Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: LPASW No. 55/2016
CM No. 8047/2025
Reserved on: 21.04.2026
Pronounced on: 14.05.2026
Uploaded on: 14.05.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced : Full
Sh. Rajinder Singh,
aged 32 years, (Ex. Constable
No.913150549 of 102 Bn.,
RAF/CRPF, S/O Sh. Tarsem
Singh,
R/O
Gawar,
P.O.Pargwal, Tehsil Akhnoor,
District Jammu.
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through:
Mr. Navneet Dubey, Advocate
v/s
1. Home Secretary to Govt.
of India, Ministry of
Home Affairs, New
Delhi.
2. The Commandant 102
Bn. RAF/CRPF,
Bhuvneshwar-11, Orisa.
3. Mr. Avtar Singh, Asstt.
Commandant, (For
Commandant 102 Bn.
RAF/CRPF),
Bhuvneshwar-11, Orisa.
4. Dy. Inspector General of
Police, RAF/CRPF,
New Delhi.
5. Inspector General of
Police, Eastern Block
No.10, R.K.Puram,
New Delhi-66.
LPASW No. 55/2016
Through:
Mr. Vishal Sharma, Sr. Advocate (DSGI) with
M/s Karan Sharma & Eishaan Dadhichi, CGSC
CORAM: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
JUDGMENT
PER OSWAL-J
CM No. 8047/2025
1. This is an application seeking restoration of LPASW No.55/2016 to
its original number, which came to be dismissed for non-prosecution
on 27.11.2025.
2. For the reasons stated in the application, coupled with no objection
from the other side, the application is allowed. Consequently, LPASW
No. 55/2016 is restored to its original number. The application stands
disposed of.
3. Main appeal is re-admitted for hearing.
LPASW No. 55/2016
1. This intra court appeal is directed against the judgment dated
31.01.2014 rendered by the learned writ Court in SWP No. 349/2000,
titled “Rajinder Singh Vs. Home Secy. to Govt. of India and Others”,
whereby the writ petition preferred by the appellant challenging his
dismissal from service has been dismissed.
2. The judgment dated 31.01.2014 has been impugned by the appellant
on the following grounds :
(a) That under Section 11(1) of the CRPF Act, it is not open to the Commandant
to impose the major punishment of dismissal from service as the said
provision contemplates only the imposition of minor punishments;
LPASW No. 55/2016
(b) That the order of dismissal from the service of the appellant has been passed
by the incompetent authority;
(c) That the learned single Judge has failed to appreciate that no Prosecuting/
Presenting officer was appointed and the Enquiry Officer himself acted as
Prosecuting officer, as such, the judgment is not sustainable in the eyes of law.
(d) That the learned single Judge has also failed to appreciate that the punishment
of dismissal from service imposed upon the appellant is disproportionate to
the alleged misconduct, especially when another Constable, Rajinder Singh of
104 Bn, RAF, CRPF, who was involved in a similar act of misconduct, was let
off with only a warning.
6. Notwithstanding the grounds of challenge set out in the memorandum
of appeal, learned counsel for the appellant has confined the challenge
to the following limited grounds: first, that the learned Writ Court
failed to consider that no Presenting Officer was appointed during the
enquiry, resulting in the Enquiry Officer acting as the Prosecutor.
Second, it is contended that a co-accused, Constable No. 90099652
Rajinder Singh, who was allegedly involved in the same incident, was
merely issued a warning. In this regard, it is argued that pursuant to
Rule 27(d) of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955, a joint
enquiry should have been conducted. Finally, counsel urges that the
appellant was denied the opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses.
7. Mr. Vishal Sharma, learned DSGI, submitted that in the instant case,
due opportunity of cross-examination was afforded to the appellant,
and he, in fact, cross-examined witnesses during enquiry. He further
submitted that a joint enquiry was not required, as the allegations
against the appellant were distinct from those involving his colleague.
He has relied upon the judgment dated 22.08.2025 passed by this
Court in LPA No. 189/2023 titled “Gautam Ray Vs. Union of India
LPASW No. 55/2016
and others”, to contend that the non-appointment of a Presenting
Officer does not, ipso facto, cause prejudice to the appellant.
8. Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the
record.
9. Before evaluating the competing arguments, we briefly set out the
facts necessary to dispose of this appeal.
10.The appellant, who was serving as Constable in CRPF, went to the
Family Quarter of SI/GD Jagdish Singh on 31.05.1997 at about 2130
hours along with another Constable No. 90099652 Rajinder Singh.
After having consumed liquor, he misbehaved with SI/GD Jagdish
Singh at his quarter in Group Centre Campus, Bhuvneshwar, and on
01.06.1997, he was found absent from night duty as a Guard Marker
and when day SO/SI/GD O.S. George, and the day NCO HC. Jagdish
Parsad and RP NK M.N.Paniker went to the Barrack in search of the
appellant, he was found consuming liquor in the living Barrack
thereby violating the Camp standing orders. The appellant and his
colleague assaulted them. Accordingly, the appellant was placed
under suspension vide order dated 03.06.1997. Subsequently a
departmental enquiry was ordered against the appellant vide order
dated 04.06.1997 and Shri Bhagwant Singh, Assistant Commandant
was appointed as Enquiry Officer to enquire into the allegations
against the appellant. The Enquiry Officer, after the conclusion of the
enquiry against the appellant, submitted his report to the Commandant
102 Bn RAF, CRPF, who vide its order dated 17.11.1997 imposed the
penalty of “Dismissal from Service” with effect 17.11.1997 upon the
appellant and period of suspension w.e.f. 01.06.1997 to 17.11.1997
LPASW No. 55/2016
was directed to be treated “as such” without any additional
emoluments. The appellant assailed the order of his dismissal through
the medium of appeal before the appellate authority, i.e. Dy. Inspector
General of Police, RAF, CRPF, New Delhi, who vide its order dated
09.03.1998 rejected the same. The appellant thereafter filed a revision
petition that was also dismissed vide order dated 14.09.98.
9. The first contention of the appellant is that the enquiry stands
vitiated, as no Presenting Officer was appointed and the Enquiry
Officer himself acted as the Presenting Officer. In order to
appreciate this contention of the appellant, it is proper to take note of
the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
“Union of India vs. Ram Lakhan Sharma”, 2018(7) SCC 670,
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court quoted with approval the
principles culled out by the Division Bench of Madhya Pradesh High
Court while considering the issue of vitiation of enquiry when the
Enquiry Officer starts himself acting as Prosecutor. The relevant para
is extracted as under:
33. The Division Bench after elaborately considering the issue summarised the
principles in para 16 which is to the following effect:
“16. We may summarise the principles thus:
(i) The Enquiry Officer, who is in the position of a Judge shall not
act as a Presenting Officer, who is in the position of a prosecutor.
(ii) It is not necessary for the disciplinary authority to appoint a
Presenting Officer in each and every enquiry. Non-appointment
of a Presenting Officer, by itself will not vitiate the enquiry.
(iii) The Enquiry Officer, with a view to arrive at the truth or to
obtain clarifications, can put questions to the prosecution
witnesses as also the defence witnesses. In the absence of a
Presenting Officer, if the Enquiry Officer puts any questions to
the prosecution witnesses to elicit the facts, he should thereafter
permit the delinquent employee to cross-examine such witnesses
on those clarifications.
(iv) If the Enquiry Officer conducts a regular examination-in-chief
by leading the prosecution witnesses through the prosecution case,
LPASW No. 55/2016
or puts leading questions to the departmental witnesses pregnant
with answers, or cross-examines the defence witnesses or puts
suggestive questions to establish the prosecution case employee, the
Enquiry Officer acts as prosecutor thereby vitiating the enquiry.
(v) As absence of a Presenting Officer by itself will not vitiate the
enquiry and it is recognised that the Enquiry Officer can put
questions to any or all witnesses to elicit the truth, the question
whether an Enquiry Officer acted as a Presenting Officer, will have
to be decided with reference to the manner in which the evidence is
let in and recorded in the enquiry.
Whether an Enquiry Officer has merely acted only as an Enquiry Officer or has
also acted as a Presenting Officer depends on the facts of each case. To avoid any
allegations of bias and running the risk of enquiry being declared as illegal and
vitiated, the present trend appears to be to invariably appoint Presenting Officers,
except in simple cases. Be that as it may.”
34. We fully endorse the principles as enumerated above, however, the principles
have to be carefully applied in fact situation of a particular case. There is no
requirement of appointment of Presenting Officer in each and every case,
whether statutory rules enable the authorities to make an appointment or are
silent. When the statutory rules are silent with regard to the applicability of any
facet of principles of natural justice the applicability of principles of natural justice
which are not specifically excluded in the statutory scheme are not prohibited. When
there is no express exclusion of particular principle of natural justice, the said
principle shall be applicable in a given case to advance the cause of justice. ----xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
35. Thus, the question as to whether the Enquiry Officer who is supposed to act
independently in an inquiry has acted as prosecutor or not is a question of fact
which has to be decided on the facts and proceedings of a particular case. In the
present case we have noticed that the High Court had summoned the entire inquiry
proceedings and after perusing the proceedings the High Court came to the
conclusion that the Enquiry Officer himself led the examination-in-chief of the
prosecution witness by putting questions. The High Court further held that the
Enquiry Officer acted himself as prosecutor and Judge in the said disciplinary
enquiry. The above conclusion of the High Court has already been noticed from
paras 9 and 10 of the judgment of the High Court giving rise to Civil Appeal No.
2608 of 2012.
(emphasis added)
11.Thus, the failure to appoint a Presenting Officer does not, ipso facto,
vitiate the proceedings. Such a challenge can only succeed if the
record establishes that the Enquiry Officer stepped into the shoes of
the Prosecutor, thereby compromising the requirement of an impartial
enquiry. After examining the record of enquiry, we find that the
Enquiry Officer recorded the statements of witnesses and even
afforded the opportunity of cross-examination to the appellant. PW-1
O.S.George, PW-2, Jagdish Singh, PW-3 Jagdish Parsad, PW-4
Shikhabat and
PW-5 M.N.Panikar were cross-examined by the
appellant. After examining the record, we hardly find that the Enquiry
Officer has himself acted as Prosecuting Officer. In view of above, we
LPASW No. 55/2016
do not find any merit in this contention raised by the appellant, and
the same is accordingly rejected.
12.It was next contended by the appellant that joint enquiry was
required to be conducted against the appellant as well as his
colleague Constable Rajendra Singh. In order to appreciate this
contention, it would be apt to extract Rule 27(d) of the CRPF Rules
of 1955, which is as under:27(d) (1) Where two or more members of the Force, including those
on deputation to the Force are concerned in any case, the InspectorGeneral [or any other authority competent to impose the penalty of
dismissal from service on all such members of the Force] may make
an order directing that disciplinary action against all of them may be
taken in a common proceeding.
Note .-Where in such a proceeding, the misconduct of a deputationist
is to be dealt with, the consent of the disciplinary authority competent
to impose the penalty of dismissal shall be obtained for the taking of
such a disciplinary action.
(2) Such order shall specify—(i) the authority which may function as the disciplinary for such a
common proceeding;
(ii) the penalties specified in the table of sub-rule (a) above which
such disciplinary authority shall be competent to impose;
(iii) whether such disciplinary authority shall hold the Departmental
enquiry himself or may designate any other enquiry officer for that
purpose; and
(iv) that the enquiry shall be held in accordance with the provisions
of sub-rule (a) and sub-rule (c) .
13.Concurring with the findings of the learned Writ Court, we are of the
considered view that the said Rule is merely a directory provision. It
empowers the disciplinary authority to conduct common proceedings
against two or more members of the Force but does not confer a
vested right upon the appellant. Consequently, the failure to hold a
joint enquiry does not, in and of itself, vitiate the departmental
proceedings. We also concur with the learned Writ Court’s finding
LPASW No. 55/2016
that the charges against the appellant’s colleague were distinct; he was
merely alleged to have accompanied the appellant to the residence of
SI (GD) Jagdish Singh and did not face any charges for unauthorized
absence. Evidently, the nature and gravity of the allegations against
the appellant were distinct and significantly more serious than those
leveled against his colleague, Constable Rajinder Singh. Thus, the
contention of the appellant that a joint enquiry was required to be
conducted in terms of Rule 27(d) of the CRPF Rules, 1955, is found
to be devoid of merit.
14.The last contention that no opportunity of cross-examination was
afforded to the appellant has already been considered and negated,
in light of the categorical finding that the appellant did cross-examine
the witnesses.
15.We have carefully examined the judgment rendered by the learned
Writ Court and find no reason to interfere with the same. Accordingly,
the present appeal, being devoid of merit, is hereby dismissed.
16.Let the record be returned to the learned counsel for the respondents.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
(Arun Palli)
Chief Justice
Jammu
14.05.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking? Yes
Whether order is reportable? Yes
LPASW No. 55/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review