Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 760 OF 2011
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 29.01.2011 IN AS NO.154 OF
2008 OF III ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, KOLLAM ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT
AND DECREE DATED 31.03.2008 IN OS NO.47 OF 2004 OF PRINCIPAL MUNSIFF COURT,
KOLLAM
APPELLANTS/APPELLANTS/ PLAINTIFFS 1,2,4, 5 AND 7 TO 12:
RAMACHANDRAN PILLAI,
S/O.JANARDHANAN PILLAI, KADAPPAL VEEDU, PATTATHANAM CHERRY,
KOLLAM.
MAHESWARI AMMA,
D/O.THANKAMMA AMMA, -DO- -DO-
SUBHADRA AMMA,
D/O.THANKAMMA AMMA, -DO- -DO-
VIJAYALEKSHMI AMMA,
D/O.THANKAMMA AMMA, -DO- -DO-
SREEDHARI,
D/O.THANKAMMA AMMA, -DO- -DO-
MAHESWARAN,
S/O.JANARDHANAN PILLAI, -DO- -DO-
SUDARSANAN PILLAI,
S/O.JANARDHANAN PILLAI, -DO- -DO-
RAJESWARI AMMA,
D/O.THANKAMMA AMMA, -DO- -DO-
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
RRAJASEKHARAN PILLAI,
S/O.JANARDHANAN PILLAI, -DO- -DO-
BY ADVS.
SUMATHY DANDAPANI (SR.)
MILLU DANDAPANI
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS 1 TO 4 AND PLAINTIFFS 3 & 6:
KERALA STATE,
REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KOLLAM- 691 001.
TAHSILDAR,
TALUK OFFICE, KOLLAM-691 01.
VILLAGE OFFICER,
VADAKKEVILA VILLAGE, VADAKKEVILA (PO), KOLLAM-691 010.
JAYAKUMAR,
S/O.KUTTAN PILLAI, JAYA JYOTHI, VETTILATHAZHIKATHU CHERRY,
THRIKKOVILVATTOM VILLAGE-691 001.
INDIRA AMMA,
D/O.THANKAMMA AMMA, SUPRIYA , PURA 129, POOJAPPURA PO,
TRIVANDRUM-695 012.
SANKARAKUMAR,
S/O.JANARDHANAN PILLAI, GURU MAHIMA, AYATHIL NAGAR-3,
AYATHIL PO, KOLLAM- 691 017.
BY ADVS.
R1 TO R3 BY GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI DENNY DEVASSY
ALEX N.MATHEW (KOLLAM)
R4 BY ADV. JAMES JOSE
R6 BY PRATHEESH.P
H.RAMANAN
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 04.04.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
JUDGMENT
1.
Appellants are the plaintiff Nos 2, 4, 5 and 7 to 12 in the suit.
Plaintiffs 2 to 12 are the children of the 1st plaintiff. The defendants
1 to 3 are State of Kerala Represented by District Collector,
Tahsildar and Village Officer. The 4th defendant is a person having
property on the southern side of the plaintiff’s property. The suit
was for declaration of title and possession of plaint B schedule
property and for a consequential permanent prohibitory injunction
against initiating action against the same.
2.
Plaint A schedule property is having an extent of 60 cents
equivalent to 24 Ares and excess situated in Survey No. 412 of
Vadakkevila Village. It is situated on the eastern side of
Ammanada-Chirayilkulam road. Plaint B schedule property is 2
Ares of land equivalent to 4.94 cents lying in a triangle shape
inside the plaint A schedule property at its south west corner,
which is mistakenly included in Re Sy. No.28/17.
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
3.
Plaintiff instituted the suit when the 2nd defendant issued Exts.B3
& B4 Notices dated 13.11.2003 under the Kerala Land
Conservancy Act, against the plaintiff and the 4th defendant
alleging that they have encroached into Puramboke land situated
in Re.Sy. 28/17 of Vadakkevila village.
It is alleged in those
Notices that the total extent of puramboke land is 5.60 ares in ReSy.No.28/17. As per Ext.B3, the plaintiff is alleged to have
encroached into 1.50 Ares. As per Ext.B4, the 4th defendant is
alleged to have encroached into 0.50 ares.
4.
The case of the plaintiffs in substance is that large extent of
properties including the plaint A schedule property belonged to
Thekkekadappal
branch
of
Kadappal
Tharavad.
O.S
No.1134/1115 was instituted for partition before the Munsiff’s
Court Kollam. Mother of the 1st plaintiff Narayani Amma was the
3rd defendant in that suit. The subject matter in the said suit was
compromised by executing a Partition deed No.8018/1119 M.E,
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
and thereupon, O.S No.1134/1115 M.E was withdrawn, and the
Court dismissed the suit as withdrawn. Thereafter, another suit
was filed before the Munsiff’s Court Kollam as O.S No.24/1120
M.E challenging the Partition Deed No. 8018/1119 M.E and for
partition. In O.S No.24/1120, the Trial Court passed a Preliminary
Decree ordering partition after setting aside Partition Deed
No.8018/1119 M.E. Final decree was passed on 29.11.1997 on
the application of the plaintiffs 1 to 9 in the present suit. The
property allotted to the share of the plaintiffs 1 to 9 was plaint A
schedule item No.3 property which is the plaint A schedule
property in the present suit. The plaintiffs 1 to 9 got delivery of the
plaint A schedule property on 26.09.2003 as per Ext.A6 Delivery
Kaichit. The plaintiff put a fence on the western boundary of plaint
A schedule property. Since the 4th defendant who is having
property on the southern side of plaint A schedule property did not
have access to his property from the eastern road, the plaintiffs
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
and 4th defendant entered into a license agreement with respect
to 1 cent lying on the southern extremity of the plaint A schedule
property for a period of six months. A Pongu tree which is
otherwise called as ‘Kambakam’ having an age of 50 years old
was standing at the south western portion of plaint A schedule
property. A banyan tree also began to sprout there. In the year
2003, the plaintiffs cut down the banyan tree. At the instance of
certain people, the 3rd defendant Village Officer issued Exts.B3
and B4 L C Notices Nos.10 and 11 of 2003 under the Kerala Land
Conservancy Act alleging that the said tree is situated in the
puramboke land. The properties covered by Exts.B3 and B4 L C
Notices are part and parcel of plaint A schedule property which is
the B schedule property in the suit. The plaintiff also claimed that
even if the 1st defendant is having right over plaint B schedule
property the same has been lost by adverse possession and
hence the defendants 2 and 3 are not entitled to take action under
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
the Kerala Land Conservancy Act.
5.
The 2nd defendant filed a Written Statement and an additional
written statement contending, inter alia, that the land being used
as a passage to the registered land of the plaintiff is a part of an
old puramboke comprised in Re.Sy. No.28/17 of Block No.24 of
Vadakkevila village. Land conservancy proceedings were initiated
since an encroachment was found having an extent of 1.50 Ares
of road puramboke in Re.Sy.No.28/17 of Block No.24 of
Vadakkevila village. The agreement between the plaintiff and the
4th defendant with respect to road puramboke land is not valid.
The way described in the plaint is a road puramboke comprised
in Re-Sy No.28/17, which was situated in old Survey No. 416, and
the same is shown as road puramboke in the BTR.
On the
eastern side of the road, there was a Kambakam tree having an
age of 50 years old worth Rs.10,000/-. Adjacent to the said tree
there was a banyan tree 10 years old. Plaintiffs 2, 6, 9, and 10 cut
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
and removed the said trees from the puramboke land, and hence,
the land conservancy proceedings were initiated. The plaintiffs
are not having any excess land. The plaintiffs put up fencing
enclosing 1.50 Ares of puramboke land before one month. 5.60
Ares, lying on the western side of the registered holding, was
encroached on by the plaintiffs and constructed fence cutting and
removing trees stood therein. The plaintiffs are claiming title over
pacca road from Ammanada to Chirayilkulam. The road
puramboke is situated in Re-Sy.No.28/17 whereas the property of
the plaintiffs and 4th defendants are in Re-Sy No.29/10. Plaintiffs
have no right to claim adverse possession over puramboke land.
The suit is filed only to defeat land conservancy proceedings
initiated against the plaintiff.
6.
The defendants 1 and 3 filed Memo adopting the contention of the
2nd defendant.
7.
The 4th defendant filed a Written Statement contending that the
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
suit is bad for the misjoinder of parties as the 4th defendant is not
a necessary party to the suit. No relief is sought against the 4th
defendant. The 4th defendant is in possession and enjoyment of
5.26 Ares in resurvey No. 29/37, 22,13 and 26 of Vadakkevila
Village. The plaint A schedule property is situated on the north of
the property of the 4th defendant. Panchayat Road is situated on
the western side. The 4th defendant is using about 1 cent of land
to enter into his property. The said 1 cent is a part and parcel of
the 4th defendant’s property. An agreement for sale was executed
by the 4th defendant with the plaintiffs and the plaintiffs received
Rs.10,000/- as advance. B schedule property exclusively
belonged to the 4th defendant. There is no other way to enter into
his property.
8.
The plaintiffs filed a Replication contending that the road on the
western side of plaint A schedule property was only a beaten
track. Now it is having a width of 3.5 meters and length of 29.5
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
meters and the same is comprised in Sy.No.28/17. An extent of
2.5 cents is lying as excess property of the plaintiffs. Old
Sy.No.416 is not a road puramboke. The said property is Kavu
Puramboke, belonged to the Pattur family. The extent of property
as per revenue records in Old Sy.No.412 is 58 cents. An extent of
5 cents excess land lying in old Sy. No.412 was falsely
incorporated as road puramboke in the Resurvey Plan. Out of the
said 5 cents of excess land, 2.5 cents converted as road, and the
balance is in the possession and enjoyment of the plaintiffs over
which the Government does not have any right.
9.
On the side of the plaintiffs, the 10th plaintiff was examined as
PW1, one witness was examined as PW2, and the Advocate
Commissioner who prepared the Ext.C1 Report was examined as
PW3. On the side of the plaintiffs Exts.A1 to A23 were marked in
evidence. On the side of the defendants 1 to 3, the 3rd defendant
was examined as DW1. On the side of the defendants Exts.B1 to
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
B7 were marked. Commission Report, Mahazar and Plan were
marked as Exts.C1 , C2 and C3.
10. The Trial Court dismissed the suit holding that plait B schedule
property is not the part and parcel of plaint A schedule property;
that plaintiff did not obtain or possess excess land other than 60
cents in old Sy.No.412 as per Ext.A6 Delivery Kaichit and that the
suit is not maintainable under S.20A of the Kerala Land
Conservancy Act.
11. The plaintiffs 1, 2,4,5 and 7 to 12
filed Appeal before the First
Appellate Court and the First Appellate Court dismissed the
appeal confirming the judgment and decree of the Trial Court. The
First Appellate Court marked two documents in evidence from the
side of the plaintiff as Exts.A24 and A25. The First Appellate Court
found that the suit filed by the plaintiffs is maintainable as the
same is not barred under S.20A of the Kerala Land Conservancy
Act. The First Appellate Court also found that there is nothing on
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
record to prove that the plaintiffs had excess property than 60
cents of land in old Sy.No. 412 covered by Ext.A6 Delivery Kaichit.
12. This Court admitted the Regular Second Appeal on the following
substantial questions of law.
i. Whether the courts below erred in holding that there is
government puramboke land in between the road and plaint A
schedule property on its eastern side ignoring the boundary
descriptions as east to the way in Exts.A1, A1(a), A7, A8, A9 and
A10 documents and in Ext.A6, delivery kaichit; and ignoring the
settled position of law regarding conflict of boundary as against the
extent, survey number etc., of land as reported in 1957 KLT 42,
1984 KLT SN 11 P 65 and 1990(1) KLT 187?
ii.Have not the courts below erred in not holding that by the
resurvey proceedings the revenue authorities arbitrarily and
illegally added portion of property corresponding to the property in
old survey No.412 to resurvey subdivision No.28/17 which is
corresponding to old survey No.416, by analyzing the documents
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
available on record and the provisions of the Kerala Survey and
Boundaries Act and Rules?
iii.Have not the courts below erred in not holding that the plaintiffs
have perfected their title to the plaint B schedule property by
adverse possession and limitation even if it is assumed that plaint
B schedule property is a Government puramboke land?
13. I
heard the learned Senior Counsel for the appellants
Smt.Sumathi Dandapani instructed by Adv.Sri.Millu Dandapani,
learned Senior Government Pleader Sri.Denny Devassy for
respondents 1 to 3 and the learned counsel for the 4th respondent
Sri.Alex N Mathew.
14. The
learned Senior Counsel for the appellant contended that
Ext.A7, A8, A9 and A10 documents would reveal that there was
excess land in plaint A schedule property which is described as
“Vadavuvashi”. Exts.A3,A5 and A6 would prove that the plaintiffs
got delivery of 60 cents of land in old Sy.No.412. The puramboke
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
is situated in old Sy.No.416. In resurvey, Re-Sy No.29/10
corresponds to old Sy.No.412 and Re-Sy No.28/17 corresponds
to old Sy.No.416. This is revealed from Ext.B5 BTR. There was
only 58 cents in old Sy.No.416 as puramboke. But in resurvey
63.25 cents is recorded as puramboke in Re- Sy.No.28/17 thus
including 5.25 cents. It clearly shows that the said extent was
taken from registered holding situated in old Sy.No.412. The
plaintiffs executed Ext.A11 License Agreement with the 4th
defendant for using 1 cent of land out of plaint B schedule
property.
Subsequently,
the
plaintiffs
executed
Ext.A12
Agreement agreeing to sell 1 cent of land to the 4th defendant for
a sale consideration of Rs.80,000/-. The disputed trees were
situated in the registered holding of the plaintiffs, and hence, the
plaintiffs had every right to cut and remove them. Even though the
plaintiff claimed B Schedule property having an extent of 4.94
cents, the claim was limited in the Replication to 1.14 Ares, which
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
is found in Sketch No.1 in Ext.C3 Plan. The evidence of the 3rd
defendant as DW1 fully supports the case of the plaintiffs. The
Trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court ought to have found
Plaint B schedule property found as 1.14 Ares in Sketch No.1 as
a part of plaint A schedule registered holding of the plaintiffs. The
Courts did not consider Exts.C1 to C3 in the right perspective.
The properties were in possession of the Receiver for more than
60 years prior to the possession of the plaintiffs. Hence
defendants 1 to 3 were not possessing the plaint B schedule
property at any point of time. The learned Senior counsel
concluded that all the substantial questions of law are to be
answered in favour of the appellants allowing the appeal setting
aside the judgments and decrees passed by the Trial Court as
well as the First Appellate Court and allowing the suit granting
reliefs in favour of the plaintiffs with respect to plaint B schedule
property as found in Sketch No.1 in Ext.C3 plan.
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
15. On the other hand the learned Government Pleader argued that
the plaintiffs can not claim any area larger than the area covered
by Ext.A6 Delivery Kaichit. The plaintiffs did not have a case that
they have excess land. When the property was taken possession
as per Ext.A6 Delivery Kaichit, reference to earlier documents for
claiming excess can not be permitted. It is obvious from the facts
that the plaintiffs filed the suit for the sole purpose of defeating the
land conservancy proceedings validly initiated by the official
defendants. The Trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court
considered the matter in the right perspective and arrived at the
correct conclusion. Learned Government Pleader concluded by
submitting that the substantial questions of law formulated in the
Appeal do not arise in the matter.
16. The
Counsel for the 4th respondent argued that the 4th
respondent/4th defendant was unnecessarily dragged into the
suit by the plaintiffs. No reliefs are claimed against the 4th
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
defendant. Counsel pressed for dismissal of the appeal.
17. I have considered the rival contentions.
18. Plaintiffs’ specific case is that plaint B schedule property is a part
of their registered holding included in Plaint A schedule. Plaint A
schedule property is shown having an extent of 60 cents
equivalent to 24 Ares and excess situated in Survey No. 412 of
Vadakkevila Village. Plaint B schedule property is shown having
2 Ares of land equivalent to 4.94 cents lying in a triangle shape
inside the plaint A schedule property at its south west corner which
is mistakenly included in Re.Sy.No.28/17.
19. Admittedly, Old Sy.No.412 is private property, and Sy.No.416 is
puramboke. In Resurvey, Re.Sy.No.29/10 is private property and
Re.Sy.No.28/17 is puramboke after assignments. The plaintiff
claimed the extent of 2 Ares of land equivalent to 4.94 cents as
Plaint B Schedule. It appears that such extent is included in Plaint
B schedule since Exts.B3 and B4 Notices to the plaintiffs and the
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
4th defendant covers total extent of 2 ares. Plaintiffs themselves
admit that it is included in Re-Sy.No.28/17. According to them, it
is by mistake included as puramboke in Resurvey. Even though
they did not amend the Plaint B schedule, the contention now
advanced is that they limited their claim to 1.14 Ares which is
found in Sketch No.1 in Ext.C3 Plan. It is not permissible to limit
the plaint claim without necessary amendment in the plaint. The
plaintiff could have amended the plaint schedule properties when
Advocate Commissioner filed Exts.C1 to C3 Reports. Now the
plaint schedule properties do not tally with the properties identified
in Ext.C3 Plan.
20. In view of the contentions advanced before me, I find that Two
questions arise for consideration. First is whether the plaintiffs had
any excess land in their registered holding. Secondly, apart from
puramboke in Old Sy.No.416, whether any private property in old
Sy.412 is included in Re-Sy.No.28. If the answers to these two
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
questions are in the affirmative, the plaintiff is entitled succeed in
the suit.
21. The plaintiffs claim excess possession of land in their registered
holding by referring to the existence of ‘Vadavuvashi’ in the title
documents. Learned Senior Counsel invited my attention to
Exts.A7,A8, A9 and A10 in this context. The schedules of A7 and
A10 documents shows existence of ‘Vadavuvashi’. But all these
documents are executed during the pendency of O.S.No.24/1120
M.E. The property available for partition was partitioned in the final
decree proceedings in O.S.No.24/1120 ME. The properties
measured and allotted to the sharers. The plaintiffs obtained 60
cents of land in Old Sy.No.412 as per Ext.A6 Delivery Kaichit
dated 26.09.2003. In Ext.A5, the Final Decree extent showed is
60 cents in Sy No.412, which is demarcated as Plot No.1 in Ext.C1
Plan therein. Ext.A20 herein is the Ext.C1 Plan therein. PW3 is
the same Advocate Commissioner who prepared Ext.A4 Mahazar
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
and Ext.A20 Plan in O.S.No.24/1120 and Exts.C1 to C3 in the
present suit. The Plot having 60 cents is specifically identified with
side and diagonal measurements in Ext.A20. It would show that
the property delivered as per Ext.A6 Delivery Kaichit is without
any excess land. Sketch No.II in Ext. C3 Plan tallies with
measurements in Ext.A20 on the basis of which the plaintiffs took
delivery of the property as per Ext.A6. In Sketch No.II of Ext.C3
Plan, the extent is found as 60 cents as per the measurements in
Ext.A20. The plaintiffs did not file any objection to Exts.C1 to C3.
When property is allotted as per Final Decree, Final Decree is the
title of the plaintiffs. They get the property only as per the Final
Decree.
Ext.A6
Delivery
Kaichit
issued
in
final
decree
proceedings in a Partition suit can not include excess land. As a
matter of fact, Ext.A6 does not include any excess land.
22. A4 Mahazar prepared by PW3 shows the existence of a Pongu
tree in Plaint A schedule item No.3 therein, which is the Plaint A
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
schedule property herein. In Ext.C1 Report, the Advocate
Commissioner stated that he had reported 60 cents, including
‘vadavuvashi’ in his Report in O.S.No.24/1120 and that he
reported a Pongu tree in the property. When measurements in
Ext.A20 and Sketch II in Ext.C3 tally each other both identifying
60 cents, it is not clear as to how the Advocate Commissioner
reported excess in the earlier Report in O.S.No.24/1120. The said
Report does not form part of the records in the present suit.
Advocate Commissioner as PW3 admitted that the Pongu tree is
situated in excess land. He admitted that no where in Ext.A4 (a)
Mahzar it is specifically stated that there is excess as
vadavuvashi. In view of this evidence, I answer the first question
that the plaintiffs did not derive any land in excess of 60 cents as
per Ext.A6 Delivery Kaichit.
23. With respect to the second question, as per Ext.A21 Settlement
Register, the extent of puramboke in Sy.No.416 is 58 cents.
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
Ext.A22/B5 BTR would show that the total extent transferred to
new Re-Sy No.28 is 25.60 equivalent to 63.2576 cents. It is not
clear how the extent of puramboke was increased in resurvey. It
is not clear whether any private land from Old Sy.No.412 is added
to Re-Survey No.28. Plaintiffs can object to Resurvey only if they
prove that part of Old Sy.No.412 is taken for Re-Survey No.28.
The plaintiffs does not claim possession and title over the land in
Old Sy.No.416 which was puramboke land.
24. The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant invited my attention
to Ext.A24 obtained under RTI Act to show the assignment of 58
cents of puramboke in Old Sy No.416 included in Ext.A21
Settlement Register. Ext.A24 would show assignments 22 cents
and 25 cents to two persons and the remaining extent as 11 cents.
It is seen that 22 cents is allotted on the western side of the road
and 25 cents is assigned on the eastern side of the road and 11
cents is remaining as road puramboke.
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
25. After assignment of 47 cents (25 +22) from puramboke land of 58
cents in Old Sy.No.416, the balance is only 11 cents. But the
remaining puramboke recorded in Re.Sy.No.28/17 as per
Ext.A22/B5 BTR is 5.60 equivalent to 13.837, thereby showing an
excess of 2.837 cents excess. It is not clear as to how the excess
occurred. DW1 Village Officer could not explain to how the excess
occurred to puramboke when resurvey was conducted. DW1
could not answer material questions put to him by the plaintiffs. It
shows that some mistakes are there in the Resurvey. The
puramboke property of 5.60 ares in Re.Sy No.28/17 is also not
identified. In Sketch I in Ext.C3, the extent of the disputed
puramboke is 1.14 ares. In Sketch II, the extent of disputed
puramboke is 0.94 ares. The extent of the disputed puramboke
could only be as shown in Sketch II of Ext.C3 as the Plaint A
schedule property delivered as per Ext.A6 is correctly identified in
accordance with Ext.A20 only in Sketch II of Ext.C3.
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
26. Thus,
it is clear that property in excess of puramboke in old
Sy.No.416 is included corresponding Re-Survey No.28, but the
material evidence as to the status of such excess added to ReSurvey No. 28 is lacking. There is no evidence that in resurvey
excess to puramboke is taken from private land belonging to the
plaintiff in Old Sy No.412.
27. The substantial question of law No.3 relates to the plea of
adverse possession and limitation.
Admittedly the plaint B
schedule property is a puramboke property. In view of Article 111
of the Limitation Act, the statutory period for claiming title on the
strength of adverse possession and limitation is 30 years as
against the Government. Admittedly, the plaintiff obtained the
plaint A schedule property as per Ext.A6 Kaichit dated
26.09.2003. The suit was filed in the year 2004. As stated earlier
there is no evidence to prove that the plaintiff obtained possession
of Plaint B schedule property along with the property covered by
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
Ext.A6 Delivery Kaichit. The property covered by Ext. A6 Delivery
Kaichit identified by Sketch No.II of Ext.C3 does not cover plaint
B schedule property. There is no evidence to prove that the
plaintiffs have been in possession of the plaint B schedule
property. There is no evidence to prove possession for the
statutory period of 30 years to claim title by adverse possession.
Hence, I hold that the finding of the First Appellate Court that the
plaintiffs failed to prove adverse possession over the property
identified as puramboke in Ext.C3 does not require any
interference.
28. The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant pointed out that
Plaint B schedule property is a small extent of land which is
situated between the road and the property of the plaintiffs. The
official defendants are attempting to assign the said land to third
parties as revealed from Ext.A23. If the said land is allotted to any
third party the plaintiffs access to the road will be affected and the
RSA No.760 of 2011
2025:KER:28564
same will cause substantial injury to the plaintiffs. It is true that if
the plaint B schedule property identified in Ext.C3 is allotted to
third parties it would affect the road frontage of the property
covered by Ext.A6 delivery Kaichit belonging to the plaintiff. But it
is not a ground to find that the plaintiffs are having any right over
plaint B schedule property. Of course, the plaintiffs are free to
raise their objections before the authorities concerned if the
official defendants attempt to assign the said land to third parties.
29. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the appellant/plaintiff is not
entitled to succeed in this Appeal. The substantial questions of
law formulated in the appeal are answered in the negative and
against the appellants. The Regular Second Appeal is dismissed.
Sd/-
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
Jma/shg
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review