Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
OWP No. 999/2018
Reserved on:
02.02.2026
Pronounced on: 09.02.2026
Uploaded on: 09.02.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced- Full Judgment
1. Sabza Begum, Age 72 years
W/O Mohd. Bashir Malik,
R/O Fazal-Abad,
Tehsil Surankote, District Poonch
2. Zakir Hussain Malik, Age 47 years
S/O Mohd. Bashir Malik,
R/O Fazal-Abad,
Tehsil Surankote, District Poonch
…..Appellant
Through: Mr. Ajay Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Naved Naik,
Mr. Shakoor Ahmed Malik,
Mr. Arjun Bharti, Advocates.
Vs
1. State (now UT) of Jammu & Kashmir
Through Commissioner/Secretary, Revenue Department,
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar.
2. Commissioner/Secretary to Government,
General Administration Department,
Civil Secretariat, Srinagar.
3. District Development Commissioner, Poonch
4. Tehsildar Surankote, District Poonch
.….Respondents
Through: Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The case, as projected by the petitioners, is that a group of armed militants
intruded into their house, at Fazal-Abad, Tehsil Surankote District Poonch on
27.07.2003 and besides beating the petitioner no.1-Sabza Begum, gunned down her
28 years’ old daughter Zubeda Begum and set on fire their residential house, as the
petitioner no.1 was working as SPO in the SOG Wing of Police; that a case was
registered vide FIR No.127/2003 for the commission of offences punishable under
OWP No. 999/2018
Sections 302/307/120-B/122/436 RPC and 7/25/26/27 Arms Act with Police
Station Surankote. The petitioners-mother and brother of the deceased were paid an
amount of Rs.1,00,000/- as ex gratia by the respondents.
2.
It has been pleaded that aggrieved of the inaction of the respondents to pay
Rs.4.00 lakhs as balance of ex-gratia, the petitioners filed writ petition (OWP
No.816/2011), which was disposed of by this Court on 13.05.2016 with the
direction to respondent-District Development Commissioner, Poonch to consider
the claim of the petitioners. The operative part of the order dated 13.05.2016 is
reproduced below:
“Accordingly, this petition at request is disposed of at this stage
with a direction to respondent No.2-District Development
Commissioner, Poonch to consider the claim of the petitioners for
grant of balance amount of Rs.4 Lac (Rs. Four Lacs only) as ex
gratia relief as projected in the writ petition, of course, under
rules and pass consideration order thereon within a period of six
weeks from the date certified copy of this order and complete set
of paper book are made available to respondent no.2 by the
petitioners.
Disposed of as above along with connected MPs.”
3.
The respondent-District Development Commissioner, Poonch vide Order
No.DCP/Rel/809-11 dated 28.02.2017 rejected the case of the petitioners allegedly
in a mechanical and arbitrary manner and aggrieved of the impugned order supra,
the petitioners have filed this instant petition, inter alia, praying for the following
reliefs:
“a.
Writ
of
certiorari
quashing
the
order
being
no.DCP/Rel/809-11 dated 28.02.2018 passed by respondent
no.3, whereby the claim of the petitioners has been
illegally, arbitrarily and capriciously rejected.
b. Writ of Mandamus, commanding the respondents to pay the
OWP No. 999/2018
remaining amount of Rs. 4 lakhs as ex gratia relief to the
petitioners being the legal heirs of deceased Zubeda
Begum alongwith interest @ 12 % per annum from the
date of the death of the deceased.
c. Writ of Mandamus, commanding the respondents to pay
compensation to the petitioners to the tune of Rs. 20 lacs
for its failure to provide protection and security to the
deceased Zubeda Begum.
d.
Any other writ or direction deemed fit and proper in the
nature and circumstances of the case may also be granted
in favour of the petitioners.”
4.
Pursuant to notice, the respondents filed objections asserting therein that the
petitioners did not fulfill the eligibility criteria prescribed under SRO 43 of 1994,
SRO 199 of 2008 and Government Order No.893/2008 for availing ex gratia
compensation to the tune of Rs.4 lakhs; that the petitioner no.1 applied after lapse
of more than 13 years from the date of the death of the deceased; that the deceased
was not bread-earner and the petitioners were not dependent upon her; that the
family was also having excess income in terms of the prescribed limit as per the
legal heirs certificate issued by the competent authority; that the case of the
petitioners was placed before the District Level Co-ordination cum Screening
Committee (DLCCSC) in light of the order passed by this court in OWP No.
816/2011 and the case of the petitioner-Sabza Begum was rejected by the
Committee vide office letter dated 28.02.2017 on the aforesaid grounds and finally,
it was prayed that the petition being false, frivolous, motivated and misconceived,
deserves no consideration and merits dismissal.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has vehemently argued that in view of
death of the deceased, who happened to be daughter and sister of petitioner no.1
and 2 respectively in a militancy related incident without her involvement in the
OWP No. 999/2018
militancy; the petitioners were entitled to be paid compensation in terms of the
various government notifications and, in particular, the Revised Guidelines of
Central Scheme for Assistance to Civilian Victims/Family of Victims of
Terrorist/Communal/Left Wing Extremist (LME) Violence and Cross Border
Firing and Mine/IED blasts on Indian Territory, 2019, which provided that such a
victim was entitled to a compensation of an amount of Rs.3 lakhs in incidents
before 24.08.2016 and Rs.5 lakhs for incidents that occurred on or after 24.08.2016
on each death or permanent incapacitation to the affected family.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioners argued that the petitioners were paid only
an amount of Rs.1,00,000/- as ex gratia at the time of the death of their daughter for
her burial and the respondents, despite directions from this court passed in OWP
no. 816/2011, had arbitrarily rejected the claim of the petitioners with regard to
payment of the rest of the amount of Rs.4,00,000- mechanically, simply on the
ground that claim was not laid by the petitioners within one year from the date of
death of deceased as required under SRO 177 dated 20.06.2014, within one year
under SRO 199 dated 04.07.2008 or within six months from the date of death of the
deceased in terms of SRO 43/1994; he has further argued that the respondents, as a
welfare State, was required to make payment of the entire amount of compensation
in the form of ex gratia to the victim’s family whose young daughter had lost her
life in terrorist violence. He has further argued that the daughter of the petitioner
no.1 was killed by the militants simply for the reason that the petitioner no.1 was
working as SPO with counter insurgent group of Police, resulting into attack on
their house, at the relevant time, which was burnt and the petitioner no.1 was
beaten, whereas her young daughter was gunned down. He has finally prayed that
the petition be allowed and the respondents be directed to make payment in terms
of the Revised Guidelines of Central Scheme for Assistance to Civilian
OWP No. 999/2018
Victims/Family of Victims of Terrorist/Communal/Left Wing Extremist (LME)
Violence and Cross Border Firing and Mine/IED blasts on Indian Territory, 2019.
7.
Learned Sr. AAG appearing for the respondents, ex adverso, argued that the
ex gratia, which was permissible to the extent of Rs.1,00,000/- at the relevant point
of time, had already been paid to the petitioners and that the petitioners have not
pointed out in their petition as to under what scheme they have claimed the
compensation, which is now being submitted by the learned counsel for the
petitioners, that they are entitled under a central scheme. It has neither been
pleaded in the petition nor the central government has been arrayed as party to the
petition so as to pass such an order by this court as prayed for. Learned Sr. AAG
has vehemently argued that the petitioners have failed to apply within the
prescribed time in terms of the various notifications on the subject, as such, the
respondents have rightly rejected the claim of the petitioners with regard to
payment of further compensation of Rs.4.00 lakhs to them and prayed that the
petition be dismissed being misconceived.
8.
The Apex Court in a case titled Dwarka Nath v. Income Tax Officer
Special Circle D Ward Kanpur & Anr., reported as (1996) AIR SC 81 has held
as under:
“Article 226 is couched in comprehensive phraseology and it ex facie
confers a wide power on the high court to reach injustice wherever it
is found. A wide language in describing the nature "Article 226 is
couched in comprehensive phraseology and it ex facie confers a wide
power on the high court to reach injustice wherever it is found. A wide
language in describing the nature of the power, the purposes for
which and the person or authority against whom it can be exercised
was designedly used by the Constitution. The High Court can issue
writs in Patna High Court CR. WJC No.68 of 2021 dt.07-04-2021 the
nature of prerogative writs as understood in England; but the scope of
OWP No. 999/2018
those writs also is widened by the use of the expression "nature",
which expression does not equate the writs that can be issued in India
with those in England, but only draws an analogy from them. That
apart, High Courts can also issue directions, orders or writs other
than the prerogative writs. The High Courts are enabled to mould the
reliefs to meet the peculiar and complicated requirements of this
country. To equate the scope of the power of the High Court
under article 226 with that of the English courts to issue prerogative
writs is to introduce the unnecessary procedural restrictions grown
over the years in a comparatively small country like England with a
unitary from of Government to a vast country like India functioning
under a federal structure. Such a construction would defeat the
purpose of the article itself. But this does not mean that the High
Courts can function arbitrarily under this Article. There are some
limitations implicit in the article and others may be evolved to direct
the article through defined channels. AIR 1961 SC 1731 and AIR
1954 SC 440. "
9.
The Apex Court in a case titled ‘Air India Statutory Corporation & Ors.
V. United Labour Union & Ors., reported as (1997) 9 SCC 377 has also held that
the founding fathers placed no limitation or fetters on the power of the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution except self imposed limitations. The arm of
the Court is long enough to reach injustice wherever it is found.
10.
The Apex Court in a case titled Nilabati Bahera (Smt.) Alias Lalit Bahera
V. State of Orissa & Ors, reported as (1993) 2 SCC 746, held that a claim in
public law for compensation for contravention of human rights and fundamental
freedoms, the protection of which is guaranteed in the Constitution, is an
acknowledged remedy for enforcement and protection, of such rights, and such a
claim based on strict liability made by resorting to a constitutional remedy
provided for the enforcement of a fundamental right is distinct from, and in
addition to, the remedy in private law for damages for the tort resulting from the
OWP No. 999/2018
contravention of the fundamental right. The defence of sovereign immunity being
inapplicable, and alien to the concept of guarantee of fundamental rights, there can
be no question of such a defence being available in the constitutional remedy. It is
this principle which justifies award of monetary compensation for contravention of
fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution, when that is the only practical
mode of redress available for the contravention made by the State or its servants in
the purported exercise of their powers.
11.
It is now a well accepted proposition in most of the jurisdictions, that
monetary or pecuniary compensation is an appropriate and indeed an effective and
sometimes perhaps the only suitable remedy for redressal of the established and
sometimes perhaps the only suitable remedy for redressal of the established
infringement of the fundamental right to life of a citizen by the public servants and
the State is vicariously liable for their acts. The claim of the citizen is based on the
principle of strict liability to which the defence of sovereign immunity is nor
available and the citizen must revive the amount of compensation from the State,
which shall have the right to be indemnified by the wrong doer. The objective is to
apply balm to the wounds and not to punish the transgressor or the offender, as
awarding appropriate punishment for the offence. The award of compensation in
the public law jurisdiction is also without prejudice to any other action like civil
suit for damages which is lawfully available to the victim or the heirs of the
deceased victim with respect to the same matter for the tortious act committed by
the functionaries of the State.
12.
It is an admitted fact that a young girl-Zubeda Begum, daughter of petitioner
No.1 and sister of petitioner No.2 had died on 27.07.2003 when their house was
attacked by the terrorists as she was gunned down besides beating petitioner No.1
and setting on fire their house at Village Fazad-Abad, Tehsil Surankote, District
OWP No. 999/2018
Poonch regarding which a case was registered vide FIR No. 127/2003 at P/S
Surankote. It is also an admitted fact that respondents had prayed an amount of
Rs.1.00 lakh as ex-gratia to the petitioners. This Court on a petition filed by
petitioners as OWP No. 816/2011 had directed the respondents to consider the
claim of the petitioners for payment of further compensation of Rs.4.00 lakhs as
ex-gratia in their favour. However, their plea was rejected by the respondentDeputy Commissioner, Poonch vide impugned order passed on 28.02.2017 mainly
on the plea that the claim was time barred without going into merits of their claim
with regard to their entitlement. The respondent-Deputy Commissioner, Poonch
has rejected the claim based on the report of the District Screening Committee
keeping into view the timelines of the application requiring to be moved and not as
to what was the quantum of compensation to be paid as ex-gratia under various
notifications issued by the Government of Jammu and Kashmir from time to time.
The Deputy Commissioner concerned has not even considered the claim of the
petitioners in terms of a centrally sponsored scheme for assistance to the victims of
the terrorism. The plea of limitation which has been made the basis for rejection of
the claim by the respondent-Deputy Commissioner seems to be an idea just to
reject the claim of the petitioners. On such a technical plea, the claim of the
petitioners should not have been rejected as it is the duty and obligation of the state
functionaries to consider the matter and take steps even at their own level after
conducting inquiry to compensate the victims of the terrorism. It is generally not
expected from the victims to approach the officers within the prescribed period as
they are not out of their trauma to which the terrorists had subjected them. The plea
of the respondents as submitted by the learned Sr. AAG with regard to limitation in
the considered opinion of this court is not applicable before this court under writ
jurisdiction. This court need not go into discussion on the power conferred upon
OWP No. 999/2018
this court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to reach out to injustice and
make appropriate orders including directions to pay damages or compensation.
13.
The Hon’ble High Court of Patna in case of Amar Nath Poddar V. State of
Bihar, reported as 2021 0 Supreme (Pat) 915 in a death case of a 18 years old
boy, who had lost his life due to bullet injuries received while participating in Ma
Durga Idol immersion procession had granted an amount of Rs.10.00 lakhs as
compensation.
14.
This court also in OWP No. 1979/2017 titled ‘Yaar Mohammad Kataria
& Anr. V. Union of India & Ors., had directed to provide compensation for the
death of sons of the petitioners, in an IED blast on 05.07.2009 had held their
parents entitled to compensation as per the revised guidelines of Central Schemes
for Assistance of Civilian Victims/Family of Victims of Terrorist/Communal/Left
Wing Extremist (LME) Violence and Cross Border Firing and Mine/IED blasts on
Indian Territory, 2019. The Division Bench of this Court in WP(C) PIL No.
18/2021 titled ‘Uri Foundation Lagama Uri V. Union of India & Ors.’ has also
asked the authorities to consider and pass necessary orders within two months for
the cross-border victims of Uri, in terms of the Central Scheme for victims.
15.
This Court had an occasion to go through the Revised Guidelines of Central
Scheme
For
Assistance
to
Civilian
Victims/Family
of
Victims
of
Terrorist/Communal/Left Wing Extremist (LME) Violence and Cross Border
Firing and Mine/IED blasts on Indian Territory, 2019. Class-6 of the Scheme
provides for procedure to be followed at the District Level in such cases for passing
the sanction order by the District Magistrate/District Collector on behalf of the
State Government, whereas Class-7 provides for the procedure to be followed by
the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA), Government of India for reimbursement of
the compensation sanctioned on behalf of the State Government by the DM/DC in
OWP No. 999/2018
a time framed manner.
16.
It will be beneficial to reproduce the Clause 4 of the revised guidelines of the
aforementioned scheme relating to eligibility as under:
4. Eligibility
i.
The financial assistance would be given to the family member(s) in the
event of death or permanent incapacitation of the civilian victim, in
Terrorist, Communal or LWE Violence and Cross Border Firing and
Mine/IED blasts on Indian Territory.
ii.
Assistance would be given to the surviving spouse in case of death/
permanent incapacitation of the husband or the wife, as the case may
be. However, if both the husband and the wife die in same incident of
violence, the family would be entitled to get the assistance, in each
case.
iii.
Families of the victims would be eligible to get assistance under the
Scheme even, if they have received any other assistance, by way of
payment of ex-gratia or any other type of relief from the Government
or any other source except when a similar scheme is already being
implemented by the Central Government.
iv.
Civilian victim/ Next of Kin (NoK) will be eligible to get financial
assistance under the Central Scheme even if he/she or any other
person in the family has been given a permanent Government job on
compassionate grounds.
v.
Civilian Victim/NoK of the Security Related Expenditure (SRE)
Districts/States will be eligible to get financial assistance under SRE
Scheme also in addition to the financial assistance under the Central
Scheme. In the case of Jammu & Kashmir, financial assistance will be
governed by the letter No.16016/4/2017-K-V dated 14thJune 2018
issued by Jammu and Kashmir Division (now Jammu, Kashmir &
Ladakh Affairs Division), Ministry of Home Affairs.
vi.
Next of Kin (NoK) of employees of Central Government, CPSEs,
Autonomous Institutions and other Government Organizations
including State Governments / State PSEs and similar organizations
of State Governments will also be eligible to receive financial
assistance of Rs.3 Lakh/Rs.5 Lakh as the case may be, in case of
death/ permanent incapacitation (50% and above) on account of
incidents of Terrorist/ 2 Communal/ LWE Violence and Cross Border
Firing and Mine/IED blasts on Indian Territory. vii. Foreign
Nationals and NRIs shall also be eligible / covered under the Scheme
OWP No. 999/2018
w.e.f. 01.04.2008 i.e. the date from which this Scheme has been made
effective.
vii.
Those permanently incapacitated, and the members of the family of
the civilian victims killed/permanently incapacitated in the Terrorist,
Communal or LWE Violence and Cross Border Firing and Mine / IED
blasts on Indian Territory would be given a health card by the District
Health Society, functioning under the National Rural Health Mission.
This card would entitle them to free medical treatment in respect of
injuries due to violence and all other major illnesses. Medical care
will also be provided to the beneficiaries of the Scheme as a special
case under the on-going schemes of the Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare, viz., Rashtriya Arogya Nidhi and the National Trauma Care
Project.
viii. Children in the family would continue to be entitled for assistance
admissible under the project 'Assist', implemented by the National
Foundation for Communal Harmony (NFCH) of the MHA.
ix.
No other criteria regarding income of the family would be considered
for the eligibility under this scheme.
x.
The perpetrators of violence or their family will not be entitled to any
assistance under the scheme.
xi.
The eligible claimants can file their claims in prescribed proforma
(Annexure-l) within 3 years of the relevant incident of Terrorist,
Communal or LWE Violence and Cross Border Firing and Mine/I ED
blasts on Indian Territory through the DM/DC/State Government
concerned. The time limit, however, can be relaxed in deserving cases
by the Central Government on the recommendations of the State Govt.
or by the Central Government suo-motu.
17.
Having regard to the aforesaid discussion and having reference to the law as
discussed hereinabove, this Court is of the considered opinion that the claim of the
petitioners with regard to payment of compensation for the death of the civiliandaughter of the petitioner no.1 and sister of petitioner no.2 in a terrorist activity has
been rejected arbitrarily and in a mechanical manner by the respondent-Deputy
Commissioner though petitioners, on the basis of admitted facts were entitled to
receive financial assistance in terms of sub clause (vii) of Clause 4 of the
OWP No. 999/2018
aforestated Central Scheme. The impugned order of rejection is, thus, quashed with
a direction to consider the case afresh in terms of the Revised Guidelines of Central
Scheme
for
Assistance
to
Civilian
Victims/Family
of
Victims
of
Terrorist/Communal/Left Wing Extremist (LME) Violence and Cross Border
Firing and Mine/IED blasts on Indian Territory, 2019, expeditiously.
18.
The compensation shall be assessed and sanction order shall be passed so
that the petitioners who have been craving for the compensation for the last more
than 22 years are given some succor for the injuries inflicted on their family by the
terrorists way back in the year 2003.
19.
The petition is thus disposed of as allowed in the above terms, along with
connected application(s).
(M A CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
Jammu
09.02.2026
Raj Kumar
Raj Kumar
2026.02.09 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
OWP No. 999/2018
Whether the order is reportable?:
Yes
Whether the order is speaking?:
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review