Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
!#$% # & ' ()%* + ,
-"
.
""" ((#**
/
0#)121
3 #1(&
# /
!
.
""" ((#**
/
0#)121
3 #1(&
'
7 5
"
!!
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
" #
" #
) "*
$ $+''&$ & (
)
"
,!
! "
$ $%&'&$ & (
!!
-
. / 0
!6
# /
-20
! "
!6
" "
, "
"
/. ,
!
!!
1. ,
! " # .
&% &
& &
"" ,
"
.
"
"
)
,"
"
"
!!
"
.
!!
*"
!!
/"
.
!
,
"
",
" ,
'2(
)" "
" ,0
" ,
.0
"
*
" "
)
.
& (
&3 & ' .
!"
. -
&
3(
" ) .,
"
!
" "
3 67
.
"
"
" . !
" ,
"
2 (
"
. " !"
( &&&8$
! "
"
.
.
,
" !
" !"
!
.0
" ,
, *"
!. -
"
."
/!.
!
$! "
! "
.
* "
*
*
" " ,0 "
&3 & '
!
" ,
$3($
$ ' (
"
5 .0
"
., <#
,"
, "
!!
5 .0
" ,
5= 0
*
!
:
*
" ,
5 .0
.!"
-
" ,
0 .
*" , !
0 . 6 &&
" ,
"
*
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
" "
.
" ,
!!
"
! "
"
*
" 0"
" ,
5 *
!
!
*
" ,
.;
0 "
" "
.
* "
.,
.;
5 !
-3."
" ,
, *"
""
! "
5 .0
!
9" ,
.
"
"
"!
*
" "
.
0 , "
.
>"
*"
"!
0 , * "
.
*
!. "
0 , * "
*
"
!
" !
?
/"
.
*
5 .0
! "
!
"
"
."
! !
*"
!!
.
!
)
"
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2 ("
>"
!
*
"
" ,
.
! !
*
"
"
5 !
"
!
" !
*
*
!
! !
" ,
! !
!
,
>"
!. 0 9 "
*"
!
"
! "
*
"
0 ,
*
*
."
!!
.,
*
&("
!
"
*"
0 , * "
."
*
*
!!
" , *
!. "
!
"!
0 5 !
?
' 0
!
!!
*
*
"
>"
" " , 6( 0
0 , * "
* "
*
!
" "
!
!
"!
"
!. 0 9 "
*
" " , 3&
* 0
* 0
" ,
" " ,*
*
0 ,
*"
3 6 7
."
&
*
" ,
5 !
* 0
*
*
!
" ,
0 ,* "
%&
!
=
.
! !
*"
9$.!
"
.
! "
<#
"
"
. *"
! "
(6
5 !
" ,
-4=
6+ #
."
# *
"
!
.
", "
"
!
# !"
;."
.
4" " ,
!"
.
"
, *"
"
!
&6 #
# *
.!! "
!!
*
,
" ,
!!
.
"
* "
"
" ) ., @
!
,."
!
*" , *"
!"
"
.0
"
"
!
."
>
"
A
:
<# . *"
:
"
5 !
:+
/
" ,
!
" ,
:%
)
:(
"
."
."
"
5 .0
!
" ,
*
# = "
!.
"0
" ,
"
3 &' & (
Statements of the appellants under Section 313 Cr.P.C were
recorded in which all the incriminating evidence appearing against the
appellants was put to them, appellants denied the same and pleaded their
innocence. They took the plea that they have been falsely involved in the
present case and nothing was recovered from them. Appellants opted to
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-5lead evidence in their defence. However, no evidence was led by the
appellants in their defence.
.
,
"
.
"
"
" "
!
"
*"
*
.
.,
* "
!!
*
!
$
."
!"
)
" "
"
!!
"
""
*
!!
/ "
!.0 " !
"
)
!
.0 .
!
" ,
"
<
,.
"
"
5 !
!
."
"
$ >
.
"
"
"
!
" "
$
, "
"
:
"
*"
;."
.
# .
"
", " ,
!"
"
"
" "
" 0
"
*
"
!!
"
$ >
" , *
"
* "
*
!
""
* "
. " ,
" " ,
!!
.
"
"
!
"
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
.
"
"
"
"
*"
# .
.
! "
*
!!
.
!!
.
# .
*
.0 " "
'2(
"
!!
4.
"
/ "
# .
"
!!
"
*"
,.
"
" , "
"
" ,
!
"
.,,
-6."
"
"
* 0
!!
" "
)"
!
# .
"
# . "
.
"
"
" ,
" ,
.
" ,
.
!!
" ,
!
0 ",
,
.
.,
*
.
/. ,
!!
.
, 0
!
.
"
"
!
!!
" # .
"
# .
, *"
"
!
"
!
" , .
<
#
, *"
"
!!
" " ,
$ >
"
"
"
>
*"
.
"
A$
"
$
% &
' ( "
)
* +
% & $
!
"
* + )
'
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
" ,
( "
-7!, '
!, . /
"
-
"
!
!,+ 0"- "
"
% &
$
!
"
* +)
' ( "
1 )
(
% & $
!
"
* +)
' (
"
% & $
!
"
* + )
'
.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
( "
-8-
3 "
(
(
% &$
!
"
* +)
'
(
"
-4
(
-
+
!
"
' ( "
% &$
!
"
* +)
' ( "
5"$
6 ! 3
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-
-90!!
"
-
!
"
' (
"
"
!
"
.
.
.
0"
3 67
"
"
" . !
" "
*"
"
"
>
/"
" ,
,
*
"
! ""
*"
"
!
"
"
"
"
.
$/ " " ,
"
!
;." " ,
!
"
." ,
*"
"
$/ " " ,
!
."
" # .
.
!!
$
"
"
*"
"
"
"
"
!
"
!
! "
!!
/"
!!
." B
.
"
" ,
"
"
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
" 0
3 6 7
" . !
"
*
"
"
" ,
!
" . !
" ,
.
"0" "
*"
" ,
"
2 (
.0
" "
. *
."
"
"
# .
!
."
"
2 (
!
" "
"
;.
"
"
# .
-10"
"
" "
"
!
"
! "
. "
*"
!!
0 ,"
*"
!
,
"
"
"
" "
!!
.!!
" ,
! ""
!
" "
"
* "
"
" "
"
"
"
!
!
# .
" !"
"
"
*"
"
"
"
!
"
!
" ,
.
" "
, "
"
0 "
!!
"
!
!
!!
", "
!!
.
",
.0
" " ,
!!
" ,
& (!
"
"
1. ,
/. ,
! " # .
"
"
= 0 " ,
*"
;.
;.
.
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
!. "
"
5 "
"
*
"
"
!!
&
!
"
" "
."
*
"
"
"
!
.
;.
"
"
"
.
"
"
.0
! "
"
" !"
."
"
*"
!!
! "
"
!!
"
" !"
"
!
0 .
" !"
$ >
.
.
!!
!!
5 "
.0 "
"
# .
*
*
-11.
,
",
. " !"
.
,
" .
!. "
.0
! "
.
! "
*" ,
"
! "
. 0
!!
/"
"
* "
" ", " ,
;.
.
A$
a.
" ,
.
,
.
&6
" !
" # .
.
" portion of the custodial
.0
sentence has been suffered.
!!
b.
.
,
*"
&(
" !
" ,
C < !!
&(
.
"
# .
.
.0
"
portion of the custodial sentence has been suffered.
c. The occurrence in question dates back to the year 2019 and a
considerable time has elapsed since then. The appellants have
faced the protracted agony of criminal trial for more than 07
years and the psychological and social ramifications of facing
criminal prosecution for such an extended duration constitute
a relevant mitigating circumstance.
d. As per the custody certificate produced by the State, the
appellant- Palwinder Singh @Happy is not involved in any
other criminal case. There is no material to suggest
habituality or recurrence of criminal conduct.
e. The appellants have maintained good conduct throughout and
is ready to be integrated into society. There is nothing on
record to indicate any subsequent misconduct. The absence
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-12of antecedents and their continued social integration deserve
a lenient and reformative approach in the matter of sentence.
.
!!
!
"
!
" "
"
!
. !"
.
;.
"
"
"
. !
! " "!
" "
*
, "
"
!
.
"
" ,
<
/. " ! .
"
!
"
#$%
&
A$
“32. The imposition of punishment is a refined judicial
function that demands a careful harmonization of its
underlying purposes namely, retribution, deterrence, and
reformation. This balance must reflect not only the reasoning
of the Court but also the ethical standards and social context
in which justice is administered. As societal values and
circumstances evolve, the prominence accorded to each of
these aims necessarily varies, requiring the Court to adapt
its emphasis in response to the changing demands of justice.
The aforesaid principle found early articulation in the
writings of Justice Caldwell, who, in his authoritative work
“Criminology,” observed that:
“If the infliction of pain is to have its greatest effect upon the
behavior of a person, it must follow soon after the act for
which it is given. But punishment always takes place weeks
or even months after the offense has been committed, since
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-13the offender must first be apprehended, tried, and convicted.
Such delay tends to disconnect the punishment from the
offense in the mind of the offender, and it may well be
considered as merely another painful experience in an unjust
world.”
33. Moreover, Italian criminologist and jurist Cesare
Beccaria, in his seminal treatise “On Crimes and
Punishments,” propounded the doctrine of penal parsimony,
emphasizing that the justification of any criminal justice
system rests upon its capacity to inflict the least possible evil
necessary to achieve its ends. The underlying premise is that
punishment, being in itself a necessary evil and devoid of
inherent virtue, must be confined strictly within the bounds of
necessity. The imposition of suffering or restriction upon an
offender cannot extend beyond what is indispensable for the
preservation of social order.
34. While ‘retributive ’object of sentencing is seen regressive,
in modern day sentencing jurisprudence for its focus on
punishing proportionally for the harm done and caters to the
negative senses of spite and anger against a wrongful act, the
rehabilitative/reformative
circumstances
surrounding
approach
examines
the
on
offender
the
social,
economical, physical and psychological level so as to
reintegrate the offender in the social mainstream. The law
extends the benefit of good and perceives a probability and
possibility of reform. It aims at capitalising a perceived
social liability. The expectation of law is based on the
surrounding circumstances to distinguish between a
‘criminal ’and an ‘offender’.
35. While the pre-requisites of crime do not distinguish two
persons, on the legal scale, this aspect is significant for
sentencing. A mere involvement of a person in crime may not
necessarily mark a person as a ‘criminal.‘ ’Criminality ’in
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
-14mind and action has to be determined from the totality of
circumstances including the mode and manner in committing
an offence, the conduct pre and post the offence, the criminal
antecedents, nature of involvement, influence of peers etc.
and not just from an isolatory consideration of commission
of an offence. A Court of law would not assume every
offender to be beyond reform and differentiate in punishment
on considering whether the offences arise due to human error
or that stem from actions propelled by mens rea.
36. The case in hand is yet another where interest of justice
would warrant a reformative approach in precedence to a
punitive or retributive approach. It is not the function of the
judges to seek the transformation of human nature itself, but
rather to shape the framework within which individuals
perceive that adherence to the law aligns with their own best
interests.”
9" , "
"
!
"
" .
" ", " , " .
!
;.
,
"
,
* 0
.
,
! ""
" "
!!
5 "
"
.
.
!!
"
" . ," , "
"
.
!!
!
!!
!
"
.
" "
;.
,
*
, .
,
! " "!
!" ,
"0
"
!
/. ,
"
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
!!
" "
*
!
" ,
1. ,
&
( )/*8 **&9#
: "
! " # .
"
& ("
""
"
-15*
.
,
!!
.
"
"!
"
" / "
"
*"
*
, "
" ,
"
!! "
"
;."
"
"
" ,
!
-"
!
0 !
"
! "
6;#/;#) 1(# <% =>)# 1& # '
6;#/;#) )#(&)/ ?*#
'
RAJ KUMAR ARORA
2026.04.20 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
! "
!!
()%* + ,
) : )&)
"
!6
!
#1> &
#1> &
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review