Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 26th JULY, 2017
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RFA No.04 of 2015
Appellant
:
Smt. Ratna Pradhan,
W/o Late K. K. Pradhan,
R/o Arithang,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
Shri Kishan Deo Thakur,
S/o Ram Singha Thakur,
R/o Third lane,
Opposite State Bank of Sikkim,
Jorethang Bazaar,
P.O. & P.S. Jorethang,
South Sikkim.
Appeal under Order XLI Rules 1 and 2 read with
Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Rahul Rathi and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa,
Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mrs. K. D. Bhutia and Mr.
Ranjit Prasad, Advocates for the Respondent.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The challenge in this Appeal is to the Judgment and
Decree, dated 30-06-2015, of the Learned District Judge, South
Sikkim, at Namchi, in Eviction Suit No.14 of 2013, “Ratna Pradhan
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
vs. Kishan Deo Thakur”. The Learned Trial Court vide the impugned
Judgment held that the Plaintiff was not entitled to the reliefs
prayed for by her and dismissed the Eviction Suit.
2.
The
facts
leading
to
the
dispute
are
that,
the
Plaintiff/Appellant (hereinafter “Plaintiff”) is the owner of a four
storied RCC building measuring 20' x 30' in Jorethang Bazaar, South
Sikkim.
The Defendant/Respondent (hereinafter “Defendant”) has
been a tenant since 1997, in a portion of the ground floor of the
building,
measuring approximately
16'
x 12'
and running a
Barbershop. The rent in 1997 was fixed at Rs.900/- (Rupees nine
hundred) only, per month, and thereafter, from 2010 onwards at
Rs.2,000/- (Rupees two thousand) only, per month, to be paid by
the Defendant within the 10th day of each month, as per letter of the
Plaintiff dated 05-07-2013, Exhibit 6.
That, from the month of
November 2012 the Defendant failed to pay the monthly rent,
without assigning any reason, till the filing of the Suit, in December
2013.
Around the month of March/April 2013, the Plaintiff received
a Money Order from the Defendant, which she refused, being
unaware of its purpose.
That, even if, the Money Order was for
rent, she had every right to refuse it, as the Defendant had failed to
pay rent for the previous four months and was, therefore, in arrears
of rent. In March 2013, she directed the Defendant to vacate the
suit property on account of default of payment of rent, in vain.
Besides, she has an unemployed son, a Graduate, who seeks to run
a Computer Training Centre, but has not been able to acquire
suitable accommodation. Hence, the prayers, inter alia, for directing
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
the Defendant to hand over vacant possession of the suit property
to the Plaintiff, as he was a wilful defaulter in payment of rent and
she bona fide required the suit premises for her son.
3.
Resisting the contentions of the Plaintiff, the Defendant
denied default in rent payment or the requirement of the Plaintiff‟s
son. That, the Plaintiff infact refused to accept the monthly rent
from November 2012 including the rents despatched by Money
Orders. The said refusal, according to him, was a ruse to evict him,
as in the month of September 2012 she had informed him of the
sale of the suit building to one Arun Ghatani. Moreover, the location
of the said premises was not suitable for running a Computer
Training Centre, besides which other tenants were in occupation of
larger areas in the same building and the Plaintiff has several other
RCC buildings located in various parts of Sikkim, where her son can
be accommodated, hence, the Suit be dismissed.
4.
The Learned Trial Court settled the following issues for
determination;
(1)
Whether the Suit is maintainable? (OPP)
(2)
Whether the suit/demised premises are required by the
Plaintiff
and/or
her
son
for
her/their
bona
fide
requirement? (OPP)
(3)
Whether the Defendant has defaulted in payment of the
concerned rent for the suit premises with effect from
November, 2012? (OPP)
(4)
Whether the Suit has been filed only to evict the
Defendant without any basis? (OPD)
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
(5)
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs prayed for
by her? (OPP)
5.
In support of her case the Plaintiff examined herself and
her son Rishi Pradhan, while the Defendant examined himself and
the Postman of the Naya Bazaar Post Office, located at Jorethang.
Though the wife of the Defendant had filed her Evidence-onAffidavit, which was confirmed before the Learned Trial Court, but
she was later dropped as a witness by the Defendant.
6.
Taking up Issue No.3 first for discussion the Learned
Trial Court reached a finding that the Plaintiff failed to prove that the
Defendant had defaulted in payment of monthly rent, since
November 2012.
Issue No.2 was next discussed and it was
concluded that the Plaintiff/her son did not require the suit
premises. In Issue No.4, the Learned Trial Court found that the Suit
had been filed for the purpose of evicting the Defendant without any
basis. Ultimately, Issues No.1 and 5 were taken up together and it
was concluded that the Suit was not maintainable, as, the grounds
on which it had been filed were not substantiated and found to be
false, thus, dismissing the Suit.
7.
Aggrieved thereby, before this Court it was argued by
Learned Counsel for the Appellant that, the Learned District Judge
erred in not considering the legal position, that, under Notification
No.6326─600-H&W─B., dated 14-04-1949, issued by the Health and
Works Department, Government of Sikkim, the Appellant is only
required to establish one of the grounds for eviction.
That, the
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
Appellant requires the suit premises for bona fide and personal
occupation, as is evident from the Trade Licence, Exhibit 7, issued in
the name of her son, who is unemployed and seeks to run a
Computer Training Centre from the suit premises. That, the Money
Order Receipts marked Exhibit „A‟ (collectively) are only attested
copies, which ought not to have been admitted in evidence. That,
the Postman serving the Money Orders was not examined and the
Money Order Acknowledgment Card does not contain the signature
of the Plaintiff. That, no proof of sale of building by the Plaintiff to
one Arun Ghatani has been furnished, besides which the Plaintiff
was not confronted with Exhibit „B‟ a letter purportedly written by
her to the Defendant at the time of her cross-examination.
Hence,
the prayers for setting aside the Judgment and Decree of the
Learned Trial Court.
8.
The contra argument of the Respondent was that the
Defendant had dispatched rent up to the month of March/April 2013
by Money Orders with no default, which the Plaintiff under crossexamination has admitted, but that she had refused the same.
That, infact, the building has been sold to one Arun Ghatani for
which efforts were on to evict the Defendant.
That, although the
Money Order receipts are attested documents, the Money Order
Acknowledgment Cards containing the endorsement “refused” are in
original and bear the seal of the concerned Post Office and each of
the Money Order Acknowledgment Card contains an endorsement of
refusal.
That, Exhibit „A‟ (collectively), has been proved by D.W.2,
the witness of the Defendant, the Postman, who used to hand over
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
the Acknowledgment Card and the money, which was unaccepted by
the Plaintiff, to the Defendant. Pointing to the provisions of Section
27 of the General Clauses Act 1897 (for short “General Clauses Act”)
it was urged that, if documents are sent through the Post Office and
the same is refused, it is deemed that the same has been served on
the addressee and that Section 114(f) of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872, also lays down a similar provision.
Reliance was placed on
Puwada Venkateswara Rao vs. Chidamana Venkata Ramana1, Harcharan
Singh vs. Shivrani and Others2
and Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta
(Dr.) and Others vs. State of Maharashtra3 to fortify his submissions.
9.
It was next contended that the question of bona fide
requirement for the son does not arise, as the Plaintiff has deposed
that she has many houses including houses at better locations than
the suit premises, where business can flourish.
It is also her
admission that the Suit was filed on the Defendant‟s refusal to enter
into a Lease Agreement. Moreover, there are sixteen vacant rooms
in the suit building, besides the tenanted premises occupied by the
Defendant and it is an admitted fact that the Computer Training
Centre of her son can be opened in any of those vacant rooms. The
Trade Licence, Exhibit 7, issued to the Plaintiff‟s son is not for the
suit premises, but for her building located at Majhigaon, and the
Trade Licence Rules of Sikkim mandates that no business can be
started in a house other than that mentioned in the body of the
Trade Licence. Moreover, P.W.2, her son, has admitted that he is
(1976) 2 SCC 409
(1981) 2 SCC 535
(2010) 13 SCC 657
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
only interested in evicting the Defendant from the suit premises and
hence, there is no bona fide requirement. That, in D. Devaji vs. K.
Sudarashana Rao4
it was held that, if a landlord had similar other
residential building in town wherein business can be started, mere
convenience of the Plaintiff or suitability of the premises cannot be
looked into. In P. Ramachander Rao vs. K. Dayanand5 it was held that,
if the landlord has some other accommodation to start a tailoring
shop, the tenant cannot be evicted.
In N. Eswari, w/o Adinarayana
vs. K. Swarajya Lakshmi, w/o Late K.V.L.N.A. Sastry 6, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court declined the landlady‟s prayer of residence at
Vijaywada, because she was living with her children at Hyderabad in
one of her two houses. Thus, based on the touchstone of the above
pronouncements, the decision of the Learned Trial Court requires no
interference.
10.
I have heard Learned Counsel at length and carefully
considered their submissions, perused the pleadings, the evidence
on record, appended documents and the impugned Judgment.
11.
What arises for consideration before this Court is,
Whether the Learned Trial Court was correct in reaching a finding
that the Plaintiff had no bona fide requirement of the suit premises
and there was no default in payment of rent by the Defendant?
12.
For clarity in the matter, we may refer to the relevant
Notification invoked by the Plaintiff;
1994 Supp (1) SCC 729
(2005) 13 SCC 159
(2009) 9 SCC 678
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
”GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
Health and Works Department.
Notification No.6326—600-H&W—B.
Under powers conferred in para 2 of Notification
No.1366-G, dated the 28th July 1947, the following Rules
have been framed to regulate letting and sub-letting of
premises controlling rents thereof and unreasonable eviction
of tenants as the scarcity of housing accommodation still
exists in Sikkim.
I The landlords can charge rent for premises either
for residential or business purposes on the basis of the rents
prevailing in locality in the year 1939, plus an increase upto
50 per cent so long as the scarcity of housing
accommodation lasts.
2. The landlords cannot eject the tenants so long as
the scarcity of housing accommodation lasts, but when the
whole or part of the premises are required for their personal
occupation or for thorough overhauling the premises or on
failure by the tenants to pay rent for four months the
landlords may be permitted to evict the tenant on due
application to the Chief Court.
3.
Any tenant may apply to this Department for
fixing his rent.
On receipt of such application the
Department will enquire about the rent prevailing in the
locality in 1939, and fix rent as per Rule (I) above.
4.
Any person acting in contravention of this
Notification will be liable to prosecution under para 4 of
notification No.1366-066-G, dated the 28th July, 1947.
5. The tenant means
occupation. Landlords
premises.
those person in actual
means owners of the
These rules will come into force with immediate
effect.
By order of his Highness the Maharaja of Sikkim.
R.B. Singh,
Gangtok,
The I4th, April, 1949.
Secretary,
Health and Works Department,
Government of Sikkim.”
Thus, the Notification deals with regulation “letting and subletting” of premises, controlling rents and to prevent unreasonable
eviction of tenants. The spirit behind the Notification is to prevent
vagrancy till such time as scarcity of accommodation prevails in
Sikkim, and to prevent harassment to the tenants on account of
such scarcity. The three grounds enumerated for eviction are (i) if
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
the premises are required for personal occupation (ii) overhauling
(iii) failure on the part of the tenant to pay rent for four months.
The grounds urged herein by the Plaintiff are for bona fide
requirement and default in payment of rent for four months by the
Defendant.
13.
Firstly, taking up the question of bona fide requirement,
it may pertinently be stated here that the Plaintiff is required to
establish a genuine need of the premises. In Damodar Sharma and
Another vs. Nandram Deviram
while culling out a distinction between
the expressions “genuinely requires” and “reasonably requires”, it
was held as follows;
“(27) .…………………………….……………………………
………………………………. It is wrong to say that
“genuinely requires” is the same as “reasonably
requires”. There is a distinction between the two
phrases. The former phrase refers to a state of
mind; the latter to an objective standard. “Genuine
requirement” would vary according to the
idiosyncrasy of the individual and the time and
circumstances in which he lives and thinks.
Reasonable requirement belongs to the “knowledge
of the law” and means reasonable not in the mind
of the person requiring the accommodation but
reasonable according to the actual facts. In my
opinion, in this part of Sec. 4(g), the landlord is
made the sole arbiter of his own requirements but
he must prove that he, in fact, wants and
genuinely intends to occupy the premises. His
claim would no doubt fail if the Court came to the
conclusion that the evidence of “want” was
unreliable and that the landlord did not genuinely
intend to occupy the premises.”
………………………………………………………………..”
14.
It is not disputed that the son of the Plaintiff is an
unemployed Graduate.
For his livelihood, he seeks to open a
Computer Training Centre and although he made enquiries for space
AIR 1960 MP 345
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
at Jorethang Bazaar, he was unable to obtain any accommodation
commensurate with his financial resources. It has been consistently
argued by the Defendant that the Plaintiff is the owner of several
properties in and around Sikkim and that P.W.2 himself has
admitted this fact. That, should he run his business in Jorethang, it
would be illegal, the Licence having been obtained for carrying out
business in Majhigaon. It would be appropriate to remark here that
penalty
for
contravening
the
relevant
Rules
of
the
Urban
Development and Housing Department pertaining to Licences would
be cancellation of Licence and is a matter entirely between P.W.2
and the Urban Development and Housing Department, Government
of Sikkim, for which no interference is expected from the Defendant.
Besides the Defendant is to confine his case to the property in
question and it is not his place to enquire into the number of
properties owned by the Plaintiff. However, the above observations
aside, the Plaintiff under cross-examination has admitted that the
suit building consists of four floors and sixteen rooms therein are
vacant.
It is also her admission that the Computer Training Centre
can be opened
by
her
son
in
the
vacant
rooms
in
their
possession.
15.
In Sait Nagjee Purushotham & Co. Ltd. vs. Vimalabai
Prabhulal and Others8 it was held that;
“4.
……………….. It is true that the landlords
have their business spreading over Chennai and
Hyderabad and if they wanted to expand their business
at Calicut it cannot be said to be unnatural thereby
denying the eviction of the tenant from the premises in
(2005) 8 SCC 252
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
question. It is always the prerogative of the landlord
that if he requires the premises in question for his bona
fide use for expansion of business this is no ground to
say that the landlords are already having their business
at Chennai and Hyderabad therefore, it is not genuine
need. It is not the tenant who can dictate the terms to
the landlord and advise him what he should do and
what he should not. It is always the privilege of the
landlord to choose the nature of the business and the
place of business. However, the Trial Court held in
favour of the tenant-appellant. But the appellate court
as well as the High Court after scrutinizing the
evidence on record reversed the finding of the trial
court and held that the need of establishing the
business at Calicut by the landlords cannot be said to
be lacking in bona fides.”
In the aforesaid case, the bona fide requirement of the
landlord was established. While it has been laid down that a tenant
cannot dictate terms to the landlord, at the same time the landlord
has to be able to indicate a real and genuine need for the suit
premises. While examining the case at hand, although it is not for
the Defendant to dictate what the Plaintiff‟s son should do,
nevertheless, it is clear from the evidence furnished that bona fide
need has not been established by the Plaintiff, for the reasons
discussed supra, consequently, on this ground, no right accrues to
the Plaintiff.
16.
Before embarking on a discussion on default of payment
of rent, I consider it essential to clear the air with regard to the
alleged sale of the building to one Arun Ghatani.
Exhibit „B‟ was
relied on by the Defendant, a hand written notice, purportedly
scribed by the Plaintiff herself.
Although there is no basis in the
evidence of the Defendant to conclude that Exhibit „B‟ was in the
hand of the Plaintiff and Exhibit „B(a)‟ was her signature, but it is
noticed that no cross-examination in this regard was conducted and
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
hence, the Learned Trial Court has taken this evidence into
consideration.
Nevertheless, Exhibit „B‟ nowhere reveals that the
building was sold to Arun Ghatani, although the Defendant has
asserted that the Plaintiff has sold the suit building to Arun Ghatani
was
not
a
false
statement.
An
assertion
made
has
to
be
substantiated by the person who makes the assertion. Section 103
of the Evidence Act clearly lays down that the burden of proof as to
any particular fact lies on that person who wishes the Court to
believe in its existence, unless, it is provided by any law that the
proof of that fact shall lie on any particular person. Infact, Exhibit
„C‟ would go to show that he is interested in purchasing the shop in
his occupation being a tenant thereof for the last 18 years, which
appears to be his staunch reason for not vacating.
Thus, in the
absence of any credible evidence, this Court is not inclined to rely on
the version of the Defendant that the Plaintiff seeks to evict him to
hand over vacant possession to Arun Ghatani.
17.
That,
having
been
settled,
the
afore-extracted
Notification, it may be reiterated, provides for eviction of a tenant if
default in payment of rent occurs for four months.
Although the
Plaintiff vehemently asserts default by the Defendant, the Defendant
is equally vehement in his denial. According to the Defendant, the
Plaintiff in her evidence has stated that the Defendant was
„presently‟ sending the rent of the suit premises, but she had
refused it. It has to be noted that her evidence was recorded on 1602-2015 and the word „presently‟ would have to be interpreted in
that context.
The Defendant has not enlightened this Court as to
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
whether he had been delivering the rent to her personally and how
she suddenly declined to accept rent for the month of November
2012. How the refusal transpired, whether he had personally gone
to deliver the rent for that month or was it sent through someone
else? These are shrouded in mystery. Apart from which, perusal of
Exhibit „A‟ (collectively) would indicate that, the Money Order
Acknowledgement Card bears the name and address of the
Defendant and are in original, but the receipts allegedly addressed
to the Plaintiff are in photocopy. No reasons have been put forth for
non-production of the original as per the requirement of law. The
Defendant has admitted that the Money Orders which form part of
Exhibit
„A‟
(collectively),
do
not
contain
the
signatures
endorsements of the Plaintiff indicating her refusal.
or
He also
admitted to having no personal knowledge as to whether the Money
Orders, part of Exhibit „A‟ (collectively), were tendered for delivery
to the Plaintiff and that she had refused it.
The evidence of the
Postman, the witness of the Defendant in no way strengthens his
case as in the first instance no proof of him being a Postman was
ever furnished.
He is unaware as to who was responsible for
delivery of the Money Orders to the address or who had endorsed
the refusal on the Money Order Acknowledgment Cards. He was not
able to throw light on whether the Postman of Gangtok Head Post
Office actually went to the house of the Plaintiff to deliver the Money
Orders.
18.
The further argument of the Defendant was that Section
27 of the General Clauses Act lays down that, where any Central Act
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
or Regulation made after commencement of the Act authorizes or
requires any document to be served by post, wherever the
expression “server” or either of the expressions “give” or “send” or
any other expression is used, then, unless a different intention
appears, the service shall be deemed to be effected by properly
addressing, pre-paying and posting by registered post, a letter
containing the document, and, unless the contrary is proved, to
have been effected at the time at which the letter would be
delivered in the ordinary course of post.
Pausing here for a
moment, the Section importantly lays down that the letter is to be
“properly addressed”.
The receipts filed by the Defendant would
indicate that it was addressed to “Ratna Pradhan (Gangtok)
Gangtok - 737101”. This address is indeed peremptory and how the
Post Office is to recognize this individual, being bereft of a detailed
address defies logic, nor is its brevity explained by the Defendant.
That apart, the Money Order Acknowledgment Card does not bear
the stamp of the Gangtok Post Office to establish receipt at the said
Post Office and the endorsement “Refuse by Payee hence Rtn to
Sender” (sic), too is devoid of the stamp of the Gangtok Post Office,
thereby failing to indicate that it was ever received in the Gangtok
Post Office at any point of time. In P. S. Nirash and Another vs. Smt.
Mintok Dolma Kazini and Another9
this Court held that, “Exhibit D-3
appears to be a refused Money Order of Rs.140/- only and, apart
from the fact that, as rightly pointed out by the District Judge, the
refusal having been denied by P.W.1 on oath, the endorsement
AIR 1984 Sikkim 1
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
“refused” on the said Money Order could not, by itself and without
the evidence of postal peon, lead to any presumption that the same
was tendered to the addressee and was refused by him.”
The
situation is similar herein as the Defendant insists that the Money
Orders were dispatched, but there is no proof whatsoever to
establish that the Money Order was indeed addressed to the
Plaintiff, or received at the Post Office, delivered to her, and refused
by her except for the month of March 2013 as admitted by her. No
Postman of Gangtok was examined to establish such refusal nor
does the signature of the Plaintiff appear on such alleged refusal.
19.
In view of the above discussions, it is clear that in the
absence of any cogent proof to establish dispatch of the house rents
and refusal of payment by the Plaintiff, no other conclusion can be
arrived at, save the fact that the Defendant failed to pay the rents
and hence defaulted. On this count, I am in disagreement with the
Learned Trial Court, who after examining the evidence found that
the Money Order Acknowledgement Cards, Exhibit „A‟ (collectively)
was sans details of the addressee, despite which he went on to
conclude that the Defendant was indeed sending the monthly rent
on a regular basis.
20.
Consequently, the findings of the Learned Trial Court on
Issue Nos.1, 3, 4 and 5 are set aside.
The Plaintiff having
established default in payment of rent by the Defendant from
November 2012, the Plaintiff is entitled to the relief on this ground,
i.e., eviction of the Defendant from the suit premises.
RFA No.04 of 2015
Smt. Ratna Pradhan vs. Shri Kishan Deo Thakur
21.
Resultant, Appeal is allowed in part.
22.
The Defendant shall vacate the suit premises on or
before 31-10-2017 and hand over vacant possession to the Plaintiff.
The Defendant shall also pay the arrears in rent from the month of
November 2012, till the time that he hands over vacant possession
of the suit premises to the Plaintiff as ordered herein.
23.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Trial Court
for information.
24.
No order as to costs.
25.
Records of the Learned Trial Court be remitted forthwith.
Sd/
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
26-07-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review