Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A (J) NO.22 OF 2021
Ranjit Ghosh,
S/o- Late Felu Ghosh,
Of Haripur, P.S. Belonia,
Dist- South Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura.
-----Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. A. Acharjee, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.
Date of hearing
: 17.11.2022.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 30/11/2022.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(ACTING)
JUDGMENT & ORDER
This is an appeal filed under Section 374 of
Cr.P.C. against the impugned judgment of conviction and
sentence dated 01.10.2021 passed by the learned Sessions
Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in Case No.ST 13(Type-II) of
whereby
and
whereunder
the
appellant
has
been
convicted under Section 304-B of IPC and sentenced him to
suffer R.I. for 7(seven) years and to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/(Rupees ten thousand only) with default stipulation.
2.
The facts of the case in brief, which may be
relevant for the present purpose and manifest on the record
are that based on the FIR lodged by the brother of the victim,
namely, Sri Bidhan Majumder, with the O/C, Belonia P.S.
alleging inter alia that, on 01.03.2005, in the night at around
11.30 P.M., to 12.00 P.M. some people informed him that his
sister is seriously ill and lying in Belonia hospital. He along with
some villagers went to Belonia Hospital, but he did not find the
husband and other relatives of the victim-sister. Thereafter, he
came to know from a doctor that his victim-sister, Bipula
Majumder was brought dead to the hospital and her dead body
was kept in the morgue. It was also alleged that his sister
Bipula Majuder was married to the accused-Ranjit Ghosh about
10(ten) months back from the date of the incident. Accused
Ranjit Ghosh and his mother Smt. Priyabala Ghosh used to
torture her on demand of money. On 14.02.2005, Bipula came
to
the
house
of
the
informant
as
the
torture
became
unbearable. On 18.02.2015, the informant along with his
sister-Bipula
went
to
her
husband’s
house
and
gave
Rs.10,000/-. But the accused-Ranjit Ghosh and his mother
Smt. Priyabala Ghosh demanded more money. Ultimately,
Bipula was found dead. After that, the informant lodged the
FIR.
3.
On this, Belonia P.S. Case No.19/2005 under
Section 304-B and 109 of IPC was registered. The case was
investigated and on completion of the investigation, Sri Jayanta
Chakraborty, SDPO, Belonia filed charge-sheet against the
accused-Ranjit Ghosh and Smt. Priyabala Ghosh for the
commission of offence punishable under Sections 304-B and
109 of IPC.
4.
Having received the charge sheet, the then learned
Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Belonia took cognizance of
the offence punishable under Section 304-B and 109 of IPC
against the accused Ranjit Ghosh and committed the case to
the Court for trial. After that, the then learned Addl. Sessions
Judge, Belonia, South Tripura framed charges against the
accused person namely, Sri Ranjit Ghosh under Section 304-B
and 109 of IPC read with Section 304-B of IPC. The contents of
the charge were read over and explained to the accused
person, to which he pleaded not guilty and desired to stand the
trial. In total 26 witnesses were examined by the prosecution
to prove the charges against the accused person. After the
process of recording the evidence, the accused person was
subjected to the examination under Section 313 of Cr.P.C.
concerning
the
incriminating
circumstances
that
surfaced
against him in the evidence on record. The pleas are of total
denial and false implication. However, he declined to adduce
any witness in his defence.
5.
Learned Court below after hearing the arguments
of both sides found that the appellant guilty and convicted him
as mentioned herein-above.
6.
impugned
Being
judgment
aggrieved
of
and
dissatisfied
conviction
and
with
sentence
the
dated
01.10.2021, the appellant herein filed this instant appeal to set
aside the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence dated
01.10.2021.
7.
Heard
Mr.
A.
Acharjee,
learned
counsel
appearing for the appeal as well as Mr. S. Ghosh, learned Addl.
P.P. appearing for the State-respondent.
8.
Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for
the appellant submits that there is no evidence that the
appellant herein demanded dowry from the deceased wife or
his family members at any point in time. The deceased wife
was a mentally unstable person due to which she committed
suicide. P.W.1, the doctor who conducted the post-mortem
examination
in
his
report
opined
and
deposed
in
his
examination-in-chief that the cause of death was a cardiac
respiratory failure for consumption of suspected poison which is
suicidal in nature. No anti-mortem injury was found.
Stating
thus, learned counsel appearing for the appellant prayed to set
aside the impugned judgment and order of conviction.
9.
Mr. S. Ghosh, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for
the State respondent submitted that no independent witness
stated that the deceased victim was mentally unstable. But at
the same time, independent witnesses deposed that the victimdeceased was tortured by the appellant herein. Even the
husband did not appear in the hospital and he simply escaped
after bringing the body of the victim to the hospital. The
deposition of the independent witnesses and the act of the
husband in not appearing in the hospital creates sufficient
suspicion. Stating thus, learned Addl. P.P. urged this Court to
uphold the judgment and order of conviction as passed by the
Court below.
10.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
11.
Before we delve into the conclusion, let us
examine the prosecution witnesses.
12.
P.W.-1, Sri Bidhan Ch. Majumder, is the brother
of the deceased victim, Bipula Majumder. He has deposed that
the deceased is his younger sister. Three years back in 1411
B.S., 28th Jaishtha, she was married to Ranjit Ghosh of Haripur.
As per their demand, cash of Rs.25,000/- and other articles
were given during the marriage. After three days of the
marriage, his victim-sister informed that her in-laws were not
satisfied with the quality of the goods given by them and
rebuked her. On 14.02.2015, the victim-sister came to his
house and again told that the furniture given was not of good
quality, so she was rebuked by her husband and mother-inlaw. On 18.02.2015, he went to the house of the accused and
paid Rs.10,000/- to the guardian of the family of the accused
herein. Ranjit Ghosh, the accused herein told him that he was
not satisfied with that Rs.10,000/- and claimed another
Rs.15,000/-. Thereafter, he promised to pay on return from
home. On 01.03.2005, at about 11/12 P.M., cousin brother of
Ranjit Ghosh along with others went by an Auto in his house
and informed him about the illness of his victim sister who was
under treatment in Belonia Hospital. At about 1.00 A.M. he
came to Belonia hospital along with his uncle Gouranga
Majumder and Sangam Baidya and searched for his sister, but
she was not available in the hospital indoor. The doctor
informed that one Bipula Ghosh was brought to the Hospital
but she was brought dead and was kept in the morgue. In the
morning Ranjit Ghosh and his family members did not come.
He talked with the doctor and arranged for the post-mortem.
He carried the dead body to his house and arranged for the last
rituals, but her husband did not attend. He further deposed
that they had believed that she was killed for dowry. On the
next day, he submitted written FIR to the Belonia P.S. and it
was written by Sangam Baidya (P.W.21). He signed it when it
was read over and explained to him. He identified his signature
as Exbt-P/1/1. He also signed in the inquest report prepared by
P.W.24 which has been marked as Exbt-P/3/1.
In the cross, he has admitted that on 24.07.2004
the mother-in-law of his sister informed that his sister has
become mentally imbalanced and doing act of madness.
Accordingly, he went to their house and saw her sitting in a
room. He took her to the doctor, A.K. Nath for treatment. He
accompanied her and the doctor told him that she was
sometimes violent, did not work, sleep, and also
talks
irrelevant. He also admitted that he kept his sister in his house,
administered medicine, and treated her. After about 2(two)
months after recovery, she was sent back to her husband's
house. In the cross, he admitted that in the FIR he mentioned
that the accused was not satisfied with the furniture and the
accused demanded Rs.25,000/-. He also admitted that a
compromise meeting was held in presence of Keshab Baidya
and Manu Basu. Manu Basu decided that Ranjit Ghosh was to
arrange for the treatment of her sister.
13.
P.W.-2, Sri Bikram Majumder, and P.W.-3 Smt.
Taru Bala Majumder is the brother and mother respectively of
the deceased. Both the witnesses have deposed in the manner
of P.W.1.
In the cross, the defence has taken the plea that
Rs.10,000/- was given for the purpose of treatment of the
deceased and not for manufacturing the furniture again.
14.
P.W.-4, Sri Narendra Pal, and P.W.-8, Sri Keshab
Baidya are the neighbours of the informant, and P.W.-6, Sri
Dulal Baishnab is the neighbour of the accused. P.W.4 ad P.W.8
deposed that both were present in the marriage of the
deceased and the accused and also in the negotiation of the
marriage. They have deposed about the cash of Rs.25,000/-,
furniture and ornaments. Both have deposed that the accused
was not happy with the articles given in the marriage and he
started mental and physical torture for the furniture on the
victim. They also deposed that Rs.10,000/- was paid for the
furniture by the victim's family. P.W.4 further deposed that
P.W-1 brought her sister after getting information about her
illness and he arranged for her treatment. After staying for
about two and half months, then again, she went to her
husband’s house and her husband refused to take her on the
ground that she was mentally imbalanced. P.W.-4 also deposed
that the accused refused to take Rs.10,000/-, which was given
by Manaranjan Basu P.W.12.
15.
P.W-5, Sri Maran Debnath is the pradhan of the
Haripur Panchayat, who was present in the house of the
accused-Ranjit Ghosh in the meeting and he deposed that he
got information from his neighbour that Ranjit Ghosh was not
accepting his wife and allowing entry into his house who came
there with her brother. So the brother of the wife of Ranjit
informed the neighbour and the neighbour informed him. In
the next day morning, salish(meeting) was held in the house of
Ranjit Ghosh and in the meeting his wife and brother of his
wife were present along with members of Panchayat. Ranjit
Ghosh complained that his wife was ill, so she was taken to her
father’s house for treatment while the brother of the wife told
him they have arranged the treatment and refused that she
was still ill. Thereafter, it was decided in the meeting that
further treatment, if necessary, is to be done by both Ranjit
Ghosh and the brother of his wife. This witness was declared
hostile by the prosecution.
16.
P.W.7, Dr. Kallol Kr. Roy is the medical officer of
Hrishyamukh PHC and he deposed that on 01.03.2005 at about
07.30 to 8.00 P.M., victim-Bipula Majumder, was brought
before the PHC as she had taken poison. As she developed
compulsion and he referred her to Belonia hospital. He also
deposed that patient could not talk with him as she was
drowsy.
17.
P.W.-9, Sri Bikash Baidya supported the case of
the informant and he deposed in the same manner as the
informant.
18.
P.W.10, Sri Gouranga Majumder is the relative of
the deceased and he deposed about the cash, different articles
given in the marriage, and also handing over money by P.W.-1
to Ranjit Ghosh.
He is only a hearsay witness and his
deposition is not taken into consideration.
19.
P.W.11, Smt. Sajali Majumder is also a relative
of the deceased and she also deposed about the cash, different
articles given in the marriage, and also handing over money by
P.W.-1 to Ranjit Ghosh.
20.
P.W.-12, Sri Manoranjan Basu deposed that after
the marriage between the victim and Ranjit Ghosh there was
dispute and due to which a meeting was held in the house of
the accused-Ranjit Ghosh. In that meeting brother of the victim
was present and he gave Rs.10,000/- to the accused Ranjit but
he did not take it, but the brother of the victim left the money
with his wife. After the death of the victim, police came to his
house, and firstly he told the police that no such amount is
paid. Then he learned from his wife that P.W.1 had left
Rs.10,000/- to her, so the police asked him to pay the amount
to the Police Station. Accordingly, he deposited the amount to
the P.S. and Darogababu seized it by preparing a seizure list
and he signed in the seizure list as a witness. He identified his
signature in the seizure list as Exbt-P/2/1. Later on, the
witness was declared hostile for some other point.
In his cross-examination, the said witness stated that
he cannot say for what purpose Rs.10,000/- was decided to be
paid to the accused.
21.
P.W-13, Sri Sambhu Basu deposed that the
victim-deceased was known to him. On 01.03.2005 in the
night, he heard a hue and cry in the house of Ranjit Ghosh. He
went there and learned that Bipula, the victim had taken
poison. So, he took her to Hrishyamukh PHC. Manik Ghosh also
accompanied him. In the hospital, the doctor asked her many
questions and the doctor then referred her to Belonia hospital.
He also deposed that he does not know who took her to Belonia
hospital.
22.
P.W.-14, Dr. Sankar Chakraborty, and P.W.-18,
Dr. Bijoy Krishna Saha are the medical officers who conducted
the post-mortem examination of the deceased. The postmortem was exhibited as exhibit-P/3 and the signature of P.W18 was marked as exhibit-P/3/1. As per the opinion in the
post-mortem report, the cause of death was cardiorespiratory
failure due to the consumption of poison which was suicidal in
nature. There was no antemortem injury found on the body.
23.
P.W.16, Sri Santosh Debnath is a seizure witness
and he identified his signature in the seizure list as Exbt-P2/1.
24.
P.W.20, Smt Gita Basu is the wife of Manoranjan
Basu, P.W-12 and she stated that the brother of the victim, i.e.
P.W.-1 gave Rs.10,000/- to the accused herein but the accused
did not receive the money and told that they may arrange the
treatment with their money.
In her cross-examination, she stated that Bidhan
paid the money to the accused for the treatment of victimBipula. The accused-Ranjit told that he would treat his wife
with his own money.
25.
P.W.23,
Sri
Bijan
Pal
deposed
that
on
15.03.2005, darogababu seized cash of Rs.10,000/- from
Manoranjan Basu in presence of him. The seizure list was
prepared in his presence and he signed in the seizure list as a
witness. He identified his signature in the seizure list as a
witness. He identified his signature in the seizure list as Exbt-
P/2/2/. After the death of victim-Bipula, Manoranjan Basu
deposited the amount to darogababu.
26.
P.W.-21, Sri Sangam Baidya is the scribe of the
ejahar. He deposed that on the dictation of P.W.1 he wrote the
ejahar and he identified the written ejahar as Exbt-P/1. This
witness supported the version of P.W.1, the informant, but in
cross examination, he admitted that in his statement recorded
under Section 161 of Cr.P.C., it has not been mentioned that
the accused demanded Rs.15,000/- as furniture was of bad
quality. He also admits that no such statement is found in his
statement
recorded
under
Section
of
Cr.P.C,
that
Rs.10,000/- was placed in the custody of relative of Ranjit
Ghosh as the cost of furniture. He also admits that he has not
seen the accused torture the victim. He never visited the house
of the accused. He heard for Bidhan (P.W.-1).
27.
P.W.22, S.I. Anup Kr. Das is the I.O of this case
and he deposed that on 02.03.2005 he was posted on O/C
Hrishymaukh
outpost.
On
that
date,
Belonia
P.S.
case
No.19/2005, under Section 304-B and 109 of IPC was endorsed
to him for investigation. During the investigation, he arrested
the accused. On 03.03.2005 he visited the place of occurrence
and prepared a hand sketch map of the place of occurrence
and its index, recorded statements of witnesses, and seized the
wearing apparel of the deceased. On 19.03.2005 cash of
Rs.10,000/- was seized from Manoranjan Basu which was given
as dowry. He prepared the seizure list after seizure of the
currency notes. He identified the seizure list as exhibit-P/2. The
amount was sent to the Court and it was returned to P.W.1 by
the order of the Court. After his transfer, the case was handed
over to SDPO, Belonia, and later part of the investigation was
done by P.W.26, Sri Kamal Chakraborty, SDPO, Belonia.
P.W.26 confirmed the Exbt-P/6 and P/7 and after his transfer,
the
case
was
endorsed
to
his
successor
Sri
Jayanta
Chakraborty, who completed the investigation and submitted
the charge sheet.
28.
P.W.-24, Smt. Shibani Dey is the Executive
Magistrate of Belonia SDM Office and she accompanied O/C
Hrishyamukh outpost and went to the Belonia hospital morgue
and prepared the inquest report of the deceased in presence of
P.W.1. She identified the inquest report which has been
marked as Exbt-P/3.
29.
P.W-25, Sri Dhirendra Ch. Das is the O/C who
registered
the
FIR
on
receipt
of
the
written
complaint
submitted by P.W.1. On that basis he registered Belonia P.S.
Case No.19/2005 under Section 304-B and 109 of IPC. He
endorsed the case to S.I. Anup Das for investigation.
30.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties
and perused the evidence on record.
31.
The accused herein has been convicted under
Section 304-B of IPC by the Court below, so, let us first extract
Section 304-B of IPC which is reproduced herein-under:“304B. Dowry death.—
(1) Where the death of a woman is caused by any burns or
bodily injury or occurs otherwise than under normal
circumstances within seven years of her marriage and it is
shown that soon before her death she was subjected to
cruelty or harassment by her husband or any relative of her
husband for, or in connection with, any demand for dowry,
such death shall be called "dowry death", and such husband
or relative shall be deemed to have caused her death.
Explanation.—For the purpose of this sub-section, "dowry"
shall have the same meaning as in section 2 of the Dowry
Prohibition Act, 1961 (28 of 1961).
(2) Whoever commits dowry death shall be punished with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than seven
years but which may extend to imprisonment for life.]"
32.
In the Section 304-B of IPC, the ingredients for
taking cognizance and connecting the accused person with the
alleged crime is that within 7(seven)years of marriage there
should be demand of dowry and the death is caused in the
process of demanding of dowry.
33.
In the present case, the independent witnesses
though in their examination-in-chief have categorically stated
that the accused-person herein has demanded dowry but in the
cross-examination, they have categorically stated they are
either unaware of the payment of the said amount or for what
purpose such amount was paid. Such a statement is found
consistent in the deposition of independent witnesses like that
of PWs. 8, 12, and 17. Further P.W.-20 who is also an
independent witness in her cross-examination categorically
stated that "Bidhan paid the money to me for the treatment of
Bipula”.
34.
Here we may refer to the Para-11 of the Apex
Court Judgment reported in (2007) 9 SCC 721 titled as
Appasaheb Vs. State of Maharashtra dated 01.05.2007
stated thus:“ 11.......A demand for money on account of some
financial stringency or for meeting some urgent domestic
expenses of for purchasing manure cannot be termed as a
demand for dowry as the said word is normally understood……”
35.
No doubt, the death has taken place under
suspicious circumstances. The accused husband and his family
members have left the body of the victim-deceased at the
hospital. The post-mortem report indicates that there are no
external injuries but in the intestine, poisonous substance
smelling
like
kerosene
was
found.
Now
the
point
of
consideration is as how the death has taken place.
36.
Though the cause of the death is established, but
whether the death of the victim was caused due to abetment
by a person or the victim committed suicide or it is murder
because of consumption of poisonous substance is to be
established. Since the charge has been framed under Section
304-B of IPC, the other point for consideration is whether the
prosecution has successfully linked the death of the victim with
the accused herein.
37.
Here I may refer Para-36 and 37 of the Apex
Court Judgment reported in (2020) 18 SCC 423 titled as
Girish Singh Vs. State of Uttarakhand dated 23.07.2009
which is reproduced herein-under:“”36. Section 304B treats this as a dowry death.
Therefore, in such circumstances, it further provides that husband
or relative shall be deemed to have caused her death. Section
113B of The Indian Evidence Act, 1872 provides for presumption as
to dowry death. It provides that when the question is whether the
dowry death, namely, the death contemplated under Section 304B
of the IPC, has been committed by a person, if it is shown that
soon before her death, the woman was subjected by such person
to cruelty or harassment, for in connection with, any demand for
dowry, the Court shall presume that such person had caused the
dowry death. It is no doubt a rebuttable presumption and it is open
to the husband and his relatives to show the absence of the
elements of Section 304B.
37. The foremost aspect to be established by the prosecution is
that there was reliable evidence to show that the woman was
subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or his relatives
which must be for or in connection with any demand for dowry,
soon before her death. Before the presumption is raised, it must be
established that the woman was subjected by such person to
cruelty or harassment and it is not any cruelty that becomes the
subject matter of the provision but it is the cruelty or harassment
for or in connection with, demand for dowry.”
38.
Here in this present case from the evidence on
record, there is no evidence to link the appellant-husband
herein as the cause of death of his wife, either by way of
abetment of suicide or suicide. Considering the mental illness
of the deceased wife which is not denied by any of the
witnesses, if a conclusion is drawn that it is an abetment of
suicide because of her unsound mind or whether it is a suicide
then we have to examine Section 305 and IPC which is
reproduced herein-below:“305. Abetment of suicide of child or insane
person.—If any person under eighteen years of age, any insane
person, any delirious person, any idiot, or any person in a state of
intoxication, commits suicide, whoever abets the commission of
such suicide, shall be punished with death or 1[imprisonment for
life], or imprisonment for a term not exceeding ten years, and shall
also be liable to fine.
39.
The prosecution and the Court below while
framing the charge has not proceeded to examine Section 305
of IPC. Hence, while confining the present case under Section
304-B of IPC, the ingredients with regard to the alleged crime
being occurred within 7(seven)years of marriage and that there
was a demand for dowry, the death being caused in the
process of such demand and linking the death of the victim to
the husband-appellant herein and holding him guilty has not
been proved beyond a reasonable doubt.
40.
Further, the demand for dowry has not been
established and the prosecution has failed to link the death of
the victim with the husband. So the prosecution has also failed
to prove that the husband either killed or he provoked
abatement to make the victim-wife consume the poisonous
substance.
41.
Since the guilt of the accused-Ranjit Ghosh has
not been proved beyond a reasonable doubt, this Court has no
hesitation to allow the appeal. Accordingly, the judgment and
order of conviction dated 01.10.2021 in ST 13(Type-II) of 2007
is set aside and quashed. The accused-Ranjit Ghosh is set at
liberty if not wanted in any other case.
42.
In view of the above discussion, this instant
appeal stands allowed and thus disposed of.
Send down the LCRs.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review