Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Reserved on:
26.12.2025
Pronounced on: 31.01.2026
Uploaded on:
31.01.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Arb P No. 72/2023
…. Petitioner(s)
S P Singla Constructions Pvt. Ltd.
Kothi No. 47, Sector-9,
Panchkula, Haryana-134113
Through its Authorized
Representative
Through:-
Mr. Siddarth Jain, Advocate.
(through Virtual Mode).
V/s
…..Respondent(s)
Jammu and Kashmir State Power
Development Corporation Ltd.
Ashok Nagar Satwari,
Jammu(J&K), Pin-18000
Through its Managing Director
Through:-
Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
CORAM : HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
JUDGMENT
1.
After the petitioner emerged as a successful bidder for allotment of
contract for “Investigation, Design and Construction of 178 m long
Steel Bridge over river Chenab.”, a letter of intent dated 26.03.2016
came to be issued in its favour, stipulating the period of completion of
works as 18 months. Thereafter, an agreement was also executed between
the parties on 14.05.2016 and in terms of the said contract, the work was
to be completed on 02.12.2017. It is stated by the petitioner that the
respondent was in continuous breach of its contractual obligations,
Arb P No. 72/2023
resulting into inordinate delay in the completion of the works. On account
of such delays, the project could not be completed within the stipulated
time period thereby causing tremendous loss to the petitioner. Between
2016 to 2023, multiple communications have been exchanged between
the parties, and it is alleged by the petitioner that the petitioner kept the
respondent informed about the various acts of breach committed by it
causing significant loss to the petitioner and right of the petitioner to
claim compensation for the same. Finally, the project was completed on
31.05.2019 and the defect liability period of three years “as stipulated
under clause 29 of the said contract” started running from 31.05.2019 and
concluded on 31.05.2022. Thereafter, the petitioner issued a letter dated
14.07.2023 to the respondent thereby consolidating its final amount/
claims against the respondent relying upon clauses 32 and 41 of the said
contract and requested the respondent to settle the same within 56 days of
the receipt of the letter in terms of clause 41 of the said contract. The total
amount as claimed by the petitioner is Rs. 18 crores, which is further
subject to applicable interest and other claims to be valued subsequently.
2.
The petitioner has made the claims under the following heads:
(i)
Release of withheld amount;
(ii)
Price Adjustment under clause 34.9.1 of the said Contract;
(iii)
Price Adjustment to cater to actual rise in the cost of construction,
being higher than price adjustment assessed under clause 26 of the
said Contract:
(iv)
Consideration to cater to time controlled costs incurred on account
of the delays caused by the respondent;
Arb P No. 72/2023
(v)
Consideration for extension of Performance Bank Guarantees
beyond intended time; and
(vi)
3.
Cost incurred for clearing land slides along with interest.
The petitioner notified the respondent that in the event of failure of
amicable settlement of the above-mentioned claims of the petitioner, the
same shall be referred to the arbitration. In the same communication, the
petitioner also notified the respondent that the delay in submission of the
final amount has been caused by the delay in discharge of performance of
bank guarantee by the respondent as the bank guarantee was discharged
only on 24.04.2023. For the respondent‟s failure in settling the claims of
the petitioner in terms of the letter dated 14.07.2023, the petitioner served
a notice dated 04.10.2023 upon the respondent for nominating the
arbitrator on its own behalf within 30 days from the date of receipt of the
said notice, so that both the nominee arbitrators may appoint the presiding
Arbitrator and the arbitration proceedings may be initiated at earliest. The
petitioner appointed Mr. A. M Choudhary, Former Chief Engineer, Punjab
Agriculture Marketing Board, as its nominee Arbitrator. As the
respondent failed to participate in the process of constituting the arbitral
Tribunal, thereby appointing its nominee Arbitrator, the petitioner filed
the petition under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act
for appointment of Arbitrator.
4.
Respondent has come up with the response stating therein that the
petitioner has not approached this Court with clean hands and has
suppressed the material facts while filing the present petition as the final
payment submitted by the petitioner was accepted and settled “as it is”
without raising any issue. This acceptance by the petitioner indicates clear
Arb P No. 72/2023
and unequivocal acknowledgement to the settlement of all claims and
payments thereby precluding any subsequent disputes or claims relating to
the same. It is further stated that no arbitration agreement exists in the
tender documents and the disputes raised by the petitioner are not
arbitrable. Having regard to the fact that the payment due to the petitioner
has already been settled and accepted by the petitioner, the petitioner
cannot now turn around and file the present petition for appointment of
arbitrator. It is also contended that this petition is hopelessly time-barred,
therefore, deserves dismissal. The respondent has admitted the execution
of contract dated 14.05.2016.
5.
It is further stated that the contentions made by the petitioner regarding
the continuous breach of contractual obligations by the respondent and
delay in execution of the project are grossly misconceived, false and
frivolous and no delay has been occasioned on the part of the respondent.
It is further stated that the original scheduled completion date under the
contract was 02.12.2017, however, the completion of work was delayed to
the combination of the factors including both the slow progress of the
contractor and certain other factors. As all the delays were not attributed
to the contractor, the same were duly addressed in accordance with the
contractual provisions by granting appropriate extension of time and
corresponding price adjustment, to ensure that the contractor is not
unfairly penalized for the delay beyond his control.
It is also the
contention of the respondent that it cannot be held responsible and
thrusted with liability on account of the delays in execution of the project,
which had purely and clearly occasioned due to the contractor‟s own slow
progress. Any loss suffered by the petitioner due to delays attributable to
Arb P No. 72/2023
the contractor is solely the responsibility of the contractor. The multiple
correspondences,
including
records
of
Review
Meetings,
were
consistently exchanged between the parties, documenting the slow
progress and various deficiencies on the part of the petitioner in achieving
the desired rate of progress and these communications, highlighting the
petitioner‟s failure to meet contractual obligations, have been duly
recorded by JKSPDC. The work was completed on 30.05.2019 and a
completion certificate was issued on 24.07.2019. The Defects Liability
Period (DLP) concluded on 31.05.2022 without any unresolved claim. It
is the positive stand of the respondent that no amount has been withheld
by JKSPDC, and the respondent has already paid the price adjustments as
admissible under the contract. The respondent has also given the factual
rebuttal to the claims projected by the petitioner which may not be
relevant to be extracted and considered by this Court at this stage.
6.
Supplementary Affidavit has also been filed by the respondent along with
Annexures, wherein the respondent has reiterated its contentions as raised
in the objections. The respondent has placed on record final payment
certificate, communications and undertaking furnished by the petitioner.
7.
Rejoinder has also been filed by the petitioner stating therein that
respondent without any justifiable reason failed to discharge the
performance bank guarantee of the petitioner, which came to be
discharged belatedly only on 24.04.2023. The petitioner has reiterated its
claims of Rs. 18,30,94,154.00/- under clause 41 of the contract, which
inter alia, include: (i) release of withheld amount; (ii) price adjustment for
materials; (iii) other time-controlled costs; (iv) unlawful extension of
Performance Bank Guarantee; (v) costs of clearing project site
Arb P No. 72/2023
impediments, and (vi) interest thereon. The petitioner has also relied upon
clause 34.61 of the contract which states that the contractor may claim
damages due and payable to it in accordance with the provisions of this
agreement. Precisely, it is the contention of the petitioner that the
objections sought to be raised by the respondent to object the appointment
of the Arbitrator cannot be considered at all by this Court, as it is settled
law that at the stage of section 11(6) of the Act, the limited scope of
inquiry of the referral Court is to determine the prima facie existence of
Arbitration agreement between the parties, and adjudication of the other
issues which are mixed questions of law and fact fall within the exclusive
domain of the arbitral Tribunal.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that in view of the
arbitration clause, in case of any disputes or differences relating to
interpretation and application of the provisions of the contract between the
parties, such disputes/differences are required to be settled amicably and
in case of failure, the same are required to be referred to arbitration. He
has vehemently submitted that the petitioner had issued the initial notice
to the respondent for settlement of disputes amicably and thereafter,
another notice for nominating the arbitrator was also served upon the
respondent but it did not yield any result. He has placed reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in “SBI General
Insurance Company Ltd. v. Krish Spinning, 2024 SCC Online SC 1754”
to submit that mere acceptance of amount by the petitioner would not
operate as a bar to invoke arbitration.
9.
Per contra, Ms. Monika Kohli, learned Sr. AAG appearing on behalf of
the respondent has submitted that as the petitioner has accepted the claim
Arb P No. 72/2023
as full and final settlement, the petitioner now cannot turn around and file
application for appointment of Arbitrator. She has placed reliance upon
the judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in “Union of India
& Ors. V. Master Construction Co. 2011 (12) SCC 349”.
10.
Heard and perused the record.
11.
A perusal of the record reveals that in terms of Clause 25 of the General
Conditions of the Contract, the arbitration shall be conducted in
accordance with the Arbitral Procedure as laid down in the Special
Conditions of the Contract. Further clause 3 of the “Special Conditions of
the Contract” is extracted as under:“3.1 In the event of any disputes or differences relating to the
interpretation and application of the provisions of the contract
between the parties, same shall be settled to the extent possible
amicably between the parties. In case, the parties are unable to
settle the disputes amicably then the matter shall be referred to the
Arbitration. The parties shall make efforts to agree on a sole
Arbitrator, only if such an attempt does not succeed, then each
party shall appoint one Arbitrator and third Arbitrator shall be
nominated by the said two Arbitrators.
3.2 The Arbitration shall be governed under the provisions of
J&K Arbitration and Condition Act 1997. The venue of the
Arbitration proceedings shall be in the state of Jammu &
Kashmir, and the language of the arbitration proceedings and that
of all documents and communications between the parties shall
be English.
3.3. The Arbitral Tribunal shall settle the disputes on the
following terms: (a) The Arbitral Tribunal shall pass a speaking
award with reference to each item of claim/dispute.
(b) The Tribunal shall not award pre-reference, pendentelite or
future interest on any claim award in favour of any party.
(c) The cost of Arbitral proceedings shall be equally shared by the
parties.
3.4 Notwithstanding the above, the parties shall continue to
perform their respective obligations during the Arbitration
proceedings.”
12.
Pursuant to the above clause, any dispute arising from the interpretation or
application of the contract must first be settled amicably. Should the
parties fail to reach an amicable settlement, the matter shall be referred to
Arb P No. 72/2023
arbitration. The parties shall first attempt to appoint a sole arbitrator;
failing agreement, each party may appoint one arbitrator, and those two
shall nominate a third to serve as the presiding arbitrator.
13.
The petitioner in terms of communication dated 14.07.2023 (Annexure V)
requested the respondent to settle the dispute amicably and when it
evoked no response, the petitioner vide notice dated 04.10.2023,
nominated Mr. A. N. Choudhary, Former Chief Engineer, Punjab
Agriculture Marketing Board, to act as an Arbitrator in terms of Special
Conditions of Contract (clause-3) and simultaneously requested the
respondent to appoint the Arbitrator within the period of 30 days from the
receipt of notice. The respondent has not disputed the issuance of the
communications dated 14.07.2023 and 04.10.2023 but has taken a positive
stand that once the petitioner has accepted the full and final payment and
has also furnished an undertaking whereby the petitioner has undertaken
that it will forego their claims on account of delay not attributable to the
contractor if JKSPDC grants extension of time upto 31.05.2019 for the
subject work, without imposition of any sort of liquidated damages, and
has accepted the payment as final settlement, the petitioner now cannot
turn around and raise a dispute with regard to the settlement of claims.
14.
Communication dated 20.06.2019, which bears the reference to
undertaking also contains the stipulation that this undertaking shall not
impact the contract provisions. Record demonstrates the existence of
Arbitration agreement between the parties and now the only question is
required to be examined whether the acceptance of the amount by the
petitioner and furnishing of undertaking would preclude the petitioner
from invoking the Arbitration mechanism under the contract or not.
Arb P No. 72/2023
15.
This is true that the petitioner had sworn an undertaking that it would
forego all its claims on account of delays not attributable to contractor, if
JKSPDC grants extension of time to M/s S. P. Singla Constructions Pvt.
Ltd. upto 31.05.2019 for completion of the above mentioned work and the
defect liability period came to expire on 31.05.2022, but the bank
guarantee
was
released
only
on
24.04.2023.
The
petitioner
notwithstanding the execution of undertaking, has also claimed damages
for delayed retention of the Bank guarantee.
16.
The petitioner has raised certain claims which are seriously opposed by
the respondent and I would not like to comment upon merits/demerits of
the claims of the parties as it would be within the sole domain of the
Arbitration Tribunal to adjudicate the same but prima facie it appears that
there are disputes between the parties which are required to be adjudicated
through arbitration.
17.
In the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent in
“Union of India &ors. V. Master Construction Co.”, it has been held that
issuance of full and final discharge voucher or „no dues certificate‟
amounts to discharge of contract by acceptance or performance and the
party issuing the discharge voucher cannot thereafter make any fresh
claim or revive any settled claim nor can it seek reference to arbitration in
respect of any claim.
However, in its latest pronouncement in “SBI
General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish Spinning”, the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court of India has observed as under:“114. In view of the observations made by this Court in In Re:
Interplay (supra), it is clear that the scope of enquiry at the stage
of appointment of arbitrator is limited to the scrutiny of prima
facie existence of the arbitration agreement, and nothing else. For
this reason, we find it difficult to hold that the observations
Arb P No. 72/2023
made in Vidya Drolia (supra) and adopted in NTPC v. SPML
(supra) that the jurisdiction of the referral court when
dealing with the issue of “accord and satisfaction” under
Section 11 extends to weeding out ex-facie non-arbitrable and
frivolous disputes would continue to apply despite the
subsequent decision in In Re: Interplay (supra).
115.The dispute pertaining to the “accord and satisfaction” of
claims is not one which attacks or questions the existence of the
arbitration agreement in any way. As held by us in the preceding
parts of this judgment, the arbitration agreement, being separate
and independent from the underlying substantive contract in
which it is contained, continues to remain in existence even after
the original contract stands discharged by “accord and
satisfaction.”
116.The question of “accord and satisfaction”, being a mixed
question of law and fact, comes within the exclusive jurisdiction
of the arbitral tribunal, if not otherwise agreed upon between the
parties. Thus, negative effect of competence- competence
would require that the matter falling within the exclusive
domain of the arbitral tribunal, should not be looked into by
the referral court, even for a prima facie determination,
before the arbitral tribunal first has had the opportunity of
looking into it.
117.By referring disputes to arbitration and appointing an
arbitrator by exercise of the powers under Section 11, the
referral court upholds and gives effect to the original
understanding of the contracting parties that the specified
disputes shall be resolved by arbitration. Mere appointment
of the arbitral tribunal does not in any way mean that the
referral court is diluting the sanctity of “accord and
satisfaction” or is allowing the claimant to walk back on its
contractual undertaking. On the contrary, it ensures that the
principal of arbitral autonomy is upheld and the legislative intent
of minimum judicial interference in arbitral proceedings is given
full effect. Once the arbitral tribunal is constituted, it is always
open for the defendant to raise the issue of “accord and
satisfaction” before it, and only after such an objection is rejected
by the arbitral tribunal, that the claims raised by the claimant can
be adjudicated.”
(emphasis added)
18.
In light of the above judgment of larger Bench (3 Judges), it can be safely
inferred that once the arbitral tribunal is constituted, it is always open for
the defendant to raise the issue of accord and satisfaction before tribunal
and only after such objection is rejected by arbitral tribunal, the claims
raised by the claimant can be adjudicated. In the instant case also, the
objection raised by the respondent is that once the undertaking has been
Arb P No. 72/2023
furnished and the payment has been accepted by the petitioner, the
petitioner cannot invoke arbitration. As per the mandate of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court of India in “SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish
Spinning (Supra)” the said issue can be conveniently adjudicated by the
learned Arbitral Tribunal.
19.
In view of the above, Arbitral Tribunal comprising of the following
members is hereby constituted:
I.
Mr. Justice Tashi Rabstan, Former Chief Justice of High Court of
Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh, residing at Plot No. 2, Lane No.
13, Tawi Vihar, Sidhra, Jammu -180019 as presiding Arbitrator;
II.
Mr. A. N. Choudhary, Former Chief Engineer, Punjab Agriculture
Marketing Board to act as Arbitrator; and
III.
Mr. Suneet Gupta, Retired District and Session Judge, residing at
Sarwal, Jammu to act as Arbitrator.
Registry to inform the above named Arbitrators about their
appointment as an Arbitrator in this matter.
20.
Needless to say that any observation made above is solely for the purpose
of adjudicating the application filed by the petitioner under Section 11 of
the Arbitration of Conciliation Act and shall have no bearing upon the
merits of the claims of the parties.
21.
The petition is, accordingly, disposed of.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
JAMMU
31.01.2026
NEHA-1
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
Neha Kumari
2026.01.31 13:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review