Civil
Renukamma D/O Govinda vs Smt. Mahadevamma @ Gattu Mahadevi and Anr
Add to a compilation
Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index.
It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence.
Sign in · See the plans
Cite this judgment
Citation
Copy citation
Link for your website or blog
Copy link code
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0 ).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
!
#
!
"
!
$
""
%
'
! "#"
$%
VARSHA N
RASALKAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
&
"
'
%
( ()
%
**
! "#"
! "#"
+
$%
*
*
",
&
&
-2-
*
*
"- !
*
#"-
"-$"&
*
"&
"" "# #"*
%
%
#
") ""
*
.
*
*
/
*
0%
0%
$!
$
0%
&
123 455647 82769 :;96<
6=>2?; "-$"& ?8 *4@27A
?:<>
=> "- ! 23 82769 BA >16 4556774;> 5<4A2;C 8?< 4; ?<96< >?
36> 43296 >16 2@5:C;69 D:9C@6;> 94>69 "" "#
764<;69
<2;=2547
.*4@27A
?:<>/& 2;
>16 <635?;96;>
76C477A
:9C6 *4@27A
?
?8 >16
42=1:< $8?< 31?<>
#"- E16<62; >16 3:2> 82769 BA
? " 23 96=<669 4;9 2> 23 96=74<69 >14> 316
E69969
?;36G:6;>7A
?:<>
#"
E286
<635?;96;>
?8
>16
96=64369
%434F4<4D
?
>?
92<6=>69
@4H6
;6=6334<A =14;C63 2; >16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 ?8 >16 96=64369
-3-
%434F4<4D 2; =?7:@;
<635?;96;>
? " BA 9676>2;C >16 ;4@6 ?8 4556774;>
<635?;96;>
? ) 4;9 6;>6< >16 ;4@6 ?8 >16
4556774;>
? " 4;9
9686;94;>
?"
4;9
4<6 5742;>288 4;9 9686;94;>
<6356=>2F67A 2; >16 3:2> B68?<6 >16 *4@27A
34H6 ?8 =?;F6;26;=6
>16
?
?:<> 4;9 8?< >16
>16 54<>263 >? >123 455647 4<6
16<62;48>6< <686<<69 2; >162< <4;H B68?<6 >16 *4@27A
?:<>
2; >16 3:2>
I
16 5742;>288 82769 >16 3:2> 2;
4C42;3> >16 9686;94;>
? " 4;9
?
B68?<6 >16 *4@27A
#"?:<>
8?< >16 <67268 ?8 96=74<4>2?; >14> 316 23 >16 76C477A E69969
E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 4;9 473? 8?< 92<6=>2?; >?
>16 9686;94;>
?
8?< 233:2;C 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 2; 16<
84F?:< BA @6;>2?;2;C 16< ;4@6 43 E286 2; =?7:@;
? ) ?8
>16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 BA 9676>2;C >16 ;4@6 ?8 9686;94;>
?"
!
16 B<268 84=>3 ?8 >16 =436 ?8 >16 5742;>288 4<6
>14> >16 5742;>288 23 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369
-4-
%434F4<4D
4>
162< @4<<24C6 E43 3?76@;2J69 ?;
;D4;6A4
=:3>?@3
E4@2
5<6F4272;C
6@576
2;
##
##-
14>;454772 F2774C6 43 56< >16
>162<
2;9:
=?@@:;2>A
96=64369 %434F4<4D 23 ;?;6 ?>16< >14; >16 A?:;C6<
B<?>16< ?8 >16 @?>16< ?8 5742;>288
56<8?<@69 ?; #
"#
##
162< 6;C4C6@6;> E43
8>6< >162< 6;C4C6@6;> 43 >16
5742;>288 4;9 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D E6<6 <674>2F63 4> >16
>2@6 ?8 @4<<24C6 >16 5742;>288 E43 5<6C;4;> ?8 4B?:> ! >?
@?;>13
16 5742;>288 769 @4<2>47 7286 E2>1 %434F4<4D 4>
42=1:< 4;9 2; >162< @4<<24C6 4 86@476 =1279 BA ;4@6
??D4 E43 B?<; ?; "- #E43 B?<; ?;
#- "#
#"
#
#"!
##- 4;9 4 3?; BA ;4@6
12F4D2
%434F4<4D 9269 2;>63>4>6 ?;
764F2;C B612;9 >16 5742;>288 4;9 123 >E?
=1279<6; 43 123 76C47 162<3 >16A B62;C 3:==633?<3 >? 123
63>4>6 4;9 5<?56<>A 768> B612;9 12@
4;9 16< =1279<6;
K=65> >16 5742;>288
>16<6 4<6 ;? ?>16< 76C47 162<3 >? >16
96=64369 %434F4<4D
16 5742;>288 4;9 16< =1279<6; <632969
E2>1 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D >277 123 743> 94A3 4>
>16 1?:36 B64<2;C
:;2=2547
?
( ()
$?79&
42=1:< 2;
( (-"
-5-
$;6E& @643:<2;C "# -
G 8>
16 3429 1?:36 5<?56<>A 23
3>4;92;C 2; >16 ;4@6 ?8 96=64369 %434F4<4D
8>6< 964>1
?8 %434F4<4D >16 5742;>288 143 455<?4=169 9686;94;>
?
8?< 233:2;C 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 ?8 16< 1:3B4;9 %434F4<4D 4;9
82769 45572=4>2?; 8?< @:>4>2?; 6;><A 2; <6356=> ?8 >16 1?:36
5<?56<>A 2; 16< ;4@6 %:> >16 9686;94;>
964>1 =6<>282=4>6 94>69 "
?8
964>1
) "#
#"
9686;94;>
56<
#
#"
6C23>6<
233:69 >16
BA <6C23>6<2;C 123 94>6
?I )
E16<62; 2; =?7:@;
?
#" ( #")
94>69
? ) >16 ;4@6 ?8 >16
? " 23 @6;>2?;69 43 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369
:=1 6;><A 23 E2>1?:> 4;A B4323 4;9 2> 23 2776C47 E2>1?:>
@4H2;C 4;A 5<?56< 6;G:2<A
16 9686;94;>
477 =?;=6<;69 E2>1 >16 96=64369
? " 23 ;?> 4>
8>6< H;?E2;C >16 3429
84=>
?;=6 4C42; >16 5742;>288 455<?4=169 >16 9686;94;>
?
4;9 82769 45572=4>2?; 8?< @4H2;C =?<<6=>2?; ?8 >16
964>1 =6<>282=4>6 @6;>2?;2;C 16< ;4@6 2; =?7:@;
>16 574=6 ?8 ;4@6 ?8 9686;94;>
9686;94;>
?
233:69
? " %:> ?;=6 4C42; >16
=6<>282=4>6
6;>6<2;C >16 34@6 43 64<726<
? ) 2;
94>69
16<648>6<
"#
#"
>16 5742;>288
-6-
233:69 76C47 ;?>2=6 >? >16 9686;94;>
?
8?< @6;>2?;2;C
16< ;4@6 43 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 2; =?7:@;
? ) ?8 >16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 %:> >16<6 E43 ;? <635?;36
8<?@ >16 9686;94;>
?
16 9686;94;>
? " 23 ;? E4A
=?;=6<;69 E2>1 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D B:> 316 143 B66;
=742@2;C >14> 316 23 >16 36=?;9 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369
E2>1?:> 4;A B4323 4;9 5<??8
16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 4> ;?
5?2;> ?8 >2@6 @4<<269 9686;94;>
? " 9:<2;C 3:B323>6;=6 ?8
123 @4<<24C6 E2>1 >16 5742;>288
6;=6
>16 5742;>288 E43
=?;3><42;69 >? 8276 3:2> B68?<6 >16 *4@27A
?:<> 4;9 316
5<4A69 8?< ;6=6334<A <67268
; 5:<3:4;=6 ?8 36<F2=6 ?8 3:@@?;3
9686;94;>
? " 4;9
>16
45564<69 >1<?:C1 >162< <6356=>2F6
=?:;3673 4;9 82769 >162< 3654<4>6 E<2>>6; 3>4>6@6;>3
16 9686;94;>
5742;> 4F6<@6;>3
? " 82769 3>4>6@6;> 96;A2;C >16
16 3:B@2>>69 >14> >16 5742;>288 23
3><4;C6< 4;9 316 929 ;?> <63296 2; >16 1?:36 ?8 >16
96=64369 %434F4<4D
=>:477A >16 9686;94;>
?;7A 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369
? " 23 >16
16 5742;>288 23
-7-
;?> 4> 477 =?;=6<;69 E2>1 >16 84@27A ?8 >16 96=64369
%434F4<4D
> 23 84736 >14> >16 =1279<6; E6<6 B?<; >? >16
5742;>288 4;9 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
6;=6 >16 G:63>2?;
?8 @:>4>2?; ?8 H14>4 ?8 >16 1?:36 5<?56<>A 2; >16 ;4@6 ?8
5742;>288 929 ;?> 4<236
3:2>
16 9686;94;>
16<6 23 ;? =4:36 ?8 4=>2?; >? 8276 >16
? " 5<?9:=69 ;6=6334<A 9?=:@6;> >?
31?E >14> 316 23 >16 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
*:<>16< >16 54<>2>2?; 1679 B6>E66; >16 84@27A @6@B6<3 ?8
>16 96=64369 %434F4<4D ?;
)#
#"! E?:79 31?E >14>
>16 1?:36 5<?56<>A 8677 >? >16 314<6 ?8 >16 96=64369
%434F4<4D 4;9 16 2; >:<; C28>69 >16 3429 5<?56<>A >? >16
9686;94;>
? " >1<?:C1 <6C23>6<69 C28> 9669
>16 3429 C28> 9669 >16 9686;94;>
? " 143 B66; 2; 51A32=47
5?336332?; ?8 >16 1?:36 5<?56<>A 32;=6
6;D?A@6;> ?8 >16 1?:36 5<?56<>A
#"! 4;9 316 23 2;
54A2;C 5<?56<>A >4K
=?;>2;:?:37A 8<?@ >16 94>6 ?8 C28> 9669
9686;94;>
; F26E ?8
16<68?<6
>16
? " 5<4A69 8?< 923@23347 ?8 >16 3:2> ?8 >16
5742;>288 E2>1 =?3>3
-8-
)
9686;94;>
?
82769
3654<4>6
E<2>>6;
3>4>6@6;> 3:B@2>>2;C >14> >16 3:2> 82769 BA >16 5742;>288
366H2;C 92<6=>2?; 4C42;3> >16 9686;94;>
?
23 ;?>
@42;>42;4B76 62>16< 2; 74E ?< ?; >16 84=>3 ?8 >16 =436
5742;>288 143 ;? 7?=:3 3>4;92 >? 8276 >16 3:2> =742@2;C
=?<<6=>2?; ?8 >16 ;4@6 2; >16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 233:69 BA
>16
:;2=25472>A
16 =?@56>6;> D:<2392=>2?; 7263 :;96<
5<?F232?;3 ?8 %2<>1 4;9
64>1
D:<2392=>2?;47
16<68?<6 >16 3:2> ?8 >16 5742;>288
4C23><4>6
=> B68?<6 >16 =?@56>6;>
8?< =14;C6 ?8 ;4@6 2; >16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 23 ;?>
@42;>42;4B76
16 5742;> 4F6<@6;>3 4<6 96;269 43 84736
8:<>16<
3:B@2>>69
<674>2?;3125
B6>E66;
%434F4<4D 6>=
?
>14>
>16
>16
4776C69
@4><2@?;247
5742;>288
4;9
96=64369
>16
23 ;?> E2>12; >16 H;?E769C6 ?8 9686;94;>
?:<> 143 ;? 5?E6< >? 477?E >16 3:2> ?< 233:6
92<6=>2?; 8?< =?<<6=>2?; ?8 >16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6
6=>2?; "
>
?8 %2<>1 4;9
64>1
; F26E ?8
=> >16 3:2> ?8 >16 5742;>288
23 @23=?;=62F69 4;9 B49 2; 74E 4;9 >16 34@6 23 ;?>
-9-
@42;>42;4B76
16<68?<6
>16 9686;94;>
?
5<4A69 8?<
923@23347 ?8 >16 3:2>
; >16 B4323 ?8 576492;C3 ?8 B?>1 >16 54<>263
>16 *4@27A
?:<> 8<4@69 8?77?E2;C 233:63 8?< =?;3296<4>2?;
!
-
"
; 3:55?<> ?8 >16 =436 ?8 5742;>288 316 C?>
6K4@2;69 16<3678 43
E2>;63363
9?=:@6;>3 4>
>?
K
? " 6K4@2;69 43
4;9
K
I
" 4;9 473? 6K4@2;69 >1<66
" >?
K
!
5742;>288
5<?9:=69
")
6< =?;><4 >16 9686;94;>
" 4;9 6K4@2;69 >E? E2>;63363 43
I 4;9 5<?9:=69 9?=:@6;>3 4>
K
" >?
- 10 -
"#
8>6< 164<2;C >16 4<C:@6;>3 ?8 B?>1 >16 54<>263
4;9 ?; =?;3296<2;C <676F4;> @4>6<2473 ?; <6=?<9
*4@27A
?:<> BA 4;3E6<2;C >16 233:6
4882<@4>2F6 4;9 >16 4992>2?;47 233:6
? " 4;9
>16
2; >16
? " 2; >16 ;6C4>2F6
143 96=<669 >16 3:2> ?8 >16 5742;>288 :;96< >16 2@5:C;69
D:9C@6;> 4;9 96=<66 94>69 "! "# #"""
%62;C 4CC<26F69 BA >16 2@5:C;69 D:9C@6;> 4;9
96=<66 >16 9686;94;>
? " 143 455<?4=169 >123
?:<> BA
8272;C >16 5<636;> 455647
"
16 4<C:@6;> ?8 >16 764<;69 =?:;367 8?< >16
9686;94;>
? " 23 >14> >16 2@5:C;69 D:9C@6;> 4;9 96=<66
?8 >16 ><247
?:<> 23 =?;><4<A >? @4>6<247 84=>3 9?=:@6;>3
4;9 6F296;=6 ?; <6=?<9 4;9 34@6 23 724B76 >? B6 36> 43296
16 ><247
?:<> 143 ;?> =?;3296<69 >16 84=> >14> >16
E2>;63363 6K4@2;69 ?; B61478 ?8 5742;>288 4<6 ;?;6 ?>16<
>14; >16 C<4;9@?>16< 4;9 B<?>16< ?8 >16 5742;>288
4<6 2;>6<63>69 E2>;63363
16A
16 *4@27A
?:<> 143 ;?>
=?;3296<69 >16 6F296;=6 ?8 9686;94;>
? " >14> 16<
@4<<24C6 E43 56<8?<@69 E2>1 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D ?;
- 11 -
#!
##
4>
4C:;>43E4@A
6F43>4;
>162< @4<<24C6 E43 7?F6 @4<<24C6
49E47
?49 4;9
;7A >16 8<26;93 ?8 >16
96=64369 %434F4<4D E6<6 5<636;> 4> >16 >2@6 ?8 @4<<24C6
4;9 16;=6 ;? @4<<24C6 =4<9 ?< 51?>?C<4513 E6<6 >4H6;
<6C4<92;C >16 @4<<24C6
16 *4@27A
?:<> 23 ;?> D:3>28269 2;
;?> =?;3296<2;C >16 9?=:@6;>3 4>
6356=2477A >16 C28> 9669 4>
K
16 *4@27A
9?=:@6;>
4>
K3
" >?
K
I
I 6K6=:>69 BA 96=64369
%434F4<4D 2; 84F?:< ?8 9686;94;>
5<?56<>A
K
? " C28>2;C >16 1?:36
?:<> 23 473? ;?> =?;3296<69 >16
"#
4;9
""
E12=1
4<6
B2<>1
=6<>282=4>63 ?8 >16 =1279<6; ?8 >16 9686;94;>
? " 4;9 >16
%4;H 5433B??H ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 4>
K
*4@27A
"-
?:<> 143 6K=66969 2>3 D:<2392=>2?; 4;9 C<4;>69
<67268 ?8 92<6=>2?; 4C42;3> >16 9686;94;>
?
>? @4H6
;6=6334<A =?<<6=>2?;3 2; >16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 ?8 >16
96=64369
;96< >16 5<?F232?;3 ?8 %2<>1 4;9
D:<2392=>2?;47
64>1
=> >16
4C23><4>6 23 =?@56>6;> 4:>1?<2>A 4;9 16;=6
F26E69 8<?@ 4;A 4;C76
>16 2@5:C;69 D:9C@6;> ?8 >16
- 12 -
><247
?:<> 23 4C42;3> >16 84=>3 5<?B4B272>A 4;9 6G:2>A ?8
=436 4;9 2> 23 724B76 >? B6 36> 43296 2; >16 *4@27A
"I
?:<>
; >16 ?>16< 14;9 >16 4<C:@6;> ?8 >16 764<;69
=?:;367 8?< >16 5742;>288 23 >14> >16 *4@27A
?:<> 143 <2C1>7A
455<6=24>69 >16 ?<47 4;9 9?=:@6;>4<A 6F296;=6 ?; <6=?<9
2; 5<?56< 56<356=>2F6 4;9 >16<6BA 96=<669 >16 3:2> 4;9
16;=6 16 3:55?<>3 >16 2@5:C;69 D:9C@6;> 4;9 >16<6BA
16 143 3?:C1> 8?< 923@23347 ?8 >16 455647
"!
; >16 B4=HC<?:;9 ?8 4<C:@6;> ?8 B?>1 >16
54<>263 2> 23 <676F4;> >? =?;3296< >16 6F296;=6 8?<>1=?@2;C
?; <6=?<9
> 23 56<>2;6;> >? ;?>6 >14> >16 3:2> 23 82769 BA
>16 5742;>288 8?< >16 <67268 ?8 96=74<4>2?; >14> 316 23 >16
76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
?>16< 14;9 >16 9686;94;>
; >16
? " 143 =?;>6;>69 >14> 316 23
>16 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
6;=6
2; F26E ?8 <2F47 =?;>6;>2?;3 ?8 >16 5742;>288 4;9 >16
9656;96;>
? " >16 6F296;=6 8?<>1=?@2;C ?; <6=?<9 8<?@
>16 B?>1 >16 54<>263 31?:79 B6 455<6=24>69
- 13 -
"
16 5742;>288 C?> 16<3678 6K4@2;69 43
"
143 82769 16< 488294F2> 43 6F296;=6 2; =1268 6K4@2;4>2?;
<62>6<4>6 >16 84=>3 4F6<<69 2; >16 56>2>2?;
16 5742;>288 143
5<?9:=69 E6992;C =4<9 4;9 8?:< @4<<24C6 51?>?3 =?5263
?8
4914<
=4<93
6;C4C6@6;>
51?>?3
@4<<24C6 E2>1 >16 96=64369 43 56<
<6356=>2F67A *:<>16< >16
?8 >16 5742;>288
96=64369
76C47
45572=4>2?;
;?>2=6
B?;9 ?8
<6C4<92;C
K3
" >?
16<
-
??D4 >16 94:C1>6<
964>1 =6<>282=4>63 ?8 >16
E2>1
5?3>47
<6=625>
4;9
4=H;?E769C@6;> =4<9 4;9 %2<>1 =6<>282=4>63 ?8 >16 =1279<6;
?8 >16 5742;>288 B?<; >? %434F4<4D 4<6 5<?9:=69 43 56<
K3
"# >?
"
") <6356=>2F67A
?<6?F6< >16 5742;>288 143 6K4@2;69 ?;6
4@B474@@4 43
@>
16 23 @4>6<;47 C<4;9@?>16< ?8 >16
5742;>288 4;9 473? @?>16< ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
143 82769 4; 488294F2> 43 6F296;=6 2; =1268 6K4@2;4>2?;
E16<62; 316 143 =764<7A 3>4>69 >14> >16 9686;94;>
? " 23
;? E4A =?;=6<;69 >? 16< 84@27A 4;9 >16 96=64369
%434F4<4D ;6F6< @4<<269 >16 9686;94;>
?"
16 143 473?
- 14 -
965?369 >14> >16 @4<<24C6 ?8 >16 5742;>288 E2>1 96=64369
%434F4<4D
E43
;D4;6A43E4@A
3?76@;2J69
6@576
?;
##
14>;454772 F2774C6 2 6
;4>2F6 574=6 ?8 16< 94:C1>6<
@>
##-
4>
4> >16
4K@2 E1? 23 473? >16
@?>16< ?8 >16 5742;>288 4;9 >16 6796< 323>6< ?8 >16 96=64369
%434F4<4D
")
> 23 ;?> 2; 9235:>6 >14> >16<6 23 =:3>?@
5<6F4272;C 2; >16 =?@@:;2>A ?8 5742;>288 >14> >16 C2<73 E?:79
@4<<A >162< @4>6<;47 :;=76
16<6 23 4B3?7:>67A ;? @4>6<247
2; >16 =<?33 6K4@2;4>2?; ?8
>? 923B6726F6 >16 6F296;=6
?8
"
I
@>
14>;454772 F2774C6
5742;>288
4C474H31@2 23 >16 <63296;> ?8
E12=1 23 ;4>2F6 ?8 >16 @?>16< ?8
I 143 82769 16< 488294F2>
E16<62; 316 143
965?369 >14> >16 5742;>288 @4<<269 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
?;
##
##- 4;9 316 4>>6;969 >16 3429 @4<<24C6
296;>28269 >16 51?>? 4>
K
E16<62; 316 45564<3 43 >16
51?>? ?8 >16 @4<<24C6 ?8 5742;>288 E2>1 96=64369 %434F4<4D
- 15 -
"-
!
<:H:;94554
82769
488294F2>
6F296;=6 2; =1268 6K4@2;4>2?; E16<62; 16 3>4>69 >14> 123
323>6< BA ;4@6
@>
<:H:;94@@4 E43 C2F6; 2; @4<<24C6
>? 6796< B<?>16< ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 4;9 >16 3429
:72C6554
4;9 >16 5742;>288 4;9
! 4<6 <63292;C 4>
42=1:<
! 4>>6;969 4;9 54<>2=254>69 2; >16 @4<<24C6
8:;=>2?; 4;9 4<<4;C6@6;> ?8 >16 @4<<24C6 ?8 5742;>288 E2>1
>16
96=64369
3?76@;2J69
?;
*:<>16<
16 296;>28269 >16 51?>? 4>
K
@4<<24C6
51?>?
%434F4<4D 4;9
%434F4<4D
?8
>16
5742;>288
E2>1
##
E12=1 23
>16
96=64369
! 23 45564<2;C 2; >16 3429 51?>?
23 ;? @4>6<247 2; >16 =<?33 6K4@2;4>2?; ?8
##-
16<6
! >? @4H6 123
6F296;=6 923B6726F4B76
#
?E6F6< >16 =?;>6;>2?; ?8 >16 9686;94;>
2; ?;6 ?8 >16 C<?:;93 ?8 455647 23 >14> >16
4;9
?"
!
4<6 <674>2F63 ?8 >16 5742;>288 4;9 >16A 4<6 2;>6<63>69
E2>;63363 %:> 2> 23 F6<A 56<>2;6;> >? ;?>6 >14> >? 5<?F6 >16
@4<<24C6 ?8 >16 5742;>288 >16 <674>2F63 4;9 8<26;93 E1?
4>>6;969 >16 @4<<24C6 4<6 @4>6<247 E2>;63363
> 23 ;?>
- 16 -
9235:>69 BA 9686;94;>
? " >14> >16
C<4;9@?>16< ?8 >16 5742;>288 4;9 >16
?8 >16 5742;>288 2 6
5742;>288
23 @4>6<;47
! 23 B<?>16<(2;(74E
! 23 B<?>16< ?8 >16 =?(323>6< ?8
16<6 23 4B3?7:>67A ;? <643?; >? 923B6726F6 >16
6F296;=6 ?8
>?
! E12=1 E?:79 5<?F6 >16 @4<<24C6
?8 5742;>288 E2>1 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
"
16 9686;94;>
? " C?> 16<3678 6K4@2;69 43
" 4;9 316 82769 16< 488294F2> 43 6F296;=6 2; =1268
6K4@2;4>2?; <62>6<4>2;C >16 84=>3 4F6<<69 2; >16 E<2>>6;
3>4>6@6;>
?E6F6< 2; >16 6F296;=6 ?8 =1268 6K4@2;4>2?;
9686;94;>
? " 43
" 143 3>4>69 >14> 16< @4<<24C6 E2>1
%434F4<4D E43 1679 ?;
#!
##
%:> >16 3429 84=> 23 ;?>
5764969 2; >16 E<2>>6; 3>4>6@6;>
=?<<6=>2?; ?8 >16 94>6
# #)
#"#
#!
##
4;9
?<6?F6<
>16<6 23
E12=1 E43 64<726< @6;>2?;69 43
3:B36G:6;>7A
2>
E43
=?<<6=>69
3 3:B@2>>69 BA >16 764<;69 =?:;367 8?< >16
5742;>288 ?;7A >? @4H6 ?:> 4 =436 >14> >16 9686;94;>
?"
@4<<269 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 64<726< >? >16 @4<<24C6 ?8
- 17 -
>16 5742;>288
#!
>16 94>6 E?:79 143 B66; @6;>2?;69 43
##
BA =?<<6=>2;C >16 34@6
48>6<>1?:C1> ?8 >16 9686;94;>
I
?<6?F6<
8?<>1=?@2;C
E12=1 23 ?;7A 4;
?"
>16<6 23 4B3?7:>67A ;? 9?=:@6;>
8<?@ >16
9686;94;>
?"
@4<<24C6 E2>1 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
9686;94;>
? " 143 5<?9:=69
K><4=>
:>4>2?;
6=625>
6=625>
64>1
6<>282=4>6
4K
28>
6<>282=4>63 ?8 16< =1279<6;
? " %14CA474K@2 %?;9
*?<@
A:31@4; %14<4>
5433B??H ?8 >16 96=64369
<2C2;47 %2773 4;9
;6
>?
5<?F6 16<
> 23 ><:6 >14> >16
4<>2>2?;
14>4
:>4>2?;
14774;
4>2?;
14>4
4<9
%2<>1
4A66 $@?>16< =4<9&
*?<@
4914< =4<93
2914F4
?D4;6 =4<9
A;92=4>6 %4;H
;924 2@2>69
43 56<
K
6>4;4
2K 51?>?3
" >?
K
I
<6356=>2F67A
!
51?>? 4>
9686;94;>
> 23 >16 =436 ?8 >16 9686;94;>
K
? " >14> >16
" 23 >16 B2<>194A 51?>?3 ?8 >16 3?; ?8
? " 4;9 2; >16 3429 51?>? >16 96=64369
%434F4<4D 4;9 123 @?>16< 45564< %:> @6<6 84=> >14> >16
- 18 -
@?>16< ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 23 45564<2;C 2; >16
51?>? ?8 B2<>194A ?8 >16 3?; ?8 >16 9686;94;>
? " =4;;?>
B6 4 C<?:;9 >? =?@6 >? >16 =?;=7:32?; >14> >16 9686;94;>
? " 23 >16 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
F6; 28 2> 23 ><:6 >14> >16 >E? =1279<6; E6<6 B?<; >? >16
9686;94;>
? " BA >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
3:=1 84=>
=4;;?> B6 4 C<?:;9 >? =?@6 >? >16 =?;=7:32?; >14> >16
9686;94;>
? " 23 >16 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369
6<6 84=> >14> >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 6K6=:>69
>16 C28> 9669 4>
I" "
K
I 2; 84F?:< ?8 >16 9686;94;>
? " ?;
#"! =4;;?> B6 4 C<?:;9 >? =?@6 >? >16 =?;=7:32?;
>14> >16 9686;94;>
96=64369
? " 23 >16 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16
16 @6;>2?; 2; >16 C28> 9669 >14> >16 9686;94;>
? " 23 E286 ?8 %434F4<4D
9?63 ;?> 5<?F6 >14> 316 23
76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
?<6?F6< 43 1679 BA >16 *4@27A
?:<> 2; >16
2@5:C;69 D:9C@6;>
6F6; >1?:C1 2; >16 6F296;=6 ?8
9686;94;>
" 316 143 3>4>69 >14> 316 @4<<269
? " 43
>16 96=64369 %434F4<4D ?;
#!
##
43 56< >16
4914<
- 19 -
=4<9 ?8 >16 9686;94;>
? " 5<?9:=69 4>
?8 B2<>1 ?8 >16 9686;94;>
? " 23 "--
4==65>69 >14> >16 9686;94;>
%434F4<4D 2; >16 A64<
##
"
>16 A64<
6;=6 28 4> 477 2> 23
? " @4<<269 >? >16 96=64369
316 31?:79 14F6 B66; 4C69 "
A64<3 4> >16 >2@6 ?8 16< @4<<24C6
9686;94;>
K
> 23 ;?> >16 =436 ?8 >16
? " 2; 16< E<2>>6; 3>4>6@6;> >14> E16; 316
E43 @2;?< 4;9 316 E43 3>:9A2;C 62>16< 2;
?<
316 @4<<269 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
)
16 9686;94;>
? " 143 6K4@2;69 ?;6
<631 43
4; 2;9656;96;> E2>;633 2; 3:55?<> ?8 16< =436
143 82769 123 488294F2> 43 6F296;=6 2; =1268 6K4@2;4>2?;
E16<62; 16 143 965?369 >14> >16 @4<<24C6 ?8 9686;94;>
? " E2>1 ?;6 %434F4<4D E43 1679 ?;
#!
##
4;9 16
E43 2;F2>69 >? >16 3429 @4<<24C6 4;9 >1:3 >16 5742;>288 23
3><4;C6<
%434F4<4D
>?
>16
84@27A
?8
>16
9686;94;>
?"
; >16 6F296;=6 2; =<?33 6K4@2;4>2?; ?8
4;9
2>
23 3>4>69 >14> >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 23 123 :;=76 B:> 16
23 ;?> >16 B7??9 <674>2F6 ?8 >16 96=64369
14;9
>16A 4<6 B67?;C2;C >? 34@6 =43>6
; >16 ?>16<
6 929 ;?>
- 20 -
<6=62F6 4;A @4<<24C6 2;F2>4>2?; ?8 >16 @4<<24C6 ?8 >16
9686;94;>
? " 4;9 %434F4<4D
*:<>16< 2> 23 F6<A 2;>6<63>2;C >? ;?>6 >14>
2; 123 6F296;=6 23 =<?33 6K4@2;4>2?; 143 3>4>69 >14> >16
54<6;>3 B<?>16<3 323>6<3 4;9 ;62C1B?:<2;C 56?576 ?8 >16
96=64369 %434F4<4D E6<6 ;?> 5<636;> 2; >16
@4<<24C6 ?8 >16
9686;94;>
?"
E2>1
>16
4776C69
96=64369
%434F4<4D *:<>16< 43 56< >16 6F296;=6 ?8
6K4@2;4>2?; >16 9686;94;>
2; =<?33
? " E43 4C69 "- A64<3 4> >16
>2@6 ?8 >16 4776C69 @4<<24C6
%:> 43 923=:3369 16<62;
4B?F6 28 >16 94>6 ?8 B2<>1 ?8 >16 9686;94;>
? " ?; >16
B4323 ?8 >16 =?;=6<;69 9?=:@6;> 5<?9:=69 BA 16< 23 >4H6;
2;>? =?;3296<4>2?; 316 31?:79 B6 4C69 "
A64<3 ?;7A 4;9
316 E43 @2;?< 4> >16 >2@6 ?8 >16 4776C69 @4<<24C6
-
16 9686;94;>
?F2;94554 43
I
? " 473? 6K4@2;69 16< 84>16<
I 143 82769 123 488294F2> 43
6F296;=6 2; =1268 6K4@2;4>2?; %:> 2> 23 F6<A 56<>2;6;> >?
;?>6 >14> >16
I 143 ;?> 965?369 <6C4<92;C >16 4776C69
@4<<24C6 ?8 9686;94;>
? " E2>1 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
- 21 -
16 6F296;=6 ?8
I 2; =1268 6K4@2;4>2?; 23 >14> >E?
=1279<6; E6<6 B?<; >? >16 9686;94;>
? " 8<?@ >16
96=64369 %434F4<4D 4;9 2; >16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 >16 ;4@6
123 94:C1>6<
9686;94;>
? " 23 31?E; 43 E286 ?8 >16
96=64369 %:> 43 4<C:69 BA >16 764<;69 =?:;367 8?< >16
5742;>288
>16
964>1
=6<>282=4>6
?8
>16
96=64369
%434F4<4D 23 G:63>2?;69 BA >16 5742;>288 2; >16 3:2>
?<6?F6< 2; >16 6F296;=6 2; =<?33 6K4@2;4>2?;
23 84>16< ?8 >16 9686;94;>
9686;94;>
?"
? " 3>:9269 "3>
I E1?
143 965?369 >14> >16
6 143 473? 965?369 >14>
>16<6 E43 @4<<24C6 2;F2>4>2?; 9?;6 <6C4<92;C >16 @4<<24C6
?8 >16 9686;94;>
? " 4;9 96=64369 %434F4<4D %:> >16
I 143 ;?> 5<?9:=69 4;A 3:=1 2;F2>4>2?; =4<9 4;9
@4<<24C6 51?>?3 ?8 >16 9686;94;>
I#
? " 2; >16 3:2>
3 923=:3369 16<62; 4B?F6 6F6; 28 2> 23 4==65>69
43 ><:6 >14> >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 6K6=:>69 >16 C28>
9669 4>
K
I 2; 84F?:< ?8 9686;94;>
? " 2> =4;;?> B6 4
C<?:;9 >? =?@6 >? >16 =?;=7:32?; >14> >16 9686;94;>
?"
23 >16 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
- 22 -
?<6?F6< 2> 23 ;?> >16 =436 ?8 >16 9686;94;>
@4<<269 %434F4<4D 4> 16< 4C6 ?8 "
@2;?<
*:<>16<
>16
<247
A64<3 E16; 316 E43
>16 ?<47 6F296;=6 4;9 >16 9?=:@6;>3
8?<>1=?@2;C 8<?@ >16 9686;94;>
9686;94;>
? " >14> 316
? " 9? ;?> 1675 >16
? " >? 847328A >16 =436 ?8 5742;>288
16<68?<6
?:<> 143 <2C1>7A =?@6 >? >16 =?;=7:32?; >14> >16
5742;>288 143 5<?F69 >14> 316 23 >16 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8
>16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
I"
16 3:B@2332?; ?8 >16 764<;69 =?:;367 8?< >16
9686;94;>
?
23 >14> >16 9686;94;>
?
143 82769 >16
E<2>>6; 3>4>6@6;> 3:B@2>>2;C >14> 2; F26E ?8 >16 5<?F232?;3
?8 >16
6C23><4>2?; ?8 %2<>13 4;9
64>13
=> >16 92<6=>2?;
3?:C1> BA >16 5742;>288 4C42;3> >16 9686;94;>
?
>?
=?<<6=> >16 ;4@6 ?8 >16 E286 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D 2;
>16 964>1 =6<>282=4>6 ?8 >16 96=64369 %434F4<4D
@42;>42;4B76
23 ;?>
%:> 2; 3:55?<> ?8 3:=1 =?;>6;>2?; >16
764<;69 =?:;367 8?< >16 9686;94;>
8?<>1 4;A 4<C:@6;> B68?<6 >16
<247
?
143 ;62>16< 5:>
?:<> ;?< 5<?9:=69
- 23 -
4;A
6F296;=6
2; 3:55?<>
?8 >162<
E<2>>6;
3>4>6@6;>
4F6<@6;>3
I
; >16 ?>16< 14;9 43 3:B@2>>69 BA >16 764<;69
=?:;367 8?< >16 5742;>288
>16 3:2> 23 8?< >16 <67268 ?8
96=74<4>2?; >14> >16 5742;>288 23 >16 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8
>16 96=64369 4;9 316 143 3?:C1> =?<<6=>2?; 2; >16 964>1
=6<>282=4>6 ?8 >16 96=64369 >? @6;>2?; 16< ;4@6 43 E286 ?8
>16 96=64369 2;3>649 ?8 >16 ;4@6 ?8 9686;94;>
?"
6;=6 >16 <67268 ?8 96=74<4>2?; 3?:C1> 4C42;3> 9686;94;>
?
23 ;?> 8?< 6;><A ?8 >16 94>6 ?8 964>1 ?8 >16 96=64369
2; >16 =?;=6<;69 <6C23>6< ?8 9686;94;>
28 9686;94;>
?
?
*:<>16< 6F6;
23 ;?> 4 54<>A >? >16 3:2> 28 >16 5742;>288
23 96=74<69 43 76C477A E69969 E286 ?8 96=64369 BA >16 3:2>
3:=1 <67268 23 B2;92;C ?; 9686;94;>
?
43 >16 2@5:C;69
D:9C@6;> 4;9 96=<66 543369 2; >16 3:2> 23 D:9C@6;> 2;
<6@
II
*:<>16< >16 =?;>6;>2?; ?8 >16 9686;94;>
?
>14> >16 3:2> 23 ;?> @42;>42;4B76 E2>1?:> 5<2?< ;?>2=6 >? >16
9686;94;>
?"
473? 9?63 ;?> 3>4;9 8?< =?;3296<4>2?;
- 24 -
*<?@ >16 9?=:@6;>4<A 6F296;=6 ?; <6=?<9
2> E?:79 B6
=764< >14> >16 5742;>288 233:69 76C47 ;?>2=6 >? >16 9686;94;>
?
43 56<
K
"! E12=1 23 94>69 "
;?>2=6 E43 36<F69 >? >16 9686;94;>
4=H;?E769C@6;> 4>
B68?<6 >16 *4@27A
>14;
K
K
"
""
?
#"
16 3429
43 56< >16 5?3>47
16 5742;>288 82769 >16 3:2>
?:<> ?;
#
#"- 2 6
48>6< @?<6
@?;>13 8<?@ >16 94>6 ?8 36<F2=6 ?8 >16 ;?>2=6 4>
"! >? >16 9686;94;>
?
6;=6 ?; >123 C<?:;9 473?
>16 =?;>6;>2?; ?8 >16 9686;94;>3
? " 4;9
23 ;?> @42;>42;4B76 4C42;3> 9686;94;>
?
>14> >16 3:2>
9?63 ;?> 14F6
76C3 >? 3>4;9 ?; >16 84=>3 ?8 >16 =436 4;9 473? 2; 74E
I!
16 @6>2=:7?:3 =?;3296<4>2?; ?8 >16 <643?;2;C
?8 >16 *4@27A
?:<> 2; >16 2@5:C;69 D:9C@6;> E?:79
=764<7A 31?E >14> >16 *4@27A
?:<> 143 455<6=24>69 >16
?<47 4;9 9?=:@6;>4<A 6F296;=6 8?<>1=?@2;C ?; <6=?<9
8<?@ B?>1 >16 54<>263 2; 5<?56< 56<356=>2F6 4;9 >16<6BA
>16 *4@27A
?:<> 143 =?@6 >? >16 =?<<6=> =?;=7:32?; >14>
>16 5742;>288 23 6;>2>769 >? >16 <67268 3?:C1> 8?< 2; >16 3:2>
6;=6 4;A ?8 >16 C<?:;93 :<C69 BA >16 9686;94;>
? " 2;
- 25 -
>16 5<636;> 455647 9?63 ;?> @6<2> =?;3296<4>2?; >? 36>
43296 >16 2@5:C;69 D:9C@6;> 4;9 96=<66 ?8 >16 *4@27A
?:<> 4> >16 14;93 ?8 >123
?;36G:6;>7A
?:<> 2; >16 5<636;> 455647
E6 4<6 ?8 >16 =?;3296<69 F26E >14> >16
455647 82769 BA 9686;94;>
? " 23 724B76 >? B6 923@23369
I
; >16 <63:7> E6 5<?=669 >? 5433 >16 8?77?E2;C
$2&
16 455647 82769 BA >16 9686;94;>
? " 4556774;> 23 16<6BA
$22&
?;36G:6;>7A
>16
D:9C@6;>
96=<66
94>69
764<;69
<2;=2547 :9C6 *4@27A
42=1:< 2;
"" "#
?
#"-
?8
4;9
>16
?:<>
#"- 31477 3>4;9
=?;82<@69
$222&
; >16 =2<=:@3>4;=6 >16<6 31477 B6
;? ?<96< 43 >? =?3>3
- 26 -
$2F&
<247
?:<>
6=?<9 31477 B6
<6>:<;69 >? >16 *4@27A
?:<> 47?;C
E2>1 =?5A ?8 >123 D:9C@6;>
()
%
"
&
!
()
%
23>
?
"
?
!
!
$
&
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review