The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. The petition originally filed as Ext.P3 – I.A. No.1/2022, was dismissed as per Ext.P5 holding that the 1 st defendant, who is present in the court, in the enquiry gave rational answers and in the said circumstance the court was satisfied that the 1 st defendant is fit and competent to defend the case and accordingly, the application was dismissed. But the said finding was interfered by this Court in Ext.P8 judgment and ordered that the 1 st defendant should be examined by a Medical Board and further ordered that in order to save the time in constituting a Medical Board, the 1 st defendant could be subjected to examination by the senior most Psychiatrist attached to the District Hospital, Ernakulam. Thereafter the 1st defendant was examined by a Psychiatrist attached to the District Hospital, Ernakulam and Ext.P9 report was submitted, wherein it is reported that the 1 st defendant has a past history suggestive of Alcohol Dependence pattern and Alcohol induced behavioral changes affecting his functioning for which he had been taking treatments both as inpatient and outpatient from O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024 :6: various Mental Health Establishments and it is also reported that the 1st defendant denied taking psychiatric medicine at present and that he is abstinent from drinking alcohol for past few months and he is not showing any major behavioral changes. In the said circumstances …
5. In the judgment in Gopakumar 's case cited (Supra), the Court interfered with the same for the reason that the Court itself O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024 :7: entered into a conclusion that the petitioner therein is not capable of protecting his interest for the reason that certain answers were found to be not rational and that the finding was entered without referring the petitioner therein for Medical Board for expert evidence. This Court also interfered with the earlier order passed as per Ext.P8 judgment for the reason that the 1 st defendant was not examined by a qualified Psychiatrist attached to the District Hospital, Ernakulam. Pursuant to the directions issued by this Court, the petitioner was examined by Psychiatrist, General Hospital, Ernakulam, who has specifically reported that in the current mental status examination of the 1 st defendant, he is found to be normal and is having a sound mind at present to undergo court proceedings. It is on the strength of the said report that the court entered into a finding as per Ext.P11 that the request of the petitioners herein for appointment of a guardian for the 1 st defendant need not be allowed. It is settled law that the prime concern of the court is to find out as to whether a person who is said to be mentally ill could defend himself properly or not. I am of the view that the trial court has taken necessary steps to find out…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
TUESDAY, THE 30TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 8TH SRAVANA, 1946
OP(C) NO. 1512 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 06.06.2024 IN OTHERS 45/2024 IN OS
NO.1158 OF 2013 OF II ADDITIONAL MUNSIFF COURT, ERNAKULAM
PETITIONERS/PLAINTIFFS:
REJITHA MOL R
AGED 43 YEARS
W/O SREEKUMAR, KATTIPARAMBIL HOUSE, IYMANAM,
KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, PIN - 686005
RENJITHA MOL R
AGED 40 YEARS
W/O GIREESH, PUTHUPARAMBIL CHERUVATHUR P.O., ,
KOTHAMANGALAM, ERNAKULAM, PIN - 686666
BY ADV M.R.MINI
RESPONDENT/1ST DEFENDANT:
RENJITH KUMAR M.R.
AGED 38 YEARS
S/O REGHUNATH, XVI/231, NEAR JANATHA CLINIC,
VELIPARAMBIL MYTHRI NAGAR, VAIKOM ROAD,
THEKKUMBHAGAM, THRIPUNITHURA., PIN – 682301
THIS
30.07.2024,
FOLLOWING:
OP
(CIVIL)
THE
COURT
HAVING
ON
COME
THE
UP
SAME
FOR
DAY
ADMISSION
DELIVERED
ON
THE
O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024
---
:2:
VIJU ABRAHAM, J.
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -O.P.(C) No.1512 of 2024
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -Dated this the 30th day of July, 2024
JUDGMENT
The petitioners have approached this Court challenging
Exts.P11 and P13 orders.
2. The petitioners herein are the plaintiffs in the suit and the
respondent is the 1st defendant. The 2nd defendant died pending
suit. The suit is one for partition and for other consequential
reliefs. It is the case of the petitioners that pending the suit, the 1 st
defendant/respondent herein had developed some mental disorder
and was admitted in Idukki District Co-operative Hospital for
treatment and the consultant Psychiatrist Dr.K.Sudarsan filed a
report dated 03.09.2019 before the trial court describing his
mental condition and stated that he needs prolonged medication
and management in a sheltered environment. Thereupon the
petitioners filed Ext.P3 application under Order XXXII Rule 2 and
of CPC seeking appointment of a court guardian to the 1 st
defendant for conducting the case. The trial court dismissed the
said application by Ext.P5 as the 1st defendant has given rational
answers to the question put to him by the court during enquiry and
O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024
:3:
as he is fit and competent to defend the case, appointment of a
guardian is not necessary. The petitioners sought review of the said
order, which was also dismissed as per Ext.P7 order. Aggrieved by
Exts.P5 and P7 Orders, petitioners approached this Court filing
O.P.(C) No. 2677/2023, which was disposed of as per Ext.P8
judgment directing the trial court to issue necessary orders to
enable
examination of the 1st defendant by a senior most
Psychiatrist attached to the District Hospital. In compliance with
the directions in Ext.P8, the 1 st defendant was subjected to medical
examination. The Psychiatrist who examined the 1 st defendant filed
Ext.P9 interim report stating that he is not showing any behavioral
changes and current mental examination status found to be normal
and that he is having a sound mind at present to undergo court
proceedings but also stated that for final conclusion, further
evaluation and admission at Government Hospital is required. The
doctor, who prepared the said report, was examined and the report
was also marked. The trial court after considering the report and
evidence of the doctor, as per Ext.P11 order found that the 1 st
defendant is fit for trial and posted the matter for evidence.
Thereupon the petitioners filed an application seeking to review of
Ext.P11 order, which was rejected by Ext.P13 order. It is in the
O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024
:4:
said circumstances that the petitioners have approached this Court
challenging Exts.P11 and P13 orders.
3. The learned counsel for the petitioners relying on the
judgment in Gopakumar v. Madhusoodanan Nair & Another
2023 (6) KHC 63] submits that the impugned orders issued by
the trial court is not in accordance with the mandates of Order
XXXII Rule 15 CPC. In the said judgment this Court held that the
Court should adopt a pragmatic approach and if it is found
necessary, call for further evidence including medical evidence,
instead of jumping into a conclusion merely on the ground that
some of the answers which were given by the person were found to
be not convincing or rational and the procedure, then available, is
to refer the parties to a Medical Board so as to obtain a report
regarding any mental ailment, retardation or disorder or any
impairment of mental ability to take a rational decision pertaining
to his affairs or to protect his interest and in Gopakumar's case
cited (Supra) the Court found that as no enquiry was conducted by
either referring the petitioner therein to a Medical Board or for an
expert evidence or by calling upon medical records, but simply
jumped into a conclusion on examination of the petitioner by the
court and found that he is not capable of protecting his interest
:5:
O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024
simply for the reason that certain answers were found to be not
rational.
It is on the strength of the said judgment, the petitioners
would contend that the findings in Exts.P11 and P13 are liable to
be interfered with.
4. The petition originally filed as Ext.P3 – I.A. No.1/2022, was
dismissed as per Ext.P5 holding that the 1 st defendant, who is
present in the court, in the enquiry gave rational answers and in
the said circumstance the court was satisfied that the 1 st defendant
is fit and competent to defend the case and accordingly, the
application was dismissed. But the said finding was interfered by
this Court in Ext.P8 judgment and ordered that the 1 st defendant
should be examined by a Medical Board and further ordered that in
order to save the time in constituting a Medical Board, the 1 st
defendant could be subjected to examination by the senior most
Psychiatrist
attached
to
the
District
Hospital,
Ernakulam.
Thereafter the 1st defendant was examined by a Psychiatrist
attached to the District Hospital, Ernakulam and Ext.P9 report was
submitted, wherein it is reported that the 1 st defendant has a past
history suggestive of Alcohol Dependence pattern and Alcohol
induced behavioral changes affecting his functioning for which he
had been taking treatments both as inpatient and outpatient from
O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024
:6:
various Mental Health Establishments and it is also reported that
the 1st defendant denied taking psychiatric medicine at present and
that he is abstinent from drinking alcohol for past few months and
he is not showing any major behavioral changes. In the said
circumstances it is reported in Ext.P9 that in the current mental
status examination he was found to be normal and the 1 st defendant
is having a sound mind at present to undergo court proceedings. It
is also stated that for reaching a final conclusion he need to be
admitted
and
evaluated
in
a
Government
Mental
Health
Establishment for adequate period of time. The Doctor was also
examined and deposition of the Doctor is produced as Ext.P10. The
court on the basis of the interaction with the 1 st defendant in the
enquiry conducted earlier and on the basis of the report of the
Psychiatrist, by Ext.P11 order found that the 1 st defendant is
competent to protect his interest and defend the case and also
found that he is not having any mental infirmity to defend his case
and protect his interest and therefore, there is no necessity to
appoint a guardian to protect his interest as he is very well capable
of protecting his interest.
5. In the judgment in Gopakumar 's case cited (Supra), the
Court interfered with the same for the reason that the Court itself
O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024
:7:
entered into a conclusion that the petitioner therein is not capable
of protecting his interest for the reason that certain answers were
found to be not rational and that the finding was entered without
referring the petitioner therein for Medical Board for expert
evidence. This Court also interfered with the earlier order passed
as per Ext.P8 judgment for the reason that the 1 st defendant was
not examined by a qualified Psychiatrist attached to the District
Hospital, Ernakulam.
Pursuant to the directions issued by this
Court, the petitioner was examined by Psychiatrist, General
Hospital, Ernakulam, who has specifically reported that in the
current mental status examination of the 1 st defendant, he is found
to be normal and is having a sound mind at present to undergo
court proceedings. It is on the strength of the said report that the
court entered into a finding as per Ext.P11 that the request of the
petitioners herein for appointment of a guardian for the 1 st
defendant need not be allowed.
It is settled law that the prime
concern of the court is to find out as to whether a person who is
said to be mentally ill could defend himself properly or not. I am of
the view that the trial court has taken necessary steps to find out
as to whether a guardian is to be appointed for the 1 st defendant
and in the interaction with him while conducting enquiry by the
O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024
:8:
Court, as well as in the report of the Psychiatrist it is clearly stated
that the 1st defendant is having sound mind at present to undergo
court proceedings.
In view of the above facts and circumstances, I find no reason
to interfere with the orders impugned in this original petition and
the same is accordingly dismissed.
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sm/
O.P.(C). No.1512 of 2024
:9:
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1512/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE PLAINT DATED 28.10.2013
IN O.S.NO.1158 OF 2013 ON THE FILES OF
THE
II
ADDITIONAL
MUNSIFF
COURT,
ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT DATED
15.10.2018 FILED BY THE 1ST DEFENDANT.
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF I.A.12022 DATED 22.06.2022
FILED UNDER ORDER XXXII RULE 2 AND 15
FILED IN O.S.NO.1158/2013.
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 03.09.2019
GIVEN BY DR.K.SUDARSAN.
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 23.01.2023
IN I.A. 1/2022 IN O.S.1158/2013
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF R.P.NO.9/2023 IN I.A.NO.
1/2022 DATED 22.02.2023.
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 07.07.2023
IN R.P.9/2023 IN I.A.1.2022
Exhibit P8
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
JUDGMENT
DATED
30.01.2024 IN OP(C) 2677 OF 2023.
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM REPORT DATED
21.02.2024 ISSUED BY DR. AJEESH P.R.,
CONSULTANT PSYCHIATRIST, GENERAL HOSPITAL
ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P10
TYPED COPY OF THE ORAL EVIDENCE GIVEN BY
DR. AJEESH P.R., CONSULTANT PSYCHIATRIST,
GENERAL HOSPITAL ERNAKULAM ALONG WITH
ORIGINAL
Exhibit P11
TYPED COPY OF ORDER DATED 06.04.2024 IN
O.S. NO. 1158/2013 ON THE FILES OF THE II
ADDITIONAL MUNSIFF COURT, ERNAKULAM ALONG
WITH ORIGINAL
Exhibit P12
TRUE COPY OF REVIEW PETITION NO.45/2024
DATED 22.05.2024
Exhibit P13
TYPED COPY OF ORDER DATED 06.06.2024 IN
REVIEW PETITION NO.45/2024 IN O.S. NO.
1158/2013
ON
THE
FILES
OF
THE
II
ADDITIONAL MUNSIFF COURT, ERNAKULAM ALONG
WITH ORIGINAL
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review