The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. The relief under the Specific Relief Act, 1963 is a discretionary relief. In view of the clear admission made by the plaintiff’s own witness Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) as the constituted attorney of late Sonam Topgay Kazi the seller that he was not authorised to sell the portion of land given to the defendant no.2, this relief cannot be granted in favour of the plaintiff. Consequently, the R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019 S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang declaration sought by the plaintiff that he was the rightful owner of land in possession of the defendant no.2 and entitled to recover the same from him cannot be granted; the relief of specific performance of the agreement dated
01. 02.2011 (exhibit-P4) and undertaking dated 05.02.2011 (exhibit-P6) also cannot be granted; The decree for mandatory injunction against the defendant no.2 directing him to demolish the „kutcha‟ house and shift to plot no.222 cannot also be granted; and the decree for recovery of possession of the portion of the suit land in occupation and possession of the defendant no.2 cannot also be granted to the plaintiff. It is accordingly so ordered.
24. While thus agreeing with the conclusion arrived at by the learned First Appellate Court viz-a-viz the defendant no.2, this court is unable to agree with some of the findings. The judgment of the learned First Appellate Court accordingly stands modified to the above extent. The appeal is dismissed and disposed of accordingly. In the circumstances, no order as to costs. (Bhaskar Raj Pradhan) Judge to/ Approved for reporting: yes Internet: yes
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
S.B: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.S.A. No.09 of 2019
S.T. Gyaltsen,
S/o late Lobzang Gyaltsen,
Yangyang Kothi,
P.O. Yangyang,
South Sikkim.
….. Appellant/Plaintiff
Versus
Kalu Tamang,
S/o late Dorjee Tamang,
Kopibari, Upper Syari,
P.O. & P.S. Deorali,
East Sikkim.
…..Respondent/Defendant No.2.
Appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. D.K.
Siwakoti and Ms. Prarthana Ghataney,
Advocate for the Appellant/Plaintiff.
Mr. B. K. Gupta, Legal Aid Counsel for the
Respondent/Defendant No.2.
--------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing: 06.08.2021, 07.08.2021 & 17.08.2021
Date of Judgment: 04.09.2021
JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
This appeal has been preferred by the plaintiff
against
the
judgement
and
decree
both
dated
30.03.2019 passed by the learned First Appellate Court.
2.
The
original
suit
for
declaration,
specific
performance of contract, mandatory injunction, and
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
other consequential reliefs under Section 10 and 39 of
the Specific Relief Act, 1963 read with Section 9 and
151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) was filed
by the appellant (the plaintiff) against three defendants
including the present respondent who was defendant
no.2 therein. For clarity the parties will be referred as
the plaintiff and defendants. The plaintiff had prayed
for:
“(a) A decree declaring that the plaintiff is
the rightful owner of the land in possession
of the defendants entitled to recover the
same from them;
(b)
A decree for specific performance of
the contract dated 1.2.2011 signed on
05/02/2011 along with the undertaking
dated 5/2/2011;
(c)
A decree for mandatory injunction
against the defendants 1, 2 and 3 directing
them to demolish kutcha mud houses on plot
No. 207 and shift to demarcated housing
sites on plot No.222 and on their failure the
plaintiff will be entitled to remove all the
kutcha mud houses with the help of the
court by executing the Decree that may be
passed in favour of the plaintiff and against
the defendant Nos. 1, 2 & 3;
(d)
A decree recovery of possession of the
suit land by evicting the Defendant nos. 1 to
3 therefrom;
(e)
A decree for the cost of the suit and
decree for any other relief or reliefs to which
the plaintiff may be found entitled to under
the law.”
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
3.
It was the case of the plaintiff that he had
negotiated the deal for purchase of the suit land
through Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) his constituted attorney
and purchased 9.22 acres of land from one late Sonam
Topgay Kazi after executing a registered sale deed dated
04.10.2010 (exhibit- P1). The plaintiff contended that he
owned large area of dry field covered by plot nos. 205,
207, 208, 209, 2011, 220, 221, 222, 220/813 and
220/814 measuring 9.14 acres. The plaintiff stated that
out of plot no.221 two plots measuring (60 feet x 60
feet) and (80 feet x 60 feet) were alienated in favour of
his relative, Hissey Doma Yongda and his daughter,
Kesang Diki Gyaltsen. The plaintiff averred that the
defendants had „kutcha‟ mud houses in plot no.207 and
the defendant no.2’s mud house covered plinth area
measuring about 40 feet x 25 feet. The total area of land
that had the houses of the defendants was the suit
land. The plaintiff stated that after various negotiations
an amicable settlement was arrived at between the
appellant and the defendants. According to the plaintiff
this agreement was entered into prior to the execution
of the sale deed on 04.10.2010 (exhibit-P1). It was
asserted that pursuant to the agreements the plaintiff
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
also paid various sums of money to various persons as
enumerated in the plaint. Although the rest of the
families who had entered into the agreements moved to
plot no 222 owned by the plaintiff, the defendants
declined to do so. Ultimately this dispute led to the
filing of the suit against the defendants.
4.
The defendants filed joint written statements. They
disputed the plaintiff’s ownership of the suit land. They
asserted that the real owner of the suit land was late
Sonam Topgay Kazi who was then residing in United
States of America. They also asserted that the suit land
did not fall in plot no.207. According to the defendants
the land they were in possession of was the one donated
by late Rhenock Athing Kazi, the father of late Sonam
Topgay Kazi to the father of defendant no.2, late Dorjee
Tamang. They averred that they had been living in the
suit properties as the owners and their rights had also
matured by way of adverse possession. It was further
averred that the plaintiff’s act of transferring the land
comprising of plot no. 221 to his relative and daughter
was to exclude the defendants from the said plot which
they were in possession of. They asserted that plot no.
221 belonged to the defendants. It was gifted to the
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
father of the defendant no.2, late Dorjee Tamang by late
Rhenock Athing Kazi, father of late Sonam Topgay Kazi
as far back as on 11.12.1962 by a written document.
The defendants are still residing there. They stated that
they were simple, illiterate, and semi-illiterate villagers.
They stated that the villagers were called by the
panchayat members viz. Phigu Tamang (P.W.4) and
Ratan Bahadur Tamang (P.W.3) to Gangtok to sign on
certain papers to obtain development benefits. It was
due to this that they had signed various written as well
as in blank papers under undue influence but later
realized that these papers were being used against them
in the suit. They asserted that the defendants never
signed any agreement with the knowledge about what
they were being made to sign and therefore, it was null
and void. They also denied the undertakings alleged to
have been executed by them.
5.
The plaintiff (P.W.1) examined himself, Kalden
Bhutia (P.W.2) the constituted attorney of late Sonam
Topgay Kazi who negotiated the deal for the purchase of
suit land; Ratan Bahadur Tamang (P.W.3) the then Zilla
Panchayat of the area; Phigu Tamang (P.W.4) the then
panchayat member of the concerned ward in Syari;
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
Ashok Tamang who had attested the sale deed (exhibitP1), the agreements (exhibit-P5), undertaking (exhibitP6) and other documents; Utpal Yongda (P.W.5) his sonin-law; G. S. Sharma (P.W.6) the concerned amin in the
District
Collectorate
and
Babita
Rai
(P.W.7)
the
defendants advocate who was examined as plaintiff’s
witness. All the witnesses except G. S. Sharma (P.W.6)
and Babita Rai (P.W.7) had assisted the plaintiff during
negotiations and the purchase of the suit land.
6.
The defendants examined themselves. Sancha
Bahadur Tamang (D.W.1) was defendant no.1, Kalu
Tamang (D.W.2) was defendant no.2 and Norbu Tamang
(D.W.3) was defendant no.3. The defendants also
examined Kalu Tamang’s wife Phul Maya Tamang
(D.W.4) and Ganga Maya Sharma (D.W.5). Ganga Maya
Sharma (D.W.5) was an 80-year-old resident of Syari
who deposed that she had seen Kalu Tamang (D.W.2)
residing in the suit land since 1962 when she came
from Geyzing. She also deposed about Kalu Tamang’s
(D.W.2) father known as „Lama Bajey‟ who had told her
that he used to work as a „chowkidar‟ with late Rhenock
Athing Kazi who had given him the suit land in plot no.
221 and a document to that effect.
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
7.
The learned Trial Court framed 8 issues and
decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff. In the
judgement dated 26.08.2017 it was held that the
plaintiff was entitled to recover possession of the suit
land from the defendants and for specific performance
of the agreement dated 01.02.2011 (exhibit-P4) and
05.02.2011 read with undertaking dated 05.02.2011
(exhibit-P6). Accordingly, a decree dated 31.08.2017
was passed.
8.
The
defendants
were
dissatisfied
with
the
judgment and the decree passed by the learned Trial
Court. They preferred Title Appeal Case No. 15 of 2017.
The learned First Appellate Court by its impugned
judgement and decree granted the plaintiff relief against
defendant nos.1 and 3 but held that he was not entitled
to any relief against defendant no.2. The plaintiff has
challenged
only
those
portions
of
the
impugned
judgement and decree that relate to defendant no.2.
Consequently, this court shall examine only those
findings and reliefs which the appellant is aggrieved of.
9.
The learned First Appellate Court disagreed with
the findings of the learned Trial Court on issue no.1 i.e.
“1) Whether plaintiff is the owner of plots of land covered
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
under plot no.205, 207, 208, 209, 211, 220, 221, 222,
220/813 and 220/814?”
The learned First Appellate
Court held that since Kalden Bhutia
constituted
(P.W.2), the
attorney of late Sonam Topgay Kazi had
himself admitted during cross-examination that he was
told by late Sonam Topgay Kazi that he could sell the
rest of the suit land except the portion which had
already been given to the defendant no.2, it became
clear
that
late
Sonam
Topgay
Kazi
had
already
acquiesced to the continued possession of the defendant
no.2 over the portion of plot no.221 which he had been
claiming was gifted to his father by late Rhenock Athing
Kazi in 1962 vide exhibit-A. It was thus held that the
sale of that portion of plot no. 221 cannot be held to be
valid. The learned First Appellate Court therefore,
modified the findings of the learned Trial Court and held
that except portion of plot 221 the plaintiff could be
regarded as owners of the said plots by virtue of the sale
deed (exhibit-P1).
To examine the correctness of the
findings it is important to examine the pleadings of the
contesting parties, keeping in mind that the burden to
prove issue no.1 was upon the plaintiff to prove that he
was in fact the owner of the said plots. Mr. B. Sharma,
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
learned Senior Advocate for the plaintiff submitted that
the defendant had not been able to prove exhibit-A as a
gift deed.
10. The plaintiff averred that in the year 2010 he was
looking for a suitable land in an around Gangtok to
start his hotel business when he learned about the
lands owned by late Sonam Topgay Kazi who was
residing abroad. The plaintiff thus contacted Kalden
Bhutia (P.W.2) of Kalimpong to negotiate the deal for
him as his constituted attorney. On 07.09.2010 the
plaintiff along with his constituted attorney Kalden
Bhutia (P.W.2), Ratan Bahadur Tamang (P.W.2) and
Phigu Tamang (P.W.3) conducted physical inspection
and verification of the plots of lands and found that the
defendants and ten other families had „kutcha‟ mud
houses scattered in different plots of lands. After
negotiations an amicable solution was arrived upon to
shift the persons including the defendants living in the
mud houses to plot no. 222. The defendant no.2’s
possession and occupation of the „kutcha‟ house in plot
no. 207 is admitted by the plaintiff. The plaintiff also
averred that by way of the amicable settlement the
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
defendant no.2 had also agreed to shift to plot no.222
where he would be provided a housing site.
11. The defendant no.2’s plea in the written statement,
however, was that the suit land did not fall in plot
no.207 but in plot no.221 which was gifted to late
Dorjee Tamang, father of defendant no.2, by late
Rhenock Athing Kazi father of late Sonam Topgay Kazi.
To substantiate their claim the defendant also produced
exhibit-B as the „purcha khatian‟ showing defendant
no.2’s possession of plot no. 221. This document
reflects attestation of the year 1978. Mr. B. Sharma
submitted that this is a manufactured document since
the area is reflected in hectares whereas in fact at the
relevant time it ought to have been in acres as observed
by this court in Shri K. B. Bhandari vs. Shri Laxuman
Limboo & Anr.1. The plaintiff, however, has failed to
prove that it is in fact a manufactured document. The
cross-examination of the defendant no.2 reflects the
stand of the plaintiff that the defendant no.2’s name
was recorded in exhibit-B by mistake. Not even a
suggestion was given to the defendant no.2 that he had
manufactured exhibit-B. Although it is evident that the
1 SLR (2017) SIKKIM 41
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
defendant is in possession of a „kutcha‟ house on a plot
of land owned by late Sonam Topgay Kazi and now sold
to the plaintiff there is some amount of uncertainty as
to the exact number of the plot in possession of
defendant no.2.
12. Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) was the plaintiff’s witness.
As per his evidence-on-affidavit he was the constituted
attorney of late Sonam Topgay Kazi by which he was
authorised to dispose of his properties situated in the
State of Sikkim. According to him he along with the
plaintiff and others inspected the lands, negotiated with
the occupants of the „kutcha‟ houses scattered in
different plots of land including the defendants and
finally an amicable settlement was entered between the
plaintiff and the occupants of the „kutcha‟ houses
including the defendants who were in plot no.207 to
provide for housing sites on plot no.222 by way of lease
deed.
13. During his cross-examination he admitted that
when he was given power-of-attorney by late Sonam
Topgay Kazi he had been told that he could sell the rest
of the suit land except a portion which was given to
defendant no.2. Mr. B.K. Gupta, learned counsel for the
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
defendant no.2 laid much emphasis on this admission.
He submitted that due to this admission by Kalden
Bhutia (P.W.2) the constituted attorney of late Sonam
Topgay Kazi it was clear that he was not authorised to
sell the land given to the defendant no.2. Kalden Bhutia
(P.W.2) however, feigned ignorance about the details of
the land given to defendant no.2. He stated that the
defendant no.2 had given a portion of the land below
the other land. The power-of-attorney was not produced
in court by the plaintiff. Although the defendants
disputed that late Sonam Topgay Kazi had in fact
appointed Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) as his constituted
attorney no effort was made by the defendants to seek
to produce the power-of-attorney before the learned
Trial Court. It is the plaintiff’s case that the defendant
no.2 is not in occupation of plot no.221 and some
portions of it were transferred in favour of Hishey Doma
Yongda and Kessang Diki Gyaltsen by the plaintiff. Due
to the categorical stand of the plaintiff, he is not entitled
to a declaration that he is the owner of plot no.221 and
the consequential reliefs about the lands he had
admittedly alienated.
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
14. In view of the clear admission of Kalden Bhutia
(P.W.2) that he was not authorised to sell the land
which was given to the defendant no.2, it is important
to examine whether it was him who had sold the land to
the plaintiff in clear violation of the restricted authority
given by the principal. It is pleaded in the plaint that it
was the plaintiff who had purchased the land from late
Sonam Topgay Kazi. According to the plaintiff, before
the execution of the sale deed dated 04.10.2010
(exhibit-P1)
an
amicable
solution
was
found
on
07.09.2010 between the plaintiff and the occupants of
the
mud
houses
agreement
entered
including
the
thereafter,
defendants.
dated
The
01.02.2011
(exhibit-P4) between the plaintiff and defendant no.2 is
a lease agreement which states that the plaintiff had
purchased 9 acres and 22 decimals of land from late
Sonam Topgay Kazi. This agreement is the agreement
which the plaintiff seeks specific performance of along
with the undertaking dated 05.02.2011 (exhibit-P6)
signed by the defendant no.2 as well. This agreement
(exhibit-P4) has been produced by the plaintiff.
The
defendant no.2 put up a case that he was simple and
illiterate and so he was cheated into signing it. The
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
recital in the agreement reflects that late Dorjee Tamang
worked as a domestic help at the residence of late
Rhenock Athing Kazi. Late Rhenock Athing Kazi had
arranged the marriage between late Dorjee Tamang and
late Chumkit lepcha. He had also handed over a plot of
land to them for their day to day living on “Kut”. Late
Dorjee Tamang and late Chumkit Lepcha settled there
and survived on the income from small scale farming
and by cattle grazing. They had resided in the said land
during the lifetime of late Rhenock Athing Kazi and after
his demise at „Kopi bari‟ as a tenant of late Sonam
Topgay Kazi which had been later purchased by the
plaintiff. The recital in the agreement as well as the
evidence led by the parties makes it clear that the
defendant no.2 is not an alien to the suit land. It is also
clear that not only the defendant no.2 but his late
father was also living in the suit lands. Admittedly, the
suit land in which the defendant no.2 has a „kutcha‟
house is in possession of the defendant no.2 till date.
The admission by Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) the constituted
attorney holder of late Sonam Topgay Kazi that he had
authorized him to sell his land except that which had
been given to the defendant no.2 gains significance.
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
This admission is unequivocally made by the plaintiff’s
own witness and therefore, is binding upon him and
must be accepted.
15. The plaintiff in his evidence-on-affidavit deposed
that he had executed the sale deed (exhibit-P1) between
the constituted attorney Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) and
himself
on
02.12.2010.
04.10.2010
Thus,
which
clearly
it
was
was
registered
the
on
constituted
attorney who had executed the sale deed (exhibit-P1) on
behalf of late Sonam Topgay Kazi for the various plots
including the plot which was in the possession of the
defendant no.2. The act of Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) to sell
the land which was in possession of the defendant no.2
was in clear violation of the authority given to him by
late Sonam Topgay Kazi, the principal. A holder of a
power-of-attorney cannot go beyond the principal. A
constituted attorney can do all that he has been
authorized to do and consequently cannot do what he
has been specifically debarred from doing. Thus, it is
held that the sale of the portion of land which was in
possession of the defendant no.2 purportedly owned by
Sonam Topgay Kazi by Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) his
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
constituted attorney was unauthorized and therefore,
null and void.
16. The issue no.6 was whether the defendants have
become the owners of plot no. 221 measuring 0.3400
hectares in view of it being gifted by Rhenock Athing
Kazi. The learned Trial Court held this issue against the
defendants. Exhibit-A and exhibit-B were the two
important documents exhibited by the defendants for
this purpose. The exhibition of these documents was
objected to by the plaintiff. Exhibit-B has been dealt
with hereinabove. Exhibit-B is a ‘purcha’, a record of
rights. It reflects that the owner of the land bearing plot
no.221 in the year 1978 was late Sonam Topgay Kazi
son of late Rhenock Athing Kazi. In the remarks column
there is an entry that late Dorjee Tamang was in
occupation of the said plot for past 20 years. The
document was exhibited in the original and therefore
constitutes
primary
evidence.
The
learned
First
Appellate Court examined exhibit-A as well. He found it
to be not clearly legible but still readable. On reading
the same he noticed that the document was signed by
late Sonam Topgay Kazi and not late Rhenock Athing
Kazi as pleaded in the plaint. He opined that there was
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
possibility that the initials of late Sonam Topgay Kazi
appeared in exhibit-A since plot no 221 was then
recorded in his name. He also opined that as exhibit-A
was not a registered document and it could not be
accepted as a valid gift deed although titled as “icha
patra”. The learned First Appellate Court however,
opined that nevertheless it would still have legal force
and would amount to an irrevocable license in favour of
late Dorjee Tamang. The learned First Appellate Court
was of the view that the nomenclature given by the
parties to a transaction or document is not decisive and
the true intent and purport of a transaction or
document must be gathered from the terms therein
based on credible and admissible evidence. It was held
that no form or consideration was required for such a
license which was based on principles of justice, equity
and good conscience and codified by the Easements Act,
1882. It was further held that Revenue Order no. 1 of
1970 would have no restriction in late Rhenock Athing
Kazi gifting or granting license in favour of late Dorjee
Tamang. Issue no.6 therefore, was decided in favour of
the defendant no.2 by the learned First Appellate Court.
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
17. Mr. B. Sharma submitted that exhibit-A was an
unreadable, unregistered, and unproved document.
18. The burden to prove issue no.6 was upon the
defendants. The learned Trial Court held that the
defendants had not become the owners of plot no.221
by virtue of exhibit-A. The defendants in their joint
written
statement
had
pleaded
that
plot
no.221
belonged to them as it was gifted to the father of
defendant no.2, late Dorjee Tamang by late Rhenock
Athing Kazi, father of late Sonam Topgay Kazi on
11.12.1962 by a written document. The stand of the
defendant no.2 in his written statement was clear. The
defendant no.2 also entered the witness box. In his
evidence-on-affidavit, he once again reiterated the
aforesaid fact. He did not take any alternative plea save
the plea of adverse possession which is admittedly not
sustainable in view of his plea of ownership.
19. The law is well settled that the court cannot make
out a case which was not even pleaded.
It is quite
evident that the learned First Appellate Court has
travelled beyond the pleadings and on its conjectures
and surmises and held exhibit-A to be an irrevocable
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
license even if it was not a gift deed when exhibit-A was
exhibited by the defendants as a gift deed.
20. Notification
No.385/G
dated
11.04.1928
as
amended by Notification No.2947/G dated 22.11.1946
provides that “an unregistered document (which ought in
the opinion of the court to have been registered) may
however, be validated and admitted in court to prove title
or other matters contained in the document on payment
of a penalty up to 50 times the usual registration fee.”
Exhibit-A was exhibited by the defendants as a gift deed
in favour of defendant no.2 by late Rhenock Athing
Kazi. In that view of the matter, it was a document
produced by the defendants as a title deed to prove their
title to plot no.221. It was clearly thus a document
which ought to have been registered as the aforesaid
notification clearly lays down that such a document will
not be considered valid unless it is duly registered. The
learned First Appellate Court has held that it is not a
registered document and not a valid gift deed. That
finding is correct. If it was so, there was a prohibition,
in view of the aforesaid notifications, for exhibit-A to be
admitted in court “to prove title or other matters
contained in the document.” The learned First Appellate
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
Court, however, went on to examine exhibit-A with great
difficulty, and held that it reflects that late Dorjee
Tamang, father of defendant no.2, had been granted
some land. This was clearly not permissible.
The
learned First Appellate Court came to such conclusion
on reading the purported translation of the illegible
exhibit-A. Even if one were to examine the purported
translation filed by the defendants, although clearly
barred, it reflects that exhibit-A purported to be a gift
deed and not an irrevocable license. Furthermore,
exhibit-A purports to be scribed by late Sonam Topgay
Kazi and not by late Rhenock Athing Kazi as pleaded in
the written statement. The learned First Appellate Court
faltered again by surmising facts, reading beyond the
document itself and guessing why signature of late
Sonam Topgay Kazi appears thereon. Exhibit-A was not
proved by defendants as required under the law. The
exhibition of this document was objected to by the
plaintiff. Neither the handwriting nor the signature
thereof was proved by the defendants. As held by the
Supreme Court in Life Insurance Corporation of India
vs.
Ram
Pal
2 (2010) 4 SCC 491
Singh
Bisen2
mere admission of a
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
document in evidence does not amount to its proof. In
other words, mere marking of an exhibit on a document
does not dispense with its proof, which is required to be
done in accordance with law. Thus, the finding arrived
at by the learned First Appellate Court that exhibit-A
was an irrevocable license is clearly unsustainable.
Neither exhibit-A nor exhibit-B supports the contention
that the defendant no.2 was the owner of plot no. 221.
It is thus held that the defendant has not been able to
prove that plot no.221 was gifted to late Dorjee Tamang
by late Rhenock Athing Kazi.
21. The learned First Appellate Court then took issue
no.2 for consideration. Issue no.2 was whether the
defendants have agreed to shift to plot no. 222 from plot
no. 207 vide agreement dated 01.02.2011 (exhibit-P4)
and whether they had agreed to vacate suit land by an
undertaking dated 05.02.2011 (exhibit-P6). The burden
to prove this issue was upon the plaintiff. The issue had
been decided in favour of the plaintiff by the learned
Trial Court. The learned First Appellate Court examined
the evidence and held that the defendants had in fact
signed the agreement dated 01.02.2011 (exhibit-P4) as
well as the undertaking (exhibit-P6). It was noted that
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
the defendant no.2 had admitted that he had executed
the agreement with a stipulation that he would shift to
plot no.222 and endorse his signature thereon. It was
noted that the defendant no.2 had admitted his
signature on the undertaking (exhibit-P6). It was noted
that the defendant no.2 had admitted having accepted
and taken money from the appellant and that he had
repaired his house with the money. It was noted that
Phul Maya Tamang (D.W.4) wife of the defendant no.2
had also admitted that they were paid Rs.10,000/- by
the appellant for shifting. The learned First Appellate
Court therefore, concluded that the defendants had in
fact signed the agreement (exhibit-P4) and undertaking
(exhibit-P6) agreeing to shift to plot no.222. The learned
Trial Court findings were upheld. However, in view of its
findings on issue nos.1 and 6 it was held that the
appellant could not stand to gain anything considering
the specific admission by the constituted attorney
(P.W.2) that late Sonam Topgay Kazi had directed him
not to sell the portion of the land in possession of the
defendant no.2.
22. The agreement (exhibit-P4) dated 01.02.2011 is
under the signature of the plaintiff as the lessor and the
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
defendant no.2 as the lessee. The authority of the
plaintiff to sign the agreement as the lessor is derived
from the sale deed dated 04.10.2010 (exhibit-P1). As
this court has held that the Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) the
constituted attorney of late Sonam Topgay Kazi did not
have the authority to execute the sale deed dated
04.10.2010 (exhibit-P1) with respect to the land which
was in possession of the defendant no.2 and the sale to
that extent in favour of the plaintiff was null and void,
necessarily the plaintiff did not have the authority to
execute the agreement dated 01.02.2011 (exhibit-P4) as
the owner of the said portion. The subsequently signed
undertaking dated
05.02.2011 (exhibit-P6) by the
defendants would also lose significance in view of the
findings on the admission made by Kalden Bhutia
(P.W.2) on the agreement dated 01.02.2011 (exhibit-P4).
23. The relief under the Specific Relief Act, 1963 is a
discretionary relief. In view of the clear admission made
by the plaintiff’s own witness Kalden Bhutia (P.W.2) as
the constituted attorney of late Sonam Topgay Kazi the
seller that he was not authorised to sell the portion of
land given to the defendant no.2, this relief cannot be
granted in favour of the plaintiff. Consequently, the
R.S.A. No. 09 of 2019
S. T. Gyaltsen. Vs. Kalu Tamang
declaration sought by the plaintiff that he was the
rightful owner of land in possession of the defendant
no.2 and entitled to recover the same from him cannot
be granted; the relief of specific performance of the
agreement
dated
01.02.2011
(exhibit-P4)
and
undertaking dated 05.02.2011 (exhibit-P6) also cannot
be granted; The decree for mandatory injunction against
the defendant no.2 directing him to demolish the
„kutcha‟ house and shift to plot no.222 cannot also be
granted; and the decree for recovery of possession of the
portion of the suit land in occupation and possession of
the defendant no.2 cannot also be granted to the
plaintiff. It is accordingly so ordered.
24. While thus agreeing with the conclusion arrived at
by the learned First Appellate Court viz-a-viz the
defendant no.2, this court is unable to agree with some
of the findings. The judgment of the learned First
Appellate Court accordingly stands modified to the
above extent. The appeal is dismissed and disposed of
accordingly. In the circumstances, no order as to costs.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
to/
Approved for reporting: yes
Internet: yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review