Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 04
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
OWP No. 857/2013
IA No. 1184/2013
CM No. 5436/2025
Date of Pronouncement:11.08.2026
Uploaded on: 17.08.2026
Rattan Chand
…. Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through:- Mr. Achal Sharma, Advocate with
Ms. Arti Devi, Advocate &
Mr. Keshav Verma, Advocate
V/s
…. Respondent(s)
State of J&K and others
Through :-
Mr. Adarsh Bhagat, GA for R-1 & 2
Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr.AAG (Sr. Advocate) with
Ms. Nazia Fazal, Assisting Counsel for R-3 & 4
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR
ORDER
1.
The case set up by the petitioner is that he is the owner in possession of
two parcels of land situated at Hazuri Bagh, Tehsil and District Jammu:
one measuring 2 kanals and 13 marlas, Khasra No. 141, and the other
measuring 3 kanals and 4 marlas, Khasra No. 144 Min. According to the
petitioner, the aforesaid parcels have been consolidated into a single plot
by raising a common boundary wall. It is averred that one Balbir Singh
had instituted a writ petition in the nature of Public Interest Litigation,
seeking directions to the respondents therein to ensure preservation of the
historic Gole Mahal, Hazuri Bagh, Talab Tillo, Jammu, on the premise
that the same was an ancient building/monument. The Division Bench of
this Court treated the said writ petition as a Public Interest Litigation and,
OWP No. 857/2013
during its pendency, directed maintenance of status quo with respect to
construction over the land in question.
2.
The petitioner further avers that, during the pendency of the aforesaid
proceedings, the respondents issued SRO 263 dated 20.05.2013, whereby
the property of the petitioner, upon which the old structure stood, came to
be declared a heritage site under the provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir
Heritage Conservation and Preservation Act, 2010. The petitioner assails
the said notification, inter alia, on the ground that it was issued without
affording him an opportunity of being heard. It is further pleaded that,
even prior to the collapse of the structure, several alterations and
construction works had been carried out therein by the erstwhile owner
from whom the petitioner subsequently purchased the property. According
to the petitioner, the structure, though old, possessed no historical or
cultural significance so as to bring it within the ambit of the aforesaid Act.
On these premises, the petitioner seeks quashment of SRO 263 dated
20.05.2013.
3.
It is further pleaded by the petitioner that SRO 263 dated 20.05.2013 has
been issued mechanically and without proper application of mind and is,
therefore, unsustainable both in law and on facts. According to him,
having acquired a lawful right to own and possess the property, the
impugned notification could not operate so as to deprive him of his right
to use, enjoy and manage the same in accordance with law. The petitioner
further asserts that he has already raised a residential house over the land
in question.
4.
The respondents have contested the writ petition. Their case, in substance,
is that Gole Mahal, situated at Hazuri Bagh, Talab Tillo, Jammu, was used
OWP No. 857/2013
as a farmhouse by late Maharaja Hari Singh and is stated to have
subsequently been purchased by two persons, namely, the petitioner and
one Surinder Kumar. The land appurtenant to the Haveli measures
approximately 5 kanals and 17 marlas and falls under Khasra Nos. 141
and 144. According to the respondents, the complex represents a
significant example of Dogra architecture, constructed with traditional
mortar and lime, and, on account of its architectural and historical
significance, became the subject matter of the aforesaid Public Interest
Litigation. It is the further stand of the respondents that, having regard to
the historical importance of the Haveli, the Government issued the
impugned SRO declaring the property to be a heritage monument
deserving conservation and preservation. The State Government is also
stated to have taken up the matter with the Archaeological Survey of India
with a view to having the site declared a historical monument under the
applicable law relating to preservation of ancient monuments. The
respondents maintain that the Administrative Department duly examined
the matter and issued the impugned notification only after following the
prescribed procedure and due process of law.
5.
The respondents further contend that the writ petition is liable to be
dismissed as the petitioner failed to avail himself of the opportunity to
object to the proposed declaration. It is asserted that, prior to issuance of
the impugned SRO, a public notice was issued inviting objections from all
concerned; however, the petitioner chose not to submit any objection
thereto. According to the respondents, Gole Mahal is a building of
considerable heritage significance and has validly been declared a
protected heritage monument under the Jammu and Kashmir Heritage
OWP No. 857/2013
Conservation and Preservation Act, 2010. Mere acquisition of ownership
rights by the petitioner, it is contended, cannot by itself constitute a
ground to invalidate the notification issued for the conservation and
preservation of a property of historical and architectural importance.
6.
The respondent-Director, Archives, Archaeology and Museums, J&K,
Jammu, has filed objections to the writ petition. It is stated therein that,
during inspection of the site, certain concrete structures were found to
have been raised within the premises of the monument and within the
prohibited area. It is further stated that a portion of the building was
bulldozed by the petitioner in the year 2012, whereas the remaining roundshaped portion of the structure stood substantially obscured by plantation
and bushes. The Director is stated to have recommended preservation of
the structure as a heritage building.
7.
After the respondents filed their reply to the writ petition, the petitioner
filed a rejoinder. It is pleaded therein that the respondents had themselves
constituted a committee comprising the Additional Deputy Commissioner
(B), Jammu; Deputy Director, Archives, Archaeology and Museums,
Jammu; and Executive Engineer, PWD (R&B), Jammu. The said
Committee inspected the premises and submitted its inspection report
dated 18.10.2010. As per the report, an area measuring 2 kanals and 13
marlas constituted the building area, and the structure standing thereon
appeared to have been constructed during the reign of Maharaja Partap
Singh. The property was subsequently stated to have been gifted by the
royal family to Princess Deeraj Kumari, daughter of Maharaja Karan
Singh, who thereafter transferred it to one Ganesh Dass. The property
subsequently devolved upon Chander Shekher, who ultimately sold it to
OWP No. 857/2013
the present petitioner, Rattan Chand. The petitioner is thus stated to be the
owner of the land measuring 2 kanals and 13 marlas upon which the
building in question stands.
8.
Placing reliance upon the aforesaid inspection report dated 18.10.2010,
learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the respondents' own
record establishes that the building in question stood only upon land
measuring 2 kanals and 13 marlas. It was, therefore, argued that the
inclusion, under the impugned SRO, of the petitioner's other parcel of
land, which according to him has no nexus with the structure in question,
within the notified heritage site is arbitrary and contrary to law. It was
further contended that, notwithstanding the respondents admitted position
that the petitioner is the owner of the property, he was never associated
with the proceedings culminating in issuance of the impugned notification
nor afforded an effective opportunity of being heard.
9.
It is pertinent to notice that, during the pendency of the writ petition, this
Court directed the respondents to file a status report. Pursuant thereto, the
Assistant Director, Archives, Archaeology and Museums, Jammu,
inspected the site on 25.09.2021 and submitted a status report. The report
records that certain concrete structures had been raised within the
premises of the monument. It further records that a portion of the
monument had been bulldozed in the year 2012, while the remaining
round-shaped portion stood substantially covered by plantation and
bushes. Certain portions of the structure, stated to be in a dilapidated
condition, were, however, visible from the other side of the building. The
status report further states that the factum of demolition of a part of the
OWP No. 857/2013
building in the year 2012 had already been brought to the notice of this
Court through objections filed on 17.09.2013.
10.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents referred this Court to the relevant record and minutes of
proceedings in support of the contention that due process prescribed under
the Jammu and Kashmir Heritage Conservation and Preservation Act,
2010 had been duly followed before declaring Gole Mahal a heritage site.
It was submitted that notices communicating the Government's intention
to declare the building/property as a heritage site were duly published in
newspapers and through other prescribed modes, inviting objections from
all concerned within a period of 30 days. No objections having been
received within the stipulated period, the competent authorities proceeded
to recommend to the Government that the building be declared a heritage
site. It was, thus, contended that the impugned decision was taken only
after due consideration of the relevant material and upon compliance with
the prescribed procedure.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the Public
Interest Litigation instituted by Balbir Singh was motivated by extraneous
considerations. According to the petitioner, Balbir Singh was interested in
purchasing the property from him and, upon the petitioner declining to sell
the same, initiated the aforesaid proceedings. It was, therefore, sought to
be contended that the very genesis of the proceedings leading to the
impugned action was actuated by considerations other than the purported
object of conservation and preservation of the property.
12.
I have heard both the counsels at length and gone through the record of the
case.
OWP No. 857/2013
13.
A perusal of the record produced by the respondents reveals that, in the
year 2010, the then Deputy Director, Archives, Archaeology and
Museums, Jammu, in response to communication dated 05.10.2010,
brought to the notice of the Director, Archives, Archaeology and
Museums, J&K, Srinagar, that the Haveli commonly known as "Gole
Mahal" was in the possession of Rattan Chand of Shakti Nagar, Jammu,
who was stated to have purchased the land from K.C. Group of Industries,
Jammu. It was reported that the owner had commenced dismantling the
upper roof of the Haveli on the ground that the structure was in a
precarious condition and was likely to collapse, thereby posing a risk of
damage. The communication further described the Haveli as a fine
specimen of Dogra architecture, constructed with lime mortar and having
an octagonal form. Considering the structure to be a heritage building
whose original character deserved to be maintained, its preservation for
posterity was recommended.
14.
The record further indicates that the Director thereafter initiated the
process for having the structure declared a State Protected Monument
under the Jammu and Kashmir Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, Svt.
1977, read with the Amendment Act of 2010. In his recommendation
dated 10.12.2012, the Director observed that the construction then existing
at the site was in violation of the provisions of the Ancient Monuments
Preservation Act and, accordingly, requested the Government to take
immediate appropriate action in the matter. While the matter was thus
under consideration before the competent authorities, one Balbir Singh
approached this Court by way of a writ petition, which came to be treated
OWP No. 857/2013
and registered as a Public Interest Litigation. The proceedings appear to
have been prompted by reports in the print media that the owner had
commenced dismantling the old structure of Gole Mahal. The petitioner
therein sought preservation and protection of Gole Mahal, situated at
Hazuri Bagh, Talab Tillo, Jammu, on the ground that it was an ancient
heritage monument. During the pendency of the said proceedings, the
authorities intervened and restrained the owner from carrying out further
work at the site. The record indicates that, although the old structure
continued to exist at that stage, a new concrete structure had been raised at
a distance of approximately 100 metres therefrom. Taking note of the
circumstances, the Division Bench, vide order dated 24.12.2012, directed
maintenance of status quo. Subsequently, the respondent-State informed
the Division Bench that the process for declaring the structure an ancient
monument was under consideration, so it proceeded to close PIL.
15.
The official noting on record further reveals that land measuring 2 kanals
and 13 marlas, falling under Khasra No. 141, stood recorded in the name
of Chander Shekhar pursuant to Mutation No. 438 dated 04.01.2010. The
said parcel of land is recorded as housing an old building described as a
Baradari. It is also borne out from the record that, in the year 2010, while
correspondence concerning the property was being exchanged amongst
the officers of the Archives, Archaeology and Museums Department, the
Government constituted a committee to examine the matter. The
Committee, upon inspection and consideration of the relevant record,
found that the property was in the possession and lawful ownership of
Rattan Chand, who had purchased the same from Chander Shekhar, the
latter having inherited it from his father, Ganesh Dass. The Committee
OWP No. 857/2013
described the building as a meticulously designed round-shaped structure
having entrances on all four sides, namely, East, West, North and South,
and exhibiting a combination of Mughal and Rajasthani architectural
influences. The structure was further found to be well planned and
constructed using traditional lime mortar and surkhi.
16.
During the pendency of the present writ petition, officials of the
Department of Archives, Archaeology and Museums, Jammu, again
inspected the site on 25.09.2021. The inspection report records that the
main entrance to the premises was found locked from outside and, there
being no alternative access to the property, the inspecting officials could
not enter the premises to verify its condition from within. The photographs
appended to the status report, however, indicate that the structure has
substantially deteriorated over the years and presently appears to be in a
dilapidated and decaying condition.
17.
The minutes and official notings placed on record further indicate that, as
of the year 2012, the structure was considered to be more than 100 years
old, although its precise date of construction could not be ascertained. On
that basis, the authorities were of the view that the structure could fall
within the ambit of the law governing preservation of ancient monuments.
At the same time, having regard to its asserted historical and architectural
significance, the authorities also considered it appropriate to examine its
declaration as a heritage building under the Jammu and Kashmir Heritage
Conservation and Preservation Act, 2010.
18.
Before adverting to the provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir Heritage
Conservation and Preservation Act, 2010,“the Act of 2010”, under which
the impugned SRO has been issued, it would be apposite to first notice the
OWP No. 857/2013
relevant provisions of the Jammu and Kashmir Ancient Monuments
Preservation Act, Svt. 1977 (1920 A.D.) “hereafter the Act of 1920”
particularly in view of the fact that the contemporaneous official record
reflects that the authorities had initially considered preservation of the
structure under the said enactment.
19.
Section 3 of the Jammu and Kashmir Ancient Monuments Preservation
Act, Svt. 1977 (1920 A.D.) empowers the Government, by notification
published in the Government Gazette, to declare an ancient monument to
be a protected monument for the purposes of the Act. For facility of
reference, Section 3(2) of the said Act is reproduced hereunder:
“(2) Where the authority is of the opinion that it is necessary so
to do, it may, from time to time, by notification in Government
Gazette, and also by publication in leading newspapers, give thirty
days’ notice of its intention to declare any building, artifacts,
structures, streets, areas and precincts of historic or architectural or
aesthetic or cultural or environmental significance and a natural
feature of environmental significance and site of scenic beauty,
including but not restricted to, scared groves, mountains, hills,
hillocks, lakes, rivers, and other water bodies (and the areas adjoining
the same) open areas, wooded areas, points, walks, rides, bridle, paths
etc. as heritage or heritage site from protection under this Act, for
inviting objections or suggestions in writing from any person or the
public or any organization and any such notification and newspaper
publication shall be affixed in a conspicuous place near the site.”
20.
In terms of Section 2 of this Act of 1920 A.D. an "ancient monument"
means any structure, erection or monument, or any tumulus or place of
interment, or any cave, rock-sculpture, inscription or monolith, which is of
historical, archaeological or artistic interest and has been in existence for
not less than one hundred years, or any remains thereof. The definition
also encompasses the site of an ancient monument as well as such portion
of the land adjoining the site as may be required for fencing, covering or
otherwise preserving the monument. Section 4 of the Act contemplates
that, after issuance of the requisite notification and consideration of
OWP No. 857/2013
objections, the Director, Archaeology may purchase or take on lease any
protected monument. The provision further enables the owner of a
protected monument, by means of a written instrument, to constitute the
Director, Archaeology as the guardian of such monument, subject to
acceptance of such guardianship. In cases where the monument has no
owner, the Director, Archaeology may assume its guardianship in
accordance with law.
21.
Section 5 provides for preservation of an ancient monument by agreement
with its owner. Such an agreement may, inter alia, regulate the custody
and preservation of the monument, impose restrictions upon the exercise
of the owner's rights, and provide for facilities of access to the monument
by the public. The statutory scheme also contemplates purchase by the
Government, at market value, of the land or such specified portion thereof
as may be offered for sale by the owner. Section 10 further empowers the
Government, where it apprehends that a protected monument is in danger
of being destroyed or allowed to fall into decay, to acquire the same under
the provisions of the law governing land acquisition, treating preservation
of the protected monument as a "public purpose" for the purposes of such
acquisition.
22.
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions makes it manifest that the
Act of 1920 A.D. is intended to secure the preservation and protection of
ancient monuments and, for that purpose, provides a statutory mechanism
governing their protection, guardianship, preservation by agreement,
purchase and, where circumstances so warrant, acquisition in accordance
with law.
OWP No. 857/2013
23.
In the present case, the record suggests that the respondents themselves
were not certain as to the precise period during which the building in
question had been constructed. This assumes significance because, for a
structure to qualify as an "ancient monument" within the meaning of
Section 2 of the Act of 1920 A.D., it must, apart from possessing the
requisite historical, archaeological or artistic interest, have been in
existence for a period of not less than one hundred years. No
contemporaneous or other reliable documentary material has been placed
on record by the respondents establishing the precise date or period of
construction of Gole Mahal. The departmental record does indicate that
the structure was associated with the erstwhile royal family and was stated
to have been gifted to Princess Deeraj Kumari; however, such material, by
itself, does not conclusively establish its date of construction for the
purposes of satisfying the statutory requirement under the Act of 1920
A.D.
24.
At the relevant point of time, however, the Act of 2010 was also in force.
Section 3 thereof empowers the Government, on the recommendation of
the competent Authority, Municipal Commissioner, Collector or Director,
as the case may be, to declare, by notification in the Government Gazette,
buildings and precincts possessing historic or architectural significance as
heritage or heritage sites requiring protection. The statutory scheme
further contemplates publication of the intention to make such a
declaration, providing a period of thirty days for submission of objections,
consideration thereof, and thereafter a recommendation to the Government
for declaring the concerned building, artefact, structure, street or precinct
as heritage or a heritage site. Once such a declaration is made, the
OWP No. 857/2013
consequential statutory provisions, including Sections 4, 5 and 6 of the
Act, become relevant and are required to be acted upon in accordance with
law.
25.
The record further indicates, and it is not seriously disputed by the
respondents, that the structure known as Gole Mahal itself stood upon land
measuring 2 kanals and 13 marlas, whereas the remaining land formed
part of the surrounding precincts. The entire notified area, however,
comprises land falling under Khasra Nos. 141 and 144.
26.
The principal question is whether SRO 263 dated 20.05.2013 was issued
in accordance with the statutory scheme and the requirements of
procedural fairness. The record shows that Gole Mahal stands on land
measuring 2 kanals and 13 marlas falling under Khasra No. 141. The
impugned notification, however, declares the entire area measuring 5
kanals and 17 marlas falling under Khasra Nos. 141 and 144 as a heritage
site. The material relied upon by the authorities primarily concerns the
historical and architectural significance of Gole Mahal; it does not
disclose any independent consideration of the necessity for including the
entire adjoining land within the notified heritage site.
27.
The record further shows that the petitioner was a known owner whose
proprietary rights were directly affected by the proposed declaration.
Although a general notice inviting objections within thirty days was
published, the material placed before the Court does not establish that the
petitioner was individually informed of the proposed action or otherwise
afforded an effective opportunity to present his objections.
28.
In the facts of the present case, publication of a general notice cannot be
regarded as sufficient compliance with the requirements of procedural
OWP No. 857/2013
fairness. Where the identity of the affected owner is known and the
proposed action materially restricts the use and enjoyment of private
property, the decision-making process must afford such owner a
meaningful opportunity of representation before the competent authority.
This conclusion does not detract from the power or obligation of the State
to protect a structure possessing genuine historical, architectural or
cultural significance. Such protection, however, must be undertaken
strictly in accordance with the governing statute and through a fair
decision-making process.
29.
It is equally a matter of concern that, despite the stated object of
conservation and preservation, the structure appears to have progressively
deteriorated during the pendency of the proceedings. The status report
based upon the inspection conducted in the year 2021 depicts the
surviving structure as being in a dilapidated condition. The very purpose
of heritage protection is conservation of the property possessing historical,
architectural or cultural significance; a declaration unaccompanied by
effective measures for preservation cannot, by itself, achieve the statutory
object.
30.
The allegation that the Public Interest Litigation instituted by Balbir Singh
was motivated by extraneous considerations does not require adjudication
for deciding the present petition. The validity of the impugned notification
must be determined on the basis of the statutory provisions, the material
considered by the competent authority and the legality of the procedure
adopted.
31.
Accordingly, the impugned notification cannot be sustained in its present
form. This shall not, however, preclude the competent authority from
OWP No. 857/2013
reconsidering the matter in accordance with law, after affording the
petitioner an effective opportunity of hearing and independently
determining the nature and extent of the property, including any adjoining
land, that is required to be protected as part of the heritage site. In that
view of the matter, this writ is allowed by quashing the impugned
notification.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
Jammu:
11.08.2026
Pawan Angotra
Pawan Angotra
2026.08.17 12:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
OWP No. 857/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review