Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Supple S- 163
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT JAMMU
HCP 86/2025
Pronounced on 29.04.2026.
Uploaded on 29.04.2026
Rashid through Jamat Ali
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s).
Through:
Mr. Ankush Sharma, adv.
Vs.
1.Union Territory of Jammu and
Kashmir
Through Additional Chief Secretary
Government of J&K
Home Department
Civil Secretariat, Jammu
...Respondent(s).
2. The District Magistrate
Udhampur. UT of J&K
3. The Senior Superintendent of
Police, Udhampur.
4.Station House Officer,
Police Station Chenani
5. The Superintendent Central Jail,
Kot Bhalwal, Jammu
Through:
Mr. Sumeet Bhatia, GA
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
Impugned in the instant petition, filed under the provisions of
Article 226 of the Constitution of India by the petitioner through his father
is an order of detention bearing No. 04-PSA-2025 dated: 07.05.2025 passed
by the respondent No. 2 (hereinafter referred to as the „Detaining
Authority‟ for short), while invoking his powers under Section 8 of the
Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978 (hereinafter referred to as the
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |1
„Act‟ for short), whereby the petitioner has been ordered to be detained
with a view to prevent him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the
maintenance of public peace & order and lodged in the Central Jail Kot
Bhalwal, Jammu.
2.
The petitioner-detenu has assailed the impugned detention order on
the grounds, inter alia, that he is a citizen of India and a domicile of UT of
Jammu and Kashmir, as such, within his rights to seek the enforcement of
his constitutional as well as other legal/statutory rights; that he is of the age
of 23 years and a permanent resident of Village Bupp Sarar, Tehsil Chenani,
District Udhampur, who has been falsely branded as a habitual bovine
smuggler for managing his prevention detention; that the impugned
detention order has not been passed on any proximate or compelling
necessity but on generalized and unverified allegations; that the grounds of
detention reflect his involvement
in two case FIR‟s both of which have
been disposed; that some DDRs dated 21.12.24, 22.12.24 & 17.02.2025
allegedly indicate his involvement in bovine smuggling, though no FIR/
charge sheet stands registered pursuant to said DDRs is pending in any
court; that the ld. Detaining Authority has mechanically acted on the police
dossier without conducting any independent verification or otherwise
applying its own mind in respect of the matter; that even if the allegations
against him are supposed to be true for arguments sake, they still pertain to
law and order violations and not to acts prejudicial to public peace & order
as alleged; that he was not furnished with the complete set of the detention
record which has made him unable to make a timely representation against
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |2
his detention order; that his detention is punitive in nature and camouflaged
as preventive; that the impugned detention order is vitiated by procedural
irregularities, absence of subjective satisfaction and colourable exercise of
power by the Detaining Authority which make the same unconstitutional,
illegal and liable to be set aside; that the grounds of detention are the
verbatim of police dossier, thereby indicating the non-application of mind
by the learned Detaining Authority and that his illegal and unjustified
detention tantamounts to the infringement of his Fundamental Right to Life
and Liberty guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
3.
The respondents through their counter affidavit filed by the learned
Detaining Authority i.e. respondent No. 2 resisted the instant petition on
the grounds that none of the legal, fundamental or statutory rights of the
petitioner-detenue have been infringed and the petition is utterly
misconceived, false and frivolous deserving its dismissal. That the
concerned
SSP
forwarded
a
dossier
vice
communication
No.
Con/PSA/2025/248-51 dated 08.04.2025, of activities of the petitioner to
the answering respondent i.e. the Detaining Authority, making out a case
for his detention being a habitual bovine smuggler in the area. That his
rising involvement in bovine smuggling characterized by a blatant
disregard for the law, has profoundly disrupted the peaceful equilibrium of
the region. That the actions of the petitioner-detenu are deeply detrimental
to the public & order, have instilled fear and animosity among the local
population, disrupting the harmonious rhythm
of community life. That
the activities of the petitioner-detenu are anti-social which can hurt the
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |3
sentiments of particular community at large and create the feeling of
enmity, hatred and disharmony on the ground of religion thereby likely to
disturb the public order in the area. That the petitioner-detenu has been
found to be implicated in numerous instances of bovine smuggling. That
the petitioner-detenu is a habitual bovine smuggler and demonstrates the
failure of conventional legal measures to deter his criminal behavior. That
the petitioner-detenu was time and again warned to shun the path of illegal
bovine smuggling and other criminal act. That the grounds of detention,
were read over and explained to the detenu in the language the detenu
understands. That the representation of the petitioner-detenu has been duly
considered and rejected being without any merit. That the petitioner-detenu
is a bovine smuggler by profession. That despite the registration of the
aforesaid FIR(s) against the petitioner, he did not mend his behaviour and
remained adamant in continuing the smuggling of bovine animals, leaving
no alternative for the answering respondent but to invoke the provisions of
the Act in the larger public interest. That the answering respondent was
aware that the petitioner/detenue is already involved in substantive
offences, but keeping in view his activities which were highly prejudicial to
the public law and order, the detenu was booked under Public Safety Act,
strictly as per the provisions of the same. That the answering respondent,
after thoroughly perusing the contents of the dossier and the ground reports
so received, was satisfied that, in view of the volatile nature of the
petitioner-detenue and his repeated tendency to commit illegal activities
prejudicial to public peace & order, recourse to the normal laws may
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |4
provide an opportunity to the petitioner-detenu to continue his nefarious
designs of creating ill-will among the people, leading to disturbance of
public order. That the petitioner was lastly involved in case FIR No.
30/2024 under Sections 188 IPC 11 PCA Act of Police Station Chenani.
That the whole of the material relied upon by the answering respondent has
been furnished to the petitioner-detenu and also read over and explained to
him in the languages which he understood fully and in token of which his
signature was obtained. That moreover the petitioner/detenue was informed
that he can make a representation to the Government as well as the
Detaining authority against his detention. That all the statutory
requirements and constitutional guarantees have been fulfilled and
complied with by the answering respondent. That the petitioner-detenue
filed a detailed representation before the Government which was
considered and found without merit. That the petitioner-detenue is
operating in a secret and systematic manner actively working to establish
and expand the smuggling of bovine animals. That despite being arrested in
previous cases, he has not shown any inclination to reform and instead he
has resumed his criminal behaviour immediately after release, continuing
to act in a way that is detrimental to the maintenance of public order. That
the detention order in question has been passed by the answering
respondent upon proper application of his mind on the basis of the record
before him.
4.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties in the matter.
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |5
5.
The learned counsel Mr. Ankush Sharma, Advocate, while
reiterating the stand already taken in the petition contended that the
impugned detention order is the outcome of illegality and incorrectness for
being devoid of application of mind and subjective satisfaction on the part
of the ld. Detaining Authority. He contended that petitioner-detenue is
alleged to be involved in case bearing FIR Nos. 125/23 & 30/2024 both
registered at Police Station, Chenani u/s 188 IPC 11 PCA besides some DD
Reports.
The learned counsel very vehemently contended that the ld.
Detaining Authority has misused its power vested in it under the Act by
ordering the preventive detention of the petitioner-detenue on the allegation
of his illegal activities which may amount to infraction of ,General “Law
and Order” and not “public disorder” in the society. He contended that
none of the allegations/involvements amount to breach of “public order” as
defined under Section 8(3) of the Act. He further submitted that it is well
settled by Hon‟ble Supreme Court in a catena of judgments that there lies a
marked distinction between the acts amounting to breach of law and order
and the acts prejudicial to the social order.
The learned counsel also contended that the detention record in its
entirety especially the grounds of detention, the Police Dossier and the
documents regarding criminal cases were not furnished to him which
amounts to the violation of the mandatory provisions of Article 22(5) of the
Constitution of India read with Section 13 of the Act.
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |6
The learned counsel submitted that in the facts and circumstances of
the case, it is quite clear that the detention of the petitioner-detenue is
apparently illegal, as not being justified under the provisions of Section 8
of the Act. He contended that the impugned detention order is the outcome
of non-application of mind on the part of ld. Detaining Authority.
6.
The leaned counsel for the petitioner in support of his arguments
placed reliance on the authoritative judgments cited as, “Kewal Kirshan
vs
U.T.
of
J&K
(2023
SCC
Online
J&K
Krishan Lal v. State (UT of J&K), 2023 SCC Online J&K 2O4”.
The learned counsel for the petitioner sought the quashment of the
impugned detention Order.
7.
Per contra, the ld. UT Counsel submitted that the petition is liable to
be dismissed as none of the constitutional or any other statutory rights of
the petitioner have been infringed by the respondents. He submitted that the
detention order impugned in the petition has been passed on the due
application of mind by the ld. Detaining Authority who was satisfied on the
basis of the record of the dossier and the field inputs gathered by him that
the activities of the petitioner are likely to endanger the public order. He
contended that despite earlier registration of criminal cases against the
petitioner and his being convicted in both the cases, he did not mend his
character but continued to indulge in aforesaid activities especially
smuggling of bovine animals. He further contended that the object of the
detention under the Act is preventive rather than punitive and is aimed at to
debar an individual beforehand from indulging in activities prejudicial to
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |7
the public order. The ld. State Counsel further contended that the
petitioner/detenue who is of the age of about 30 years is known as habitual
bovine smuggler in the area. That his criminal behaviour is becoming more
serious and the general public has been registering its strong resentment for
the actions of the petitioner-detenu regarding bovine smuggling.
8.
The learned UT counsel further contended that the copies of the
detention record in entirety were furnished to the petitioner/detenue who
has acknowledged the receipt of the same at the time of his detention. That
he was also informed of the grounds of detention in the language
understood by him with further information that he has a right to make a
representation to the detaining authority as well as to the Government.
9.
I have perused the instant petition, the reply affidavit and have also
gone through the detention record produced by the ld. UT Counsel.
10.
Keeping in view the aforesaid perusal and the consideration of the
rival arguments advanced on both the sides in the light of law on the
subject, this Court is of the opinion that a ground is made out for interfering
with the impugned detention order as the same suffers from patent
illegality, misuse of power and non-application of mind on the part of the
detaining authority.
11.
The main issues for redressal in the instant case are:
I.
Whether the allegations against the petitioner culminating into
registration of two Case FIR‟s both already disposed of and recording
of some DD Reports have the tendency to be prejudicial to the social
order and if the answer is in the negative, whether the impugned
detention order suffers from non-application of mind?
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |8
12.
Taking the issue for determination, the Court in the facts and
circumstances of the case is of the opinion that although the criminal acts
of petitioner which have culminated into the registration of two case FIRs
and three DD Reports, no doubt, amount to infraction of law and order by
falling within the definition of relevant offences under IPC/BNS, yet this
does not constitute any public disorder.
13.
It is apt to reproduce the provisions of Section 8(3) of the Act
which defines the social order for the purposes of Section 8(1)(a) of the
Act.
“8. Detention of certain persons
(3)
For the purposes of sub-section (1)
[(a) omitted.
(b) “acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of
public order” means –
(i)
promoting, propagating or attempting to create, feelings
of enmity or hatred or disharmony on ground of religion, race,
caste, community, or region;
(ii)
making preparations for using, or attempting to use, or
using, or instigating, inciting, provoking or otherwise, abetting
the use of force where such preparation, using, attempting,
instigating, inciting, provoking or abetting, disturbs or is likely to
disturb public order;
(iii)
attempting to commit, or committing, or instigating,
inciting, provoking or otherwise abetting the commission of,
mischief within the meaning of section 425 of the Ranbir Penal
Code where the commission of such mischief disturbs, or is
likely to disturb public order;
(iv)
attempting to commit, or committing, or instigating,
inciting, provoking or otherwise abetting the commission of an
offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life or
imprisonment of a term extending to seven years or more, where
the commission of such offence disturbs, or is likely to disturb
public order;
[(c) “smuggling” in relation to timber or liquor means possessing
or carrying of illicit timber or liquor and includes any act which
will render the timber or liquor liable to confiscation under the
Jammu and Kashmir Forest Act, Samvat, 1987 or under the
Jammu and Kashmir Excise Act, 1958, as the case may be;]
[(d) “timber” means timber of Fir, Kail, Chir or Deodar tree
whether in logs or cut up in pieces but does not include
firewood;]
[(e) “Liquor” includes all alcoholic beverages including beer]”.
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |9
14.
The Hon„ble Apex Court has in a catena of judgments noted the
difference between, “law and order” and “public order”.
15.
In Ram Manohar Lohia Vs. State of Bihar (1966) 1 SCR 709, it
was held by the Hon„ble Apex Court through Hon„ble M. Hidayatullah. J.
(as the Chief Justice then was) at para 54 as under: “54. Public order if disturbed, must lead to public disorder.
Every breach of the peace does not lead to public disorder. When
two drunkards quarrel and fight there is disorder but not public
disorder. They can be dealt with under the powers to maintain law
and order but cannot be detained on the ground that they were
disturbing public order. Suppose that the two fighters were of
rival communities and one of them tried to raise communal
passions. The problem is still one of law and order but it raises
the apprehension of public disorder. Other examples can be
imagined. The contravention of law always affects order but
before it can be said to affect public order, it must affect the
community or the public at large. A mere disturbance of law and
order leading to disorder is thus not necessarily sufficient for
action under the Defence of India Act but disturbances which
subvert the public order are.”
16.
In Arun Ghosh vs. State of West Bengal (1970) 1 SCC 98 again
Hon„ble M. Hidayatullah, (CJ) observed that it is not the every case of a
general disturbance to public tranquility which can be termed as public
disorder and the test to be applied in such cases is whether the alleged act
leads to the disturbance of the current of life of the community so as to
amount to disturbance of the public order. That if the alleged act affects
some individual or individuals leaving tranquility of the society
undisturbed, the act cannot be termed as amounting to public disorder. In
that case the petitioner/detenu was detained by an order of a district
magistrate since he had been indulging in teasing, harassing and molesting
young girls and assaults on individuals of a locality. While holding that the
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |10
conduct of the petitioner/detenu could be reprehensible, it was further held
that it (read: the offending act) does not add up to the situation where it
may be said that the community at large was being disturbed or in other
words there was a breach of public order or likelihood of a breach of public
order.
The observations made by the Hon„ble Apex Court in the said case
at para 3 are reproduced as under:“3. Public order was said to embrace more of the community
than law and order. Public order is the even tempo of the life of
the community taking the country as a whole or even a specified
locality. Disturbance of public order is to be distinguished from
acts directed against individuals which do not disturb the society
to the extent of causing a general disturbance of public
tranquility. It is the degree of disturbance and its affect upon the
life of the community in a locality which determines whether the
disturbance amounts only to a breach of law and order. … It is
always a question of degree of the harm and its affect upon the
community.…This question has to be faced in every case on
facts. There is no formula by which one case can be distinguished
from another.”
17.
In Kuso Sah vs. The State of Bihar (1974) 1 SCC 195, the
Hon„ble Apex Court through Hon‟ble Y.V. Chandrachud, J. (as the Chief
Justice then was) speaking for the Bench held at paras 4 & 6 as under:“4. The two concepts have well defined contours, it being well
established that stray and unorganized crimes of theft and assault
are not matters of public order since they do not tend to affect the
even flow of public life. Infractions of law are bound in some
measure to lead to disorder but every infraction of law does not
necessarily result in public disorder.”
“6. The power to detain a person without the safeguard of a
court trial is too drastic to permit a lenient construction and
therefore Courts must be astute to ensure that the detaining
authority does not transgress the limitations subject to which
alone the power can be exercised.”
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |11
18.
The allegations against the petitioner-detenu as per the pending DD
Reports bearing No. 14 dated 21.12.2024, No. 08 dated 22.12.2024 & No.
16 dated
17.02.2025 at Police Station Chenani
are
regarding the
smuggling of bovine animals, not having resulted in the commission of
any social disorder by affecting the society as a whole. It is not even the
allegation or in reports that any resentment was shown by the public at
large.
The alleged activities of the petitioner/detenue, which present a law
and order situation to be dealt with under the normal law, cannot warrant
or justify preventive detention on the pretext of “public disorder.”.
19.
On the basis of the afore referred authoritative Judgments, this
Court is of the opinion that the Detaining Authority has not applied its
mind before passing the impugned detention order.
20.
It was incumbent upon the Detaining Authority to satisfy itself as to
how the ordinary criminal law is inadequate to deal with the petitioner. No
case FIR stands registered against the petitioner subsequent to disposal of
the earlier two case FIRs, three DD Reports being unverified and not
proceeded by any formal FIR cannot be acted upon. There appears no
proximity or live link between the alleged allegations and the need for
passing of the detention order.
21.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of “Rekha Vs. State of Tamil
Nadu through Secretary to Government and Anr” reported in (2011) 5
SCC 244, has laid emphasis on the fundamental right to life and personal
liberty of a citizen of India guaranteed under Article 21 of our Constitution
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |12
and has, accordingly, stressed for taking great care and caution while
passing any preventive detention orders so that same are passed in case of
genuine and inevitable need only without any misuse or abuse of the
powers.
22.
The preventive detentions need to be passed with great care and
caution keeping in mind that a citizen‟s most valuable and inherent human
right is being curtailed. The arrests in general and the preventive detentions
in particular are an exception to the most cherished fundamental right
guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The preventive
detentions are made on the basis of subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority in relation to an apprehended conduct of the detenue by
considering his past activities without being backed by an immediate
complaint as in the case of the registration of the FIR and, as such, is a
valuable trust in the hands of the trustees. The provisions of Clauses (1)
and (2) of Article 22 of our Constitution are not applicable in the case of
preventive detentions. So, the provisions of Clause (5) of the Article 22 of
our Constitution, with just exception as mentioned in Clause (6), requiring
for application of mind, subjective satisfaction, inevitability of the
detention order, proper and prompt communication of the grounds of
detention and the information of liberty to make a representation against
the detention order, are the imperative and detention order.
23.
For the foregoing discussion, the impugned order appears to be the
outcome of the non-application of mind and misuse of powers.
HCP (86/2025)
P a g e |13
24.
The petitioner/detenue has already suffered detention of about more
than 11 months pursuant to the detention order.
25.
Accordingly, the petition is allowed and the impugned detention
order bearing No.
04-PSA-2025 dated: 07.05.2025 passed by the
respondent No. 2 i.e. District Magistrate, Udhampur, is quashed with the
direction to the respondents to release the petitioner/detenu, namely Rashid
s/o Ibrahim r/o Bupp Sarar, Tehsil Chenani, District Udhampur forthwith
from his preventive detention in the instant case.
(Mohd Yousuf Wani)
Judge
Jammu
29.04.2026
Ayaz
Whether the judgment is speaking?
Whether approved for reporting?
HCP (86/2025)
No
No.
P a g e |14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review