The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. Having considered the pleadings and materials on record and the submissions made at the bar, we find no sufficient ground to interfere with the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge. In the result, the writ appeal stands dismissed. Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE DSV/-
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
2025:KER:24700
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 11.02.2022 IN WP(C) NO.26307
OF 2019 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
RUGHMANI (RETIRED CLERK),
AGED 72 YEARS,
W/O.SETHUMADHAVAN, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT CO-OPERATIVE
PRINTING PRESS LTD NO. E-119, ERNAKULAM, RESIDING AT
KUNNATH HOUSE, EROOR, TRIPUNITHURA, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT,
PIN - 682306.
BY ADVS.
N.V.VINAY
ARUN P. ANTONY
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
KERALA STATE CO-OPERATIVE EMPLOYEE PENSION BOARD,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, KALA NIVAS, P.B NO. 85,
CHINMAYA LANE, KUNNUMPURAM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
PIN - 695001.
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
2025:KER:24700
THE SECRETARY,
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT CO-OPERATIVE PRINTING PRESS LTD.
NO.E-119, MILLS LANE, CHURCH LANDING ROAD, ERNAKULAM
DISTRICT, PIN - 682016.
BY ADVS.
M.SASINDRAN, SC, KERALA STATE COOPERATIVE
K.S.ARUN KUMAR
EMPLOYEES PENSION BOARD
ARYA B. VENUGOPAL
VIJAY SANKAR V.H.
JERIN JOSEPH
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
04.03.2025, THE COURT ON 24.03.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
2025:KER:24700
JUDGMENT
Muralee Krishna, J.
The petitioner in W.P.(C) No.26307 of 2019 filed this writ
appeal under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958,
being dissatisfied by the judgment dated 11.02.2022 passed by
the learned Single Judge, whereby the writ petition filed by the
appellant under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking a
writ of mandamus commanding the 2nd respondent the Secretary
Ernakulam District Co-operative Printing Press Ltd. to remit the
pension contribution to the pension fund of the 1st respondent the
Kerala State Co-operative Employees Pension Board and also a
writ of mandamus commanding the 1st respondent to sanction the
monthly pension to the appellant and disburse the same with
arrears within a time limit, was dismissed.
2.
The appellant who was an employee of the 2nd
respondent Society retired from service on 31.12.2006. She
worked in the Society from 10.08.1973. According to her, she
received retirement benefits in installments from 2010 to 2019,
but has not received any amount towards pension. She pleads that
the 2nd respondent has not made any contribution towards the
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
2025:KER:24700
pension fund in respect of the appellant though the 1st respondent
directed the 2nd respondent to remit the employer’s contribution
towards
the
pension
scheme.
She
alleges
that
Ext.P2
representation submitted by her has not been responded to by the
2nd respondent. Having considered the rival contentions raised by
the parties, the learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition
holding that the appellant had not disclosed the entire facts while
approaching the Court with the writ petition.
3.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellants, the
learned Standing Counsel for the 1st respondent and the learned
counsel for the 2nd respondent.
4.
The learned counsel for the appellant submitted the
appellant retired from the service in the year 2006 and as per
Ext.R2(a) letter dated 08.05.2017, the Assistant Registrar of Cooperative Societies directed the president of the employer of the
appellant to remit employer’s contribution to the 1st respondent
Board. In Ext.R2(b) writ petition also the appellant has alleged
inaction on the part of the 2nd respondent in paying Rs.66,410/being the portion of the pensionary benefits due to the appellant.
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
2025:KER:24700
The 2nd respondent has to pay the employer’s contribution to the
1st respondent so as to facilitate the 1st respondent to pay pension
to the appellant as per the pension scheme.
5.
The learned counsel for the 1st respondent board
submitted that the employer’s contribution toward the pension
fund was not paid by the 2nd respondent and only if the payment
is made, the board can pay pension to the appellant. The learned
counsel for the 2nd respondent argued that all the amounts due to
the appellant were paid by the bank. Even the employer's
contribution was received by the appellant and she did not refund
the portion of the employer's contribution and she approached this
Court with a false claim. After the disposal of W.P.(C) No.7141 of
2019, the portion of the amount stated as due in that writ petition
was also paid to the appellant.
6.
In the writ petition, the appellant claimed that she had
not received any money towards her pension. According to her,
the 2nd respondent has not remitted the employer's contribution
towards the pension scheme. However, in the counter affidavit
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
2025:KER:24700
filed by the 2nd respondent, this contention of the appellant was
denied. Paragraphs 5 to 7 of that counter affidavit read thus:
“5. The averments in paragraph 1 of the writ petition are
incorrect and hence denied. The petitioner has agreed that
she has received her entire dues including all retirement
benefits of Rs.2,93,410/- as final settlement and she has
received the said amounts, except Rs.66410/. The said
amount of Rs.66410/- was ready with this respondent and
the petitioner did not bother to collect the same from the
respondent society. The said amount of Rs.66410/- was
later collected by her on 04.07.2009 by cheque and thus
the entire due amount was duly paid to her. That an
employee, who has received the contributory provident
fund shall be eligible for pension only on the refund of that
portion of the employers contribution in the contributory
provident fund together with interest thereon to the pension
fund before applying for pension. The petitioner has not
refunded employers contribution with interest or not even
applied for pension. The length of services as stated by the
petitioner is not correct. The allegations contrary to the
same in the petition and her affidavit are absolutely false.
6. The averments in paragraphs 3 & 4 of the writ petition
are incorrect and hence denied. The petitioner did not pay
any contribution to the pension scheme. The petitioner has
received a total amount of Rs.2,93,410/- as retirement
benefits. Out of this an amount of Rs.46,061/- received as
provident
fund,
Rs.36,950/-
as
terminal
surrender,
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
Rs.50,535/-
as
subsistence
2025:KER:24700
allowance,
Rs.90,097/-
Retrenchment allowance, and Rs.69767/- as gratuity. The
petitioner is not entitled to get any pension contribution.
The second respondent has duly issued reply to the first
respondent stating that the petitioner is not entitled any
other pension benefits. The answering respondent is not
withholding any payment. The answering respondent is in
fact in very serious financial problems and not able to pay
salary to the present employees.
7. The petitioner in this case knowingly suppressed the
material facts from this Hon'ble Court and approached this
Hon'ble Court with most unclean hands to abuse the
process of law to wreak vengeance on the second
respondent, who had not conceded to illegal demands. The
petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.7141 of 2019 and Contempt
case No.1168 of 19 for pension and retirement benefits.
Again filing this writ petition by the petitioner is an abuse of
process and the petitioner is not entitled any reliefs.”
7.
Section 18 (1) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies
Employees Self Financing Pension Scheme, 1994 which was
extracted in the statement filed by the learned Standing Counsel
for the 1st respondent as well as in the impugned judgment passed
by the learned Single Judge, reads thus:
“18. Eligibility for Pension:-- (1) Every employee of a
society to which this Scheme applies shall, subject to the
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
2025:KER:24700
other provisions of the Scheme, be eligible for pension
under this Scheme;
Provided
that
an
employee,
who
has
received
the
contributory Provident Fund shall be eligible for pension
only on the refund of that portion of the employers'
contribution in the Contributory Provident Fund together
with interest thereon to the Pension Fund before applying
for pension.
xxx
8.
xxx
xxx"
As found by the learned Single Judge, as per the
Proviso to Section 18(1) of the Scheme, an employee, who has
received the contributory Provident Fund shall be eligible for
pension only on the refund of that portion of the employers’
contribution in the Contributory Provident Fund together with
interest thereon to the Pension Fund before applying for pension.
9.
The appellant has received various amounts towards
her retirement benefits as stated in the counter affidavit filed by
the 2nd respondent which is not disputed by her by filing any reply
affidavit. The receipt of Rs.66,410/- by the appellant after the
disposal of her previous writ petition and contempt case filed by
her is not disclosed in the writ petition. Since she failed to comply
with the stipulation in Section 18 of the Scheme, the learned
WA NO. 54 OF 2023
2025:KER:24700
Single Judge rightly found that she is not entitled for the relief
sought in the writ petition.
10. Having considered the pleadings and materials on record
and the submissions made at the bar, we find no sufficient ground
to interfere with the impugned judgment of the learned Single
Judge.
In the result, the writ appeal stands dismissed.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
DSV/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review