Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS.
CRR 4808 OF 2022
REETU MUKHERJEE
VS.
THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Kamalesh Chandra Saha, Adv.
Ms. Payel Mitra, Adv.
Ms. Piali Santra, Adv.
Mr. Anurag Bose, Adv.
For the Opposite Party
No. 2
:
Mr. Shibaji Kumat Das, Adv.
Ms. Deblina De, Adv.
For the State
:
Mr. Suman De, Adv.
Ms. Sana Naaz, Adv.
Last heard on
:
27.02.2026
Judgement on
:
08.06.2026
Uploaded on
:
08.06.2026
CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS, J. :1. The application has been filed for quashing of the entire proceeding as well as
the FIR and the order dated 30.11.2022 and subsequent orders passed therein
by the Learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Barrackpore in Dum Dum
P.S. case no. 272 of 2022, under Section 406/506/120B/34 of the Indian
Penal Code Pending before the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Barrackpore, District 24 Parganas North.
Brief Fact of the case
2. It is the case of the petitioner that the opposite party no. 2 being the husband
of the present petitioner filed a complaint under Section 156 (3) of Cr.P.C
before the learned court alleging criminal breach of trust and criminal
intimidation as she kept all his valuable documents under her custody and
she did not return the same. It was averred in the petition of complaint that
after marriage commenced on 10.12.2004, they started their conjugal life at
the parental address of the opposite party no. 2 and on good faith the opposite
party no. 2 handed over his important documents and papers to the petitioner.
It is the case of the petitioner that she kept valuable documents and papers in
her custody, but gave ultimatum that she will destroy the valuable documents,
which includes the school certificate, mark sheet and books, technical
certificate, birth certificate, Indane gas certificate, marriage certificate, bank
fixed deposit, and other papers, including the air conditioners, sofa set table,
bed, television, along with the gold Jewelleries, the details of which has been
described in the complaint. It was further alleged that despite repeated
demand and request made to the petitioner, she refused to return back the
same documents and lastly he had to lodge a general diary with Bizpur Police
Station being GDE no. 1387 dated 15.3.2022 against the petitioner for her
illegal acts, but as no action was taken and
he lodged complaint to the
Commissioner of Police, Barrackpore Commissionerate on 21.3.2022, which
also yielded no result .Hence filed the complaint before the court under section
156(3) Cr.P.C. The further case of the petitioner that the Opposite Party
no.
2 lodged a frivolous complaint against the petitioner as a counter blast to the
complaint lodged by her against the husband
and other members of the
matrimonial house before Dum Dum P.S. being Dum Dum P.S. case no. 192 of
2022 dated 17.3.2022, under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code and the
instant complaint is lodged maliciously and
failed to disclose any offence
against the petitioner and thus the said F.I.R, and the order passed in is liable
to be quashed.
3. It is further her case that without applying the specific provisions of law, the
investigating officer seized some articles which do not belong to the Opposite
Party no. 2, and the learned Court passed an order for handing over the same
in favour of the Opposite Party no. 2. On 30.11.2022, on the prayer of the
Opposite Party no. 2 the learned court once again passed an order of search
warrant for recovery of the remaining article in terms of Section 93 and 94
Cr.P.C without verifying any documents regarding the ownership of the said
article. Accordingly prayed for setting aside such order. It is further submitted
that the entire allegation is civil in nature and there is no criminal liability
against the petitioner and it is imperative that in the interest of justice, all the
impugned proceedings should be quashed.
Submissions
4. The learned Advocate representing the petitioner further submits that an
application under Section 13 (1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 has been
filed by the present Opposite Party no. 2 for a decree of divorce. A revisional
application was filed against an order dated 17.2.2023 passed by the learned
Executive Magistrate, Barrackpore, 24 Parganas North in connection with M.P
case no. 240 of 2022, under section 107 of Cr.P.C filed by the Opposite Party
no.2, and the learned coordinate bench by an order dated 25.11.2024,
quashed the entire proceeding . The learned advocate on the other hand
argued that in course of investigation, the investigating officer seized number
of documents some of which were mentioned in the petition of complaint and it
prima facie proved the allegation levelled by the present Opposite Party no. 2
made against the petitioner. She claimed to be not aware about the document
seized from her, which separately showed her ill intention as those were seized
from her custody. She also did not give any objection when those documents
were handed over to the present petitioner. The other articles are still lying in
her custody and therefore it is necessary that the proceeding must be allowed
to be continued.
5. The prosecution on the other hand argued that at the time of investigation
when the documents, books and LIC policy certificate, birth certificate, etc.
were seized, but due to non-availability of documents, other article being took
air, conditioner, sofa set, table set, bed, TV, and Gold ornament would not be
seized. It is further submitted that number of litigations are pending between
the parties and on completion of investigation, the charge sheet has been
submitted against the present petitioner for which the trial should be allowed
to be continued.
Analysis
6. Heard the submissions. The complaint lodged
by the O.P no. 2 specifically
alleged about handing over important documents and papers to the present
petitioner being wife after marriage which were in her custody, but she gave
threat to destroy the valuable documents and denied to return the same. The
Learned court found that petition discloses prima facie existence of cognizable
offence and hence send the petition by hand to the I/C of Dum Dum Police
Station with a direction to treat the same as F.I.R. After the articles were
seized, it was kept under the custody of the present opposite party.no.2 by
furnishing zimmanama after executing a bond. On perusal of the report the
learned court, passed the direction to take effective steps for recovery of the
articles as mentioned in the written complaint and this revisional application
is filed to quash the entire proceeding as well as the order dated 30.11.2022.
In the decision as relied upon in Muskan versus Ishaan Khan1, it was held
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that normally for quashing an F.I.R, it must be
shown that there exists no prima facie case against the accused persons. In
the said case, the Hon’ble court found allegations of harassment and demand
of dowry and found those were filed by the Appellant without mentioning the
specific instances which were later on mentioned and held it as an
afterthought and counter blast to the legal notice sent by the husband to the
appellant and therefore observed that the approach adopted by the High Court
amounts to conducting a mini trial. Hence, reversed, such order of quashing.
2025 SCC online SC 2355
7. The learned In the case of Chandrasekhar Singh and others versus State
of U.P2 and others, the learned Single Judge of High Court of judicature at
Allahabad took note of the decision of Sadhupati Nageswar Rao vs State of
Andhra Pradesh3 where it was held that“The basic requirements to bring home the
accusations under section 305 of the Code are
the
requirements
to
prove
conjointly
(i)
entrustment and (ii) whether the accused was
actuated
by
dishonest
intention
or
not,
misappropriated it or converted it to his own use
to the detriment of the persons who entrusted it.”
In the decision of Pratibha Rani vs Suraj Kumar and Anr.4 it was held
that:“…..the fundamental core of the offence of
criminal breach of trust is that a property must
be entrusted and the dominion of the property
should be given to the trustee.”
8. Here the opposite party no. 2 specifically stated in his written complaint that
after marriage on good faith he handed over those documents like the birth
certificate, technical papers ,School certificates birth certificate, Aadhaar card
of the present petitioner, along with other valuable documents to the petitioner
which she refused to return and some of them were seized from the custody of
the present petitioner from her flat situated at 45, Arvind Sarani, F-4C Nerima
Apartment, West, Kamalpur, Dum Dum, District 24 Parganas North. The said
documents were produced by the petitioner in presence of the Opposite Party
no. 2 to whom such documents were handed over under zimma. In fact, the
CRR 1252 of 2004
AIR 2012 SC 3242
(1985) 2 SCC 370
materials so collected during enquiry would further reveal that other articles
as mentioned in the written complaint was also found in her custody , but
because of non-cooperation and threatening, those cannot be seized and hence
the court passed the order of reseize. No justification can be found from the
record in this case that as to why the birth certificate and Aadhaar card and
other important valuable personal documents were found from her custody. In
the petition before this court on oath, the petitioner has said that the
investigating officers seized some articles which do not belong to the Opposite
Party no. 2, but it has been denied by the present Opposite Party no. 2 and he
received the documents under zimmanama after executing a bond.
9. Therefore when primarily as per the complaint the documents and some
articles were found from her custody who was the wife of the opposite party no
2 so it can be said that he had the confidence in the person taking the articles
so it is a clear allegation of entrustment by the husband to the wife. The
opposite party
received those documents after being satisfied and after
executing a bond of Rs 50,000/- in such situation questioning of the
ownership those articles or papers whether those belongs to the husband or
not, can only be ascertained at the time of trial. The petitioner failed to
establish before this court that as a counterblast to the complaint filed by her
against her husband under Section 498A of IPC, the Opposite Party no. 2 has
filed the complaint and or no such documents were recovered from her
custody. In the decision of Pratibha Rani versus Suraj Kumar and Anr.5,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court discussed the requirement to maintain the charge
of criminal breach of trust and in paragraph 41 observed5
(1985) 2SCC 370
“41. The Supreme Court in a large number of
cases has held that the fundamental core of the
offence of criminal breach of trust is that a
property must be entrusted and the dominion of
the property should be given to the trustee…….”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court took note of the case of Jaswantrai Manilal
Akhaney vs state of Bombay 6 where it was held :“43. For an offence under Section 409 of the
Penal Code, 1860, the first essential ingredient
to
be
proved
entrusted…..
is
but
that
the
property
when
section
was
which
defines ‘criminal breach of trust’ speaks of a
person being in any manner entrusted with
property, it does not contemplate the creation of
a trust with all the technicalities of the law of
trust.
It
contemplates
the
creation
of
a
relationship whereby the owner of property
makes it over to another person to be retained by
him until a certain contingency arises or to be
disposed of by him on the happening of a certain
event.”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court further observed that“48. In the case of State of Gujarat versus
Jaswantlal Nathalal (1968) 2 SCR 408,
Hegde. J., speaking for the Court observed thus:
the expression ‘entrustment’ carries with it the
implication that the person handing over any
property or on whose behalf that property is
handed over to another, continues to be its
owner. Further the person handing over the
AIR 1956 SC 575
property must have confidence in the person
taking the property so as to create a fiduciary
relationship between them.”
10. In the instant case during subsistence of marriage tie the opposite party
handed over his valuable documents as described in the petition of complaint
to his wife. Whether she took those documents or the other article and
jewelleries or denied to hand over the same on demand is to be proved in
course of evidence. Merely a criminal complaint is pending against the
husband the complaint lodged by the husband cannot be treated as a counter
blast to the same when it is evident valuable documents like Adhar card ,Birth
certificate of the opposite party no. 2 are found lying under the custody of the
petitioner who was residing in a different flat. The learned court passed the
order to re –seize the articles after being satisfied about the ownership of the
same but the provision is clear that there must be reason to believe and in this
case in the order passed by the learned court no such specific satisfaction can
be found specially in respect of the furniture ,fixtures and gold jewelleries and
therefore this court is inclined to set aside the said order with a direction to
the learned court for further consideration in accordance with law.
11.
It was held by the Hon’ble Supreme court that the inherent power which is
sought to be entertained is naturally to be exercised to do the right and undo
wrong in the course of administration of justice.
So far the charge under
section 506 IPC in order to attract ingredient of Section 506 IPC, the intention
of the accused must be found to cause alarm to the victim. Mere vague and
bald allegation that the accused threatened the victim with dire consequences
without any intention to cause alarm would not suffice to attract the
provisions under Section 506 I.P.C. and in the instant case no such specific
allegations are found to such extent .While giving evidence during SA also the
complainant did not say anything about any threatening hence the complaint
alleging commission of offence under Section 506 IPC so no prima facie case to
attract this provision is attracted .Similarly no iota of materials can be found
in the F.I.R to allow the proceeding with the charge under Section 120B IPC
against the petitioner.
Conclusion
12. Therefore the sum and substance of the above deliberation and on reading
the complaint as a whole it results in conclusion that the proceeding pending
with the allegation against the petitioner under section 406IPC cannot be
quashed since it cannot be said to be the abuse of the process of law and the
fact requires to be substantiated by adducing evidence and the available
materials therefore does not warrant to exercise the jurisdiction under section
in this case to quash the entire proceeding. This court therefore in
exercise of the inherent jurisdiction quashes the charge under Section
506/120B IPC directing the Learned Magistrate to proceed with the case with
the charge under Section 406 IPC.
13. However this Court does not find enough reasoning to pass the order dated
30.11.2022 to re-seize and hence directs the Learned Magistrate to hear afresh
in accordance with law.
14. In the result the Criminal Revisional application stands partly allowed with
the above observation.
15. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.
[CHAITALI CHATTERJEE (DAS), J.]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review