Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL (AGAINST ACQUITTAL) NO. 1861 of 2026
==========================================================
RAJNIKANT DAHABHAI PATEL POA HOLDER JATIN H . PATEL
Versus
HARISHBHAI MAGANLAL HUDLANI & ANR.
==========================================================
Appearance:
NIMIT Y SHUKLA(8338) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
MS JIRGA JHAVERI ADDITIONAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR for the
Opponent(s)/Respondent(s) No. 2
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT M.
PRACHCHHAK
Date : 08/09/2026
ORAL ORDER
1.
The appellant – original complainant has preferred this appeal
against the judgment and order dated 04.03.2025 passed by the
learned 9th Additional Sessions Judge, Vadodara (hereinafter be
referred to as “the appellate Court”) in Criminal Appeal No.440 of
2022 whereby, the appellate Court has allowed the appeal and set
aside the order of conviction passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Vadodara (hereinafter referred to as “the trial Court”) in
Criminal Case no. 13925 of 2019 dated 01.12.2022.
2.
Brief facts giving rise to the present appeal are that the
complainant is the sole and absolute owner and possessor of
immovable property situated at 45, Cractors Park Society, Abhilasha
Char Rasta, Nizampura, Vadodara, registered with Sub-Registrar
Vadodara. That, the said property, specifically two rooms along with a
bathroom and toilet on the ground floor, was let out to the accused
under a rent agreement for a period of 11 months starting from
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
01/01/2013 to 30/11/2013, at a monthly rent of Rs. 5,000/-. That, the
rent agreement was executed on 31/01/2013 and was notarized on
02/02/2013, Registration No. 3208. Both parties accepted and agreed
to the terms and conditions of the said agreement. That, as per the
agreement, upon expiration on 30/11/2013, the accused was required
to vacate and hand over the possession of the rented premises to the
complainant without dispute. The premises were rented solely for
business purposes under the trade name "Bhavya Collection." That,
despite the expiration of the rent agreement, the accused illegally
retained possession of the premises and also defaulted in payment of
rent. That, the accused neither renewed the agreement nor paid the
agreed monthly rent of Rs. 5,000/- for the period thereafter. That, the
net payable by the accused stands at Rs. 3,72,760/-. That, upon
repeated demands, the accused issued a cheque bearing No. 000139
dated 14/12/2018 for Rs. 2,50,000/- drawn on UCO Bank, Uma Co-op
Branch, in favor of the complainant. The cheque was presented on
22/01/2019 in Bank of India, Fatehgunj Branch, Account No.
250510100015729. That, the said cheque was dishonored and
returned with a return memo dated 22/01/2019 citing the reason
"Stop Payment." That, upon dishonor, the accused failed to provide
any explanation or repayment. Therefore, a legal notice dated
20/02/2019 was issued which was received by the accused on
21/02/2019. That, despite receiving the notice, the accused has
neither made payment of the cheque amount nor replied to the
notice.
2.1
That, the appellant had filed an application under section 138 of
the Negotiable Instruments Act (hereinafter be referred to as “NI
Act”), 1881, before J.M.F.C., Vadodara, which was registered as
Criminal Case No. 13925 of 2019 whereby, the respondent was
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
convicted for the aforesaid offence vide judgment and order dated
01.12.2022 wherein the trial court has passed order awarding simple
imprisonment of 1 year along with the penalty of amount of
Rs.5,00,000/-
to
be
given
to
the
complainant/appellant
as
compensation and in default of the payment, further imprisonment of
two months to be followed. That, being aggrieved with the above
judgment and order, the respondent preferred an appeal before the
concerned appellate court being Criminal Appeal no. 440 of 2022
which came to be allowed and the conviction passed in Criminal Case
no. 13925 of 2019 was set aside vide judgment and order dated
04.03.2025.
3.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the aforesaid judgment
and order dated 04.03.2025, the appellant – original complainant has
preferred this appeal.
4.
Heard Mr. Nimit Shukla, learned counsel for the appellant at
length.
5.
Mr. Shukla, learned counsel has submitted that the appellate
Court has committed serious error of law and facts while reversing the
judgment of the JMFC, Vadodara whereby the respondent – accused
was ordered to be convicted for offence punishable under Section 138
of the NI Act. He has submitted that the appellate Court has erred in
allowing the evidence and arguments regarding a supposed property
sale which were neither part of the original pleadings nor supported
by admissible documents, thus causing prejudice to the complainant.
He has submitted that the appellate Court failed to appreciate the fact
that the claim of the accused that the cheque was part of a property
deal, while also asserting it was not meant to be presented, is
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
inherently contradictory which should have rendered the defence
unreliable. He has submitted that the appellate Court has erred in not
considering that “Stop Payment” instructions do not constitute a valid
defence under section 138 of the NI Act. Over and above the
contentions raised in the memo of appeal, learned counsel has urged
that the present appeal deserves to be allowed and the impugned
judgment and order recorded by the appellate Court deserves to be
quashed and set aside and the order of conviction and sentence
imposed by the JMFC be restored in the interest of justice.
6.
I have heard the learned counsel for the appellant and perused
the materials available on record. Mr. Shukla, learned counsel has
submitted a copy of the paper book of the concerned Court. Upon
perusal of the deposition of the complainant, certain material facts
emerge. The appellant had issued a legal notice to the respondent at
Exhibit 39, which was replied to by the accused. It appears that
another notice had also been issued, which was likewise replied to by
the respondent wherein the details regarding the property, which was
agreed to be sold to the respondent by the original owner for a
consideration of Rs.54,00,000/-, were specifically referred to. The
present complaint was lodged by the appellant in his capacity as the
power-of-attorney holder of the original owner of the property. It
appears
that
the
respondent
had
already
paid
more
than
Rs.20,00,000/- towards the sale consideration; however, since there
was a dispute regarding the documents of the property, which were
not supplied to the respondent and which were required by him for
obtaining a bank loan, the respondent instructed his bank to stop
payment of the disputed cheque and on the basis of that the present
proceedings came to be initiated by the complainant. It appears that
during his cross-examination, the complainant admitted before the
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
concerned Court that the aforesaid facts were not mentioned in the
notice issued by the complainant. Upon perusal of the evidence
produced by the appellant, the relevant portion of the crossexamination of the complainant is reproduced hereinbelow:
“It is true that the complaint which was instituted by me has
been instituted by me on the basis of the Power Of Attorney Deed. It
is true that the deeds and the transactions pertaining to the property
had been executed between the accused Harish and Rajnikantbhai. It
is not true that I do not have any direct information about the
translations. It is true that prior to the complaint, the accused had
been served a notice on 13/11/2018 through Advocate Shri Yogesh I.
Rana. It is true that a copy thereof is not produced in the case on
hand. I am willing to produce the notice. It is true that, there is no
mention about the notice either in the complaint or in the affidavit
qua the Examination-in-Chief. It is true that the accused had given
me a reply of the notice on 17/12/2018. It is true that a copy of the
reply given by the accused is not produced in the present case,
however, I am willing to produce the same. It is true that I have not
stated about the aforesaid reply in my complaint or the affidavit of
the Examination-in-Chief. It is true that in the aforesaid reply, the
accused has denied all the facts stated by us in the notice. It is true
that, thereafter, we had sent other two notices to the accused on
18/02/2019. It is true that I have produced in the present case only
one notice, out of the aforesaid two notices. I am willing to produce
the second notice. The notices which had been served were
regarding the cheque return and vacating of the premises. It is true
that in both the notices, I have demanded the amount of the
dishonored cheque.
It is true that I have not stated, in the complaint or in the
affidavit for the Examination-in-Chief, as to when did the accused
give me the cheque complained of. I am shown the cheque produced
at Exhibit 11. After examining the same, I state that the cheque is
dated 14/12/2018. It is true that I had deposited the cheque into my
bank account on 21/01/2019. It is not true that the accused had
clearly communicated to us in the notice that the cheque ought not
to be deposited. It is true that, in the Bank-Return Memo produced by
we the Complainant, the reason for dishonoring of cheque is stated
as “payment stopped by drawer”. The complained cheque has been
deposited in the account of the original complainant, i.e.
Rajnikantbhai. I am willing to produce last four years’ Bank
Statement of the account.
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
It is true that the due amount stated in the complaint has
been stated by me, in my complaint as well as the affidavit qua the
Examination-in-chief, as the outstanding dues towards the rent of the
property. It is true that there is no outstanding rent amount due to
the accused. It is true that it was agreed, on 11/01/2018, to convey
the rented part of the property to the accused on selling basis
against the consideration of Rs. 54 Lakh. It is true that the original
complainant and the owner of the property, i.e. Ranjnikantbhai, had
executed an informal agreement in writing in favor of the accused on
11/01/2018, for conveyance of the property on selling basis against
the consideration of Rs. 54 Lakhs in my presence. The witness states
voluntarily that merely the price was agreed at Rs. 54 lakhs and the
same was communicated to me through a WhatsApp message. I am
willing to state the mobile (WhatsApp) number of the original
complainant before the Hon’ble Court. It is +0018173077650. After
the selling price was agreed, the accused has rendered to the
complainant about Rs. 17 Lakhs, till date. It is true that the above
stated amount of Rs. 17 lakhs is still with we the Complainant.
At this stage, pursuant to an Adjournment Application by the
Ld. Advocate for the accused, further cross examination has
been adjourned.
It is true that the Bank Statement produced by me at Exhibit
40 is the Bank Account Statement of the original complainant
Rajnikant Dahyabhai Patel. It is true that there are seven entries
pertaining to deposit of Rs. 9300/- by the accused towards the
monthly rent. The entries are dated from 16/06/2017 to 21/12/2017.
It is true that it was agreed to convey the rented premises on selling
basis against the consideration of Rupees fifty four lakhs. It is true
that a deed for conveyance was executed on a paper and its copy
was sent to me through a WhatsApp message. I am shown Mark
41/1. After examining the same, I state that it is a copy of whatsapp
chat containing the deed executed by the complainant. It is true that
the complainant used to send the acknowledgments from time to
time from U.S.A. of receiving monies as and when the amounts were
remitted by the accused in parts. I am shown the WhatsApp text of
Mark 41/1. The facts stated therein are true. It is true that in each of
the pages of the document in the WhatsApp Chat shown at Mark
41/1, it is stated at the top of the pages that ‘Rent amount Rs. 9300/is pending for the month January 2018’. It is true that, in the
WhatsApp chat produced at Mark 41/1, it is not mentioned that any
rent prior to January 2018 was due. It is true that the accused has
rendered, till date, Rupees twenty lakh and twenty two thousand to
the complainant towards consideration of the property and the same
amount is with the complainant even as on today. I am shown Mark
41/2. It is the Bank Account Statement of the Accused, wherein the
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
sums of Rs. 9300/- are seen as deposited to the complainant’s
account. As Mark-41/1 and 41/2 have been referred to during the
Cross Examination and the same have been admitted by the witness,
both the documents are assigned Exhibit 42 and 43, respectively.
The notice produced at Exhibit 37 is the notice sent on 04/11/2018. It
is true that, at Para-4 of Exhibit 37, it has been stated that, until a
Sale Deed of the property is executed, you the accused have agreed
to take the property from our client on rental basis against the rent
of Rs. 10230/-, starting from January 2018. It is true that, even in the
stated notice, it is not mentioned that any rent amount pertaining to
a period prior than January 2018 is due. It is true that it has been
stated, in the complaint as well as in the deposition, that the accused
has not paid any rent for a period from 01/01/2013 to 31/12/2018. It
is true that in my complaint, the rent amount, as shown credited in
the Bank Account Statement produced at Exhibit 40, have not been
stated as having been credited. It is true that, in our complaint, it has
been stated that the accused ceased to be our tenant as per law on
expiry of the Rent Agreement on 30/11/2013. It is true that the
accused used to remit the rent amount to us even in cash. It is not
true that the complained cheque was given by the accused to us as a
part of sell-consideration. It is not true that, as the accused wanted
to avail a loan from a bank for paying the remaining consideration
amount, he had demanded the legal documents of the shop from us.
However, it is true that the accused had asked for the legal
documents of the shop. It is true that we the complainant have not
given the legal documents of the shop to the accused before
instituting the present complaint. It is not true that as we had not
given the accused the documents of shop, the accused had stopped
honoring of the complained cheque. It is true that before the cheque
complained of was deposited in the bank, the accused had given a
reply as well as a cross-notice, through his advocate on 17/12/2018,
wherein the accused had stated that, “please give me the legal
documents of the property so that I can avail a loan from the bank
and remit the remaining consideration amount.” It is not true that,
though there was no outstanding rent amount, the cheque which was
given for the purpose of sell-consideration was misused to institute
the present complaint which is wrongful and illegal.
Cross Examination over.”
7.
Considering all the aforesaid facts and circumstances, it is
evident that the present appellant has failed to establish the
existence of any legal enforceable debt insofar as the alleged rent is
concerned. It appears that the original complainant, in the Whatsapp
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
chat produced before the concerned Court, has admitted the relevant
facts. A copy of the said Whatsapp chat was produced before the
concerned Court, from which it is revealed that no rent was due and
payable by the respondent prior to the year 2018 and thus, the
defence was raised by the respondent that the cheque was issued
towards the sale consideration of the property. The respondent has
specifically contended that since the documents relating to the
property were not supplied to him, he was unable to obtain finance
from the bank for purchasing the said property and to pay the
remaining amount of the sale consideration. It appears that all these
facts were not stated by the complainant in his notice and the same is
admitted by the complainant in his cross-examination. These facts
and circumstances clearly show that the appellant has failed to
establish any legal enforceable debt as alleged against the
respondent.
8.
After considering all these facts, the appellate Court, in
paragraphs 11, 12, 13 and 14 of its judgment, has recorded its
findings and recorded its conclusions in paragraphs 16 and 17 and
passed the impugned order. I am in complete agreement with the
findings recorded by the appellate Court, which reversed the
judgment of the trial Court convicting the respondent. In view of the
above, I am of the opinion that the appellate Court has not committed
any error of facts and law in passing the impugned judgment and
order and there is no any illegality and infirmity found in the judgment
and order.
9.
It is well settled by catena of decisions that the an Appellate
Court has full power to review, re-appreciate and reconsider the
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
evidence upon which the order of acquittal is founded. However,
Appellate Court must bear in mind that in case of acquittal there is
double presumption in favour of the accused. Firstly, the presumption
of innocence is available to him under the fundamental principle of
criminal jurisprudence that every person shall be presumed to be
innocent unless he is proved guilty by a competent Court of law.
Secondly, the accused having secured his acquittal, the presumption
of their innocence is further reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened
by the trial Court.
10.
Further, if two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis
of the evidence on record, the Appellate Court should not disturb the
finding of acquittal recorded by the trial Court. Further, while
exercising the powers in appeal against the order of acquittal, the
Court of appeal would not ordinarily interfere with the order of
acquittal unless the approach of the lower Court is vitiated by some
manifest illegality and the conclusion arrived at would not be arrived
at by any reasonable person and, therefore, the decision is to be
characterized as perverse. Merely because two views are possible, the
Court of appeal would not take the view which would upset the
judgment delivered by the Court below. However, the Appellate Court
has a power to review the evidence if it is of the view that the
conclusion arrived at by the Court below is perverse and the Court has
committed a manifest error of law and ignored the material evidence
on record. A duty is cast upon the Appellate Court, in such
circumstances, to re-appreciate the evidence to arrive to a just
decision on the basis of material placed on record to find out whether
the accused are connected with the commission of the crime with
which they are charged.
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
11.
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
The scope and principles are enunciated by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in case of Chandrappa and others Vs. State of Karnataka
reported in (2007) 4 SCC 415, more particularly paragraph Nos.
42 and 43, which was subsequently re-affirmed by the Hon’ble Apex
Court Rajesh Prasad Vs. State of Bihar and another, reported in
[2022] 3 SCC 471, wherein, the Hon’ble Apex Court has enunciated
the general principles in case of acquittal, more particularly in
paragraph No. 26 the general principles are set out by the Hon’ble
Apex Court based upon various decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court.
Then in case of Babu Sahebagouda Rudragoudar Vs. State of
Karnataka, reported in AIR 2024 SC 2252 = (2024) 8 SCC 149,
the Hon'ble Apex Court has dealt with the similar issue, more
particularly, in paragraph Nos. 37 to 40. Hence, I am in complete
agreement with the findings recorded by the trial Court.
12.
It is also worthwhile to refer to the recent decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ramesh vs. State of
Karnataka, reported in [2024] 9 SCC 169, wherein the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held and observed in paras-20 and 21 as under:“20. At this stage, it would be relevant to refer to the
general principles culled out by this Court in Chandrappa
and others vs. State of Karnataka , regarding the power of
the appellate Court while dealing with an appeal against a
judgment of acquittal. The principles read thus:
“42. …. (1) An appellate court has full power to review,
reappreciate and reconsider the evidence upon which the
order of acquittal is founded.
(2) The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 puts no
limitation, restriction or condition on exercise of such
power and an appellate court on the evidence before it
may reach its own conclusion, both on questions of fact
and of law.
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
(3) Various expressions, such as, “substantial and
compelling reasons”, “good and sufficient grounds”, “very
strong circumstances”, “distorted conclusions”, “glaring
mistakes”, etc. are not intended to curtail extensive
powers of an appellate court in an appeal against acquittal.
Such phraseologies are more in the nature of “flourishes of
language” to emphasize the reluctance of an appellate
court to interfere with acquittal than to curtail the power of
the court to review the evidence and to come to its own
conclusion.
(4) An appellate court, however, must bear in mind that in
case of acquittal, there is double presumption in favour of
the accused. Firstly, the presumption of innocence is
available to him under the fundamental principle of
criminal jurisprudence that every person shall be
presumed to be innocent unless he is proved guilty by a
competent court of law. Secondly, the accused having
secured his acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is
further reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial
court.
(5) If two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis
of the evidence on record, the appellate court should not
disturb the finding of acquittal recorded by the trial court.
21. In Rajendra Prasad v. State of Bihar, a three-Judge
Bench of this Court pointed out that it would be essential
for the High Court, in an appeal against acquittal, to clearly
indicate firm and weighty grounds from the record for
discarding the reasons of the Trial Court in order to be able
to reach a contrary conclusion of guilt of the accused. It
was further observed that, in an appeal against acquittal, it
would not be legally sufficient for the High Court to take a
contrary view about the credibility of witnesses and it is
absolutely imperative that the High Court convincingly
finds it well-nigh impossible for the Trial Court to reject
their testimony. This was identified as the quintessence of
the jurisprudential aspect of criminal justice. Viewed in this
light, the brusque approach of the High Court in dealing
with the appeal, resulting in the conviction of Appellant
Nos. 1 and 2, reversing the cogent and well-considered
judgment of acquittal by the Trial Court giving them the
benefit of doubt, cannot be sustained.”
R/CR.A/1861/2026(GJHC240345672026)
13.
ORDER DATED: 08/09/2026
Considering the entire evidence on record, it clearly appears
that there is no credible evidence to connect the present accused with
the alleged crime and the evidence on record is not so convincing to
prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused has committed the
alleged crime. Therefore, the accused cannot be convicted on the
evidence on record.
14.
On perusal of the impugned judgment and order, it clearly
transpires that the appellate Court has not committed any error of
fact and law in appreciating the evidence on record and in acquitting
the accused from the charges levelled against him. Even on reappreciation of the evidence, it clearly transpires that the prosecution
has miserably failed to prove the charge levelled against the accused
beyond reasonable doubt. Therefore, the impugned judgment and
order of the appellate Court is sustainable and the present appeal is
liable to be dismissed.
15.
In view of the above, the present appeal is devoid of merits and
it deserves to be dismissed. Resultantly, it is dismissed. The impugned
judgment and order of acquittal passed by the appellate Court is
hereby
confirmed.
Bail
bond
stands
cancelled.
Record
and
proceedings, if any, be sent back to the concerned Court forthwith.
(HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK,J)
ANUSRI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review