Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
DATED : 11th MARCH, 2020
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH :
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bail Appln. No.02 of 2020
Applicant/Accused
:
Rupa Gurung
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Petition under Section 439 read with Section
482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ppearance
Mr. K. T. Tamang, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Hissey Gyaltsen Bhutia and Ms. Mukun Dolma Tamang,
Assistant Public Prosecutors for the State-Respondent.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioner seeks enlargement on bail by filing
the instant application. Learned Counsel for the Petitioner
submits that she was arrested on 18-01-2020 in connection
with Singtam Police Station, East Sikkim, FIR No.03/2020,
dated 18-01-2020, under Section 7(a)(b) and 14 of the Sikkim
Anti Drugs Act, 2006 (for short, SADA, 2006) and under
Section 9(1)(b) of the Sikkim Anti Drugs (Amendment) Act,
2017, on allegations of selling controlled substances.
2.
Consequent upon the Complaint lodged against her
a house search was conducted by the Singtam Police, wherein
controlled substances, i.e., ―Spasmo-Proxyvon plus‖ capsules,
and ―Nitrosun 10‖ tablets, were recovered from her residence.
Bail Appln. No.02 of 2020
Rupa Gurung
vs. State of Sikkim
That, the controlled substances so recovered are not of
commercial quantity besides there being an anomaly in the
quantity reflected in the FIR and the Seizure Memo.
The
Petitioner has no criminal antecedents and her permanent
home is in Singtam, therefore the question of her attempting to
abscond or for that matter tamper with the Prosecution
evidence does not arise. That apart, her husband infact was
earlier
arrested
for
possession/consumption
of
controlled
substances but the Policy inquiry in the instant matter did not
extend to him.
That, she has several physical ailments such
hypertension and high uric acid levels, added to which her
daughter is on the family way for which her presence is
required.
The penalty prescribed is not with death or
imprisonment of life but rigorous imprisonment for two years,
which may extend to five years.
That, the Charge-Sheet has
not yet been filed despite a lapse of more than forty-five days
since
the
lodging
of
the
FIR.
Considering
the
above
circumstances, she may be enlarged on bail on any stringent
conditions.
3.
Per contra, Learned Assistant Public Prosecutor
objecting to the petition for bail submits that the substances
were recovered not only from the house of the accused when
she was present therein, but large quantities were also
recovered from her next door neighbour in the same building,
who is co-accused in the matter.
The said co-accused in the
instant matter is a habitual offender. That, the investigation is
being taken up expeditiously and the report of the controlled
Bail Appln. No.02 of 2020
Rupa Gurung
vs. State of Sikkim
samples sent for testing to the RFSL Saramsa, East Sikkim, are
awaited which is likely to be completed within a few days. On
submission of the RFSL Report, the Charge-Sheet shall be filed
immediately. In view of the nature of the offence, the matter
may not be considered leniently and the petition for bail
rejected.
4.
Counsel
I have heard the rival contentions of Learned
at
length
and
taken
into
consideration
their
submissions. I have also perused the documents placed before
this Court.
5.
The facts are not disputed.
The seizures of
controlled substances were made from the Petitioner’s house
allegedly kept for sale.
It needs no reiteration that there is
rampant abuse of controlled substances by people of all ages in
the State especially by the youth.
The law enforcement
agencies are embattled in their efforts to control the sale and
use of these substances which is spreading to gargantuan
proportions.
The abuse of the substances is primarily on
account of easy availability and sale by unconscionable persons,
at exorbitant prices who having found an easy way of earning
money by luring the young and indulge in its sans conscience.
Besides the victim, the unsuspecting family of the victim bears
the brunt of these sales and purchases which strike at the root
of a stable family and society.
In my considered opinion, no
misplaced sympathy ought to be extended to persons who
Bail Appln. No.02 of 2020
Rupa Gurung
vs. State of Sikkim
indulge in the sale and easy supply of controlled substances to
the impressionable youth.
6.
In this thread, useful reference may be made to the
observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
which while
considering grant of bail under the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (for short, NDPS Act) in
State of Kerala etc. vs. Rajesh etc.
involving the sale of Hashish
Oil was pleased to observe that under Section 37 of the NDPS
Act bail can be granted in case there are reasonable grounds
for believing that the accused is not guilty of such offence and
that he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Paragraph 18 of the Judgment supra
held as follows;
“18. The jurisdiction of the Court to grant
bail is circumscribed by the provisions of Section
37 of the NDPS Act. It can be granted in case
there are reasonable grounds for believing that
accused is not guilty of such offence, and that he
is not likely to commit any offence while on bail.
It is the mandate of the legislature which is
required to be followed. At this juncture, a
reference to Section 37 of the Act is apposite.
That provision makes the offences under the Act
cognizable and non-bailable. It reads thus:—
“37. Offences to be cognizable and nonbailable.—(1) Notwithstanding anything
contained in the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974),—
2020 SCC OnLine SC 81
(a)
every
offence
under this Act
cognizable;
punishable
shall be
(b)
no person accused of an
offence
punishable
for
[offences under section 19 or
section 24 or section 27A and
also for offences involving
commercial quantity] shall be
released on bail or on his own
bond unless—
Bail Appln. No.02 of 2020
Rupa Gurung
vs. State of Sikkim
(i)
the Public Prosecutor
has been given an
opportunity to oppose
the application for such
release, and
(ii)
where
the
Public
Prosecutor opposes the
application, the court is
satisfied that there are
reasonable grounds for
believing that he is not
guilty of such offence
and that he is not likely
to commit any offence
while on bail.
(2) The limitations on granting of bail
specified in clause (b) of sub-section (1)
are in addition to the limitations under the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of
1974), or any other law for the time being
in force on granting of bail.‖
(emphasis supplied)”
In Paragraph 20, it was further observed as follows;
“20. The scheme of Section 37 reveals that
the exercise of power to grant bail is not only
subject to the limitations contained under
Section 439 of the CrPC, but is also subject to the
limitation placed by Section 37 which commences
with non-obstante clause. The operative part of
the said section is in the negative form
prescribing the enlargement of bail to any person
accused of commission of an offence under the
Act, unless twin conditions are satisfied. The first
condition is that the prosecution must be given an
opportunity to oppose the application; and the
second, is that the Court must be satisfied that
there are reasonable grounds for believing that
he is not guilty of such offence. If either of these
two conditions is not satisfied, the ban for
granting bail operates.
[emphasis supplied]”
In Paragraph 21, it was held thus;
“21. The expression “reasonable grounds”
means something more than prima facie grounds.
It contemplates substantial probable causes for
believing that the accused is not guilty of the
alleged
offence.
The
reasonable
belief
contemplated in the provision requires existence
of such facts and circumstances as are sufficient
in themselves to justify satisfaction that the
accused is not guilty of the alleged offence. In the
case on hand, the High Court seems to have
completely overlooked the underlying object of
Section 37 that in addition to the limitations
provided under the CrPC, or any other law for the
Bail Appln. No.02 of 2020
Rupa Gurung
vs. State of Sikkim
time being in force, regulating the grant of bail,
its liberal approach in the matter of bail under the
NDPS Act is indeed uncalled for.”
7.
In Union of India vs. Ram Samujh and Another2 it was
held as follows;
“7. It is to be borne in mind that the
aforesaid legislative mandate is required to be
adhered to and followed. It should be borne in
mind that in a murder case, the accused commits
murder of one or two persons, while those
persons who are dealing in narcotic drugs are
instrumental in causing death or in inflicting
death-blow to a number of innocent young
victims, who are vulnerable; it causes deleterious
effects and a deadly impact on the society; they
are a hazard to the society; even if they are
released temporarily, in all probability, they
would continue their nefarious activities of
trafficking
and/or
dealing
in
intoxicants
clandestinely. Reason may be large stake and
illegal profit involved. ...................
8.
To check the menace of dangerous
drugs flooding the market, Parliament has
provided that the person accused of offences
under the NDPS Act should not be released on bail
during trial unless the mandatory conditions
provided in Section 37, namely,
(i)
there are reasonable grounds for
believing that the accused is not
guilty of such offence; and
(ii)
that he is not likely to commit any
offence while on bail
are satisfied. The High Court has not given any
justifiable reason for not abiding by the aforesaid
mandate while ordering the release of the
respondent-accused on bail. Instead of attempting
to take a holistic view of the harmful socioeconomic consequences and health hazards which
would accompany trafficking illegally in dangerous
drugs, the court should implement the law in the
spirit
with
which
Parliament,
after
due
deliberation, has amended.
[emphasis supplied]”
8.
On the bedrock of the ratiocination supra, it is
apposite to refer to the relevant provision of the SADA, 2006,
viz., Section 18. Section 37 of the NDPS Act is embodied in
Section 18(2) of the SADA, 2006, which reads as follows;
(1999) 9 SCC 429
Bail Appln. No.02 of 2020
Rupa Gurung
“18.
vs. State of Sikkim
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 –
(a) every offence punishable under this Act
shall be cognizable;
(b) no person accused of an offence
punishable under this Act shall be released
on bail or on his own bond unless –
(i) the Public Prosecutor has been heard
and also given an opportunity to oppose
the application for such release, and
(ii) where the Public Prosecutor opposes
the application, the court is satisfied that
there are reasonable grounds for believing
that he is not guilty of such offence and
that he is not likely to commit any offence
while on bail.
(2) The limitations on granting of bail
specified in clause (b) of sub-section (1)
are in addition to the limitations under the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 or any
other law for the time being in force on
granting of bail.
[emphasis supplied]”
It is clear that Section 18 of the SADA, 2006 lays down
the exact same requisites as Section 37 of the NDPS Act while
considering a petition for bail.
9.
After giving due consideration to the facts and
circumstances in the instant case despite the urging of Learned
Counsel for the Petitioner that she is 47 years old, a
grandmother who has no criminal antecedents, I find that
should this Court be inclined to grant bail for the offence, in all
likelihood she will revert back to the activities she was indulging
in vis-à-vis the controlled substances.
The act of selling
controlled substances for monetary profits without looking into
deleterious effects it has on the health of the victim has to
stringently be discouraged.
It is reiterated that such persons
strike at the very future of our society since most of the
consumers are the youth who are yet to have their feet on
terra-firma or to understand the consequences of the choices
Bail Appln. No.02 of 2020
Rupa Gurung
vs. State of Sikkim
that they are making and its long term effects besides throwing
away their future.
In consideration of the provisions of the
Statute there is no guarantee that the Petitioner will not repeat
the offence while on bail and for the present purposes there is
no reason to disbelieve the Prosecution case.
Although I
hasten to add that this is a prima facie observation and will
have no bearing on the merits of the case, which includes the
evidence furnished by the Prosecution to establish its case.
10.
Consequently,
the
application
for
bail
stands
rejected.
However, the Investigating Officer shall file the
Charge-Sheet within the mandated period of limitation and the
Learned Trial court shall take not more than eight months
thereafter to dispose of the instant matter.
11.
Let the Superintendent of Police (Jails) ensure that
the blood pressure of the accused is measured on a daily basis
at the Clinic in the Jail. That, a blood sample of the accused,
subject to her consent, be drawn for checking her uric acid
levels.
That Doctor concerned shall take necessary steps
accordingly.
12.
The Bail Appln. stands disposed of.
13.
Copy of this Order be made available to all the
Special Judges (Sikkim Anti Drugs Act, 2006) for information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
11-03-2020
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review