Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
DATED: 8th May, 2017
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRP No. 7 of 2016
Petitioners
:
1.
Shri Rinzing Wangyal Bhutia,
S/o Late Achung Kazi,
R/o Yangtay,
Gyalshing, West Sikkim.
2.
Shri Zamyang Kunga Bhutia,
S/o Shri Ringzing Wangyal Bhutia,
R/o Yangtay,
Gyalshing, West Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Shri Wangchuk Bhutia,
S/o Late Topgay Bhutia,
R/o Lotus Village,
Gyalshing, West Sikkim.
2.
Shri Thinlay Odzer Bhutia,
S/o Late Topgay Bhutia,
R/o Dentam, West Sikkim.
3.
Sub Registrar,
District Administrative Centre,
Rabdentse,
Gyalshing, West Sikkim.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Tashi Rapten Barfungpa and Mr. Ugang Lepcha, Advocates for the
Petitioners.
Mr. Rahul Rathi, Mr. Pujan Kharka, Mr. Bishal Subba and Mr. Karma
Bhutia, Advocates for the Respondents No.1 and 2.
Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Senior Government Advocate with Mrs. Pollin
Rai, Assistant Government Advocate, for the Respondent No.3.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This
Revision
Petition
impugns
the
Order
dated
08.09.2016, of learned Civil Judge, West Sikkim at Gyalshing, in
CRP No. 7 of 2016
Shri Rinzing Wangyal Bhutia & Another vs. Shri Wangchuk Bhutia & Others
Title Suit No. 4 of 2016, in the matter of Shri Wangchuk Bhutia
and Another vs. Shri Rinzing Wangyal Bhutia & Another, vide
which the learned Civil Judge rejected the prayer of the Petitioners
in a Petition filed by them under Order VII, Rule 11 (a) (b) and (d)
read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for
short “the CPC”).
2.
The grounds being pressed before this Court are under
Order VII Rule 11 (a) and (d) of the CPC. The Petitioners were the
Defendants 1 and 2 before the learned Trial Court, while the
Respondents 1 and 2 were the Plaintiffs (hereinafter, Petitioners
and Respondents, respectively). Respondents 1 and 2 filed a Civil
Suit seeking Declaration, Recovery of Possession, Cancellation of
Mutation and other consequential reliefs, which was registered as
the aforesaid Title Suit, before the learned Trial Court. Their case
is that, their grandfather late Dorjee Bhutia, was the owner of
several plots of land measuring a total area of 7.4360 acres at
Yangtay, West Sikkim, which were recorded in his name. Of the
said properties, the scheduled properties fell in the share of the
Respondents father late Tobgay Bhutia, who passed away in 2012.
In 2015, on enquiry of the title and possession of their ancestral
lands, it came to light that the scheduled properties were recorded
in the name of the Petitioners. It is alleged that the said mutation
had been done without adherence to the due process of law and in
connivance with employees of the District Collectorate, Gyalshing,
West Sikkim. The Respondents approached the Petitioners for an
amicable settlement but were rejected, inter alia, on ground that
the Respondents grandfather had sold the plots of lands to them
but records would show that some properties were bought from
one Tenzing Dorjee Bhutia, who was not their grandfather, in
addition to which the procedure prescribed for mutation had not
been followed in connection with the other properties. Hence, the
prayers for setting aside the mutation of the suit lands recorded in
the name of the Petitioners 1 and 2, a declaration that the
Respondents are the absolute owner of the suit lands, a
declaration granting restoration of possession of suit lands to the
CRP No. 7 of 2016
Shri Rinzing Wangyal Bhutia & Another vs. Shri Wangchuk Bhutia & Others
Respondents and that the Petitioners have no right, title and
interest over the suit properties. The Petitioners 1 and 2 filed their
Written Statements before the learned Trial Court and after issues
were settled for determination, the parties having been duly
examined under Order X, a Petition under Order VII Rule 11 read
with Section 151 of the CPC was filed by the Petitioners. The
learned Trial Court rejected the said Petition by the detailed
impugned Order.
3.
Before this Court, it is contended by learned Counsel
for the Petitioners that the suit discloses no cause of action,
inasmuch as the documents filed by the Respondents would
indicate that the suit lands have been legally transferred to the
names of the Petitioners, duly supported by the Sale Deed
documents filed by them, subsequent to which, “Khatiyan Parcha”
for the disputed plots of lands were issued in their names. That,
although the Respondents father was alive till 2012, the Petitioners
forbore from making enquiries about the suit lands in his life time
and it was allegedly only after his passing, that, in 2015 the
Respondents
started
making
enquiries.
That,
although
the
Respondents claim that the suit properties fell in the share of their
father, no documents of partition have been submitted to fortify
this averment, nor does the Plaint make any averment of oral
partition. That, the Respondents had in fact attained the age of
majority by 1998/2000 but did not raise the issue of ancestral
lands with their father and have now come to the Trial Court with
concocted facts withholding the truth there from. That, in view of
the above facts and circumstances, there is no cause of action
thereby making the suit liable for rejection under Order VII Rule
11 (a) of the CPC. Besides, the suit property as evident from the
Sale Deed documents were purchased in the year 1985 and 1988
and as the suit is for declaration and recovery of possession, it is
clearly barred by law as provided under Order VII Rule (d) and
hence, considering the aforesaid infirmities, the suit be dismissed.
CRP No. 7 of 2016
Shri Rinzing Wangyal Bhutia & Another vs. Shri Wangchuk Bhutia & Others
4.
Per contra, it was vociferously argued by learned
Counsel for the Respondents that a perusal of the Sale Deed
documents would in fact show that one of the Sale Deeds reflects
the name of the Seller as “Tenzing Dorjee Bhutia” while the name
of
the
Respondents
grandfather
was
only
“Dorjee
Bhutia”,
therefore, how the said Tenzing Dorjee Bhutia came to be in
possession of the suit lands and sold it to the Petitioners, requires
to be looked into. Besides, they did not enquire into the ancestral
property during their father’s life time, as he was the head of the
family, apart from which there was never talk of alienation of
ancestral lands at any point of time. Now, on enquiries, they have
learnt that the suit lands are indeed their ancestral properties, as
it stood in the name of their grandfather not only in the survey
operation of 1950-51 but also in 1977-78. While canvassing the
arguments, the averments in the Plaint were reiterated by learned
Counsel.
5.
I have considered the submissions made by both
learned Counsel and I have also perused the impugned Order.
6.
What is cause of action has been succinctly laid down
in The Church of Christ Charitable Trust & Educational Charitable
Society, Represented by its Chairman vs. M/s Ponniamman
Educational Trust, Represented by its Chairperson/Managing
Trustee : (2012) SCCR 700, inter alia, as follows;
“8………………………….…………….The
cause of
action is a bundle of facts which taken with the law
applicable to them gives the plaintiff the right to
relief against the defendant. Every fact which is
necessary for the plaintiff to prove to enable him to
get a decree should be set out in clear terms. It is
worthwhile to find out the meaning of the words
“cause of action”. A cause of action must include
some act done by the defendant since in the
absence of such act no cause of action could
possibly accrue.
9. In A.B.C. Laminart Pvt. Ltd. and another
vs. A.P. Agencies, Salem, (1989) 2 SCC 163, this
Court explained the meaning of “cause of action” as
follows:
“12. A cause of action means every fact,
which if traversed, it would be necessary for the
CRP No. 7 of 2016
Shri Rinzing Wangyal Bhutia & Another vs. Shri Wangchuk Bhutia & Others
plaintiff to prove in order to support his right to a
judgment of the Court. In other words, it is a
bundle of facts which taken with the law applicable
to them gives the plaintiff a right to relief against
the defendant. It must include some act done by
the defendant since in the absence of such an act
no cause of action can possibly accrue. It is not
limited to the actual infringement of the right sued
on but includes all the material facts on which it is
founded. It does not comprise evidence necessary
to prove such facts, but every fact necessary for
the plaintiff to prove to enable him to obtain a
decree. Everything which if not proved would give
the defendant a right to immediate judgment must
be part of the cause of action. But it has no relation
whatever to the defence which may be set up by
the defendant nor does it depend upon the
character of the relief prayed for by the plaintiff.”
7.
That having been said, in order to consider a petition
under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, the Court is required to look
into averments in the plaint but at the same time, it is necessary
to point out that averments in the written statements are
immaterial inasmuch as the pleas taken by the defendants are
wholly irrelevant and the matter requires decision solely on what
has been put forth in the Plaint.
8.
It has been laid down in a catena of decisions that if on
meaningful reading of the plaint it is manifestly vexatious and
meritless, in the sense of not disclosing a clear right to sue, the
court should exercise its power under Order VII Rule 11 of the
Code. At the same time, in P.V. Guru Raj Reddy & Ors. vs. P.
Neeradha Reddy and others : 2015 (2) RCR (Civil) 43 (Civil Appeal No.
5254 of 2006, D/o 17.02.2015), it was held that the rejection of a
plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC is a drastic power
conferred in the Court to terminate a civil action at the threshold.
The conditions precedent to the exercise of power under Order VII
Rule 11, therefore, are stringent and have been consistently held
to be so by the Hon’ble Apex Court. It is only if the averments in
the plaint ex facie do not disclose a cause of action or on a reading
thereof the suit appears to be barred under any law the plaint can
be rejected. In all other situations, the claims have to be
adjudicated.
CRP No. 7 of 2016
Shri Rinzing Wangyal Bhutia & Another vs. Shri Wangchuk Bhutia & Others
9.
In the aforesaid backdrop, it would be essential to see
whether the Plaint discloses
a cause of action.
It is the
Respondents claim that the suit properties have been illegally
transferred in the names of the Petitioners, for which the
Respondents place reliance on the survey operations of 1950-52
and 1977-78, when the same lands stood recorded in their
grandfather’s name. Some portions have been recorded in the
name of the Petitioners after being transferred to them from one
Tenzing Dorjee Bhutia, who was not their grandfather. Thus, there
are pertinent questions that require to be delved into thereby
disclosing a clear right to sue. So far, as the question of limitation
is concerned, it is trite to mention that the same involves mixed
questions of law and facts and therefore, at this stage, on this
ground, the suit of the Respondents cannot be dismissed.
10.
In view of the above aforesaid reasons, I am of the
considered opinion that findings of the learned Trial Court in the
impugned Order, requires no interference.
11.
Nonetheless, the observations in this Order are not to
be construed as observations on the merits of the case, which shall
be decided at the time of trial.
12.
Accordingly, the Revision Petition is rejected.
13.
Copy of this Order be sent to the learned Trial Court
and records be remitted forthwith.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
08-05-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review