Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No. 913/2024
Reserved on:
31.07.2026
Pronounced on: 05.08.2026
Uploaded on:
05.08.2026
Operative part or full judgment : Full
Romesh Chander Anand
S/O Late Babu Ram Anand
R/O House No. 218, Adarsh Enclave
Lane No. 02, Sector-1, Ext.
Trikuta Nagar, Jammu.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Ajay Gandotra, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Yogeshwar Singh, Adv.
Vs.
1. UT of J&K through SHO,
Police Station, Kathua
District Kathua.
2. Arvind Kumar Gupta,
S/O Late M.L. Gupta,
R/O Ward No. 01, Jawahar Nagar,
Kathua District Kathua.
…Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioner in terms
of Section 528 of the BNSS, 2023, seeking quashment of FIR
No. 346 of 2022 dated 05.09.2022 registered at Police
Station, Kathua for offences punishable under Sections 451,
504 and 506 of IPC, alleging his false implication.
2.
It is pleaded in the petition that the petitioner has been
falsely implicated by the respondent No. 2/complainant and
CRM(M) No.913/2024
the incident is motivated to involve the petitioner into
unnecessary and uncalled for litigation just, to harass the
petitioner in order to wreck vengeance; that the impugned
FIR is an act of counter blast as against criminal act
committed by respondent No. 2 who has illegally and
wrongfully encroached upon the land of the petitioner, as a
consequence whereof a case vide FIR No. 382/2014 under
Sections 447, 427 RPC on 02.11.2014 came to be registered
against the respondent No. 2/complainant in Police Station,
Kathua; that the respondent No. 2/complainant thereafter
filed petition for seeking quashment of the aforesaid FIR
which was dismissed by this Court; that as a counterblast,
another case vide FIR No. 358/2014 was got registered
against the petitioner and two others, namely, Khajan Singh
and Sat Pal, which was challenged by the petitioner along
with two others in this Court by way of filing CRMC No.
573/2015 which was allowed and the said FIR stood
quashed with the direction to the Police Station, Kathua to
conclude the investigation with respect to FIR No. 382/2014
dated 02.11.2014 registered against the respondent No.
2/complainant.
3.
It is further pleaded in the petition that despite the direction
of this Court, the then SHO, Police Station, Kathua did not
proceed with the investigation of FIR No. 382/2014; that the
petitioner and other owners of conjoint plots approached the
CRM(M) No.913/2024
revenue officials including Deputy Commissioner, Kathua for
demarcation of the land comprised under Khasra No. 230 as
against the land of respondent No. 2, falling under khasra
No. 2301 in respect whereof mutation No. 1697 has been
attested and Deputy Commissioner, Kathua received the
report from Tehsildar, Kathua on 31.10.2014 where it was
confirmed that respondent No. 2 started construction work
in plot No. 1 falling on the southern side of his plot and it
amounts to encroachment by illegal means.
4.
It is alleged that when the petitioner while accompanying the
Patwari to conduct demarcation of land to prove the
commission of offence by respondent No. 2/complainant on
22.08.2022, reached near the gate of the respondent No.
2/complainant, he was abused and dragged by respondent
No. 2 and his son Arjun Gupta inside their compound, as a
result
whereof, the
25.08.2022
petitioner
to SHO
Police
lodged a
Station,
complaint on
Kathua;
that
the
respondent No. 1, however, at the behest of respondent No.
2/complainant,
in
order
to
pressurize
the
petitioner,
managed the commencement of investigation of impugned
FIR which was so registered at his behest on 05.09.2022;
that the respondent No. 2/complainant has also filed civil
suit of Declaration and Injunction against the petitioner and
other owners of conjoint plots in the court of learned
Munsiff, Kathua, which is pending adjudication and the
CRM(M) No.913/2024
impugned FIR is the result of animosity. Finally, it has been
prayed that the impugned FIR being abuse of the process of
law, be quashed.
5.
Pursuant to notice, respondent No. 1 has filed the status
report stating therein that the respondent No. 2/complainant
filed a complaint against the petitioner alleging therein that
on 22.08.2022, the demarcation of the land in dispute was to
be conducted and at about 11.30 a.m, the accused
(petitioner herein) came to the complainant’s house and
when the respondent No. 2/complainant opened the gate for
the Patwari conducting the demarcation, the accused forcibly
entered the house, abused and assaulted the respondent No.
2/complainant with fists and blows; that before leaving, the
accused threatened to kill the respondent No. 2/complainant
and it was prayed in the complaint that appropriate legal
action be taken against the accused, in accordance with law;
that as per the contents of application, impugned FIR was
registered against the petitioner for offences punishable
under Sections 451, 504 and 506 of IPC.
6.
Respondent No. 1 was directed to furnish the status report of
the investigation in case FIR No. 382/2014 registered against
the respondent No. 2/complainant by the petitioner who, in
his compliance report, stated that on 12.10.2014 the
respondent/complainant criminally trespassed into the land
of the petitioner and dismantled the brick wall of the
CRM(M) No.913/2024
petitioner’s land; that on this report, the case was registered;
that during the course of investigation, the then I.O visited
on spot, prepared site plan, recorded the statements of the
witnesses under section 161 CrPC; that vide different letters
communications were addressed to Tehsildar concerned for
demarcation of land measuring 01 kanal comprising of
khasra No. 230 min situated at Taraf Tajwal, tehsil and
district Kathua but till date the demarcation of the above
said land has not been carried out by the concerned
department nor the report thereof has been provided to the
respondents.
Finally, it has been stated in the said
compliance report that after obtaining the said demarcation
report, the investigation of the case would be taken up
accordingly.
7.
Respondent No. 2/complainant, despite service of notice
upon
him,
chose
neither
to
appear
nor
file
any
reply/objections to the petition filed by the petitioner to seek
quashing impugned FIR, lodged by the respondent No.
2/complainant.
8.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
9.
The admitted factual position emerging from the record is
that both the parties are entangled in a long-standing
dispute concerning possession and alleged encroachment
over adjoining parcels of land. Criminal proceedings between
CRM(M) No.913/2024
them have been pending since the year 2014. The existence
of FIR No. 382/2014 lodged by the petitioner against
respondent No. 2, the previous litigation before this Court,
the pending civil proceedings concerning the same property
and the indisputed fact that demarcation proceedings were
scheduled
on
the
date
of
the
alleged
occurrence
unmistakably demonstrate that the genesis of the dispute is
essentially, civil in nature.
10.
Significantly, the compliance report filed by respondent No. 1
discloses
that
even
after
more
than
a
decade,
the
investigation in FIR No. 382/2014 has remained incomplete
because the demarcation of the land has not been either
undertaken or succeeded to be completed by the Revenue
Authorities. When the basic issue in dispute, namely, the
exact location and boundaries of the land belonging to the
parties, has not yet been finally determined, the allegations
made in the impugned FIR cannot be considered separately
from the ongoing civil disputes with regard to land between
them. The pendency of the earlier criminal case instituted by
the petitioner and the failure of the investigating agency to
conclude the same despite the earlier directions of this Court
lend considerable support to the petitioner's plea that the
present FIR has been lodged only as a counterblast to the
earlier case.
CRM(M) No.913/2024
11.
It is not out of place to mention that the alleged occurrence
is stated to have taken place on the very day when official
demarcation proceedings were to be conducted by the
Revenue officials. The petitioner has consistently stated that
he had accompanied the Patwari in connection with the
demarcation, which is an admitted fact in the FIR and that
complainant himself had submitted a complaint to the police
immediately after the incident. The respondents have not
disputed the existence of such complaint. These facts create
doubt about the version put forward by the prosecution and
show that the criminal proceedings appear to have arisen out
of the existing property dispute between the parties.
12.
The allegations contained in the impugned FIR, even if
accepted at their face value, do not disclose any element
independent of the underlying land dispute. The allegations
of criminal trespass, abuse and criminal intimidation are
closely connected with the ongoing dispute regarding the
demarcation of land and the alleged encroachment. It
appears that the criminal case has arisen out of this
property dispute and is, in substance, a continuation of the
civil dispute between the parties, rather than a case
involving an independent criminal offence.
13.
The inherent jurisdiction of this Court under Section 528 of
the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 is intended
to prevent abuse of the process of law and to secure the ends
CRM(M) No.913/2024
of justice. Where criminal proceedings are started only to
take revenge in a dispute which is intrinsically, civil in
nature, and the facts clearly show that the complaint has
been filed with a dishonest or mala fide intentions, allowing
such proceedings to continue would amount to abuse of the
legal process. The Supreme Court has consistently held that
although the inherent powers of the High Court should be
exercised with great caution and only in exceptional cases,
the Court can quash criminal proceedings where they are
clearly motivated by ‘mala fide’ intentions or have been
initiated only to harass the accused and settle personal
scores.
14.
In the present case, the chronology of events assumes
considerable significance. The earlier FIR lodged by the
petitioner
against
respondent
No.
remains
pending
investigation. The dispute regarding encroachment is yet to
attain finality. Civil proceedings concerning the same subject
matter are also pending. The impugned FIR came to be
registered immediately after the visit of revenue officials for
demarcation proceedings and in the backdrop of the
continuing hostility between the parties.
15.
Permitting the investigation and prosecution to continue in
such circumstances would not advance the cause of criminal
justice but would instead amount to encouraging the misuse
of the criminal process for settling private scores. This Court
CRM(M) No.913/2024
is, therefore, satisfied that the present case falls within the
well-recognised
parameters
governing
the
exercise
of
inherent jurisdiction to prevent abuse of the legal process of
the Court and to secure the ends of justice.
16.
Consequently, the petition is allowed. Impugned FIR No. 346
of 2022 dated 05.09.2022 registered at Police Station,
Kathua for offences punishable under Sections 451, 504 and
IPC,
against
the
petitioner,
together
with
all
consequential proceedings arising therefrom, is hereby
quashed.
17.
Disposed of accordingly along with connected application(s).
(M A CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
JAMMU
05.08.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the order is reportable:
Whether the order is speaking:
…
Yes
Yes
Naresh Kumar
2026.08.05 16:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM(M) No.913/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review