Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.888 of 2022
Rama Chakraborty,
care of Prabir Chakraborty,
resident of Srinagar, TV Centre,
Road No.5, P.O. A.D. Nagar, Pin-79903
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
to be represented by the Secretary, Department of
Health & Family Welfare, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, P.S. New Capital Complex,
P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010
2. The Secretary, Finance Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
P.S. New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin-799010
3. The Secretary, Law,
Law & Parliamentary Affairs Department,
Government of Tripura, 1st Floor, Room No.1105,
Secretariat Building, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin-799006
4. The Deputy Legal Remembrancer & Deputy Secretary, Law,
Law & Parliamentary Affairs Department,
Government of Tripura, 1st Floor, Room No.1105,
Secretariat Building, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin-799006
5. The Director of Health Services,
Health Directorate Building, 1st Floor,
Pandit J.N. Complex, Agartala, Tripura,
Pin-799006
6. The Member Secretary,
Tripura State Legal Services Authority (TSLSA),
East Bank of Melarmath Dighi, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin-799001
7. The Deputy Secretary,
Tripura State Legal Services Authority (TSLSA),
East Bank of Melarmath Dighi, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin-799001
8. The Member Secretary,
Sadar Sub-Divisonal Legal Services Committee,
Court Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001
……….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. D. Paul, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing &
Judgment & Order
:
27.04.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order(Oral)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing for
the petitioner as well as Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for
the respondents No.1 to 5 and Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents No.6 and 7.
2.
By means of this writ petition the petitioner has prayed for
necessary directions from the Hon’ble High Court upon the respondents to
sanction and release the Medical Reimbursement Bill for a sum of
Rs.2,39,753/- and TA Bill for Rs.10,796/- in favour of the petitioner. The
petitioner has also prayed for necessary direction quashing and setting aside
the letter dated 30.06.2022 issued by the D.L.R. and Deputy Secretary, Law,
Government of Tripura.
3.
The petitioner is serving as a Head Clerk under the Tripura
State Legal Services Authority. The petitioner is posted at Sadar SubDivisional Legal Services Committee, Sadar, Agartala.
4.
The L.R. & Secretary, Law, Government of Tripura vide
notification dated 12.12.2012 conveyed to all concerned, that in exercise of
the powers conferred by Section 28(2) of the Legal Services Authorities Act,
1987 read with Rules 9, 12(1), 14 & 17 of Tripura State Legal Services
Authorities Rules, 1998, the State Government, in consultation with the Chief
Justice of the Gauhati High Court, has made the Tripura State Legal Services
Authority (Conditions of Services and the Salary and Allowances of the
Officers and other Employees) Rules, 2012, to regulate the method of
recruitment and prescribe the salary and allowances and other conditions of
service of the officers and other employees of the Tripura State Legal
Services Authority, High Court Legal Services Committee, District Legal
Services Authorities and the Sub-Divisional Legal Services Committees. The
said notification was published in Tripura Gazette Extra ordinary issue dated
13.12.2012.
5.
Rule 14 of the Tripura State Legal Services Authority
(Conditions of Services and the Salary and Allowances of the Officers and
other Employees) Rules, 2012 provides Conditions of service and the Salary
and Allowances of Officers and other Employees, in the following manner :
“i) The officers and other employees shall be entitled to draw
pay and allowances in the scale of pay at par with the State
Government employees holding equivalent posts;
ii) In all matters like age of retirement, pension, Death-cumRetirement Gratuity, pay and allowances, leave, other benefits
and entitlements the officers and other employees shall be
governed by the State Government rules as are applicable to
persons holding equivalent posts.
iii) The officers and other employees shall be entitled to such
other facilities, allowances and benefits as may be notified by
the State Government, from time to time.”
6.
The petitioner was referred by Standing Medical Board for
treatment outside Tripura. Vide referral certificate, dated 20.09.2021, issued
by the Standing Medical Board, the petitioner was referred to Medical
Hospital, Kolkata/RTIICS, Kolkata, as the petitioner for her treatment. The
petitioner was suffering from heart ailment. Being so referred, the petitioner
availed treatment at Medica Hospital, Kolkata. The petitioner underwent
heart surgery at Medica Hospital, Kolkata. After availing treatment at Medical
Hospital, Kolkata and after returning to Agartala, the petitioner vide
forwarding letter dated 20.12.2021, submitted MR Bill for Rs.2,39,753/- to
the Member Secretary, Tripura State Legal Services Authority, through proper
channel. Along with the forwarding letter, the petitioner supported MR bills,
duly certified by the concerned authority of Medica Hospital. The petitioner
has also submitted money vouchers, receipts, to substantiate her claim of
medical reimbursement for Rs.2,39,753/-.
7.
Be it mentioned here that the petitioner submitted her claim
for MR Bill in a prescribed format of application claiming refund of medical
expenses incurred in connection with Medical Attendance and Treatment of
Central Government Servant and their families. Thereafter, the Member
Secretary, Sadar, Sub-Divisional Legal Services Committee, vide letter dated
22.12.2021 forwarded the MR Bills submitted by the petitioner to the Member
Secretary, Tripura State Legal Services Authority. The petitioner is also
entitled to medical reimbursement as the petitioner is covered by the Central
Services (Medical Attendance) Rules, 1944, which has been adopted by the
State of Tripura and is applicable to State Government employees as well.
It appears that the Deputy Secretary, TSLSA, Agartala, vide letter dated
07.02.2022 forwarded MR Bill of Rs.2,39,753/- and TA Bill for Rs.10,796/-,
submitted by the petitioner to DLR & Deputy Secretary, Law, Government of
Tripura, for taking necessary action. In this letter, it is stated that Smt. Rama
Chakraborty, Head Clerk, Group-C, TSLSA, i.e., the petitioner herein,
attached to Office of the Sadar, Sub-Division Legal Services Committee,
Sadar, Agartala, has submitted MR bill of Rs.2,39,753/- and TA Bill for
Rs.10,796/-, after availing treatment regarding cardiac operation at Medica
Super Specialty Hospital, Kolkata, Mukundapur. It is also mentioned in the
letter that the petitioner was referred by the Chairman, State Referral Board,
AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala & Director of Health Services, Government of
Tripura. In the said letter, it is further stated that at present, Smt. Rama
Chakraborty is serving under TSLSA as Head Clerk, Group-C under regular
scale of pay of Rs.5700-24000/- and GP Rs.4200/-. In that letter, it is further
stated that in terms of Memo, dated 09.08.2005, issued by the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura, Smt. Rama Chakraborty, Head Clerk,
being a Group-C employee, is entitled to get Medical Reimbursement facility.
It is further stated that in the said notification dated 08.05.2018, issued by
the Government of Tripura it is mentioned that entitlement of medical
allowance shall depend on the erstwhile Grade Pay or Level of Pay matrix
applicable to the post in which the concerned Government employee has
been appointed substantially. Stating so, by that letter, the Deputy Secretary,
TSLSA, sought for clarification regarding admissibility of MR Bills submitted
by the petitioner. The petitioner is entitled to medical reimbursement. The
petitioner is not getting any medical allowance.
8.
The D.L.R. and Deputy Secretary, Law, Government of Tripura,
vide letter dated 30.06.2022, communicated to the Deputy Secretary, TSLSA,
regarding MR bill and TA bill amounting to Rs.2,39,753/- & Rs.10,796/submitted by the petitioner. From that letter, it is found that the matter
regarding sanctioning of MR Bills submitted by the petitioner was submitted
to the Finance Department, Government of Tripura for their concurrence, and
in turn, the Finance Department has regretted the proposal as TSLSA is not a
department under the State Government. The petitioner had been eagerly
waiting for sanction and release of MR bills amounting to Rs.2,39,753/-. But
the petitioner had not been informed about the status of her MR bills. In view
of that, the petitioner by submitting a letter dated 28.07.2022 approached
the Member Secretary, Tripura State Legal Services Authority, through proper
channel. By that application, the petitioner has stated that she has submitted
medical bills in connection with expenditure incurred by her for her treatment
at Medica Super Specialty Hospital, Kolkata, Mukundapur. The petitioner has
further stated that she has been informed that the matter had been sent to
the Hon’ble LR & Secretary, Law, Government of Tripura, Agartala, for
consideration, but is unaware of any decision taken in this regard. For this
reason, the petitioner requested to the Member Secretary, to inform the
status of her application dated 20.12.2021.
9.
It appears that the D.L.R. and Deputy Secretary, Law,
Government of Tripura vide letter dated 07.09.2022 informed the Member
Secretary, TSLSA, that Finance Department has declined to give concurrence
for sanctioning of MR & TA Bills submitted by Smt. Rama Chakraborty, i.e.,
the petitioner herein. The Deputy Secretary, TSLSA, vide letter dated
20.09.2022 informed the petitioner that the Finance Department has held
that the petitioner is not entitled to MR Bills and along with letter, the letters
of Law Department, conveying the messages of Finance Department, were
also enclosed.
10.
Rule 14(i) of the said Rules of 2012 makes it clear and without
any ambiguity or doubt, that, pay and allowances of the petitioner would be
like that of the employees of the State Government. Rule 14(ii) has
specifically provided that, in all matters like age of retirement, pension,
Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity, pay and allowances, leave, other benefits
and entitlements, the officers and other employees covered by the Rules,
2012 shall be governed by the State Government rules as are applicable to
persons holding equivalent posts. Rule 14(iii) makes it very clear that, the
officers and other employees, covered by the Rules of 2012 shall be entitled
to such other facilities, allowances and benefits as may be notified by the
State Government, from time to time.
11.
The Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 was enacted to
constitute legal services authorities to provide free and competent legal
services to the weaker section of the society to ensure that opportunities for
securing justice are not denied to any citizen by reason of economic or other
disabilities, and to organize Lok Adalats to secure that the operation of the
legal system promotes justice on a basis of equal opportunity.
12.
It is the mandate of Section 6 of the Act, 1987 that every State
Government shall constitute a Legal Services Authority for the State to
exercise the powers and perform the functions conferred on a State Authority
under the Act, 1987. The State Authority shall consist of the Hon’ble Chief
Justice of the High Court who will be the Chairman of the State Authority, or
any other serving or retired Judge of the High Court to be nominated by the
Governor in consultation with the Chief Justice, and as such, other members
possessing such experience and qualifications as may be prescribed and
nominated by the State Government. As such, the Tripura State Legal
Services Authority has been constituted by the Government of Tripura as per
the mandate of Section 6 of the Act, 1987, and the petitioner being an
employee of the Tripura State Legal Services Authority, under the Tripura
State Legal Services Authority (Conditions of Services and the Salary and
Allowances of the Officers and other Employees) Rules, 2012, is an employee
of the Government of Tripura, and is entitled to Medical Reimbursement
which is admissible to similarly situated employees of the State Government.
13.
The Joint Secretary to the Government of Tripura in the
Finance Department issued Memo dated 09.08.2005, the subject matter of
the said memo is medical reimbursement facility to Group-C & Group-D
Government employees for treatment as referred case outside the State and
also for treatment of Cancer in the Cancer Hospital of the State. By the said
memorandum, clarification has been given to the effect, that, when a GroupC or Group-D Government employee, himself or herself suffering from
disease other than cancer, is referred to Medical Institution or Hospital to
which he or she is referred to the cost of treatment in that Institution or
Hospital excluding the cost of journey, is admissible for reimbursement. The
said memorandum also provides that the reimbursement facility for
implanting of pacemaker as provided in Memo dated 26.02.1996 and Memo
dated 24.05.1997 for Group-C and Group-D employees shall continue to be
admissible, subject to limit fixed therein. The memorandum dated 01.08.2007
issued by the Under Secretary to the Government of Tripura in the Finance
Department, it has been clarified that whenever a Group-C or Group-D
employee, duly referred by the Standing Medical Board to a particular
institution for medical treatment undertakes the medical treatment at some
other institution of his or her own volition, he or she shall be entitled to get
medical reimbursement which shall be limited to the treatment cost at the
rates of the referred medical institutions or hospitals including journey
expenses.
14.
According to the petitioner, Right to Life is a fundamental right
of every Indian citizen as enshrined under Article 21 of the Indian
Constitution. It is an obligation cast on the State to provide adequate medical
service to the people under Article 47 of the Constitution of India. According
to the petitioner, the respondents have illegally regretted the MR Bills for
Rs.2,39,753/- submitted by the petitioner, being oblivious of the fact, that,
the Tripura State Legal Services Authority has been constituted as per the
mandate of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, and so far as conditions
of services & pay and allowances of the petitioner is concerned, the
petitioner, being an employee of TSLSA, is at par with her counterparts in
other Departments of the State Government.
15.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties this
court is of the considered opinion that the petitioner is entitled to medical
reimbursement benefits as according to this Court The L.R. & Secretary, Law,
Government of Tripura vide notification dated 12.12.2012 conveyed to all
concerned, that in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 28(2) of the
Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 read with Rules 9, 12(1), 14 & 17 of
Tripura State Legal Services Authorities Rules, 1998, the State Government,
in consultation with the Chief Justice of the Gauhati High Court, has made
the Tripura State Legal Services Authority (Conditions of Services and the
Salary and Allowances of the Officers and other Employees) Rules, 2012, to
regulate the method of recruitment and prescribe the salary and allowances
and other conditions of service of the officers and other employees of the
Tripura State Legal Services Authority, High Court Legal Services Committee,
District Legal Services Authorities and the Sub-Divisional Legal Services
Committees. The said notification was published in Tripura Gazette Extra
ordinary issue dated 13.12.2012.
16.
Rule 14 of the Tripura State Legal Services Authority
(Conditions of Services and the Salary and Allowances of the Officers and
other Employees) Rules, 2012 provides Conditions of service and the Salary
and Allowances of Officers and other Employees, in the following manner :
“i) The officers and other employees shall be entitled to draw
pay and allowances in the scale of pay at par with the State
Government employees holding equivalent posts;
ii) In all matters like age of retirement, pension, Death-cumRetirement Gratuity, pay and allowances, leave, other benefits
and entitlements the officers and other employees shall be
governed by the State Government rules as are applicable to
persons holding equivalent posts.
iii) The officers and other employees shall be entitled to such
other facilities, allowances and benefits as may be notified by
the State Government, from time to time.”
17.
Moreover, in terms of Memo, dated 09.08.2005, issued by the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura, Smt. Rama Chakraborty, Head
Clerk, being a Group-C employee, is entitled to get Medical Reimbursement
facility. It is further stated that in the said notification dated 08.05.2018,
issued by the Government of Tripura it is mentioned that entitlement of
medical allowance shall depend on the erstwhile Grade Pay or Level of Pay
matrix applicable to the post in which the concerned Government employee
has been appointed substantially. Stating so, by that letter, the Deputy
Secretary, TSLSA, sought for clarification regarding admissibility of MR Bills
submitted by
the
petitioner. The
petitioner is entitled to medical
reimbursement. As such, the employees of State Legal Services is also part
and parcel of the said reimbursement benefits. The respondents are directed
to consider the
case
of
the
petitioner for
releasing
the
medical
reimbursement as early as possible, preferably within a period of two months
from today.
Having observed thus, the writ petition is allowed and disposed
of.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review