Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.181 of 2023
Rekha Chakma
.....Petitioner
V_E_R_S_U_S
The State of Tripura & 4 Others
.....Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI.
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, G.A.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
02/05/2023
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. B.
Majumder, learned Deputy SGI, Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned G.A. assisted by
Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This petition has been filed under Article-226 of the Constitution
of India directing the respondents to give the family pension all post death
benefits including gratuity, full and final withdrawl of GPF to thepetitioner
following the death of the petitioner’s deceased husband on 10.10.2022 while
he was in the post of Rifleman, TSR, 6th BN TSR, Khowai, Tripura under the
respondents. Further, cancelling the letter dated 19.01.2023 issued by the
Deputy Secretary, Government of Tripura, Home Department to the Director
General of Police, Tripura.
[3]
The case of the petitioner is that the petitioner has filed this writ
petition for necessary direction upon the respondents to give her all post death
benefits including family pension, gratuity, full and final withdrawal of GPF
etc. following the death of the deceased husband on 10.10.2022 while he was in
the post of Rifleman, TSR, 6th BN TSR, Khowai, Tripura under the
respondents. The petitioner has also sought for quashing and cancelling the
letter dated 19.01.2023 issued by the Deputy Secretary, Govt. of Tripura, Home
Department, to the Director General of Police, Tripura.
[4]
Hence, the present petition has been filed by the petitioner before
this Court for redress.
[5]
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that
after marriage between the petitioner and the S. Babu (deceased herein) they
lived at their rented house at Chakmaghat and out of their marriage two sons
have been born. They are B. Rahul and B. Rabin, the birth certificate of the
petitioner’s sons recorded the names of Rekha Chakma i.e. the petitioner and
deceased S. Babu as their parents. After few months of marriage the dispute
arose between them and subsequently, the deceased a filed written statement in
the case No. Crl. Misc 05.2017 (125) before the Family Court, Unakoti Judicial
District. In the written statement he did not dispute the marriage. But the
respondent contended that the marriage between them had been dissolved
through the Chakma Social Panchayat.
[6]
However, as per settled position of law, the Chakma Social
Panchayat has no jurisdiction to dissolve the marriage between the petitioner
and the deceased S. Babu. The real fact was that marriage between them was
not dissolved by the so called panchayat and the marriage was subsisting. On
17.01.2018, the petitioner came on mutual understanding with her deceased
husband and filed the petition before the Court to withdraw the above
mentioned case as she did not want to proceed with the case any further.
[7]
After few days of withdrawal of the case, the problem again
cropped up between the petitioner and her husband. The deceased left h is wife
i.e. the petitioner in a rented house and denied to maintain her. in the year 2018
the petitioner was compelled to file a case i.e. Misc (DV) 03 of 2018 before the
Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Longtharai Valley, Dhalai Tripura against her
deceased husband.
Subsequently, the husband of the petitioner died on 10.10.2022 leaving behind
the two minor sons as legal heirs and survivors. At the time of death S. Babu
was 42 years old. The deceased was posted at 6th BN TSR (IR-II), Ramchandra
Ghat, Khowai, West Tripura.
[8]
After the death of the husband of the petitioner she is entitled to
family pension being the legally married wife of deceased Govt. employee. The
petitioner had her two minor sons are also entitled to all service benefits. On
17.11.2022 the petitioner has submitted representation to the Commandant, 6th
BN, TSR, Khowai and requested to provide her all the post death benefits
including regular monthly pension etc. following the death of deceased as the
petitioner is the legally married wife of the deceased. Thereafter, after getting
no response, the petitioner served a legal notice dated 08.01.2023 to the
Commandant, 6th BN, TSR, , Khowai for providing her all service benefits.
[9]
The Deputy Secretary, Govt. of Tripura, the respondent No.3 vide
letter dated 20.01.2023 directed the Director General of Police to take
necessary action as per views of law department. In the said letter referring to
the opinion of the law department, it is stated that though there is an order of
payment of Rs.3000pm given by the SDM in favour of the claimant, but it is
not the conclusive proof that the claimant was the legally wedded wife of the
deceased Govt. employee. Thereafter, the petitioner has submitted another
representation to the Director General of Police, the respondent No.2.
[10]
It is clear from the order of the learned Family Court that the
petitioner is the legally married wife of the deceased S. Babu and out of their
wedlock two sons have been born. In view of this, the respondents acted
unreasonably and arbitrarily by asking the petitioner to obtain the declaration
from the civil Court to the effect that she is the legally wedded wife of the
deceased S. Babu. The respondents ought to have acted upon the genuine claim
of the petitioner by releasing the family pension and post death benefits.
[11]
It has been submitted on behalf of the respondents that the office
of the respondent No.5 is discharging the duties of Authorization of pensionery
benefits of the State Govt. employees while the concerned HOD/DDOs are the
Pension Sanctioning Authority. In discharging the duty of Authorizing
authority, the office of the respondent No.5 is duty bound to scrupulously
follow the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 as adopted by the Tripura State
Government as well as the rules and regulations as issued by the Finance
department, Govt. of Tripura.
[12]
The bone of contention of the issue as transpires from the instant
writ petition reveals that the writ petitioner has filed the present case in order to
obtaining the pensioner benefits like family pension, gratuity, final withdrawal
of GPF etc. in respect of the deceased employee. But it reveals from the letter
of the Deputy Secretary, Govt. of Tripura dated 19.01.2023 that there may have
some matrimonial dispute.
[13]
In view of above discussion and observation, this Court is of the
view that the case of the petitioner is that she is the legally wedded wife of the
deceased government employee and she is also blessed with two children. It
has also been revealed that they were not in a cordial relationship and
subsequently, for separation, the petitioner is also approached before the
learned Family Court in this regard and taking recourse of the proceeding dated
17.01.2018, wherein, it has been categorically recorded in its docket
proceeding that the husband of the petitioner who is presently deceased has
accepted that the petitioner herein is his legally wedded wife and they had
blessed with two children and their names were also recorded in the service
record.
[14]
From the office of the Commandant, 6th Battalion TSR (IR-II),
Ramchandraghat, Khowai Tripura, regarding marital status, one letter has been
communicated to the petitioner and for the purpose of reference the relevant
part of the same may be reproduced herein below:
“......In this regard, Smt. Rekha Chakma has already been informed of the
legal opinion of the Law Departmetn, Government of Tripura on the issue
of authorization of family pension in respect of late S. Babu (Ex.Rfn (GD)
which was communicated from Home Department, Government of
Tripura vide letter No. F.42(4)-PD/2016/210 dated 19.01.2023.
Subsequently, Smt. Rekha Chakma has been asked to obtain a decree of
declaration in respect of marital status from the competent Civil Court
within a period of 01(one) month to the Office of the Commandant 6th
Battalion, TSR (IR-II) for taking further necessary action vide this office
letter No. 0801/F.25/TSR-6/Die-in-harness/2020 dated 27.01.2023. The
copy of views of Law Department as conveyed vide letter dated
19.01.2023 of the Home Department Government of Tripura and copy of
this office letter dated 27.01.2023 are enclosed herewith for ready
reference.
Therefore, appropriate course of action can be taken on production of a
decree of declaration in respect of marital status of Smt. Rekha Chakma
with the deceased and the status of B. Rahul & B. Rabin with the deceased
from the competent Civil Court in accordance with the legal opinion of the
Law Department, Government of Tripura on the issue....”
[15]
In support of her contention, birth certificate containing names of
the petitioner herein and also the father, deceased S. Babu was there and with
this document the petitioner has approached before the respondent but the
respondent has rejected the claim with regard to release of death benefits of the
deceased husband and contending that proper clarification from the Court
needs to be obtained and subsequently, the same was communicated to the
petitioner.
[16]
Thereafter, the present writ petition has been filed. It has been
stated that the name of the petitioner is not found in the service record and
becomes difficult for the respondent authority to take any such decision. In the
present circumstances, it is seen that counter affidavit has not yet been filed by
the respondent and sought for a month’s time for filing counter.
[17]
Since, this writ petition has already been admitted on 31.03.2023
and the petitioner is going around the office of the respondents for couple of
years, this Court feels that instead of keeping this petition pending, if the matter
is decided by the respondents and accordingly, the same is ordered. However,
liberty it given to the petitioner to approach before the respondents with all the
relevant documents including the records of the judicial proceeding in support
of her claim with regard to her claims as prayed in this petition and represent
the matter. On such receipt of the representation, the respondents shall consider
the same in accordance with law and after determination, the same be
communicated to the concerned respondents for doing the needful as early as
possible preferably within a period of two months after receipt of such
representation from the end of the petitioner.
[18]
In that view of the matter, the present petition stands disposed of.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review