Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRA-S-245-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
Sr. No.146
CRA-S-245-2026
Date of Decision: 09.03.2026
...Appellant
RAM KISHAN
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS
....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANDEEP PANNU
Present:-
Mr. Lupil Gupta, Mr. Apurv Kamboj and
Mr. Jashandeep Singh, Advocates
for the appellant.
Mr. Hardeep Hans, AAG, Punjab.
Mr. Vikram Singh, Ms. Arushi Lamba Brar and Mr. Vishavjeet
S. Beniwal, Advocates for respondents No. 2 and 3.
*****
MANDEEP PANNU, J. (Oral)
1.
The present criminal appeal has been filed by Ram Kishan,
appellant/complainant, challenging the order dated 16th October 2025, vide
which the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Bathinda has made absolute
the bail order dated 8th October 2025 and has granted anticipatory bail to
respondents No. 2 and 3, namely Sukhbir Singh and Sukraj Singh.
2.
The facts of the case, as emerging from the FIR are that the
proceedings originated from Application No. 650517 dated 28.08.2025
submitted by complainant Ram Krishan to the authorities, which was
forwarded through official channels including the National Commission for
Scheduled Castes and the office of the Senior Superintendent of Police,
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
Bathinda, regarding alleged illegal occupation of his house. In the
application, it was alleged that respondents Sukhbir Singh and Sukhraj
Singh had illegally occupied his house, had not paid any rent or utility bills,
and had damaged the property and removed his name plate. It was further
alleged that they had acted with the intention of permanently usurping the
property, despite knowing that the house belonged to a person belonging to a
Scheduled Caste, and that they were residing there along with their family.
The complainant also stated that earlier a written compromise dated
06.01.2025 had been effected but the occupants failed to comply with its
terms, and despite seeking three months’ time to vacate the house, they
neither vacated it even after about seven months nor cleared any dues. The
application was thereafter taken up by the police authorities and forwarded
by the Senior Superintendent of Police, Bathinda to DSP City-2, Bathinda
for investigation. Thereafter, the matter was examined on the basis of the
earlier inquiry report submitted by the investigating officer, which had been
forwarded for legal opinion to DDA Legal, Bathinda. The Deputy District
Attorney, vide office letter dated 16.04.2025, opined that since the dispute
was under consideration before the Rent Controller, no action was required
on the part of the local police and the application be filed, leaving it open to
the applicant to approach the competent authority. The said opinion was
examined in office on 18.04.2025.
3.
Subsequently, copies of the first investigation report along with
the legal opinion were forwarded with a request to obtain fresh legal opinion
so that the matter could be reconsidered on the basis of facts and a proper
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
report could be submitted to the National Commission for Scheduled Castes.
The Deputy Superintendent of Police, City Bathinda, who had conducted the
inquiry, submitted the report accordingly. Upon perusal thereof, the Senior
Superintendent of Police, Bathinda directed the SP-D to examine the matter
and furnish comments, pursuant to which a further investigation report dated
26.09.2025 was prepared. In the said report, reference was made to the
complaint filed by Ram Krishan before the National Commission for
Scheduled Castes alleging forcible occupation of his house and related acts
against Sukhbir Singh and Sukhraj Singh, and the matter was processed for
further action.Thereafter, during investigation conducted by DSP City-2,
Bathinda, statements of the parties were recorded and it was noted that the
respondents Sukhbir Singh and Sukhraj Singh were alleged to have occupied
the house knowing that the complainant belonged to a Scheduled Caste and
were stated to be residing there without any agreement. It was also recorded
that, as per the statements considered during inquiry, the complainant Ram
Krishan had earlier rented out the said house situated in Narwana Estate,
Bathinda to the respondents on 02.10.2023 and had retained one room on the
second floor for himself. It was further observed that rent fixed between the
parties was paid only twice in installments and thereafter payment of rent
was stopped. When the complainant asked them to vacate the premises, they
allegedly refused, whereupon he instituted proceedings before the Rent
Controller.
4.
The report further recorded allegations that when the
complainant visited the house, he was not allowed to enter by the
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
respondents, who also removed the name plate bearing his name from the
gate and installed cameras in the house without his consent. It was also
alleged that in the presence of Harpreet Singh, they used caste-based
language against the complainant and threatened him. On the basis of these
allegations, the inquiry officer opined that the acts attributed to Sukhbir
Singh and Sukhraj Singh prima facie satisfied the ingredients of offences
under Sections 3(1)(g), (r) and (s) of the SC & ST Act and Section 351(3) of
the BNS, and recommended that a case be registered and investigated.
Acting on the said report, the Senior Superintendent of Police, Bathinda
directed the SHO, Police Station Civil Lines, Bathinda to proceed in
accordance with law, and consequently a criminal case was registered
against the aforesaid accused persons and investigation was set in motion.
Thereafter, the present petitioners/accused Sukhbir Singh and Sukhraj Singh
moved an application seeking anticipatory bail in the aforesaid FIR. The
learned counsel for the applicants contended that they were innocent and that
the FIR did not contain any specific allegation attracting the provisions of
the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. It
was further submitted that the FIR had been registered only after the
complainant approached the National Commission for Scheduled Castes and
that even on a bare reading of the complaint, no derogatory words against
the caste of the complainant had been alleged. On the other hand, the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor assisted by counsel for the complainant
opposed the application and argued that specific allegations had been
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
levelled and that there existed a statutory bar under Section 18 of the Act
against the grant of anticipatory bail.
5.
Vide order dated 08.10.2025, the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Bathinda granted interim anticipatory bail to the applicants. While
doing so, the Court, upon prima facie consideration of the record and the
allegations contained in the complaint and FIR, observed that no specific
allegation regarding use of caste-based derogatory language against the
complainant was made out and, therefore, a prima facie offence under the
SC & ST Act did not appear to be established at that stage. The Court further
noted that where the ingredients of an offence under the Act are not
disclosed on the face of the record, the statutory bar contained in Section 18
would not operate. Holding the case to be fit for grant of interim protection,
the Court directed that the applicants join the investigation and ordered that
in the event of their joining investigation, they shall be released on bail on
furnishing bail bonds to the satisfaction of the Investigating Officer, subject
to conditions as envisaged under Section 482(2) of the BNSS.
Vide impugned order dated 16.10.2025, the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Bathinda allowed the application filed by the accused and made the
interim anticipatory bail granted earlier absolute. While doing so, the Court
observed that as per the record, the first complaint filed by the complainant
in December 2024 did not contain any allegation that the present applicants
had used caste-based derogatory language against him. The Court further
noticed that although subsequent statements alleged use of such words,
neither the complainant nor witness Harpreet Singh had disclosed the date,
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
month or year of the alleged utterances, and that the statements of other
witnesses recorded later introduced such allegations for the first time. It was
also noted that the relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties
was admitted and eviction proceedings were already pending before the Rent
Controller, and therefore the dispute appeared to be essentially civil in nature
at that stage.
6.
The Court further recorded that the statements relied upon by
the prosecution were vague regarding time and particulars of the alleged
caste-based remarks and lacked specific details. In these circumstances,
without commenting on the merits of the case, the Court held that no ground
was made out to deny the concession of anticipatory bail and consequently
ordered that the interim order dated 08.10.2025 be made absolute, subject to
the conditions earlier imposed, while clarifying that the observations were
only for the purpose of deciding the bail application.
7.
Feeling aggrieved by the impugned order dated 16.10.2025
passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Bathinda, whereby the
interim anticipatory bail granted to respondents No.2 and 3 was made
absolute, the present appeal has been preferred by the complainant/appellant
Ram Kishan. Learned counsel for the appellant has contended that the
learned trial Court failed to appreciate that Inspector Harjot Singh, while
appearing before it, had specifically stated that during investigation it had
come to light from the statements of witnesses that respondents No.2 and 3
had used derogatory remarks against the caste of the appellant, and thus
prima facie offences under the provisions of the SC/ST Act were clearly
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
attracted; however, this vital aspect was ignored by the Court while granting
relief. It has further been argued that the statements of the complainant and
witness Harpreet Singh recorded on 23.09.2025 disclosed that when they
visited the accused to ask them to vacate the premises or pay rent, castebased abusive words were used against the appellant, and subsequent
statements of witnesses Sohan Lal, Pushpinderpal Singh and Buta Singh
recorded on 15.10.2025 also supported the allegation by specifying that such
words were used in September 2025. According to learned counsel, the trial
Court erred in discarding these statements as vague merely because the exact
date was not mentioned, despite corroborative material on record and despite
the FIR itself disclosing allegations of caste-based abuse. It has additionally
been submitted that the learned trial Court overlooked the statutory bar
contained in Section 18 of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act against grant of anticipatory bail where a
prima facie offence is made out, and therefore the order granting such relief
is contrary to settled law. In support of his submissions, reliance has been
placed upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kiran vs.
Rajkumar Jivraj Jain (SLP (Crl.) No. 8169 of 2025), wherein it has been
held that although Section 18 creates a bar against anticipatory bail in cases
involving offences under the SC/ST Act, the Court must examine the FIR
and allegations to determine whether a prima facie offence is disclosed; if
such accusations exist, the bar would operate and anticipatory bail ought not
to be granted. It is thus contended that in the present case, since the
allegations and witness statements prima facie disclose commission of
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
offences under the Act, the impugned order is illegal and liable to be set
aside.
8.
Notice of motion was issued in the present appeal. In response
thereto, the learned State counsel appeared and advanced arguments broadly
on the same lines as those addressed by learned counsel for the
complainant/appellant, supporting the challenge to the impugned order.
9.
Per-contra, learned counsel for respondents No. 2 and 3/accused
on the other hand has argued that there is no illegality in the impugned order.
Learned Court below has rightly held that the ingredients of Section 3(1)(g),
3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) are not made out.
10.
After hearing learned counsel for the appellant, as well as
learned State counsel and learned counsel for respondents No. 2 and 3, and
upon careful perusal of the record, this Court is of the considered opinion
that no illegality, perversity or jurisdictional error can be said to have been
committed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge while passing the
impugned order making the interim anticipatory bail absolute.
11.
At the outset, it is necessary to note that the scope of
interference by an appellate court against an order granting anticipatory bail
is limited, particularly when such order is based on appreciation of record
and prima facie assessment of allegations. The material placed on record
reveals that the dispute between the parties primarily arises out of a
landlord–tenant relationship, which is not disputed. The record further shows
that the complainant/appellant himself had rented out the house to
respondents No.2 and 3 pursuant to a rent agreement executed on
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
02.10.2023 for a specified period. It is also borne out from the record that
eviction proceedings are already pending before the Rent Controller. Thus,
the genesis of the dispute is essentially civil in nature relating to possession
and tenancy, and the criminal proceedings appear to have been initiated in
the backdrop of that civil dispute. The learned trial Court has taken note of
this foundational circumstance and rightly treated it as a relevant factor
while assessing the existence of a prima facie case.
12.
A perusal of the record further shows that the first complaint
admittedly filed by the complainant in December 2024 did not contain any
allegation that the accused had used caste-based derogatory words against
him. The allegation regarding use of such words surfaced only in subsequent
statements recorded during inquiry. Even in those later statements, neither
the complainant nor the witness Harpreet Singh disclosed the specific date,
month or year when such words were allegedly uttered. The statements of
other witnesses, namely Sohan Lal, Pushpinderpal Singh and Buta Singh,
recorded subsequently, also introduced such allegations without giving
precise particulars of time or circumstances. The learned Additional Sessions
Judge has carefully evaluated this aspect and found that the allegations were
vague and lacking material particulars. This Court finds no fault in such
appreciation, because for attracting the provisions of Sections 3(1)(r) and
3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act, the allegation must prima facie disclose intentional
insult or abuse by caste name in a place within public view. In the absence of
clear particulars regarding the occurrence, the context, and the public nature
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
of the alleged utterances, the essential ingredients of the offence cannot be
said to be disclosed on the face of the record.
13.
Likewise, the allegation relating to wrongful dispossession
under Section 3(1)(g) of the Act also does not prima facie stand established.
The admitted position that the complainant had voluntarily given the
premises on rent to the accused pursuant to a rent arrangement and that
eviction proceedings are pending before the competent civil forum prima
facie negates the element of wrongful dispossession contemplated under the
said provision. Whether the accused/respondents No.2 and 3 have
overstayed after expiry of tenancy or failed to pay rent is essentially a matter
to be adjudicated by the Rent Controller or civil court and does not, by itself,
constitute an offence under the special statute unless accompanied by the
specific statutory ingredients, which are not clearly disclosed here. The
learned trial Court was therefore justified in observing that, at this stage, the
dispute appears predominantly civil and that the penal provisions of the
special enactment are not attracted prima facie.
14.
This Court also finds that the learned Additional Sessions Judge
correctly applied the settled principle that although Section 18 of the SC/ST
Act creates a bar against grant of anticipatory bail, such bar operates only
when the allegations in the complaint or FIR disclose, on their face, the
commission of an offence under the Act. Where the Court, upon prima facie
examination, finds that the essential ingredients of the alleged offence are
not made out, the statutory bar would not apply. The learned trial Court has
precisely undertaken such prima facie scrutiny and recorded reasons for its
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
conclusion. The reasoning cannot be said to be arbitrary or perverse so as to
warrant interference.
15.
As regards the judgment relied upon by learned counsel for the
appellant, namely Kiran vs. Rajkumar Jivraj Jain (Supra) the same is
clearly distinguishable on facts. In the said decision, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court reiterated that anticipatory bail is barred where the accusations
specifically disclose commission of an offence under the SC/ST Act. The
ratio of that judgment presupposes the existence of clear and specific
allegations constituting the offence. In the present case, however, the learned
trial Court has recorded a categorical prima facie finding that the allegations
regarding caste-based abuse are vague, lacking particulars, and absent from
the earliest complaint, and that the dispute substantially arises from a
tenancy. Therefore, the foundational factual requirement for applying the
principle laid down in the aforesaid judgment is itself not satisfied.
Consequently, the reliance placed upon that authority is misplaced and does
not advance the case of the appellant.
16.
It is well settled that at the stage of consideration of anticipatory
bail, the Court is not required to conduct a meticulous examination of
evidence but only to see whether the allegations, taken at face value,
disclose the ingredients of the alleged offences. In the present case, the
learned Additional Sessions Judge has undertaken precisely such an exercise
and has given cogent reasons for concluding that no prima facie case under
the special statute is made out so as to attract the statutory bar. The order
reflects due application of mind, consideration of relevant factors, and
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
CRA-S-245-2025
adherence to settled legal principles. No material has been shown before this
Court to demonstrate that the discretion exercised by the learned Court
below was either arbitrary, capricious or contrary to law.
17.
Accordingly, this Court finds no merit in the present appeal.
The impugned order dated 16.10.2025 passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Bathinda does not suffer from any illegality or infirmity
warranting interference, and the same deserves to be upheld.
18.
However, nothing observed herein shall be construed as an
expression of opinion on the merits of the case.
19.
All pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(MANDEEP PANNU)
JUDGE
09.03.2026
Anu
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
ANU
2026.03.10 17:49
I am the author of this document
Chandigarh
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review