Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 2nd OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 78 of 2017
BETWEEN:RAMESHWAR S/O RAMSINGH RAJPUT, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
1. OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST, R/O VILLAGE KAKATTI TEH.
BARWAH DISTRICT KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
BHURESINGH S/O RAMSINGH RAJPUT, AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
2. VILLAGE KAKATTI, TEHSIL BARWAH, (MADHYA PRADESH)
VIJAY S/O RAMSINGH RAJPUT, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, R/O VILLAGE
3. KAKATTI, TEHSIL BARWAH, DISTRICT KHARGONE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
VIMLABAI D/O RAMSINGH W/O SHAKARSINGH, AGED ABOUT 45
4. YEARS, R/O VILLAGE KAKATII, TEHSIL BARWAH, DISTRICT
KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
KAMUBAI D/O RAMSINGH W/O BALDEVSINGH, AGED ABOUT 43
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST,
R/O
VILLAGE
5. KAKATII,TEHSIL BARWAH, DISTRICT KHARGONE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
KOMALBAI S/O RAMSINGH W/O BHAGWANSINGH, AGED ABOUT 45
6. YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST, R/O VILLAGE SURIPURA,
TEHSIL MAHAWAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI PRADIP KUMAR GUPTA, ADVOCATE.)
AND
FULCHAND S/O ONKARLAL KURMI, AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
1. OCCUPATION: BUSINESS, R/O 1211, DWARKAPURI, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
10:43:47
-2JASWANT S/O NATHUSINGHRAJPUT, AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS, R/O
2. VILLAGE KAKATTI, TEHSIL BARWAH, DISTRICT KHARGONE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
GULABSINGH S/O MOTESINGH RAJPUT, AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
3. OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST, R/O VILLAGE KAKATII,TEHSIL
BARWAH, DISTRICT KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
NEELABAI D/O NATHUSINGHRAJPUT, AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
4. OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST, R/O VILLAGE KAKATTI TEH
BARWAH, DISTRICT KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
COLLECTOR THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH,
KHARGONE (MADHYA PRADESH)
DISTRICT
.....RESPONDENTS
(NONE PRESENT FOR THE RESPONDENTS.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This appeal coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
01.
Heard on I.A. No.4144/2017, an application for bringing
legal heirs on record and I.A. No.4145/2017, an application under
Section 5 of Limitation Act.
02.
After filing this appeal, respondent No.4-Neelabai expired
on 19.12.2015 who happens to be a sister of appellants. Application is
filed for bringing her son and two daughters on record alongwith an
application under Section 5 of Limitation Act.
03.
The respondents filed the reply opposing the aforesaid
applications.
04.
Keeping the reasons mentioned in the applications, I.A.
No.4144/2017 & I.A. No.4145/2017 are hereby allowed. Let necessary
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
10:43:47
-3-
corrections be made in the cause title.
05.
Also heard on the question of admission.
06.
This is an appeal filed by defendants No.1 to 6 against
judgment dated 05.12.2014 passed in Civil Suit No.30-A/2013 by First
Civil Judge, Class-II, Badwah and judgment dated 22.12.2016 passed in
First Appeal No.7-A/2015
by Additional District Judge, Badwah,
District Khargone.
Facts of the case in short are as under:
07.
The respondent No.1 / plaintiff-Phoolchand filed the suit
seeking decree of declaration, possession, means profit and permanent
injunction against the defendants in which the defendants filed the
counter suit for decree of declaration of title and permanent injunction.
Chensingh and Nathusingh were the real brothers, the disputed
agricultural land bearing survey No.191 area 2.772 hectare at Gram
Kakatti, Patwari Halka No.5, Tehsil Badwah was recorded in the name
of son / daughter of Nathusingh i.e. Jaswant, Gulabsingh & Neelabai i.e.
defendant No.7, 8 & 9. According to the plaintiff, he purchased the suit
land vide registered sale-deed dated 27.01.2012 from defendant Nos.7 to
9 and applied before the Tehsildar for mutation in which defendants
No.1 to 3 filed an objection. Defendants No.1 to 6 are son and daughter
of Ramsingh and Basantibai. Basantibai filed a civil suit against the
defendant Nos.1 to 6 claiming title on the basis of the adverse
possession.
08.
After the death of Basantibai, the defendants No.1 to 6
became the plaintiff being legal heirs. Vide judgment dated 23.06.2005,
the learned trial Court did not accept the plea of adverse possession and
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
10:43:47
-4-
refused to declare the title. However, the defendants No.1 to 6 were
found in possession and the protection was given to the effect that they
be not disputed without due process of law. The defendant Nos. 1 to 3
filed a written statement denying the pleadings of the plaint and claimed
the title by way of adverse possession. The defendants No.7 to 9
reamined exparte.
09.
On the basis of pleading, the trial Court framed 12 issues for
adjudication. After recoding the evidence, the Civil Judge has held that
plaintiff is an owner of the suit land by virtue of sale-deed dated
27.01.2012. The defendants No.1 to 3 have failed to prove their adverse
possession against the defendants No.7 to 9. Vide judgment dated
05.12.2014, the learned Court has decreed the suit in favour of the
plaintiff by declaring him owner of survey No.191 area 2.772 hectare at
Gram Kakatti, Patwari Halka No.5, Tehsil Badwah. The defendants
No.1 to 6 were directed to handover the vacant possession to the
plaintiff with means profit @ Rs.25,000/- per year. The relief of
permanent injunction has also been granted by dismissing the counter
claim.
10.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree, the
defendants No.1 to 6 preferred first appeal before the Additional District
Judge, Badwah. Vide judgment dated 22.12.2016, the learned District
Judge dismissed the appeal and upheld the judgment and decree passed
by the trial Court in toto hence, this second appeal before this Court.
I have heard learned counsel for the appellant.
11.
In order to explain the relationship between the parties,
family tree of Chen Singh is reproduced below:
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
10:43:47
-5-
12.
Ramsingh and Nathusingh were real brothers. The
defendant Nos. 1 to 6 are the son and daughters of Ramsingh and
defendant Nos. 7 to 10 are the legal heirs of Nathusingh. Wife of
Ramsingh i.e. Basantibai filed a suit for declaration of title against
defendants No.7 to 10 i.e. legal heirs of Nathusingh and the suit was
dismissed vide judgment dated 23.05.2005. During pendency of the said
suit, Basantibai expired and present defendants No.1 to 6 were brought
on record as plaintiff, therefore, in that earlier Civil Suit No.25-A/1995,
the defendants have lost and did not get the decree of adverse
possession, therefore, in this present suit they are estopped from taking
the plea of claiming ownership or title by way of adverse possession.
13.
Therefore, learned trial Court has rightly dismissed their
counter claim in respect of title. So faras the present plaintiff is
concerned, he purchased the land from the defendant Nos.7 to 10 whose
titles are not in dispute in respect of suit land hence, the plaintiff has
rightly been declared owner of the suit land and he has also been held
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
10:43:47
-6-
entitled to get the possession as well as the means profit from the
defendants. Hence, I do not find following substantial questions of law
involved:
AWhether the courts below have erred in law in
decreeing the suit of the respondent no. 1, without
considering the family tree of the appellants.
BWhether the courts below erred in law in not holding
that the appellant are became Bhumi Swami on the basis of
their adverse and hostile possession over the suit land since
long.
CWhether the finding arrived at by the courts below are
perverse and not born out from the evidence and material on
record.
DWhether the learned trail court grossly erred in law in
dismissing the counter claim of the appellant by applying the
principal of res-judicata.
14.
The learned Courts below have not committed any error in
decreeing the suit in favour of plaintiff / respondent No.1. The
defendants No.1 to 6 have failed to prove their title twice by way of
adverse possession in earlier Civil Suit No.25-A/1995 as well as in First
Appeal No.7-A/2015. There are concurrent findings recorded by both
the Courts which are not liable to be interfered in second appeal as held
by Apex Court in following cases:
15.
Kondiba Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai Sopan Gujar : (1999)
3 SCC 722, has held as under:
5. It is not within the domain of the High Court to investigate the
grounds on which the findings were arrived at, by the last court
of fact, being the first appellate court. It is true that the lower
appellate court should not ordinarily reject witnesses accepted by
the trial court in respect of credibility but even where it has
rejected the witnesses accepted by the trial court, the same is no
ground for interference in second appeal when it is found that the
appellate court has given satisfactory reasons for doing so. In a
case where from a given set of circumstances two inferences are
possible, one drawn by the lower appellate court is binding on the
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
10:43:47
-7High Court in second appeal. Adopting any other approach is not
permissible. The High Court cannot substitute its opinion for the
opinion of the first appellate court unless it is found that the
conclusions drawn by the lower appellate court were erroneous
being contrary to the mandatory provisions of law applicable or
its settled position on the basis of pronouncements made by the
Apex Court, or was based upon inadmissible evidence or arrived
at without evidence.
6. If the question of law termed as a substantial ques-tion stands
already decided by a larger Bench of the High Court concerned
or by the Privy Council or by the Federal Court or by the
Supreme Court, its merely wrong application on the facts of the
case would not be termed to be a substantial question of law.
Where a point of law has not been pleaded or is found to be
arising between the parties in the absence of any factual format, a
litigant should not be allowed to raise that question as a
substantial question of law in second appeal. The mere
appreciation of the facts, the documentary evidence or the
meaning of entries and the contents of the document cannot be
held to be raising a substantial question of law. But where it is
found that the first appellate court has assumed jurisdiction
which did not vest in it, the same can be adjudicated in the
second appeal, treating it as a substantial question of law. Where
the first appellate court is shown to have exercised its discretion
in a judicial manner, it cannot be termed to be an error either of
law or of procedure requiring interference in second appeal. This
Court in Reserve Bank of India v. Ramkrishna Govind Morey
[AIR 1976 SC 830]held that whether the trial court should not
have exercised its jurisdiction differently is not a question of law
justifying interference.
16.
In case of Laxmidevamma v. Ranganath : (2015) 4 SCC
264, again the Apex court has held as under:
16. Based on oral and documentary evidence, both the courts
below have recorded concurrent findings of fact that the plaintiffs have established their right in A schedule property. In the
light of the concurrent findings of fact, no substantial questions
of law arose in the High Court and there was no substantial
ground for reappreciation of evidence. While so, the High Court
proceeded to observe that the first plaintiff has earmarked the A
schedule property for road and that she could not have fullfledged right and on that premise proceeded to hold that
declaration to the plaintiffs’ right cannot be granted. In exercise
of jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC, concurrent findings of
fact cannot be upset by the High Court unless the findings so
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
10:43:47
-8recorded are shown to be perverse. In our considered view, the
High Court did not keep in view that the concurrent findings
recorded by the courts below, are based on oral and documentary
evidence and the judgment of the High Court cannot be
sustained.
17.
Recently, the Apex Court in case of Adiveppa & Others Vs.
Bhimappa & Others : (2017) 9 SCC 586 has held as under:
"17. Here is a case where two Courts below, on appreciating
the entire evidence, have come to a conclusion that the Plaintiffs
failed to prove their case in relation to both the suit properties.
The concurrent findings of facts recorded by the two Courts,
which do not involve any question of law much less substantial
question of law, are binding on this Court.
18. It is more so when these findings are neither against the
pleadings nor against the evidence and nor contrary to any
provision of law. They are also not perverse to the extent that no
such findings could ever be recorded by any judicial person. In
other words, unless the findings of facts, though concurrent, are
found to be extremely perverse so as to affect the judicial
conscious of a judge, they would be binding on the Appellate
Court."
18.
In view of the above, Second Appeal is dismissed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Divyansh
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
10:43:47
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review