The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
05. 01.2005 was set aside and the parties were directed to move appropriate applications along with relevant documents before Tehsildar for their mutation and since, admittedly, the order dated 05.01.2005 which pertains to some other survey number and the entry on its basis in the Khasra was rightly set aside, there was no occasion for the Additional Commissioner to set aside the order passed by the SDO dated 20.05.2015 where already opportunity was afforded to both the parties to submit fresh application along with all documents for mutating their names in the revenue records. It was further contended that from bare perusal of the order passed by the Additional Commissioner, it could be observed that on some irrelevant consideration of non-scrutinizing of the documents with regard to survey nos.1074 and 1088 by the SDO while passing the said order it was held that the order passed by SDO was bad in law, but while setting aside the order passed by the SDO has remitted the matter again to Tehsildar for fresh adjudication which was per se illegal. 12:02:28 PM With regard to the contention that the order passed by the Board of Revenue is against a dead person, it has been argued that there is nothing on record to show as to when Ram Singh s/o Shri Ram Prasad who was respondent no.2 before the Board of Revenue had expired. No date of his death has been brought on record by the petition…
05. 01.2005 passed in case no.16/15.09.2004 was challenged. The aforesaid amendment appears to have been brought due to the anomaly which has been crept out from the Khasra entry wherein on the basis of this second order dated 05.01.2005, the name of the petitioner has been mutated in the revenue records in relation to survey no.1074. Further it appears to this Court that though SDO has rightly held that vide order dated 05.01.2005 passed in Namantran no.16/15.09.2004 which pertains to land bearing survey no.1088 situated within the jurisdiction of gram panchayat Khurera, the name of the petitioner has wrongly been mutated as vide the said order names of Shivnarayan, Nahar Singh, Raj Kumar s/o Tikaram Jatav were mutated, but this court finds that the SDO had wrongly set aside the order dated 05.01.2005 rather the SDO should have directed the parties or to the petitioner to produce the actual order of mutation and should have heard the matter. The petitioner herein challenging the order passed by the SDO also without bringing the said fact in a correctly before the Additional Commissioner 12:02:28 PM had assailed the said order and in the guise of the said pleadings the Additional Commissioner also appears to have fell in trap and without clarifying the said position had remanded the matter back to the Nayab Tehsildar though in the eventuality in other terms the SDO has passed the s…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
ON THE 9th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. PETITION No. 2236 of 2018
BETWEEN:RAMVEER SINGH S/O SHRI DEVI SINGH THR. POWER
OF ATTORNEY HOLDER CHANDRABHAN SINGH
RAGHUVANSHI
S/O
SHRI
RANDHEER
SINGH
RAGHUVANSHI, AGED-42 YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRIL.
R/O VILL. RANDHEER COLONY AIRPORT BHIND ROAD
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI N.K. GUPTA, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MISS RASHI KUSHWAHADVOCATE)
AND
1.
BHAGCHAND S/O LATE SHRI RAMDAYAL R/O
VILL. KHURERI GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SULTAN SINGH S/O LATE SHRI RAMDAYAL R/O
VILLAGE KHURERI TEHSIL AND DISTRICT
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
MAHESH KUMAR S/O BHAROSILAL SAUDAGAR
SANTAR MORAR GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SARVESH KUMAR SHARMA- ADVOCATE FOR R-1 AND SHRI S.K.
SHRIVASTAVA- ADVOCATE FOR R-2)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is
directed against the order dated 16.02.2018 passed by Member, Board of
Revenue in Revision No.2833-PBR/2016, whereby order passed in second
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
appeal no.5/2015-16 dated 20.07.2016 passed by Additional Commissioner,
Gwalior Division was set aside and the order passed by the SDO dated
20.05.2015, whereby the order dated 05.01.2005 mutating the name of the
petitioner in the revenue records with regard to survey no.1074/min 3 was set
aside, was upheld.
Learned senior counsel Shri N.K. Gupta along with Miss Rashi Kushwah
had assailed the order passed by Board of Revenue on two fold grounds, the
first one being that respondent no.2 who was one of the vendors, during the
pendency of the revision before the Board of Revenue, had expired and without
impleading his legal representatives, the revision has been decided and,
secondly, on merits the order passed by the Additional Commissioner, which
was sound and well founded wherein it was observed that the Namantran
no.16/15.09.2004, whereby vide order dated 05.01.2005 mutation of
Shivnarayan, Nahar Singh, Raj Kumar s/o Tikaram Jatav was made was with
regard to survey no.1088 on the basis of registered sale-deed in their favour,
whereas the dispute between the parties was in relation to survey no.1074 and
without ascertaining the aforesaid fact and conducting any enquiry in that regard
the SDO has passed the order which was per se illegal and, thus, while setting
aside the order passed by SDO dated 20.05.2015, the matter was remanded
back to the Tehsildar for conducting a fresh enquiry into the matter and take
appropriate decision, which was not required to be interfered with but the
Member, Board of Revenue had gone into another aspect of the matter and had
given a finding which was not in dispute regarding the sale-deeds been executed
through power of attorneys and the said power of attorneys were not filed
before any of the Courts below, therefore, the said order is not sustainable.
Further since, no illegality committed by the SDO in passing the order and
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
without considering the said aspect by the Additional Commissioner had
passed the said order, thus, the order is bad in law.
It was further submitted that one of the judgments which has been relied
upon by the counsel for the respondent in the matter of Anant Singh and
Another vs. Govind and Ors reported in 1999 RN 99, wherein it had been
held that while passing the order if no rights of the parties had been decided and
the matter has been remitted back to the lower authority, no prejudice could be
said to have been caused to either of the parties and if the parties believed in the
merits of the case, they should face the enquiry instead of shying away from it
and as the learned Additional Commissioner had not decided any rights of the
parties rather had remitted the matter to Tehsildar for fresh adjudication it did
not require interference.
It has also been argued while placing reliance in the matter of
Prabhudayal and Ors. vs. Kishorilal passed in M.P. No.1609/2020 dated
15.06.2023 that the SDO without considering the contents of the application
under Section 5 of the Limitation Act and without any discussion about the
genuineness of the reasons which has been assigned by the appellant/present
respondent and without assigning any reason has condoned the delay of more
than 8 years in preferring the appeal, which was perverse, thus, in the light of the
judgment passed by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of Kranti
Associates Private Ltd. and Anr. vs. Masood Ahmed Khand and Ors
reported in 2010 (9) SCC 496, the order on this count passed by SDO was
illegal. On the strength of the aforesaid arguments, it was contended that the
present petition deserves to be allowed and the order passed by the Board of
Revenue is required to be set aside and that of Additional Commissioner is to
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
be restored.
Per contra, Shri S.K. Shrivastava appearing for the respondents has
vehemently opposed the contentions as raised by the learned Counsel for the
petitioner. It has been contended that the order passed by the SDO dated
20.05.2015 was in consonance with the record available before it as admittedly
the order dated 05.01.2005 by which the name of the petitioner was mutated in
the revenue record was found to be pertaining to some different survey number
i.e.1088 and the names of Shivnarayan, Nahar Singh, Raj Kumar s/o Tikaram
Jatav were mutated on the basis of sale-deed, thus, it was found by the SDO
that since on the basis of the order dated 05.01.2005 the name of the petitioner
has wrongly been mutated in the revenue records, therefore, the order dated
05.01.2005 was set aside and the parties were directed to move appropriate
applications along with relevant documents before Tehsildar for their mutation
and since, admittedly, the order dated 05.01.2005 which pertains to some other
survey number and the entry on its basis in the Khasra was rightly set aside,
there was no occasion for the Additional Commissioner to set aside the order
passed by the SDO dated 20.05.2015 where already opportunity was afforded
to both the parties to submit fresh application along with all documents for
mutating their names in the revenue records.
It was further contended that from bare perusal of the order passed by
the Additional Commissioner, it could be observed that on some irrelevant
consideration of non-scrutinizing of the documents with regard to survey
nos.1074 and 1088 by the SDO while passing the said order it was held that the
order passed by SDO was bad in law, but while setting aside the order passed
by the SDO has remitted the matter again to Tehsildar for fresh adjudication
which was per se illegal.
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
With regard to the contention that the order passed by the Board of
Revenue is against a dead person, it has been argued that there is nothing on
record to show as to when Ram Singh s/o Shri Ram Prasad who was
respondent no.2 before the Board of Revenue had expired. No date of his death
has been brought on record by the petitioner, thus, this fact that he had expired
during the pendency of the revision before the Board of Revenue cannot be
accepted. It was further argued that even otherwise it is assumed that
respondent no.2 before Board of Revenue had expired during the pendency of
the revision, since he was the vendor and had not challenged the order passed
by the SDO had in fact accepted the said order, this Court finds that no rights
thereof had left with him, rather or his LRs, which could adversely affect him or
in case of his death to his legal representatives and at the most it could be said
that the revision would have abated so far as Ramsingh s/o Ramprasad is
concerned. Thus, the order passed by the Board of Revenue cannot be said to
be bad in that regard.
Learned counsel for the respondent has also placed reliance in the matter
of Anant Singh (supra) and has contended that the present writ petition since
basically is against the order passed by the SDO dated 20.05.2015, whereby the
matter has been remanded back to the Tehsildar is not maintainable as nothing
had been decided in favour of either of the parties rather the matter has been
remitted to the lower authority for fresh adjudication. Thus, it was submitted
that the present petition on this Count also deserves to be dismissed.
Heard the counsels for the parties and perused the record.
During the course of the arguments, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner had placed before this Court certified copies of the record of
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
mutation proceedings conducted by Additional Tehsildar in mutation case
no.9/04-05/A-6, wherein vide order dated 03.11.2004 the application under
Section 110 of the MPLRC preferred by the present petitioner on the basis of
sale-deed no.383 dated 08.06.1993 through power of attorney was allowed and
the name of the petitioner was directed to be mutated in the revenue records.
The said record was also made available to the counsel for the respondent who
after going through the same had not controverted it. Thus, from the
subsequent fact which has emerged today it appears to this Court that before
SDO a wrong amendment was carried out at the behest of present respondent
and instead of challenging the order dated 03.11.2004 some other order dated
05.01.2005 passed in case no.16/15.09.2004 was challenged.
The aforesaid amendment appears to have been brought due to the
anomaly which has been crept out from the Khasra entry wherein on the basis
of this second order dated 05.01.2005, the name of the petitioner has been
mutated in the revenue records in relation to survey no.1074.
Further it appears to this Court that though SDO has rightly held that vide
order dated 05.01.2005 passed in Namantran no.16/15.09.2004 which pertains
to land bearing survey no.1088 situated within the jurisdiction of gram
panchayat Khurera, the name of the petitioner has wrongly been mutated as vide
the said order names of Shivnarayan, Nahar Singh, Raj Kumar s/o Tikaram
Jatav were mutated, but this court finds that the SDO had wrongly set aside the
order dated 05.01.2005 rather the SDO should have directed the parties or to
the petitioner to produce the actual order of mutation and should have heard the
matter.
The petitioner herein challenging the order passed by the SDO also
without bringing the said fact in a correctly before the Additional Commissioner
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
had assailed the said order and in the guise of the said pleadings the Additional
Commissioner also appears to have fell in trap and without clarifying the said
position had remanded the matter back to the Nayab Tehsildar though in the
eventuality in other terms the SDO has passed the same order.
Challenging the aforesaid order passed by the Additional Commissioner
the present respondent had approached the Board of Revenue and the Board of
Revenue also without discussing the aforesaid or scrutinizing the record held
the order passed by the Additional Commissioner to be bad in law, but in the
end result was the same, both the parties by the order of SDO as well as by the
order of Additional Commissioner were to go before Tehsildar and to raise their
respective claims with regard to their mutation in the revenue records, which the
petitioner has already done and the respondent is yet to approach. Thus, this
Court deems it fit to relegate the parties before the SDO for deciding the appeal
afresh, treating it to be an appeal against the order dated 03.11.2004 passed the
mutation case no.9/04-05/A-06, with a direction to pass a speaking and
reasoned order after giving opportunity of hearing to the parties.
With the aforesaid direction, the petition stands disposed of.
It is needless to observe that this Court has not observed anything on
merits.
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
Chandni
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 1/11/2024
12:02:28 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review