The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. 01.2018, however, the aforesaid FIR has been lodged after the complainant was in a position to lodge the FIR as he had suffered paralysis of the lower limb on account of the injuries. It is also submitted that after the FIR was lodged, proper investigation was carried out by the concerned police station and charge-sheet was also filed and the owner of the vehicle Dinesh in his police statement has also admitted that the accident took place because of his vehicle only, and it is also admitted that the vehicle was driven by the said driver/respondent No.1. Thus, it is submitted that there was no occasion for the Claims Tribunal to reject the case of compensation. 5] Counsel has further submitted that the deceased was earning Rs.30,000/- per month, however, the learned Judge of the Claims Tribunal has not reflected upon the loss occurred to the appellants and dependency has also not been decided. 6] Counsel for the respondent No.3/insurance company, on the other hand, has opposed the prayer and it is submitted that no case for interference is made out only on the ground that the FIR itself has been lodged after around 45 days and no cogent reason has been assigned in the FIR for such delay. It is also submitted that the vehicle in question has been subsequently introduced as an afterthought to claim the compensation from the Insurance Company, and the owner of the vehicle is also …
27. 01.2018 i.e., after more than one month, in which, there is a mention of Ashok Leyland vehicle being involved, but the author of the FIR has also not been examined in the Trial Court. 14] In such facts and circumstances of the case, when the driver of the vehicle has also not been examined by the complainant, this Court is unable to come to a conclusion that the accident took place with the vehicle No.MP-09-GG-0935, which was already attached in the same company of PW-2 Vinod. 6:31:40 PM 15] Resultantly, this Court is of the considered opinion that the finding recorded by the learned Member of the Claims Tribunal that the claimants have not been able to prove the factum of accident, does not require any interference. 16] In view of the same, the appeal being devoid of merits, is hereby dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR
MISC. APPEAL No. 2684 of 2023
BETWEEN:1.
RAJESH S/O BALUSINGH CHOWDHARY
KUMAWAT (DECEASED) THROUGH LRS.
SMT. ASHA W/O RAJESH CHOWDHARY,
AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HOUSEHOLD R/O BAJRAJKHEDI DISTT.
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
RAJESH S/O BALUSIGNH CHOWDHARY
KUMAWAT (DECEASED) THROUGH LRS.
NAITIK
MINOR
THROUGH
NATURAL
GUARDIAN MOTHER ASHA W/O RAESH
CHOWDHARY, AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOUSEHOLD BAJRAJKHEDI
DISTRICT UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
RAJESH S/O BALUSINGH CHOWDHARY
KUMAWAT (DECEASED) THROUGH LRS.
PREM
MINOR
THROUGH
NATURAL
GUARDIAN MOTHER ASHA W/O RAJESH
CHOWDHARY, AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOUSEHOLD BAJRAKHEDI
DISTRICT UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
CHANDERBAI W/O BALUSINGH, AGED
ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOME
WORK BAJRAKHEDI DISTRICT UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
BALUSINGH S/O BHAIRRAJI, AGED ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
LABOR
BAJRAKHEDI DISTRICT UJJAIN (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/30/2024
6:31:40 PM
(BY SHRI MANISH JAIN, ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
BALRAM S/O RADHESHYAM KUMAWAT,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
DRIVER
R/O
GANESH
TEKRI
PATELNAGAR UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
DINESH S/O CHANDIRAM SONTANI, AGED
ABOUT 40 YEARS, OCCUPATION: VEHICLE
OWNER JAGRATINAGAR, P.S. JUNI INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.
OFFICE SAVITRI SADAN, FREEGANJ, UJJAIN
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SARANJIT SINGH CHAWLA, ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
No.3)
…............................................................................................................
Reserved on
:
21.11.2023
Pronounced on
:
30.01.2024
…........................................................................................................
This appeal having been heard and reserved for judgement,
coming on for pronouncement this day, the court passed the
following:
JUDGEMENT
Heard finally, with the consent of the parties.
2]
This miscellaneous appeal has been preferred by the
appellants/claimants under Section 173(1) of Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 against the award dated 24.01.2023, passed by Third Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Ujjain (M.P.) in Claim Case
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/30/2024
6:31:40 PM
No.375/2018 whereby, the claim filed by the appellants to seek
compensation for the death of Rajesh Chaudhary has been rejected.
3]
In brief, the facts of the case are that Rajesh was a labourer
(hammal), and on 12.12.2017, when he was working in the premises
of Mama Road Lines Transport Doodh Talai, Ujjain, at around 3
o’clock, while he was unloading a handcart (haath thela), at that time,
an Ashok Leyland vehicle (chhota hathi) bearing registration No.MP09-GG-0935, driven rashly and negligently by the respondent No.1
dashed against the handcart, as a result of which, it rammed into the
waist of Rajesh, as a result of which, Rajesh suffered grievous injuries
on his spinal cord and was immediately taken to hospital and died in
the hospital on 10.10.2018, as he was being hospitalized intermittently
on account of injuries suffered by him on 12.12.2017. Subsequently, a
claim case was filed by the legal representatives of the deceased, who
are the widow, minor children and parents seeking claim of
Rs.50,00,000/-, however, learned Member of the MACT rejected the
same on the ground that the FIR in the present case has been lodged
after a period of around 45 days. It was also held that the appellants
have not been able to prove that the deceased suffered injuries on
account of the aforesaid Ashok Leyland vehicle bearing registration
No.MP-09-GG-0935.
4]
Counsel for the appellant has submitted that the impugned
award is liable to be set aside as it has been passed without properly
appreciating the evidence led by the appellants in the Trial Court. It is
also submitted that it is true that the incident took place on
12.12.2017, whereas the FIR has been lodged after 45 days on
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/30/2024
6:31:40 PM
27.01.2018, however, the aforesaid FIR has been lodged after the
complainant was in a position to lodge the FIR as he had suffered
paralysis of the lower limb on account of the injuries. It is also
submitted that after the FIR was lodged, proper investigation was
carried out by the concerned police station and charge-sheet was also
filed and the owner of the vehicle Dinesh in his police statement has
also admitted that the accident took place because of his vehicle only,
and it is also admitted that the vehicle was driven by the said
driver/respondent No.1. Thus, it is submitted that there was no
occasion for the Claims Tribunal to reject the case of compensation.
5]
Counsel has further submitted that the deceased was earning
Rs.30,000/- per month, however, the learned Judge of the Claims
Tribunal has not reflected upon the loss occurred to the appellants and
dependency has also not been decided.
6]
Counsel for the respondent No.3/insurance company, on the
other hand, has opposed the prayer and it is submitted that no case for
interference is made out only on the ground that the FIR itself has
been lodged after around 45 days and no cogent reason has been
assigned in the FIR for such delay. It is also submitted that the vehicle
in question has been subsequently introduced as an afterthought to
claim the compensation from the Insurance Company, and the owner
of the vehicle is also involved in this, which is also reflected from his
admission in his statement recorded on 29.01.2018 under Section 161
of Cr.P.C. and it is rather unnatural that the injured would be informed
about the vehicle’s registration number by eye witnesses Pappu and
Vinod after he was discharged from the hospital. Vinod is AW-2, in
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/30/2024
6:31:40 PM
whose statement also there are material omissions and contradictions
as he has admitted in his cross-examination that while recording the
MLC, he has not informed to the doctor that the accident has taken
place on account of any vehicle hitting the handcart, which in turn
dashed against the deceased Rajesh and there was no reason for him
not to disclose this aspect of the case to the doctor. It is also submitted
that even the postmortem report has not been filed on record. Counsel
has also drawn the attention of this Court to the deposition of treating
doctor DW-1 Dr. Bhojraj Sharma, who has recorded the MLC, and has
admitted that he was only informed that the handcart has fallen on the
injured and he was not informed that it was the result of an accident
by a vehicle.
7]
Shri Chawla, learned counsel for the respondent No.3 has also
drawn the attention of this Court to para 15 of the cross-examination
of Asha Chaudhary AW-1, the wife of the deceased in which she has
clearly submitted that the deceased has died due to heart failure.
8]
Heard counsel for the parties and perused the record.
9]
On perusal of the deposition of the parties, this Court finds that
PW-1 Smt. Asha Choudhary, who happens to be the wife of deceased
Rajesh Choudhary has admitted that in the MLC Ex.P/3 recorded at
Government Hospital, Madhav Nagar, Ujjain, it is mentioned that the
injury was caused to the deceased on account of handcart having
fallen on him. Similarly, DW-1 Dr. Bhojraj Sharma, who was the
Medical Officer posted at Madhav Nagar Government Hospital, Ujjain
on 12.12.2017 has proved the MLC Ex.P/3, in which he has
mentioned the general condition of the patient and has admitted in his
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/30/2024
6:31:40 PM
cross-examination that the general condition is stated to be ‘OK’, and
that the patient was conscious.
10]
Although, the deceased, when he filed the claim case while he
was alive, gave his initial statement in the Court, in which it is stated
that while he was working at Mama Transport, at that time, the Ashok
Leyland vehicle bearing registration No.MP-09-GG-0935 which was
attached with the said transport, came rashly and negligently and
dashed against the handcart, next to which he was standing, as a result
of which, he had suffered the injuries, but this statement was given by
the deceased on 03.10.2018 i.e., after a period of almost 10 months.
11]
It is true that it is not expected that a person or his relatives
would narrate the entire facts of the case while he is being treated in
the hospital, however, in the MLC Ex.P/3, it is clearly mentioned that
the deceased has suffered injuries on account of falling of handcart on
his body, whereas, one Vinod Sontani, PW-2, the owner of Mama
Roadlines where the deceased used to work as a labour, has been
examined, and he has reiterated the story of the claimants that the
accident took place due to the vehicle attached in his transport
company. This witness has also been cross-examined and has stated
that he had informed in the hospital while recording the MLC that
how the accident has taken place, however, apparently, it does not find
place in the MLC Ex.P/3 that any vehicle was also involved. He has
also admitted that he came to know about the death of Rajesh after
nine months.
12]
In the present case, it was not the initial case of the claimants
that the deceased got injuries on account of some motor accident, in
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/30/2024
6:31:40 PM
fact, their initial case, even as per the MLC was that he got injuries on
account of the handcart having fallen on the injured, and it is also
found that the deceased was initially taken to the hospital by the
owner of the transport only and there was no reason for him not to
mention the aforesaid fact that any vehicle was also involved, even if
he was not able to recall the vehicle number at that time, and in his
cross-examination also, he has been confronted with the fact that he
did not mention the registration number of the vehicle when the
deceased was taken for treatment and when the MLC was recorded, to
which he has submitted that he had informed the vehicle number to
the doctor, however, he does not know as to why the vehicle number
has not been mentioned. Whereas, DW-1 Dr. Bhojraj Sharma has
admitted in his examination-in-chief that he was informed that the
injured got injuries as a handcart had fallen on him. He has also
admitted that he was not informed that the injured suffered injuries on
account of vehicle No.MP-09-GG-0935 and had it been informed to
him at that time, he should have mentioned this fact in the MLC.
13]
It is found that the FIR has been lodged by Premchandra on
27.01.2018 i.e., after more than one month, in which, there is a
mention of Ashok Leyland vehicle being involved, but the author of
the FIR has also not been examined in the Trial Court.
14]
In such facts and circumstances of the case, when the driver of
the vehicle has also not been examined by the complainant, this Court
is unable to come to a conclusion that the accident took place with the
vehicle No.MP-09-GG-0935, which was already attached in the same
company of PW-2 Vinod.
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/30/2024
6:31:40 PM
15]
Resultantly, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
finding recorded by the learned Member of the Claims Tribunal that
the claimants have not been able to prove the factum of accident, does
not require any interference.
16]
In view of the same, the appeal being devoid of merits, is
hereby dismissed.
(SUBODH ABHYANKAR)
JUDGE
Bahar
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 1/30/2024
6:31:40 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review