Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 19th JUNE, 2017
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH : THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.02 of 2017
Appellants
:
1.
Smt. Rajiya Begum,
W/o Late Md. Mustaque @ Md. Mustak,
Aged about 21 years.
2.
Ms. Muskan Begam,
D/o Late Md. Mustaque @ Md. Mustak,
Aged about 2 years.
Both residents of
Village : Binnabari,
Chitalaghata, Chopra,
P.O. Sonapurhat, P.S. Chopra,
District Uttar Dinajpur,
West Bengal – 733214.
Versus
Respondents
:
1.
The Branch Manager,
United India Insurance Company Limited,
Having its office at;
N.H. 10, Deorali Bazaar,
P.O. Tadong, P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim, PIN - 737102.
(Insurer of Bolero Pick-Up bearing
Registration No. SK-01-D-0274)
2.
Shri Sheikh Naseem,
S/o Shri S.K. Saffiullah,
Resident of Singtam,
P.O & P.S. Singtam,
East Sikkim.
(Insured/Owner of Bolero Pick-Up bearing
Registration No.SK-01-D-0274)
Appeal under Section 173 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Ajay Rathi and Pramit Chhetri, Advocates for the Appellants.
Mr. Dinesh Chauhan, Advocate for the Respondents No.1.
Mr. Ashok Pradhan, Advocate for the Respondent No.2.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East
Sikkim at Gangtok (for short ―Learned Claims Tribunal‖), vide its
Judgment in MACT Case No.03 of 2016, dated 23.12.2016,
dismissed the Claim Petition of the Appellants/Claimants, seeking
compensation from the Respondents for a sum of Rs.8,38,300/(Rupees eight lakhs, thirty-eight thousand and three hundred)
only, on account of the death of one Mustaque, husband of
Appellant No.1 and father of Appellant No.2.
Aggrieved by the
impugned Judgment, this Appeal assails the finding therein.
2.
The Respondent No.1 was the Opposite Party No.1 and
the Respondent No.2, the Opposite Party No.2, before the learned
Tribunal.
3.
In Appeal, the main thrust of the argument of Learned
Counsel for the Appellant is that the Learned Claims Tribunal while
reaching a finding that the Appellants were not entitled to the
compensation so claimed, relied on the Autopsy Report of the
victim (Exhibit-7).
As per the Learned Claims Tribunal as the
victim‘s body had been recovered from the Mahananda Canal at
Phulbari, West Bengal on 22.7.2015 and the Doctor who conducted
the Autopsy had opined vide Exhibit-7 that the cause of death was
due to the effects of strangulation by ligature, ante mortem and
homicidal in nature, it was established that the death of the
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
deceased was not due to a motor accident, but homicidal
strangulation. It was also urged that the Learned Claims Tribunal
had pointed out that there was discrepancy with regard to Exhibit12, the Authorisation Letter issued to the driver. That, in fact the
vehicle
belonged
to
the
Respondent
No.2,
however,
the
Authorisation Letter that was filed before the Learned Claims
Tribunal pertained to another vehicle, but it is undisputed that the
deceased was the employee of Respondent No.2. It was canvassed
before this Court that the strict rules of evidence do not apply to a
Claim Petition under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short ―the
Act‖). To reinforce this submission, strength was drawn from the
decision in Bimla Devi and Others vs. Himachal Road Transport
Corporation and Others1.
That, it is indubitable that the driver was
driving the vehicle Mahindra Bolero Pickup, bearing Registration
No. SK-01-D-0274 which was duly insured with Respondent No.1
herein. Although the Police have concluded that the death of the
deceased was due to strangulation, undeniably the proximate
cause of the death was due to the fact that he was travelling in the
vehicle. To buttress his submissions, reliance was placed on Rita
Devi (Smt) and Others vs. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. and Another2.
On the ratiocination of Rita Devi2, the compensation ought to have
been granted to the Claimants, hence, the Judgment of the
Learned Claims Tribunal be set aside and compensation calculated
at Rs.8,38,300/- (Rupees eight lakhs, thirty-eight thousand and
three hundred) only, be granted to the Claimants/Appellants.
1.
2.
(2009) 13 SCC 530
(2000) 5 SCC 113
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
4.
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
Per contra, it was argued by Learned Counsel for the
Respondent No.1 that neither the body of the deceased nor the
vehicle in the alleged accident were recovered from the alleged
place of occurrence (for short ―P.O.‖). The body was recovered in
Phulbari, West Bengal, and the parts of the vehicle allegedly found
at the P.O. were not seized vide a Seizure Memo. The next doubt
raised was that no vegetables, allegedly a load of which was
carried in the vehicle, were recovered at the P.O. leading to an
inevitable conclusion that no accident had infact occurred and the
death was purely homicidal. Thus, there was no error or perversity
in the Judgment of the Learned Claims Tribunal which warranted
no interference.
5.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.2, submitted
that the Authorisation Letter filed was indeed a wrong copy but the
error is not material for the purposes of the case.The vehicle in
accident was insured and the deceased a licensed driver was
employed by him, therefore, the liability for compensation cannot
be foisted on him.
6.
I have heard the rival contentions of Learned Counsel
at length. I have also carefully perused the pleadings, documents
on record and the impugned Judgment.
7.
In order to appreciate the matter, it would be essential
to briefly visit the facts of the Appellants‘ case.
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
8.
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
On 21.7.2015, the deceased Late Mustaque, husband
of the Appellant No.1 and father of Appellant No.2, driver of the
Bolero Pick-Up vehicle, bearing No.SK-01-D-0274 was driving the
aforesaid vehicle from Siliguri (West Bengal) to Singtam (East
Sikkim) with miscellaneous goods and vegetables. The vehicle was
insured with the Respondent No.1 and belonged to Respondent
No.2. Enroute the vehicle went off the road at ―Bhotey Bhir‖ under
the jurisdiction of Rangpo Check-Post (West Bengal), pursuant to
which the vehicle and the deceased went missing. The Respondent
No.2
lodged
a
Missing
Report
at
the
said
Check-Post
on
21.07.2015, which was duly registered as G.D. Entry No.204/15.
On the next day, the body of the deceased was recovered from the
Mahananda Canal, Phulbari, West Bengal. Upon such recovery the
Phansidewa Police Station, West Bengal registered U.D. (Unnatural
Death) Case No. 48 of 2015 and forwarded the body to North
Bengal Medical College. Information of recovery of the body and
its location in the North Bengal Medical College was transmitted to
the Kalimpong Police Station. On 25.7.2015, the father of the
deceased identified the body as that of his son.
Likewise the
Appellant No.1 identified the body as that of her husband.
Subsequently, on 4.8.2015, the Respondent No.2, lodged an FIR
at Kalimpong Police Station, which was duly registered as
Kalimpong Police Station Case dated 04/08/2015, FIR No.263/
2015, U/s.279/304‗A‘ of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
9.
On account of the said death, the Appellant No.1, for
herself and on behalf of the minor Appellant No.2, filed a Petition
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
for
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
compensation
under
Section
163A
of
Act,
seeking
compensation of an amount of Rs.8,38,300/- (Rupees eight lakhs,
thirty-eight thousand and three hundred) only, with interest. The
Respondents in their averments before the Learned Claims
Tribunal had put forth the same submissions as made in this
Court.
10.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the
Learned Claims Tribunal settled a single Issue for adjudication,
i.e.,
“1. Whether the Claimants are entitled to the
compensation claimed? If so who is liable to
compensate them?”
11.
The Appellant No.1 examined herself as witness for
herself and Appellant No.2. The Respondent No.1/Insurance
Company did not examine any witness, while the Respondent
No.2/Sheikh Nassim/Owner of the vehicle examined himself as his
sole witness. On consideration of the evidence on record, the
Learned Claims Tribunal pronounced the impugned Judgment,
inter alia, declining the compensation, on the ground, that the
Appellants had failed to establish that the deceased had died due
to a motor accident as Exhibit-7 proved that the death was due to
homicidal strangulation.
12.
Now, the question that would arise for determination
before this Court is, Whether the cause of the victim‘s death
having been opined as homicidal would disentitle the Appellants
from being granted compensation under Section 163A of the Act?
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
13.
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
Firstly, we may walk through the relevant provision of
Law, Sub-Sections (1) and (2) of Section 163A of the Act provides
as follows;
“163A. Special
compensation
on
provisions
structured
as to payment of
formula
basis .—(1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in any
other law for the time being in force or instrument having
the force of laws, the owner of the motor vehicle or the
authorized insurer shall be liable to pay in the case of
death or permanent disablement due to accident arising
out of the use of motor vehicle, compensation, as
indicated in the Second Schedule, to the legal heirs or the
victim, as the case may be.
(2) In any claim for compensation under sub-section
(1), the claimant shall not be required to plead or
establish that the death of permanent disablement in
respect of which the claim has been made was due to any
wrongful act or neglect or default of the owner of the
vehicle or vehicles concerned or of any other person.
(3)
14.
………………………………………………………………...”
Sub-Sections (1) and (2) of Section 163A of the Act
extracted hereinabove indicate that a victim or his heirs are
entitled to Claim either from the owner or the Insurance Company,
compensation for death or permanent disablement suffered due to
accident, arising out of the use of the motor vehicle.
The Law
does not envisage proof of a wrongful act or negligence or default
of any one. It merely requires use of a motor vehicle, leading to
the death of the victim. On this count, it would be beneficial to
refer to the decision of Rita Devi2. In the said case, D was the
driver of an autorickshaw, owned by another person. The
autorickshaw was registered as a public carrier vehicle for hire by
the
passengers.
It
was
insured
with
the
respondent.
On
22.3.1995, some unknown persons hired the autorickshaw, but
subsequently
stole
it
and
killed
the
driver.
The
legal
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
representatives of the deceased driver filed Claim Petition under
Section 163A of the Act claiming damages for the death of
deceased caused during the course of his employment from the
owner of the said autorickshaw as the death was caused in an
accident arising out of the use of the motor vehicle. The Learned
Claims Tribunal allowed the Claim against the owner of the
autorickshaw and also fastened legal and statutory liability on the
insurer. The Insurer, Respondent, preferred an Appeal before the
High Court which allowed the Appeal on the ground that the case
was
one
of
murder
and
not
that
of
accident.
The
legal
representatives of the deceased, in Appeal, contended that the
murder of deceased squarely fell within the words “death due to
accident arising out of the use of motor vehicle” found in Section
163A(1) of the Act. That, in the absence of a definition of the word
‗accident‘ in motor vehicles Act which is beneficial legislation a
liberal interpretation should be given so as to achieve the object of
the act. It was further contended that the Appeal filed by the
insurer was not maintainable, no leave having been obtained from
the Tribunal as required under Section 170 of the Act. Per contra,
the Respondent Insurer contended that the meaning ascribed to
the word accident in the Workmen‘s Compensation Act by judicial
pronouncements could not be applied to the word accident in the
Motor Vehicles Act because the objects of the two Acts were
different. That, the death of the driver of the autorickshaw was
caused by felonious acts of certain unknown persons and not by an
accident arising out of the use of the vehicle and that the Insurer‘s
Appeal to the High Court was maintainable.
Rejecting the
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
Respondent‘s contentions and allowing the Appeal the hon‘ble
Supreme Court held, inter alia, as follows;
“14. Applying the principles laid down in the above
cases to the facts of the case in hand, we find that the
deceased, a driver of the autorickshaw, was dutybound to
have accepted the demand of fare-paying passengers to
transport them to the place of their destination. During
the course of this duty, if the passengers had decided to
commit an act of felony of stealing the autorickshaw and
in the course of achieving the said object of stealing the
autorickshaw, they had to eliminate the driver of the
autorickshaw then it cannot but be said that the death so
caused to the driver of the autorickshaw was an
accidental murder. The stealing of the autorickshaw was
the object of the felony and the murder that was caused
in the process of stealing the autorickshaw is only
incidental to the act of stealing of the autorickshaw.
Therefore, it has to be said that on the facts and
circumstances of this case, the death of the deceased
(Dashrath Singh) was caused accidently in the process of
committing theft of the autorickshaw.
…………………………………………………………………………
18. In the instant case, as we have noticed that
facts, we have no situation in coming to the conclusion
that the murder of the deceased (Dasarath Singh) was
due to an accident arising out of the use of motor vehicle.
Therefore, the trial court rightly came to the conclusion
that the court was wrong in coming to the conclusion that
the death of Dasarath Singh was not caused by an
accident involving the use of motor vehicle.”
15.
The facts of the case at hand appear to be identical to
the facts in Rita Devi2.
Admittedly, the deceased had a valid
Driving Licence and was the driver of the vehicle in accident, which
was duly insured with the Respondent No.1 and owned by
Respondent No.2. He was driving from Siliguri towards Sikkim
when the vehicle went off the road. No evidence was furnished to
the contrary by either of the Respondents. Thus, being the driver
of the vehicle, although the vehicle was not recovered, there is a
preponderance of probability that he was driving the vehicle at the
relevant time. His body, however, was recovered in Mahananda
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
Canal in Phulbari with a ligature mark on his neck.
It is not
necessary to delve into the details as to what caused the ligature.
Suffice it to say that assuming his death was homicidal it cannot
be disputed that the proximate cause of his death was the use of a
motor vehicle. As observed in Rita Devi2, in the case at hand also
the murder was incidental to the predominant object of stealing
arising out of the use of the vehicle by the driver. The evidence of
Respondent No.2 supports this assumption as he has deposed that
he came to learn from the Investigating Officer of the Kalimpong
Police Station that the victim was murdered by one Subba of
Kakarvitta in order to rob the vehicle.
16.
Hence, in the facts and circumstances as evident from
the aforesaid discussions and in keeping with the decision in Rita
Devi2,
I am of the considered opinion that the Learned Claims
Tribunal arrived at an erroneous finding by declining to grant the
compensation and the Claimants are entitled to compensation as
calculated hereinbelow which is found to be just.
17.
With regard to the Exhibit-12, the Authorisation Letter,
bearing vehicle No.SK-01-D1602 instead of SK-01-D-0274, no
serious arguments were forwarded by the Respondent No.1 and it
is admitted by Respondent No.2 that when the vehicle met with an
accident, the relevant documents were also swept away in the
vehicle. At the time of filing of documents before the Learned
Claims Tribunal, Exhibit-12 was erroneously inserted, but was
admitted in evidence. It may be stated here that a plethora of
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
judicial pronouncements have settled the position that when a
document is admitted in evidence at the stage of trial and not
objected therein, no objection can be raised at the Appellate stage.
This lends a quietus to the said issue. The other documents of the
vehicle are found to be in order and are not disputed.
18.
Hence, in conclusion, it is found that according to
Exhibit-10, the date of birth of the deceased is 1.1.1989, making
him 26 years old at the time of his accident. As per the evidence
of the owner, Respondent No.2, it is admitted that the deceased
was engaged by him for a monthly salary of Rs.3,325/- (Rupees
three thousand, three hundred and twenty-five) only. Hence, the
compensation is calculated as follows;
Monthly income of the deceased
Rs.
3,325.00
Annual Income of the deceased (Rs.3,325/- x 12 months)
Rs. 39,900.00
Multiplier of „18‟ has been adopted in terms of the
Second Schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
Rs.7,18,200.00
Less 1/3rd of Rs.7,18,200/-
Rs.2,39,400.00
[deducted from the said amount in consideration of
the instances which the victim would have incurred
towards maintenance, had he been alive]
Net yearly income
Rs.4,78,800.00
Add Funeral Expenses
Rs.
2,000.00
Add Loss of consortium
Rs.
5,000.00
Add Loss of estate
Total
=
Rs. 2,500.00
Rs.4,88,300.00
(Rupees four lakhs, eighty-eight thousand and three hundred) only.
19.
The Respondent No.1 is directed to pay the awarded
amount to the Appellants No.1 and 2 within one month from today
with interest @ 10% per annum, failing which he shall pay simple
MAC App No.02 of 2017
Smt. Razia Begum & Another
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited & Another
interest @ 12% per annum from the date of filing of the Claim
Petition till realisation.
The awarded amount of compensation shall be divided
20.
amongst the Appellants No.1 and 2, as follows;
(i)
50% of the total award to the Appellant No.1.
(ii)
50% of the total award to the Appellant No.2. Of the
said 50%, one-half shall be kept in a Fixed Deposit in a
Nationalised Bank until she attains the age of majority.
The remaining one-half shall be expended towards her
education and upkeep.
21.
Appeal allowed.
22.
Judgment of the Learned Claims Tribunal is set aside.
23.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Claims
Tribunal for information.
24.
Records of the Learned Claims Tribunal be transmitted
forthwith.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
19-06-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review