The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Thus, on the basis of the allegations as contained in the FIR and in the charge-sheet, no case whatsoever is made out against the petitioner. Accordingly, this petition is allowed and FIR No.149/2020 registered at Police Station Unhel, District Ujjain for the offences punishable under Section 337, 338 and 304-A of the IPC, the charge-sheet dated
30. 08.2020 and the entire consequential proceedings of No.908/2020 pending before the Court below against the petitioner are hereby quashed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 9th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 55765 of 2022
BETWEEN:RAMSINGH MODAVAT S/O SHRI BHEEMA
MODAVAT,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE R/O VILLAGE
PIPALIYA MOLU UNHEL DISTT. UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI M.A. MANSOORI - ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION
HOUSE OFFICER THROUGH POLICE STATION
UNHEL DISTT. UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI A. S. PARIHAR – PANEL LAWYER)
This application coming on for admission this day, the court
passed the following:
ORDER
With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, the matter is
finally heard.
02. By this petition preferred under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, the petitioner has prayed for quashment of FIR
Signed by: SHILPA
NAGDEVE
Signing time: 23-01-2024
14:42:13
registered by Police Station Unhel, District Ujjain against him vide Crime
No.149/2020 for offences punishable under Sections 337, 338 and 304-A
of the IPC, charge-sheet dated 30.08.2020 and the entire consequential
proceedings of RCT No.908/2020 pending before the trial Court.
03. As per the prosecution, on 16.05.2020 deceased Lal Singh
along with one Hakam Singh and others was extracting soil from Lal
Singh’s well. From the outside Ram Singh was running the machine
while Hakam Singh and others were filling the soil from inside. During
course of such work, due to sinking of the soil, Lal Singh along with the
machine fell inside the well due to which he and Hakam Singh sustained
injuries and eventually succumbed to the same. On receiving the
information from the complainant Darbar Singh, two merg were
registered and statements were recorded and subsequently it was found
that the incident has occurred due to the negligence of the
petitioner/accused. Thereafter, the FIR was registered against the
petitioner and upon completion of the investigation, charge-sheet has
been filed before the Magistrate for the offences as referred to above of
which cognizance has been taken by the Judicial Magistrate.
04. This petition has been preferred by the petitioner on the ground
that the allegations as leveled in the charge-sheet even if taken to be true
at this stage do not make out any offence against the petitioner hence the
continuation of the proceedings against him would be gross abuse of
process of law. There is no evidence against the petitioner as there is
nothing to suggest that due to his negligence the death of the deceased
took place. The petitioner had no legal duty imposed upon him since the
land on which the incident took place does not belong to him. The
material available on record itself shows that the incident occurred due to
Signed by: SHILPA
NAGDEVE
Signing time: 23-01-2024
14:42:13
sinking of the soil hence no role can be attributed to the petitioner. There
is no allegation of any haste or negligence on part of the petitioner. No
witness examined by the prosecution has alleged that the petitioner was
negligent or is responsible for the incident. It is hence submitted that it is
a case of no evidence against the petitioner in view of which the
proceedings against him deserve to be quashed. Reliance has been placed
by the learned counsel for the petitioner on the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew Vs. State of Punjab and Another
(2005) 6 SCC 1 and of the Gujrat High Court in Kaushik Ambalal Oza
and Others Vs. State of Gujarat and Another, ABC 2015(II) 66 Guj.
05. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent has submitted
that there is sufficient material available on record to proceed with
against the petitioner and it cannot be said that no offence as alleged has
been committed by him in view of which the petition deserves to be
dismissed.
06. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have
perused the entire charge-sheet.
07. On the record against the petitioner is only the statement of one
Wali Mohammad, the choukidar of the village, who has stated that when
Ram Singh was digging his well, he had told him not to do so since there
is a prohibition in that regard but even thereafter he got certain persons to
dig the well. He has not stated that in the matter of drilling the well there
was any negligence on part of the petitioner or that he did not exercise
due care and caution for ensuring safety of the persons digging the well
as a result of which the incident took place resulting in death of two
persons. On the contrary, all the other witnesses examined on part of the
prosecution have categorically stated that the machine fell into the well
Signed by: SHILPA
NAGDEVE
Signing time: 23-01-2024
14:42:13
on account of sinking of the soil. None of the witnesses have stated that
there was any negligence on part of the petitioner as a result of which the
machine fell into the well resulting in death of those persons. Even the
statement of Wali Mohammad does not indicate that in the matter of
digging of the well there was omission on part of the petitioner to
perform any duty which he ought to have performed in the facts and
circumstances of the case. At best the petitioner could be alleged to have
violated certain rules and gone ahead with the digging of the well despite
there being prohibition for doing the same. That by itself would not
attract the provisions of Section 304–A of the IPC.
08. In Ambalal D. Bhatta Vs. State of Gujarat, AIR 1972 SC
1150, it has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in paragraph No.8
as under:"8. It appears to us that in a prosecution for an offence
under Section 304A, the mere fact that an accused contravenes
certain rules or regulations in the doing of an act which causes
death of another, does not establish that the death was the result
of a rash or negligent act or that any such act was the proximate
and efficient cause of the death. If that were so, the acquittal of
the appellant for contravention of the provisions of the Act and
the Rules would itself have been an answer and we would have
then examined to what extent additional evidence of his
acquittal would have to be allowed, but since that is not the
criteria, we have to determine whether the appellant's act in
giving only one batch number to all the four lots manufactured
on 12-11-62 in preparing batch No. 211105 was the cause of
deaths and whether those deaths were a direct consequence of
the appellants' act, that is, whether the appellant's act is the
direct result of a rash and negligent act and that act was the
proximate and efficient cause without the intervention of
another's negligence. As observed by Sir Lawrence Jenkins
in Emperor v. Omkar Rampratap (1902) 4 Bom LR 679 the act
causing the deaths "must be the cause causans; It is not enough
that it may have been the causa sine qua non". This view has
been adopted by this Court in several decisions. In Kurban
Hussein Moham-medali Rangwala v. State of Maharashtra , the
Signed by: SHILPA
NAGDEVE
Signing time: 23-01-2024
14:42:13
accused who had manufactured wet paints without a licence was
acquitted of the charge under Section 304A because it was held
that the mere fact that he allowed the burners to be used in the
same room in which varnish and turpentine were stored, even
though it would be a negligent act, would not be enough to make
the accused responsible for the fire which broke out. The cause
of the fire was not merely the presence of the burners within the
room in which varnish and turpentine were stored though this
circumstance was indirectly responsible for the fire which broke
out, but was also due to the overflowing of froth out of the
barrels. In Suieman Rahiman Mulani v. State of
Maharashtra the accused who was driving a car only with a
learner's licence without a trainer by his side, had injured a
person. It was held that that by itself was not sufficient to
warrant a conviction under Section 304A. It would be different
if it can be established as in the case of Bhalchandra v. State of
Maharashtra that deaths and injuries caused by the
contravention of a prohibition in respect of the substances
which are highly dangerous as in the case of explosives in a
cracker factory which are considered to be of a highly
hazardous and dangerous nature having sensitive composition
where even friction or percussion could cause an explosion, that
contravention would be the causa causans."
09.
In
Kurban
Hussain
Mohammadalli
Vs.
State
of
Maharashtra, AIR 1965 SC 1616, it has been held by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court as under:"3. We shall first take up s. 304-A which runs thus :"Whoever causes the death of any person by doing any rash or
negligent act not amounting to culpable homicide shall be
punished with imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both."
The main contention of the appellant is that he was not present
when the fire broke out resulting in the death of seven workmen
by burning and it cannot therefore be said that he caused the
death of these seven persons by doing any rash or negligent act.
The view taken by the Magistrate on the other hand which
appears to have been accepted by the High Court was that as
the appellant allowed the manufacture of wet paints in the same
room where varnish and turpentine were stored and the fire
resulted because of the proximity of the burners to the stored
Signed by: SHILPA
NAGDEVE
Signing time: 23-01-2024
14:42:13
varnish and turpentine, he must be held responsible for the
death of the seven workmen who were burnt in the fire. We are
-however of opinion that this view of the Magistrate is not
correct. The mere fact that the appellant allowed the burners to
be used in the same room in which varnish and turpentine were
stored, even though it might be a negligent act, would not be
enough to make the appellant responsible for the fire which
broke out. The cause of the fire was not merely the presence of
burners in the room in which varnish and turpentine were
stored, though this circumstance was indirectly responsible for
the fire which broke out. But what s. 304-A requires is causing
of death by doing any rash or negligent act, and this means that
death must be the direct or proximate result of the rash or
negligent act. It appears that the direct or proximate cause of
the fire which resulted in seven deaths was the act of Hatim. It
seems to us clear that Hatim was apparently in a hurry and
therefore he did not perhaps allow the rosin to cool down
sufficiently and poured turpentine too quickly.”
10. In Jacob Mathew Vs. State of Punjab and Another, AIR
2005 SC 3180, it has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court as under:"11. The jurisprudential concept of negligence defies any
precise definition. Eminent jurists and leading judgments have
assigned various meanings to negligence. The concept as has
been acceptable to Indian jurisprudential thought is well-stated
in the Law of Torts, Ratanlal & Dhirajlal (Twenty-fourth
Edition 2002, edited by Justice G.P. Singh). It is stated (at p.441442) ___ "Negligence is the breach of a duty caused by the
omission to do something which a reasonable man, guided by
those considerations which ordinarily regulate the conduct of
human affairs would do, or doing something which a prudent
and reasonable man would not do. Actionable negligence
consists in the neglect of the use of ordinary care or skill
towards a person to whom the defendant owes the duty of
observing ordinary care and skill, by which neglect the plaintiff
has suffered injury to his person or property. The definition
involves three constituents of negligence: (1) A legal duty to
exercise due care on the part of the party complained of towards
the party complaining the former's conduct within the scope of
the duty; (2) breach of the said duty; and (3) consequential
damage. Cause of action for negligence arises only when damage
occurs; for, damage is a necessary ingredient of this tort."
Signed by: SHILPA
NAGDEVE
Signing time: 23-01-2024
14:42:13
11. In the present case, the allegation against the petitioner is that
he did not listen to the gram choukidar who told him that there is
prohibition for digging the well and went ahead with the same. The act
attributable to the petitioner would thus only be that he went ahead with
the digging of the well in contravention to the prohibition on the same but
it cannot be said that there was any negligence on his part in the matter of
digging of the well which resulted in death of two persons. On the
contrary, the record emphatically shows that the machine fell into the
well on account of the soil sinking around the well. Thus, it cannot be
held that there was any negligence or rashness on part of the petitioner in
the performance of his duties which he ought to have performed. Even if
it is assumed that there was some negligence on part of the petitioner, it
cannot be said to be the direct or proximate cause of death of the
deceased.
12. Thus, on the basis of the allegations as contained in the FIR and
in the charge-sheet, no case whatsoever is made out against the petitioner.
Accordingly, this petition is allowed and FIR No.149/2020 registered at
Police Station Unhel, District Ujjain for the offences punishable under
Section 337, 338 and 304-A of the IPC, the charge-sheet dated
30.08.2020
and
the
entire
consequential proceedings
of
RCT
No.908/2020 pending before the Court below against the petitioner are
hereby quashed.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
Shilpa
Signed by: SHILPA
NAGDEVE
Signing time: 23-01-2024
14:42:13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review