Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:49998-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO.4027 of 2019
1. Sachin Tukaram Navgire
2. Prashant Balwantrao Rakhe
VERSUS
1.The State of Maharashtra
2. Shivaji S/o Kishanrao Ghuge
Mr. S. S. Rathi, Advocate for Applicants
Mr. A. R. Kale, APP for Respondent - State
Mr. P. S. Paranjape, Advocate for Respondent no. 2.
CORAM : R. M. JOSHI, J.
DATE
: 13th OCTOBER, 2026
PER COURT :1.
By way of the present application applicants seek quashment
of First Information report Crime No. 69/2019 registered at Bamni Police
Station Taluka Jintur District Parbhani on 17.08.2019 for the offences
punishable under section 420, 217, 218, 406, 467, 468, 469, 471, 34 of
Indian Penal Code (For short ‘ the IPC’) along with charge-sheet bearing
no. 64/2020 dated 31.12.2020 and quashment of order of issuance of
summons dated 12.01.2021 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate
First Class Jintur, District Parbhani.
2.
On perusal of the First Information Report, it reveals that,
the present case arises out of a property dispute involving agricultural
land admeasuring 1 H 57 R in Gut No. 488 situated at village Ambarwadi,
Cri Appln-4027-2019 (copy).odt
1 of 8
Taluka Jintur, District Parbhani. On 05.06.1985, the complainant’s father,
Kishanrao Vitthalrao Ghuge, purchased the subject land from the original
owner, Raghoji Medsing Jadhav, under Registered Sale Deed 1402/1985.
Pursuant to the sale, Mutation Entry No. 106 was recorded in the
revenue register, establishing the complainant’s father as the absolute
owner and possessor of the land. The legal heirs of the Raghoji Medsing
Jadhav Accused Nos. 1 to 5 in the FIR allegedly colluded with local
government officials Gram Sevak (Accused No. 6), Talathi (Accused No.
7) i.e. applicant no. 1, and Circle Officer (Accused No. 8) i.e. applicant
no. 2 to fraudulently enter their names in the land records. The accused
no. 7 allegedly submitted a false and fabricated death certificate of late
Raghoji Jadhav to claim the land by inheritance. It is alleged that without
verifying the earlier registered sale deed or conducting a proper inquiry,
the applicant no. 1 proposed Mutation Entry No. 1672 on 15.05.2014,
which was subsequently sanctioned by the Circle Officer on 12.01.2015.
Thereafter, Mutation Entry No. 1724 was also certified on 10.03.2015. In
2016. Upon obtaining a copy of the 7/12 extract, the complainant
discovered the unauthorized mutation entries. Upon inquiring with the
Gram Panchayat, the Gram Sevak, accused no 6. confirmed in writing
that no official record or entry of Raghoji Jadhav’s death certificate
existed in the Gram Panchayat register. Since the local police failed to
take action on his complaints, the complainant on 29.07.2019 filed a
Private Criminal Complaint under Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal
Cri Appln-4027-2019 (copy).odt
2 of 8
Procedure before the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Jintur. The
learned Judicial Magistrate First class passed the order in Criminal Misc.
Application No. 208/2019 directed Bamni Police Station to register a First
Information Report against all eight accused. Pursuant to the Report,
investigation is done and culminated in the filing of charge sheet. The
learned Trial Court issued process against present applicants or accused.
3.
The learned counsel for the applicants submitted that the
applicants are public servants, Applicant No. 1 working as a Talathi and
Applicant No. 2 as a Circle Officer, who acted in the bona fide discharge
of their official revenue duties. It was contended that the prosecution
failed to obtain the mandatory prior sanction under Section 197 of the
Criminal
Procedure
Code,
thereby
rendering
the
learned
Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Jintur order of taking cognizance legally invalid.
He argued that sanction must exist prior to taking cognizance. He further
argued that a bare perusal of the FIR reveals no allegation against
accused no. 6 to the effect that he knowingly or intentionally issued a
forged death certificate despite having knowledge of its falsity. Even if it
is assumed that sanction could be obtained subsequently, the law
mandates that there must be valid sanction prior to taking cognizance,
which is conspicuously absent in the present case. It was further argued
that the entire dispute is around the title, ownership, and revenue
mutation entries concerning land Gut No. 488, which is purely a civil
Cri Appln-4027-2019 (copy).odt
3 of 8
property dispute currently pending before the Civil Judge Junior Division,
Jintur, District Parbhani in R.C.S. No. 48/2019. Counsel submitted that
the complainant maliciously initiated criminal proceedings to pressurize
the revenue officers and bypass the civil court. Furthermore, it is
submitted that the revenue mutation entries processed and approved by
the applicants were subsequently upheld on appeal by the Sub-Divisional
Officer, Sailu, and the Additional District Collector rejected the application
for stay, which demonstrates that the present applicants acted strictly
within their official powers and without any criminal intention. He further
submitted that the allegations in the FIR as well as the charge-sheet and
documents on record fail to make out a prima facie case, as there is no
evidence on record that the applicants, on their own, forged or created
any fake documents. He argued that the order of issuance of summons
dated 12.01.2021 was passed by the Learned Judicial Magistrate First
Class, Jintur without applying judicial mind, and continuing such
proceedings against public servants constitutes a misuse of the legal
process and an abuse of the judicial process. Learned counsel for the
applicants relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
case of Suneeti Toteja v. State of U.P. And Another, AIR 2025 SC
1308 and Atmarram Zubaji Bansode and Another v. State of
Maharashtra and Another, AIR Online 2019 Bom 1272.
Cri Appln-4027-2019 (copy).odt
4 of 8
4.
Learned APP opposed the application by referring to the
evidence collected during the course of investigation.
5.
Learned counsel for the complainant/Respondent No. 2
opposed
application
by
submitting
that
the
complainant’s
father
purchased 1 H 57 R of land in Gut No. 488 through a registered sale
deed in 1985, which was recorded under Mutation Entry No. 106.
Consequently, neither the original owner nor his legal heirs, i.e., Accused
Nos. 1 to 5, retained any right over the property. It is alleged that the
present applicants processed and approved Mutation Entry No. 1672 on
15.05.2014, 15 days before Accused No. 1 had even submitted an
application. He argued that the fraudulent mutation was executed on the
strength of a fake death certificate claiming that the original owner,
Raghoji Medsingh Jadhav, died in 1984, which directly contradicted a
previous official entry recording his death in 1986. According to him, the
accused no.6 explicitly denied issuing the death certificate dated
12.06.2014, while the official death register was reported missing. He
argued that fabricating public records and conspiring to deprive someone
of their property cannot be considered official duty. Therefore, the
applicants cannot claim protection under Section 197 of the Cr.P.C.
Furthermore, upon completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet has
already been filed against the applicants, which indicates that a
Cri Appln-4027-2019 (copy).odt
5 of 8
prima facie criminal case exists and the disputed questions regarding
forgery must be decided at trial.
6.
Perusal of the record and documents placed on record
indicates that the question before this Court is whether continuing
criminal proceedings against the applicants, who are public servants
working as Talathi i.e. Applicant No. 1 and Circle Officer i.e. Applicant No.
2, is an abuse of the court process. It is undisputed that the actions
attributed to the applicants were performed entirely within the scope of
their official duties in processing land revenue entries. A bare perusal of
the charge-sheet contains no evidence showing that the applicants
personally created, forged, or fabricated the fake death certificate. Their
role was simply to process the application and papers submitted to them
in their official capacity. Apart from the fact that except suspicion raised
by informant about collusion between applicants and co-accused, there is
no evidence to prima facie hold so. There is further no evidence collected
during investigation that applicants participated in any act amounting to
criminal offence or they are beneficiaries of the crime. Since the act done
by them is purported to be done in discharge of their duties, and since
the prosecution failed to obtain the mandatory prior sanction under
Section 197 of the Cr.P.C. prior to the taking of cognizance, the order of
taking cognizance and issuance of summons against the applicants is not
sustainable. It is well-settled that obtaining prior sanction is a mandatory
Cri Appln-4027-2019 (copy).odt
6 of 8
condition precedent before taking cognizance, and the lack of valid prior
sanction renders such order illegal. In this regard, it would be relevant to
refer to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Suneeti Toteja
v. State of U.P. And Another, AIR 2025 SC 1308, where in
Paragraph 29 following observations are under:-
“29. As per the aforementioned proposition, it is only to
be seen if the accused public servant was acting in the
performance of his/her official duties, and if the answer
is in the affirmative, then prior sanction for their
prosecution is a condition precedent to the cognizance
of the cases against them by the courts. It is therefore
largely a disputed question of fact here and not a
question of law. However, this fact of appellant herein
acting in her official capacity is not seriously contested
by the respondents herein. In the instant case, the
appellant had filed the counter affidavit and interacted
with the complainant in her capacity of a Presiding
Officer, ICC. The correctness of the allegations with
regard to the conduct of the appellant need not be
ascertained herein by this Court but the fact that she
was acting in her official duty is sufficient to hold that a
prior sanction from the department was in fact
necessary before the Magistrate taking cognizance
against her. The Magistrate therefore erred in
proceeding to take cognizance against the appellant
without the sanction for prosecution being received
from BIS, and since BIS has eventually refused to grant
sanction for the prosecution of the appellant, the
prosecution against the appellant could not have been
sustained.”
7.
Furthermore, revenue officers certifying mutation entries
cannot be accused in criminal cases for forgery or cheating even if it is
accepted that the allegations against co-accused (private party) of
submitting false papers is true. The presence or absence of a prima facie
Cri Appln-4027-2019 (copy).odt
7 of 8
case against the accused must be gathered strictly from the contents of
the FIR and the material collected during investigation. So also, the
complainant
cannot
use
an
affidavit-in-reply
to
fill
gaps
in
the
prosecution’s case. As held in the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335,
continuing criminal proceedings against these public servants without
mandatory statutory sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C. and without a
prima facie case against them personally in the FIR constitutes a clear
abuse of the process of law.
8.
In case the criminal prosecution is permitted to be proceeded
against the Government Official without sanction and in absence of any
material against them, constituting offence, on their allegations against
informant of collusion between accused persons. No public servant would
be in a position to discharge his duties without fear. In the facts of the
case the criminal proceedings against the applicants cannot be allowed to
be proceeded.
9.
In view of the above applications stands allowed in terms of
prayer clauses ‘C’, ‘C-1’, ‘C-2”.
B. S. Joshi
Cri Appln-4027-2019 (copy).odt
(R. M. JOSHI, J.)
8 of 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review