Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
DATED : 16th APRIL, 2021
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH :
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bail Appln. No.08 of 2021
Petitioner
:
Rohit Tamang
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Application under Section 439 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Leonard Gurung, Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr. Yadev Sharma, Additional Public Prosecutor with SI Manish
Gurung, Investigating Officer, for the State-Respondent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioner, aged about 36 years, is accused of the
offence under Section 7, 9(1)(c) and 14 of the Sikkim Anti Drugs
Act, 2006 (SADA, 2006) read with Section 506 of the Indian Penal
Code. Jorethang PS FIR Case No.7 of 2021, dated 31-01-2021, was
registered against him on the basis of a Complaint lodged by the
SHO, Jorethang Police Station. The Petitioner was arrested on 1702-2021 and is presently in judicial custody, hence the instant Bail
Petition.
2.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the
Prosecution allegation is that the Petitioner was seen with the
controlled substances, seized vide Annexure 6, the Property Seizure
Memo,
by
two
Police
„Bharikhola‟, Jorethang.
personnel
on
an
abandoned
road
at
No photographs of the Petitioner or the
Bail Appln. No.08 of 2021
Rohit Tamang
vs. State of Sikkim
controlled substances were taken by the two Police personnel to
substantiate this allegation.
Stones allegedly pelted at the Police
personnel and the khukhuri with which the Petitioner was said to
have threatened them have not been seized.
Annexure 6 reveals
the location from where seizure of the controlled substances were
made but the Petitioner‟s name finds no mention therein. In such
circumstances, the Petitioner cannot be foisted with the offences
reflected in the FIR. The SHO had taken the witnesses along with
him for the purposes of seizure of the controlled substances
rendering the seizure suspicious as the witnesses could well have
been tutored by the Prosecution.
Two persons, namely, Sanjay
Subba and Padam Bahadur Sanyasi, were found roaming at the
place where the seizures were made.
They were accordingly
arrested and their vehicle was seized. The vehicle does not belong
to
the
Petitioner,
consequently
none
of
the
circumstances
enumerated by the Prosecution connects the Petitioner to the
offence.
The allegation that the Petitioner was absconding is
preposterous as in fact on 03-02-2021 he had taken his family and
gone to Delhi. No intimation was made to the Petitioner requiring
his presence before the Police either on 03-02-2021 or any other
date prior in time. The Petitioner who is innocent, is a Carpenter by
profession, belongs to a respectable family and has no criminal
antecedents.
He is the only earning member of his family
comprising of his wife and minor sons aged 7 years and 18 months
respectively and his incarceration would adversely affect them,
besides, his sons are presently unwell and he is required to facilitate
their treatment.
That, the Petitioner may be enlarged on bail in
Bail Appln. No.08 of 2021
Rohit Tamang
vs. State of Sikkim
consideration of the above circumstances, on any terms and
conditions.
3.
Repudiating the contention of Learned Counsel for the
Petitioner, it is submitted by Learned Additional Public Prosecutor
that the Petitioner was at the place of occurrence with the controlled
substances from where he absconded on being seen by the two
Police personnel, leaving behind the controlled substances, which
were subsequently seized by the Police. The arrest of the Petitioner
took place only on 17-02-2021, on account of the fact that there
were three other persons involved in the offence with the Petitioner
for which steps were taken simultaneously by the concerned
Investigating Officer (I.O.).
On 03-02-2021, on enquiry, the I.O.
was informed by the Petitioner‟s sister that he had left for Delhi.
Upon ascertaining his exact movements and location he was traced
in Delhi from where he was arrested on 17-02-2021.
That, the
offence is grave and the controlled substances are valued at
approximately Rs.22,00,000/- (Rupees twenty two lakhs) only, in
the open market.
facts
and
That, the Learned Trial Court considering the
circumstances
had
correctly
disallowed
the
Bail
Applications of the Petitioner. That, now the Charge-Sheet has been
submitted before the Learned Trial Court on 29-03-2021. The RFSL
Report which was awaited has been received yesterday and shall be
filed before the Learned Trial Court by tomorrow.
Should the
Petitioner be enlarged on bail the Prosecution apprehends that he
will abscond as he is a permanent resident of West Bengal. Besides
which, not only would it thwart the course of justice but enlarging
him on bail would send a wrong message to society at large when
he is found indulging in activities deleterious to the society.
Bail Appln. No.08 of 2021
Rohit Tamang
4.
vs. State of Sikkim
Having given due consideration to the rival submissions
of Learned Counsel for the parties, it is to be reiterated here that
indiscriminate sale and consumption of controlled substances is a
continuing bane of our society.
Not only are the youth being led
astray by consumption and sale of controlled substances they are
dropping out of school or colleges thereby not only ruining their
future prospects but also leading to a deterioration of their quality of
life, both physical and mental.
That apart, it also embroils the
unsuspecting family of the substance abuser to a life of misery and
travails which has a direct bearing on their mental health and
happiness quotient.
The sale of controlled substances fructifies in
easy money sans effort and unconscionable people indulge in it with
nary a care to the consequence it results in so long as it meets their
objective.
The negative impact of the sale and consumption of
controlled substances also affects the society at large whose
interests cannot be ignored or sidelined.
These points definitely
need to be factored in while considering cases for bail under the
SADA, 2006, as is the instant one.
5.
The Supreme Court while being concerned with the
menace of dangerous drugs flooding the market observed as follows
in Union of India vs. Ram Samujh and Another1;
“7. It is to be borne in mind that the aforesaid
legislative mandate is required to be adhered to and
followed. It should be borne in mind that in a murder case,
the accused commits murder of one or two persons, while
those persons who are dealing in narcotic drugs are
instrumental in causing death or in inflicting death-blow to a
number of innocent young victims, who are vulnerable; it
causes deleterious effects and a deadly impact on the
society; they are a hazard to the society; even if they are
released temporarily, in all probability, they would continue
their nefarious activities of trafficking and/or dealing in
intoxicants clandestinely. Reason may be large stake and
illegal profit involved. ..........................
(1999) 9 SCC 429
Bail Appln. No.08 of 2021
Rohit Tamang
vs. State of Sikkim
8.
To check the menace of dangerous drugs
flooding the market, Parliament has provided that the person
accused of offences under the NDPS Act should not be
released on bail during trial unless the mandatory conditions
provided in Section 37, namely,
(i)
there are reasonable grounds for believing
that the accused is not guilty of such offence;
and
(ii)
that he is not likely to commit any offence
while on bail
are satisfied. The High Court has not given any justifiable
reason for not abiding by the aforesaid mandate while
ordering the release of the respondent-accused on bail.
Instead of attempting to take a holistic view of the harmful
socio-economic consequences and health hazards which
would accompany trafficking illegally in dangerous drugs, the
court should implement the law in the spirit with which
Parliament, after due deliberation, has amended.”
[emphasis supplied]
6.
Others
Further, in State of Kerala and Others vs. Rajesh and
the Supreme Court held as follows;
“17. The jurisdiction of the court to grant bail is
circumscribed by the provisions of Section 37 of the NDPS
Act. It can be granted in case there are reasonable grounds
for believing that the accused is not guilty of such offence,
and that he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail.
It is the mandate of the legislature which is required to be
followed. At this juncture, a reference to Section 37 of the
Act is apposite. That provision makes the offences under the
Act cognizable and non-bailable. It reads thus:
“37. Offences to be cognizable and non-bailable.—(1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974)—
(a) every offence punishable under this Act
shall be cognizable;
(b) no person accused of an offence
punishable for offences under Section 19 or Section
24 or Section 27-A and also for offences involving
commercial quantity shall be released on bail or on
his own bond unless—
(i) the Public Prosecutor has been given
an opportunity to oppose the application for
such release, and
(ii) where
the
Public
Prosecutor
opposes the application, the court is satisfied
that there are reasonable grounds for
believing that he is not guilty of such offence
and that he is not likely to commit any offence
while on bail.
(2) The limitations on granting of bail specified in
clause (b) of sub-section (1) are in addition to the limitations
under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), or
any other law for the time being in force on granting of bail.”
(emphasis supplied)
………………………………………………………………………
(2020) 12 SCC 122
Bail Appln. No.08 of 2021
Rohit Tamang
vs. State of Sikkim
19. The scheme of Section 37 reveals that the
exercise of power to grant bail is not only subject to the
limitations contained under Section 439 CrPC, but is also
subject to the limitation placed by Section 37 which
commences with non obstante clause. The operative part of
the said section is in the negative form prescribing the
enlargement of bail to any person accused of commission of
an offence under the Act, unless twin conditions are
satisfied. The first condition is that the prosecution must be
given an opportunity to oppose the application; and the
second, is that the court must be satisfied that there are
reasonable grounds for believing that he is not guilty of such
offence. If either of these two conditions is not satisfied, the
ban for granting bail operates.
20. The expression “reasonable grounds” means
something more than prima facie grounds. It contemplates
substantial probable causes for believing that the accused is
not guilty of the alleged offence. The reasonable belief
contemplated in the provision requires existence of such
facts and circumstances as are sufficient in themselves to
justify satisfaction that the accused is not guilty of the
alleged offence. In the case on hand, the High Court seems
to have completely overlooked the underlying object of
Section 37 that in addition to the limitations provided under
the CrPC, or any other law for the time being in force,
regulating the grant of bail, its liberal approach in the matter
of bail under the NDPS Act is indeed uncalled for.”
[emphasis supplied]
The observations made and extracted supra explicitly apply to
the matter at hand, the principles of Section 37 of the Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act) being
embodied in Section 18(1)(ii) of the SADA, 2006.
7.
Having considered the facts and circumstances placed
before me and having examined all documents on record, it must be
mentioned firstly that the medical report of the children of the
Petitioner is of no assistance to him as it is evidently flu that they
were suffering from which required no hospitalisation.
It is now
almost a month since the medical reports were prepared and no
untoward incidents have occurred. It
needs
no
reiteration
that
apart from the above circumstances, the nature and gravity of the
offence, the penalty likely to be imposed on the Petitioner if
convicted of the offence charged with, apprehension of the accused
absconding and thereby thwarting the course of justice, previous
criminal antecedents, if any, of the accused and his position and
Bail Appln. No.08 of 2021
Rohit Tamang
vs. State of Sikkim
standing in society as well as apprehension of the offence being
committed and witnesses being influenced are required to be
extended due consideration.
8.
As already discussed the offence is grave and heinous as
it deals with selling of controlled substances. The penalty, if found
guilty, is high.
There is an apprehension that the Petitioner could
abscond being a resident of West Bengal, making it difficult for the
Prosecution to secure his presence at the trial.
Over and above
these points, the quantity of the controlled substances recovered is
gargantuan which is deleterious to the interest of society at large.
Resultant, I am of the considered opinion that the Petitioner does
not deserve to be enlarged on bail.
9.
However, in view of the fact that the Charge-Sheet has
already been submitted, let the trial commence after the RFSL
Report is filed in the relevant Court. The Learned Trial Court shall
made all efforts to dispose of the matter within eight months from
the date of filing of the RFSL report.
10.
The
Bail
Appln.
stands
rejected
and
disposed
of
accordingly.
11.
The observations made herein above are only for the
purposes of this Bail Application and shall have no bearing on the
merits of the case.
12.
Copy of this Order be sent to the Learned Trial Court for
information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
16-04-2021
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review