove, this Court modifies the
conviction of appellant no. 1, Kailash Ram, and holds him guilty of
committing culpable homicide amounting to murder of his wife, Sita Devi.
Accordingly, he stands convicted for the offence punishable under Section
302 of the Indian Penal Code only. Consequent thereto, the impugned
order of sentence dated 20.11.2018, in so far as it relates to appellant no. 1,
Kailash Ram, passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-XII,
Hazaribagh, in Sessions Trial No. 335 of 2017 corresponding to G.R. No.
2102 of 2017 arising out of Charhi P.S. Case No. 58 of 2017, requires no
interference and is hereby sustained and upheld.
Page | 40
117. So far as appellant no. 2, Lalita Devi, is concerned, this Court held in the
preceding paragraphs that no incriminating material against her. The only
circumstance relied upon by the prosecution is that when the witnesses
reached the place of occurrence, namely the house of appellant no. 1, she
was not present and had absconded. Beyond this solitary circumstance, no
cogent overt act has been attributed to her, nor has any witness deposed
that she ever participated with appellant no. 1 in causing cruelty to the
deceased. It is further an admitted fact that she had contracted marriage
with appellant no. 1 only a few days prior to the occurrence, and therefore
she cannot be implicated in the longstanding strained relationship between
appellant no. 1 and the deceased.
118. In these circumstances, mere suspicion or conjecture that appellant no. 2
might have participated in the crime cannot substitute for proof. The settled
principle of law is that suspicion, however strong, cannot take the place of
legal evidence.
119. Accordingly, the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence
dated 20.11.2018 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge-XII,
Hazaribagh, in Sessions Trial No. 335 of 2017 corresponding to G.R.
No.2102 of 2017 arising out of Charhi P.S. Case No.58 of 2017 against
appellant no. 2, Lalita Devi, is hereby quashed and set aside.
120. Consequent thereto she stands acquitted of all charges.
121. Appellant Lalita Devi who is on bail, is discharged from the liabilities of
her bail bonds.
122. In the result, Criminal Appeal (D.B.) No. 1389 of 2018, is partly allowed.
Page | 41
123. Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
124. Let the Trial Court Records be sent back to the Court concerned forthwith,
along with a copy of this Judgment.
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
I agree,
(Sanjay Prasad, J.)
(Sanjay Prasad, J.)
High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi
Dated: 30/09/2026
Saurabh /A.F.R.
Page | 42
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review