Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Pronounced on : 07.10.2026
HCP No. 43/2026
Romelu Ram
Through his son Jagjit Singh
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. P.C. Sharma, Advocate and
Mr. Karan Sharma, Advocate
Vs
UT of J&K & Ors.
.….Respondents
Through: Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner as well as for
the respondents.
02.
Perused
the
writ
pleadings
and
the
documents
therewith. Also perused the detention record produced from the
end of Mr. Suneel Malhotra, learned GA for the respondents.
03.
The petitioner-Romelu Ram is suffering preventive
detention custody lodged in District Jail, Jammu. The petitioner
acting through his son has come forward with the present writ
petition under article 226 of the Constitution of India for the
HCP No. 43/2026
purpose of seeking quashment of his preventive detention custody
inflicted by virtue of an order No. PSA/178 dated 04.04.2026
passed by the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Kathua
under the J&K Public Safety Act, 1978.
04.
A case for preventive detention of the petitioner was
mooted and routed by the respondent No. 3 - Sr. Superintendent
of Police (SSP), Kathua who, by virtue of a communication No.
Pros/26/13081-84/DPOK
dated
12.03.2026,
submitted
a
dossier to the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Kathua
thereby reporting the alleged state of activities of the petitioner
which was reckoned to be prejudicial to the security of the State
warranting detention of the petitioner under the J&K Public
Safety Act, 1978.
05.
In
his
dossier,
the
respondent
No.
3–
Sr.
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Kathua came forward stating that
the petitioner is a 66 years aged person having retired from the
Medical Department and now pursuing his occupation as a
farmer as native of village Machhedi, tehsil Lohai Malhar, district
Kathua. The petitioner is further referred to be a history sheeter
of Police Station Billawar and was reckoned to be involved in antisocial/ anti-national activities having links with anti-national
activists and agencies by being a great sympathizer of banned
terrorist
organizations,
HCP No. 43/2026
providing
all
possible
help
like
transportation, internet, food and shelter to the terrorists of
different banned outfits. The petitioner himself is referred to be
involved in terrorist activities as well as responsible for law and
order problems. The petitioner is further referred to be working as
an OGW of a terrorist organization by being willingly inclined
towards militancy and voluntarily providing logistic support to the
militants, providing information about movement of security
forces as a result whereof many cordon and search operations
were frustrated.
06.
By reference to his adverse antecedents/indulgences,
the petitioner is referred to have been subjected to proceedings
under Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 by
reference to section 129 on two occasions i.e. 23.02.2026 &
05.03.2026 by the Police Station Billawar. In addition, adverse
DDR Nos. 19 dated 10.02.2026 & 20 dated 10.03.2026 from
Police Station Billawar and of Police Station Malhar respectively
came to be cited to portray the petitioner as a person involved in
alleged
activities
prejudicial
to
the
security
of
the
State
particularly in district Kathua.
07.
By reference to the aforesaid adverse texted and toned
dossier from the end of the respondent No. 3 – Sr. Superintendent
of Police (SSP), Kathua, by a purported application of mind on his
part, the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Kathua came to
HCP No. 43/2026
frame grounds of detention by literally borrowing word to word
text of the dossier and then on that basis suffixing his purported
appraisal holding that the alleged state of activities of the
petitioner is highly objectionable and prejudicial to the security of
the State.
08.
In formulation of grounds of detention, the respondent
No. 2 – District Magistrate, Kathua has come forward with a very
express reference to and reproduction of section 8(3)(b) of the
J&K Public Safety Act, 1978 as to what amounts to acting in any
manner prejudicial to the security of the State.
09.
On the basis of the purported grounds of detention, the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Kathua came forward with
issuance of detention order No. PSA/178 dated 04.04.2026
thereby directing arrest and preventive detention of the petitioner
and his confinement in District Jail Jammu.
10.
The petitioner came to be taken into custody on
06.04.2026 when PSI Ganesh Dutt (EXJ-196739) from the Police
Station Billawar is said to have been taken the petitioner into
custody and carrying out the formality of handing over notice of
the detention order, grounds of detention along with dossier
besides
reading over and explaining to
Hindi/Dogri
HCP No. 43/2026
language
and
in
the petitioner in
acknowledgment
getting
his
signature on the receipt. The petitioner is simultaneously said to
have been apprised of his right to make a representation to the
Government as well as to the detention order making authority
against his detention.
11.
By virtue of Govt. Order No. Home/PB-V/418 of 2026
dated 15.04.2026, detention order came to be approved by the
Government of UT of Jammu & Kashmir, acting through its Home
Department in terms of the requirement of section 8(4) of the J&K
Public Safety Act, 1978. The case of the petitioner was then
referred to the Advisory Board for its opinion in terms of the
mandate of section 15 of the J&K Public Safety Act, 1978.
12.
The Advisory Board on its part, in exercise of
jurisdiction under section 16, came forward with its Opinion
Report dated 21.04.2026 on file No. Home/PB-V/56/2026
thereby holding the petitioners detention to be resting on
justifiable grounds. The fact of there being no representation from
the end of the petitioner against his detention also came to be
highlighted and, accordingly, the opinion report came to be
submitted.
13.
The Advisory Board’s said Opinion Report, thus,
resulted in confirmation of the petitioner’s detention in terms of
Govt. Order No. Home/PB-V/490 of 2026 dated 30.04.2026 by
HCP No. 43/2026
settling the first installment of detention period for a period of six
months from 06.04.2026 to 05.10.2026 and place of detention
to continue to be District Jail Jammu.
14.
The petitioner came forward with the present writ
petition filed on 22.05.2026.
15.
The petitioner in his petition has assailed his detention
on the grounds as set out in para 12.
16.
It is pleaded by the petitioner that the entire course of
action related with his preventive detention custody is a colorable
exercise of power and authority on the part of the respondents
and sheer non-application of mind at each and every step of the
exercise from the end of the authorities concerned including the
Advisory Board.
17.
It is pleaded that without any basis and material of any
sense and substance but going purely on imagination and
conjecturing, the respondent No. 3 – Sr. Superintendent of Police
(SSP), Kathua as well as the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate, Kathua carried out the detention order making
exercise related to the petitioner so as to deprive him of his
personal liberty which otherwise is a fundamental right of the
petitioner. It is further pleaded that the grounds of detention are
perverse.
HCP No. 43/2026
18.
The petitioner is referring to the fact that he came to
exercise his constitutional right of submitting a representation
against his preventive detention which has gone waste. The
petitioner refers to the fact that he submitted his representation
on 19.04.2026 through his son addressed to both the Principal
Secretary to Government, Department of Home, Government of
UT of Jammu & Kashmir and also to the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Kathua sent through registered postal means
on 21.04.2026. The writ petition is accompanied with a copy of
said representation along with the postal receipts to confirm the
fact that the petitioner did submit his representation.
19.
The counter affidavit to the writ petition came to be
filed on 22.07.2026 from the end of the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Kathua, coming forward to defend the
exercise of power under the J&K Public Safety Act, 1978 in
ordering the petitioner’s preventive detention.
20.
In his counter affidavit, the respondent No. 2 – District
Magistrate, Kathua has referred to the judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India which are – State of T.N Vs Nabila, (2015)
12 SCC 127, Haradhan Saha Vs State of W. B., (1975) 3 SCC
198, State of Bombay Vs Atma Ram Shridhar Vaidya, AIR 1951
SC 157 & Sunil Fulchand Shah Vs Union of India, (2000)3 SCC
409.
HCP No. 43/2026
21.
When this Court examines the submissions of the
learned counsel for the petitioner as well as of the respondents in
the light of the writ pleadings, documents therewith and the
detention record produced, this court gathers an instant
conviction that the petitioner’s preventive detention is a sheer
abuse of process of law beginning right from the end of the
respondent No. 3 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Kathua to
the end of the Government of UT of Jammu & Kashmir with
intervening actor/s as well like the Advisory Board.
22.
A bare perusal of the dossier would show that the
petitioner has been branded as a terrorist without even a single
case of ordinary criminal nature having been ever registered
against him by any of the Police Stations in district Kathua or for
that matter at any other place in the entire UT of Jammu &
Kashmir. For the facility of reference, this Court reproduces the
exact dossier text to highlight this fact which is as under:“The subject is a history sheeter of P/S Billawar and
it was gleaned through sensitive channels that, the subject
is involved in Anti-Social/Anti National activities and has
links with the Anti National activists/agencies a great
sympathizer of banned terrorist organizations and has
been
alleged
to
provide
all
possible
help
like
transportation, internet, food and shelter to the terrorists
of different banned outfits. He was involved in AntiNational /Anti-Social activities but always escapes from the
clutches of law. According to credible sources on ground,
HCP No. 43/2026
the subject has started to work as OGW of terrorist
organization.”
23.
Thus, without there being any reported act of alleged
involvement in terrorist activities, the petitioner has come to be
branded as an OGW of terrorist organization without any remote
reference as to which terrorist organization/banned outfit the
petitioner was found to be linked with. The dossier does not refer
as to vide which order number, the petitioner has shown to be a
history sheeter of Police Station Billawar when there is not even a
single criminal case cited in the entire dossier from the end of the
respondent No. 3 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Kathua. It
appears that the respondent No. 3 – Sr. Superintendent of Police
(SSP), Kathua has cut paste the contents of the dossier relatable
to some other person actually having the linkage with the
terrorist organizations/banned outfits and also a history sheeter
of the Police Station Billawar and then ascribed it to the
petitioner.
24.
The only proceedings under the criminal procedure
against the petitioner cited in the entire dossier are that of section
129 vide Istghasa No. 30/6-10 dated 23.02.2026 & Istghasa
No. 32/6-10 dated 05.03.2026.
25.
By reference to the proceedings under section 129 of
the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, the
HCP No. 43/2026
respondent No. 3 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Kathua in
his dossier has not bothered himself to know, and then to make it
known to the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Kathua, as
to whether the same have been taken to logical conclusion by a
final order under section 136 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 from the end of the Executive Magistrate
Ist Class, Billawar so as to bind the petitioner on bond maintain
good behavior.
26.
The other adverse material relatable with the petitioner
is two purported entries as DDR No. 19 dated 10.02.2026 of the
Police Station Billawar and DDR No. 20 dated 10.03.2026 of the
Police Station Malhar which are literally hearsay inputs.
27.
Thus, the dossier is making a very fairy story like
representation of and against the petitioner without any factual
content whatsoever except that reference to proceedings relatable
to section 129 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita
(BNSS), 2023 and DDR Nos. 19 & 20 of the Police Station
Billawar and the Police Station Malhar.
28.
The dossier so submitted by the respondent No. 3- Sr.
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Kathua ought to have suffered an
outright rejection by and from the end of the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Kathua but instead, the respondent No. 2 –
HCP No. 43/2026
District Magistrate, Kathua took time at his leisure to come
forward with his purported application of mind, after more than
22 days, to formulate the grounds of detention and pass
detention order No. PSA/178 dated 04.04.2026.
29.
The non-application of mind on the part of the
respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate, Kathua is ex-facie
exhibited from the very fact that while the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Kathua is applying section 8(3)(b) of the J&K
Public Safety Act, 1978 as to the act/s which amounts to acting
in any manner prejudicial to the security of the State but the
same are actually relatable to “Maintenance of Public Order”.
30.
This Court reproduces the exact text of the grounds of
detention formulated on the part of the respondent No. 2 –
District Magistrate, Kathua which is:“Before proceeding further, it would be appropriate to
outline the provisions of Section 8(3)(b) of J&K Public Safety Act,
1978 that spells out the meaning of acting in any manner
prejudicial to the security of the state, which is reproduced as
under:-
1.
Promoting, propagating, or attempting to create, feelings of
enmity or hatred or disharmony on ground of religion, race,
caste, community, or region;
2.
Making preparations for using, or attempting to use, or
using, or instigating, inciting, provoking or otherwise,
abetting the use of force where such preparation, using,
attempting, instigating, inciting, provoking or abetting,
disturbs or is likely to disturb public order;
HCP No. 43/2026
3.
Attempting to commit, or committing, or instigating,
provoking or otherwise abetting the commission of, mischief
within the meaning of section 425 of the Ranbir Penal Code
where the commission of such mischief disturbs, or is likely
to disturb public order;
4.
Attempting to commit, or committing or instigating, inciting,
provoking or otherwise abetting the commission of an
offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life or
imprisonment of a term extending to seven years or more,
where the commission of such offence disturbs, or is likely
to disturb public order;”
31.
Section 8 sub-section (3)(b) of the J&K Public Safety
Act, 1978 is reproduced herein next:“(3)
For the purposes of sub-section (1),
(a)
[Omitted.] [Omitted by Act XII of 1988, section 2.]
(b)
"acting
in
any
manner
prejudicial
to
the
maintenance of public order" means(i)
promoting,
create,
propagating,
feelings
of
or
enmity
attempting
to
or
or
hatred
disharmony on ground of religion, race, caste,
community, or region;
(ii)
making preparations for using, or attempting
to use, or using, or instigating, inciting,
provoking or otherwise, abetting the use of
force
where
such
preparation,
using,
attempting, instigating, inciting, provoking or
abetting, disturbs or is likely to disturb public
order;
(iii)
attempting to commit, or committing, or
instigating, provoking or otherwise abetting
the
commission
of,
mischief
within
the
meaning of section 425 of the Ranbir Penal
Code where the commission of such mischief
disturbs, or is likely to disturb public order;
(iv)
attempting
to
commit,
or
committing
or
instigating, inciting, provoking or otherwise
HCP No. 43/2026
abetting
the
commission
of
an
offence
punishable with death or imprisonment for
life or imprisonment of a term extending to
seven years or more, where the commission of
such offence disturbs, or is likely to disturb
public order;”
32.
Thus, the respondent No. 2 – District Magistrate,
Kathua is caught on wrong foot in terms of his very elementary
understanding of the J&K Public Safety Act, 1978 by co-relating
something which is dealing with the activities prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order and referring it to as the activities
prejudicial to the security of the State and acting on the sheer
misunderstanding and misconception of law, the respondent No.
2 – District Magistrate, Kathua has examined the fate of the
petitioner’s personal liberty.
33.
On this technical aspect itself, the preventive detention
of the petitioner ought not to have been held justified by the
Advisory Board in terms of its Opinion Report but, nevertheless,
even the Advisory Board seems to have given a skip to such
patent anomaly and has taken mechanical exercise at its end to
dish out a favourable opinion report to the Government to justify
the confirmation of the petitioner’s preventive detention.
34.
This Court has no iota of doubt that there seems to be
a malafide at work from the end of the District Police against the
HCP No. 43/2026
petitioner so as to book him under the J&K Public Safety Act,
1978 without any occasion and basis for acting and doing so.
35.
In the light of the aforesaid, this Court holds the very
preventive detention of the petitioner as illegal and the entire
exercise relatable therewith also illegal vitiated with malice in law.
36.
with
Detention order No. PSA/178 dated 04.04.2026 read
approval/conformation/extension
order/s
whatsoever
passed by the Government of UT of Jammu & Kashmir are held to
be illegal and are hereby quashed.
37.
The petitioner is directed to be released to his personal
liberty forthwith by his release from the District Jail, Jammu.
38.
The Superintendent, District Jail, Jammu to act in
abidance of the directions of this Court by releasing the petitioner
from his Jail.
39.
Disposed of.
40.
Detention record to be returned back to the learned
counsel for the respondents.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
JAMMU
07.10.2026
Muneesh
Whether the judgment is speaking :
Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable :
No
Muneesh Sharma
2026.10.07 18:06
I attest to the accuracy and
HCP
No. 43/2026
integrity of this
document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review