Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 09
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Rama Rani
Through: Ms. Mandeep Reen, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Sanchi Gupta, Advocate
vs
.…. Respondent(s)
Chaman Lal
Through: Mr. Varun Raina, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
14.07.2026
1.
The petitioner, who is the defendant before the trial Court, has invoked the
revisional jurisdiction of this Court to challenge order dated 26.05.2023
passed by the Court of the 3rd Additional Munsiff, JMIC, Jammu, in Civil
Suit No. 2785/2022, Chaman Lal v. Rama Rani, whereby the petitioner's
right to file the written statement was closed on the ground that the same
had not been filed within the statutory period of 120 days prescribed under
Order VIII Rule 1 CPC.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that several litigations are
pending between the parties. It was contended that the petitioner's mother,
late Krishna Devi, had earlier instituted a suit for permanent prohibitory
injunction against the respondent, titled Krishna Devi & Anr. v. Chaman
Lal & Anr., File No. 184/2014, before the same Court. After her mother's
demise, the petitioner, a 70-year-old lady, continued to pursue the said
litigation through her son-in-law, who was entrusted with monitoring the
proceedings and coordinating with the counsel.
3.
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
It was submitted that following the death of the petitioner's son-in-law, she
engaged another counsel and learnt that the earlier suit had been dismissed
in default on 30.10.2021. While obtaining certified copies of the record
relating to the said suit, the petitioner came to know for the first time about
the respondent having instituted the present suit. Consequently, she
engaged counsel on 03.05.2023, filed a Vakalatnama, and sought time to
file the written statement. The certified copies of the earlier suit were
received on 25.05.2023, and when the matter was taken up on 26.05.2023,
the petitioner's counsel again sought time for filing the written statement.
However, the trial Court closed the petitioner's right to file the same despite
recording the reasons for the delay.
4.
It was further argued that the impugned order suffers from material
irregularity and non-application of mind, as the petitioner had never been
served with summons in the present suit and became aware of its pendency
only while pursuing the records of the earlier litigation. It was contended
that the trial Court erroneously relied upon the judgment of this Court in
Rajinder Singh Manhas v. Anil Gaind & Ors. decided on 25.04.2023,
without appreciating that the facts of the said case were distinguishable.
5.
Learned counsel further contended that under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC, the
statutory period of 120 days commences only from the date of valid service
of summons upon the defendant. In the present case, neither does the record
disclose issuance or service of summons upon the petitioner in accordance
with Order V CPC, nor has the trial Court recorded any satisfaction
regarding due service. It was argued that under Order V Rule 1 CPC,
summons is required to call upon the defendant to appear, answer the claim,
and file the written statement within thirty days of service, extendable up to
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
ninety days for reasons to be recorded. Since the mandatory requirements
relating to service were not complied with, the trial Court erred in
mechanically closing the petitioner's right to file the written statement.
6.
In support of the above submissions, reliance was placed upon the
judgment of the Coordinate Bench in Abdul Qayoom Sheikh v. Sajad
Haider, CM(M) Nos. 2/2024 and 3/2024, decided on 28.11.2024, wherein
it was held that unless the requirements of Order V CPC regarding service
of summons are fully complied with, the period prescribed under Order
VIII Rule 1 CPC cannot be reckoned against the defendant.
7.
The respondent contended that the petitioner-defendant had been duly
served with the summons, as was evident from the trial court record. It was
argued that the trial court had recorded its satisfaction regarding service on
the basis of the plaintiff's service affidavit, and that the defendant had also
been served with the injunction order and the affidavit required under Order
XXXIX Rule 3 CPC on 07.01.2023. According to the respondent, the
period of 120 days prescribed for filing the written statement commenced
from that date, and since the defendant failed to file the written statement
within the prescribed period, the trial court rightly closed her right to do so.
Reliance was placed on AIR 2015 SC 1252 to contend that an endorsement
of service by the Process Server constitutes sufficient service under Order
V CPC unless successfully rebutted.
8.
Having heard the respective Counsels and upon considering the rival
submissions and examining the record, it emerges that the suit was
instituted on 27.12.2022, whereupon summons was directed to be issued
requiring the defendant to appear and file the written statement as well as
objections to the interim application. On 25.01.2023, the trial court
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
recorded its satisfaction that service had been affected on the defendant on
the basis of the plaintiff's affidavit and adjourned the matter awaiting her
appearance. The defendant eventually entered appearance through counsel
on 03.05.2023, filed a vakalatnama, and sought time to file the written
statement. Despite subsequent opportunities, no written statement was filed.
On 26.05.2023, the trial court, relying upon the judgment in Rajinder Singh
Manhas v. Anil Gaind and others dated 25.04.2023 supra held that the
mandatory period of 120 days for filing the written statement had expired
and, consequently, closed the defendant's right to file the same.
9.
Thus, the controversy essentially turns on whether the service effected on
the defendant was valid service of summons in accordance with Order V
CPC, thereby commencing the limitation period under Order VIII Rule 1
CPC, or whether the service of the injunction order and documents under
Order XXXIX Rule 3 CPC could not be treated as valid service of
summons for the purpose of calculating the 120-day period. The answer to
this issue determines the legality of the trial court's order closing the
defendant's right to file the written statement.
10.
Scanning of the record reveals that, although the Trial Court, vide order
dated 27.12.2022, directed issuance of summons to the defendant for
causing appearance and filing the written statement, the record is
conspicuously silent regarding the issuance or service of any such summons
upon the defendant. In fact, no summons was issued pursuant to the order
dated 27.12. 2022.Instead, what was served upon the defendant, Rama
Rani, was only a copy of the ex parte order dated 27.12.2022 passed by the
Trial Court under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil
Procedure. The said order was served upon her on 07.01.2023, and its
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
receipt was duly acknowledged by her. The Trial Court, however, treated
the said service as sufficient service in accordance with law and proceeded
to compute the period of 120 days for filing the written statement
therefrom, which period had admittedly expired by the time the impugned
order came to be passed.
11.
Whereas, vide the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization (Adaptation of
Central Laws) Order, 2020, S.O. 1123(E) dated 18.03.2020, which came to
be effected on that very day, Proviso 2 to Order VIII Rule 1 CPC has been
substituted as under: “Provided that where the defendant fails to file the written
statement with the said period of thirty days, he shall be
allowed to file the written statement on such other day, as may
be specified by the court, for reasons to be recorded in writing
and on payment of such costs as the court deems fit, but which
shall not be later than one hundred twenty days from the date
of service of summons and on expiry of one hundred twenty
days from the date of service of summons, the defendant shall
forfeit the right to file the written statement and the court shall
not allow the written statement to be taken on record.”.
12.
Prior to the issuance of the aforesaid S.O., the legal position prevailing in
the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir was governed by the settled
judicial interpretation that, notwithstanding the period prescribed under
Order VIII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the Court, in exceptional
circumstances and for reasons to be recorded, possessed the discretion to
permit the defendant to file the written statement even beyond the
prescribed period. In AIR 2007 SC 1574, Aditya Hotels (P) Ltd. v.
Bombay Swadeshi Stores Ltd., the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:
"The time limits prescribed under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC are directory in
nature; however, extension of time is an exception and not the rule. The Court
must insist upon a satisfactory explanation for the delay and record reasons in
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
writing before granting such extension, rather than extending time as a matter
of routine."
13.
In the said case, as neither the Trial Court nor the High Court had recorded
any reasons justifying the acceptance of the written statement after the
expiry of the prescribed period, the Hon'ble Supreme Court set aside the
orders passed by both the Courts and remitted the matter to the Trial Court
for fresh consideration in accordance with law.
14.
However, with the coming into force of the Jammu and Kashmir
Reorganisation Act, 2019 and the subsequent adaptation of the Code of
Civil Procedure through the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation
(Adaptation of Central Laws) Order, 2020 (S.O. 1123(E) dated
18.03.2020), the legal position has undergone a material change. Under the
substituted second proviso to Order VIII Rule 1 CPC, the defendant is
required to file the written statement within 120 days from the date of
service of summons. Upon the expiry of the said period of 120 days, the
defendant forfeits the right to file the written statement, and the Court is
divested of the jurisdiction to permit the written statement to be taken on
record thereafter.
15.
It was, however, submitted during the course of arguments that the validity
of the aforesaid amendment is presently under challenge before this Court
in various proceedings.
16.
The petitioner has not laid any challenge to the validity of the aforesaid
provision. Rather, the entire thrust of her submission is that the learned
Trial Court failed to record its satisfaction regarding due service of
summons in accordance with law. According to the petitioner, in the facts
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
of the present case, the said period could commence only after she had
entered appearance before the Trial Court pursuant to valid service.
17.
It is true that a Coordinate Bench of this Court, in Abdul Qayoom Sheikh v.
Sajad Haider, while examining the question whether service had been duly
affected in accordance with law, noticed that the defendant was alleged to
have been served only with a copy of the interim order through registered
post. However, neither the acknowledgment due card nor any other proof of
service had been produced by the plaintiff in any of the suits so as to
establish due service or to attribute knowledge of the proceedings to the
defendant. In these circumstances, the Coordinate Bench held that the
requirements of lawful service had not been satisfied. Paragraph 11 of the
said judgment reads as under:
“Unless, a trial Court is fully satisfied with the service of summons of a suit upon
the defendant, it will not be open to the said Court to take resort to stringent
provisions contained in Order 8 Rule 1 CPC and close the right of the defendant to
file written statement after the expiry of 120 days. Closure of right of a defendant to
file written statement has serious consequences upon his civil rights, therefore,
provisions contained in Order 8 Rule 1 CPC have to be strictly construed and the
expression ‘service of summons’ appearing in Rule 1 of Order 8 has to be take
colour from the provisions contained in Order 5 of the CPC. Unless the
requirements specified in Rules 9 to 30 of Order 5 of the CPC regarding service of
process upon the defendants are not fully satisfied, it cannot be presumed by a civil
Court that service of summons has been effected upon the defendants within the
meaning of Rule 1 Order 8 CPC”.
18.
Whereas, in the authority cited by the counsel for the respondent, it was an
admitted case that no personal service of notice had been effected upon the
appellants and while considering the issue of service and non-service of
notice, the Hon’ble Apex Court, in AIR 2015 SC 1252, Prabin Ram
Phukan V/s State of Assam, held in Paras 26 and 27 as under:“26. In our considered opinion, there lies a distinction between non-service of
notice and a notice though served but with some kind of procedural
irregularities in serving. In the case of former category of cases, all
consequential action, if taken would be rendered bad in law once the fact of
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
non-service is proved whereas in the case of later category of cases, the
consequential action, if taken would be sustained. It is for the reason that in
the case of former, since the notice was not served on the person concerned
he was completely unaware of the proceedings which were held behind his
back thereby rendering the action “illegal” whereas in the case of later, he
was otherwise aware of the proceedings having received the notice though
with procedural irregularity committed in making service of such notice on
him. If a person has a knowledge of the action proposed in the notice, then the
action taken thereon cannot be held as being bad in law by finding fault in the
manner of effecting service unless he is able to show substantial prejudice
caused to him due to procedural lapse in making service on him. It, however,
depends upon individual case to case to find out the nature of procedural
lapse complained of and the resultant prejudice caused. The case in hand falls
in former category of case.”
“27. In our considered opinion, therefore, it is mandatory on the part of the
State to serve a proper notice to a person, who is liable to pay any kind of
State’s dues strictly in the manner prescribed in the Regulation. It is equally
mandatory on the part of the State to give prior notice to the defaulter for
recovery of dues before his properties (moveable or/and immovable) are put
to sale in the manner prescribed in the Regulation”.
19.
Learned counsel for the respondent laid considerable emphasis on the
submission that where a person has knowledge of the proceedings initiated
against him, any action taken pursuant thereto cannot be invalidated merely
on account of an irregularity in the mode of service, unless such person is
able to demonstrate that substantial prejudice has been caused to him by the
procedural lapse. It was, therefore, argued that the petitioner cannot dispute
having been served with the order of temporary injunction and, once such
service is admitted, the service ought to be treated as sufficient compliance
with law.
20.
The aforesaid submission, however, does not merit acceptance. The Trial
Court, vide order dated 30.10.2021, directed issuance of summons to the
defendant calling upon her to appear and file the written statement. A
perusal of the record, however, does not disclose even the slightest material
to indicate that any summons was ever issued by the Court or transmitted
through the Process Serving Agency for effecting service upon the
petitioner. The service of an ex parte order of temporary injunction cannot
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
be equated with the service of summons contemplated under Order V of the
Code of Civil Procedure. Order V Rule 1 CPC mandates that, upon
institution of a suit, every summons issued by the Court shall require the
defendant to appear and answer the claim and to file the written statement
of defence, if any, within thirty days from the date of service of the
summons. The proviso thereto dispenses with the issuance of summons
only where the defendant appears at the presentation of the plaint and
admits the plaintiff's claim. Further, Rule 2 of Order V requires that every
summons shall be accompanied by a copy of the plaint and shall be signed
by the Judge or such officer as may be authorised in that behalf and sealed
with the seal of the Court. Rule 16 further provides that where the serving
officer personally delivers or tenders a copy of the summons to the
defendant or to an authorised agent, he shall obtain the signature of the
person served as an acknowledgment of service and endorse the same upon
the original summons. The provisions of Order V thus prescribe not only
the purpose for which summons is to be issued, namely, to require the
defendant to appear and file a written statement in answer to the suit, but
also the mandatory procedure and mode by which such summons is to be
served.
21.
On the other hand, Order XXXIX Rule 3 CPC operates in an altogether
different field. It provides that where the Court proposes to grant an
injunction without notice to the opposite party, it shall record the reasons
for its opinion that the object of granting the injunction would be defeated
by delay and shall require the applicant to deliver or send to the opposite
party, immediately after the grant of the injunction, a copy of the
application for injunction, the plaint, copies of the documents relied upon,
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
together with a copy of the order of injunction, and to file an affidavit
affirming compliance with the said requirement. The object of such service
is merely to intimate the opposite party of the interim order and the material
on the basis whereof it has been granted. Such service cannot, by any
stretch of imagination, be treated as a substitute for the issuance and due
service of summons under Order V CPC, which alone triggers the statutory
period prescribed under Order VIII Rule 1 for filing the written statement.
In that background trial court landed in error in relying on Rajinder Singh
Manhas v. Anil Gaind case which was decided on different set of facts
regarding effective service.
22.
The distinction between service of summons under Order V and service of
an interim order under Order XXXIX Rule 3 is not merely procedural but
substantive. While the former initiates the defendant's obligation to appear
before the Court and triggers the statutory timeline prescribed under Order
VIII Rule 1 CPC for filing the written statement, the latter is confined to
ensuring compliance with the principles of natural justice in relation to an
ex parte interim order. To conflate the two would amount to reading into
the statute something which the legislature has consciously omitted, so
view taken in Abdul Qayoom supra is re-affirmed.
23.
Accordingly, in the absence of lawful issuance and valid service of
summons in accordance with the mandatory provisions of Order V CPC,
the statutory period prescribed under Order VIII Rule 1 CPC could not have
commenced. The Trial Court, therefore, fell into manifest error in
computing the period of 120 days from the date on which the petitioner was
served only with the ex parte injunction order and, on that basis, closing her
right to file the written statement. The impugned order, having been passed
CR No. 23/2023
CM No. 4495/2023
on an erroneous understanding of the statutory scheme, cannot be sustained
in law hence is set-aside, written statement if filed shall be taken on record
and if not be filed, immediately on next date of hearing whereafter the trial
court shall proceed to dispose of the suit in accordance with law. Record be
sent back and parties to appear before trial court on 10.08 2026.
24.
Disposed of as such.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
Jammu
14.07.2026
Diksha
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review