The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. In view of the foregoing analysis no offence under Section 306, 506 and 34 of the IPC is made out against the petitioners even if the allegations levelled against them are assumed to be true. As a consequence, the petition is allowed and FIR bearing Crime No.341/2022 registered at Police Station Jeeran, District Neemuch for offence under Section 306, 506 and 34 of the IPC and all proceedings subsequent thereto against the petitioners including order dated 6/12/2023 passed by the trial Court framing charge against the petitioners are hereby quashed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
--1--
IN THE
HIGH COURT
OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 4th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 56912 of 2023
BETWEEN:RAVI DAS S/O GOPAL DAS BAIRAGI, AGED ABOUT 22
1. YEARS, OCCUPATION: STUDENT, R/O VILLAGE
KUCHROD, P.S. JEERAN, (MADHYA PRADESH)
SUNITA W/O GOPAL DAS BAIRAGI, AGED ABOUT 40
YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSE WIFE, R/O VILLAGE
2.
KUCHROD, P.S. JEERAN, DISTRICT NEEMUCH (MADHYA
PRADESH)
YASHODABAI W/O MOHAN DAS BAIRAGI, AGED ABOUT
75 YEARS, OCCUPATION: STUDENT, R/O VILLAGE
3.
KUCHROD, P.S. JEERAN, DISTRICT NEEMUCH (MADHYA
PRADESH)
GOPAL DAS S/O MOHAN DAS BAIRAGI, AGED ABOUT 50
YEARS, OCCUPATION: STUDENT, R/O VILLAGE
4.
KUCHROD, P.S. JEERAN, DISTRICT NEEMUCH (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI ABHAY SARASWAT, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS).
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH P.S.
JEERAN, DISTRICT NEEMUCH
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI ANENDRA SINGH PARIHAR, P.L. FOR RESPONDENT/STATE)
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 56426 of 2023
BETWEEN:JABIR HUSAIN KHAN S/O SABBIR HUSAIN KHAN, AGED
--2-ABOUT 51 YEARS, OCCUPATION: REVENUE INSPECTOR
R/O.819, ABHINANDAN VISTAR 1, MANDSAUR DISTRICT
MANDSAUR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI HIMANSHU THAKUR, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH P.S.
JEERAN, DISTRICT NEEMUCH)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI ANENDRA SINGH PARIHAR, P.L. FOR STATE)
This application coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
1.
ORDER
Heard. Perused the case diary.
2.
Since these applications are arising out of the same crime number and
are related to the same offence, they have been heard together and are being
decided by the common order.
3.
These petitions have been preferred by the petitioners / accused for
quashing the FIR registered vide Crime No.341/2022 at police station Jeeran,
District Neemuch and all subsequent proceedings pursuant thereto including
the order dated 6/12/2023 passed by the 1st Addl. Sessions Judge, District
Neemuch framing charge against them for offence punishable under Section
306, 506 and 34 of the IPC.
4.
As per the prosecution, one Balwant Bairagi committed suicide on
10.11.2022 by consuming a poisonous substance. Thereafter investigation was
commenced in which a suicide note in the handwriting of the deceased was
recovered in which he had stated that his family members are not responsible
for his death and that the accused named therein are so responsible. Thereafter
the statements of his family members were recorded from which it transpired
that a dispute as regards a right of way had been pending between the
--3-deceased and the accused since the year 2016. The deceased had been trying to
get open the way and had initiated proceedings before Tehsil Office Jeeran in
that regard in which an order was passed on 25/8/2017 in his favour yet the
encroachment over the way was not removed. Whenever the deceased used to
go over the way, the present petitioners and the other accused persons used to
fight with him. As a result of the dispute as regards the way not getting settled
the deceased used to remain tensed. The accused persons used to fight with the
deceased and had threatened him that if he shall initiate legal proceedings his
son would be implicated in a false case. As a result of the harassment having
been meted out to him by the petitioners and the other co-accused persons, the
deceased eventually committed suicide. Upon completion of the investigation
charge sheet has been filed by the police before the Court concerned and
eventually charge as aforesaid has been framed against them.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the petitioners are
innocent and have falsely been implicated in the case. The entire allegations as
levelled against the petitioners even if taken to be true at their face value do
not amount to an offence punishable under Section 306 of the IPC. There is no
allegation against the petitioners of either instigating or abetting the deceased
in any manner to commit suicide and it cannot be said that due to act of the
petitioners, the deceased had no other option but to commit suicide. He had
various other legal remedies available to him. The only allegations against the
present petitioners are that whenever the deceased used to go over the way, the
present petitioners and the other accused persons used to fight with him. As a
result of the dispute as regards the way not getting settled the deceased used to
remain troubled. The accused persons used to fight with the deceased and had
threatened him that if he shall initiate legal proceedings his son would be
implicated in a false case. The same cannot in any manner be said to be
abetment or instigation or even a remote cause for the deceased to commit
--4-suicide. It is hence submitted that the FIR registered against the petitioners be
quashed.
6.
Per contra learned counsel for the respondent/State has submitted that
there is sufficient material available on record to proceed against the
petitioners and it cannot be said that no offence whatsoever is made out in
view of which the petition deserves to be dismissed.
7.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and have perused
the record.
8.
Section 107 of the IPC makes it obligatory for the prosecution to show
and establish the elements of instigation. The Apex Court in the case of Sanju
@ Sanjay Singh Senger V/s. State of M.P., AIR 2002 SC 1998 has opined as
under :“Even if we accept the prosecution story that the appellant did tell the
deceased “to go and die”, that itself does not constitute the ingredient of
“instigation” the word “instigate” denotes incitement or urging to do
some drastic or inadvisable action or to stimulate or incite. Presence of
mens rea, therefore, is the necessary concomitant of instigation. It is
common knowledge that the words uttered in a quarrel or on the spur of
the moment cannot be taken to be uttered with mens rea it is in a fit of
anger and emotion.”
9.
In the case of Sanju @ Sanjay (supra) the accused allegedly told the
deceased "to go and die". Yet Apex Court opined that it does not constitute the
ingredient of "instigation". In the instant case if story of the prosecution is read
and believed as such it would be clear that the petitioners did not in any
manner instigate the deceased to commit suicide. There is no element of
"incitement" or "instigation" on their behalf. Thus Section 306 of the IPC is
not attracted against the petitioners.
10.
The ancillary question is whether their acts fall within the ambit of
Section 306 of the IPC. In Gangula Mohan Reddi V/s. State of Andhra
Pradesh 2010 (1) SCC 750 the Apex Court opined as under :17. Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or
--5-intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act
on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide,
conviction cannot be sustained. The intention of the legislature and the
ratio of the cases decided by this Court is clear that in order to convict a
person under Section 306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to
commit the offence. It also requires an active act or direct act which led
the deceased to commit suicide seeing no option and this act must have
been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he
committed suicide.
11.
The principle flowing from this judgment is that the overt act of accused
person must be of a nature where the victim had no option but to commit
suicide. Even assuming that whenever the deceased used to go over the way,
the present petitioners and the other accused persons used to fight with him
and threaten him that if he shall initiate legal proceedings his son would be
implicated in a false case, this does not fall within the ambit of "incitement" or
"instigation".
12.
This Court in Hukum Singh Yadav V/s. State of M.P. reported in ILR
(2011) MP 1089 considered the judgment of Supreme Court in Sanju @
Sanjay Singh Senger and held as under :10. Considering these legal aspect this is to be observed that whether
applicants have had same knowledge that deceased would commit
suicide. As per the prosecution case when deceased was going with his
father. Applicants restrained deceased and his father Jagdish and
abused and threatened both of them, hence it cannot be assumed that
applicants had knowledge that one of them particularly deceased will
commit suicide. When act of abusing and threatening was alleged to be
done with deceased as well as his father, so it cannot be said that
applicants had knowledge or intention that deceased should commit
surcide. There is no evidence that they provoked, incited or encouraged
deceased to commit suicide. It is also not alleged that when applicants
threatened to kili deceased and his father Jagdish they were armed with
some weapons. So it cannot be presumed that deceased was so
frightened that he had no option left except committing suicide and was
compelled to do so.
13.
The act of the petitioners, in the opinion of this Court does not attract
Sections 306 of the IPC. In absence of establishing necessary ingredients for
attracting Section 306 of the IPC, the petitioners cannot be compelled to face
--6-the trial unnecessarily.
14.
In view of the foregoing analysis no offence under Section 306, 506 and
34 of the IPC is made out against the petitioners even if the allegations
levelled against them are assumed to be true. As a consequence, the petition is
allowed and FIR bearing Crime No.341/2022 registered at Police Station
Jeeran, District Neemuch for offence under Section 306, 506 and 34 of the IPC
and all proceedings subsequent thereto against the petitioners including order
dated 6/12/2023 passed by the trial Court framing charge against the
petitioners are hereby quashed.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
SS/Digitally signed by SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Date: 2024.01.05 13:34:57
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review