Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SA No. 656 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 20-02-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
SA No. 656 of 2018
Ramesh Krishnan
Rep by his Power Agent Mr.Surya Narayanan,
No.40/51, Beach Road, Kalakshetra Colony,
Besant Nagar , Chennai - 90
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1.Nirmala Victor,
W/o.Mr.Victor Wilson, Res At Flat No.G1,All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41Chennai
2.Thomas Wilson,
S/o.Mr.M.Victor Wilson, Res At Flat No.G1, All
Are Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27,
Justice Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
3.Sandra Wilson,
W/o.Mr.Thomas Wilson, Res At Flat No.G1, All
Are Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27,
Justice Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
4.M/s.Value Logics Private Ltd.,
Having Office At , Flat No.1, And Rep By
Mr.Subramaiyam Sharma , Regional Manager
(operation)
5.S.Jayaraman
Owner Of Flat No.2, All Are Res At Their
Respective Flats At No.27, Justice Balakrishnan
Road, Valmiki Nagar, Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai 41
__________
Page1 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
6.R.Prema
W/o.Mr.Ramachandran , Owner Of Flat No.3, All
Are Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27,
Justice Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
7.S.Kumaran
S/o.Mr.K.Subramaniam, Owner Of Flat No.4, All
Are Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27,
Justice Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
8.S.Maheshwaran
S/o.Mr.G.Sridharan, Owner Of Flat No.5, All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
9.Shyamala Sridharan,
W/o.Mr.Sridharan , Owner Of Flat No.5, All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
10.Srikant Srinivasan,
S/o.Mr.V.Srivasan, Owner Of Flat No.6, All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
11.Ravikaran
S/o.Mr.Narasimhanan , Owner Of Flat No.7, All
Are Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27,
Justice Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
12.Latha Ganapathy
D/o.Mr.Ganapathy, Owner Of Flat No.7, All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
13.N.Subramanyan
__________
Page2 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
S/o.Mr.V.Natarajan, Owner Of Flat No.7a, All
Are Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27,
Justice Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
14.Manu Natarajan
S/o.Mr.K.Natarajan, Owner Of Flat No.9, All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
15.Sujatha Manu
W/o.Mr.Manu Natarajan, Owner Of Flat No.9,
All Are Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27,
Justice Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
16.P.Prem
S/o.Mr.P.S.Nair, Owner Of Flat No.10, All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
17.Beena Prem,
W/o.Mr.P.Prem, Owner Of Flat No.10, All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
18.Vivek Prem
S/o.Mr.P.Prem, Owner Of Flat No.10, All Are
Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27, Justice
Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
19.Lakshmi Rama Krishnan
D/o.Mr.N.Ramakrishnan , Owner Of Flat No.11,
All Are Res At Their Respective Flats At No.27,
Justice Balakrishnan Road, Valmiki Nagar,
Thiruvanmiyur, Chennai - 41
20.The Principal Secretary,
Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority ,
__________
Page3 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
No.01, Gandhi Irwin Road, Thalamuthu
Natarajan House, Egmore , Chennai - 600008
21.The Commissioner,
Greater Chennai Corporation, Rippon Buildings,
Sydenhams Road, Kannappar Thidal , Periyamet,
Chennai - 600003
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER: This second appeal has been filed to set aside the Judgment and
decree dated 30.01.2018 passed in AS.No.336 of 2011, on the file of VI
Additional Judge, City Civil Court at Chennai, confirming the Judgment and
Decree dated 10.12.2010 passed in OS.NO.1775 of 2007 on the file of the XV
Judge, Assistant City Civil Court at Chennai.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.S.Sivaraman
For Respondent(s):
Mr.K.V.Anantha Krushnan for
RR3, 5 to 8, 10 to 12, 19 & 21
Mr.M.Rajendiran, AGP for R20
JUDGMENT
This second appeal has been preferred as against the decree and judgment
passed by the VI Additional City Civil Court, Chennai in AS No.336 of 2011
dated 30.01.2018.
2.The appellant is the 4th defendant, who is the legal heir of the first
defendant. In fact, the respondents 1 to 19 in this Second Appeal have filed the
main suit in O.S.No.1775 of 2007 on the file of XVI City Civil Court, Chennai
__________
Page4 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
for the reliefs of declaration and permanent injunction and the said suit was
decreed. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgement, the defendants have
preferred an appeal before the VI Judge, Additional City Civil Court, Chennai
and the first appellate Court dismissed the appeal. Aggrieved by the decree and
judgement of the first appellate Court, the present second appeal has been
preferred by the appellant /4th respondent, who is one of the legal heirs of the
first defendant.
3. The brief averments of the plaint are as follows:
The second and third defendants, who are the owners of Plot no.5/2A,
5/2B, 2nd Seaward Road/Justice Balakrishnan Road are the owners of the suit
property. The first defendant is the daughter of the second defendant and sister
of the third defendant and she is the Proprietress of Sri Devi Constructions. The
second and third defendants entered into a Joint Venture Agreement dated
06.09.1995 with the first defendant for construction and development of
apartments and the 4th defendant had granted permission and the 5th defendant
also issued planning permission through proceedings dated 08.01.1996 for
construction of 13 apartments. The first defendant also constructed 13
apartments and sold to the plaintiffs. Thus, the plaintiffs became the owners of
the apartments, called Avatar apartments. The first defendant entered into
separate construction agreement with the plaintiffs for the construction of the
flats. The first defendant in the year 2001, after the completion of construction
__________
Page5 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
of 13 apartments, had put up an unauthorized construction of approximately
1790 sq.ft., in open terrace which is common area earmarked for all the
apartment owners. The first defendant have no right or authority to put up any
unauthorized construction in the common open terrace. While so, the 4th and
5th defendants regularized the unauthorised construction without following the
Rules. The first defendant received the entire sale consideration from all the flat
owners for the entire suit property but failed to convey to some of the flat
owners the undivided share of the land in proportion to the plinth area of the
apartments. Now the plaintiffs understand that the first defendant is attempting
to sell away the unauthorised construction put up in the terrace portion with the
un-conveyed, undivided share illegally retained by her. When the Flat Owners'
Association through letters dated 26.12.2006 and 02.01.2007 questioned the
first defendant’s locus-standi and called upon to furnish all the documents
relating to the property, the first defendant sent a letter dated 08.02.2007 by
enclosing some documents along with her explanation, claiming right to the
open terrace. The first defendant claims right to unauthorised construction in the
terrace portion on the basis of the Clause included in the promoters agreement
entered with each of the flat owners. According to her, the alleged Clause gives
right to the promoter/first defendant to reserve and claim the exclusive right to
the common open terrace portion and right to put up additional construction.
But the said Clause is contradictory to the other Clauses and the same are
against the provisions of the Tamilnadu Apartment Ownerships Act,2022 and
__________
Page6 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
opposed to Section 23 of the Contract Act. The first defendant unauthorisedly
encroached 1/4th portion in the open terrace. The second defendant is the
mother of the defendants 1 and 3. The first defendant had obtained Power of
Attorney from the second and third defendants for the sale of undivided share.
Therefore, the plaintiffs have filed the suit.
4. The brief averments of the written statement filed by the defendants 1
to 3 are as follows:
The suit is not maintainable either in law or on facts. This Court has no
territorial jurisdiction to try the suit. Originally the larger extent of lands were
owned and possessed by the second and third defendants. The first defendant
was the Proprietrix of Sri. Devi Constructions. Accordingly, the first defendant
had entered into the Joint Development Agreement with the second and third
defendants for construction and development of the property on 06.09.1995.
The CMDA and the Corporation of Chennai have also granted permission and
issued construction permit. Accordingly, the apartments were constructed.
Consequently, building Agreement was entered into with the flat owners and the
undivided share of the land was also registered separately in favour of each of
the plaintiffs. Subsequent to the construction, there was some additional
construction in the property and the same was rightly regularized by the 4th and
5th defendants. The suit is questioning the action of the 4 th and 5 th defendants
and this Court has no jurisdiction to entertain the suit. The first defendant had
__________
Page7 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
already entered into a separate construction agreement with each of the
plaintiffs for construction of their flats and in the said agreement, the terrace of
the building to be constructed except the areas specifically allotted and who had
private terrace shall always be under the control and ownership of the builder or
promoter. After signing the agreement, the plaintiffs are estopped from denying
the right of the defendants. The suit is barred by limitation since the transactions
were taken place as early as in the year 2001 while the present suit is filed in the
year 2009. Therefore, the suit is liable to be dismissed.
5. Based on the above said pleadings and after perusing the records, the
trial Court has framed the following issues for trial:
(i) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for permanent injunction as
prayed for?
(ii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for other reliefs?
6. On the side of the plaintiffs, PW1 was examined and marked Ex.A1 to
A16 and on the side of the defendants, DW1 was examined and no documents
were marked. The trial Court decreed the suit through its judgement and decree
dated 10.12.2010. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgement of the trial
Court, the defendants have preferred appeal in A.S.No.336 of 2011 on various
grounds. During the pendency of the appeal, the first appellant died and all the
legal heirs of the first appellant have been brought on record.
__________
Page8 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
7. The first appellate Court was framed the following point for
determination:
(i)Whether the appellate Court is warranting to interfere the
judgement and decree dated 10.12.2010 passed in O.S.No.1775 of
2007 by the learned 5th Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai
to set aside the same or not?.
8. After evaluating the oral and documentary evidences adduced on both
sides and the judgments of trial court, the first appellate Court dismissed the
appeal by confirming the decree and judgement passed by the trial Court in
O.S.No.1775 of 2007 dated 10.12.2010. Aggrieved by the said decree and
judgement, the present second appeal has been preferred by the 4th appellant in
the first appeal, who is one of the legal heirs of the first appellant.
9. This Court at the time of admitting this Second Appeal, framed the
following substantial questions of law:
(i)whether the suit is maintainable, when the jurisdiction of the
Civil Court is barred in matters relating to the regularization of the
buildings granted by the CMDA under the Tamil Nadu Town and
Country Planning Act?
(ii)Whether the Courts below are correct in law in ignoring the
__________
Page9 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
issue of limitation which has been raised by the defendants in
paragraph Nos.9 & 10 of the written statement and not framing the
issue with reference to the same?
(iii)Whether the common area in the terrace portion can be
interfered by the promoter under the pretext, they are entitled to
construct, based on the remaining available un-utilized un-divided
share of 982 sq. feet.?
10. Parties are hereinafter referred to as per their litigative status and
ranking before the Trial Court
11. The learned counsel for the appellant would submit that the appellant
is the legal heir of the deceased first defendant. Originally, the properties
belonged to second and third defendants and they entered into construction
agreement with the mother of the appellant and they constructed flats and
thereafter, sold the apartments to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs purchased the
property for a particular extent and as per the construction agreement, the
terrace portion of the building to be constructed except the areas specifically
allotted to whom has exclusive private terrace shall always be under the control
and ownership of the builder or promoter. Therefore, after signing the said
agreement, the plaintiffs are estopped from raising the right of the builder who
constructed the apartments. The said construction was constructed in the year
__________
Page10 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
2001. At the time of construction, the plaintiffs were well aware of the
construction and the concerned authorities, who are the defendants 4 & 5 have
also regularised the said construction and after 6 years, the plaintiffs have filed
the suit for declaration and permanent injunction. The Courts below failed to
consider that the disputed flat was constructed well prior to the enactment of the
amendment of the Tamilnadu Town and Country Planning Act i.e. 28.02.1999
and the application for regularisation was made in the first instance itself that is
before extended date on 30.06.2000 and thereby, it does not come under Section
113 A of the Tamilnadu Town and Country Planning Act. The plan for the
schedule of property was sanctioned in the year 1994-1995 and the
regularization application for the construction to be made in the terrace was
granted in the year 2002 itself, whereas the original suit was filed in the year
2007, i.e. after 5 years thereafter. The construction portion was completed in the
year 1998. The application for regularization was submitted prior to 30.06.2000.
The plaintiffs’ Association was an unregistered one. The plaintiffs challenged
the regularization order given by the statutory authorities through this suit and
the same is not maintainable. Therefore, the Court below has failed to consider
the same and erroneously decreed the suit. Moreover, the trial Court has not
framed proper issues in respect of limitation, maintainability of the suit and no
issue has been framed in respect of the declaration of the title and only framed
an issue in respect of permanent injunction. The appellate Court also not framed
proper issues and only framed a point for determination whether the judgement
__________
Page11 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
and decree passed by the trial Court are correct or not?. Therefore, the Courts
below have not framed proper issues and appreciated the facts and evidence in
the proper prospective and therefore, the decree and judgement passed by the
Courts below are liable to be set aside and the second appeal is liable to be
allowed.
12. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent would submit that
the second appeal itself is not maintainable and the appellant has no any right
over the subject property and the second and third defendants are the owners of
the property and the appellant has stepped into the shoes of the first defendant,
who is the builder and she has no locus standi to file the appeal and to conduct
the proceedings. The plaintiffs are the purchasers of the flats and at the time of
executing sale deeds, the builder conveniently executed the sale deeds for the
lesser extent of the undivided share and once the entire property was sold to the
flat owners, the builder has no right over the property to retain any property in
his favour and the entire terrace portion is common to all the flat owners but
contrary to the provisions of law, the first defendant put up an unauthorised
construction in the terrace and the defendants 4 & 5 viz., CMDA and the
Corporation of Chennai erroneously regularized the unauthorized construction
contrary to the provisions of law and therefore, the plaintiffs have filed the suit
for declaration to declare the title of the plaintiffs to enjoy the open terrace
portion in the building and for permanent injunction restraining the defendants
__________
Page12 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
from interfering with the exclusive possession of the plaintiffs and from
alienating the property. The trial Court, after careful consideration of the
evidence adduced on both sides and after referring to the legal provisions,
correctly decreed the suit and the first appellate Court also confirmed the
judgment and decree of the trial Court after an elaborate discussion. Therefore,
the Courts below have correctly appreciated the facts and there is no perversity
or illegality in the judgement and decree passed by the Courts below and there
are no substantial questions of law involved in this case and the second appeal is
liable to be dismissed.
13.This Court heard both sides and perused the records.
14.In this case, the plaintiffs are the owners of the apartments and they
purchased their respective flats with UDS through various sale deeds and the
defendants also admitted the purchase of the properties by the plaintiffs. The
main dispute is that the first defendant, who is the builder has not conveyed the
entire property of UDS and he illegally retained some portion and also he
unauthorizedly constructed the building in the open terrace, which is common to
all the apartment owners. According to the defendants, based on the agreement
entered between the first defendant and the apartment owners, they purchased
the property and as per the agreement, a terrace of the building to be constructed
except the areas specifically allotted which has exclusive private terrace shall
__________
Page13 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
always be under the control or ownership of the builder. Therefore, the plaintiffs
admitted the right of the builder and purchased the properties. Now they cannot
question the same. Once the suit is filed for declaration and for permanent
injunction, it is the duty of the plaintiffs to prove their case. The trial Court has
not framed relevant issue in respect of the limitation and also for the
declaration. The issue is only for permanent injunction and no specific issue has
been framed in respect of the declaration when the prayer for declaration is the
main relief sought for by the plaintiffs. Though the parties have adduced the
evidence and marked the documents without framing the relevant issue in
respect of the main relief, the suit cannot be disposed of. Further, the trial Court
has failed to frame issue in respect of limitation. The trial Court has not
appreciated the facts and the judgment is not in consonance with the Order 20
Rule 4(2) of CPC. As per Order 20 Rule 4(2) of CPC, the judgements of the
Courts shall contain concise statement of the case, points for determination, the
decision thereon and the reasons for such decision. But on perusal of the
judgments and decrees passed by Courts below, it appears that no proper issues
have been framed and not even considered crucial issue regarding the
maintainability of the suit when on the date of filing of the suit, the construction
was made and the prayer is only for the terrace portion of the building. On the
date of filing of the suit, since the construction was made and that constructed
portion cannot be considered as terrace portion. Therefore, the judgment of the
trial Court is not in consonance with the Order 20 Rule 4(2) of CPC. Therefore,
__________
Page14 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
the decree and judgment passed by the trial Court are liable to be set aside even
without going into the merits of the case. As far as the first appellate Court is
concerned, the first appellate Court has framed the point for determination as:
‘’Whether the appellate Court is warranting to interfere the judgment and
decree dated 10.12.2010 passed in O.S.No.1775 of 2007 by the learned XV
Assistant Judge, City Civil Court at Chennai to set aside the same or not?’’
15. The appellate Court has not framed the proper points for
determination and not appreciated the facts and the judgement of the first
appellate Court is not in consonance with the Order 41 Rule 31 of the CPC. As
per Order 41 Rule 31, the judgement of the appellate Court shall state the point
for determination, the decision thereon and the reasons for the decision and the
relief granted. Therefore, it is appears that the first appellate Court’s judgment is
not in consonance with Order the 41 Rule 31 CPC. Both the Courts have failed
to frame proper issues and appreciated the facts and evidence and erroneously
decreed the suit, which cannot be sustained.
16. Therefore, without going into the merits of the case, this Court is
inclined to set aside the judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below and
the matter is remanded back to the trial Court for framing proper issues and to
dispose of the suit afresh. In such view of the matter, the substantial questions
of law cannot be answered.
__________
Page15 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
17. In the result, the Second Appeal is allowed and the judgment and
decree dated 10.12.2010 passed in OS.NO.1775 of 2007 on the file of the XV
Judge, Assistant City Civil Court at Chennai and Judgment and decree dated
30.01.2018 passed in AS.No.336 of 2011, on the file of VI Additional Judge,
City Civil Court at Chennai are hereby set aside and the matter is remanded
back to the trial Court for framing appropriate issues and to dispose of the suit
afresh, after affording reasonable opportunity to both parties to adduce evidence
in respect of the issues to be framed. Since the suit is of the year 2007, the trial
Court is directed to complete the evidence and dispose of the same within a
period of six months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. There shall
be no order as to costs.
20-02-2026
DN
To
1. The VI Additional Judge, City Civil Court at Chennai
2. The XV Judge, Assistant City Civil Court at Chennai
__________
Page16 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 656 of 2018
P.DHANABAL J.
DN
SA No. 656 of 2018
20-02-2026
__________
Page17 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review