Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:25917
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-1-:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 6TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 299 OF 2014
[AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 31.10.2013 IN OP NO.1072
OF 2011 OF FAMILY COURT, NEDUMANGAD]
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
HARI S.V.
AGED 33 YEARS
S/O.SOMARAJ,HARI NIVAS,MUKKAMPALAVILA
VEEDU,VAZHUTHOOR, NEYYATTINKARA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
BY ADVS.
SRI.V.JAYAPRADEEP
SRI.ABE RAJAN
SRI.SHANE WILFRED MORRIS
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
ANSY
D/O.LALITHA,AGED 25 YEARS,A.A
NIVAS,THEKKUMKARA,KARIPOOR VILLAGE,NEDUMANGAD
TALUK,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
BY ADV SRI.J.JAYAKUMAR
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON 12.03.2025, ALONG WITH Mat.Appeal.300/2014, THE COURT ON
27.03.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:25917
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-2-:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 6TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 300 OF 2014
[AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 31.10.2013 IN OP NO.1058
OF 2010 OF FAMILY COURT, NEDUMANGAD]
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS:
S.V.HARI
AGED 33 YEARS
S/O.SOMARAJ, HARI NIVAS, MUKKAMPALAVILA VEEDU,
VAZHUTHOOR, NEYYATTINKARA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
VASANTHAKUMARI
AGED 56 YEARS
D/O.SARASWATHY, HARI NIVAS, MUKKAMPALAVILA VEEDU,
VAZHUTHOOR, NEYYATTINKARA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
BY ADVS.
SRI.V.JAYAPRADEEP
SRI.ABE RAJAN
SRI.SHANE WILFRED MORRIS
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS:
ANSY
AGED 25 YEARS
D/O.LALITHA, A.A.NIVAS, THEKKUMKARA, KARIPOOR
VILLAGE, NEDUMANGAD TALUK, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695
ANCHIMA
D/O.ANSY, A.A.NIVAS, THEKKUMKARA, KARIPOOR
VILLAGE, NEDUMANGAD TALUK, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695
BY ADV SRI.J.JAYAKUMAR
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON 12.03.2025, ALONG WITH Mat.Appeal. No.299/2014, THE
COURT ON 27.03.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:25917
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-3-:
SATHISH NINAN & SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, JJ.
—-------------------------------------Mat.Appeal Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
—------------------------------------Dated this the 27th day of March, 2025
J U D G M E N T
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN,J:
The husband is the appellant in the above two
appeals
filed
against
the
common
judgment
in
O.P.Nos.1072/2011 and 1058/2010 of the Family Court,
Nedumangad. Mat Appeal No.299/2014 is filed by the
husband against the decree for dissolution of marriage,
and Mat Appeal No. 300/2014 is filed against the decree
declaring the wife as the absolute owner of item Nos.1
to 3 in
Schedule “A” properties, and to return 24
sovereigns of gold ornaments or its present market
value,
₹1,00,000/-
given
as
pocket
money,
and
₹2,00,000/- as value of household articles. For the
sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as
husband and wife.
2.
The brief facts of the case are as follows:-
The marriage between the parties was solemnised on
28.05.2009.
A
child
was
born
in
their
wedlock.
2025:KER:25917
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-4-:
According to the wife, 41 sovereigns of gold ornaments
were given to her at the time of marriage. On the date
of ‘Adukkalakanal’, a gold chain weighing 4½ sovereigns
and a bracelet of 2½ sovereigns were given to the
husband, and two gold bangles weighing one sovereign
each were given to the husband's mother and sister,
respectively. An extent of 50 cents of property was
settled by her father in favour of the daughter and
son-in-law.
property
The
and
sovereigns
property
of
wife
house
claimed
were
gold
admeasuring
that
purchased
ornaments.
1.750
2.500
by
cents
of
selling
11½
Further,
cents
and
adjacent
house
were
purchased in the name of the wife and husband by the
wife’s
father
by
selling
15½
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments belonging to the wife. The wife alleges that
out of 41 sovereigns of gold ornaments, she was left
with only 14 sovereigns.
All the gold ornaments were
entrusted to her mother-in-law and sister-in-law and
were not returned to her.
It was also alleged that
there were several incidents of harassment during her
pregnancy,
including
demands
for
increased
dowry.
2025:KER:25917
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-5-:
Furthermore after being enrolled for
post graduation,
she was prohibited from writing her examinations and
was also restricted from contacting her parents over
the phone. Thus, she filed a complaint before the
Women’s Commission, Thiruvananthapuram and due to the
interference of the Women’s Commission, she was allowed
to write the first semester examination. The husband
allegedly prohibited her from pursuing her education.
The wife further alleged that she was subjected to
cruelty
and
Consequently,
physical
a
assault
by
case
was
police
the
husband.
registered
at
Nedumangad Police Station. Moreover, M.C.No.37/2010 was
filed before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court,
Nedumangad under the Domestic Violence Act. The wife
claimed
declaration
of
title
over
the
properties
described as ‘A’ schedule item Nos.1 to 3, further
sought for return of 24 sovereigns of gold ornaments or
their present market value,
₹1 lakh given as pocket
money
the
and
₹2
lakh
being
value
of
household
articles given to the husband. Further, an amount of
₹50,000/- was also claimed towards delivery expenses.
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-6-:
3.
The
husband
denied
the
entrustment
of
amounts by her father and also denied the allegation
that the properties were purchased by selling the
gold
ornaments
and
with
the
money
spent
father-in-law.
He
contended
that
the
by
his
properties
were acquired using his own funds and therefore she
was not entitled to claim ownership or declaration
of title over the properties.
allegation
of
He further denied the
misappropriation
of
gold
ornaments
weighing 24 sovereigns. The allegation that she was
prevented from writing the examination was denied.
Instead claimed that he had not subjected her to any
cruelty.
He
further
stated
that
the
wife
had
voluntarily left their matrimonial home and returned
to the parental home.
4.
The
Family
Court,
after
elaborate
consideration of the evidence, decreed the original
petitions,
granting
all
except
Rs.50,000/-
alleged
to
have
maternity
expenses.
Aggrieved
the
been
by
prayer
for
incurred
for
the
same,
the
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-7-:
husband has filed the above appeals.
5.
learned
We have heard Adv.Mr.Jayapradeep.V., the
counsel
for
Adv.Mr.J.Jayakumar,
the
the
appellant/husband
learned
counsel
and
for
the
respondent/wife.
6. First, we shall consider the appeal filed by
the
husband
marriage
against
took
dissolution
place
on
of
28.05.2009.
marriage.
The
The
parties
resided together only for 9 months and admittedly,
they are living separately from 22.03.2010. It is
the
case
of
the
wife
marriage,
the
husband
that,
was
immediately
harassing
the
after
wife
claiming more dowry. The wife alleged that, after
marriage, she was not permitted to continue with her
MSc course. The husband always had an inferiority
complex that he had studied only upto 10 th standard.
It is an admitted fact that she had approached the
Women's Commission with a complaint stating that she
was prevented from writing the M.Sc. examination. It
is after the intervention of the Women's Commission
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-8-:
that she was permitted to write the examination. It
was also her case that the husband was harassing her
with abusive language and it is due to his cruelty
that she had to leave the matrimonial home.
7.
In
the
written
statement
the
husband
contended that when the wife came to know that she
was
pregnant,
she
was
unhappy
about
it.
However
during cross examination, he admitted that his wife
was happy when she came to know about the pregnancy.
It reveals the character of the husband that he has
no hesitation in giving false statements regarding
his
wife.
The
husband
had
raised
an
allegation
against the father of the wife that he was a person
of immoral character and he wanted his daughter to
live with him throughout his life and that is the
reason for all the problems that arose in the life
of
the
evidence
husband
that
and
the
wife.
husband
It
is
clear
from
the
treated
the
wife
with
cruelty. He did not even permit her to write her
examinations
or
pursue
her
higher
studies
which
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-9-:
ultimately resulted in intervention of the Women’s
Commission.
8. The couple lived together only for 9 months.
False allegations made against the spouse amount to
mental cruelty. In Princy v. Varkey [2000 (1) KLT
756] (FB), this Court has held that cruelty need not
be of such a nature as to cause danger to life, limb
or health. Causing a reasonable apprehension of such
danger and inflicting mental agony is also cruelty.
Though
from
22.03.2010
the
parties
were
living
separately, the husband has not filed any petition
for restitution of conjugal rights. It is clear from
the evidence adduced that the wife is unwilling to
continue the relationship with the husband due to
the cruelty meted out to her. The marriage between
the
parties
have
irretrievably
broken
down.
The
emotional bond had become dry, and the warmth of
their
matrimonial
relationship
went
increasingly
missing and the marriage between the parties was
dead. In such circumstances, if a decree of divorce
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-10-:
is
not
granted,
the
parties
would
be
forced
to
endure unnecessary suffering, misery and emotional
distress.
The
husband
and
wife
have
been
living
separate and apart for an extended period. We are of
the
opinion
that
the
Family
Court
has
rightly
granted a decree for divorce to the wife. We are not
inclined to interfere with the same.
9. Next, we shall consider the issue regarding
realisation of money, gold and property. Firstly, as
regards the money, according to the wife, an amount
of
₹1,00,000/- was given to her as pocket money and
she has claimed ₹2,00,000/- as the value of the
articles given to her husband. The afore ₹1,00,000/was given by the wife’s parents at the time of
marriage and an amount of ₹2,00,000/- is claimed by
the wife, towards the value of the items described
in
Schedule
‘B’
which
consists
of
items
of
property. The wife had relied on Ext.A4, document to
prove that her father had withdrawn an amount of
₹1,00,000/-
on
22.04.2009
and
Ext.A3
photograph
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-11-:
which shows the pocket money was received
by the
husband’s uncle. The husband had denied the receipt
of the amount of ₹1,00,000/-. Exts.A3 photograph, A4
copy of passbook and the testimony of PWs.2 and 3
would substantiate the case of the wife that the
husband was paid an amount of ₹1,00,000/- as pocket
money on the date of engagement. Hence, we are not
inclined
to
interfere
with
the
decree
granted
regarding the payment of ₹1,00,000/-.
10. As regards the claim of ₹2,00,000/-
being
the value of items in B Schedule, PW4- the driver of
the
vehicle
had
deposed
that,
on
the
date
of
marriage, he had delivered one almirah, one grinder,
one
mixie,
one
pressure
cooker,
one
copper
pot,
several presentation articles to the house of the
husband. He had also testified that on the same day,
he had taken a godrej fridge to the house of the
husband. Further, PW4 had further deposed that four
months after marriage, he had taken a TV stand,
computer table, computer etc. to the house of the
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-12-:
husband.
During
cross-examination
brought
out
to
discredit
Hence,
the
family
court
the
nothing
testimony
allowed
the
was
of
PW4.
prayer
for
return of ₹2,00,000/-, being the value of items in B
Schedule. We find no reason to interfere with the
same.
11. Regarding the declaration of title over
item Nos. 1 to 3 in A Schedule, it is the specific
case
of
the
wife
that
11½
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments belonging to the wife was sold at Bhima
Jewellery,
Thiruvananthapuram
and
another
₹2,00,000/- given by the parents of the wife were
utilised and 2½ cents of property with building was
purchased on 03.08.2009 in the joint names of the
wife
and
the
husband.
Further,
according
to
the
wife, the husband was not willing to reside in the
above house and again another 15½ sovereigns of gold
ornaments were sold at Bhima Jewellery on 05.09.2009
and another property admeasuring 1.750 cents with
building was purchased and document was executed on
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-13-:
09.09.2009. It was the specific case of the wife
that, though the name of the husband was shown in
the
documents
he
had
not
spent
any
amount
for
purchasing the property.
12. On the other hand, the husband claimed
that the above properties were purchased in their
joint names by utilising the amount of the husband,
by availing loan from his department and also by
selling
the
property
belonging
to
the
husband’s
mother. The husband has also claimed that his mother
had obtained ₹3,00,000/- when his father died, who
was an employee in the Railway department and by
using
that
amount
2½
cents
of
property
were
purchased. He further stated that 1.750 cents of
property and building was sold to his paternal uncle
in 2007 and that amount was kept in the almirah, and
with that amount the property was repurchased by him
in 2009. Other than his contentions, no documents
such as any bank statements or loan statement was
produced by the husband to prove the transaction,
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-14-:
whereas the wife produced Ext.A14 to prove that 11½
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments
were
sold
on
30.07.2009, Exts.A15 and A16 to prove that 2.500
cents of properties were purchased on 03.08.2009,
Exts.A17 and A18 to prove that 15½ sovereigns of
gold ornaments were sold on 05.09.2009 and another
property admeasuring 1¾ cents with the building was
purchased and document was executed on 09.09.2009.
Further, Ext.A19 document was produced to prove that
₹81,000 and ₹16,000 were withdrawn on 05.09.2009 and
07.09.2009
respectively
from
the
account
of
the
father of the wife. Admittedly, the sale deed was
executed on 09.09.2009. Satisfactory evidence was
adduced by the wife to prove that the properties
were
purchased
by
selling
her
gold
ornaments
weighing 27 sovereigns as well as by utilising the
amount of her father.
13. On appreciation of evidence, the Family
Court has come to the conclusion that the wife is
entitled for declaration of title over item Nos. 1,2
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-15-:
and 3 of Schedule A properties. We find that the
declaration
granted
is
on
proper
appreciation
of
facts and evidence. We do not find any reason to
interfere with the same.
14. Finally, regarding the claims for return
of gold ornaments, the wife has claimed that out of
51 sovereigns claimed, 27 sovereigns were utilised
for purchasing the property and the claim is for 24
sovereigns of gold ornaments. It is the case of the
wife that on the date of engagement, one sovereign
of gold ornament was given to the husband. Further,
on the date of marriage, she was adorned with 41
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments.
She
has
further
claimed that a gold chain of 4½ sovereigns and a
gold bracelet of 2½ sovereigns were given to the
husband on the date of the reception. It was further
claimed that 2 gold bangles of 1 sovereign each were
given to the mother-in-law and sister-in-law. The
wife has also alleged that 27 sovereigns were sold
for
purchase
of
the
properties.
So,
out
of
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-16-:
sovereigns, she admits that 14 sovereigns were left.
By
adding
the
sovereigns
given
to
the
husband,
mother-in-law and sister-in-law, she claims return
of 24 sovereigns of gold ornaments.
15. The husband contended that he was not
aware of the gold ornaments or its quantity, which
were worn by the wife at the time of the marriage.
According to the husband, all the gold ornaments
were handed over to her father immediately after the
marriage. During cross-examination, the husband who
was examined as CPW1 has admitted that 26 sovereigns
of gold ornaments were sold for the purchase of the
properties. Upon examining Ext A5 marriage photos,
it
is
seen
substantial
document
that
the
quantity
shows
that
wife
of
is
gold
the
adorned
with
a
ornaments.
Ext
A6
gold
ornaments
were
purchased on 04.04.2009. Satisfactory evidence had
been adduced by the wife, by adducing evidence as
PW1 and produced Exts.A2, A7, A22, A23 and A24 in
support of her claim. The testimony of the wife is
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-17-:
more reliable and her evidence that she was having
51 sovereigns of gold ornaments is to be believed.
16. However, the family court has found that
the wife is entitled for the return of 24 sovereigns
of
gold
would
ornaments.
have
been
The
ornaments
wearing
while
which
the
wife
she
left
the
matrimonial home was not considered. The wife has
stated that she was not permitted to leave the house
or to call the parents over telephone. However, she
found shelter in the police station on 22.03.2010
and it is, as per the intervention of the police,
that she could reach her parental home. Deducting 4
sovereigns of gold ornaments which would have been
with her for her use, we hold that the wife is
entitled for return of only 20 sovereigns of gold
ornaments. The judgment of family court is liable to
be modified to that extent.
In
the
result,
Mat.A.No.299
of
is
dismissed. Mat.A.No.300 of 2014 is partly allowed.
The wife is entitled to recover 20 sovereigns of
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-18-:
gold ornaments or its present market value within a
period of one month, in default of which, the wife
will
be
entitled
to
realise
the
same
from
the
husband personally and from his assets, both movable
and immovable. The judgment and decree of the Family
Court is modified to the extent as above. No costs.
sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
MBS/
Mat.A.Nos.299 & 300 of 2014
:-19-:
APPENDIX OF MAT.APPEAL 300/2014
APPELLANTS' ANNEXURES:Annexure A1
JUDGMENT IN CC NO. 380/2011 OF JFMC-I,
NEYYATINKKARA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review