Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
MACA NO. 3921 OF 2016
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 02.05.2016 IN OPMV NO.618 OF
2014 OF
II ADDITIONAL MACT, THODUPUZHA
APPELLANT/3RD RESPONDENT:
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD
REP. BY ITS LEGAL CLAIMS MANAGER,
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
ERNAKULAM
BY ADV TAPAS VARMA A
RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANTS & RESPONDENTS 1& 2:
LALY PRINCE
W/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH, PUTHOOR HOUSE,
ANAKKARA VILLAGE, PUTTADY PO,
IDUKKI DISTRICT 685 551.
PRITTY JOSEPH (MINOR)
D/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH, PUTHOOR HOUSE,
ANAKKARA VILLAGE, PUTTADY PO,
IDUKKI DISTRICT 685 551
ALEN JOSEPH (MINOR)
S/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH, PUTHOOR HOUSE,
ANAKKARA VILLAGE, PUTTADY PO,
IDUKKI DISTRICT 685 551
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
MICHAEL JOSEPH (MINOR)
S/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH, PUTHOOR HOUSE,
ANAKKARA VILLAGE, PUTTADY PO,
IDUKKI DISTRICT 685 551
MARYKUTTY JOSEPH
W/O.JOSEPH P.M., PUTHOOR HOUSE,
ANAKKARA VILLAGE, PUTTADY PO,
IDUKKI DISTRICT 685 551
MS.YATHRA HOLIDAYS PVT. LTD
25 NEXT TO CITY HOSPTIAL MARUTHINGAR,
MAIN ROAD, HOSUR, MAIN ROAD MADIWALA,
BANGALORE 560068.
ESSA.N. IPE, S/O.N.T.ERAVE,
NADUMPARAMBIL HOUSE, PALLOM,
KOTTAYAM DISTRICT 686 007.
BY ADV SRI.P.C.HARIDAS
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH CO.64/2017, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
TUESDAY, THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 29TH MAGHA, 1946
CO NO. 64 OF 2017
IN MACA NO.3921 OF 2016 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
CROSS OBJECTORS/RESPONDENTS 1-5/PETITIONER:
LALY PRINCE
W/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH, AGED 40 YEARS,
PUTHOOR HOUSE, ANAKKARA VILLAGE,
PUTTADY PO, IDUKKI DISTRICT.
PRITTY JOSEPH (MINOR)
D/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH, AGED 13 YEARS,
PUTHOOR HOUSE, ANAKKARA VILLAGE,
PUTTADY PO, IDUKKI DISTRICT 685 551
REPRESENTED BY HER MOTHER AND NEXT FRIEND,
LALY PRINCE, W/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH,
AGED 40 YEARS, PUTHOOR HOUSE,
ANAKKARA VILLAGE, PUTTADY PO,
IDUKKI DISTRICT
ALEN JOSEPH (MINOR)
S/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH, AGED 11 YEARS,
PUTHOOR HOUSE, ANAKKARA VILLAGE,
PUTTADY PO, IDUKKI DISTRICT
REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER AND NEXT FRIEND,
LALY PRINCE, W/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH,
AGED 40 YAERS, PUTHOOR HOUSE,
ANAKKARA VILLAGE, PUTTADY PO,
IDUKKI DISTRICT 685 551
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
MICHAEL JOSEPH (MINOR)
S/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH, AGED 8 YEARS,
PUTHOOR HOUSE, ANAKKARA VILLAGE,
PUTTADY PO, IDUKKI DISTRICT
REPRESENTED BY HIS MOTHER AND NEXT FRIEND,
LALY PRINCE, W/O.LATE PRINCE JOSEPH,
AGED 40 YAERS, PUTHOOR HOUSE,
ANAKKARA VILLAGE, PUTTADY PO,
IDUKKI DISTRICT 685 551
MARYKUTTY JOSEPH
W/O.JOSEPH P.M. AGED 70 YEARS,
PUTHOOR HOUSE, ANAKKARA VILLAGE,
PUTTADY PO, IDUKKI DISTRICT
BY ADV P.C.HARIDAS
RESPONDENTS/APPELLANT-RESPONDENTS 6 & 7/RESPONDENT:
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO.LTD.
REPRESENTED BY ITS LEGAL CLAIMS MANAGER,
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD,
ERNAKULAM-682018
M/S YATHRA HOLIDAYS PVT. LTD
#25 NEXT TO CITY HOSPITAL,
MARUTHINNAGAR, MAIN ROAD HOSUR,
MAIN ROAD MADIWALA, BANGALORE-560068
ESSA N. IPE
S/O N. T. ERAVE, NADUMPARAMBIL HOUSE,
PALLOM, KOTTAYAM -686007
BY ADV TAPAS VARMA A.
THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FIANLLY
HEARD ON 18.02.2025, ALONG WITH MACA.3921/2016, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 18th day of February, 2025
Respondent No.3 in O.P.(M.V.). No.618/2014 on the file of the
Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-II, Thodupuzha is the appellant
herein. The petitioners in the O.P are the cross objectors. (For the
purpose of convenience, the parties are hereafter referred to as per their
rank before the Tribunal).
2. The O.P. was filed under under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988, by the wife, children and mother of the deceased by name
Prince Joseph, who died in a motor vehicle accident that occurred on
11.11.2012. According to them, the deceased was engaged by the 1 st
respondent as paid driver of the bus bearing registration No.KA-01AB5377. On 11.11.2012, while the bus was returning from Banglore to
Kottarakkara, at about 11 a.m., the bus hit behind a lorry bearing
registration No.TN 52-9946 and as a result of which he sustained serious
injuries and he succumbed to the injuries on the same day.
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
3.
The 2nd respondent was the driver of the bus at the time of
the accident. The 1st respondent is the owner and 3rd respondent is the
insurer of the offending vehicle. According to the petitioners, the accident
occurred due to the negligence of the 2nd respondent. The quantum of
compensation claimed in the O.P. was Rs.35,54,000/- limited to
Rs.35,00,000/4.
The insurance company filed a written statement, admitting the
accident as well as the policy but disputing the negligence on the part of the
2nd respondent. It was also contended that the accident occurred due to the
negligence of the driver of the lorry.
5.
The evidence in the case consists of the documentary evidence
Exts.A1 to A12 and B1.
6.
After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal found
negligence on the part of the2nd respondent, awarded a total compensation of
Rs.20,63,000/- and directed the 3rd respondent to pay the same.
7.
Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal, the Respondent No.3 preferred this appeal.
8. Now the points that arises for consideration are the following:
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
1) Whether Exhibit B1 policy covers the deceased also?
2) Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal is just and reasonable?
9. Heard Sri. A. Tapas Varma, the learned Standing Counsel appearing
for the 3rd respondent/appellant, and Sri. P.C. Haridas, the learned Counsel for
the petitioners/Cross objectors.
10.
The Points: In this case the accident as well as valid policy of the
offending vehicle are admitted. The main contention raised by the learned
standing counsel for the appellant is that at the time of the accident the
deceased was not the driver and hence Exhibit B1 policy does not cover him.
However, the Tribunal found that as per Exhibit B1, an additional sum of
Rs.25/- was collected in addition to the legal liability under IMT 40 and as
such the deceased being a spare driver, is covered under the policy.
The
learned counsel for the petitioners also relied upon the decision of a Single
Bench of this Court in Hariharan VV and Ors. v. Pailoth and Others
(MACA No.352/2018) decided on 7.11.2024, in which in a similar instance,
the learned Single Judge held that the spare driver is covered by the insurance
policy. Therefore, I do not find any ground to interfere with the finding of the
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
Tribunal that Exhibit B1 policy covers the deceased also.
11.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would argue that the
deceased was a driver by profession, earning Rs. 20,000/- per month, but the
Tribunal fixed his monthly income at Rs.9,000/-.The learned counsel for the
insurer would argue that the income fixed by the tribunal is reasonable.
12.
It is true that the petitioners could not prove the income of the
deceased, as claimed in the OP. However from Ext. A11 and A12, it is proved
that the deceased was a driver by profession. As per the dictum laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the decision in Ramachandrappa v. Manager,
Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC 236], the
notional income of a coolie, during the year 2012 will come to Rs.8,500/-.
Therefore, considering the fact that the deceased was a driver by profession,
his notional income is fixed at Rs.10,000/-, for the purpose of computing the
loss of dependency.
13.
On the date of accident, the deceased was aged 37 years.
Therefore, 40% of the monthly income is liable to be added towards future
prospects, as held in the decision in National Insurance Co.Ltd v Pranay
Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] and the multiplier to be applied is 15, as held in
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, (2009) 6 SCC 121.
Since the deceased was married who left behind 5 dependents, towards
personal and living expense, 1/4 of the income is liable to be deducted,
as held in Sarla Verma (supra). In the above circumstances, the loss of
dependency will come to Rs.18,90,000/-
14. The Tribunal has awarded Rs.5,000/-towards loss of estate,
Rs.25,000/- towards funeral expenses, Rs.1,00,000/- towards loss of
consortium and Rs.1,00,000/- towards love and affection. In the light of
the decision in Pranay Sethi (supra), the appellants are entitled to get a
consolidated sum of Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate, Rs.15,000/towards funeral expenses, and the dependents (parents, children and
spouse) are entitled to get a sum of Rs.40,000/- each towards loss of
consortium, with an increase of 10% in every three years. Therefore,
towards loss of estate and funeral expense they are entitled to get a sum
of Rs.18,150/- each. Towards loss of consortium, petitioners together are
entitled to get a sum of Rs.2,42,000/- (48,400 x 5).
15. Since compensation for loss of consortium was given, further
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
compensation for love and affection cannot be granted, in view of the
decision in New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Somwati and
Others, (2020)9 SCC 644. Therefore, the compensation awarded
towards love and affection is to be deducted.
16.
Towards the head ‘pain and sufferings’, the Tribunal has awarded
Rs.5000/- which according to the learned counsel for the petitioners, is on the
lower side. The deceased died in this case on the date of the accident. In the
above circumstances, I hold that the compensation awarded towards pain and
suffering is on the lower side, and hence, it is enhanced to Rs.25,000/17.
No change is required, in the amounts awarded on other heads,
as the compensation awarded on those heads appears to be just and
reasonable.
18.
Therefore, the petitioners/appellants are entitled to get a total
compensation of Rs.21,98,800/-, as modified and recalculated above and
given in the table below, for easy reference:
Sl.
No.
Head of Claim
Transportation expenses
5,000/-
5,000/-
Damage to clothing etc.
500/-
500/-
Amount awarded by
Tribunal (in Rs.)
Amount Awarded in
Appeal (in Rs.)
MACA. No.3921/2016 & CO 64/2017
2025:KER:17455
Love and affection
1,00,000/-
Nil
Loss of estate
5,000/-
18,150/-
Funeral expenses
25,000/-
18,150/-
Loss of dependency
18,22,500/-
18,90,000/-
Loss of consortium
1,00,000/-
2,42,000/-(48400x5)
Pain and suffering
5,000/-
25,000/-
Total
20,63,000/-
21,98,800/-
Enhanced Rs.1,15,800/-
19.
In the result, this Appeal and cross-objection are disposed of
directing the 3rd respondent to deposit a total sum of Rs.21,98,800/- (Rupees
twenty one lakh ninety eight thousand eight hundred only), less the amount
already deposited, if any, along with interest at the rate ordered by the
Tribunal from the date of the petition till realisation/deposit, within a period
of two months from today.
(Enhanced compensation will carry interest
@8%).
19. O
sou.
Sd/C. PRATHEEP KUMAR,
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review