The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. Therefore, in my view, the Claimants are entitled to compensation @ of Rs.1,30,000/- per Hectare for the acquired jirayat land and @ of Rs.1,95,000/- for seasonally irrigated land, the rates would be as per the nature/classification of the land made by the learned Reference Court. Hence, I proceed to pass the following order: (i) The present appeals are partly allowed. (ii) The judgments and awards dated 27.02.2006 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nandurbar, in Nos.02/2003, 04/2003, 05/2003, 07/2003, 8 of 8 908-FA.453.2008 08/2003, 10/2003 and 18/2003 are modified to the extent that the respective Claimants shall be entitled to receive compensation @ of Rs.1,30,000/- per Hectare for the jirayat lands and @ of Rs.1,95,000/- for seasonally irrigated lands as per the nature/classification of lands made by the learned Reference Court. (iii) The Claimant shall be entitled to all statutory benefits including interest in accordance with the law laid down by the Full Bench of this Court in State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailash Shiva Rangari, reported in 2016(3) Mh.L.J.
457. (iv) The rest of the judgment and award remains unaltered. (v) The modified award be drawn accordingly. (vi) The Claimants shall pay deficit Court fee, if any, on the enhanced amount of compensation. (vii) Pending civil applications, if any, are also disposed of. (SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J.) Tauseef
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:42121
1 of 8
908-FA.453.2008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
908 FIRST APPEAL NO. 453 OF 2008
KAMLABEN SHRIPAT PATEL
VERSUS
THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NANDURBAR AND ANR
...
Mr. Umesh Mitkari h/f. Mr. M. S. Kulkarni, Advocate for Appellant.
Mr. B. A. Shinde, AGP for Respondent-State.
...
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 455 OF 2008
GIRDHAR VEDU PATIL
VERSUS
THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER AND ANR
…
Mr. Umesh Mitkari h/f. Mr. M. S. Kulkarni, Advocate for Appellant.
Mr. B. A. Shinde, AGP for Respondent-State.
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 454 OF 2008
RAMU MADAN PATIL
VERSUS
THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NANDURBAR AND ANR
…
Mr. Umesh Mitkari h/f. Mr. M. S. Kulkarni, Advocate for Appellant.
Mr. B. A. Shinde, AGP for Respondent-State.
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 456 OF 2008
SUDAM KALU PATIL
VERSUS
THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NANDURBAR AND ANR
…
Mr. Umesh Mitkari h/f. Mr. M. S. Kulkarni, Advocate for Appellant.
Mr. B. A. Shinde, AGP for Respondent-State.
…
AND
2 of 8
908-FA.453.2008
NOT ON BOARD, TAKEN ON BOARD
FIRST APPEAL NO. 499 OF 2008
GIRIDHAR SHANKAR PATEL
VERSUS
THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NANDURBAR AND ANR
…
Mr. Umesh Mitkari h/f. Mr. M. S. Kulkarni, Advocate for Appellant.
Mr. B. A. Shinde, AGP for Respondent-State.
…
AND
NOT ON BOARD, TAKEN ON BOARD
FIRST APPEAL NO. 485 OF 2008
MADHU LAXMAN CHAUDHARI
VERSUS
THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NANDURBAR AND ANR
…
Mr. Umesh Mitkari h/f. Mr. M. S. Kulkarni, Advocate for Appellant.
Mr. B. A. Shinde, AGP for Respondent-State.
…
AND
NOT ON BOARD, TAKEN ON BOARD
FIRST APPEAL NO. 4241 OF 2008
GIRDHAR NATHU MALI
VERSUS
THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NANDURBAR AND ANR
…
Mr. Umesh Mitkari h/f. Mr. M. S. Kulkarni, Advocate for Appellant.
Mr. B. A. Shinde, AGP for Respondent-State.
…
CORAM :
SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J.
DATE
2nd SEPTEMBER, 2026
:
P.C.:1.
Since the acquisition proceedings pertain to the year 2000,
the appeals are heard finally with the consent of the learned Advocates
for the respective parties.
3 of 8
2.
908-FA.453.2008
By these appeals, the Appellants/Claimants are aggrieved by
the judgments and awards dated 27.02.2006 passed by the learned
Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nandurbar, in LAR Nos.02/2003,
04/2003, 05/2003, 07/2003, 08/2003, 10/2003 and 18/2003,
whereby the learned Reference Court partly allowed the references, but
did
not
grant
compensation
at
the
rate
claimed
by
the
Appellants/Claimants.
3.
(i)
Brief facts of the present cases are as under:The lands belonging to the Appellants/Claimants were acquired
for the Minor Irrigation Project at village Chaupala, Taluka and
District Nandurbar.
(ii)
The Notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short, “the Act”) was published on 21.09.2000. The
Notification under Section 6 of the Act was published on
20.09.2001, and the Notification under Section 9 of the Act was
published on 10.12.2001.
(iii)
The Land Acquisition Officer (for short, “the LAO”) passed the
award on 19.05.2002. The particulars of the lands acquired from
the respective Gat numbers, the compensation awarded by the
LAO and the compensation awarded by the learned Reference
Court are as follows:-
4 of 8
908-FA.453.2008
Sr.
No.
F.A. No.
LAR No.
Name of
Claimant
Gat
No.
Area
Rates by Rates by
SLAO
Ref.
per H
Court
per H.
Land as
per Ref.
Court
453/2008
05/2003
Kamlaben
Patel
40 R
88091
1,02,243
Jirayat
454/2008
08/2003 Ramu Patil
81 R +
15 R
Potkhara
b
88091
1,53,365 Seasonally
+
irrigated
51,122
for
potkhara
b
499/2008
18/2003
20 R
1,32,135 1,53,365 Seasonally
irrigated
456/2008
04/2003 Sudam Patil
76 R
1,32,135 1,53,365 Seasonally
irrigated
485/2008
10/2003
Madhu
Chaudhari
142/ 1 H 11 R
88091
1,02,243
Jirayat
455/2008
07/2003
Girdhar
Vedu Patil
30 R
88091
1,02,243
Jirayat
4241/2008
02/2003
Girdhar
Nathu Mali
32 R
88091
1,02,243
Jirayat
(iv)
Girdhar
Shankar
Patel
Being dissatisfied with the compensation granted by the learned
Reference Court, the Claimants have filed present first appeals
seeking higher compensation.
4.
Mr. Umesh Mitkari, learned Advocate holding for Mr. M. S.
Kulkarni, learned Advocate for the Appellants, submits that the learned
Reference Court ought to have considered the sale instances at
Exhibits-20, 21 and 22 relied upon by the Claimants and ought to have
awarded compensation at a higher rate. While determining the
compensation, the LAO did not take into consideration the sale
instances of lands situated at village Chaupala which had taken place
during the period of three years preceding the Notification under
5 of 8
908-FA.453.2008
Section 4 of the Act. The LAO also did not take into consideration the
income derived by the Claimants from the acquired lands. It was
further contended that the acquired lands had non-agricultural
potential, as they were situated adjacent to Nandurbar town.
Therefore, he prays to enhance the compensation by allowing the
appeals.
5.
Mr. B. A. Shinde, learned AGP for the Respondent-State,
supports the judgment and award passed by the learned Reference
Court. He submits that the Appellants have failed to establish sufficient
ground for enhancement and the determination of compensation made
by the learned Reference Court is based upon material available on
record. Therefore, he prays to dismiss the first appeals.
6.
Having heard the learned Advocates for the respective parties
and with their assistance, have gone through the record and
proceedings. The Claimants, upon receipt of the award passed by the
LAO, were granted compensation at the rate of Rs.88,091/- per Hectare
for Jirayat land. In First Appeal Nos.499 of 2008, 454 of 2008 and 456
of 2008, the LAO had awarded compensation at the rate of
Rs.1,32,135/- per Hectare for seasonally irrigated land. In the
remaining appeals, the acquired lands have been treated as jirayat
lands.
7.
The Claimants relied upon the sale instances at Exhibits-20,
6 of 8
908-FA.453.2008
21 and 22. However, the learned Reference Court discarded those sale
instances on the ground that the lands covered by the said sale
instances were situated adjacent to the Nandurbar-Dhule Highway. The
learned Reference Court, instead, relied upon the sale instance in SLAO
award at Sr. Nos.9, 63 and 68 dated 21.11.1995, 20.02.1999 and
14.07.1999 respectively. By the sale instance at Sr. No.68 dated
14.07.1999, land admeasuring 1 Hectare 56 R from Gat No.440/2 was
sold @ of Rs.92,948/- per Hectare. The learned Reference Court
applied 10% escalation as the Notification under Section 4 of the Act
was published subsequent thereto on 21.09.2000, thereby arriving at a
market value of Rs.1,02,243/- per Hectare.
8.
The Claimants have relied upon the sale instances at
Exhibits-20 and 21. Both the sale instances are of the same date i.e.
15.07.1999 and pertain to the same Gat No.57. As per the sale instance
at Exhibit-21, an area admeasuring 1 Hectare 28 R was sold for a
consideration of Rs.2,37,500/-. Thus, the rate works out to
approximately Rs.1,85,546/- per Hectare for jirayat land.
9.
The learned Reference Court discarded the said sale instance
at Exhibit-21 principally on the ground that the land covered by the
sale instance was situated adjacent to the Highway. However, the fact
remains that the sale instance is from the same village. Merely because
the land covered by the sale instance is situated adjacent to the
7 of 8
908-FA.453.2008
Highway, the sale instance cannot be discarded in its entirety,
particularly when it pertains to a substantial area of 1 Hectare 28 R
and is from the same village.
In the facts and circumstances of the present case, in my
10.
view, deduction of 30% would adequately take care of the locational
advantage enjoyed by the land covered by the sale instance. After
applying 30% deduction to the rate of approximately Rs.1,85,546/- per
Hectare, the rate works out to approximately Rs.1,29,882/- per
Hectare. The same can reasonably be rounded off to Rs.1,30,000/- per
hectare for Jirayat land and proportionately for seasonally irrigated
land, in accordance with the classification made by the learned
Reference Court.
11.
Therefore, in my view, the Claimants are entitled to
compensation @ of Rs.1,30,000/- per Hectare for the acquired jirayat
land and @ of Rs.1,95,000/- for seasonally irrigated land, the rates
would be as per the nature/classification of the land made by the
learned Reference Court. Hence, I proceed to pass the following order:
ORDER
(i)
The present appeals are partly allowed.
(ii)
The judgments and awards dated 27.02.2006 passed by
the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nandurbar, in
LAR
Nos.02/2003,
04/2003,
05/2003,
07/2003,
8 of 8
908-FA.453.2008
08/2003, 10/2003 and 18/2003 are modified to the
extent that the respective Claimants shall be entitled to
receive compensation @ of Rs.1,30,000/- per Hectare
for the jirayat lands and @ of Rs.1,95,000/- for
seasonally
irrigated
lands
as
per
the
nature/classification of lands made by the learned
Reference Court.
(iii) The Claimant shall be entitled to all statutory benefits
including interest in accordance with the law laid down
by the Full Bench of this Court in State of Maharashtra
Vs. Kailash Shiva Rangari, reported in 2016(3) Mh.L.J.
457.
(iv)
The rest of the judgment and award remains unaltered.
(v)
The modified award be drawn accordingly.
(vi)
The Claimants shall pay deficit Court fee, if any, on the
enhanced amount of compensation.
(vii) Pending civil applications, if any, are also disposed of.
(SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J.)
Tauseef
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review