Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE RAVI MALIMATH,
CHIEF JUSTICE
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA
ON THE 29th OF JANUARY, 2024
FIRST APPEAL No. 1009 of 2010
BETWEEN:1.
RAJKUMAR S/O MANGILAL, AGED ABOUT 55
YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS, R/O PETLAWAD
DISTT. JHABUA (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
DILEEP KUMAR S/O BAPULAL PALRECHA, AGED
ABOUT 43 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS R/O
PETLAWAD
DISTRICT
JHABUA
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
3.
VIJAY KUMAR S/O BASANTILAL CHANODIA,
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS,
R/O PETLAWAD, (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
NARENDRA KUMAR S/O BAPULALJI PALRECHA,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
BUSINESS, R/O PETLAWAD DISTRICT JHABUA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(BY SHRI YASHPAL RATHORE - ADVOCATE)
AND
Signed by: MUKTA
CHANDRASHEKHAR KOUSHAL
Signing time: 1/31/2024 6:34:23
PM
1.
PREMIER NUTRISONS, PROPRIETOR PREMIER
INDUSTRIES INDIA LTD. REGISTERED OFFICE
45/47, INDUSTRIAL AREA NO.1 AB ROAD DEWAS'S
CHAIRMAN RAJESH AGRAWAL THROUGH
POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER, GURU PRASAD
S/O BHANWARLAL ARORA, AGE 50 YEARS,
ADDRESS SUBHASH MARG, THANDLA DISTRICT
JHABUA (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SMT. CHANDRAKANTA W/O SURESH KUMAR
NIMJA JAIN, AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
HOUSEHOLD
(MADHYA PRADESH)
PETLAWAD
3.
SURESH KUMAR S/O BAPULALJI NIMJA, AGED
ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS, R/O
PETLAWAD
DISTRICT
JHABUA
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
4.
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
COLLECTOR, DISTRICT JHABUA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI RISHI AGRAWAL - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NOS.2 & 3)
This Appeal coming on for orders this day. Hon'ble Shri Justice Vijay
Kumar Shukla passed the following:
JUDGMENT
With the consent of parties, heard finally.
Facts of the case are that plaintiffs/appellants filed a suit for specific
performance of contract dated 1.1.2002 for sale of agricultural land Khasra No.
2185/3 Area 0.21 Aara for a consideration of Rs.3,00,000/-. Rs.50,000/- was
paid through 4 cheques on 1.1.2002 and further Rs.20,000/- was paid in cash
on 1.12.2004. Cause of action to file the suit arose when respondent No.1 sold
the suit land to respondent Nos.2 and 3 vide registered sale deed dated
30.08.2006 for Rs.95,000/- without getting the agreement with the appellants
cancelled and on very much less price in comparison to the price proposed by
the appellants. Plaintiffs further claimed the relief of declaring the sale deed null
and void executed by defendant No.1 in favour of defendant No.2 and 3.
Defendant Nos.1 and 4 were ex-parte. Defendant Nos.2 and 3 denied the plaint
allegations and submitted that they were not aware of the agreement. The suit is
time barred.
2.
Signed by: MUKTA
CHANDRASHEKHAR KOUSHAL
Signing time: 1/31/2024 6:34:23
PM
After appreciating the evidence adduced by the parties, the trial court by
the impugned judgment and decree partly allowed the suit for specific
performance, however directed for refund of amount of Rs.70,000/- from
defendant No.1. Out of Rs.70,000/-, Rs. 50,000/- shall carry interest @ 6% per
annum w.e.f. 1.1.2002 and the remaining Rs.20,000/- shall carry 6% annual
interest from 1.12.2004 till the payment is made.
3.
Counsel for the appellants submits that the trial court has erred while not
granting the decree of specific performance of contract. It is argued that all the
issues have been decided in favour of appellants, despite that the trial court held
that appellants are not entitled for a decree of specific performance.
4.
Counsel for respondent Nos.2 and 3 submitted that respondent Nos.2
and 3 are bonafide purchasers, and therefore, the trial court has rightly
dismissed the suit for specific performance.
5.
After hearing learned counsels for the parties and upon perusal of the
agreement executed between the plaintiffs and defendant No.1, it is evident that
in the agreement, a condition was incorporated that there is an encroachment on
the land in question by the defendant No.3 and the matter is pending for
eviction before the Tahsildar against the defendant No.3 and if the defendant
No.1 gets possession of the said land, then decree shall be executed of the said
land in favour of plaintiffs on payment of remaining sale consideration. The
plaintiffs have further pleaded that defendant No.1 fraudulently sold the said
land in favour of respondent Nos.2 and 3 by registered sale deed dated
30.08.2006. From the Ex.P/16 it is evident that a notice was issued by the
defendant No.2 for sending copy of the agreement. From Ex.P/17 it is further
evident that the Chairman of Premier Nutrisons has also sent its reply to the
plaintiffs that he has not received copy of the agreement. Ex.P/18 is ordersheet
of revenue court-Tahsildar and in the ordersheet dated 16.8.2000 it is mentioned
Signed by: MUKTA
CHANDRASHEKHAR KOUSHAL
Signing time: 1/31/2024 6:34:23
PM
that possession of respondent No.3-Suresh Kumar has been found on the land.
In this regard, a demarcation report was also submitted by the order dated
18.2.2003. Nobody appeared on behalf of Guruprasad and the case before
Tahsildar was dismissed for want of prosecution. From the evidence of
plaintiffs, it transpires that they have failed to establish that they have been
vigilant to ascertain about the fulfillment of condition of agreement that the
encroachment by Suresh Kumar has been removed. Admittedly the condition of
agreement was that whenever the encroachment by defendant No.3 is removed
and possession is obtained by defendant No.1, then the sale deed shall be
executed by the respondent No.1 in favour of plaintiffs on payment of
remaining sale consideration. The revenue case of eviction against Suresh
Kumar
has already been rejected and therefore, condition of removal of
encroachment and handing over of vacant possession to defendant No.1 was
not fulfilled. For passing a decree for specific performance, the following
conditions are to be fulfilled as enumerated under section 16 of the Specific
Relief Act :
"Section 16 - Personal bars to relief - Specific
performance of a contract cannot be enforced in favour of
a person -
(a) who would not be entitled to recover compensation
for its breach; or
( b ) who has become incapable of performing, or
violates any essential term of the contract that on his
part remains to be performed, or acts in fraud of the
contract, or wilfully acts at variance with, or in
subversion of, the relation intended to be established
by the contract; or
(c) who fails to aver and prove that he has performed
or has always been ready and willing to perform the
Signed by: MUKTA
CHANDRASHEKHAR KOUSHAL
Signing time: 1/31/2024 6:34:23
PM
essential terms of the contract which are to be
performed by him, other than terms the performance
of which has been prevented or waived by the
defendant.
Explanation - For the purpose of clause (c)(i) where a contract involves the payment of money, it
is not essential for the plaintiff to actually tender to
the defendant or to deposit in Court any money except
when so directed by the Court;
(ii) the plaintiff must aver performance of, or
readiness and willingness to perform, the contract
according to its true construction."
6.
The words readiness and willingness to perform the contract are essential
ingredients for passing a decree of specific performance of contract. In the case
o
f U.N.Krishnamurthy
(since
deceased)
through
L.Rs.
Vs.
A.M.Krishnamurthy reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 588 it has been held
that continuous readiness and willingness on the part of plaintiffs is a condition
precedent for grant of relief of specific performance. It is the bounden duty of
the plaintiff to prove his readiness and willingness by adducing evidence. In the
said case, the suit for specific performance was filed just before expiry of
period of limitation. The Court declined to grant equitable relief of specific
performance of immovable property on the ground that plaintiff was waiting for
expiry of period of limitation of 3 years. The three years' period is intended to
assist the purchaser in special cases, as for example where the major part of the
consideration has been paid to the vendor and possession has been delivered in
part performance, where equity shifts in favour of the purchaser. The Court
also referred the judgment passed in the case of Saradamani Kandappan Vs.
S.Rajalakshmi reported in (2011) 12 SCC 18. Thus, the words used in the
Signed by: MUKTA
CHANDRASHEKHAR KOUSHAL
Signing time: 1/31/2024 6:34:23
PM
aforesaid section, readiness and willingness includes vigilance on the part of
intended purchaser.
7.
In the present case after dismissal of case for eviction by the revenue
Court on 18.2.2003, the plaintiffs did not adduce any evidence that they had
taken steps to get evicted the defendant No.3, encroacher from the land in view
of condition of the agreement. There is explicit condition in the agreement that
the sale deed shall be executed in favour of the plaintiffs only in case the
encroachment from the land is removed and the possession is handed over to
the defendant No.1. Since the condition of agreement could not be complied
with,
therefore, the trial court has rightly rejected the suit for specific
performance. Jurisdiction to decree the suit for specific performance is
discretionary and Court is not bound to grant relief of specific performance
merely because it is lawful to do so, as held by the Apex Court in the case of
Jayakantham Vs. AbhayKumar reported in AIRONLINE 2017 SC 276.
Since payments by the plaintiffs were proved, the Court has rightly directed for
refund of the amount with interest. We do not find any illegality in the impugned
judgment and decree which is based on evaluation of entire facts and evidence.
8.
Accordingly, First Appeal is dismissed. No order as to costs.
(RAVI MALIMATH)
CHIEF JUSTICE
MK
Signed by: MUKTA
CHANDRASHEKHAR KOUSHAL
Signing time: 1/31/2024 6:34:23
PM
(VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review