Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Miss Ruby Soram, aged about 20years, D/O (Late) Soram
Indubala Devi, resident of Uripok Sorbon Thingel, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus 1.
2.
4.
5.
6.
The
State
of
Manipur
represented
by
the
Commissioner/Secretary/Add. Secretary (Labour & Emp.)
Government of Manipur.
The Accountant General (A & E) Manipur.
The Director, Directorate of Employment, Government of
Manipur.
The Joint Secretary (Pension Cell), Government of Manipur.
The Additional Director, Directorate of Employment Exchange,
Lamphelpat, Manipur, Imphal.
........Respondent/s
Smt. Lairenmayum Ningol Akoijam Ongbi Roma Devi, aged
about 41 years, W/O Akoijam Kiran Singh, resident of
Kwakeithel Lonjeng Leikai, P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West
District, Manipur.
......impleaded as R-6 vide
order
dated
21.09.2016
pased in MC(WP(C) NO. 198
of 2016.
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners
::
Mr. K. Roshan, Adv.
For the respondents
::
Mr. Th. Sukumar, G.A. & Mr. S.
Suresh, Adv.
Date of Hearing
::
02.08.2024/17.12.2024
Date of Judgment and Order
::
27.12.2024
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 1
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. K. Roshan, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr.
Th. Sukumar, learned G.A. for the State respondent and Mr. S. Suresh,
learned counsel for respondent No. 2. None appeared on behalf of the
respondent No.6 at the time of hearing after filing of counter affidavit.
[2]
The brief fact of the case is that the petitioner is the daughter
of Shri Soram Ranjit Singh and Soram Ongbi Surnalata Devi both resident
of Uripok Sorbon Thingel, Imphal West District. The petitioner’s adopted
mother, namely, late Soram Indubala Devi, the elder sister of Shri Soram
Ranjit Singh was unmarried and she died as a spinster. Further, Soram
Indubala Devi was physically handicap, suffering from “SLE affecting her
whole body with Bil-THL” affecting mobility and stability. During the lifetime
of late Smt. Soram Indubala Devi, she worked as Technical Assistant, in the
Directorate of Employment, Lamphelpat, Imphal and she had never entered
into wedlock with anybody and as such, being handicap and having no one
to look after her, she adopted the present petitioner by performing adoption
ceremony according to the Hindu Meitei customary rites and rituals on
03.03.2007 in the presence of Sagei (Clan) elderly members and relatives
validating adoption. Since the adoption of the petitioner was not disputed,
late Soram Indubala Devi, in compliance of the requirements of law,
registered the adoption in the year 2012 vide Deed of Adoption dated
12.09.2012 in the office of the Sub-Registrar (HQ), Imphal, Manipur. The
petitioner has become the daughter of late Soram Indubala Devi for all intent
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 2
and purposes by the execution of the adoption on 03.03.2007 and the Deed
of adoption dated 12.09.2012 and the adoption of the petitioner has been
intimated to the authorities concerned by submitting Form No. 3 as per the
requirements of Rule 54 (12) (ii) of the Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 1972.
[3]
Due to physical conditions, the petitioner’s mother i.e. Soram
Indubala Devi sought voluntary retirement and the Department concerned
consented to her request for voluntary retirement and she was allowed to
retired voluntarily vide order dated 28.09.2012 with effect from 30.09.2012.
Vide letter dated 02.02.2013, the petitioner’s adoptive mother submitted her
pension papers to the authorities concerned alongwith the required
documents including Form No. 3 intimating the authorities the petitioner as
her daughter and on the basis of the submission of the pension papers,
process of pension was intimated. The petitioner’s name was shown in Form
No. 3 submitted for the purpose of the pension as daughter. During the
process, Ms. S. Indubala died unfortunately on 06.02.2013 and the Registrar
Birth & Death, Imphal Municipal Council issued Death Certificate dated
18.02.2013 to that effect and after the expiry of the petitioner’s mother, she
approached the respondents for payment of the family pension of her late
mother’s service. However, the petitioner came to know of a Letter dated
23.05.2013 communicated by the Accountants Officer to the Addl. Director,
Directorate of Employment Exchange, Lamphel, Imphal demanding for
certain documents to be furnished.
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 3
[4]
Subsequent to and in consequence of the letter dated
23.05.2013, another letter dated 21.10.2013 was communicated to the
Additional Director of Employment, the Head of Office requesting inter-alia
for taking actions to authorise pension/gratuity. However, till date no actions
have been taken for paying the pension of late Soram Indubala to the
petitioner. As such, the petitioner approached this Court by way of the
present writ petition.
[5]
Respondent Nos. 1, 3 & 5 have filed counter affidavit stating
that as per the letter of the Sr. Accounts Officer (Pension) Office of the
Accountant General (A & E), Manipur, it is intimated that adoption took place
on 03.03.2007 and if the present petitioner deemed to be the child of Ms.
Soram Indubala Devi for all purpose with effect from the date of adoption,
the name of the her adoptive mother in HSLC certificate should be Soram
Indubala Devi (adoptive mother). However, there was no name of the
adoptive mother in the HSLC certificate except those of real parents name
i.e. Shri S. Ranjit Singh and S (O) Surnalata Devi. It is also stated that there
is no official record prior to 11.12.2012 which is the date of preparation of
pension papers stating Ms. Ruby Soram was adopted by (Late) Ms. Soram
Indubala Devi, Ex-Technical Assistant in the Directorate and as such, there
is no question of payment of family pension to the petitioner. It is further
stated that Form No. 3 was submitted at the time of pension preparation.
However, controversy arose only when another claimant Smt. AK. (O)
Lairenmayum Roma Devi came to know that she is the only daughter of late
Ms. Indubala Devi. It is also stated that the HSLC certificate of the petitioner
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 4
was issued in the year 2012, the adoptive mother’s name was not there in
spite of adoption ceremony performed on 03.03.2007 and as such, the
adoption was not effective till the issue of HSLC certificate.
[6]
Respondent No. 6 also filed counter affidavit wherein it is stated
that
the two certificates dated 21.02.2008 and 12.06.2013 annexed at
Annexures – A/1 & A/2 in the writ petition have all been fabricated and
Annexure – A/2 regarding unmarried status of late Soram Indubala Devi is
unacceptable and not authentic for want of authority on the part of the SDC
to issue any such certificate. It is stated that respondent No. 6 i.e. Roma Devi
is the only natural daughter of L. Surendro Singh and (late) Soram Indubala
Devi. It is stated that as on the date of execution and registration of the deed
of adoption dated 14.09.2012, the age of the petitioner i.e. Ruby Soram was
16 years and 8 months as the date of her birth recorded in the said HSLC
Examination, 2012 i.e. 10.01.1996. Under Section 10(iv) of the said Hindu
Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956, the age of the adoptee child (present
petitioner) should have been below 15 years.
[7]
Respondent No. 2 filed counter affidavit stating on 11.02.2013,
the office of the Accountant General (the respondent No. 2) received pension
papers and application for commutation of S. Indubala Devi together with a
copy of Adoption Deed and other related documents furnished by the
Department of Personnel (Pension Cell), Government of Manipur vide letter
dated 07.02.2013 and on scrutiny of pension papers and Service Book, the
name of the present petitioner (Ruby Soram) was found recorded in Form-3
(List of family members) as adopted daughter, supported by Adoption Deed
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 5
dated 12.09.2012. However, one A.K. (O) Roma Devi submitted an
application to the Additional Director of Employment, Government of
Manipur requesting not to give any financial benefit to any other person
without her knowledge by stating therein that she is the only daughter of
(late) Soram Indubala Devi. Vide letter dated 23.05.2013, the respondent
No. 2 requested the Additional Director, Directorate of Employment to furnish
certain documents/clarification so as to enable the office of the respondent
No.2 to finalise the matter and in response thereof, the Additional Director of
Employment, Government of Manipur, vide letter dated 31.08.2013
furnished the documents sought for including an affidavit duly signed by one
Shri L. Surendro Singh declaring that S. Indubala Devi was his wife and in
the said affidavit, Shri L. Surendro Singh also stated that A.K (O) Roma Devi
was the daughter of S. Indubala Devi. Vide letter dated 21.10.2013,
respondent No. 2 sought for further clarification from the Additional Director,
Directorate of Employment however no convincing reply is received till date.
[8]
Mr. K. Roshan, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
there is a presumption of validity for registered adoption deed under Section
16 of HAMA, unless it is disproved in a legal proceeding before a competent
court. It is pointed out that mere failure to record the name of the adoptive
parents in the school certificate will not automatically invalidate a duly
registered adoption deed. Learned counsel draws the attention of this Court
to a suit for declaration filed by the respondent No.6 herein before the Family
Court, Manipur being Mat.(Decl.) Suit No. 16 of 2017, inter-alia, praying for
declaring her as the biological daughter of late S. Indubala Devi and for
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 6
cancellation of the Adoption Deed dated 12.09.2012 in favour of the
petitioner herein. Prior to the suit filed by the respondent No.6, the petitioner
herein also filed a suit being Mat.(Decl.) No. 92 of 2013 to declare her as the
adopted daughter of late S. Indubala and the respondent No.6 also filed a
counter claim that she was the natural daughter of late S. Indubala. It is
pointed out that vide common order dated 02.11.2015, both the suit and
counter claim were disposed of as not pressed without any liberty to file fresh
ones. In order dated 29.05.2023 passed by a Division Bench of this Court in
Mat. App. Case No. 2 of 2019, titled as Ms. Ruby Soram v. Smt. L. Roma
Devi: MANU/MN/0112/2023, the whole proceeding of Mat.(Decl.) Suit No.
16 of 2019 filed by the respondent No.6 herein was closed as barred by the
provisions of Order 23 Rule 1 Sub-Rules (3) & (4) of CPC, as no liberty to
filed fresh suit was granted when similar suits were withdrawn. Mr. K.
Roshan, learned counsel for the petitioner also relies on the decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ram Shridhar Chimukar v. Union
of India: (2023) 4 SCC 312 to the point that benefit of family pension is
restricted only to the child legally adopted by the government employee
during his/her lifetime. It is urged that the petitioner herein was adopted by
the deceased government employee during her life time. It is prayed that the
respondents be directed to release family pension of late S. Indubala in
favour of the petitioner as per the provisions of Rule 54 of the Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 and in terms of intimation dated 02.02.2013
submitted by the Addl. Director, Employment Exchange, Manipur to the Joint
Secretary (Pension), Govt. of Manipur nominating the petitioner as nominee.
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 7
[9]
Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned GA has pointed out that the petitioner
did not use the name of her adoptive mother in the matriculation certificate
and names of the biological parents were shown in the certificate even after
execution of the alleged adoption. This issue has been raised by the office
of the Principal Accountant General, Manipur vide letters dated 23.05.2013
and 21.10.2013 addressed to the Administrative Department. It is submitted
that since the presumption under Section 16 of HAMA is rebuttable, nonrecording of name of adoptive mother in the school certificate will raise a
grave suspicion, when the respondent No.6 has also claimed to be natural
daughter of the deceased government employee. It is clarified that the
petitioner is not entitled to the family pension as prayed for.
[10]
Mr. S. Suresh, learned counsel for the Principal Accountant
General, Manipur has pointed out that vide letters dated 23.05.2013 and
21.10.2013, clarification was called from the Administrative Department. Till
the same is clarified, the office of AG will not be able to do needful for the
release of family pension of late S. Indubala in favour of the petitioner.
[11]
In the counter affidavit of the respondent No.6, it is stated that
she is the daughter of late S. Indubala and her neighbour L. Surendro, born
outside wedlock and denied that the petitioner was the adopted daughter.
The alleged adoption was done when the petitioner was 16 years and 8
months in violation of Section 10(iv) of HAMA and the same is not valid.
[12]
It is a settled proposition law that a registered adoption deed
shall be presumed to be valid unless disproved in a legal proceeding. In the
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 8
case of Jai Singh vs. Shakuntala: MANU/SC/0187/2002: (2002) 3 SCC
634, Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the statutory presumption of validity
of a registered adoption deed under Section 16 of the Hindu Adoption and
Maintenance Act, 1956 and held that such presumption is rebuttable in a
legal proceeding before a competent court. Para 1 and 2 are reproduced for
clarity.
“1. The matter under consideration pertains to the effect of statutory
presumption as envisaged under Section 16 of the Hindu Adoption and
Maintenance Act, 1956. For convenience sake, it would be worthwhile to
note the provision for its true purport. Section 16 reads as below:
"16. Presumption as to registered documents relating to adoption. Whenever any document registered under any law for the time being
in force is produced before any Court purporting to record an
adoption made and is signed by the person giving and the person
taking the child in adoption, the Court shall presume that the adoption
has been made in compliance with the provisions of this Act unless
and until it is disproved."
2. The Section thus envisages a statutory presumption that in the event of
there being a registered document pertaining to adoption there would be a
presumption that adoption has been made in accordance with law.
Mandate of the Statute is rather definite since the Legislature has used
"shall" instead of any other word of lesser significance. Incidentally,
however the inclusion of the words "unless and until it is disproved"
appearing at the end of the statutory provision has made the situation not
that rigid but flexible enough to depend upon the evidence available on
record in support of adoption. It is a matter of grave significance by reason
of the factum of adoption and displacement of the person adopted from the
natural succession - thus onus of proof is rather heavy. Statute has allowed
some amount of flexibility, lest it turns out to be solely dependent on a
registered adoption deed. The reason for inclusion of the words "unless
and until it is disproved" shall have to be ascertained in its proper
perspective and as such the presumption cannot but be said to be a
rebuttable presumption. Statutory intent thus stands out to be rather
expressive depicting therein that the presumption cannot be an irrebuttable
presumption by reason of the inclusion of the words just noticed above. On
the wake of the aforesaid the observations of the learned single Judge in
Modan Singh v. Sham Kaur and Ors. MANU/PH/0171/1973 stands
confirmed and we record our concurrence therewith.”
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 9
[12]
In a recent case, Hon’ble Supreme Court has examined the
presumption of validity of a registered adoption deed under Section 16 of
HAMA in the case of Moturu Nalini Kanth vs. Gainedi Kaliprasad (Dead)
through L.Rs.: MANU/SC/1240/2023. Para 45 is reproduced below.
“45. In Dhanno wd/o. Balbir Singh v. Tuhi Ram (Died) represented by his
LRs. MANU/PH/0035/1996 : AIR 1996 P & H 203, a learned Judge of the
Punjab & Haryana High Court, faced with the argument that Section 16 of
the Act of 1956 required a registered adoption deed to be believed, held
that the presumption thereunder, if any, is rebuttable and by merely placing
the document on record without proving the ceremony of due adoption, it
could not be said that there was a valid adoption. The learned Judge rightly
noted that the factum of adoption must be proved in the same way as any
other fact and such evidence in support of the adoption must be sufficient
to satisfy the heavy burden that rests upon any person who seeks to
displace the natural succession by alleging an adoption.”
[13]
The necessary corollary of the above decisions is that the
statutory presumption of a valid registered adoption deed under Section 16
HAMA is rebuttable, until disproved in a legal proceeding before a competent
court. This Court is of the view that mere failure to record names of adoptive
parents in the matriculation certificate will not, ipso facto, render the adoption
as invalid without any proper adjudication. It may also be clarified that the
writ court is not a competent jurisdiction to examine the validity of a
registered adoption deed even when this issue arises as a collateral point.
As held by this Court in a previous case of Ruby Soram (supra) about the
adoption of the petitioner herein, the suit for declaration filed by the
respondent No.6 herein challenging the adoption of the petitioner was closed
as not maintainable. It is admitted fact that no court has till date declared the
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 10
adoption of the petitioner as invalid. The presumption under Section 16 of
HAMA will still operate and mere failure to record name of the adoptive
parents in the matriculation certificate cannot be consider as a rebuttal
specially when no court of competent jurisdiction has declared the adoption
as invalid. Rather, the suit for declaring the adoption of the petitioner as filed
by the respondent No.6 was closed by this Court as barred by law in the
case of Ruby Soram (supra).
[14]
In view of the above factual positions and settled proposition of
law, the petitioner is deemed to be adoptive daughter of late S. Indubala, as
no court has declared the adoption as invalid. Accordingly, she is entitled to
receive family pension as prayed for. The Administrative Department is
directed to forward the necessary documents for preparation of the family
pension of late Indubala in favour of her adopted daughter Ms. Ruby Soram
to the office of Principal Accountant General Manipur, within a period of one
month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and on receipt of the
necessary papers, the office of Principal Accountant General, Manipur shall
issue family pension authority within further period of one month.
[15]
With the above observations and directions, the writ petition is
allowed. No cost. Send a copy of this order to the respondent Nos. 1 & 2 for
doing needful.
signed
RAJKUMA Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
R PRIYOJIT PRIYOJIT SINGH
Date: 2024.12.27
SINGH
13:51:34 +05'30'
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Kh. Joshua Maring
WP(C) No. 315 of 2016
Page 11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review